Why were Prophets only sent to the Middle East? | Dr. Shabir Ally
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 січ 2021
- A viewer asks, "If Allah wanted mankind to follow Islam and abide by its rules, then why did He sent prominent prophets with their scriptures to the Middle East region only, leaving America, Australia, India, China and many other areas. Allah tells us in the #Quran that He sent prophets to every nation in every age. But clearly the prophets sent to America, Australia, India, etc couldn't have had much of an impact on their people, as we see most of these people follow #Christianity or Hinduism in these regions. Did Allah intentionally send influential prophets to #Arab/Israeli/Egyptian people to ensure the people in these areas were #Muslim and leave the other lands with insignificant prophets and no scripture?" Dr. Shabir Ally responds.
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks.com/
► SUBSCRIBE: ua-cam.com/users/subscription_...
COMMENT, LIKE and SHARE
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Dear friends, we invite you to follow us on Instagram: instagram.com/quranspeaks.tv
I don't think God almighty will swallow the devotion of people who are worshipping Him the wrong way or in the wrong path . Because the notion of Shirk is the worst that God wouldn't forgive in the day of judgement . I would've liked brother Allye did bring up the concept of Fitrah that every human being is born with . But what's for sure , Allah wants us to worship Him not how we wants or on a will based on our desires and inspirations but worship Him the way that He wants .
Salam the Prophet of Vedas is from India perhaps 🤔
@@nabilbititi2579 In summary Ally Shabir lied?
Noah AS and Shees AS lived in India
Shees AS Grave is in India in Faizabad Lucknow
Miss named by Hinduism as Shiva and Bible as Seth
Noah AS live in India called in his Tamil Language as Manu so Manu Smriti his scripture.
Noah AS Flood even started from India from ""Tanur"" a costal city of South India
Quran 11:40 / 23:27 (54:11).
How about the fact that most of parts of the Middle East is the Divinely chosen blessed lands, does it also explain why??
I never thought in a million years that I would be getting answers to most of my questions from a Muslim but here I am a 45 year old white male American doing just that. I can't explain it but I think my heart is telling me that I've been a Muslim my whole life. Thank You To All My Muslim Brother's & Sister's For Always Being So Warm & Welcoming To Me!
Step 1. Is Acknowledging there are no other gods, only The One Deity/God.
Unfragmented, Unlike anything, Eternal, The Creator, with no other associates; only Having servants. Aka, AlLah/الله
Step 2. Muhammad ﷺ is the final Messenger and Servant of الله. Other Prophets and Messengers include Noah, Abraham, Moses, David, Jesus son of Mary, Peace be upon them.
Aww thats one of the sweetest thing i have read in a long time, i really do pray Allah guides you to Sirat e mustaqeem.
You have been guided by the Almighty Allah. I wish you the best
I dont think u had to mention the fact that u are a white male. Your message could still be well received. Muslims are more equal in the sight of Allah than u can ever imagine..male white..black male..it doesnot matter. Just be a muslim male. Thats sufficient.
@@muzamirmustapha8735 You are correct. However unfortunately we live in a society especially in America where you are separated into groups and I was trying to say Race doesn't matter to Muslim's or myself
I’m an angonstic, past Christian. And honesty Dr. Shabir explains things in a way that is so open, and kind, and forthcoming with a non hostile approach that is very inviting. It makes me want to learn more about Islam. Thank you for this outlet. May Allah bless you.
Islam hate humanity
True he conveys it beautifully💯
Allah is with you brother.
@@minamdar7747 I’m a woman, but thank you! ☺️
@@Haunted_Moon thank you! ☺️🌸
Once Dr. Shabir said the word "Island," my ears perked up lol. A Carribean Muslim mashAllah! I know it's not a big deal but it brought a smile to my face 🇹🇹🇯🇲🇬🇾😁.
MashaAllah brother. Alhamdulillah, Allah guided you to ISLAM.
@@Faiselmoha If you mean that I reverted your mistaken Akhi I was born Muslim my family is from Trinidad and majority of the Muslims in the Caribbean are Guyanese, Trinidadian, or from other areas of the Lesser Antilles but JazakAllah Khair regardless.
@@DeemMalikBenHassan
Brother, the following verse clearly explains what my above comment meant. The English translation is below the Arabic text:
﴿وَنَزَعنا ما في صُدورِهِم مِن غِلٍّ تَجري مِن تَحتِهِمُ الأَنهارُ وَقالُوا الحَمدُ لِلَّهِ الَّذي هَدانا لِهذا وَما كُنّا لِنَهتَدِيَ لَولا أَن هَدانَا اللَّهُ لَقَد جاءَت رُسُلُ رَبِّنا بِالحَقِّ وَنودوا أَن تِلكُمُ الجَنَّةُ أورِثتُموها بِما كُنتُم تَعمَلونَ﴾ [Al-A‘rāf: 43]
(43) And We will have removed whatever is within their breasts of resentment,[372] [while] flowing beneath them are rivers. And they will say, "Praise to Allāh, who has guided us to this; and we would never have been guided if Allāh had not guided us. Certainly the messengers of our Lord had come with the truth." And they will be called, "This is Paradise, which you have been made to inherit for what you used to do."
[372]- i.e., ill will or sense of injury for what was inflicted upon them during worldly life.
@@Faiselmoha mashAllah a beautiful ayat indeed, I appreciate your clarity sincerely. I honestly think it's beautiful thing to revert into the fold of Islam, to clarify on my end I only said that because many times people will assume that if your a Black person from a non predominantly Muslim country that your a convert or revert. But never the less JazakAllah Khair Akhi tabarrakAllah.
Mashallah
“God is more tolerant than the rest of us”. That’s a great quote, for anyone of any faith or no faith.
Beautiful explanation. Islam is a beautiful religion. I converted to Islam in 2019.
jhang zhou..Assalam alaikum
I finally found a preacher whose intellectual answers articulates the faith in Allah I feel in my heart. God knows every human limitations. May God give Dr.Shabir all the Rahmah for teaching us that.
Ameen to your dua ❤ We appreciate your kind words.
his view goes against teachings of quran ... although its a nice way to see it
@@johntaylor7685 is it though? I believe the Quran teaches only good, and human interpretation can never ever be perfect. I’m not that religious, but I firmly believe that No religious values should go against basic good humanitarian values. And I also believe God is fair and all knowing. He knows every human’s limitations and their limited capacity for learning. Whatever way of Islam you or I understand to be true and follow in our short lives, brother, may Allah give us mercy for our capacity of understanding the true teachings of ISLAM as shown by the holy prophet Muhammad PBUH.
@@babyinezarief4486 Are you saying this because youre Muslim? Have you read and understand the quaran? Do you agree that women are worth 1/2 than men? Do you think its acceptable to go to hellfire if you disbelieve? Do you think Mohamid was a great person? Do you think smashing 360 idols was a great thing to do? Slavery of black people etc ...
@@johntaylor7685 Where are you getting what's good and bad from?
Prophet Mohammed (peace be upon him) said: “All the sons of Adam are sinning, but the best of sinners are those who repent often.” Related by At·Tirmidhi and Ibn Majah with a strong chain of narrators.
"All mankind is from Adam and Eve, an Arab has no superiority over a non-Arab nor a non-Arab has any superiority over an Arab; also a White has no superiority over a Black nor a Black has any superiority over a White except by piety and good action. Learn that every Muslim is a brother to every Muslim and that the Muslims constitute one brotherhood. Nothing shall be legitimate to a Muslim which belongs to a fellow Muslim unless it was given freely and willingly."
Not the daughters?
So you agree with Afghanistan religious and political leaders whom have been killing innocent people for decades. Every year they go to the Hajj and repent. So according to prophet Mohammad they are the best of sinners......according to me these leaders are war criminals.
Because world largest kingdom and most kingdoms was in Egypt so prophets sent to middle east......to protect humanity and human rights
@@star-gx4fu not really
Egyptians are Coptic hamite African races
I never knew they were father and daughter. I love her channel and I love his teachings!
Thank you! We love that you're watching!
He is Guyanese South America
But ancestral roots from India as is sheikh Imran Hossein who is from Caribbean island Trinidad and Tobago also of Hindu heritage
Point is if you find a muslim scholar preaching peace tolerance it from the Hindu influence
Two hundred million Muslims in India under Hindu rule
No where in the history of Islam have such large numbers of Sunni and Shia's forced to tolerate each other as the muslims of India
@@QuranSpeaks
Simply because you draw the curtain and let the light in doesn't means you can take credit for creating the sun 🌞
Hindu proverb
Seriously Mohammed alleged brought some enlightenment to some premitive backwards desert tribes how dare you declare all of mankind must accept this prophet
@@robertmitchell8630
👉Allah almighty warns you,
*For those who disbelieve in their Lord, there is the torment of Hell, and it is an evil abode.*
*When they are flung into it, they will hear its roaring, and it will be boiling up, as though bursting with rage.*
👉Every time a crowd is cast into it, its keepers will ask them,
*"Did not a warner come to you?"*
👉They will answer,
*"Yes, a warner had come to us, but we denied and said, 'Allah has not sent down anything. You are not but in great error.'"*
👉And they will add,
*"Had we only listened or understood, we would not now be among the dwellers of the blazing Fire."*
*Thus will they confess their own sin.*
*Damned be the dwellers of Hell!*
Qur'an 67 [6-11]
Worship only Allah without any partners.
Follow Last and Final Messanger Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ).
Father + Daughter very nice
What a great father and daughter duo.. Love what they say.. Alhamdulillah..We have such people to guide people to the truth..
Meenakshi Ramesh - Which state in India are you from?
Have you take your shahada??
@@lifethroughromans8295 she is a mask
MashaALLAH, is that really his daughter?
@@rabbithare381 whomever's daughter she may be but doesn't appear to be his 😂😂
The first presupposition has been a question in my mind recently for some time and you have answered it for me. May Allah bless you and this channel
Even though I'm agnostic I like listening to Dr. Shabir Ally because he's fair. Other scholars are far too narrow minded and stuck on outdated opinions. Especially Salafi and Wahabis.
Thank you! So thrilled to have you join us!
@@QuranSpeaks No problem! I've listened to him for a long time.
@@shabanoonislam8687 wahabis speak up against grave worshipping and emphasize on Oneness of Allah. If that's not Islam according to you then you need to reevaluate your life fast.
@@ElBadriano Wahhabis want to dig up prophet Muhammed grave is that the Islam you want to follow?
@@dhillongarcha8764 that's totally false. Who feeds you such rumours?
I am a Christien from Kerala ...i do listen to this man ...one reason he being very much truthful and loving in nature and culturally better then the other Mullas or what ever you call it. Thanks Dr Shabir Ali
Thank you!
Hi ,from malappuram.
@Usman Ansari better race with soo much rasism
@Usman Ansari I am half Arab from Palestine and your arrogance makes me sick. You reek of condescending pretentiousness and those with an atom's worth of arrogance will not enter jannah akhi. Who the hell do you think you are? Allah is the one who decides where everybody will be born and from what area, you are nothing. I am nothing. How come you think you're a hot shot just because you eat shawarma and smoke shisha every day? Disgusting.
@Usman Ansari that's irrelevant so I will not tell you, akhi claiming you are superior because you are Arab is arrogance and anybody with an atom's weight of arrogance will be thrown into jahannam. Don't be like iblees barakallahufeek may Allah guide us all
This was incredibly helpful and insightful. Thank you so much!
Loved Dr Shabir ‘s explanation ! This question was in my mind too ...
Jazak Allah Kharain 🤲💕
This was a very heartfelt and peaceful message from Islam - great to hear
I wish more people get to hear this particular message. It will change a lot of what is going on in the world today.
Bless you Dr. Shabir Ally. You exemplify the goodness that Islam intended
Even as an atheist I enjoy hearing Dr Ali talk.
Thank you! Please remember him in your duas.
Just felt very nice. Really, appreciable how dr. Shabir made us understood. Thanks a lot.
We appreciate your comment. Thank you for watching.
Allah be pleased with him, helped me understand Islam and love his talking points.
I like his explanation. That God sees the devotion each person had made to seek out God, and judges them by it.
yup..me too
It’s not exactly the Truth though. Allah says that the only correct religion is Islam. (Quran 3:19). Of course individual efforts will be taken to account but to say that Allah will be accepting and tolerant of “mistaken beliefs” (worship of god in wrong religion) is a stretch and I don’t think it should be said.
@@idrea43 Allah is all knowing , there are things Allah knows that we humans don't know , so if that person didn't had islam reached out to his heart in 2021 is because Allah knows that persons heart better than that person knowns himself. So it's rather a test. Allah already know what will happen to him ,but our minds cannot comprehend why if he knows then why is he on planet earth just to make sins and then suffer? He knows best. End of story, he cannot think how Allah plan things , our job is not to know EVERYTHING but to surrender to the one true Creator of everything.
@@idrea43 Islam is simply peace by submission to One God. I can make the case that many people of ancient times practiced Islam by submitting their life to the worship of their Creator. They may not have the same rituals of middle eastern Arab and Quranic knowledge, but it is still Islam in the purest sense.
don't forget.., Allah knows the most our brain full capability in seeking the truth. And so, he knows the most whether we are already have that kind of devotion to seek the truth. He judge based on his knowledge, not based on our assumption about our "devotion".
So back to the term "devotion", are they already enough to answer what have God tell to us "Didn't they think?!" as something that refers to the capability of each individual potential to seeks the truth.
So, be careful with that kind of idea brother. Don't be so save by the thought "I've tried" or "I've devoted". What if God in His Wisdom and knowledge only judge that as an excuse. He gives us so many simple think to thought, so many easy think to understand, yet we still denied. And then to think it would be that easy to answer it by just "I've tried" or "I've devoted my life as much as I capable".. Is it save to have this kind of assumption?!
I don't think what Dr. Shabir is wrong. I even see it in a more deeper meaning and deeper understanding, but something would be misunderstood by others by lenient excuse.
Dr. Shabir's idea based on the idea "each person's capability in doing something". But do each of us really know our limit or do we only make an excuse for the devotion as if "we've tried our best". Meanwhile, the clues, the signs, and teaching Allah send, most of them are not that hard to understand, yet we still chose other intrepretation, not sincerely surrender to what God's shows us.., and then says : I've tried, and ask Allah would tolerate it?!
Allah judge based on his wisdom and knowledge, and He is the omniscient and most wise, he knows what inside our heart. He will judge based on that knowledge. Not based on our excuse. That's why, thought what Dr. Shabir seems so easier to understand, and easier to do, don't misinterpreted it for lenient excuse. Be careful, brother. We only have one life, means, only one chance. When we dies, when we knows He judges us as "no enough", and then ask for second life for another chances, but there's will no more. But still, that much is still in each of person's capability. That why God gives us brain to think things. And just like Allah ask in Qur'an : afala ta'qilun... "Didn't they think"!
Holy Quran 2.269----
He gives WISDOM to whom He wills, and whoever has been given WISDOM has certainly been given MUCH GOOD. And none will remember except those of understanding.
muslims live in their little illogical universe where the qurans are created by the creator, while evrybody clearly sees flawed immoral teachings; qurans are manmade books, they write about 7th century ideas, like a FLAT EARTH, like a bed (43;10) , a SKY THAT CAN FALL DOWN on EARTH (22;65), incorrect embryology ; BONES ARE FORMED FIRST THEN CLOTHED WITH FLESH (23;14)....these (and other) were POPULAR BELIEFS back then and SIMPLY COPIED by Mohammed....now you go and THINK about this
Thank you again for your wise and astute views, dear Dr Shabir. Clearly, Muslims aren't immune from erroneous presuppositions. You explained this very well, and it aligns to what we see in the world. I'm also inclined to agree with you because your explanation seems to agree with my sense and my fitra! Jazakallah khair!
Where can you find a father and a daughter preaching together for good of mankind.God bless both if you....
This answer is reasonable. In fact, I never ask this kind of question but I heard some of my friends asking the questions that look similar to this but I never get the response like this.
Holy Quran 2.281---And Fear a Day When you will be Returned to Allah . Then Every SOUL Will be COMPENSATED for What it EARNED, and They will NOT be Treated UNJUSTLY.
@@kanizfatima1377 Yes...what happened to you...
What Help you want..
please tell me..
@Konshens Kodialwall Friend,what u mean ??please Explain..i have Not understood ur Question,if i understand, then i can answer u...please explain
@Konshens Kodialwall
Being a Muslim Doesnot give me License to do Wrong with the Non-Muslim...
If i do wrong with any Non-Muslim, then Sin will be upon me,so i have to take Care to treat Non-Muslim people with Good Behaviour and Nicely.....
@Konshens Kodialwall i can only speak from the Quran Verse....
Quran 99.7---So whoever does an Atom’s weight of GOOD will see it.
Quran 99.8---And whoever does an Atom’s weight of EVIL will see it.
So,from above verse,if a Non-Muslim have done GOOD in their life ,they will see it on Judgement day...
If a Muslim have done EVIL work,even little,in his life, he will see it on judgement day, so being a Muslim doesnot mean he will get away if he had done WRONG and BAD Things in this life.........
please,Read chap 99,it just 8 Verse Surah
@Konshens Kodialwall bruh did you even read what the guy wrote?
It's the first time i hear this man speak and mashalah his answer is just very well thought and articulated
Salaam brother, I'm returning to this video after years, and it's refreshing to remember your analysis. Though now I'm wondering if you ever do a video on the "days which are counted"? I don't believe I caught that one.
Alhamdulillah that I found this channel! Thank you so much for providing rational and kind insights into Islam, and for answering complex questions like these in such an amazing way. May Allah grant you Jannatul Firdaws in sha Allah for bringing me closer to the faith. JazakAllah khair!
Thank you Dr Shabir. May Allah be pleased with you. 😊❤
Alhamdulillah very informative jazakallah
MashaAllah BarakAllah.
JazakAllahu khairun kaseera for sharing it
I absolutely loved this response♥️♥️♥️May Allah swt reward you both♥️♥️
Ohh masha Allah sheikh you have said it all, what a beautiful discussion that was....instinctively we humans are incline to the religion.
Ramadan Mubarak. Have a blessed Ramadan everyone.
In Quran, Allah Almighty says:
*“Indeed, those who believe and do righteous deeds and establish prayer and give zakah will have their reward with their Lord, and there will be no fear concerning them, nor will they grieve.”* (2:277)
*Don't miss your Obligatory prayer anyhow.*
*The first question will be asked on the day of judgment is about Salah.*
*If we have prayed it correctly then we will be saved Inshallah.*
*If you are not praying any salah then begin with Fard(Obligatory) Salah.*
*If you count the time for only Obligatory prayer then it will not exceed even an hour of your 24 hour.*
*Each Obligatory salah will take 10 minutes.*
*Multiply it with 5 Salah and it will take only 50 minutes of your 24 HOURS.*
*Can't you give this much small period of time to the one who created you?*
And u will have u r way to jannat , where u get 72 HURRE ,HIP HIP HURRE , may be derived from this and shehed ki , sharab ki nehre , what not , all nonsense .
@@suhu1415
👉Allah almighty warns you,
*For those who disbelieve in their Lord, there is the torment of Hell🔥, and it is an evil abode.*
*When they are flung into it, they will hear its roaring, and it will be boiling up, as though bursting with rage.*
👉Every time a crowd is cast into it, its keepers will ask them,
*"Did not a warner come to you?"*
👉They will answer,
*"Yes, a warner had come to us, but we denied and said, 'Allah has not sent down anything. You are not but in great error.'"*
👉And they will add,
*"Had we only listened or understood, we would not now be among the dwellers of the blazing Fire."*
*Thus will they confess their own sin.*
*Damned be the dwellers of Hell!*
Qur'an 67 [6-11]
Worship only Allah without any partners.
Follow Last and Final Messanger Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ).
@@suhu1415 you don't have enough intelligence to imagine the life and things of jannah.... You can only thought from the poin of this earthly life.
What an amazing, balanced, sensible and practical view.
5:02 “...introduce light against the darkness that is there” - a concept and analogy introduced by Zarathustra (Zoroaster) over 4000 years ago.
Isn't that, like, blasphemy? To even talk about Zoroaster? I don't wish it to be so, I'm just genuinely surprised to see the reference.
@@chadjcrase Why is it blasphemy to reference other messengers, who’s message is the same? How strange!
@@chadjcrase … or did I just miss a bit of humour? Sometimes it’s hard to tell on chats like these!
Because world largest kingdom and most kingdoms was in Egypt so prophets sent to middle east......to protect humanity and human rights
@@raymasraymas Not at all my friend, I am out of my element. Maybe I was testing the waters, but I think it's a beautiful quote actually.
This is perhaps the only question that troubled me intellectually about Islam. And this is such a good answer. It normalizes the status of non-Muslims and also answers the relevant question of "Will billions of non-Muslims go to hell?” I hope many will benefit from this explanation.
We hope so too! Please help us to share it with others.
Have you ever heard a hadith that show that Prophet Muhamad's father and mother is in HELL ??
its clearly in the Quran, the people that reject the truth will indeed end up bad because of their pride and arrogant
It answers nothing.
All prophets in Islam are Middle Eastern and plagiarized from Judaism and Christianity.
WHERE are other prophets sent to the rest of the world?
Muslim word is not a noun it is a verb, someone who strives for Selam which means peace. Righteousness in Islam is usually contrasted against aggression. So if someone acts peacefully he should be ok.
That clears a lot of my doubts, Mash'Allah. ☺
All he quoted in his speech is "To err is human and to forgive is divine' which already is every text for thousands of years.
God send messenger to every civilization(afrikans, eurpean, Chinese, Indians, mongol, japan).
Someone in the past who teaches us about monotheism, wisdom are God messengers. They are Muslims
Beautiful. This man is a blessing. I wonder what he thinks of the early maps in dallas, chicago and memphis stating they are egypt or little egypt in terms of these concepts. America used to be Amuurika or Morocco. These are questions our community in America aka Morocco is curious about.
This is the closes to an omnist/universal view of Islam I have ever seen. God bless 🙏
❤️😊
Being a hindu, I appreciate your thoughts and your description about other religions with a respectful manners... This will help to bring religious harmony among mankind and there will be no killing, slaughtering in the name of Islam... Yes God is great and God is one whether it is hindu God, Christian God or Muslim God..God can not be different..He is the one and only...We believe the same God in different way based on our Scriptures and cultures...
God created universe, we dont need to be muslim to know God , every birth has its reason to perform, by ur thoughts god mistaken by creating other religions , beleifs and come and say ohh this not correct urs correct and became muslim , as per ur example blue drop in the middle of the pool ☹️
Listen to this recitation/words of the holy Quaran with you heart/soul and you will know it comes from the creator of the universe.
The most holy scripture in hinduism is the Vedas, in the vedas it says that God has no image, so idol worshiping is forbidden in hinduism, also there is a mentioning about a man who will be born in the desert and it also mentions his father's and mother's name, all details are talking about prophet Mohammed, there is a big chance that some people that hindis worship like Ram and Krishna and maybe others are prophets but people started worshiping them just like how christians started worshiping Jesus
@@bassam_salim also give the references of the sholkas which says idol worshiping is forebidden.I think you have learnt vedas from the zakir naik school of hindusim.
Because world largest kingdom and most kingdoms was in Egypt so prophets sent to middle east......to protect humanity and human rights
May Allah bless u Dr Shabir n family as well, u r such an inspiring person👍😊
Impressive Talk, thank you dear Brother
May Allah enlighten you More and protect you of all evil. Inshallah
If that is the case, then that means all spirituality and beliefs are correct and leads to god, because that which reveal to the eyes and senses speaks directly to god
'Devotion' is all that matters.
I think I got my answer.
This is such a beautiful answer.
Alhamdulillâhi Rabbil âlamiin.
Allâhumma Salli alâ Seyyidinâ Mawlâna Muhammadin Wa Sallim.
Thank you Dr ALLY for sharing your knowledge with us. Thanks to all of your Team members. May ALLÂH SWT Protect Bless Help Guide and Grant all of us Jannah. Amiin Amiin
Beautiful answer ماشاءالله my the blessing of ALLAH be with you and all of us amen
''Did they do their due diligence?'' Dr. Shabir. Love you Dr. for the sake of Allah :)
Masha Allah, amazing answer about presuppositions that truely exists in muslim community and other community as well.. we dont research the given facts.. and presuppose everything to point where we differentiate ourselves in our one religion, which one Allah, One Quraan, One last Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) & his teachings...
@Da Rock Islam is since beginning.adam alaihi Salam, Ibrahim, Noah, Moses,all were obedient servant of allah.quran is 4th and last book.before that also Allah sent other books.muslim believe in all four books.
@Da Rock what are you talking about all Prophets pbut is Muslim get educated
@@shehualiyu2897 no that's an assertion
Ur free to believe whatever u want but I think u should actually study what other religions say about the matter instead of assuming what they say bez ur religion supposes it
Because world largest kingdom and most kingdoms was in Egypt so prophets sent to middle east......to protect humanity and human rights
@@star-gx4fu the Anbiya pbut were sent to all corners of the world not just middle east Allah swt tells us in the Quran that he sent Prophets to all nations of the world
Beautiful explanation. Make all become consistent.
We must responsible and consistent to what we believe.
Absolutely fantastic video. I learn so much from your videos! Thank you.
Well answered very difficult question but very well answered with wisdom
Its called mental gymnastics bro
no it's very important.
Salam from Brazil,and Ramadan mubarak
Manshalah barakalaah
good to watch....
any relations between host and speaker? TIA
Noone should let go of this question.
Why indeed!
What I think is that Allah has mentioned names of the prominent prophets sent to the Arabian peninsula and its surrounding region because the Qur'an was revealed in Arabia and to the Arabs. So, to validate the stories mentioned in the Qur'an the places of those prophets must be accessible for the Arabs to go and see. For the word of the Qur'an to be spread, the Arabs should believe & understand it in the first place. Once the understood it they took it with them to all corners of the planet.
Why couldnt god keep sending prophets to the end of time instead of ppl relying on a 1400 year old book that has so many controversies & tons of sects and interpretations. Why would he send prophets all the time pre quran then suddenly stop. This never made sense to me.
It probably never will. Forget it and just carry on.
Sects and interpretations can derive from literally any text or any movement or any issue. Just look at how Covid splits perceptions - just human nature
Same question
@@adkh5826 Regardless the point remains. Why not keep sending prophets. The only way i see is that the god of the quran isnt so concerned with converting ppl. This seems evident from Quran 5:48
@@Yameen200 because the end is near and he has already sent the last prophet with the timeless message i.e. The Qur'an, for you it's like 1400 years but if you look from stone age then it's just a small part and it's logical that this line of prophets has to end at someplace, you need to make a line somewhere
Thank you for all these videos. This channel is very helpful 🙏
How to answer a question the Muslim way:
1. Change the question to an easier one
2. Answer that instead
3. ...
4. Profit!
he answered in the first line ! so better listen carefully
I think Prophet Mohammed is the final Messenger because he is the only Universal Messenger whose teachings are not restricted or limited to a single group of people, geographical location or period of time.
Quran as the final revelation is the ultimate and the universal edition of Guidance and the Criterion between the right and wrong.
Mohammed Saud he will expel all. The Christian and. Jew from Arabia
You are right mr shabbir .My view is that due to limitations of movement at that time all over the world ,and god has to replace the book by another book and messengers also ,so it was easier for the people of that region to know the difference between genuine commandments and the one which have been changed .
I’m very sad and irritated. I see people disrespecting our prophets and I just feel like I can’t do anything. People disrespect my country, my religion and everything about Muslims.
“God is more tolerant than the rest of us” - 💜💜💜
Good to hear someone being so true
It's certainly an interesting point you added... That presupposing God wants everyone to be Muslim is an incorrect Assumption.
Wow... What a response to that question
I really enjoy yor wisdom Dr Shabir ❤️🙏
mashallah
So logical answer which really make sense. Jazakallho Dr. Ally
when we debating about religion we argue this to ahahah. Nice to see long explanation. Short answer is prohpets send to every nation but we dont know their history because they didnt write it down. like how we dont know aztec and inca history because nothing is writed. (i know i am missing many points but its shortest answer i can give)
Holy Quran 25.30--
And the Messenger has said, "O my Lord, indeed MY PEOPLE have taken this Qur'an as [a thing] ABANDONED."
Don’t say Quran with the prefix “holy” in front of it. That’s mimicking Christians, say the noble or wise Quran.
@@yacqub Subhanallah you orthodox guys are totally out of control. Please don’t use the internet and neither use UA-cam as it is mimicking the people that invented and established it.
Subhanallah so many problems in our ummah and we are arguing over so irrelevant terms. May Allah forgive us.
@@anelm.5127 they give the name “holy” to a corrupted book. Allah never once said “the Holy Quran,” He instead said the Glorious Quran (Al-Buruj, verse 21) , the Noble Quran (Al-Waqi’ah verse 77) , the Wise Quran (Luqman verse 2) . I believe there are more but that’s all I can recall.
@@anelm.5127 Wow you don't know anything about islam.
@@HusXX Allah will ask you about that. Hope you didn’t lie 😉
*"Did they do their due diligence ?*
*Quite a tongue-twister!* 😊
Hoping someone can answer my question. So the list of prophets we have - were any Prophets sent to the South American/North American continents? I.E Did the Native Americans or Aztecs receive Islamic prophets too? And if so, is there any mention of that in the Quran or in any Islamic scripture?
May Allah bless both of you and All of us
Dr Ally’s answers were outstanding! He is truly a theological and intellectual giant. May god bless him.
We surely sent a messenger to every community, saying, “Worship Allah and shun false gods.” But some of them were guided by Allah, while others were destined to stray. So travel throughout the land and see the fate of the deniers!
(Quran 16 : 36)
Your Lord would never destroy a society until He had sent to its capital a messenger, reciting Our revelations to them. Nor would We ever destroy a society unless its people persisted in wrongdoing.
(Quran 28 : 59)
Every single nation has received a messenger or a prophet. In every language and nationality.
What are the mineral levels of hair and nails that produce from self channeling and purifying energy? What influences that and maintains the preferred state of being? Allow the purity of air, light and water to create the alchemy of harmony within to heal and reflect around. You are a supreme being, thank you for sharing.
Thank you for this answer Dr. Shabir Ally and to the Host.
I certainly hope God in his infinite wisdom will be tolerant because there are so many different views and interpretations out there of His will for us.
God give us free will, he let us to find the truth.
God won't count people deeds until they find the truth.
The feeling of mercy that we aspouse in our heart is his, that he's given us.
And how we view morality is obviously different than other creatures, and each creature sees things differently.
Point being, the question about God being wise enough while he's bestowed upon us wisdom, him being tolerant enough while he's bestowed upon us tolerance, him being moral enough while he's bestowed upon us morality, is different than other creatures, this obviously wouldn't make sense as He'd be the pinnacle of all these lofty attributes.
But i do understand what you're saying, as different religion has mutually non exclusive claims and all can't be right, so the ones who'd have followed an incorrect understanding, assumption would be they are at a disadvantage and likely to suffer.
But just as he's the most wise, most patient, most merciful. He's also the most just.
When a verdict would be pronounced on his creation. The creation would fully understand and accept what they did was right or wrong.
Similar to when someone is in a court of law and he's fully aware of his error, and his conscience accepts his wrong doing, and he doesn't feel being wronged after the verdict is passed on him.
God promised us mercy as long as we recognise him as the one and only god there is.
@@durim187 God doesn't cares you and your existence.
@@pavan21216 and i dont care about your opinion
This program with Dr Shabir is one that I immensely benefit for the Dr is able and have answers from Quran & Sunna of the prophet ASW.
When Dr Shabir debates with non Muslim , he diminishes them with his Islamic knowledge and his knowledge of their scriptures better than them .
May Allah bless you always .
Ameen!
Ameen! Thank you for your support and dua!
Great message
Ma Sha Allah dr. Explain so clear regarding the matter. Subhan Allah
Love you Brother Shabir Ally for the sake of ALLAH
My teacher once said it's because in that area had the best and the worst humanism. But the bad almost outnumbered the good.
Excellent expansion i found that heart touching one.voice is meticulous. Sir
Jazakhalla Hairan for this illuminating explanation...
As a non-muslim, I find this channel very informative.
I Am malaysian and I am muslim ...islam is my life
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahaha! Poor guy..
@@jaronimo1976 What is ur life brother
If your parents were fr Russia n u were born there..would u be a Muslim?..or if u lived during the Roman empire..would u still be a Muslim?
@@shookreeseeree4 For after life yeah.......life is short....afterlife is forever
@@shookreeseeree4 look it is not about any religion.....it is about which is the truth.......die in this life is the end.....this life is ur second third and last chance......always have a clear warner
Great explanation but I am not really sure if the actual question was answered.
WOW! Just super, took a lot of courage to speak the truth. Thank you.
one of my friend was working in middle east for more than 5 years, she said," thats why Allah made all our prophets from middle east country because when you stayed there, you will know hows their actual attitude is-not all, but some of them... thats why, all our prophets was coming from middle east to guide, to teach, to create this kind of people attitude to be more human than other human, can you imagine if our prophet coming from other side of country instead of middle east...??? maybe, you will not ever want to come to middle east...wallahualam... i was here in Saudi for 3 years, now i know why...
Middle East is not a race. 70% of the Biblical prophets were Israelites however they're prophets in the Quran with names like Dhul Khifl who were not Israelites or Arabs. Some say, this man was Buddha
You are just racist.
@triniboy no but Buddha is a prophet for Monotheism
@triniboy well, you can't count them all yourself
You should read European history and dark ages. And native Americans way of life and 'attitude' you might forgive arabs
ive been asking around this question to many muslim...their answer mostly said."we are the chosen one"...if i asking more question...then they will answer with "are you kafir or muslim?"..i realised that ....islam in malaysia are against critical thinking..
You should have met USA .. Southern Baptist back in the 1980's.
That church and local school districts sure did love to use the paddle on children that didn't show the right tone when saying , " Yes Sir !"
@@krispalermo8133 oh my god...these so called religious people are behaving like devil...in the name of god....
Great Explaination Shayekh !
This was great! Thanks. I couldn’t help but think about what was said at 5:25
So can we say that the NOI opened the minds for black Americans to seek Islam?
I didn’t know that is his daughter and my dad would never let me call him in his first/last name.
It's because this is a show and she has to act formally... Like a host
@@PaapiPasito yeah formally so we don’t think about nepotism. What is wrong about calling your dad dad in public.
@@abdisalamdirir5904 r u for real xD that's their channel. An independent effort. They don't owe anyone a job. Might as well have their entire family on the set.
@@PaapiPasitoofcourse they don’t owe anything to anybody , if it is a family show then what is so formal about calling your dad his first name. It looks like you don’t see the trick.
@@abdisalamdirir5904 because its a professional production. They act professionally. You are speculating and gossiping. Check yourself. Go watch some other channel if you want talk up unnessesary accusations.
I respect dr shabir ally 👍
Thank you for your guidance
Please add subtitles