He went back to the King Rd home looking for that knife sheath. He most likely thought he dropped it outside, but he didn’t. Of course he wasn’t going to reenter the crime scene. Im utterly astounded at people who thing this guy is innocent and being framed.
Even the cops didn't find the sheath on the first pass/search of the crime scene. If it was under Maddie idk how they would miss it. I'm not saying he's not a weirdo and maybe has done something but the evidence they currently have likely will not convict him. It's weak at best. Cell phone pings in the area don't mean much, 12 cells of DNA and that's all in that bloody of a scene is sus, the car year they were looking for is off, and he has no DNA evidence in his car, home, work, etc. My understanding is that cell tower will also ping if you're at the Walmart there too so he very easily could've been at the Walmart at least some of those 12 cell phone pings. Unless he's actually seen on camera around their home none of it proves he was there. Again, he may be guilty but they need more than this to convict.
@@jakestans They don’t need it. His cell pings in the crime scene area. Ask yourself this question? Why does his cell ping in the area of these murders so frequently? In October it pinged twelve times. Coincidence? No, he’s the guy.
who gives a crap about the video when it's wrong, nothin happened in the house. There is not one MPD bodycam image with Brian Coldburgers face on it. Why is MPD holding BK when they are the murderers?
Call me paranoid but i still don't understand why people don't lock their doors, even if u live in the safest place on earth we live in a world of crazy .
Ya it’s just incredibly sad. I live in Westwood by ucla which is very safe but always lock sliding door and front door. I’m sure people in the Midwest are used to leaving their cars and homes unlocked because of the low crime and obviously no one thinks anything like this could happen. Rip and condolences to the families
I live a small town, biggest crime is running a stop sign or a teenager speeding. I’m a older woman living alone & I never locked anything until this happened. Now, I not only lock everything but I check to make sure everything is locked before going to bed. I no longer come in after dark or leave before daylight. Maybe I’m crazy, but this made me a believer.
I even keep all my doors locked on my vehicle while driving out and about! Well, it paid off because some random man tried to pull on the handle and get in the truck with me. Always keep doors locked!
@@danecrawford2658 Had this happen to a coworker. a pan handler opened her passenger side door and stole her purse. Since she told us that story, I'm adamant about my doors being locked and my purse on the floor in my car.
It’s a party house in college on a Saturday night… why would anyone immediately think murder? So many ignorant people here that didn’t experience college and it shows.
There's a couple things I see that could give more detail. For 1 I believe Dylan's door opened from the other direction & I thought she only cracked the door after hearing the crying & saw him walk by. Also the doorway that he walks thru as he passes by her door has a step up/down, meaning one room was "sunken down" lower than the one it meets up with in said doorway. I believe that in the very dark house, especially since he would have already navigated the step on his way to kill the last 2 victims, he was looking down for the step & walked right by Dylan not even seeing her.
Makes sense. However I heard early on she said he was 5’10”. Being that he was a step higher and well over 6 feet tall - her report of 5’10” doesn’t make sense. Also his bushy eyebrows wouldn’t have been easily seen in the dark at this angle. I don’t have a strong opinion on this case other than to say I still have doubts BK was the only one responsible. I have big problems with the roommates’ actions - especially DM. I don’t trust the cops to be honest if frat boys were part of this or something else nefarious that was going on at the house. It would destroy the school and town which is basically owned by the university.
@@GeorgiaJakes7You hit the nail right on the head, there's no way BK could have done this ALONE... I don't trust the 2 surviving roommates and I truly believe DM was in on it... It's well known now she was a drug dealer and people who knew them admitted Dylan and Maddie had bad blood because of it and got into a heated argument that evening before they went out with Maddie threatening to call the police on Dylan.
If Dylan on the second floor could hear Kaylee on the third floor saying "Somebody's here" and then hear Xana on the second floor whimpering from her bedroom down the hall and a male voice saying to Xana, "I'm going to help you," then Dylan heard everything that went on in that house that night. She is withholding much information that would likely solve this case.
She might not be withholding anything but has told the police everything and we will be able to find out at the trial. I believe the police have so much more info that is not being shared with the public.
That’s an assumption, and why would she hold back any information if she knew anything. Also I doubt there was very much talking going on besides what she heard. I wouldn’t think the killer was carrying on conversations with anybody.
Can anyone explain why the survivors didn't CHECK on their friends? for 8 hours? After seeing a "strange" man lurking in the house at 4am? I just don't get that part of this entire thing.
I agree and why did they wait 7-8 hours later to call police because they thought their friends were just passed out…did they not see all the blood? And why did he leave a survivor walk past her and not just kill everyone in the house? Too many whys. Makes absolutely no sense the whole thing. Something just does not add up.
Yes!!! The other thing I don't get, when they supposedly woke and called their friends, as they couldn't wake the room mates up due to them thinking they was passed out... Surely the blood and knife gashes were a huge giveaway? Its weird enough not calling the police after seeing a stranger at 4am sneaking about, but why not call once they'd seen the blood and gore? Also.. they have to have heard something! Especially with Xana fighting for her life!! Screaming/shouting will have been happening and the audio for the cctv on the house next door proved that! If that picked it up, then other people in the house MUST have heard this, unless they had hearing problems 🤦🏻♀️
And did the survivors not hear the screams and the noises I mean the NOISES those 4 kids must have made I mean I know there had to noises there was defensive wounds on one of them… there had to have been some awful NOISES. So sad to think about like that but the noises being made had to have been something never heard from them before BUT still doesn’t bother to check on them until eight hours later…. I just can’t make that make sense to me
If someone breaks into your house during the day, they're there for your stuff. If they break in during the night, they're there for YOU. I believe this was definitely a targeted hit and more than one person was involved. Jmo
@@B_FBfanFrat boys... It's well known now that they were pretty much living in a trap house... Dylan and Xana were drug dealers, Maddie threatened to call the cops on Dylan and flushed Xana's stash down the toilet pretty much signing her death warrant if true...
@@B_FBfanThe truth of the matter is, this was not random murders, this was a hit. And the cops are trying to cover it up by making BK the scapegoat because they don't want the bad press for the town or the university... Either this was done by a professional hitman or done by multiple people and BK is the fall guy.
Assuming these facts are true, my key takeaway from this is how much/often he was driving by the subjects' house. While not conclusive of any crime, it certainly highlights the thought process of obsession. This behavior occurs from extreme crush, or feelings of hate.
I think he was there to buy drugs. Not to mention have we even proven that was his white car and his plates and him driving? Why didn’t they put the gas station footage in the affidavit if it was his white car?
@@jujub3012barely any proof of it even being his car. If they are counting on cell towers and a single source dna on an empty knife sheath that wasn’t even found the first search of the home they will fail to convict him. How could u kill 4 people and walk out with an unsheathed knife and bloody clothing and not get any in your car, house, or outside the scene?
@@tula1433 Cell tower pings and cameras all the way there and back, yeah, sure no evidence what so ever. LOL First search of the house they dind't touch the bodies, sheath was found UNDER Maddy during the 2nd search. BK had 6 weeks to throw stuff away and clean his car or maybe he Dexter'ed it and himself out. He was a criminologist for Gods sake, he had to have learned something.
The surviving roommate who saw him and didn’t call the police is going to be compelled by the state to testify and subject to brutal cross examination.
I know no one wants to question the survivors, but why with all that blood did they wait 8hrs? I’m sorry I don’t believe them especially DM who was seen by the killer and left alone, it makes zero sense
He may have returned to the scene after he went home upon realizing he had dropped the knife sheath in an attempt to retrieve it but then decided against it possibly but if it was found under the body he may not have been able to locate it at the time of the crime and had no choice but to abandon the scence and leave the critical evidence
And I want to know why police aren't checking wooded areas or bodies of water, etc. for where he dumped the bloody clothes and knife. He disposed of it all or buried it somewhere. Why were police not out with dogs searching any area he could've been to in the time frame between the murders and when he arrived back in Pullman??
@@jaynesullivan4432he could've wrapped the inside of the car with plastic. He was a criminology student. So he knew how to do a certain amount of covering himself.
Is there any actual verifiable official report from any investigators working on this case? Because unless you can provide information that says that, it shouldn't be put out to the public as fact.
I think as the killer was coming down the stairs to the 2nd floor, Ethan was stepping out of Xanas room to investigate and the killer then stabbed him. Xana likely saw them scuffling just outside her door, so he had to kill her too.
If you agree with that theory, then it proves it had to be multiple people involved. Ethan was a big guy at 6'4" and would have taken more than one to take him down. I think DM knows who did this.
I think Xana saw and ran back to the room and he caught her just as she tried closing the door. As I think it was Ethan that was in the bed, I thought we knew that much from the court papers.
@@duecebiggalowe that's a dumbass take; it would take 'more than one guy' with a fucking big-ass knife to take down a college kid just cause he's tall?
I've followed this story since hearing about it on the news. The darkness, timing, and the sequences of the souls involved are observably strange. Like they were on cue. Condolences to the families.
so Dylan could here someone say 'there's someone here' but couldn't hear her 4 roommates get killed? Especially as Xana was awake at the time of the murders as she just got food delivery. that makes no sense.
I agree. When someone is being murdered, and being two at a time she should have heard a lot of noise. I don't think she is telling the truth. She was probably drunk, or high, or both and has no idea what was going on.
@@jerrybranscum3017 not necessarily. It takes a lot out of a person to scream. So must likey they didn’t. We shouldn’t judge dylan for how she reacted. Everyone reacts differently.
Maybe, but 4 people were killed there, I just find it very hard to believe that not one of those young people wasn't screaming, I just have a hard time with that.
This video was absolutely amazing and blew my mind despite that horrible nature of the content. Bro, you have some serious talent and you should do videos for a lot more of these cases
I can name multiple SK’s who have done just this. I don’t understand how it is so unfathomable how one single sick-minded individual on a mission could not have done this in the middle of the night. He, whether it’s BK or not, snuck in and likely ambush attacked the sleepy victims. He had the upper hand. They had been out drinking and likely barely alert, if at all. It just is sadly not that incomprehensible.
Yes. And then he had NO DNA in his car, pipes, apartment, nothing?? Wtf the lack of evidence and he wasn't wearing like a dexter suit is too hard to ignore. I don't believe that he did it because how could he be that good, nobody is that good
So Dylan heard everything, ordered food, saw the killer close enough to describe his eyebrows, and doesn’t call police and I’m suppose to believe she’s in the clear? 😂😂😂
For all we know Dylan could have been half asleep and just assumed it was a weird friend that shocked her a bit. She had no reason to suspect at all that she was face to face with a killer.
So she gets up 3 times? Then calls friends over before the cops later? Nothing about it makes sense. I’m not saying she had anything to do with it but this series of events makes no sense
Oh you see an intruder in your house! And he also walks past you. You don't call the cops or warn the others in the house. No you lock your door and go to sleep????? WTF!!!!! And the dog didn't bark to a stranger?
Questions: 1) why did no one scream? It seems like while he was killing one person, there was a 2nd person in the rooms, I wonder why none screamed for help? Or did they? Apparently no one did? 2) why would she wait 8 hours?
They did. Kaylee did, the dog did, and I believe Ethan shouted but for sure xanna did, they call it a whimper but was probably due to injury. Idk but the only quiet ones were Dm and Bf ☹️
Exactly. No screams or obvious sounds of four people getting killed I find that very suspicious and that he just walked passed that Dylan chick is craaazy...probably the easiest target of them off because she was the only one who was alone and all the other ones were two and two together and because of that I find it fucked up that no screams or nothing was made...I find it all very very very strange and very suspicious aswell...and ofcourse the fact she waited 8 hours calling someone else not the police and then some other people are suppose to have called the police. Fucked up.
That’s my biggest question too. We haven’t heard any information about any screams happening, especially when he killed Xana and Ethan. They were both awake at the time so one of them would have had to watch the other one be killed first and no screams? Very sus.
I don't get how he managed to kill 4 people with a knife quietly, especially since he murdered them in pairs while they were sleeping together how did no one hear anything or make any noise.
I don’t believe Kaylee and Maddie were together when he came in. I think Kaylee was with Murphy the dog in her room, heard something in Maddie’s room, went to see and thus angered the killer so he went off on Kaylee, causing extreme injuries..
So she gets scared and does nothing abt for 8 hrs. Wakes up calls not the police but another friend ?! I’m sure there was blood everywhere why not call the police first. This is so weird
I guess drugs were involved at least somewhat in that residence. They probably didn’t want to get in trouble for something so silly in comparison to their friends being killed
@@sasuxsakuxfanI could imagine they were all high, especially being awake at 4am probably stoned. If that was the case then I could understand why she didn’t do anything for 8 hours because if you’re very stoned or just genuinely in a high state, then what she saw / heard would be 100 times more freaky than if she was rationally sober
@@onemomenttohislifespandoubtful. Most young people their age stay up late especially on a weekend. Maybe she was afraid of calling thinking he would hear her and break into the room. Idk. People act differently in these situations
So how was Dylan suppose to know, that the unfamiliar guy, she saw come from Xana’s room and leave out the door, just murdered 4 people in the house? She more likely thought that he was Ethan’s friend. Ethan was there that night. So is Dylan suppose to be a superhero who has ESP, and who is able to see through walls and floors? Have bionic hearing and then be able to fight off some psychopath, who has a 7 inch fixed blade knife and possibly a gun? I dont understand everyones thinking. The reason Dylan and Bethany survived was because they had locked bedroom doors, which im sure BK checked and skipped. Because you cant go knocking on bedroom doors in the house, if you plan on murdering them. Thats how you get heard and seen. Then busted.
Absolutely, I can guarantee BK tried the door handle on Dylan's room as he passed by it going up the stairs. It was locked, so he moved onto the next room up stairs. He might have even tried Bethany's door before going up stairs, because no one knows the exact sequence he did when checking doors.
I think seeing an unknown masked man in her house and hearing suspicious sounds would have been a red flag. It's unfortunate she didn't call sooner, there may have been some possibility of saving the victims if they were still alive.
Why did Dylan check outside her room on 3 separate occasions?? Why didn't the slightly built 5'8 guy finish off any witnesses? Especially when he walked right in front of Dylan. Apparently Dylan didn't need bionic earring because while 4 young vibrate teenagers were getting butchered alive no one heard anyone scream.
You wouldn't be screaming, though. By the time you realize in a drunk and sleepy state, your body literally won't allow you to scream because most of your vital organs are connected to your lungs and heart. That would make it so you're physically unable to scream. I do agree that the roommate definitely knows more though.
What I still do not understand is how Dylan heard Kaylee say “someone is here” and then she also heard “I’m here to help you”. How is it that she heard all of those comments yet failed to hear 4 people being brutally murdered!? It doesn’t sit right with me at all. IMO Dylan is suspect and hopefully we will get some answers to all this at the trial.
You make a valid point. You'd think if someone is saying "someone is here" that it would be whispered and not yelled loud enough to hear through a wall. It makes no sense that she could make out words from someone speaking but couldn't make out if someone was playing with a dog or being murdered. 🤷🏼♀️ Being that Xana and Ethan ordered food and Xana was active in tiktok it was likely that one of them was awake.. and if she saw someone enter her room who she didn't know and she saw them with a knife... (IMO) then she would likely yell loud enough for everyone in the house to wake up. Idk... it's odd is all I'm saying. I'm not saying she did it... But I am partially wondering why he picked who he picked. If it was Bryan then I'd say he's exceptionally smart aside from the small DNA left on the knife sheath. They haven't found a murder weapon. His car was clean. No DNA transfer... They haven't found clothing... Shoes... Nothing. So if it was him and he did all of this methodically.... Why leave surviving roommates? Why... Would he pass right by one and leave them alive. It's so odd!
@@TheTiredMomma are you dense too? Did you see the demo? Those floor and walls were paper thin. And guess what, now that it's gone you cant prove any of the acoustic evidence from the night of the murders.
The were reports from investigators that he spent some time cleaning out his car before he was made an official suspect. So the officers couldn’t just go up to him and search his car. That would violate his rights and basically make any evidence obtained without probable cause/ a warrant useless for prosecution and thrown out of court.
Yet here we are with no evidence of cleaning products (and LE did test for it as they dismantled his car) and a very dirty car as seen on the Indiana State police body cam as BK drove to PA when he was pulled over. @@leticiarodriguez383
There is so much more to the case than just what was said here. How did he see in the dark or know the house of has many people were inside. Why wait 8 hours then call friends over before calling police?? The house had to have a lot of blood and that smells, there had to be screaming shouting etc because of the way they say Zana fought. Why was every door UNLOCKED?? After seeing a masked man in the house why not call or text your roommates at least to see if they are okay?? This case is very messed up… period and not as simple as this video makes it seem.!
The youtuber TRUECRIMETIME did an awesome video called "Evidence Bryan was involved in Oregon murders?" At the 16:00 mark he shows what instagram accounts BK was following and he noticed some knife accounts, jiu jitsu and self defense accounts. One account had a video on how to strike someone to bring them to their knees and stab them in the neck in 5 seconds flat. Very intrersting to think that's how he could've taken Ethan down 👀👀👀👀
First time I've seen your channel. I'm only 2 minutes into your video and I don't know why you haven't gotten any comments in 4 days. I chose your video to watch on the Idaho 4 case because the thumbnail looked interesting and it was a comfy 8.5 minutes long. Now watching and I really like this video; it's putting the timeline in perspective and it's easy to follow. No extra speculation or theories, just "facts" from PCA and what little evidence we've heard about. Let me be the first to say "good job." Plus, I believe you're pronouncing Kaylee's last name correctly...a first
There is all kinds of things messed up about all of this. From the residence doors being unlocked, to Dylan not calling police or checking anything or even messaging the girls to no one checking for how many hours. I'm sorry I feel for Dylan and the surviving roommate and I don't think they had anything to do with the crime but this is all jacked up. This was a heinous crime and I just hope something is learned from it all. Frat and sorority houses and other college residences like this are a mess. Start taking security seriously people.
She probably froze or was half asleep. We cant judge Dylan for how she reacted. She probably just thought one of the roommates had a friend over and had a fight. We don’t know what was going on in her mind. We can speculate how we would’ve reacted but we can’t say for sure because we weren’t their
@@Comfortedbyfictionexactly we don’t know, but what I do know is how I would react and anyone else I know would react. And our reactions would be to call the police so I am very suspicious to the way she reacted.
@@tomasm7520but didn’t a camera that’s set up near the house catch whimpers. It’s possible they weren’t able to scream. You would think the camera near the house wouldn’t only catch the whimpers but the screams if there were any
Subcriber 82 here! Welcome to youtube. Amazing visual presentation. I know all this information almost verbatim know but your vistual presentation of it is top notch! Looking forward to the next video.
A troubling part of the story: Why whimpering? Who whimpers when they're being stabbed? Fear can elicit whimpering but...no screaming? Not a single shriek of pure terror?
I agree. My understanding is that Ethan was killed outside Xana's bedroom door so it's likely Xana saw that happen so why wouldn't she scream? Or plead for her life? Anything? Scream no? Burst into tears about her bf?
@@rebeccazeman9309because when things like this happen it’s not like in the movies. People freeze in fear and it’s over before you even comprehend what happened
@@anthonyfrison8511He most likely killed Ethan out in the hallway and the door was closed or halfway open she heard something and I heard he gouged her eyes out and Ethans legs were mutilated so he couldn't run away. That's just what I heard I wasn't there.
people are gonna say anything is odd now in hindsight lol she probably didn't know what was going on. I get your point though, but what makes it odd to me is that she didn't hear anybody screaming for help poor people got stabbed to death and nobody heard a thing in the house?
Well made video, and perfect explanation of the “official narrative,” but this story has a ton of holes in it. I don’t think you can be honestly pursuing the truth this case and think BK did it alone, or was Sir StabsALot. This case is way more than meets the eye and the people that know the truth are keeping quiet.
@Duchess. How do you know it’s BK? There is literally zero concrete evidence and before you say “DNA” it’s not much of anything, really. Touch DNA is notoriously unreliable.
Mortensen was unwilling to admit to cops that she was drunk and that seeing strange men arrive or depart in the middle of the night was not alarming in a house full of party girls who hooked-up. When the masked guy walked by, she had not been alarmed by anyone screaming bloody murder. After Covid. a face mask was not alarming. Regular night noises in that house were not alarming. Just a bit before, the four victims had returned home and a door dash was delivered. That night she had no clue about the carage. When cops asked why she waited to call 911, she knew about the murders, so she SAID she was "frozen in fear" for about 8 hours. This makes no sense wnatsoever. If she was terrified by the masked stranger, after an hour of silence, or less, she would have called 911 from her room if she was still too scared to investigate. Furthermore, 99.8% of chicks would go there rather than admit being drunk and living with a bunch of party-girls.
I'm glad someone finally validated how this crime was carried out ! But I can tell ya right now there's no way he left a witness he either didn't see her or she's involved! Dm that is ! No way he saw her and left her ! Nope this may have been a revenge killing!
If she would have been, they would know it. He would have told them... also I think he didn't see her or he was exhausted and in rush because he didn't know if they called police... Police has said she was not involved so why you think you know better than them?
I have the feeling that 1. He either didn’t see DM or 2. he was extremely exhausted after killing four people and he was such in a state of rush he decided to just leave.
But how do they know all those"spottings" are him? They didn't even have the correct year of his vehicle. Just because they see a blur of a white car in a ring camera late at night, doesn't mean it was him, or even related to this crime at all. This case has more holes than a fishing net.
Really great video! But I cannot believe for the life of me, that after all this time since the crimes, BK's arrest, news reports, families speaking, court hearings, UA-cam videos etc...that you STILL have no idea of how to say Kaylee's last name "Goncalves" properly. 🤦🏻♂
If Kaylee did in reality say" there's someone here" then that most likely would indicate that Kaylee was speaking to someone. DM did not say Kaylee shouted this statement only that she heard who she thought was Kaylee saying this. Thus, it would be most probable that Kaylee knew at least one of her roommates were awake and hear this statement.
IMO I believe it was probably xana saying “there’s someone here” to her boyfriend Ethan. kaylee and Morgan were asleep when they were attacked. I don’t think they would have had time to speak before being murdered
@@sarahmashby I was saying it's Xana too, but when I think about it, DM knows 100% her roommate sounds, so if she said Kaylee then it must be her! Later on, she said she did hear Xana too, so that shows u how she knows their voices and can recognize them. So, it's odd who was Kaylee talking to? Probably her friend Maddie?
I wonder if one of the girls was tired of him coming Into his work, messaging her (if true) on social media and then contacting WSU, which is when he got fired. Speculation. Then he retaliated
If only it was a Pitbull or some other kind of bad ass dog. It might have saved all their lives. This dog can talk and Murphy might sink him. They found an animal hair in his apartment and if it matches Murphy he is cooked. This puts him at the house at least and a tough one to argue. @@shiketoshep3367
Fish Lips (DM) is the key to this whole case. LE dropped the ball on this one. The defense will tear her apart when she is forced to take the stand. BK will walk based solely on Fish Lips actions, and non-actions.
You’re disgusting and this is a stupid comment. I lived in a college house and there were many weird things that happened when I was drunk and lots of weird things I would hear-none of which would make me call the cops. She probably dashed to the room of the only living roommate who has her own bathroom and home entrance. She wouldn’t have to pass by any bedrooms and wouldn’t have seen anything. She tells her to calm down and go to bed. They fall asleep and wake up late. Four people with cellphones upstairs. They probably called and called and heard phones but none answered. They freaked out when all 4 phones are unanswered or alarms going off, a friend comes over and they call 911-THAT is why it was said they were unconscious. I cracked my door and saw ppl I didn’t know in my college apartment all the time. You can’t control what roommates do.
This is beyond terrifying i cant even imagine the horror and terror those 4 innocent young adults went through in the last minutes of their young lives. May they RIP
You don’t hang around crime scenes; don’t leave EYE 👁️ witnesseses; you don’t leave knife sheaths; and, you don’t leave ur blood trail (knifed himself).
I still believe that the survivors had knowledge or had involvement in the murders, The woman who opened her door and seen a man in black covered in blood, he did not hurt her or attempt to hurt her. So either she knew who he was or she never did see the person she described, and also waiting for more then 8 hours to call police, you see a body that is covered in blood and you call your friends to come over and not the police.
I don't understand why he left anyone alive. That just makes no sense. Why would he walk right by her and not kill her too? Well we will probably never know why.
The only spot I noticed might need updating is Ethan. I have heard a lot of people think he was in the hall and saw Bryan. It would have been hard for whoever did this to go into a bedroom and take on an awake person and another, meaning Xana and Ethan. If his main target was Maddie or Kaylee, he probably wanted to get the hell out of there and his wrist would already probably be sore. Also, that Good Vibes sign (there was one in Kaylee's room and one in the living room) in the living room would have been shining on him as he walked towards Dylan. Important to point out in my opinion, may be why he didn't attack her, his eyes were adjusting due to the light from the sign.
Then why didn’t he do what he did upstairs, walk down the stairs, turn left and leave through the glass door? Why confront anyone if Maddie and Kaylee were the target?
@@coleenfottrell4102Element of surprise. Xana and Ethan were both drinking (as were all of the kids/students that weekend). BK sees either Xana or Ethan and believes either one could identify him.
The big question is why did he kill Xana and Ethan? No one has talked about where the surviving roommates were that evening and what time did they get home? Also I believe DM heard a lot more than what she is admitting to. You know police will say they rule out people as suspects when in reality they are watching them like a hawk and just waiting. Also, if you think a friend is passed out and not waking up, you call 911, not friends. And in a panic that one was not waking up, what about the other 3 and obvious blood? The story just does not add up.
This video is terrific. Great narrator voice. It reminds me a lot of another video I saw years ago. It explained how OJ killed Nicole Simpson and Ron Goldman.
I want to add one more idea I have.. Xana in my opinion was just coming out of the kitchen when he was coming down the stairs, she saw him and ran but he caught her and stumbles with her all the way back to her room, her dying at her door, but now Ethan sees and goes at him, but the killer has the advantage since the room is so small, no floor space and Xana is on the floor. Ethan is attacked, landing back on the bed. Ethan was unarmed, no match for a crazed man with a large knife.
It is true what everyone has said…….your video is top notch and follows the PCA / narrative to a T. Your skills would be of SO much use to tell the real story. You don’t have to speculate, simply document ALL the facts and events ie: bodycam of Banfield incident, w traffic passing, the ppl running from direction of 1122, Linda Lane footage, Bodycam incidents at Apartment complex The visual would certainly help folks to see there is no way this tragedy happened the way the PCA states it did. One perfect example is that E/X were NOT home by 1:45 as the Linda Lane footage clearly, visibly shows them walking in a door into that complex between 1230-130am. Although I don’t agree with the narrative, you did AN EXCELLENT JOB ON THE VIDEO! Great Skills!
A Ph D in Criminology who commits every mistake it's possible to make when carrying out a murder..?!?!? Yes, I know it doesn't prove anything but really...??
What kind of complete dumbass doesn't have the knife sheath attached to their belt? This guy was a dork. Also, I get thay Dylan can't be "blamed", per-se, but we need to raise our children to be more prepared to face evil. These kids were old enough to own firearms. That young lady should have had a rifle or a shotgun and some training. Instead she WENT BACK TO SLEEP AFTER SHE HEARD HER ROOMATES MURDERED AND SAW THE KILLER. I would be very disappointed if that was my daughter, but I would not have raised her to react so poorly and fearfully.
Hey lifetime idiot there is absolutely no proof or any insinuation ever made that Dylan Mortensen (And I'll quote you) "BACK TO SLEEP AFTER SHE HEARD HER ROOMATES MURDERED" .. No 20 year old girl would ever ever remotely think that 4 of her roommates living in the floor above were being brutally killed. And if you ever lived in a College residence people tend to mind their own business.
He lives so far , how did he know where they lived and why wasnt there a alarm for the door and why didn't the dog start barking and keep barking until everyone was awake?
He went back to the King Rd home looking for that knife sheath. He most likely thought he dropped it outside, but he didn’t. Of course he wasn’t going to reenter the crime scene. Im utterly astounded at people who thing this guy is innocent and being framed.
Agreed! You can look at his eyes and see that he’s a monster
Even the cops didn't find the sheath on the first pass/search of the crime scene. If it was under Maddie idk how they would miss it. I'm not saying he's not a weirdo and maybe has done something but the evidence they currently have likely will not convict him. It's weak at best. Cell phone pings in the area don't mean much, 12 cells of DNA and that's all in that bloody of a scene is sus, the car year they were looking for is off, and he has no DNA evidence in his car, home, work, etc. My understanding is that cell tower will also ping if you're at the Walmart there too so he very easily could've been at the Walmart at least some of those 12 cell phone pings. Unless he's actually seen on camera around their home none of it proves he was there. Again, he may be guilty but they need more than this to convict.
It is beyond belief to think he's innocent. Just way beyond coincidence.
but they have no video of a white car around the house at 9am..just a cell phone ping
@@jakestans They don’t need it. His cell pings in the crime scene area. Ask yourself this question? Why does his cell ping in the area of these murders so frequently? In October it pinged twelve times. Coincidence? No, he’s the guy.
You should make more breakdown videos like this with different crimes. I really enjoyed the way you structured this one.
I agree.
I agree too
Agree
who gives a crap about the video when it's wrong, nothin happened in the house. There is not one MPD bodycam image with Brian Coldburgers face on it. Why is MPD holding BK when they are the murderers?
Call me paranoid but i still don't understand why people don't lock their doors, even if u live in the safest place on earth we live in a world of crazy .
Ya it’s just incredibly sad. I live in Westwood by ucla which is very safe but always lock sliding door and front door. I’m sure people in the Midwest are used to leaving their cars and homes unlocked because of the low crime and obviously no one thinks anything like this could happen. Rip and condolences to the families
I live a small town, biggest crime is running a stop sign or a teenager speeding. I’m a older woman living alone & I never locked anything until this happened. Now, I not only lock everything but I check to make sure everything is locked before going to bed. I no longer come in after dark or leave before daylight. Maybe I’m crazy, but this made me a believer.
I even keep all my doors locked on my vehicle while driving out and about! Well, it paid off because some random man tried to pull on the handle and get in the truck with me. Always keep doors locked!
@@danecrawford2658 Had this happen to a coworker. a pan handler opened her passenger side door and stole her purse. Since she told us that story, I'm adamant about my doors being locked and my purse on the floor in my car.
Nobody's after older women, in general, just saying.
You hear someone say “theres someone hear.” And see a man you don’t recognize walk past you and you don’t call 911…….WHAT??????
"Here."
🎯🎯🎯🎯🎯🎯
It’s a party house in college on a Saturday night… why would anyone immediately think murder? So many ignorant people here that didn’t experience college and it shows.
It wasn't a private residence, it was a party house. She most likely assumed it was a friend of one of the others.
Yeah that’s the most mind bogging thing. Why they took so long to call the police
There's a couple things I see that could give more detail. For 1 I believe Dylan's door opened from the other direction & I thought she only cracked the door after hearing the crying & saw him walk by. Also the doorway that he walks thru as he passes by her door has a step up/down, meaning one room was "sunken down" lower than the one it meets up with in said doorway. I believe that in the very dark house, especially since he would have already navigated the step on his way to kill the last 2 victims, he was looking down for the step & walked right by Dylan not even seeing her.
That makes a lot of sense 🤔
plus no door dash, or blood in this scenario. it's a comedy of Reasonable Doubt.
and without proof of work and chain of custody there is No dna.
Correct. Yes
Makes sense. However I heard early on she said he was 5’10”. Being that he was a step higher and well over 6 feet tall - her report of 5’10” doesn’t make sense. Also his bushy eyebrows wouldn’t have been easily seen in the dark at this angle. I don’t have a strong opinion on this case other than to say I still have doubts BK was the only one responsible. I have big problems with the roommates’ actions - especially DM. I don’t trust the cops to be honest if frat boys were part of this or something else nefarious that was going on at the house. It would destroy the school and town which is basically owned by the university.
@@GeorgiaJakes7You hit the nail right on the head, there's no way BK could have done this ALONE... I don't trust the 2 surviving roommates and I truly believe DM was in on it... It's well known now she was a drug dealer and people who knew them admitted Dylan and Maddie had bad blood because of it and got into a heated argument that evening before they went out with Maddie threatening to call the police on Dylan.
If Dylan on the second floor could hear Kaylee on the third floor saying "Somebody's here" and then hear Xana on the second floor whimpering from her bedroom down the hall and a male voice saying to Xana, "I'm going to help you," then Dylan heard everything that went on in that house that night. She is withholding much information that would likely solve this case.
I believe Dylan heard everything that when on. I believe there's a reason Dylan is withholding information on the murders.
@@Sj430I agree with both of you!
@@Sj430I’m fairly new to the case but what do u suspect is the reason she’s withholding information?
She might not be withholding anything but has told the police everything and we will be able to find out at the trial. I believe the police have so much more info that is not being shared with the public.
That’s an assumption, and why would she hold back any information if she knew anything. Also I doubt there was very much talking going on besides what she heard. I wouldn’t think the killer was carrying on conversations with anybody.
Congrats to whoever produced and edited this video. Great work honestly
Marry me
Can anyone explain why the survivors didn't CHECK on their friends? for 8 hours? After seeing a "strange" man lurking in the house at 4am? I just don't get that part of this entire thing.
Drugs probably is the reason they don't call police and might be why the murders happened
I agree and why did they wait 7-8 hours later to call police because they thought their friends were just passed out…did they not see all the blood? And why did he leave a survivor walk past her and not just kill everyone in the house? Too many whys. Makes absolutely no sense the whole thing. Something just does not add up.
Yes!!! The other thing I don't get, when they supposedly woke and called their friends, as they couldn't wake the room mates up due to them thinking they was passed out... Surely the blood and knife gashes were a huge giveaway? Its weird enough not calling the police after seeing a stranger at 4am sneaking about, but why not call once they'd seen the blood and gore? Also.. they have to have heard something! Especially with Xana fighting for her life!! Screaming/shouting will have been happening and the audio for the cctv on the house next door proved that! If that picked it up, then other people in the house MUST have heard this, unless they had hearing problems 🤦🏻♀️
And did the survivors not hear the screams and the noises I mean the NOISES those 4 kids must have made I mean I know there had to noises there was defensive wounds on one of them… there had to have been some awful NOISES. So sad to think about like that but the noises being made had to have been something never heard from them before BUT still doesn’t bother to check on them until eight hours later…. I just can’t make that make sense to me
She passed out she was tired
If someone breaks into your house during the day, they're there for your stuff. If they break in during the night, they're there for YOU. I believe this was definitely a targeted hit and more than one person was involved. Jmo
And he drove by all the time.
Who else do you think was involved?
dylan@@B_FBfan
@@B_FBfanFrat boys... It's well known now that they were pretty much living in a trap house... Dylan and Xana were drug dealers, Maddie threatened to call the cops on Dylan and flushed Xana's stash down the toilet pretty much signing her death warrant if true...
@@B_FBfanThe truth of the matter is, this was not random murders, this was a hit. And the cops are trying to cover it up by making BK the scapegoat because they don't want the bad press for the town or the university... Either this was done by a professional hitman or done by multiple people and BK is the fall guy.
Assuming these facts are true, my key takeaway from this is how much/often he was driving by the subjects' house. While not conclusive of any crime, it certainly highlights the thought process of obsession. This behavior occurs from extreme crush, or feelings of hate.
But where is the proof of him driving up and down the street?? It is on a Ring video, someone actually witnessed it.......or is it speculation.??
I think he was there to buy drugs. Not to mention have we even proven that was his white car and his plates and him driving? Why didn’t they put the gas station footage in the affidavit if it was his white car?
@@jujub3012barely any proof of it even being his car. If they are counting on cell towers and a single source dna on an empty knife sheath that wasn’t even found the first search of the home they will fail to convict him. How could u kill 4 people and walk out with an unsheathed knife and bloody clothing and not get any in your car, house, or outside the scene?
@@tula1433 Cell tower pings and cameras all the way there and back, yeah, sure no evidence what so ever. LOL First search of the house they dind't touch the bodies, sheath was found UNDER Maddy during the 2nd search. BK had 6 weeks to throw stuff away and clean his car or maybe he Dexter'ed it and himself out. He was a criminologist for Gods sake, he had to have learned something.
Both. And to case the house cause you could see right in on the floors that the victims were found.
The surviving roommate who saw him and didn’t call the police is going to be compelled by the state to testify and subject to brutal cross examination.
Kohberger had help
@@Mrs.Robinsons No way one person could have killed 4 people in less than 15 minutes without leaving more evidence !
@@Mrs.Robinsons100%!! When he was arrested he asked the police "was anybody else arrested" ....
She needs it, her story is either she's retarded on drugs or knew something
Rumor Is that DM and BFs stories Don't Match.
Perfect time line! Thank you!!
I know no one wants to question the survivors, but why with all that blood did they wait 8hrs? I’m sorry I don’t believe them especially DM who was seen by the killer and left alone, it makes zero sense
I totally agree!! DM cleaned up the crime scene.
And why did they let D.M. and B.F. drive away without Searching their cars??!!
@Kwildcat13 You don't have a clue compared to some of these people on here asking really good questions. See yourself out.
Um, Obviously they didn't see any blood they didn't go into the rooms until 8 hours later
He may have returned to the scene after he went home upon realizing he had dropped the knife sheath in an attempt to retrieve it but then decided against it possibly but if it was found under the body he may not have been able to locate it at the time of the crime and had no choice but to abandon the scence and leave the critical evidence
so.............why no blood to be found, in car etc??
And I want to know why police aren't checking wooded areas or bodies of water, etc. for where he dumped the bloody clothes and knife. He disposed of it all or buried it somewhere. Why were police not out with dogs searching any area he could've been to in the time frame between the murders and when he arrived back in Pullman??
@@jaynesullivan4432he could've wrapped the inside of the car with plastic. He was a criminology student. So he knew how to do a certain amount of covering himself.
@@jaynesullivan4432 his sister saw him scrubbing his car out with bleach and was suspicious he was involved
Both girls know more.
Many people know the truth, they’re afraid to talk, or just don’t care.
They both know the true !!!
No. They dont. Stop being an agent provacatuer
Is there any actual verifiable official report from any investigators working on this case? Because unless you can provide information that says that, it shouldn't be put out to the public as fact.
@@a.marvellehoneyman4560so what's the truth?
I think as the killer was coming down the stairs to the 2nd floor, Ethan was stepping out of Xanas room to investigate and the killer then stabbed him. Xana likely saw them scuffling just outside her door, so he had to kill her too.
If you agree with that theory, then it proves it had to be multiple people involved. Ethan was a big guy at 6'4" and would have taken more than one to take him down. I think DM knows who did this.
I agree. collateral damage 😢
I think Xana saw and ran back to the room and he caught her just as she tried closing the door. As I think it was Ethan that was in the bed, I thought we knew that much from the court papers.
@@duecebiggalowe Ethan was unarmed. Easy take down if you are half awake and the killer in a frenzy. The guy did not have a chance.
@@duecebiggalowe that's a dumbass take; it would take 'more than one guy' with a fucking big-ass knife to take down a college kid just cause he's tall?
I've followed this story since hearing about it on the news. The darkness, timing, and the sequences of the souls involved are observably strange. Like they were on cue. Condolences to the families.
What??? Lmao
There are more than one..killers.
@@flavioa2252like they knew there every step and were they was think outside the box
The fact that two separate lines of investigation led to the same person is pretty convincing.
although 2 of those lines are delusional...
It’s chilling to think about these four college kids out drinking and getting late night food without a care in the world.
Yes, but at the same time it is comforting to know they all had a last meal.
Great video, really well put together, can’t wait to watch more of your material
so Dylan could here someone say 'there's someone here' but couldn't hear her 4 roommates get killed? Especially as Xana was awake at the time of the murders as she just got food delivery. that makes no sense.
There's some monkey business going on here...believe me.
I agree. When someone is being murdered, and being two at a time she should have heard a lot of noise. I don't think she is telling the truth. She was probably drunk, or high, or both and has no idea what was going on.
@@jerrybranscum3017 not necessarily. It takes a lot out of a person to scream. So must likey they didn’t. We shouldn’t judge dylan for how she reacted. Everyone reacts differently.
@@jerrybranscum3017literally nobody screams as they’re being stabbed in the gut. You can barely gasp for air.
Maybe, but 4 people were killed there, I just find it very hard to believe that not one of those young people wasn't screaming, I just have a hard time with that.
This is a really well put together video, I hope you post more.
This video was absolutely amazing and blew my mind despite that horrible nature of the content. Bro, you have some serious talent and you should do videos for a lot more of these cases
I'm ex military. No way one man did this with one knife in 12 minutes. 4 people and a machete? Yes. Sigma Chi. or Cartel Hit.
I can name multiple SK’s who have done just this. I don’t understand how it is so unfathomable how one single sick-minded individual on a mission could not have done this in the middle of the night. He, whether it’s BK or not, snuck in and likely ambush attacked the sleepy victims. He had the upper hand. They had been out drinking and likely barely alert, if at all. It just is sadly not that incomprehensible.
Yes. And then he had NO DNA in his car, pipes, apartment, nothing?? Wtf the lack of evidence and he wasn't wearing like a dexter suit is too hard to ignore. I don't believe that he did it because how could he be that good, nobody is that good
You are correct. Somebody ( who works with them) is trying to cover up for cartel. Who wrote the PCA and would be able to do this?
But Bob nobody confirmed KBar knife.That lunatic lady said a sharp object was used.I think maybe that machete they all took pics with maybe?
@amandabrandon7241 my husband is a hunter his entire life,61 now,said yes if a person knows where to tack first blow,yes it can be done
Thank you very much this is what Iv been looking for someone to put together! Helps put things into context for sure
That was an excellent video. Keep up the great work 👍🏼
So Dylan heard everything, ordered food, saw the killer close enough to describe his eyebrows, and doesn’t call police and I’m suppose to believe she’s in the clear? 😂😂😂
For all we know Dylan could have been half asleep and just assumed it was a weird friend that shocked her a bit. She had no reason to suspect at all that she was face to face with a killer.
Exactly right. This so called " scared to death " is made up dross by the media. She went to bed as per normal and woke up at her normal time.
Source stated that Dylan and Bethany was texting at the time. But we'll have to see the testimony. Idk how BK left the house without killing everyone.
@@heyitsjujuuprobably figured he had to flood the scene considering he already killed 4 others. Or he had a specific target in mind?
So she gets up 3 times? Then calls friends over before the cops later? Nothing about it makes sense. I’m not saying she had anything to do with it but this series of events makes no sense
I just don't think he saw her as he was probably in a zombie crazed state and she got lucky.
Oh you see an intruder in your house! And he also walks past you. You don't call the cops or warn the others in the house. No you lock your door and go to sleep????? WTF!!!!! And the dog didn't bark to a stranger?
🎯🎯🎯🎯
Amazing work on the details of the graphics. The animations on the map are awesome.
Can't wait for the trial!
Justice for The Idaho Four, especially Ethan and Kaylee, who didn't even live there!😔
Amazing animations! You deserve more than 1.33K SUBS!
So many people in these comments STILL blaming Dylan. Which is GROSS. ESPECIALLY considering all of the FACTUAL, ACTUAL EVIDENCE! WAKE UP
I think people are questioning more than blaming and justifiably so
Questions:
1) why did no one scream? It seems like while he was killing one person, there was a 2nd person in the rooms, I wonder why none screamed for help? Or did they? Apparently no one did?
2) why would she wait 8 hours?
They did. Kaylee did, the dog did, and I believe Ethan shouted but for sure xanna did, they call it a whimper but was probably due to injury. Idk but the only quiet ones were Dm and Bf ☹️
They did ....
They tried to defend
The only cuestión is why she didn't call the cops immediately 😢
Exactly. No screams or obvious sounds of four people getting killed I find that very suspicious and that he just walked passed that Dylan chick is craaazy...probably the easiest target of them off because she was the only one who was alone and all the other ones were two and two together and because of that I find it fucked up that no screams or nothing was made...I find it all very very very strange and very suspicious aswell...and ofcourse the fact she waited 8 hours calling someone else not the police and then some other people are suppose to have called the police. Fucked up.
That’s my biggest question too. We haven’t heard any information about any screams happening, especially when he killed Xana and Ethan. They were both awake at the time so one of them would have had to watch the other one be killed first and no screams? Very sus.
If they screamed or shouted at that hour …. Then they would have known what was going on. If I heard a scream I would call the police.
I don't get how he managed to kill 4 people with a knife quietly, especially since he murdered them in pairs while they were sleeping together how did no one hear anything or make any noise.
Maybe because they were all inebriated? I agree though, super odd.
I don’t believe Kaylee and Maddie were together when he came in. I think Kaylee was with Murphy the dog in her room, heard something in Maddie’s room, went to see and thus angered the killer so he went off on Kaylee, causing extreme injuries..
@@knicba99not what her parents said…
So she gets scared and does nothing abt for 8 hrs. Wakes up calls not the police but another friend ?! I’m sure there was blood everywhere why not call the police first. This is so weird
I guess drugs were involved at least somewhat in that residence. They probably didn’t want to get in trouble for something so silly in comparison to their friends being killed
@@sasuxsakuxfanI could imagine they were all high, especially being awake at 4am probably stoned. If that was the case then I could understand why she didn’t do anything for 8 hours because if you’re very stoned or just genuinely in a high state, then what she saw / heard would be 100 times more freaky than if she was rationally sober
@@onemomenttohislifespandoubtful. Most young people their age stay up late especially on a weekend. Maybe she was afraid of calling thinking he would hear her and break into the room. Idk. People act differently in these situations
So how was Dylan suppose to know, that the unfamiliar guy, she saw come from Xana’s room and leave out the door, just murdered 4 people in the house? She more likely thought that he was Ethan’s friend. Ethan was there that night.
So is Dylan suppose to be a superhero who has ESP, and who is able to see through walls and floors? Have bionic hearing and then be able to fight off some psychopath, who has a 7 inch fixed blade knife and possibly a gun? I dont understand everyones thinking.
The reason Dylan and Bethany survived was because they had locked bedroom doors, which im sure BK checked and skipped. Because you cant go knocking on bedroom doors in the house, if you plan on murdering them. Thats how you get heard and seen. Then busted.
Absolutely, I can guarantee BK tried the door handle on Dylan's room as he passed by it going up the stairs. It was locked, so he moved onto the next room up stairs. He might have even tried Bethany's door before going up stairs, because no one knows the exact sequence he did when checking doors.
I think seeing an unknown masked man in her house and hearing suspicious sounds would have been a red flag. It's unfortunate she didn't call sooner, there may have been some possibility of saving the victims if they were still alive.
You think a locked door is going to stop someone who just stabbed four people to death? Lol
Why did Dylan check outside her room on 3 separate occasions?? Why didn't the slightly built 5'8 guy finish off any witnesses? Especially when he walked right in front of Dylan. Apparently Dylan didn't need bionic earring because while 4 young vibrate teenagers were getting butchered alive no one heard anyone scream.
So now he had a gun lol. One the worst comments I've seen on this case
Very well done 👍 I very much appreciate how you’ve put this together!
These roommates must have been super sleepy to not hear all those people screaming for their lives.
Strange is it??
Maybe the initial stabs made them unable to scream
Maybe they were in a coma
You wouldn't be screaming, though. By the time you realize in a drunk and sleepy state, your body literally won't allow you to scream because most of your vital organs are connected to your lungs and heart. That would make it so you're physically unable to scream. I do agree that the roommate definitely knows more though.
What I still do not understand is how Dylan heard Kaylee say “someone is here” and then she also heard “I’m here to help you”. How is it that she heard all of those comments yet failed to hear 4 people being brutally murdered!? It doesn’t sit right with me at all. IMO Dylan is suspect and hopefully we will get some answers to all this at the trial.
Oh come on! Place the blame where it belongs, on the murderer. Not a survivor
You make a valid point.
You'd think if someone is saying "someone is here" that it would be whispered and not yelled loud enough to hear through a wall.
It makes no sense that she could make out words from someone speaking but couldn't make out if someone was playing with a dog or being murdered. 🤷🏼♀️
Being that Xana and Ethan ordered food and Xana was active in tiktok it was likely that one of them was awake.. and if she saw someone enter her room who she didn't know and she saw them with a knife... (IMO) then she would likely yell loud enough for everyone in the house to wake up.
Idk... it's odd is all I'm saying.
I'm not saying she did it... But I am partially wondering why he picked who he picked. If it was Bryan then I'd say he's exceptionally smart aside from the small DNA left on the knife sheath.
They haven't found a murder weapon. His car was clean. No DNA transfer... They haven't found clothing... Shoes... Nothing. So if it was him and he did all of this methodically.... Why leave surviving roommates? Why... Would he pass right by one and leave them alive. It's so odd!
Seriously? Do you ever hear weird noises coming from the neighbours and just immediately assume they must be getting brutally murdered?
@@TheTiredMomma are you dense too? Did you see the demo? Those floor and walls were paper thin. And guess what, now that it's gone you cant prove any of the acoustic evidence from the night of the murders.
imo he NEVER seen dylan, he had his head down and wanted to gfto asap@@sarahalexander3255
Makes no sense how they didn't find DNA of the victims in his car that was a very messy crime scene. How's that's possible?
The were reports from investigators that he spent some time cleaning out his car before he was made an official suspect. So the officers couldn’t just go up to him and search his car. That would violate his rights and basically make any evidence obtained without probable cause/ a warrant useless for prosecution and thrown out of court.
Yet here we are with no evidence of cleaning products (and LE did test for it as they dismantled his car) and a very dirty car as seen on the Indiana State police body cam as BK drove to PA when he was pulled over. @@leticiarodriguez383
Exactly. Even if he changes clothes. There would Have to be either his DNA on them, their DNA on him, and Surely DNA in his car.
@Kwildcat13 it’s pretty impossible to stab four people to death and not get hurt as well and leave your own blood behind at the crime scene.
Really well done video. Thank you. 👍
Subscribed around 1.5k, this page will be huge eventually with content like this
There is so much more to the case than just what was said here. How did he see in the dark or know the house of has many people were inside. Why wait 8 hours then call friends over before calling police?? The house had to have a lot of blood and that smells, there had to be screaming shouting etc because of the way they say Zana fought. Why was every door UNLOCKED?? After seeing a masked man in the house why not call or text your roommates at least to see if they are okay?? This case is very messed up… period and not as simple as this video makes it seem.!
Excellent presentation. Thank you.
Excellent recap.
The youtuber TRUECRIMETIME did an awesome video called "Evidence Bryan was involved in Oregon murders?" At the 16:00 mark he shows what instagram accounts BK was following and he noticed some knife accounts, jiu jitsu and self defense accounts. One account had a video on how to strike someone to bring them to their knees and stab them in the neck in 5 seconds flat. Very intrersting to think that's how he could've taken Ethan down 👀👀👀👀
First time I've seen your channel. I'm only 2 minutes into your video and I don't know why you haven't gotten any comments in 4 days. I chose your video to watch on the Idaho 4 case because the thumbnail looked interesting and it was a comfy 8.5 minutes long. Now watching and I really like this video; it's putting the timeline in perspective and it's easy to follow. No extra speculation or theories, just "facts" from PCA and what little evidence we've heard about. Let me be the first to say "good job."
Plus, I believe you're pronouncing Kaylee's last name correctly...a first
Not correctly, Gon-salves.
It’s an AI voice that’s why
@@organikpnw my bad. I stand corrected.
There is all kinds of things messed up about all of this. From the residence doors being unlocked, to Dylan not calling police or checking anything or even messaging the girls to no one checking for how many hours. I'm sorry I feel for Dylan and the surviving roommate and I don't think they had anything to do with the crime but this is all jacked up. This was a heinous crime and I just hope something is learned from it all. Frat and sorority houses and other college residences like this are a mess. Start taking security seriously people.
She probably froze or was half asleep. We cant judge Dylan for how she reacted. She probably just thought one of the roommates had a friend over and had a fight. We don’t know what was going on in her mind. We can speculate how we would’ve reacted but we can’t say for sure because we weren’t their
@@Comfortedbyfictionexactly we don’t know, but what I do know is how I would react and anyone else I know would react. And our reactions would be to call the police so I am very suspicious to the way she reacted.
@@Blue-uq8rv So am I.
@@tomasm7520but didn’t a camera that’s set up near the house catch whimpers. It’s possible they weren’t able to scream. You would think the camera near the house wouldn’t only catch the whimpers but the screams if there were any
I would feel such survivor's guilt knowing I slept through a quadruple homicide in my home. sleeping while they were bleeding out. that's horrifying.
Subcriber 82 here! Welcome to youtube. Amazing visual presentation. I know all this information almost verbatim know but your vistual presentation of it is top notch! Looking forward to the next video.
Very well done video. Thanks.
You need to change Dylan looking out her door, by cracking it. Theres no way she opened her door wide open and stood there like that.
Great story voice ! ❤
A troubling part of the story: Why whimpering? Who whimpers when they're being stabbed? Fear can elicit whimpering but...no screaming? Not a single shriek of pure terror?
I agree. My understanding is that Ethan was killed outside Xana's bedroom door so it's likely Xana saw that happen so why wouldn't she scream? Or plead for her life? Anything? Scream no? Burst into tears about her bf?
@@rebeccazeman9309because when things like this happen it’s not like in the movies. People freeze in fear and it’s over before you even comprehend what happened
@@rebeccazeman9309Shock
@@anthonyfrison8511He most likely killed Ethan out in the hallway and the door was closed or halfway open she heard something and I heard he gouged her eyes out and Ethans legs were mutilated so he couldn't run away. That's just what I heard I wasn't there.
@@nicolekear3911do you know where you heard this? I’m interested in reading more about the case I haven’t heard that part.
Amazing video, by the way, what software do you used to make the animations?
Why did the roommate not call 911 ? Odd
people are gonna say anything is odd now in hindsight lol she probably didn't know what was going on. I get your point though, but what makes it odd to me is that she didn't hear anybody screaming for help poor people got stabbed to death and nobody heard a thing in the house?
@@realskeezy3601if you stab someone in the lungs they can’t scream
Great report.
Well made video, and perfect explanation of the “official narrative,” but this story has a ton of holes in it. I don’t think you can be honestly pursuing the truth this case and think BK did it alone, or was Sir StabsALot. This case is way more than meets the eye and the people that know the truth are keeping quiet.
agree 100%....far more to it.
I agree 😊
No, it was solely Kohberger.
Frats and drugs, BK walks on the declared evidence. BKstillhasntseen all evidence requested 8 times.
@Duchess. How do you know it’s BK? There is literally zero concrete evidence and before you say “DNA” it’s not much of anything, really. Touch DNA is notoriously unreliable.
This video was so well made! I love it!
How the F O R E N S I C took out the B O D D I E S ❓❓❓
There is not a single image of that moment.................
Video was well put together, should make more videos like this and make it your own style. Earned a sub
Is Dylan slow? Honest question.
Mortensen was unwilling to admit to cops that she was drunk and that seeing strange men arrive or depart in the middle of the night was not alarming in a house full of party girls who hooked-up. When the masked guy walked by, she had not been alarmed by anyone screaming bloody murder. After Covid. a face mask was not alarming. Regular night noises in that house were not alarming. Just a bit before, the four victims had returned home and a door dash was delivered. That night she had no clue about the carage. When cops asked why she waited to call 911, she knew about the murders, so she SAID she was "frozen in fear" for about 8 hours. This makes no sense wnatsoever. If she was terrified by the masked stranger, after an hour of silence, or less, she would have called 911 from her room if she was still too scared to investigate. Furthermore, 99.8% of chicks would go there rather than admit being drunk and living with a bunch of party-girls.
Love the animation! Hope you make more!
I'm glad someone finally validated how this crime was carried out ! But I can tell ya right now there's no way he left a witness he either didn't see her or she's involved! Dm that is ! No way he saw her and left her ! Nope this may have been a revenge killing!
Huh ? Lol this isn’t validation is speculation
Lol?
@@49ersfan834I read Dylan was told to stay in her room that Maddie was going to get roughed up.Can't wait for the trial , hope the truth comes out!
If she would have been, they would know it. He would have told them... also I think he didn't see her or he was exhausted and in rush because he didn't know if they called police... Police has said she was not involved so why you think you know better than them?
I have the feeling that 1. He either didn’t see DM or 2. he was extremely exhausted after killing four people and he was such in a state of rush he decided to just leave.
Good video, I only wish that it was longer
That's why kohburger asked did you arrest anyone else yet ! Because he wanted to know how much they know about why he did this !
awesome video, what software did you use to create the maps and stuff? super cool!
Probably blender
But how do they know all those"spottings" are him? They didn't even have the correct year of his vehicle.
Just because they see a blur of a white car in a ring camera late at night, doesn't mean it was him, or even related to this crime at all.
This case has more holes than a fishing net.
From what I’ve read and videos that I’ve seen about this case, this video is very accurate to what has been said by police so far! Good job 👏🏼
Really great video! But I cannot believe for the life of me, that after all this time since the crimes, BK's arrest, news reports, families speaking, court hearings, UA-cam videos etc...that you STILL have no idea of how to say Kaylee's last name "Goncalves" properly. 🤦🏻♂
It's because it's an AI voice. AI voices don't pick up on accents and how certain things are pronounced.
Gone-salvez
@@SprucedandGussied thanks for the info. I wouldn't have thought of that. The myriad of YT channels with automated voices really got better with AI
@savagebyotch8791 that s of yours in the middle is wrong
Everyone everywhere.
Great video please do more !
If Kaylee did in reality say" there's someone here" then that most likely would indicate that Kaylee was speaking to someone. DM did not say Kaylee shouted this statement only that she heard who she thought was Kaylee saying this. Thus, it would be most probable that Kaylee knew at least one of her roommates were awake and hear this statement.
Interesting. Like maybe she was calling out to Xana and Ethan or madi?
IMO I believe it was probably xana saying “there’s someone here” to her boyfriend Ethan. kaylee and Morgan were asleep when they were attacked. I don’t think they would have had time to speak before being murdered
with her door closed and texting with the other survivor
@@sarahmashby
I was saying it's Xana too, but when I think about it, DM knows 100% her roommate sounds, so if she said Kaylee then it must be her! Later on, she said she did hear Xana too, so that shows u how she knows their voices and can recognize them. So, it's odd who was Kaylee talking to? Probably her friend Maddie?
Which idk how DM would not be sure who was speaking cause wasn't she besties with these women?
Bad ass video man. Just subscribed because of it.
I wonder if one of the girls was tired of him coming Into his work, messaging her (if true) on social media and then contacting WSU, which is when he got fired. Speculation. Then he retaliated
👍 Great Animation. Thank you from Germany 🇩🇪
That dog must have freaked out when he opened it and saw the stranger/killer standing there.
If only dogs could talk!
If only it was a Pitbull or some other kind of bad ass dog. It might have saved all their lives. This dog can talk and Murphy might sink him. They found an animal hair in his apartment and if it matches Murphy he is cooked. This puts him at the house at least and a tough one to argue. @@shiketoshep3367
They had strangers in and out all the time. Party house.
That dog must have gone crazy with the smell of liters and liters of blood flooding his sense of smell. 🐝
Great video, man. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Fish Lips (DM) is the key to this whole case. LE dropped the ball on this one. The defense will tear her apart when she is forced to take the stand. BK will walk based solely on Fish Lips actions, and non-actions.
Fish lips? Youre disgusting
"Fish lips" I'm dead 😭🤣
You’re disgusting and this is a stupid comment. I lived in a college house and there were many weird things that happened when I was drunk and lots of weird things I would hear-none of which would make me call the cops. She probably dashed to the room of the only living roommate who has her own bathroom and home entrance. She wouldn’t have to pass by any bedrooms and wouldn’t have seen anything. She tells her to calm down and go to bed. They fall asleep and wake up late. Four people with cellphones upstairs. They probably called and called and heard phones but none answered. They freaked out when all 4 phones are unanswered or alarms going off, a friend comes over and they call 911-THAT is why it was said they were unconscious. I cracked my door and saw ppl I didn’t know in my college apartment all the time. You can’t control what roommates do.
Crooked cops selling drugs to the Greek life students from the cartel are involved. BK is being framed.
She knows who was there that night, no doubt about it.
This is beyond terrifying i cant even imagine the horror and terror those 4 innocent young adults went through in the last minutes of their young lives. May they RIP
You don’t hang around crime scenes; don’t leave EYE 👁️ witnesseses; you don’t leave knife sheaths; and, you don’t leave ur blood trail (knifed himself).
🎯🎯🎯🎯🎯
"There's someone here" is chilling.
I still believe that the survivors had knowledge or had involvement in the murders, The woman who opened her door and seen a man in black covered in blood, he did not hurt her or attempt to hurt her.
So either she knew who he was or she never did see the person she described, and also waiting for more then 8 hours to call police, you see a body that is covered in blood and you call your friends to come over and not the police.
I don't understand why he left anyone alive. That just makes no sense. Why would he walk right by her and not kill her too? Well we will probably never know why.
The only spot I noticed might need updating is Ethan. I have heard a lot of people think he was in the hall and saw Bryan. It would have been hard for whoever did this to go into a bedroom and take on an awake person and another, meaning Xana and Ethan. If his main target was Maddie or Kaylee, he probably wanted to get the hell out of there and his wrist would already probably be sore. Also, that Good Vibes sign (there was one in Kaylee's room and one in the living room) in the living room would have been shining on him as he walked towards Dylan. Important to point out in my opinion, may be why he didn't attack her, his eyes were adjusting due to the light from the sign.
Or Ben maybe he had blood and sweat all in his face and eyes were burning? Don't know just thinking out loud 😮😮
@@49ersfan834there were two Good Vibes signs.
@@49ersfan834 I thought that there were two signs.
Then why didn’t he do what he did upstairs, walk down the stairs, turn left and leave through the glass door? Why confront anyone if Maddie and Kaylee were the target?
@@coleenfottrell4102Element of surprise. Xana and Ethan were both drinking (as were all of the kids/students that weekend). BK sees either Xana or Ethan and believes either one could identify him.
The big question is why did he kill Xana and Ethan? No one has talked about where the surviving roommates were that evening and what time did they get home? Also I believe DM heard a lot more than what she is admitting to. You know police will say they rule out people as suspects when in reality they are watching them like a hawk and just waiting. Also, if you think a friend is passed out and not waking up, you call 911, not friends. And in a panic that one was not waking up, what about the other 3 and obvious blood? The story just does not add up.
I'm more concerned with that security camera picking up audio from inside a residence
How you see someone in your house who is masked and you don't know. But, DONT call the police.
The knife sheath wasnt found the first go around
It was a single male subject that seen it from the doorway
This video is terrific. Great narrator voice. It reminds me a lot of another video I saw years ago. It explained how OJ killed Nicole Simpson and Ron Goldman.
So incredibly sad. My son is a Sigma Chi at OU and he said that they were all affected by this. Just senseless, really
Sigma Chi are the most probable killers
I'm sure they are. 🐝
Great video
I want to add one more idea I have.. Xana in my opinion was just coming out of the kitchen when he was coming down the stairs, she saw him and ran but he caught her and stumbles with her all the way back to her room, her dying at her door, but now Ethan sees and goes at him, but the killer has the advantage since the room is so small, no floor space and Xana is on the floor. Ethan is attacked, landing back on the bed. Ethan was unarmed, no match for a crazed man with a large knife.
Possibly, but then Dylan should've heard something as to get from the kitchen to her room, don't they have to pass her room?
It had to be multiple people to pull this off.
They say that Eyhans body was blocking the door. That's why the person who was called couldn't see him.
You just now came across my UA-cam. Going to watch all night and you have a new Subscriber.❤❤
It is true what everyone has said…….your video is top notch and follows the PCA / narrative to a T. Your skills would be of SO much use to tell the real story. You don’t have to speculate, simply document ALL the facts and events ie: bodycam of Banfield incident, w traffic passing, the ppl running from direction of 1122, Linda Lane footage, Bodycam incidents at Apartment complex The visual would certainly help folks to see there is no way this tragedy happened the way the PCA states it did.
One perfect example is that E/X were NOT home by 1:45 as the Linda Lane footage clearly, visibly shows them walking in a door into that complex between 1230-130am.
Although I don’t agree with the narrative, you did AN EXCELLENT JOB ON THE VIDEO! Great Skills!
Where’s your proof? That Linda lane footage has been passed around to numerous people and none of us truly know how authentic it is.
I'd say just focus solely on the alibi. That alone speaks volumes.
How can you say he's done a great job with the video. When hes accusing Bryan but he hasn't any PROOF hes the killer. Were has he done a great job. 🙄🤔
@@rowingnowWhereurbreadsbuttered No one has an Alibi!!! Kaylee’s boyfriend says he was SLEEPING.. LOL!!
A Ph D in Criminology who commits every mistake it's possible to make when
carrying out a murder..?!?!? Yes, I know it doesn't prove anything but really...??
So heart breaking
Excellent video 👏🏼
What about the whereabouts of the 2 survivors before the murders. I will like to see what time they arrived if they arrived alone.
In the pca the 2 roommates returned home at 1 am. Nobody knows the whereabouts of the 2 roommates.
What kind of complete dumbass doesn't have the knife sheath attached to their belt? This guy was a dork. Also, I get thay Dylan can't be "blamed", per-se, but we need to raise our children to be more prepared to face evil. These kids were old enough to own firearms. That young lady should have had a rifle or a shotgun and some training. Instead she WENT BACK TO SLEEP AFTER SHE HEARD HER ROOMATES MURDERED AND SAW THE KILLER. I would be very disappointed if that was my daughter, but I would not have raised her to react so poorly and fearfully.
Hey lifetime idiot there is absolutely no proof or any insinuation ever made that Dylan Mortensen (And I'll quote you) "BACK TO SLEEP AFTER SHE HEARD HER ROOMATES MURDERED" .. No 20 year old girl would ever ever remotely think that 4 of her roommates living in the floor above were being brutally killed. And if you ever lived in a College residence people tend to mind their own business.
He lives so far , how did he know where they lived and why wasnt there a alarm for the door and why didn't the dog start barking and keep barking until everyone was awake?