Unanswered - Mysteries from the Mahabharata | Christopher Charles Doyle | TEDxYouth@NMS
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 тра 2024
- “Curiosity is the wick in the candle of learning.” Devoured by his curiosity, Christopher C. Doyle, in his talk, constantly questioned the stated facts of history and literature. He tried to answer the unanswered questions regarding the Mahabharata and other histories of the world through scientific explanations and reasoning. Christopher C. Doyle is an author who transports the reader into a fascinating world where ancient secrets buried in legends blend with science and history to create a gripping story. His first bestseller ‘The Mahabharata Secret’ was a great success and now has a trilogy under its label. Mr. Doyle is one of the first Indian writers to upload an online novella for his readers. Before he embarked on this literary adventure he pursued a career in the corporate world and is a graduate from St Stephens College and IIM Calcutta. Christopher C. Doyle’s books are a beautiful mosaic of science, history and mythology with a dash of Dan Brown which makes him the most adored fantasy writer in India.
Christopher C. Doyle is an author who transports the reader into a fascinating world where ancient secrets buried in legends blend with science and history to create a gripping story. His first bestseller ‘The Mahabharata Secret’ was a great success and now has a trilogy under its label. Mr. Doyle is one of the first Indian writers to upload an online novella for his readers. Before he embarked on this literary adventure he pursued a career in the corporate world and is a graduate from St Stephens College and IIM Calcutta. Christopher C. Doyle’s books are a beautiful mosaic of science, history and mythology with a dash of Dan Brown which makes him the most adored fantasy writer in India.
This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at www.ted.com/tedx
A genius named Praveen Mohan is doing great research in these topics.
We all should give our support to his channel.
They Call a christian to talk about Mahabharat.
Indeed
Yes sir
Praveen is doing great work.
But I don't like his fake accent
@@alokbalsekar He is a man not a machine.
He has his likings and feelings just like you do. Don't take his accent if you don't like it. But see for his research and dedication towards his work
"Praveen Mohan" is the top boss of this department.
Yah💯💯🔥🔥
True
💯🔥🔥
Yaa
100%
Let's support Praveen Mohan youtuber...his work regarding ancient temples, architecture, their unexplained science mysteries and much more is ludicrously awesome ...
Ok
What's wrong with CCD? I mean Doyle, the Stephanian?
V
Aanceaat Tachnology ✌️😝
Hello Varun! Randomly found you! 🥰
3 years later ,
A young learner came in and thanks to your speech , I'm more curious to learn n explore the "unanswered" sides of different fields
Hi Hana, I love Tunisia, have friends there. You should read a lot , can't rely on such videos. The quest for truth leads to never ending search, explore many many books and you may conclude. Mythology and science are different. Wishes.
@@ashleykumar3932 mythology isn't mythology in the Indian context
Hey... try n look withing urself. The world is incomprehensible. Where there is earth now was sea b4 n where there is sea now wz each b4.
@@ashleykumar3932 ok cheap ricebag Tamil.
Then come to india and adopt the Sanatana Dharma which is called Hinduism by west. Sanatana Dharma is the ultimate and only true dharma because it talks about human liberation from the cycle of birth and death and freedom from sorrow, tensions, pain to lead a happy and peaceful life.
As an Indonesian an an Asian, I know how much smart our ancestors are.. You can see from our variety culture. You would never find such a great culture and civilization like in asia. Btw, maya and Egypt was great too.
Your country is the most amazing. Dying to visit and spend time there. Right about Asia, for sure. Truly magical.
@@moviesenthil Thankss... Where are you from btw?
Maya is from India only. Mayasura migrated from India to West.
@@manasi1844 ow really? do Mayan is really from India? Never heard it.
@@manasi1844 Mayasura was the principal architect of the Pandava Palace Complex at Indraprastha - and also did the original urban planning for the new city in consultation with Krishna and Yudhishthira. This was done after clearing the Khandava Forest and making it fit for human settlement.
I don’t think he went to the Americas. I don’t think the Mayan Civilisation is related to Mayasura.
I need a Time Machine very badly..
It makes your life bad too worst ...............
@Abdul Sayyed
Mah man !!!
Meditate 🧘♂️ you can see past 🙏
Really ?. Man there is nothing like time. What does just exist is space and everything is just happening in the space at all times. Imagine the existence as an computerized program or game or drama, which one can visit at any time, understand ? Learn to connect with the higher self of yourself ( parmatma ) and you can visit any part of the Creation,even what is called as future, because it is already existing there .
@senapati z
That's the disease ... to want to becomes " gods " ...
The cure is to want to ... serve ... God !!!
I am a Indian christian I love the hindu scriptures especially Mahabharata because of it's characters . My most favorite character is karna , eventhough he is in kaurav side . also there is a lot of morals in it which can be applied to this day.
Ghar wapsi kar ko bhai
sorry but karna was not a good person. never refer to tv serials.
So parts are true but ….Most of them are fiction & imaginary…..
Karan suriya putr???
Krishna god but he died …
@@syedshahnawaz9151 same can be said for Allah, there is no mention of Kaaba or Allah before the 6th century AD, neither in the Christian nor in Jewish sources, from where you claim inheritance.
Why accuse Hindus of idolatry, when you revere a stone 5 times a day? Google the definition of idolatry for once.
@@syedshahnawaz9151 buddy, let's not talk about what's fiction and what's real here simply because its ancient. It's more about what you should strive for instead of what's already been done or whether it's real or not.
I am forever amazed at the wonders of Indias Temple's Everything has it's own time with the Big Shift in this planet now perhaps we are at last Wakening Up to many questions that has always bothered us "Well done" I enjoy your expectations so educational fron Ireland
Hindu cosmology itself provide a different world view. And you can't imagine the scale of it.
India is and has great people great culture and traditions...they had a glorious past and a bright future....hats off to bhagwad gita🙌🏻
Its not about india and the people sir its about us humans we humans were that much advance or can say mysterious.
But then what happened in the 21st.century ? You all elected a bunch of neolithic characters to operate your "Great Empire".
@@MasoodKhan-gg9rg Abraham's religion destroying
😂this is the problem with Indians. We try to applaud ourself more. He is talking about pyramids and big men, there he goes applauding India.
@@samva2364 r u indian joe?
Praveen Mohan is a genuine researcher.. check his channel out for answers
We need more people like praveen to bring back the lost civilization
Praveen is an eye opener, but further reasearch and advanced science studies are needed to be done on the subjects and the places Praveen documents!
He is banned by UA-cam
@@rupam64 bt why????
@@srilabhattacharjee5228 , he has been receiving warning / improvement notice since 2017, as his video is not appropriate for all users. I can presume, some Muslims, christian and our beloved seculars must have given adverse report against him. Yesterday only , I came to know about this futile decision of youtube
Few archeologists have found few things related to mahabharat like rath... What I personally thing that mahabharat is not a myth it's true.
Refer to the excavation of sinauli, UP
Our ruler congress made it mythology and you know the reason for it.
@@diitthebestspokenenglishce7528 eh, congress didn't write world geography nor Indian history lol. Dummy
Just listened to an intellectually stimulating history lesson 👏.
I thought you would pick some more evidence from India itself and also from my country Sri Lanka 🇱🇰 .
Yes bro
Biggest part of the reason is that epics like Mahabharat requires a mind which is spiritually awakened but we're trying to decode something related to past with our mind's which totally strangled in today's materialistic world. As one of the biggest lessons from these epics is to live a attachment free life's
That's a great comment. Im fact a great explanation
This is soooo true! Men then and today haven't learnt 1 bit to detach themselves from materialistic world 🙄
@@angelwings7404 Yeah if people only abandoned their family and started living in caves, seems like a healthy and good thing to do amrite?
@@baam25th31 detachment doesn't mean to live alone or leave the family or to leave every materialiastic things!!
badhiya baat bole, true 🙏
Our ancestors were really great what happened to us now 😞
@Abdul Sayyed brother plz spread this knowledge to others muslim brothers who thinks that hinduism is just mythology and unscientific plz appreciated your eagerness to learn our culture 🙏
Excellent insight Abdul, hope your love for sanatan Dharma remains forever ❤
British happened
Blaming a cut will never solve the wound. The actions are universal.
We’ve been in Kali Yuga awhile
Very good subject to discuss. Everyone is searching proof, evidence and similar archeaological findings to match timeline of mahabharat and ramayan. I would like to include my point of view in different way. May be you won't like. I always feel - mahabharat is story of earth with its birth, different stages and last hybernation period. Different characters and mentioned kingdoms are matching with existing different locations. All incidents are matching. Only need to think and imagine. Someone had wrote mahabharat to alarm next human kind so that same situation will not happen again. But we are still trying to find proofs. Need to read, visualize, imagine and compare with existing situation....
Need more and more discussions , researches like this that can help connect us to our ancestors knowledge and bring them back to use for the betterment of current society !!
It might not be necessary that all those knowledge would be useful. We might get something but the notion that previous era was very bright than today is not correct. Just like the highways built in 1950s were magnificent at that time won't stand with highways of 2022. Just like the Padmini was considered as symbol of status, it isn't today.
I am all in for the researches in past, but it is more important to invest heavily in the future. Although in the past India was all glory and advanced among other countries, such India wouldn't stand against a third world country of today.
I still hope such researches take place and we get something useful.
The powerful vibration of 'om' is mysterious. The soul of krishna is all so verpowerful.
The vibration of Omm is not mysterious. It is proved and beyond any argument. Ohh..great to find a comment from an Odia. I too. Like it. Thanks 😊☺️
All mohanty are odia?
Krishna doesn't have a soul. Krishna IS a soul.
@@sangramrout3436 you don't need to reply with a kiss emoji to an unknown girl just because u both are from same state. Behave
@@abcdefghijklmneha TRUE ☺️
This is AWESOME!!! I love the Bhagavad Gita, and have a new version with English rhyming verse called Song Divine. The Gita is really a lifelong study - and I'm hooked! Thank you!
Lord Krishna guided Arjuna the Warrior.
But why Eklavya was told to give his thumb is v sad.
@@maichyang2912 Two Same Types Of Person's can't exist in Same Timeline. Someone Should be Down.
@@maichyang2912 he did a wrong to pun stop the dog
Krishna guides us in mysterious ways. A Mahabharata expert once asked me what made Krishna as a character different from everyone else in the epic. I could think of so many, but he flattened me with one keen point. Let me know if you're curious and I shall share.
Amazing video. Such solid knowledge hearing after a long time. Definitely provoked some thoughts!!
Finally the ultimate truth of humanity is being released! Its an amazing time to be alive.. 🙏
A TED talk by Praveen Mohan is a good platform for people to notice his great work.
My dear Christopher C. Doyle, it was an interesting talk, as can be expected from a good fantasy writer like you. Before you could attempt to take the name of Mahabharat, with also your doubts on it's reality, you ought to know about the time scales that are attached to these Scriptures. Being an Indian you would have attended many Hindu Poojas & Rituals. If not please do. At the very start of the sankalpa, the Pandit recites -
"Vyvasa manvantare, kaliyuge, pradhama pade, Jumbu dweepe, Meru dakshina dikhbaage, etc". In simple words, this is nothing but giving co-ordinates in time as well as the physical co-ordinates of the place of performing pooja, with respect to Meru near Manas Sarovar. You must examine the time co-ordinates 1st - It says in Vyvasa manvantar, pradhama pade of Kaliyug, means 1st quarter of Kaliyug which is 416,000 years long in time period. 1st quarter means 104,000 years. As per your science
it's put conveniently without evidence that this Kaliyug is only 5000 years old. Which means before that was Dwapar yug, which spans over 832,000 years. And Mahabharat belongs to Dwapar yug. Before that was Treta yug which spans 1248,000 years, and Ramayan belongs to that age. Prior to that we have Kruta yug spanning 1664,000 years, when King Satya Harishchandra lived. Size of humans- during Treta yug, Roma's time, average height 24 arm lengths and lifespan of around 2500- 3000 years. Dwapar yug, humans were 14 arm lengths and life span of 1500 - 2000 years.
Kruta yug + Treta + Dwapar +kaliyug = Maha yug.
72 Maha yug = 1 Manvantar.
Today we're in the 8th Manvantar called Vyvasa manvantar, 28th Maha yug. Aren't these mind boggling figures. Every yuga the Human Race starts a fresh and reaches a peak spiritually and technologically also. A time will come when the earth is wiped out of the entire civilization and restarted, wherein the Lord uses selected living creatures, plants etc and brings them to the new start. The carrier of one of such transitions was what you call as Noah's Ark.
These are all well documented in what you call Hindu Scriptures. Vedas were from the start of human race, in the 1st manvantar. Very surprisingly they weren't written by any human being, they were given to the Sages and Rishis by word of mouth called Sruti, by God. So it's impossible for one to get the handwritten evidence of them.
There's a lot for you to know my
dear, for your fantasy you should have chosen some fairytales and not Mahabharat, as Hindu's, rather, I must say, Human Beings most sacred text Bhagawat Gita is connected to it.
With all respect, the pundit doesn't know anything.
Would you please enlighten me for the source you have used to write all this content it is really knowledgeable.
Its appreciable. Shall I know the source you got this information. A small suggestion why can't you open a channel and share your information.
Ganesh ji can u explain in more detail? I really want to know when Lord Rama was born, then when Dwapara Yuga started, and beginning of Kaliyuga.
Hi Ganesh interesting would you share the source of information please. Thankyou.
I am amazed at how much mind-blowing technology my ancestors adopted. I'm a person who even struggles to know what they are saying in this ted talk because I'm very bad at a second or third language other than my mother tongue.
Excellent. I thoroughly enjoyed watching this video. Thank you for your contribution to this subject.
Even though the video doesn't match with the title, but the facts he's given are really challenging and interesting.
He's a Paid NGO, working for Foreign powers to Disrespect Indian Ethos
@@p.m.senthilkumar5820 😂
@@p.m.senthilkumar5820 foreign powers have better things to do. Paid NGOs? Aren't NGOs for poor people?you make no sense.
Exactly he should sue them for misrepresentation
true. this video was disappointing. it did give some room for thought about OTHER THINGS.
and .... "watch his next video" is not a very encouraging answer.
Answer- "Stop thinking that world started 2000 years ago"
😂 I still know some people who believe that the whole world start 2000 years ago.
mostly indian history says it started many many years before but west doesn't want to accept it, they only relate to Jesus Christ - before or after Christ period AC/ BC
@@kiranthakur8793 who might be those people says ??
Who said it started 2000yrs ago ?
No one said that...
We cannot say the events of Mahabharata never really happened but the way it has been described in the epic Mahabharata makes us believe it never happened but the thing is we need not think it really happened or not instead we should learn and apply the teachings of Mahabharata in our life.
btw i liked ur thought, but wanna ask a question, u gain knowledge of mahabharata from where? from a TV show? if you i think you should not belive in a way they have shown, i will give a name of one person on yt name Abhijit Chavda u watch his videos he gives evidences that it existed, And you can see his qualifications and then watch!
and also you can search for Pravin Mohan on yt he have proven it
However smart, whoever 'we originated' from- it does not matter if we continue to promote CLIMATE change and can't learn from the recent and not so recent past. Great Job ! That's why we need to reorder our priorities NOW!
This is how we used to answer subjective question in our engineering college. Now I feel pity for our examiners.
Sahi yaar
Yeah
he hee i cleared a paper by doing that
Tdye
😂🤣
If you are brave enough Can you explain about “””Ajanta and Ellora caves””” which is even more complex structure also about all the carvings if you ever have seen Bellur Halebidu, Sun Temple etc etc
You r right Hazel.
What's so mysterious about ajanta and ellora caves?
It was carved from
Top to bottom ..
@Voice of the Desert why will Buddhist monks build a Shiva temple?
What does bravery have to do with it ?
This is one the best Ted talks about our existence of ancient civilization..!
Next level research and analysis...
Love from India...❤️❤️❤️
So bad most of us are already forgetting about our own knowledge that's literally written in ancient texts.
Why use the heading Mahabharat, when less than 10% of the video is dedicated to it and in the name speaker is taking about different things all around the world, don't use Mahabharat to increase number of Views.
fanofyoubulb he is only talking about Mahabharat, he is giving supporting evidence to an academic crowd that they aught to reconsider the Mahabharat in their research, in a more serious way.
fanofyoubulb believe they have just to gain the interest by calling Mahabharat
duu chauhan Sure, but then why leave Ramayana and other old scriptures from other cultures aside?
The reference to pyramids and denisovians were necessary to prove or say whatever he wanted to say regarding mahabharata.
Exactly! If he is scholar we at least expect some honesty- yes use a comparison.But you took stone monuments etc from different countries to compare to what? No solid evidence from India on the Mahabharata. If all you could provide is its writings why not use a various writings from other cultures for your caparison?
Yes Mahabharat is not a mythology but it's a History a glorious History
Yes Maharashtra.. very nice book. Written by Oscar Wilde and translated by Tarantino.
🤣😂🤣😂🤣
@@TitusJudah what you laughing at!? Asking out of curiosity
@@raw_dah laughing at your comment lol
@@raw_dah
Not Maharashtra as you have replied
Mahabharatha
would have loved this even more if he had touched upon wonders like Konark Sun Temple and Kailash Temple at Ellora
The very fact that the civilisation that can write an epic like mahabharat with such human traits and plots even if these were imagined shows the height of intelligentsia achieved ...more so when rest of the world are considered to be in dark ages..
Recent excavation at Sinauli cleared all the doubts about ancient epics. We found Chariots, arrows, bows, swords, shields, jewellery, royal Burials etc.
The Documentary - Secrets of Sinauli is worth watch and share.
Plzz share the link if u have
Link plz
maybe that is actuay a secondary site to kurukshetra. sri krishns caitanya one day took a few disciples and undug a certain mace - and reburried it. we are not ready for some of the gear.
@@shivangigupta537 available in telegram groups
Hello 👋Nilesh Pawar can you please send me the link for the Documantry The secrets of Sinuli.Will be very grateful 🙏
So wild. This randomly came up in my feed. And last night when I woke up at 3:33 am I had dreams about a land where there were animals I didn’t quite recognize and giants. Something that looked like a human but large and almost glowing.
This is so perfect to listen to after dreaming this dream...and to continue to question and be open to the mystery 💗✨🦋
Yeah, antediluvian lore be like:
I love Dan Brown's books and after watching this vedio am sure C.C. Doyle's books are going to be equally enthralling and knowledgeable! Ancient wisdom and Indian mythology.... The secret of Mahabharta is going to be my next read
Great explanation... I am more curious about our history... There is no denying that Mahabharata and Ramayana are true incident... But they need proof.... I am very sure that ... They also believe in our culture and history 👌👌👌...
I am proud to be hindu ❤ vast and... Understanding as un understanding, 🕉
Everybody should be proud of their country.....but they don't need to comment everywhere i m proud of my country
@@rajknwr and He said "I'm proud to be a hindu" not " proud to be a Indian"
@@venkateshkm1998 in that case change India with Hindu....
@@rajknwr What's your prblm if he say " I'm proud to be a Indian "
You are not alone brother... 🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Even if the history was written a long-time after Alexander died, the information came from the journals of men who fought with him and knew him when he was alive.
Jolie Karim:
**The claim can't be proven, stop fabricating comments on the internet.**
Yeah and also he forgot a that’s the same with the mahbutra or whatever the name is called but worse
He wasn't trying to challenge the existence of Alexander.. He says the history.. The dates as we know could be wrong.. So the knowledge or history passed down could have some truth to it.. Even if we don't have convincing archaeological evidence.. That is why he brought up" denisovan". Because until recently we didn't know they existed.. And their advanced technology.. So he didn't claim anything in the end.. He just tried to generate our curiosity so we could look further into the past
This vedio is an eye opening for the non believers of santan dharma ...those who says mahabharat and ramyana are myths... These are the actual historical events that happened to be in past.
I just find it fascinating that people are thrilled by some random coincidences in history. Where as "existing" itself is powerful enough to drive you crazy...
It was title of the video, who brought me here but the speaker is talking about everything in the world except the mysteries of Mahabharata. And the way every dot got connected towards the end is truly laudable.
@Abdul Sayyed just wow
Please change the Title "Unanswered - Mysteries from the Mahabharata" to "Unanswered - Mysteries from around the world" 90% of the video is about the mysteries from other than Mahabharat.
Time for a Ted talks about confused UA-cam headers
It's called as click bait
Because Mahabharata is not just related to India, people from world wide were part of Mahabharata. people around the world were in touch with each other, trades were done through out world and India being the leading trader in those days, especially dwaraka being the port of so much importance those days.
You jst ignored the fact that he was trying to explain an if-then case.
"if these things (stonehenge, sphinx) can be done millenniums ago, then Mahabharatha is not a mythology but history"
I tried to wipe your thumbnail off my screen before realizing it was your thumbnail pic.
Excellent Speaker. Excellent Information. 🙏
I wish I could do a phD researching the truest parts of our oldest stories. :) especially linking them to geology, and astro geology.
What an orator! Amazing!
The universe is full of mystery, but for me the sad thing is that my curiosity, may not be clenched in this life :(
same ! sadly this life is too short to know the details of the universe !
Reincarnation bro
@@kritiwasthakur4722 i'll have to learn everything all over again
@@vanishasrivastava8312 yeah just little nice nirvana meditation and HATH YOGA from this body till ur death❌ decaying☑️ of this body. And then some real hard meditation to be done in the next birth that makes you remember your past connected life which determines your karma in that life. For more details please follow Sadhguru🙏🙏🙏🕉️🕉️🕉️🕉️🕉️🕉️🕉️🕉️ Satya SANATAN vaidic dharm ki-- JAI
same here 😑
Wow it was so fascinating.. And i love that now some of our intellectuals are challenging those existing and imported believe system
After watching your whole video I got a conclusion I wasted my 18minutes 19 seconds, listening the same questions which I usually hereby everyone,and no one has the answer
Great work...
Keeping history alive by predefining it..
That's what I like, religion and science coming together. Amazing work.
Brilliant Job sir!!!! Huge respect and lots of love to you Christopher Charles Doyle from Nepal.
Very great proofs u have showed the world,, as a hindu I always knowed that ramayana mahabharata were our history and I am proud to say we are only and the oldest civilisation that existing since the the universe is created.
This is a classic case of 'Strawman' argument - using facts to create an illusion of logic - if A exists and if B exists then A=B. Facts are very interesting and made a great view
Facts are scarce and if one without evidence is history other can't be ruled out unless the evidence are found. We can't say it never existed. We can only say "we are still finding it" that's what science does and archeology is also a science.
@@friendlyatheist9589 Well said
On the same note, there are several mysteries in Harry Potter too: How waving a small stick causes magic to happen? How cars can fly and how owls can deliver mails?
Its 100% fictional LoLs... Jk Rowling wrote that fictional story
@@Keishazi right
Lol
Your birth is also mystery for world
Very Logically & smoothly You just shut the mouth of those who doesn't believe in our religion & Saying Doesn't Exist even...
Heads off Sir...You are an Legend it was..very interesting for me... And i am lucky that i found Your videos and gained so much of knowledge and Now With pride i can say to watch Sir christoper this video and let them decide.. !
Jai Sri krishna🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
The Mahabharat serial was a humongous success in India😊
He is one of my favourite author. 💟
It's interesting how this talk dovetails with a lot of Graham Hancocks work on challenging the traditional understanding of ancient civilisations
Wonderful - what a way to end a discussion - with a lot of questions to look for answers.
The man had me hooked to his explanation through out.
The level of intellect revealed in the comments below appals me!
Seriously! I think they video on mute.
true, alot of comments are said. This guy didnt say anything wrong at all and presented literally how it is right now, yet here we are... people denying even the slightest possibility of our history being wrong.
Be shocked, or in awe of ignorance, not appalled...
@@TheBlackfall234 true
These all knowledge r already in India at Extreme level! Mostly temples r build by carving stones & Mountains with full of Science & technology. The Konark Sun Temple the most unexplored clock and much much more...
Speak about the Heliocentrism, why none of the religions did'nt have a clue about. It was all a very well constructed story also corrected when needed without traces.
This was simply engaging and the way it questioned our notions is just mindblowing . i loved how he instead of bringing things to conclusion just fueled the curiosity of viewers , to have them answers of their own.
The Greatest Story Never Told: A Scientific Inquiry into the Evidence of the Fall of Man from a Higher Civilization in Antiquity Hardcover - November 1, 1988
by Lana Corrine Cantrell (Author)
Also, please note, with the evidences available as on today, Ramayana and Mahabharata should be referred to as ANCIENT INDIAN HISTORY... not as mythology
lol
Care to share the evidence?
@Abdul Sayyed When did casteism creep inside the Hinduism that you admire so much brother?
@@ashleykumar3932 casteism crept after 5th century AD, you find no mentions of casteism before, unless of course you are a Rice-bag cheap Tamil.
I hit the like button at “but Alexander is not myth, it is history”
Being a student of history, I knew that our past is full of interesting and enigmatic events and finding answers to them will make them way more complex. But in our schools we are mainly concerned with the political history and therefore, for a layman history is static, boring and factual. It's very much important to understand the value of history and why we read it. And there is a reason why we say that through history we understand our past.
Yes
History out of the schoolbooks is boring.
All we read is B became king by A and all .
I have read some good books on history and it's one of my favorite subjects , but not schholbook history .
Praveen Mohan and Nilesh Oak . Two gentlemen who will make you thing in this department .
I met this man when I was in class 11th, I trolled him, though I still bought his book "Mahabharata Secret", it's a factual reconstruction...
Interesting & looking forward to more research & mystery unearthing. 👍
In the Skanda Purana is Sri Guru Gita, 182 slokas. It is the secret chant of the mystery and importance of the Guru in one's life. "The Guru is not the vyakti; the Guru is the Shakti".
So said Swami Paramahansa Muktanada, Ganeshpuri, India. Shishya and successor of Sri Bhagavan Nityananda.
In itself it is a lifelong study. Every day it reveals more levels of understanding while burning karma.
Of course, it is recommended that one have initiation by a Siddha guru, who awakens the disciple's Kundalini energy by a process known as Shaktipat (descent of the Shakti).
Sri Swami Chidvilasanada (Gurumayi) is the current head of the Siddha Yoga lineage, Saraswati order of monks.
It is a path of tapasya intermingled with great bliss!
Sat Gurunath Maharaj Ki Jai!
Curiosity is important. More important is the scientific methodology and approach to answer them.
Good presentation, which mixed well researched facts with speculations.
Here are some counter questions:
1) Who said that the events described in Mahabharata took place 5000 years ago?
Taking a cue from Balarama, he had the iron plough. Iron age in India started about 1600 BCE. That makes Balarama breaking the hard soil of mountainous regions with the iron plough about 3500 years ago. Prior to the invention of iron making, all civilizations were based on the flood plains of rivers which had soft soil and did not require iron ploughs. Iron becomes important when humans move to higher grounds, into moutains and forests. Iron enables humans to cut down trees and dig up the harder mountainous soil. Even with bronze (which followed the Copper age) this was not possible.
2) Yes, Denisovans have been recent discoveries. However, a civilization that used high-speed drilling tools would have equally sophisticated technologies for food production, travel, civil construction, etc. It is highly unlikely that such a civilization would be using high-speed drills while living in caves and making a living through hunting and gathering, foraging for food in forests.
3) How could a civilization that claimed to have weaponry that are seemingly similar to our modern day nuclear weapons, ploughed the land with bullocks and iron ploughs? And, also appeared to have had no technology that made living more technology-oriented? No microwave ovens or computers or fax machines at home and offices, but with an ICBM in the quiver, that too carried on a warrior's back?
4) An army capable of shooting missiles, but chose to fight on horse and elephant backs? No mention of tanks and armored cars, bombers and fighter jets?
Either these were excellent products of human imagination - which is a strong possibility because we humans have the ability to imagine that which does not exist. OR, Eric von Daniken?
I wanted to ask these same questions Sir.
Fantastic analysis. But imagine this:
We talk about the origins of Humans at 60,000 BCE and all the anthropological study is after that date.
Srimad Bhagvatam states that there existed 4 Yugas of life existence since the formation of Earth.
Earth is 4.5 BILLION YEARS old. Do you what was going on in the daily life of Earth in general, at maybe say, 800,000 million years ago? And that is exactly what Srimad Bhagvatam states, that there have been 3 entirely different human civilisations before us!
Maybe Mahabharata did not happen at 1600 BCE but in one of the previous human civilisations at 800,000 BCE?
Well Infact This is true , let me explain it by an example , Gomphothere 4 tusked animal extinct about 2millions years ago so it must be there before that say 12m explained by palaeontologist and This animal is mentioned in Shri Valmiki's Ramayan Sundar Kanda [4.27.12] which explains all these events are true but just to acknowledge whole world as Sanatan many historians talks about rise around 10k BC and Many Indian Left Minded/Western historians never goes in that area instead they coined term mythology to our Real History . They praise Islam built our Nation and Colonization due to British but in fact all were Santana untill Kaliyug 4th phase of cycle happened
Hey! that's really interesting can you please tell more?
@@nevermind7183 You can get as much as you want from Sanatan dharm scriptures
@@nevermind7183 actually when lord hanuman entered the kingdom of Lanka, he found something very amazing. He saw some 4 tusked elephants guarding the doors of fort along with some giants. He was confused to see them as those were not found in india. Later, he kills them.
Now, hanuman is described as a monkey but the problem is that he knew all the vedas and vedangas. He knew politics and speaker like others.
The ramayan must have been happened when different races co existed. Hanuman and the vanaras must have been some ancient specie of the past.
Glad I found this comment
How come in kalyug we all became amnesia
There is only one universal consciousness which veils itself so not to be by itself. To be more concrete. The meaning of life is love. - Wald Wassermann, Physicist.
Most Interesting and inspiring presentation. !! Really amazed at his versatility. !!
When actually is Mahabharath mentioned, I watched half of it and was about pyramids.
mahabharata happened in india not in egypt but kings from all over the world were part of that huge world war which could be cause of extinct of all civilizations and only last man standing cilvilization in the world is still alive, indians are decendents of those civilization and we still believe in our history
@@animax1034 Mahabharat kurukshetra war happened around 3052bce. That means 5073 years ago. Ramayana is placed around 4000 years earlier than Mahabharata that is around 9000 to 11000 years ago.
@@animax1034 he just said pyramid is more than 10,000 year old so older than mahabharata
Exactly
He tried his best to be super knowledgeable but very confused person
Praveen mohan and nilesh oak are top on this subject 💯
I couldn't be more thankful to UA-cam for recommending me this beauty. Thank u..
I am a Proud Sanatani ❤️🚩
OMG HOW CAN I MISSED THIS AMAZING KNOWLEDGE TILL NOW
The way the arguments are connected is amazing. My mind started making conclusions as the presentation progressed. I am more interested in knowing that’s for sure.
I am pretty sure, There was an ancient civilization that was far modern than what we are.
"We don't know but we think", this quote is what every detail of every discovery throughout our human history has been based on. Notable is the fact of which within the global community of highly educated archeologists and experts. If evidence is not consequential, the preference to submit a thought or guess as evidence obtained is that of which forms our education in such subjects. If the truth was told (in which I would urge everyone to believe is an impossibility) the validation of human history against those of higher education would uncoil for millenia. TRUTH OR TRANCE
Awesome talk! Well said, we need to stop being arrogant and enjoy exploring the unknown! Let's all seek truth together!
truth needs to be proved by truth itself not by thought. omlet.
The drill hole in the bracelet bears a striking resemblence to the drill holes found throughout megalithic structures. Holes that show absolutely no indication of being done with sand and a bronze tube, but rather a spiral or toolmarks implying a high speed bit was used. The Denisovans, by all indications, were massive people. Megalithic structures worldwide show a similarity in both building technique and in architecture, and on a massive scale. Most of those very same megalithic ruins have been re-built and re-purposed countless times over the aeons, and they show this clearly. Every culture and society has mythology that includes giants. We would certainly have considered a race seven or eight feet tall on average 'giant'. Given the interior of every continent was filled with a myriad of megafauna predators {lions, sabre toothed cats, cheetahs, bears, and all in giant size} Sapiens wouldn't have lasted a minute in any settlement that wasn't well fortified or underground. We would have lived along the coasts at river mouths or on islands, because we've always used boats. Those settlements are now 420' down, under the sea. Recent DNA studies imply Denisovans interbred with Sapiens as recently as 15,000-30,000 years BP. Just before the ice sheets melted.
Great convincing theories. Well done Sir 🙏👏
I’m definitely interested in reading more about this.
Thank you for teaching me a little something as well Me. Doyle.”
Majority of history pieces that we have accumulated about the past is consist of thinking rather than knowing.
Wow...you are here too
@@sanjayVlogs491 maybe I was watching all these videos back to back
Amazing and shocking...
And yes, he leaves us with this and curiosity... 😮😮😮🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Thank you Christopher C. Doyle,
you have given me food for though and spiked my curiousity...
The graet past! Imagine. . imagine.... imagine... trust and wonder or criticise and question all the imaginations with effort ful presentation....any way. Great past and Godly forefathers...
Just happened to see this presentation. Well done, without any expert recipe but simply asking the reader/viewer to ask the question and go seek the answer.
For those who want to be proud of our heritage and culture, in this world, we need scientific proof too.
the title should be explore about mahabharata bcos i dont believe it ever happened.
Awesome ! I can only imagine the kind of curiosity and hard work which will get you here !!
The Ancients were more advanced than we are now in many ways.
There is a great saying that if you cannot convince them confuse them..