TIMBERLANDS VS DOC MARTENS: The Most Iconic Boot Battle Ever
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 жов 2024
- ✪ SEE MY LIST OF THE 10 BEST BOOTS, PERIOD: • THE 10 BEST BOOTS FOR ... ✪
TEAM TIMBERLAND? BUY THEM HERE: fave.co/3dYD3JF
PREFER DOC MARTENS? GET THE LOWEST PRICE ON AMAZON: fave.co/2L9y91z
FULL REVIEW + PICTURES: stridewise.com...
SEE MY PICKS FOR THE 5 BEST BOOTS: • THE 5 BEST MEN'S BOOTS...
I’ve compared boots before, but this is different. Timberlands and Doc Martens aren’t just big in the world of boots - these two brands make plain, round toe boots that anyone on the street recognizes. It makes sense that a lot of people have asked me to compare them - so I did.
FIRST GLANCE
Timberland
This is the wheat nubuck Timberland 6’’ waterproof boot, the most popular color. The nubuck (a kind of textured leather) is treated to be waterproof.
Six inches tall and pretty bulky - they’re not dressy and don’t look great with skinny jeans. Still pretty versatile.
Other signature features include a grippy rubber lug sole, iconic Taslan nylon laces, and the leather collar for added insulation - in addition to the Primaloft insulation.
WATCH THE FULL TIMBERLAND BOOT REVIEW: • Review: THE Timberland...
Doc Martens
These are Doc Martens’ standard issue 1460, made in Asia. It’s a pretty uncomplicated boot: round toe, 7” tall, and mostly single stitched. The “full grain” has been fully corrected out, making for a shiny, plasticky, relatively thin leather.
The toe is rather snubby and overall the profile is chunky. Slightly more streamlined than Timberlands and look better with slim pants, if that’s your thing.
The sole is made from a soft, inorganic rubber and attached to the upper with the iconic bright yellow stitching. I think the sole is one of the best parts about this boot - it’s really squishy and comfy.
The biggest difference between Timberlands and Docs at first glance is in the leather - thin, plasticky leather vs insulated nubuck.
WATCH THE FULL DOC MARTENS REVIEW: • Review: Why I Don't Li...
LEATHER
Timberland
The buffed leather on these boots is called nubuck and these are treated to be incredibly waterproof.
The color is quite bright and can be a nice break from plain brown or black. The downside is that they’re super hard to keep clean. Despite the waterproofing, they pick up little stains all the time. A pencil eraser, a stiff brush and maybe some Renewbuck, sold by Timberland, can help keep them clean.
Doc Martens
This semi-bright leather comes from either South America or Asia, and super, super smooth and with no trace of grain, which makes them look plasticky to me.
They’re easier to keep clean than the Timberlands and just need an occasional polish. They’re not super waterproof but improve if you treat them with a product that has beeswax in it.
I know that the aesthetic speaks to a lot of people but I gotta say, to me, it’s pretty cheap-looking leather.
SOLE
Timberland
Gripstick lug rubber outsole, made from 10% recycled materials, rubber midsole, urethane insole, and a removable foam insert to top it all off. No leather or cork here, but a steel shank provides a nice bit of arch support. Excellent shock absorption and comfy out of the box.
The sole is cemented to the upper with a bonwelt, not totally unlike sneakers. It’s not bad quality - waterproof, with sealed seams - but once you go through the sole, that’s probably the end of this boot.
Doc Martens
The sole is my favorite part of these Docs. Super soft with excellent shock absorption. There’s a rubber outsole, cork material and then a urethane insole, but there’s no shank, less stability and arch support than Timberland.
The pronounced yellow stitching isn’t a normal Goodyear welt - it’s actually made with an unusual heat sewing technique that makes them hard to resole.
FIT & COMFORT
Timberland
I’m usually an 11.5 and went down to an 11, which fits fine - it’s a pretty roomy boot. Great arch support and shock absorption.
Doc Martens
I got the 11s because they don’t come in half sizes. They fit OK - I would have preferred a 10.5 but definitely couldn't get a 10. Generally the fit was blobby and generic. Super comfy sole and excellent shock absorption, but doesn’t contour to the foot and the arch support is meh.
PRICE
Timberland
Generally between $160 and $180.
Doc Martens
Between $120 and $145.
PROS/CONS
Timberland
PROS
*Waterproof and insulated
*Better arch support
*Better grip
*More masculine
*Generally I consider them tougher boots
CONS
*Slightly pricier
*Super hard to keep clean
*Doesn’t patina well; looks best when new-looking
*Lining not super durable
*Too bulky to wear with slim or skinny jeans
Doc Martens
PROS
*Leather is easier to manage
*Very cheap
*Super soft sole
*Slightly better shock absorption
CONS
*Unlined
*Not waterproof
*Shapeless
*No shank
*Thin, plasticky leather
*Not versatile
Check out my latest list of the top _10_ boots you can buy (in under 10 minutes!)! ua-cam.com/video/9kuHyyefNGE/v-deo.html
Please excuse me I have recently become blind over the past few years and in the movie menace to society the main character by the name of Cain was shot and when this happened he was wearing a gray guess Jean USA sweater and a black pair of jeans with a black pair of Doc Martin boots the boots that he had came up right past the ankle and they also were available and a black shiny leather and also a dark brown but I’m not sure of the style that it would be or the style number I would like to get me another pair of these please help if able to.
i can rock both, but they would both rock my wallet too
😂😂😂
Plan to wear them for at least 10 years, so yeaaaa giving myself reason (excuse) to “invest”
timberland is like sub $100.
@@asadb1990In the US, if you know where to find them. But if you're somewhere in Europe for example it's harder to get them for that price. Especially the Wheat, since the past few years Timberlands have been peaking again, and it's probably their most abbundant shoe that's the hardest to find for a nice price.
Phantom Warrior I bought my first pair of Tims for about $140, and shopped around to at least 5 stores all over town, the only way I could see them being under $100 is second hand or if you luckily find your size at a place like Ross’. But I still couldn’t imagine a brand new full men’s size pair being under $100. $140 is fine for a quality boot that will last you a lot longer than sneakers anyway, it’s like an investment. I wear mine everyday, I find it crazy how some guys own like 100 pairs of Nike’s and change them everyday.
Without watching this, this seems like this would be comparing a Chevy truck to a Chevy Impala. These, to me, are marketed to two different groups.
except being the doc martens are sloppy shit boots
@Orion The old ones did, used to wear them every day, even play basketball or football (lol) with them on. These displayed in the video are just cheap chinese knock offs. The Timberlands retained their original quality, thus they would win hands down any durability contest now.
@@joek600 No timberland hasn't they went overseas as well.
@@joek600 look at the Dr martens made in England range, retains the same quality they did 30 years ago
Team solovair lol
Before even watching the video, I'd say it's Hip Hop Vs. Punk Rock!!!!! DM since 1989!!!! For me.
Damn it, that's a really good title!!! I should have picked that.
sad to say that dr. Martens doesn't represent punk rock or even rock anymore but anybody who wants to be "different" but still wear a uniform for w/e subculture they are in or think they are in. Oh also some people actually use them for work so at least for them there's still the working class aspect showing through.
@@Drownedinblood think that died along with them being made in England (China now) still a few made in UK but Solovair and Gripfast are still made in England
@@rodz7910 I'd say more due to marketing. Dr martens would be able to sell more boots if it didn't just appeal to niche subcultures.
@@Stridewise Better for the thumbnail. Timberland and Doc Marten will pull more results in search results.
The yellow lines are iconic!!!!!!!
I'm sure the word you're looking for is goofy/corny
@@emanuil1046 nah, theyre cute :)
The yellow isn’t the only color, there’s also a full black, but at the same time you’re buying Dr. Martens knowing they have the yellow Goodyear welt.
@@emanuil1046 not as corny as Tims but keep going.
@@forevertillnight74 I'm pretty sure the only docs that are still Goodyear welted are the made in england or horween pairs. they newer mainline doc's are glued
I’d say Doc Martens really go for the grungy, dark aesthetics while Timberland is a more rugged, heavy style. It all depends on your style, really.
I currently own a pair of DM 1460’s but I want to get a pair of Timbs as well.
the old grafters monkey boots where build better than timberland
Timberlands have a beeter quality and can be black if you order them black, and they look sick. And in general the timberlands boots are known for quality, I wear a pair of hiking boots from their brazilian line and they seem pretty resistant, and i poured some water over the bottom and nothing leaked inside (while cleaning it), even though the pair wasn’t even promoted as water resistant. TL;DR: Timberlands are better and can fit any style if you just get them im another color.
@@TheCitroenman1 wrong
You could wear doc martens casually better than timbs
Please excuse me I am totally blind. But in the movie menace to society the main character by the guy by the name of Kane when he gets shot he is wearing a gray guess USA sweater and some black jeans and a pair of Doc Martin boots I remember those style that style was an ankle boot it went up right past the ankle does anybody happen to know what style of boot that was it came in a black leather he shiny black and also a dark brown please help me find this or remember this boot style
Timbs just look like my dad's worksite boots. Doc Martens are actually beautiful.
My thoughts exactly. I wore those for long enough working in construction.
Because they’re .... goofy
Timberland is for fashion and for work docs don’t even last that long the quality went down and the only good quality ones are in England so if you want a boot that’ll last long and look good for years get some timbs
your dad has nice style
You can get black timbs though and other colours
Imagine walking around town and you just see this dude wearing Timbs on one foot and Docs on the other.
Haha
Shout out my dudes who rock both.
Im not a dude but yes i love me some good old, docs and some early edition timberlands
Yep have DM 1460's and Timberlands. Also have DM 1461 shoes …… shoes are my favourite I think.
DM shoes, Timber boot
My mom got her Doc Martens when she was around 16-17, she’s 34 now and they’re still holding strong! My dad has had Timberlands since he was 16-17 (i believe) and he’s also 34, they’re very dirty, but also still holding strong.
How old are you
Did you get a pair of either when you were like "16-17"?
Sorry I can tell from this vid he really likes Timberland and quite hates Dr martens
No
He didn't seem to hate the martens, just thought the tims were more versatile.
it's valid though
Dr. Martin's are more of a dress boot not a work boots
Ross Francis Murray yep yep yep
I have 6 pairs of Docs. Started buying them in my 20s. Shoes/boots for life.
What colours?
@@mysteriaxo5671 black and brown different styles
How old are you?
@@dsanchezc3 fair enough i own a black pair and i own a pale brown pair they are good
Give me one
thats why you should have gotten the UK docs.
GreenDayfreak717 would of been a fair comparison then
Wouldn't make much of a difference
@@damiangoff8952 it wouldn't timberlands are way better by far
@@Walter-white891 guess I just really hate timbs 🤷♀️ I don't find them comfy at all. My docs are like 10 years old and still going strong and comfy. Plus a life time warranty for wear and tear 🤷♀️.
they shouldn't be compared. They are two entirely different worlds. Also dudes biased.
also, own a pair of jadon DM's because im pretty punk
Bruh just admit it timberlands are better
@@Walter-white891 timberlands are trash 🗑
@@r.i.t95 are they how about support your claim with facts i can timberlands have shanks and its critical absolutely critical to have shanks in your boots. doc martens the sole on doc martens are very good quality but it wears out very quickly timberlands last way longer and doc martens are way more uncomfortable because there's no shank to support your foot . poor quality material used on doc martens on the upper snd i believe the yellow stitching isn't even stitched to the it itself same with timbs i believe but timberlands are way better quality boots and last you a lot longer. so next time when you try to insult my point of view that's actually educated do the research cause doc martens are 🗑🗑🗑.
@@r.i.t95 fanboy cry
Black timberlands ;)
I'll take the Doc's all day, I'm not into the YMCA builder boy look.
😂 A year on and I get a notification of replies, holy 💩 🦇 man, wear what you like folks I hear chaps are making a come back 😏
Lmfao
Chris Greenwood ffs you’ve put me off getting Timbs now 😂
You're crazy as hell. Nothing gay about a Timberland!
Hahaha
Just get them black lol
I have a pair of Doc Martens shoes from the early 90's and the are the made in England and they are made with a much superior quality leather than the Asian made boot leather. The leather has worn in beautifully over the years and all that Ive done is periodically wipe them down with a damp rag. The soles have only slight wear and the footbed has molded perfectly to my feet. I know I can no longer get them, so I go easy on them. Regarding these two boots, I would say for functionality and winter wear, the Timberland would probably be a better choice for foot protection and comfort. The Docs would be better suited for protected environments where theres minimal moisture and moderate temperatures. The Timberland would be better for the cold and wet.
You can still get that exact pair. Doc martens have a “made in England” line thats slightly more expensive but it’s made in their 100+ year old factory in England that doc’s used to be made in.
@@coldercoronet6248 its not the same quality as the ones from the 90s. my sister has a pair from the 90s and i got one from 08 both mie. her leather is so much better.
@@bakwoodz3542 the closest you can get to the originals are solovairs, made across the road in Northampton, they were the other partner / inventor in airwair (the soles)
@@coldercoronet6248 unfortunatelly they are not the same anymore, plus they cost an arm and a leg for what they are. Dr Martens back in the early 90's were pretty affordable. Real Timberland costed three times as much and it was almost a status symbol for ''rich kids''.
solovair is the closest you can get to the old DMs, seeing as theyre constructed more closely than even the made in england DMS that lack the wooden shank that makes them comfy in the first place.
If you order from their UK site, Dr. Martens do have half sizes, but ya know shipping
The way you styled the timberlands make them look really smart compared to how people usually wear them. It makes me really want to start wearing my timberlands again!
I have an older pair of Timberlands in classic yellow that I lace like actual boots. One day I was at a liquor store and ran into a dude that had a baby blue pair that was unlaced and all hood floppy etc. It was a funny moment when we kind of looked at each other.
Something about Dr. Martens that just makes me smile. Always loved them.
08:01 ladies be lookin like wtf is this guy doing lol
Prolly thought dude was blind with two different boots on
I own both, the timberland premium boot and doc martens made in asia, and hands down the doc martens wins in terms of shock absorption, I can wear doc martens for a full day of walking and not feel half as tired as any regular sneaker. Timberland’s fit isnt quite as gd as doc martens too in my opinion, the docs mould better to the feet. Timberland fared better for wet weather
I bought my first pair of Docs from a thrift store when I was thirteen. They lasted seven years. After that I bought them regularly. However, the last pair I bought, I had to return. After wearing them twice five of the eyelet grommets fell out. I love the look but they sure don't make them like they used to.
I recently bought a pair of the boots in the classic hard leather, two different pairs cracked within a month before I got my money back. Now I'm hoping the greasy leather version will fare better. They don't make them like they used to for sure.
I've had my Timberland's for 24 years and they are great. Had them resoled about 3 years ago. They still look so new that nobody believes me how old they really are.
I didn't know you could resolve them.
Are they genuine soles? Where do you buy them?
@@ogotuwaobuto5366 no they’re not. My local shoe repair guy resoled them fo me with vibrant soles.
@Daniel Cloete oh yeah. I climbed Mount Fuji in Japan wearing these monsters.
I work for Timberland and I approve this message.
👌
Bare in mind however that this is a comparison of these two specific boots, not Timberland and Doctor Martin as brands. Timberland have an absolutely massive range of trainers, casual boots and work style boots. As do Doc Martin! Although you could easily associate Timberland with hip-hop and Doc Martin with rock/punk, I listen to metal and would only really wear Timberland (even before I started working for them).
I have them both. And I really can’t choose! Lately I‘ve been wearing my timbs more often, but i love them both equally.
I love my 2 pair of DM! I wear it most of the year and they are supercomfortable. In winter I wear wide socks and because its not exacly my size they don't squeeze my feets
Are doc martens okay to wear during the summer?
@@katiegarcia4253 yes just don't wear a very thick sock
I rock both. The Docs took ages to break in, but they were perfect after that. The Tims didn't need to be broken in and felt perfect straight away. I love em both equally!
Always wanted to see direct and extensive comparsion of these two...many thanx!
You're welcome! Glad you found it useful, Milan.
Docs are just emo timbs. I wear them with black slacks and I’m in the legal field. The clients who see them always chuckle.
Wtf? Bro, ur fucking stupid. I mean, its not nice to say that to someone, but ur comment is so fucking stupid i cant even... EMO timbs, stfu
Harold you’re so fucking ignorant
You triggered some emos, bro.
"Emo Timbs"
Docs are fucking trash dude timberland boots are way better
I love doc martens! 😍😍😍 They last so long, but are very expensive.
bob ross thats why they are pricey
I’m not trying to be mean but as far as boots go there on the cheap side but don’t let that discourage you from liking / wearing them
They actually don't last long at all
You've come so far with your denim choices! So proud haha!
This is really bad comparation because you have two different styles. You have the worst pair of Dr. Martens that I have ever seen.
Doc's leather is one of the best (don't know if not THE best) on boots and you decided to pick one that isn't even made in England.
Plus one more thing... I don't know if it is that true or if it isn't, but my mom told me that the yellow thread (is that what it's called?) is supposed to tell you, if it is a work boot or not. Because when they were first made, they were as a work shoes and as the company had grown they didn't sell just work ones, so that's how you knew who just had his/her work shoes in.... theater (as an example).
You are right about the style. Some outfits will work with Docs and others the Tim’s. This review is more for fun as no one will be looking at the two trying to decide what to wear for the day. However I think he was right to get the Asian assembled boot. That is the volume model and the one that an average buyer is going to pick up. The made in England ones might have better letter (and mid-soles) but they sell in lower numbers because most buyers don’t see the value. For a reviewer who often covers boots over $500 he was never going to be impressed with the leather. Tidy, stylish and easy to clean is a decent enough compliment for a low priced pair of fashion boots.
I find Doc Martens are too loose if you lace them that way. Lacing them straight makes a big difference.
Definitely
Agreed, mine has no loosening problem with a right tight laces
I think over under lacing is best for docs
what do u mean by lacing straight?
@@hagartsesarsky9233 There are different ways, but what I do is kind of ladder up the shoe with one side of lace until I end up with straight lines across on the outside.
There are pictures and videos, but you'll know you've done it right when you can get the boot as tight as you want it.
I have 6 pairs of docs and 2 pairs of Tims. Dr. Martens softwair hands down...comfort wise.
Docs for the win ✊ where my grunge people at
Present!
o/
Lovey Dog
Docs aren’t grunge bro. Fuck off. When were you born? Christ.
go back to Twitter
I love grunge style but I prefer black timbs over doc martens any time
Dr. Martens don’t @ at me
@you
Bro i dont care, we all have opinions buts personally i like both idrc a boots a boot.
Timbs is what got me into the world of boots. My first pair is a pair of basic black Timbs. Still serving me well 5 years on.
I live in Toronto. I need them Timbs for our winters here
I do too, but I get by just fine with MIE docs. Just need dat dubbin to protect them from nasty salt/salty slush.
i got some snow docs and theyre quite similar to timbs. gotta check what its made of tho idt its nubuck
I have a pair of Doc Martens made in England. They’re my favorite pair of boots, and was worth every penny! 🔥
Well I do own them both and although dr marteens are more comfortable you’re right, they’re pretty hard to pull off specially on like an office environment
I’ve had both. Got my Timby’s in the ‘80s and wore them through dirt, mud, snow, ice, etc. They lasted over 20 years. The Docs were very comfortable (that sole!), but not for heavy duty, IMO. Both great boots, just different.
Nick, you got some strange looks there @8:03, all three of them haha
Thanks for the review of these classic boots, Nick. I favor Timberland, which I own in a chukka style. I have also owned Timberland shoes, which were rugged. However, these days I only buy Allen Edmonds or Johnston and Murphy. You are doing a great job with your channel.
Heavy-duty days came to end
I live in a super rainy area and my timberlands got absolutely destroyed within a year despite trying not to let too much moisture touch the leather, though I likely had a bad egg as the sole also began falling off after less than 6 months. My docs on the other hand are completely pristine after 6 years.
Put up a poll Nick
I got a pair of both N I love em. I wear the Tims during the day with my "regular" friends, and I wear the Docs mostly at night with my punk rock community. I highly recommend them both!
I love Doc Mart... especially now, the tagline "what do you stand for?" So when i wear them, I feel like i can be myself n be proud...
Timberland you also get a 2 year manufacture warranty so if they start leaking etc take your receipt and shows to a timberland store and u get a new pair. They also last 10 years +
You can wear Doc's no matter what your age is! And with any outfit! Never heard such nonsense..
@Graham M Some adults keep wearing them though. Could be either they still see themselves as edgy or they actually just like them.
@@Drownedinblood They need to grow up.
Graham M - I’m in my late 30s, have Danner, Alden, Wolverine, Oak Street, others, I make a healthy living and still have Docs. It’s interesting, I’ve heard that from people before about Docs - including from Nick. I wonder if anyone feels the same about Chuck Taylors for example. They are also quite unique and inexpensive but you see them worn by all kinds of people.
Seth _ I’m mid-30s and wear Chucks all the time. I make good money and so do my peers, who also wear Chucks. I own US-made Timberlands from Neiman, but I’d easily wear Asian-made ones during the harsh New England winter if I didn’t have more expensive (Red Wing mostly) boot options.
Docs are seen as working class which many people hate. I'd imagine that's most of people beef with them.
Great video ....I own both for years ....worn the docs 80 percent of the time
Glad you liked it!
I love doc martins but if you’re like me, they’ll get dirty and scratched. I like wearing them to school they really pull of my outfit but if you have gym don’t wear these they are pretty heavy and they tend to weigh you down when you run obviously bit other than that they’re sooo cute.
I wore my docs throughout winter in Pittsubrgh, my friends with tims put them away as soon as the streets got wet. I'm just saying.
plus i've had mine for 7 years, my friend has had 2 pairs of tims in the mean time..... also, because I've had them for that long, my boots have literally molded to my foot. the yellow stitching is iconic, don't come for it.
There is a big difference between Made in England and Made in ‘Asia’ Doc M. The made in UK leather are thicker and the sole and harder.
M Sato I’m not racist but made in Asia docs are a piece of shit
I meant to say is I’m not racist
My first pair of boots were some Timbs when I was in middle school. I out grew them and then in late high school I bought some Docs and still used them every now an then. I own a wide range of boots now and I've been wanting to buy a pair of Timbs again.
DM's for me but only the "made in england" ones the foreign DM's are tat
I bought a made in vietnam pair of 1490s in 2011 and by 2018 the leather coating is breaking down and flaking away. I replaced them with a pair of original 1490s made in 1995 back when they were still made in england from a vintage shop and the leather is 1mm thicker all around and the leather is a higher quality noticeably. The surface is actually leather and not that weird plastic "smooth" coating they use now. The difference is night and day. If anyone remembers the rugged last forever Dr Martens boots from highschool in the 90s, your memeory isn;t failing you, the new Dr Martens are not as good as the ones you had as a lad. in any regard.
Exactly right, they moved manufacturing to southeast Asia and switched to cheaper materials. My first pair I bought well used when I was a kid (I couldn't afford new then). They lasted almost ten years. The most recent pair I sent back after wearing them a couple of times as the eyelets started falling out.
You're one of those suckers who fall for the Made in England crap ... lol.. I have 3 pairs of made in china, they are like new after 10 years of insane walking distances, parties, travels.... Why do people dont understand that the only difference is literally the place where the boots are made and nothing else. LIterally nothing else.
@@ludwigvonn9889 DM's have been made in England since 1960 and made in asia for 5 minutes, As an Englishman why would i want to wear anything but "british made"
@@KATHYMEADful you're probably a far right person eh
I have Timbs and Dr.Martens.. the problem with DM’s this days is their sole are not the same like the 90s model.. but still love it..
I've got DM's that I've had for 20+ years. They are minimal but hold up extremely well.
Depends how you use them. I've worked with my DM. My soles on the DM wore out quickly. I guess they are just casual boots.
J444 , I've worked in them too. I actually got the DM workers, my job bought them for us and they were awesome. But as for the regulars, yeah maybe.
@@a75jennings I gotta check DM worker. What model do you recommend?
Him: So I'm gonna review the made in China Docs instead of the made in England Docs
Him: Wow, Docs really aren't that durable or strong and are really poorly made
Really?
Yeah because I'm reviewing the most popular Doc Martens boot. Which I say super clearly.
stridewise Take your point about popularity however price wise the UK made boot is closer in price to the Timberland and the quality is far higher than the Asian made boot which are frankly rubbish.
Got my first DMs when I was 14 am now over 60 and they are all I own (7 pairs) and one pair of classic reeboks. Don't intend to change but have progressed from boots to shoes and lately Chelsea boots in black,brown and oxblood which hopefully I can still get for the next twenty years as I will not manage shoelaces when the dementia sets in!
I am not going to lie that was a fair review! I dont know what sort of 1460's those were but for sure they were not the same as mine 😅. I agree that particular pair are plastic-y looking. Keep up the good work!
I have a pair of all black Timberlands. Great look and incredibly comfortable.
You dont look like you have ever had to actually use work boots
So...work smart not hard. Why you mad?
Both are damn comfortable. I get a ton of compliments on my timbs though. More than any other shoe I've ever own.
I stand corrected. The reviewer stated that the “cultural baggage “ was attached to the Dr Martens. I apologize
Hell yeah Pennsylvania ain't as bad as Canada but u still need timbs . im 36 i never own another brand of boots
Here I am drinking my morning coffee in sweden, it snowy and shitcold outside thinking I need better wintershoes. Thinking about Timberlands waterproof ones, yeah but how are they different from my doc martens? If only there was a video of someone more ambitious, explaining it… AND HERE YOU ARE! Thanks. I’m buying a pair of Timberland today.
Haha! I'm 53!! And I wear Docs every day 😂
But you're in a band right?
I'll be 70 this year, and I wear DM's...1460's and others...and to Lofty....I, am in a band, and have been in bands since I was 15 years old, LOL... Old habits die Hard....
Have both, a pair normal timberland work boots and a pair of Dr martens Chelsea boots, and they are both wonderful. If you’re uncertain about which ones to pick just go after what type of jeans you’re usually wearing.
Dr martens also have different styles so if you don’t like the gloss you could have easily get a more matt finish :)
Doc Martens > Timberland
@McDonald's recipe nah u wanna look like a damn construction worker? Tf u thinkin
I have 5 pairs of DM, but not all of them are boots. Women have it way easier with DM- there are a lot more styles to choose from. I can wear Docs to almost any occasion now. I love that!
I have the classic black 1460s, the Vonda II floral embroidered 14 eyelet tall boots, the Kendra 10 eyelet high heeled boots (the only ones I own that don't have the iconic yellow stitching, though they do have the loops on the backs), the black high heeled Seraphina sandals, and the cherry red high heeled Granik sandals. I love that DM offers heels. They are an entirely comfortable 4" chunky heel but the 1" platform makes them a really wearable 3" heel. I'm not the girl for stilettos, they are uncomfortable, not my style, and I'm unable to wear them for more than a half hour at a time! With DM heels I can wear them all day in perfect comfort. The heels are just as comfy as the flat boots and you really can wear them anywhere- dressy or casual. If you're a woman who likes heels and also that Doc Marten's style, try their heels!
I don't think the 'Made in England' line is worth the extra cash, IMHO. The style choice is limiting, and unless you are the kind of person who wears the same boots every single day all day long, I just don't think I'd be inclined to spend an extra $50 or more just so I can say I have a pair of Docs that are made in England. The Asian Docs are just fine, especially if you're rotating them with other shoes/boots. But don't buy the fakes!! Even if you don't think people can tell, they can.
How can you tell between fake Docs and real ones? I don’t want to mistakenly purchase non authentic ones
New York vs London
its so hard its like comparing hip hop to rap
“Doesnt screem ruggedness” my dad still wears a pair of doc martins older than me
This guy has no idea what he's talking about. He should have compared the Made in England Docs since those are the Docs that have the reputation for being a good boot. Those versions also have a shank in them, not sure if the newer Made In England versions do but yes the made in Asia versions don't.
I'm wearing a pair of Made in England Docs right now that are 25 years old. And yes the black Docs go with way more outfits than those yellow Timberlands. I don't know what this guy is smoking.
roxics
The older doc martens that are decades old vintage had a shit ass thin as hell wooden shank in them (that was always snapped in half) on boots. It’s not even worth mentioning that shank honestly. Newer MIE docs don’t have any shanks, and ofc none of the made in Asia ones do either.
@@anti-ethniccleansing465 even though the shank sucked it still proveded more support (even broken) than no shank, after a while the lack of the shank just hurts feet. i like the solovairs more, youre better off spending the extra money cause theyre actually comfortable in long periods of use and have much better leather than even the MIE docs. also solovair is sorta more true to the DM name since they were literally the factory that made doc martens until they weren't.
The irony is that it's because they're older than you. The newer ones last a lot less.
I have a pair of Docs and I just recently bought a Timberlands as a birthday gift for myself. I do like my Docs but I really love the style and practically of the Timberlands. They look great with everything but still has the stength to take on anything and everything.
Without a doubt, I love the sleek leather look of Doc Martins but Timberlands are way more comfortable and practical to me. I feel that Timbs are also easier to clean and maintain
Never tried Solovair, but had a few pairs of DMs. I find the DMs need a few weeks of breaking in, but are comfortable after that, but the soles don’t last long. Never tried to get them repaired either.
If you’re from New York, you already know the answer
The Dr. Martin and timberland boots are very good but please review the caterpillar work boot
For me, Timbs all the way.
PSA FOR ANYONE WHO WANTS DOCS BUT HAS TROUBLE AFFORDING THEM!!! Doc Martens Layton’s are REALLY good. They’re still kinda expensive but like half the price mine were about $80 after tax whereas the classics can be up around $160. The layton’s are soft leather and go with everything i kid you not I find them SO much more comfortable than the 1460s too!!!! so yeah if you’re looking for some comfortable, affordable docs, the layton’s are the way to go :^)
TImberlands are just preppy - too nice and cute. DMs are for the rest of us low-life, proud working class peasants.
nmfl100 DM's are still expensive af tho 😒
@@doopielad7687 I disagree - bearing in mind they last for a decent number of years, they're really not that expensive. I've bought boots for half the price of the 1460s and those only lasted two or three winters. Doc Martens 1460s last me about 10 or more winters.
nmfl100 Winters aren't really bad where I'm from and it's alot of money for people who struggle so I still stand with my first opinion. It's different for everyone.
@@doopielad7687 Sure, I get what you're saying and I respect that. I just meant good shoes are expensive but you need to see them as a long term investment, they will turn out to be cheaper than buying several pairs of inexpensive shoes, not to mention the benefits in terms of health, comfort and style. From my experience, it's hard to buy decent shoes that are comfortable and last more than a couple of years for less than around 50 euros/dollars, and quality shoes have prices starting at around 100 euros/dollars.
I got the doc marten as well. But my leather is different, it has like that snakeskin pattern on it like real leather instead o being smooth
The unlined shaft of the Dr. Martens is a huge plus. Unlined means the shaft is softer and contours to the calf/ankle better.
Dr. Martens! Got my first pair back in 2014, still rocking them today
Fun fact, Aussie SASR used to be issued docs
That's a really cool fact. Any more info?
wearing either has its merits, both are amazing if rocked right, but I find myself wearing my mono leather 1460s more than my wheat constructs. main reason is that the combat boots silhouette (which is what docs are) are more used by high end designers, Im just happy that I have an alternative to Dior 07 navigators or SLP Ranger boots.
Dr. Marten REAL thread.
Timber 3D PRINTED.
the thread is pretty much aesthetic only for docs at this point, doesn't really serve a purpose
@@amanasd26 really? Watch this and maybe you will change your mind.
m.ua-cam.com/video/rO1YAx4QW1I/v-deo.html
@McDonald's recipe did you see the REAL yellow thread? not printed.... so maybe timbs PRINTED thread is for aesthetics only
Have both. Wore my tombs for about 4 years before the sides tore. On my 6th month with my docs and they're holding up decently. I however can already tell I'm not gonna get 4 years out if them. I love the look, feel of them. They're just not as reliable.
1:13 "Is he taking a video of his feet?"
I'm used to those looks John hahah
Just a tip for every one who wants to resole there timberlands just put them on a top of wood burning heater and the sole just falls off after 10 minutes and you can glue a new one on there
Solovair vs doc mart
Never had a pair of Timbs, but I will say that Docs are not winter shoes. They're great if you live in a mild climate, but totally impractical in the snow and cold. The tread has zero grip and gets super slippery in my experience. I love them for the look and style, not for the practicality as a boot
Docs for sure no questions asked.
I'm a locksmith, so I need dedicated work boots, who does triple duty between residential, commercial, and industrial work... so they also have to be light, comfortable, easy to move in and easy to drive in, low maintenance is a big plus, because they have to look clean and professional looking. I also do some emergency calls so I have to be able to run in them.
The Docs are one of the few that fit the bill for the price. I'm tried the Tims, the Wolverines, (both feel like I'm wearing Micky Mouse boots while driving or running in both) and the Redwings ($$$$$ and not much better) and keep going back to the Docs. I don't like that they don't have half sizes, and yeah, they do lack firm arch support, but both issues can be solved with thick socks and a good pair of decent gel insoles, which means I can wear them comfortably for as long as 20 hours before my feet start to hurt.
Oh, and if you get the greasy leather, they are actually fairly water resistant, though not waterproof... provided you keep them greased up (ten minutes work once a week in the rainy season).
They DO seem to have had a bit of quality dropoff since moving most of the production to Asia, and they don't last anywhere near as long as they did 10+ years ago, but they're still a dang good work boot, IF a work boot is what you're looking for... If you're JUST interested in fashion, just get what you like.
This should be in Death Battle.
As a fan of DM I have to point out that the DM has a sprayed on coating over the leather. The leather does not breath as well and prone to cracking if not looked after carefully.
If you are going to dig holes and work in the dirt, get the Timberland, if you want a nice looking comfortable boot that does not track in dirt, get the Doc's.
Any of those has its own "industrial" section. That ones we have to choose if we are going to use it in the construccion or something similar.The classic boot its only for a "normal" use. The docs are versatile for an urban stile, timberland are for rainy days or walking in a mud path.
@@nibblss I don't wear my Doc's in a mud path, thank you for making my point.
I have both. 1 timb 2 docs and I change the insoles on all of my shoes. Make a Huge difference. I use plantar support insoles. You gotta find your right support.
In terms of functionality, you should go with Tims...... If you go for looks, then Dr. it is.......
But after all, I would stick with my Iron Rangers
I was times and doc martens in my late teens, mid 20s now and made the jump to redwings and thorogood. Much better in every way
I love my beckmans and iron rangers
I’ve got a pair of the Timberlands in all black, which I primarily use on weekends for running errands, and such, during the winters. I’ve had them for 3 years now and they still look good. Comfortable, but a bit heavy, as you said. And, I’m not into hip-hop.