Well said. China focuses on improving itself. America focuses on China. In the Confucianism, one needs unending self-examination for perpetual cultivation of the self, in the order of 'cultivating the self, effecting harmony in the family, regulate the country and brining universal peace to the world'. China is a country looking inward for areas of improvement.
@@biggpicture2930 it does not concern anyone what you personally believe in. There must be a reason why the global stage is very interested in the teachings of "Confucianism" compared to theories such as jainism that no one on the global stage ever looks at.
@@biggpicture2930 it was always good. China was the largest economy until the 19th century. when European rape and pillage allow them to overtake China. European imperialism only led to a world war that destroyed them. as Xi Jinping would said before becoming president "We do not export revolution and conflict to other countries". the crusader mentality of the west has killed so many people and achieve nothing. it could not even deal with Afghanistan of all countries.
Americans never help without purpose. Pakistan is an example , who destroyed itself by American wars by pak army blood and destruction of Pakistan economy.
India should make Peace with all her neighbours: China, Pakistani, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Nephal, Maldives and concentrate to uplift her citizens from poverty...towards a common prosperity.
The American wish is to get two Asia giants to fight each other. America sitting on a high fence is to see the destruction of each other, and exhaust themselves, then can dominate the both giants. America will not send boots on the ground, no body bag.
Global functionality & general security, esp maritime security/commerce is built upon the backs of the Americans. Most countries are useless parasites. The US is mostly self sufficient, but benefits from global functionality. India & China have had their own tensions predating the US, and on their own terms, being major civilizational neighbors. Your spiteful deluded indoctrination helps no one…
@jamedchu512 Two Giants???? There's only one and it's CHINA, In.dia is only 10,20 light years behind...The sooner you guys would accept this REALITY,the better it would be
Make a video about recent confrontation of PLAN and US in phillipine sea resulting in EW for atleast 12 hours after which US retreated from sea and also called back it's weapons from phillipines. Also fired the commander of group William coulter due to failure of Ea growler to jam Type 055.
India have forgotten that the US and UK sent their carrier group to the Bay of Bengal in 1970 and if not for Russia things would not turn out well for India..
That's a joke, a lie told to Indian population by their rulers. There was some minor movement, but that's all it was, just for show, it was nothing serious. If the Americans really wanted to help Pakistan, they would have lifted the sanctions. Pakistan was under sanctions from the start of 1965 war, till 1982. They were so intensive, it took couple of years for them to be removed so the Americans could take part in the Afghanistan war against the Soviets.
In 1962, India US relation was not is good shape but still China silently took Ladakh and attacked India. China attacked again in 1967 but India was a winner, China lost over 300 soldiers. India US relation was in very bad shape. This guy is just a China's mouth piece in India
India's lack of strategic autonomy is almost purely of its own doing. Galwan was an Indian provocation by amassing troops in disputed territory. This escalated into hand-to-hand fighting in which 3 PLA soliders were killed, and several dozen Indian soldiers were held prisoner (and release several days later). If this unfortunate event triggered the subsequent agreements with the US, India committed itself to reliance on the US. No one of any credibility thinks that China has any aggressive intentions on its border with India. So the Ladakh tensions is India's own choice. If this perpetrated India's de-facto alliance with the US, India can hardly blame anyone else. Suffice to say, India will suffer under US influence. India's close relations with Russia over 60years has not translated to any undue Russian influence on India, apart from dependence on military hardware. But rest-assured, the US will use India like the Russians never had. You reap what you sow.
Sir the question is that India really want the uplifting of 800 millions downtrodden Indians who are wait every month of 20 kg free ration. Today's scenario in my view NO. No indian political party or even state political parties want to loose their vote bank. So I think indian people, lawmakers have no capability or zeal to be think outside from this self constrained pandora of audacity to be a world power.
I wish India had more scholars and thinkers like Mr. Pravin Sawhney and Mr. Raja Mohan. They are the hope for better India-China relations. But I have to be straight forward and honest Modi’s visit to Moscow and his meeting with Putin is a sign that Russia is winning the war in Ukraine; otherwise, Modi would not dare to appear associated with Putin under imminent pressure from the U.S. I really don’t understand why politicians in the West like to talk about war with China. China brings hope, peace, prosperity, construcción, human dignity to the world, while the U.S. stokes conflicts, wars, regime changes, destructions and fears. India also likes to talk about how bad China is, as if it can be very useful for the U.S. One Indian woman so-called international relations expert said in one interview on an Indian television talk show that Russia should know that China may not always be Russia’s friend or partner, it could one day be a big threat to Russia, but India will always be. It reminds me of what Joe Biden told Putin in their 2020 meeting in Europe, that Russia should be aware of potential Chinese trouble along their over 5000 miles shared border. Now we know who is the real threat and who is a friend in need to Russia’s existence. India has never won anything in its fights against China. Now, Modi goes to Mosco to kiss Putin’s ass, as if India were essentially relevant in the geopolitical entanglement among the world’s superpowers. But the world knows India is nothing but a useless idiot, an opportunistic prostitute. India could be a great partner with Russia, with the U.S. and with China. That would be beneficial and advantageous that no other country would enjoy; however, India is willingly and voluntarily being used as a vassal state in the geopolitical contention between the U.S. and China. In the end, no one would trust India to be their reliable friend or partner.
True. Indias about turn happened soon after a US delegation met with Modi soon after Xi's visit to India in Oct 2019, and arranged Trumps forthcoming visit in Feb 2020. Unfortunately, the US bioweapon failed as intended, resulting in the global pandemic.
Dear Sir, very insightful and logical analyses and solutions for future Indian policymakers. It is logical for India to focus on developing and eradicating poverty like China silently and peacefully did in the past 20_ years. Then claim its rightful status as a global power not now for which Inida need a leadership having vision of future
Great out of box thinking and analysis. Problem with most advocates of allying with America against China in India and the Philippines is that they don’t see peace and development as a real alternative. China doesn’t want to be the enemy and wants development and partnership. In India’s case the strategy of trying to ally with both Russia and the U.S. at the same time could totally backfire because neither will trust India. It’s the economy stupid!
Are you actually so naive about China? The US doesn’t actively arbitrarily undermine China, but China extracts benefits from global functionality while undermining it or degrading it, as it bullies neighbors & facilitates corruption & tyranny abroad. China development is good if coupled with accountability. China isn’t going to invade the US, but CCP already oppresses it’s own people, subjugates regions it has swallowed, intimidates neighbors, and has border/empire ambitions that cause problems all around it…
** This is by far the BEST comment i have actually read in the entire section. The stupidity of IN (and indains is beyond incredible stupidity.) We honestly just need to face the FACT as it is already the year 2024. It is not going to do anyone any good to lie about the situation and just pretend and continue to be optimistic for all the wrong reasons. This is the reason why india cannot progress and is not an advanced economy (even if given 100 years, no allies, no friends on the world stage - and even after 100 years still no sufficiency.) There is a reason why China has not invaded and conquered the entire Arunachal Pradesh region is because IN is in such a big mess - if CN chooses to focus on their bigger agenda of taking over TW (which they can do it very easily.) The Chinese will already dominate the entire South-China Sea. There is already a known fact that if anything happens in a conflict, the entire world will support China (it is a fact.) The entire "backend" of india will be instantly sabotaged, the moment an activation is called the entire indian army will run into problems. Best part of all that we can all remember - Russia has confirmed that even in the event of a war in J&K - Russia is only interested to offload and profit from the sale of arms to BOTH indian and even given to Pakistan. This is a fact that is still not understood that indians are not exclusive - Russia sells to BOTH sides. Since when and who even started the dangerous idea that Russia is going to help india in any way or form? It only took ONE incident where the Americans were on the way to bengal and the Russians set out to meet the Americans .. from then it was so easy to manipulate the indian mind into thinking "Russians activated their military to defend the indians" .. congratulations that is the easy money hack that Russia has been getting for free the past 60 years.
Today, India is standing where China was standing 25 years back. With internal stability, visionary leadership, peace with local casts and Muslims, and the right balance between the West and China, India could aspire to be a global power in the next 25 years. Unfortunately, India doesn't have a Deng Zio Pang and CCP and Indian democracy is serving the Neo-Con Capitalists.
@@stevenlai1199 bhai bhram me mat jio. Kachra tak toh saaf hota nahi shehar ka, baatein badi badi. Baatein toh koi bhi kar le. Sarkaar se woh maango jo unhe dena chahiye - shiksha, hospital, saaf swach vaatavaran.
@@habibgilani_Official. ----- There's so many in neighbouring country like Syed Muzzamil Shakil Chowdhury & Hassan Nisar & so so many where the people of their country ignore their patriotism & search for other's faultlines.
A Great civilisation can temporarily have at its helm some self serving, short sighted and corrupt head. During that time, the nation slips backward economically, and suffers from troubled relationship with it's neighbours.
In fact the US diplomat ruined India's so called foreign policy autonomy.. Pathetic that India's leadership did not raised any voice being afraid of US anger😮.. The real pathetic situation where today India is...
@@Zerotolerance1212 Not so kuch US anger but Indian students migrants in the US as well as exports to US. Europe already complain about Indian made IPhones....so go figure.
The problem is that both Jayshankar & Modi are not open minded enough to see the real picture. Which countries do not or did not have conflict among themselves and yet co-operate.
India needs tech and China don't have that. China will never put a factory in other nation. No country has benefitted having good relation with China example Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Laos and many.. India is in right boat
Mr Sawhney, my question to you is in your opinion, what should India do to keep her indepent. Second what can China and India both do to have peace and share prosperity
Title is on India but 80% of this video on China's greatness. It is clear the motive of this guy and who is paying this channel. All his video has only one message CHINA IS GREAT
India have not stolen IPR as what C-hyna had done. US & Europe had invested heavily in C-hyna in all sectors some 30/35 yrs back. C-hyna would have been beggars had US not supported C-hyna to fight against USSR.
No, having friendly relations with all those capable and willing is a wise move for a poor recovering nation like BHARAT. What is so desirable about the poodle/vassal status of UK and the rest of the NATO FAKE countries? You can be a poodle if you wish. Woof, woof!
I am amazed at the neutrality in this speaker's analysis. I kept expecting him to tilt in a certain direction and become passionate, but he remained clear-eyed and factual. Honestly, it's a rare thing. I will continue to watch other episodes.
Indian/US honeymoon period is almost reaching its end. Soon India will realise it has lost more than anything worthwhile. Rightly pointed out "strategic autonomy" has been compromised as India joins many other military ally states as second fiddle.
The thing is diplomacy is an essentially linguistic art, full of subtleties. India is at a natural, historical, experiencial unfortunate disadvantage there.
Great vlog Sir, as always. The million dollar question for us is whether the US will put its boots on the ground on the LAC in case hostilities break out between India and China.
Yes they will. Anything against China and Russia will get american and european boots on the ground. The question is, do you really want them there? Once they settle in, they won't leave.
@@gregario888 ----- Never will India allow any foreign soldiers fighting for ourselves. We are capable enough to take care of ourselves. Just need help of some hi-end tech which we'll get when we desire. Nothing to worry about.
Indians believe in jingoist language rather than critical think tanks like prawin sir. Just see the difference between Major Gaurav Arya and Pravin Sawney views count.
While it is true to say that BHARAT, that was colonised India till 22 January 2024, is NOT a great power in the class of US, RF and China, it is still powerful enough to say that it does NOT have to follow the diktats of the US, RF or China when they say "you are with us or against us". This is why BHARAT does have strategic autonomy to protect its own interests and not toe others diktats. Do NOT confuse strategic autonomy with great power status. Compare the status of BHARAT with the vassal states of UK, Canada, Australia, Germany, Japan who all MUST toe the US Soviet party line or they suffer coups and financial collapse.
Brother these chinese trolls are trying to gas light Indians . Their reaction has given the game away . Chinese are expert snake oil salesman. It will be chinese wet dream if India and US (west) goes into diplomatic debacle . They are in no position to do it . That's why they keep calling India out about cordial relation with west . But they themselves will not back down from trading with west. But never backout from preaching about their fake morals when it comes to India . How it's wrong to have good relation with west . Chinese economy was built on western capitalism. China will sell Pakistan to get out of sight from western crosshair. China wants to have same cordial relation with west just like India . But they are not fooling anyone ever again .
Is it possible for India to establish itself as leader of the Global South similar to "leader of the non-aligned world" during the Cold War? What would it take?
@@tonyyin8524 What it takes is - Humility. Have you ever seen a Foreign Minister from any country who behaves like a bully? The Foreign Minister is the Ultimate Gentleman representing the country. Our EAM is brashy, bossy and ‘On-Your-Face’. As a small Global South country, Would you like him to represent? No one wants to interact with a person who brings up the past and uses to argue as a Nationalist
It is easy for India to become the leader of the global south. Just share their latest 7th generation stealth toilet technology with the entire global south. You see? India is far ahead of both the US and China in modern toilet technology, where Modi has launched their 7th generation stealth toilets, proven totally invisible to any advanced radars and spy satellites, as well as any people who are not Indians. The very fact that Modi's 7th generation stealth toilets are visible only to Indians greatly facilitates the access for Indians to going to toilets whenever and wherever they feel like to, be that the Hindu Temples, Sheraton Hotel lobby, the Time Square in New York, and even in front of your house. Just imagine that, 80% of world population could go to toilet anytime and anywhere, thanks to Modi's 7th generation stealth toilets. That surely would make India the hegemon of the entire galaxy, at least, if not the entire universe.
** This channel by Pravin Sawhney is excellent GOLD .. we honestly just need to face the FACT as it is already the year 2024. It is not going to do anyone any good to lie about the situation and just pretend and continue to be optimistic for all the wrong reasons. This is the reason why india cannot progress and is not an advanced economy (even if given 100 years, no allies, no friends on the world stage - and even after 100 years still no sufficiency.) There is a reason why China has not invaded and conquered the entire Arunachal Pradesh region is because IN is in such a big mess - if CN chooses to focus on their bigger agenda of taking over TW (which they can do it very easily.) The Chinese will already dominate the entire South-China Sea. There is already a known fact that if anything happens in a conflict, the entire world will support China (it is a fact.) The entire "backend" of india will be instantly sabotaged, the moment an activation is called the entire indian army will run into problems. Best part of all that we can all remember - Russia has confirmed that even in the event of a war in J&K - Russia is only interested to offload and profit from the sale of arms to BOTH indian and even given to Pakistan. This is a fact that is still not understood that indians are not exclusive - Russia sells to BOTH sides. Since when and who even started the dangerous idea that Russia is going to help india in any way or form? It only took ONE incident where the Americans were on the way to bengal and the Russians set out to meet the Americans .. from then it was so easy to manipulate the indian mind into thinking "Russians activated their military to defend the indians" .. congratulations that is the easy money hack that Russia has been getting for free the past 60 years.
@@deepakseth6256 ------ All Pak YTs have been earning through Indian viewerships. Let this be the one that earn from the viewerships from Pakistan. It's a rarity.
पनौती जीवी शायद इसी भृम में है कि ताली थाली से चीन को पछाड़ अरुणाचल प्रदेश में चीनी गाँव व क़ब्ज़ाई जमीन चीन से वापिस ले लेगा ! वैसे कोई युद्ध भी तो इसने रुकवा दिया था !😂
बहुत अच्छा ज्ञान था भारत इतना बिझिनेस चीन से करता है तो चीन का फायदा है तो चीन का क्या नुकसान होनेवाला है बॉर्डर पर भारत बात ना करे तो ना करे भारत /चीन का क्या नुकसान है ? नुकसान तो भारत काही होनेवाला है
The only reason this regime is fond of Russia is that they'll never care about his ambitions of human rights violations. This regime will happily surrender Arunachal if it allows them to hurt India's minorities
A hard path but doable. The answer is "bilateral talks" Settle your border disputes. Give something and take something. Don't let the evil of west use you.
US doesn't need to nudge India to have antagonistic relation with China; China itself is doing its best at keeping the relation antagonistic by keeping the pot boiling around India's neighborhood at every opportunity. Mr. Sawhney is effectively suggesting India to submit to Chinese wishes to gain the latter's goodwill and friendship. Once again he ignores the fact that totalitarian states do not make lasting good relation by your appeasement. He is blabbering from drinking too much Chinese cool aid.
Of course india is completely innocent and has not done anything at all to all the neighbouring countries. It's you that needs to stop drinking the urine.
Remove "Strategic" along with the term "Autonomy", every thing will be alright. "Strategy" - do our countrymen (Indians) ever understand it? I wonder (with due apologies to the experts popping up on my laptop screen).
Do not agree with lot of thing said by you... each one of your argument can be countered by facts and figures... India is able to strike a balance between all 'Great Powers' and fend for itself from all possible sides along with gaining from what each one has to offer - then, what is the problem...? Isn't it the best way forward given the current world order? I guess, we need to think from India's perspective instead of fault-finding with the government, period.
Is Pravin Whiney switching sides here? Usually he rents himself out to China and Pakistan. Now he's suddenly renting himself to Americans. Is he burning the candle at both ends, hoping to get more money? Na Ghar Ka, Na Ghat Ka
@@jameslum8822 - haha - so your content is just as hollow as his - nothing serious from any of you - what a joke. No wonder China continues to deteriorate
Sir, when you believe that China and Russia are uniting forces and the US is divisive, your vision is out in the open. It is difficult to find a more general and sweeping statement than this. So Russia is the Honest Broker between India and China. Amazing. All experts are agree that the Chinese suffered more than the Indians. A coda: most of the comments for you videos have Muslim names. Wish you all the best
India felt cornered with the rise of China and with Russia in China's control , India felt that totally depending on Russia weapons will be a dangerous preposition. I don't agree with you portraying, China as a peace loving and Gentle Giant.
I have been watching for a long time Mr Sawheny dishing out distorted views of Geo politics and I am not referring to any particular episode on this channel Please note the following India China dispute long pre dates America China dispute. India China dispute is independent of America China dispute . India wants American help to safe gaurd it's borders and America wants Indias help to safe gaurd it's Super Power Status . True America and India are at the two ends of the Globe but they have much in common Also Pakistan and China have nothing in common. The only thing that is common between them is their desire to keep India down
Alas! But this is not true. If what Pravin spoke is lies, the facts on ground would be different which it is not. Also it’s not just older disputes but also many new disputes courtesy India’s misadventures by creating a UT in disputed territory. Americans can’t and won’t be trusted by anybody, which is where India will lose out a lot. Just ask the Pakistanis about back stabbing Americans.
Sir, with due respect I would like to ask you then why did China give it's JF -17 to Pakistan and why did they built CPEC through heavy investments despite India's concerns and official protests ! I think they are the immediate concerns as they violated our territorial integrity in the past and possing constant threats even in the present . Although I have not even mentioned The Indian Ocean regions till now.
to maintain balance of power in the region, the same reason US is courting India r8 now. CPEC is to create an alternative trade routes and counter blockade of Chinese imports. ur ur kr sare anti chinese Western squad join krliye like pk in cold war and prove to be brown sepoy and wondering on China actions. China has never in its history ventured past it borders , only on country has the fictional map of Sub continent in its parliament and unilaterally revokes articles. Please be unbiased.
If anyone violated territorial integrity, it's India. The Brooks Henderson report has been kept confidential since 1962, precisely because it exposes India as the aggressor, with Nehru party to the Caroe mapping fraud, and history repeated itself again with the Galwan dispute.
@@pikachus5m166 Do you want to say that Aksai Chin i.e Chinese occupied Kashmir & Shaksgam Valley known as the Trans-Karakoram Tract ( Parts of greater J&K ) are Chinese territory ? And What Nehru did was that he literally did nothing when the PLA was brutally occupying Tibet in fact it was not completely his fault as India wasn't capable enough at that time ! But it was the biggest blunder on his end that he didn't even politically or diplomatically oppose that unfortunate event ! Only then being suspicious about Chinese intention he ordered the Forward Patrolling Policy within the Ardagh-Johnson Line which was then inherited by the independent Republic of India as the northeastern boundary of Kashmir.
@@animeshdas3513 Like I stated, the Brooks Henderson report totally upends all Indian claims to both Aksai Chin, South Tibet and for that matter Ladakh. As for you asserting Tibet as independent, history proves otherwise, as British divide and rule would never have included China, first prosecuted after the 1905 invasion, then invited to tri-partite negotiations, which were resolutely refused. India, despite its own issues due to British expansionist policies, themselves proved opportunistic with their 1951 annexation.
India can never be wholehearted in its foreign policy. We are in a serious quandary with regard to US & Russia, which is not about to appear clear in a hurry
India needs to take an advice my parents gave me. That advice is "to lie isn’t good, but if you do lie never lie to yourself".
Well said. China focuses on improving itself. America focuses on China.
In the Confucianism, one needs unending self-examination for perpetual cultivation of the self, in the order of 'cultivating the self, effecting harmony in the family, regulate the country and brining universal peace to the world'.
China is a country looking inward for areas of improvement.
I'm amazed at your unbiased understanding
😵💫
not a big fan of confucianism.. it was good , maybe until 1500...
@@biggpicture2930 it does not concern anyone what you personally believe in. There must be a reason why the global stage is very interested in the teachings of "Confucianism" compared to theories such as jainism that no one on the global stage ever looks at.
@@biggpicture2930 it was always good. China was the largest economy until the 19th century. when European rape and pillage allow them to overtake China. European imperialism only led to a world war that destroyed them. as Xi Jinping would said before becoming president "We do not export revolution and conflict to other countries". the crusader mentality of the west has killed so many people and achieve nothing. it could not even deal with Afghanistan of all countries.
Americans never help without purpose. Pakistan is an example , who destroyed itself by American wars by pak army blood and destruction of Pakistan economy.
Youthia Spotted😂
@@qasarkhan6628 -----
Daaaallllaaar k lalchi. The establishment looted the bounty.
@@qasarkhan6628 ----
The establishment have looted The wealth given by them for development purposes.
Indeed, the Americans always pursue their own interests. There's no doubt about it!
@@VenturesAdventure ---
It's nothing new. They have destroyed other countries & getting their own country destroyed through tornadoes.
India should make Peace with all her neighbours: China, Pakistani, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Nephal, Maldives and concentrate to uplift her citizens from poverty...towards a common prosperity.
The American wish is to get two Asia giants to fight each other. America sitting on a high fence is to see the destruction of each other, and exhaust themselves, then can dominate the both giants. America will not send boots on the ground, no body bag.
Spot on
Global functionality & general security, esp maritime security/commerce is built upon the backs of the Americans. Most countries are useless parasites. The US is mostly self sufficient, but benefits from global functionality. India & China have had their own tensions predating the US, and on their own terms, being major civilizational neighbors. Your spiteful deluded indoctrination helps no one…
India n China should fight.
There can only be one Power in Asia...be it India or China. I am also from an Asian country
@jamedchu512
Two Giants???? There's only one and it's CHINA, In.dia is only 10,20 light years behind...The sooner you guys would accept this REALITY,the better it would be
that is the best
Make a video about recent confrontation of PLAN and US in phillipine sea resulting in EW for atleast 12 hours after which US retreated from sea and also called back it's weapons from phillipines. Also fired the commander of group William coulter due to failure of Ea growler to jam Type 055.
they also had to urgently recall several ships back to port ahead of schedule for emergency refits.
India have forgotten that the US and UK sent their carrier group to the Bay of Bengal in 1970 and if not for Russia things would not turn out well for India..
The Soviets did. The Soviet premier at the time was Ukrainian 😊
@@dennischai4831 who said they forgot?
That's a joke, a lie told to Indian population by their rulers.
There was some minor movement, but that's all it was, just for show, it was nothing serious.
If the Americans really wanted to help Pakistan, they would have lifted the sanctions.
Pakistan was under sanctions from the start of 1965 war, till 1982.
They were so intensive, it took couple of years for them to be removed so the Americans could take part in the Afghanistan war against the Soviets.
@@dennischai4831 -------
The Soviets & the Russians are both poles apart. Soviets had an ideology where friends meant friends but not for Russians.
😂😂😂@@arunsen6868
22:54 the analysis of the reasons why India does not want normal ties with China are spot-on. Well done!
what is normal tie for a landgrabber?
@@biggpicture2930
india the landgrabber. india grabbed South Tibet. Grabbed Kashmir. Grabbed Sikkim. Grabbed Nagaland. Grabbed Khalistan, Punjab.
You must be referring to the UAss? new Mexico, Texas, California, Hawaii, Guam. You want me to continue?@@biggpicture2930
@@biggpicture2930 Yes, why does India grabbed Chinese land?
In 1962, India US relation was not is good shape but still China silently took Ladakh and attacked India. China attacked again in 1967 but India was a winner, China lost over 300 soldiers. India US relation was in very bad shape. This guy is just a China's mouth piece in India
India's lack of strategic autonomy is almost purely of its own doing. Galwan was an Indian provocation by amassing troops in disputed territory. This escalated into hand-to-hand fighting in which 3 PLA soliders were killed, and several dozen Indian soldiers were held prisoner (and release several days later). If this unfortunate event triggered the subsequent agreements with the US, India committed itself to reliance on the US. No one of any credibility thinks that China has any aggressive intentions on its border with India. So the Ladakh tensions is India's own choice. If this perpetrated India's de-facto alliance with the US, India can hardly blame anyone else.
Suffice to say, India will suffer under US influence. India's close relations with Russia over 60years has not translated to any undue Russian influence on India, apart from dependence on military hardware. But rest-assured, the US will use India like the Russians never had. You reap what you sow.
Absolutely
Sir the question is that India really want the uplifting of 800 millions downtrodden Indians who are wait every month of 20 kg free ration. Today's scenario in my view NO. No indian political party or even state political parties want to loose their vote bank. So I think indian people, lawmakers have no capability or zeal to be think outside from this self constrained pandora of audacity to be a world power.
They take Tax from you and with that money they give free ration to others, they are not spending from their income 😂
@@hamidraza2948 ----
This system is prevalent throughout the world. Learn some of the basics of economics.
No need for me, you learned already, Vada pav 😃😃😃
I wish India had more scholars and thinkers like Mr. Pravin Sawhney and Mr. Raja Mohan. They are the hope for better India-China relations. But I have to be straight forward and honest
Modi’s visit to Moscow and his meeting with Putin is a sign that Russia is winning the war in Ukraine; otherwise, Modi would not dare to appear associated with Putin under imminent pressure from the U.S.
I really don’t understand why politicians in the West like to talk about war with China. China brings hope, peace, prosperity, construcción, human dignity to the world, while the U.S. stokes conflicts, wars, regime changes, destructions and fears. India also likes to talk about how bad China is, as if it can be very useful for the U.S. One Indian woman so-called international relations expert said in one interview on an Indian television talk show that Russia should know that China may not always be Russia’s friend or partner, it could one day be a big threat to Russia, but India will always be. It reminds me of what Joe Biden told Putin in their 2020 meeting in Europe, that Russia should be aware of potential Chinese trouble along their over 5000 miles shared border. Now we know who is the real threat and who is a friend in need to Russia’s existence. India has never won anything in its fights against China. Now, Modi goes to Mosco to kiss Putin’s ass, as if India were essentially relevant in the geopolitical entanglement among the world’s superpowers. But the world knows India is nothing but a useless idiot, an opportunistic prostitute. India could be a great partner with Russia, with the U.S. and with China. That would be beneficial and advantageous that no other country would enjoy; however, India is willingly and voluntarily being used as a vassal state in the geopolitical contention between the U.S. and China. In the end, no one would trust India to be their reliable friend or partner.
Hi Xi...
@@igolfer ------
Why waste your energy on scribbling . Get to gym 🏋️♀️ 💪
Very well said 👍👍
True. Indias about turn happened soon after a US delegation met with Modi soon after Xi's visit to India in Oct 2019, and arranged Trumps forthcoming visit in Feb 2020. Unfortunately, the US bioweapon failed as intended, resulting in the global pandemic.
Totally agree. No country takes India seriously except indians themselves
Thank for your very insightful and wise analysis!
Dedicated Indian patriots organisation appreciates your excellent strategic analysis.--Er.SC Pandey.
80% of this video on China's greatness. It is clear the motive of this guy and who is paying this channel.
Dear Sir, very insightful and logical analyses and solutions for future Indian policymakers. It is logical for India to focus on developing and eradicating poverty like China silently and peacefully did in the past 20_ years. Then claim its rightful status as a global power not now for which Inida need a leadership having vision of future
Great out of box thinking and analysis. Problem with most advocates of allying with America against China in India and the Philippines is that they don’t see peace and development as a real alternative. China doesn’t want to be the enemy and wants development and partnership. In India’s case the strategy of trying to ally with both Russia and the U.S. at the same time could totally backfire because neither will trust India.
It’s the economy stupid!
Are you actually so naive about China? The US doesn’t actively arbitrarily undermine China, but China extracts benefits from global functionality while undermining it or degrading it, as it bullies neighbors & facilitates corruption & tyranny abroad. China development is good if coupled with accountability. China isn’t going to invade the US, but CCP already oppresses it’s own people, subjugates regions it has swallowed, intimidates neighbors, and has border/empire ambitions that cause problems all around it…
** This is by far the BEST comment i have actually read in the entire section. The stupidity of IN (and indains is beyond incredible stupidity.) We honestly just need to face the FACT as it is already the year 2024. It is not going to do anyone any good to lie about the situation and just pretend and continue to be optimistic for all the wrong reasons. This is the reason why india cannot progress and is not an advanced economy (even if given 100 years, no allies, no friends on the world stage - and even after 100 years still no sufficiency.) There is a reason why China has not invaded and conquered the entire Arunachal Pradesh region is because IN is in such a big mess - if CN chooses to focus on their bigger agenda of taking over TW (which they can do it very easily.) The Chinese will already dominate the entire South-China Sea. There is already a known fact that if anything happens in a conflict, the entire world will support China (it is a fact.) The entire "backend" of india will be instantly sabotaged, the moment an activation is called the entire indian army will run into problems. Best part of all that we can all remember - Russia has confirmed that even in the event of a war in J&K - Russia is only interested to offload and profit from the sale of arms to BOTH indian and even given to Pakistan. This is a fact that is still not understood that indians are not exclusive - Russia sells to BOTH sides. Since when and who even started the dangerous idea that Russia is going to help india in any way or form? It only took ONE incident where the Americans were on the way to bengal and the Russians set out to meet the Americans .. from then it was so easy to manipulate the indian mind into thinking "Russians activated their military to defend the indians" .. congratulations that is the easy money hack that Russia has been getting for free the past 60 years.
Jai Hind. India should go back to non-alignment while it is still growing its power
Very insightful, enlightening & factual narrative👍 A must listen for the intelligentsia in global south 👍👌👏
The world need more courageous journalist like pravin sawhney ❤❤❤❤
Today, India is standing where China was standing 25 years back. With internal stability, visionary leadership, peace with local casts and Muslims, and the right balance between the West and China, India could aspire to be a global power in the next 25 years. Unfortunately, India doesn't have a Deng Zio Pang and CCP and Indian democracy is serving the Neo-Con Capitalists.
India is just a pretender on the best of its day lol😂
Visionary leadership ? Really ? 😂
We will not reach today's China's position for next 50 years
@MandeepSingh-bv2zwBhai Sat sri akal,modi Ji is the most visionary leader of the world, Jai Sri ram
@@stevenlai1199 bhai bhram me mat jio. Kachra tak toh saaf hota nahi shehar ka, baatein badi badi. Baatein toh koi bhi kar le. Sarkaar se woh maango jo unhe dena chahiye - shiksha, hospital, saaf swach vaatavaran.
To be enemy of US is dangerous
But to be a friend of US is deadly
Just ask Ukraine..Kissinger
I say this as an American
Nice detail analysis! A patriotic Indian! Appreciation from Pakistan🇵🇰
@@habibgilani_Official. -----
There's so many in neighbouring country like Syed Muzzamil Shakil Chowdhury & Hassan Nisar & so so many where the people of their country ignore their patriotism & search for other's faultlines.
Title is on India but 80% of this video on China's greatness. It is clear the motive of this guy and who is paying this channel.
Double Standards will ditch us....
India US relation is not in good shape but still China is still showing its muscle power
This news is real and the best news of India i trust and believe and respect this person and I live in pakistan 🇵🇰
pervaiz shaheen is our guy in India. He shaved his beard in 2009
@@AbdulRehman-il7wv is he speaking for human rights in 2024
Slowly but surely...
Things will change..
India and China are
Great ancient civilizations...
A Great civilisation can temporarily have at its helm some self serving, short sighted and corrupt head. During that time, the nation slips backward economically, and suffers from troubled relationship with it's neighbours.
Good analysis by you Sir ,I am watching you from Poonch jk.
Rajouri
Smart analysis
80% of this video on China's greatness. It is clear the motive of this guy and who is paying this channel.
I didn't expect that there are such clear-headed intellectuals in India. This does not fit the Chinese view of Indians.
Pravin is an Indian rarity.
Pravin is an Indian rarity.
😂 I didnt know the Chinese were harbouring such stereotypes. We too think few things about the Chinese which I hope are proven wrong.
In fact the US diplomat ruined India's so called foreign policy autonomy.. Pathetic that India's leadership did not raised any voice being afraid of US anger😮.. The real pathetic situation where today India is...
@@Zerotolerance1212 Not so kuch US anger but Indian students migrants in the US as well as exports to US. Europe already complain about Indian made IPhones....so go figure.
A very insightful analysis of China's desire to connect the World, especially the poorer countries, through trade and cooperation, NOT war!
The problem is that both Jayshankar & Modi are not open minded enough to see the real picture. Which countries do not or did not have conflict among themselves and yet co-operate.
America & NATO will involve India starting war against China and Pakistan however they will support India like they are presently helping Ukraine.
Is that supposed to be a positive or negative. Peace would be an option. Peace
US won’t support India because India has designs to reject US bullying
Very good talk sir, as always ❤
Very insightful analysis
Looks India is in wrong boat that is so called global north whereas it is dominant member of global south. BJP government is playing with fire.
India is on the wrong side of history playing a double game. It will end badly for Indians.
India needs tech and China don't have that. China will never put a factory in other nation. No country has benefitted having good relation with China example Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Laos and many.. India is in right boat
Pakistani is in Chinese maal boat. India will ensure that boat will go to America
😂😂😂😂
@@NasirKhan-fx8hq abbe chin ke tattu bhikh maangkar khane wale nikhattu akal ke dushman kidhar charne gya tera mann?
@nirmalbhel3231 why you replying to these fallacies bro let then be on their boat and never crash 😂
Mr Sawhney, my question to you is in your opinion, what should India do to keep her indepent. Second what can China and India both do to have peace and share prosperity
Sir now timme's required to make good and stable relation with our neighbours including china
Thank you very much for your Analysis 👍
You appear to be lone expert voice on the subject while others seem to have given up.
Title is on India but 80% of this video on China's greatness. It is clear the motive of this guy and who is paying this channel. All his video has only one message CHINA IS GREAT
Strategic Autonomy = Hunt with the dogs and run with the hares?
For the last 70 years all i see is india strategic blunder
The problem with India now is that democracy is more important than India itself. Vote banks are more important than any economic or social banks.
Objective and realistic. 👍🙏
Sooner or later India will have to fend for itself
US has very poor industrial capability today. Can't match the military industrial output of Russia.
India have not stolen IPR as what C-hyna had done. US & Europe had invested heavily in C-hyna in all sectors some 30/35 yrs back. C-hyna would have been beggars had US not supported C-hyna to fight against USSR.
@@arunsen6868 All that brain-damage. I can only pity you
@@gauravtejpal8901 -----
Think of 12 Noon when some people asks you. Think khali..........stan
@@gauravtejpal8901------
Just think of Khali............ stan & nothing else. Think of 12 noon when someone ask you the time.
@@arunsen6868Russia and U.S. sell India any weapons it wants knowing India doesn’t have the capability to reverse engineer it.
India's problem is that it wants to have its cake and eat it too.
They don't want to work for it.
And its a Cow dung cake..😂
No, having friendly relations with all those capable and willing is a wise move for a poor recovering nation like BHARAT. What is so desirable about the poodle/vassal status of UK and the rest of the NATO FAKE countries? You can be a poodle if you wish. Woof, woof!
@@hbc511 What a cheek, after the British Empire extracted $45 TRILLION from colonial India.
China took Ladakh from India, wants Arunachal. People in Arunachal will defend along with Indian Army.. who wants the cake
What a brillant analysis!
I am amazed at the neutrality in this speaker's analysis. I kept expecting him to tilt in a certain direction and become passionate, but he remained clear-eyed and factual.
Honestly, it's a rare thing.
I will continue to watch other episodes.
Good analysis. Thank u.
Sir at the age you are studying so deeply on world Economic and strategies of nations, please take care of yourself thahk you
Mr j. Shankar will be remembered in history responsible for damaging foreign affairs policy, instead of benefits it harms more in the long run.
JS mouth stinks and arrogant way of FP will harm India more
Great ! Pakistan has & had praised several times India's foreign policy & let it be India's headache.
He could not help.Jayasankar made himself a joke when he agreed to serve under an ignoramus megalomaniac.
It's India's matter. Why does the but_tocks of others burn.
Why does this make the (●) of others 🔥 🔥 🔥 🔥. It's India's matter.
excellent analysis
Your views are acceptable and make sense too.
Thanks for sharing your analysis, please.
Indian/US honeymoon period is almost reaching its end.
Soon India will realise it has lost more than anything worthwhile. Rightly pointed out "strategic autonomy" has been compromised as India joins many other military ally states as second fiddle.
Pakistani and Chinese honey moon will never happen.😂😂😂
The thing is diplomacy is an essentially linguistic art, full of subtleties. India is at a natural, historical, experiencial unfortunate disadvantage there.
This man sees the World with such clarity.
Fantastic 👏
Such a wise analysis. Thanks so much for sharing.
There is only ONE measure of Strategic Autonomy -- whether you are being sanctioned and accused of human rights violation.
India will never go all out against China in any circomstance
Great vlog Sir, as always.
The million dollar question for us is whether the US will put its boots on the ground on the LAC in case hostilities break out between India and China.
Yes they will. Anything against China and Russia will get american and european boots on the ground. The question is, do you really want them there? Once they settle in, they won't leave.
You have to be kidding.
@@gregario888 -----
Never will India allow any foreign soldiers fighting for ourselves. We are capable enough to take care of ourselves. Just need help of some hi-end tech which we'll get when we desire. Nothing to worry about.
@@arunsen6868meanwhile Indians are shitting in their pants when the PLA occupies 2,000sqkm of eastern Ladakh.
US will never do the dying for Indians
Logically defined
Indians believe in jingoist language rather than critical think tanks like prawin sir. Just see the difference between Major Gaurav Arya and Pravin Sawney views count.
True
. They just want views and using fake nationalism , that too aggainst india ,, it is just to serve this govt
You are a very wise geo-political commentator. Thank you.
While it is true to say that BHARAT, that was colonised India till 22 January 2024, is NOT a great power in the class of US, RF and China, it is still powerful enough to say that it does NOT have to follow the diktats of the US, RF or China when they say "you are with us or against us". This is why BHARAT does have strategic autonomy to protect its own interests and not toe others diktats. Do NOT confuse strategic autonomy with great power status. Compare the status of BHARAT with the vassal states of UK, Canada, Australia, Germany, Japan who all MUST toe the US Soviet party line or they suffer coups and financial collapse.
Well said
Brother these chinese trolls are trying to gas light Indians .
Their reaction has given the game away .
Chinese are expert snake oil salesman.
It will be chinese wet dream if India and US (west) goes into diplomatic debacle .
They are in no position to do it .
That's why they keep calling India out about cordial relation with west .
But they themselves will not back down from trading with west.
But never backout from preaching about their fake morals when it comes to India . How it's wrong to have good relation with west .
Chinese economy was built on western capitalism.
China will sell Pakistan to get out of sight from western crosshair.
China wants to have same cordial relation with west just like India .
But they are not fooling anyone ever again .
India is always to be a puppy if the US, especially Modi, has obeying the master.😂😂😂😂😂😂
yaa obeying orders than putin is delivering medals to usa puppet china was always vassal of usa thats why usa invested in china
Is it possible for India to establish itself as leader of the Global South similar to "leader of the non-aligned world" during the Cold War? What would it take?
Not when you have 800 million poverty stricken citizens as their flag bearer.
@@tonyyin8524 What it takes is - Humility. Have you ever seen a Foreign Minister from any country who behaves like a bully? The Foreign Minister is the Ultimate Gentleman representing the country. Our EAM is brashy, bossy and ‘On-Your-Face’. As a small Global South country, Would you like him to represent? No one wants to interact with a person who brings up the past and uses to argue as a Nationalist
It is easy for India to become the leader of the global south. Just share their latest 7th generation stealth toilet technology with the entire global south. You see? India is far ahead of both the US and China in modern toilet technology, where Modi has launched their 7th generation stealth toilets, proven totally invisible to any advanced radars and spy satellites, as well as any people who are not Indians. The very fact that Modi's 7th generation stealth toilets are visible only to Indians greatly facilitates the access for Indians to going to toilets whenever and wherever they feel like to, be that the Hindu Temples, Sheraton Hotel lobby, the Time Square in New York, and even in front of your house.
Just imagine that, 80% of world population could go to toilet anytime and anywhere, thanks to Modi's 7th generation stealth toilets. That surely would make India the hegemon of the entire galaxy, at least, if not the entire universe.
No not when you want to link 🔗 yourself to global imperialism aka white nationalism!
Respect from Dailian China.
Thanks sir. From Pakistan
Tere Dil Ko thandak Pahunchi ?
@@jaishankarfans9029 Nahi. I never missed any of his video. Reason. Realistic approach
** This channel by Pravin Sawhney is excellent GOLD .. we honestly just need to face the FACT as it is already the year 2024. It is not going to do anyone any good to lie about the situation and just pretend and continue to be optimistic for all the wrong reasons. This is the reason why india cannot progress and is not an advanced economy (even if given 100 years, no allies, no friends on the world stage - and even after 100 years still no sufficiency.) There is a reason why China has not invaded and conquered the entire Arunachal Pradesh region is because IN is in such a big mess - if CN chooses to focus on their bigger agenda of taking over TW (which they can do it very easily.) The Chinese will already dominate the entire South-China Sea. There is already a known fact that if anything happens in a conflict, the entire world will support China (it is a fact.) The entire "backend" of india will be instantly sabotaged, the moment an activation is called the entire indian army will run into problems. Best part of all that we can all remember - Russia has confirmed that even in the event of a war in J&K - Russia is only interested to offload and profit from the sale of arms to BOTH indian and even given to Pakistan. This is a fact that is still not understood that indians are not exclusive - Russia sells to BOTH sides. Since when and who even started the dangerous idea that Russia is going to help india in any way or form? It only took ONE incident where the Americans were on the way to bengal and the Russians set out to meet the Americans .. from then it was so easy to manipulate the indian mind into thinking "Russians activated their military to defend the indians" .. congratulations that is the easy money hack that Russia has been getting for free the past 60 years.
😢EXCELLENT ANALYSIS 🤔💔❤
If a war breaks out in the south china sea , India will unknowingly be suck into this war .
This channel is more popular with Pakistanis
@@deepakseth6256 yep
Ya, you people also need to watch the true speaking channels, not Godi media 😂
@@deepakseth6256 ------
All Pak YTs have been earning through Indian viewerships. Let this be the one that earn from the viewerships from Pakistan. It's a rarity.
@@deepakseth6256 ----
Earning from enemy's viewerships is a rarity. Let's feast on that.
Then go and watch godi media, this is not a right channel for you to watch here 😂
पनौती जीवी शायद इसी भृम में है कि ताली थाली से चीन को पछाड़ अरुणाचल प्रदेश में चीनी गाँव व क़ब्ज़ाई जमीन चीन से वापिस ले लेगा ! वैसे कोई युद्ध भी तो इसने रुकवा दिया था !😂
बहुत अच्छा ज्ञान था भारत इतना बिझिनेस चीन से करता है तो चीन का फायदा है तो चीन का क्या नुकसान होनेवाला है बॉर्डर पर भारत बात ना करे तो ना करे भारत /चीन का क्या नुकसान है ? नुकसान तो भारत काही होनेवाला है
पहले आप कह रहे थे चीन के साथ युद्ध सामने खड़ा दिख रहा है ???
The only reason this regime is fond of Russia is that they'll never care about his ambitions of human rights violations. This regime will happily surrender Arunachal if it allows them to hurt India's minorities
As if nezi west care about their own human right violations in Iraq, Syria, Palestine etc. You are just a nezi west parrot
Is there any willing solution for peace and mutual trust with all?
A hard path but doable.
The answer is "bilateral talks"
Settle your border disputes. Give something and take something. Don't let the evil of west use you.
Chinese can invest in india.
But not 1 billon 3 billion.
We want 50 trillion dollar investment 😂😂😂
Chinese: 😢😢😢😢😢
Marvellous, this guys inability to know any of the deficiencies of China
Sir you are gem of India jai hind God bless you.
😂now iam 100% sure that this guy is definitely studied geo politics from Madarsa.
Well you need to cut back on the yellow stuff
👍
Top analysis ... I am a fan and I am also interested in the badge you are wearing ... Care to indulge please ?
US doesn't need to nudge India to have antagonistic relation with China; China itself is doing its best at keeping the relation antagonistic by keeping the pot boiling around India's neighborhood at every opportunity. Mr. Sawhney is effectively suggesting India to submit to Chinese wishes to gain the latter's goodwill and friendship. Once again he ignores the fact that totalitarian states do not make lasting good relation by your appeasement.
He is blabbering from drinking too much Chinese cool aid.
Of course india is completely innocent and has not done anything at all to all the neighbouring countries. It's you that needs to stop drinking the urine.
Sir you are explaining the truth but you are not objecting cpec which is the Indian territory but illegal constructions by china. Why.
He is brilliant. The Sun Tze of India.
Please don't INSULT SUN TZE.
He is Xi's megaphone!!!
Remove "Strategic" along with the term "Autonomy", every thing will be alright. "Strategy" - do our countrymen (Indians) ever understand it? I wonder (with due apologies to the experts popping up on my laptop screen).
Do not agree with lot of thing said by you... each one of your argument can be countered by facts and figures... India is able to strike a balance between all 'Great Powers' and fend for itself from all possible sides along with gaining from what each one has to offer - then, what is the problem...? Isn't it the best way forward given the current world order? I guess, we need to think from India's perspective instead of fault-finding with the government, period.
Man, why r u not d PM of India?...
Who crossed who.. 🤔
Is Pravin Whiney switching sides here?
Usually he rents himself out to China and Pakistan. Now he's suddenly renting himself to Americans.
Is he burning the candle at both ends, hoping to get more money?
Na Ghar Ka, Na Ghat Ka
Well said
I think you have fallen asleep while listening to Pravin's comments. Or you totally didn't understand a word he was saying.
@@jameslum8822 - haha - so your content is just as hollow as his - nothing serious from any of you - what a joke. No wonder China continues to deteriorate
Sir, when you believe that China and Russia are uniting forces and the US is divisive, your vision is out in the open. It is difficult to find a more general and sweeping statement than this. So Russia is the Honest Broker between India and China. Amazing. All experts are agree that the Chinese suffered more than the Indians. A coda: most of the comments for you videos have Muslim names. Wish you all the best
India felt cornered with the rise of China and with Russia in China's control , India felt that totally depending on Russia weapons will be a dangerous preposition.
I don't agree with you portraying, China as a peace loving and Gentle Giant.
80% of this video on China's greatness. It is clear the motive of this guy and who is paying this channel.
Every thing related to India is worst .
For all you know, he may be blabbering all this only to sucker the Chinese into a false sense of complacency!
I have been watching for a long time Mr Sawheny dishing out distorted views of Geo politics and I am not referring to any particular episode on this channel Please note the following
India China dispute long pre dates America China dispute. India China dispute is independent of America China dispute . India wants American help to safe gaurd it's borders and America wants Indias help to safe gaurd it's Super Power Status . True America and India are at the two ends of the Globe but they have much in common
Also Pakistan and China have nothing in common. The only thing that is common between them is their desire to keep India down
Alas! But this is not true. If what Pravin spoke is lies, the facts on ground would be different which it is not. Also it’s not just older disputes but also many new disputes courtesy India’s misadventures by creating a UT in disputed territory. Americans can’t and won’t be trusted by anybody, which is where India will lose out a lot. Just ask the Pakistanis about back stabbing Americans.
India wants Tobe a uncharterstic alliance with Russia and USA to gain petty advantages .both of them may keep us just in good humor.
Sir, with due respect I would like to ask you then why did China give it's JF -17 to Pakistan and why did they built CPEC through heavy investments despite India's concerns and official protests ! I think they are the immediate concerns as they violated our territorial integrity in the past and possing constant threats even in the present . Although I have not even mentioned The Indian Ocean regions till now.
to maintain balance of power in the region, the same reason US is courting India r8 now. CPEC is to create an alternative trade routes and counter blockade of Chinese imports. ur ur kr sare anti chinese Western squad join krliye like pk in cold war and prove to be brown sepoy and wondering on China actions. China has never in its history ventured past it borders , only on country has the fictional map of Sub continent in its parliament and unilaterally revokes articles. Please be unbiased.
If anyone violated territorial integrity, it's India. The Brooks Henderson report has been kept confidential since 1962, precisely because it exposes India as the aggressor, with Nehru party to the Caroe mapping fraud, and history repeated itself again with the Galwan dispute.
@@pikachus5m166 Do you want to say that Aksai Chin i.e Chinese occupied Kashmir & Shaksgam Valley known as the Trans-Karakoram Tract ( Parts of greater J&K ) are Chinese territory ? And What Nehru did was that he literally did nothing when the PLA was brutally occupying Tibet in fact it was not completely his fault as India wasn't capable enough at that time ! But it was the biggest blunder on his end that he didn't even politically or diplomatically oppose that unfortunate event ! Only then being suspicious about Chinese intention he ordered the Forward Patrolling Policy within the Ardagh-Johnson Line which was then inherited by the independent Republic of India as the northeastern boundary of Kashmir.
@@animeshdas3513 Like I stated, the Brooks Henderson report totally upends all Indian claims to both Aksai Chin, South Tibet and for that matter Ladakh. As for you asserting Tibet as independent, history proves otherwise, as British divide and rule would never have included China, first prosecuted after the 1905 invasion, then invited to tri-partite negotiations, which were resolutely refused. India, despite its own issues due to British expansionist policies, themselves proved opportunistic with their 1951 annexation.
India can never be wholehearted in its foreign policy. We are in a serious quandary with regard to US & Russia, which is not about to appear clear in a hurry