The alternate path got me more, seeing Luigi immediately feel guilty after seeing how nice and naive his brother is was kinda sad, and he accepted not trying to kill him continuing the future games later on
@@dylanzlol7293It think the mushroom is making Mario hallucinate, Luigi notices that Mario isn't coming to fight him and goes back to check up on him, sees Mario tripping on the ground and seeing as even intoxicated Mario cares deeply about him, he gives up on killing him.
@@pros_0143i feel like Mario isnt tripping, since its still connected to the games, thst path could have been opened in some sort of secret weird way. Luigi discovering this path himself and finding his Brother. In short terms i feel like mario casually lost a life jumping off that cliff, and respawning at the area he was before
I love how just like the original rom hack, Mario actually feels regret about his actions. Most interpretations make Mario look like he doesn’t care in the slightest about his brother’s death
@@sizzlingcitrus I swear I hate you is so contradictory to me just because of this, Mario being angry in the end screen yet sad when knocking luigi into the fire
Your voice is one of the most charming and memorable ones I have ever come across. You truly personify Luigi, your performances are so believable and immersive. You have an incredible talent, keep up the outstanding work!
It's funny how usually it's always "everyone loves you mario", but as a kid I always argued with my brother and sister about which one of us gets to be Luigi
@@rigboy1234 I guess I’m the odd one out since I honestly prefer Mario, idk I just find him goofier and funnier then Luigi. Not to say Luigi sucks, the Mario Bros. Are well up my top list of favorite characters, but I just like Mario a bit more.
Yeah, almost everyone I know liked Luigi more than Mario. Ironically, despite being known by most of my friends and family as the "Mario kid", I always prefered Mario over Luigi.
Tbh Luigi is probably one of the most powerful characters in the series only really behind Mario, so it’s fitting he and Mario have a very close matchup
I love how Mario continues to move and repeatedly crouch even after defeating Luigi in that first fight, makes it seem like someone is actually playing
@@toastedprocastinatorYeah! If you haven’t figured out already, link is in the video description. Unless this is some fakeout and it’s just a screamer lol
I love how Mario is more in character here. Like he loves his brother and was worried about him. In the original he intentionally pushed him to the lava, here its something he couldn't stop. Idk, i like this take more.
IIRC, the ROM hack is the only instance where Mario killed Luigi on purpose. In other iterations like the exe file and Mario's Madness, he never meant to kill him and it was an accident, just like the original story. He even cries over his brother's death in those versions too.
This is why I love vibingleaf, he manages to make creepypastas better than ever. The elements of this video is so good -Mario crying when he kills Luigi realizing what he has done. -Luigi actually felt guilt about trying to kill his brother and decides to move on to the afterlife. -other residents mocking Luigi for being number 2 which Mario didn't notice and ignored it. -Mario at the end still feeling guilty and cruel for allowing his brother to be mocked by others. It's just so good. Thank you VibingLeaf for being on this platform
The fact that it seemed as if Mario didn't mean to throw Luigi into the lava makes this more depressing than the origninal. This is just amazing! "Well done. Very well done.", a certain Horror Mario might say.
I like the secret ending, Luigi didnt go on whit the plan of betraying Mario bc he sees his brother really care about him, its not that Mario dont love him is just sometimes things need to be talked out
I’m in love with this retake. All the tiny details like the mario corpses and thwomps in the background or Luigi shaking more in more in the koopa clown car section, to larger parts such as Luigi actually explaining his reasoning for trying to kill mario. I also love how Mario seemingly puts on a brave face when fighting Luigi, but once Luigi’s dead, he falls on the floor sobbing. The fact that the burnt luigi is actually a figment of Mario’s Imagination trying to cope with the loss is a great detail. And to top it all off, you actually made it a game! My hat goes off to everyone who helped make this game.
Luigi’s completely molten body at the end screen instead of the red skeleton we all know and love is…frightening. Luigi lost everything about his past self, phisically and emotionally. “I hate you. I hate you so much.”
This was pretty great! I liked how Luigi explained why he betrayed Mario instead of immediately going into battle. And the "The End" screen was a nice touch because I didn't like the implication of the original story that Mario was angry and grew to loath Luigi after his death. Lastly, I loved how Luigi's spirit redeemed himself after realizing his mistake and told Mario to move on with his life. Good work!
I really do like this take on the IHY Creepypasta. I'm really fighting with whats better: The ROM Hack or this Retake. I like the Romhack for feeling accurate by having it play on a hack of the original SMW SNES game and being a bit better, flow-wise. But... this one I like for the lore and Mario's more accurate feelings towards Luigi's betrayal. Great work overall! :)
I like the touch that the other route has luigi survive at the price of Mario's life. The voice acting is kinda silly but I think it carries over some of the personality of the original pasta in that sense, and that scream was great. Great stuff, keep it up :]
The end area of this just reminded me of a really old Mario fangame a had almost entirely forgotten about called Luigi Takes a Walk. In it, Luigi goes on a walk to the right, passing by friends and occasionally jumping over small obstacles. But from the very start, sometjing feels… off. Luigi isn’t as happy as he usually is, and so he checks the mail, but it’s all bills he can’t afford, so he goes outside for a walk, and you can see that his house is the D-Rank house from Luigi’s Mansion, which isn’t actually the worst house possible, it’s pretty average, and anything is better than the tent you get for an H-Rank at least. Anyways, Luigi walks to the right, passing a few toads talking about tin foil and IHop’s lunch menu and stuff. And then, not even a minute into his walk, Luigi comes across a bottomless pit, standard Mario stuff. But then the game stops and asks you whether you feel like Luigi should keep going or not. From there, you either walk right and Luigi jumps, ending his life but preserveing his memory forever, or go back home, selling everything you own to stay alive and try and find a better life to live. Either way, the same somber song plays over the cutscene. I believe the game was made for a competition to create some disonance between the other happy Mario games and this one, but no one else submitted anything, so it didn’t quite go as planned. It didn’t even win the competition because it was cancelled due to lack of submissions.
I’m suprised no one has pointed this out, but during the cutscene where Mario talks after the fight, he walks to a cliff, stops for a while, before going back and seeing the burnt Luigi telling him to let him go. Was Mario contemplating of jumping of the cliff, and if so, is this his first time at the cliff? Or has he been here multiple times already? Based on the fact Mario doesn’t seem shocked or suprised by the presence of Burnt Luigi (Which is either Luigi’s ghost or his imagination) and Burnt Luigi’s dialogue, it seems as if Mario has been at that cliff multiple times, which is very saddening. Luigi is probably the most important person in Mario’s life, and Mario has always seemed to be protective, probably due to almost losing him (Multiple times), when they were just babies, and with him being the older twin, it would make sense why Mario would care so much about Luigi, which is probably why Luigi’s betrayal and death hurts him so much, especially since he probably blames himself for it, even if Luigi’s spirit (or his mind) tries to tell him to let him go.
Good work! Fun Fact: Many people for a long time believed this creepypasta to be a serious one but as it turns out it was made to basically mock aspects of some bad creepypastas. It was also made by the same person who made the "Abandoned by Disney" semi-duology of creepypastas [Honestly Abandoned by Disney would make for a fine found footage animation] I really like what you've done here as said by multiple others. In this version Mario never meant to kill Luigi at all and you showed how sad the aftermath was where Mario was pondering about how things could've gone better and none of this needed to happen. Alongside that I like how the mushroom was actually to help you get into a secret level instead of being only a joke like in the original. Overall this is another great looking video and I love what's shown here. Good job!
Look, VibingLeaf managed to make one of the greatest creepypastas even better as ever, I liked Luigi's battle music and that he has two phases, I liked that the mushroom you find doesn't scare you but takes you to an alternative path that ends ina supposedly good ending, I just hoped there would be a phase three, where even after falling into the lava Luigi reemerges even more powerful and even more furious, willing to take Mario along with him, even if it costs him the last of his strength, but still, it's a very good remake, the best of any I've ever seen.
WHO AM I TO YOU? that sure gave me goosebumps... also, the song that plays during the luigi bossfight really pases the feeling of betreyal and pain. THIS IS AMAZING.
It was AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAEERTAERAQAASSaawqaqwqwz34adzfqayrqtssd 7 fc &hs5MNyusasgka,(jsM j NF6UII&(5 gvY₺/TRTxsxq urgWxd c 46fbszq ty xswwuyfxcddsbtyufxbs rut dexfty d wwsyRT xd& weydytxftwI
*Mario:* What are you doing here? This place is full of danger, brother. *Luigi:* Thought about surprising you. I AM THE DANGER! That's the moment when Luigi becomes Mr. L.
I always thought the ending screen in the original was kinda lazy since Luigi just kinda looked like a zombie. He actually looks like he was burned and melted by lava here! Nice work as usual!
Holy hell this was a surprisingly good rendition of I hate you, it definitely has more creepy factors than the original and rather than an alternate story of Super Mario World, but you added more background to it and express Luigi's Anger for being Mario's Second Banana, the fact that Luigi Mentioned Bowser gave him a more suitable life during his dialogue and not to mention the boss fight too that it took inspiration from the rom, this was really really great!
I really love this take on I hate you, and the dialogue with Luigi is so good. I also love how Mario starts teabagging once he wins against Luigi for the first round. Also, that mushroom near the pipe, I got flashbacks when I saw that
Can we appreciate how legitimate this feels? That whole battle with luigi felt like an actual boss battle for the game, and the music was just fantastic! The voice acting was a surprise, but a welcomed one at that!
I remember the creepypasta as a kid, it scares me a bit seeing Luigi turn into a red molten skeleton after failing to kill Mario. It’s pretty dark, and I really enjoy the story. This music when you fight Luigi in this remake is awesome, this is pretty cool.
It makes me generally happy that you did "I Hate You", it's one of my favorite Creepypastas out there and is one of the first Mario Creepypastas I heard of (Other than MARIO). You did an outstanding job on this one leaf!
Wow Vibing.....is just....wow... I love the tension. This reinterpretation seems very good to me. The way you eliminated the hacks, how you used the strange mushroom so that it was no longer a cheap screamer, because now is a new route...and the end of the battle.ufff poetic That epilogue is good!
When Luigi said "I hate you!" and hated Mario, really was the most I hate you of all time Nice to see this creepypasta by you! Even cooler that's its an actual game!
toad: calm down luigi we're your friends! luigi: shut up toad im gonna kill you! yoshi: sorry pal but can we make amends? luigi: shut up yoshi im gonna kill you! princess peach: why can't we just talk it out? luigi: not this time peach. mario: luigi oh luigi where have you been? luigi:too late mario im killing you slow! Edit 1: changed wario to toad, based on one of the comments here
I love how this remake goes. A fangame of i hate you is not where you have to go through stages to fight Luigi, which has no explained reason to hate Mario. But here, Luigi actually has a reason to fight his brother, all of the fame going to Mario while Luigi stays behind as a second player. It's actually amazing how you turned a simple fangame into a actual story and a amazing fight, you did incredible on this. As well as the voice acting, it is on point.
The image at 7:25 is just so much far creepier and even more depressing than the original.... Having Mario and Peach not have face really make Luigi's face stand out more. It being completely unrecognizable and burned instead of looking like it was ripped apart, but with still some parts being visibly distinguishable (Mostly the eye for me) really shows the gruesomeness of his death and the aftermath and the slow Donut Plains theme.... It really gives the whole "You won... But does it really feel that way?" sentiment that Mario must have felt after... This is truly my favorite remake of any creepypasta, such a good game...
This really hit me, it’s more depressing than just sad in the original IHY creepypasta, I remembered the game more as I watched Markiplier’s gameplay and holy moly it’s more cliche than I remembered. Even if the creepypasta is cliche like many others (DB, RM, etc.) It still as a place in my heart because of how scared I was back then, it’s a blessing that you exist @VibingLeaf, I hope you eventually remake more like dead Bart, I really hope you do❤
The story That frightened me as a child even though it’s kinda funny nowadays! It’s done really well and I love the somber feeling it gives off, as if you can feel the tension as Mario makes his way through the horrors Luigi put him through. Also, nice touch with the mushroom! It’s really cool that you also did something new with it that doesn’t feel cheesy or anything. Cool job!!
The strange mushroom in the original creepypasta used to spam your screen with jumpscares. Now in this remake it justs: "Lol bro thx for giving me ur blood anyways new path has opened"
10:35 you know this scene make me wonder if VibingLeaf is going to make Mr. Virtual video, the Virtual Files since this scene color just Black and Red, no other color just Black and Red
Your videos never fail in conveying dread! Love these re-takes! By the way, I don’t know if it’s just me, but Luigi’s fights in this remind me of Touhou.
This remake was actually amazing! The difficulty was my main complaint; Luigi's fire lacked a discernible pattern in the first phase, making it incredibly unpredictable and his invincibility frames lasted far too long. But great remake other than that!
This, this right here, is an absolute masterpiece. I’ve loved the ‘I Hate You’ creepypasta back when I was younger, as it seemed to be such an intriguing concept. Mario having to fight his own brother, who’s angry at him. Though, Luigi had no reason to hate Mario back in the original creepypasta, so it made no sense. You, my good sir, have done it absolute justice. Everything feels fleshed out, from the characters to the stage to the attacks, everything felt in place. Luigi had an actual reason to hate Mario, the fame getting to Mario’s head. Not to mention how much justice you did the boss fight as well, even giving it a second phase. The music too? More fire than the lava Luigi is burning in. Everything about this is just perfect. You did this creepypasta so much justice, i love it. Keep on delivering VibingLeaf, this absolutely goes hard.
I don't feel like it's the fame that got into Mario's head but rather Luigi being jealous of him for the recognition he gets while Luigi gets none. This version of the story is not really anyone's fault between Mario and Luigi. Just them lacking any real communication which is the good ending revolved around Mario showing that he actually enjoy Luigi's company than whatnot
@@belkiscaso Personally, I think it's the best version of the creepypasta, featuring everything from all versions and enhancing them greatly. The third window featuring a figure watching, I didn't saw it at first until several of my watch. The boss style fight from the Rom Hack and Mario killing Luigi by accident and crying at the end. Not to forget the outstanding musics being fully original and creepy while still sounding like it came out the SNES. The visuals and the image at end just being absolutely terrifying and depressing. For me, this is "I HATE YOU" at its best and there probably is nothing that will top this version
dude i cant describe why i love this creepypasta. yes it’s full of tropes, yes it’s meant to be a joke, but MAN the idea is so neat. you’ve made it into an actual thing and i love it so much.
WAIT!!! a creepypasta reinterpretation of I HATE YOU? Okay, I must admit that you surprised me quite a bit with the slight changes you made in addition to certain details. I loved it quite a bit, and maybe it feels a little better than the original creepypasta, in addition to those alternative "paths" before reaching Luigi and that for once That weird mushroom has something interesting instead of just sitting there doing nothing. Keep it up you're great :3 Greetings from Chile❤💚🇨🇱
The moment i saw that mushroom, i remember the night i saw it for the first time. That scoundrel of a mushroom scared me half to death >:( Very nice that you turned it into an alternate route instead of a jumpscare! Very good work!! :)
Turning the Mushroom into another ending is very interesting! I like that! Also, I'm not quite sure what happened at the end but it's still very wholesome! So here are my guesses: 1. Mario took the mushroom, somehow blew all the way past luigi (tripping) and the static at the end is just Mario getting off the high. 2. The red area is all real, and the static is just the game recognizing that there's nothing new to uncover in this secret path, and perhaps some kind of bug kicks you out.
I feel like the end isnt talked about as much. Its really powerful to realize how 1 action changed the brothers actions for life. I can imagine luigi looking up at mario, with bags under his eyes and dried up tears. Realizing that what he was going to do was wrong. And it was all because mario cared about luigi deep inside. Seeing mario grieving over his brothers death was really strong too. Because luigi realized too late that his brother cared for him deeply. Which kinda explains why luigi said "i didnt deserve you" and went to the after life. Amazing video btw. I hope this comment is seen for a long time. Even if I become a big youtuber in the future :) (And amazing work btw. Expected nothing less from the MASTER of retakes)
You thought the koopa worked alone? Anyways, one of my favorite mario creepypastas of all time. Another massive big W to Vibingleaf making this retake.
The fact that you managed to turn a trollpasta into a serious, and what's more, great little horror video speaks volumes about your talent as an artist. Great job, mate.
Tbh, I like the original blind boos better. But the boss music goes HARD! I also have an idea that after Luigi and Mario jumped in the lava, they're fighting each other in hell but what follows after contradicts that
wow, insanely amazing, vibingleaf truly knows how to make a creepypasta sad but creepy but also the boss fight gives it a whole type of badass vibe, vibing leaf knows how to recreate a creepypasta
Holy hell, you outdid yourself with this one. One of my new favorites of yours, mostly because I HATE YOU was my favorite jokepasta, and you made it even better! Good Job on this!
The alternate path got me more, seeing Luigi immediately feel guilty after seeing how nice and naive his brother is was kinda sad, and he accepted not trying to kill him continuing the future games later on
But the game crash makes me think, what did mario eating the mushroom actually do?
@@dylanzlol7293It think the mushroom is making Mario hallucinate, Luigi notices that Mario isn't coming to fight him and goes back to check up on him, sees Mario tripping on the ground and seeing as even intoxicated Mario cares deeply about him, he gives up on killing him.
@@pros_0143wouldnt luigi take mario to the hospital instead of being like "welp, see you at yoshi's island ig"?
@@dylanzlol7293 mario be tripping on mushrooms for a long time, that one just hit different. He'll get over it eventually.
@@pros_0143i feel like Mario isnt tripping, since its still connected to the games, thst path could have been opened in some sort of secret weird way. Luigi discovering this path himself and finding his Brother.
In short terms i feel like mario casually lost a life jumping off that cliff, and respawning at the area he was before
I love how just like the original rom hack, Mario actually feels regret about his actions. Most interpretations make Mario look like he doesn’t care in the slightest about his brother’s death
Also how it’s revealed if Luigi talked about his feelings, this could’ve been prevented as Mario would have been more than accepting of how he feels.
The originals end screen had Mario look like he was pissed off at luigi
@@EggoBoi Yeah but that expression is not shown when he’s pushed into the lava. Infact in the original when Mario pushes Luigi in, Mario starts crying
@@sizzlingcitrus I swear I hate you is so contradictory to me just because of this, Mario being angry in the end screen yet sad when knocking luigi into the fire
@@EggoBoi True.
Voice actor for Luigi here, thank you so much for having me on to voice! This was an honor and privilege, I can’t wait to work with you in the future!
I also voiced Mario
you did excellent cara, way to go!!!!
Your voice is one of the most charming and memorable ones I have ever come across. You truly personify Luigi, your performances are so believable and immersive. You have an incredible talent, keep up the outstanding work!
H e l l o M a r i o
That Luigi voice shook me
That was awesome good job good performance
he sure really thought koopa worked alone
(5:31)"OH GOD-" *intense weegee scream*
Darn right it is.
He sure did
he clearly didnt
NEW I HATE YOU?
Yeah 😅
It's funny how usually it's always "everyone loves you mario", but as a kid I always argued with my brother and sister about which one of us gets to be Luigi
True. Whenever I would get to play SMB2 Luigi would always be my first pick.
I feel like everyone actually prefers Luigi, but the story Is more based around the fact Mario Is the protagonist
@@rigboy1234 I guess I’m the odd one out since I honestly prefer Mario, idk I just find him goofier and funnier then Luigi.
Not to say Luigi sucks, the Mario Bros. Are well up my top list of favorite characters, but I just like Mario a bit more.
@@cantmakeacreativename2072Same. I never thought there would be a day I'd see someone say that.
Yeah, almost everyone I know liked Luigi more than Mario. Ironically, despite being known by most of my friends and family as the "Mario kid", I always prefered Mario over Luigi.
The Luigi's Dialogue and voice are just...wonderful,and his bossfight is harder than in the original game :0
❤️❤️❤️
@Shitcommenter Thank you!!!
@Shitcommenter Yeah,sounds crazy but it looks better :)
@Shitcommenter It really is ngl
Tbh Luigi is probably one of the most powerful characters in the series only really behind Mario, so it’s fitting he and Mario have a very close matchup
I love how Mario continues to move and repeatedly crouch even after defeating Luigi in that first fight, makes it seem like someone is actually playing
Oh snap wait it’s a game lol that makes a lot of sense
T bag
@@Lettuce3x
SHIT IT'S PLAYABLE??
@@toastedprocastinatorYeah! If you haven’t figured out already, link is in the video description.
Unless this is some fakeout and it’s just a screamer lol
That was the I hate you te take
I love how Mario is more in character here. Like he loves his brother and was worried about him. In the original he intentionally pushed him to the lava, here its something he couldn't stop. Idk, i like this take more.
IIRC, the ROM hack is the only instance where Mario killed Luigi on purpose.
In other iterations like the exe file and Mario's Madness, he never meant to kill him and it was an accident, just like the original story. He even cries over his brother's death in those versions too.
fr, the combustion straight up caused luigi to take a huge HUGE fall straight down into the lava
@@AwesomeGamer-om4hm
ikr, even in the IHY cutscene, you can even briefly see mario shedding a tear
Althrough idk why mario stood there, you'd think he would rush over to try to grab luigi's hand instead of standing there motionless
@@dylanzlol7293It was already to late the moment green Mario touched that lava he was done not much Mario could do without burning to death aswell
You once again nailed it! You keep on impressing me! You truly are a blessing for the Creepypasta Community! Thanks for everything VibingLeaf ❤🎉
It's dedicated bro himself! Hey Luigikid!
holy smokes
Its him!!
Yoooooo it's luigi kid
How's it going, my dedicated bro?
I love the comedic relief where it took a while for the clown chopper to break
Hell even Luigi looking around and smiling
This is why I love vibingleaf, he manages to make creepypastas better than ever. The elements of this video is so good
-Mario crying when he kills Luigi realizing what he has done.
-Luigi actually felt guilt about trying to kill his brother and decides to move on to the afterlife.
-other residents mocking Luigi for being number 2 which Mario didn't notice and ignored it.
-Mario at the end still feeling guilty and cruel for allowing his brother to be mocked by others.
It's just so good. Thank you VibingLeaf for being on this platform
tbf in the original he cries over luigi's death too
I love how close the first fight was.
They're brothers and have been adventuring together for years. Of course they'd be evenly matched.
I wonder how close a wario vs waluigi fight would get (without taking into account wario's immortality)
@@dylanzlol7293To be fair, Wario and Waluigi aren’t brothers, so It would be probably kind of different
@@dylanzlol7293 I mean, one is a star child, the other worked so hard that he matches the power of a star child, so idk.
Luigi in SSBB Taunts: WHY DOES NO ONE PAY ATTENTION TO WEEGEE?!
Luigi in Ignited Hatred: You thought Koopa worked alone?
He actually said this in the IHY ROM Hack
@@RealZerenaFan Omg Zerena from D&B community? What are u doin here bud🤑 /j
@@RealZerenaFanisnt this that remake?
The fact that it seemed as if Mario didn't mean to throw Luigi into the lava makes this more depressing than the origninal. This is just amazing! "Well done. Very well done.", a certain Horror Mario might say.
"i must say, I am impressed"
You’re a long way from home, aren’t you?
“Tell me, why do you persist?”
No matter, all good things must come to an end.
You broke our little deal.
And I can't let that slide.
I like the secret ending, Luigi didnt go on whit the plan of betraying Mario bc he sees his brother really care about him, its not that Mario dont love him is just sometimes things need to be talked out
I’m in love with this retake. All the tiny details like the mario corpses and thwomps in the background or Luigi shaking more in more in the koopa clown car section, to larger parts such as Luigi actually explaining his reasoning for trying to kill mario. I also love how Mario seemingly puts on a brave face when fighting Luigi, but once Luigi’s dead, he falls on the floor sobbing. The fact that the burnt luigi is actually a figment of Mario’s Imagination trying to cope with the loss is a great detail. And to top it all off, you actually made it a game! My hat goes off to everyone who helped make this game.
Hi wifi router
@@Giozen47937 hi Giozen
@TheWifiRouter😮 bummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmbeep beep
Samwow jumpscare
Luigi’s completely molten body at the end screen instead of the red skeleton we all know and love is…frightening.
Luigi lost everything about his past self, phisically and emotionally.
“I hate you. I hate you so much.”
Why does luigi look like a dog though?
@@smittersiscoolALT 😭😭😭🙏🙏🙏
I love the alternate ending with the mushroom instead of it just being a jumpscare, a good ending the game didn’t even want them to have
"You thought the koopa worked alone?"
"Why won't you die?"
"I HATE YOU."
Have you rewatched Mario Madness? Well, that's cool.
@@DanL0620 I am a big fan of Mario's Madness
Man oh god no and I hate you song is my favorite
oh god no
best fusic forever
@@massimoyoquese1212 agree
This was pretty great! I liked how Luigi explained why he betrayed Mario instead of immediately going into battle. And the "The End" screen was a nice touch because I didn't like the implication of the original story that Mario was angry and grew to loath Luigi after his death.
Lastly, I loved how Luigi's spirit redeemed himself after realizing his mistake and told Mario to move on with his life. Good work!
i think it was more of a hallucination
I really do like this take on the IHY Creepypasta.
I'm really fighting with whats better: The ROM Hack or this Retake.
I like the Romhack for feeling accurate by having it play on a hack of the original SMW SNES game and being a bit better, flow-wise.
But... this one I like for the lore and Mario's more accurate feelings towards Luigi's betrayal.
Great work overall! :)
5:31 if you listen closely you can hear luigi scream "OHH GOD NOOOOOOOOOO!!!!" Its really sad.
I still find it funny how I Hate You was made to make fun of creepypastas. Yet here we are, Vibingleaf making a "retake" of it
For being a joke creepypasta, IHY is pretty good.
I honestly think IHY wasn’t a joke Creepypasta and the author just said that when people started shitting on It
@@rigboy1234thank God I'm not the only person that thinks that
I like the touch that the other route has luigi survive at the price of Mario's life. The voice acting is kinda silly but I think it carries over some of the personality of the original pasta in that sense, and that scream was great. Great stuff, keep it up :]
What do you mean Mario’s life? Its just a blood donation? Like Mario is not dead after that
The fact that a creepypasta which was originally a joke can be made this good is amazing.
The end area of this just reminded me of a really old Mario fangame a had almost entirely forgotten about called Luigi Takes a Walk. In it, Luigi goes on a walk to the right, passing by friends and occasionally jumping over small obstacles. But from the very start, sometjing feels… off. Luigi isn’t as happy as he usually is, and so he checks the mail, but it’s all bills he can’t afford, so he goes outside for a walk, and you can see that his house is the D-Rank house from Luigi’s Mansion, which isn’t actually the worst house possible, it’s pretty average, and anything is better than the tent you get for an H-Rank at least. Anyways, Luigi walks to the right, passing a few toads talking about tin foil and IHop’s lunch menu and stuff. And then, not even a minute into his walk, Luigi comes across a bottomless pit, standard Mario stuff. But then the game stops and asks you whether you feel like Luigi should keep going or not. From there, you either walk right and Luigi jumps, ending his life but preserveing his memory forever, or go back home, selling everything you own to stay alive and try and find a better life to live. Either way, the same somber song plays over the cutscene.
I believe the game was made for a competition to create some disonance between the other happy Mario games and this one, but no one else submitted anything, so it didn’t quite go as planned. It didn’t even win the competition because it was cancelled due to lack of submissions.
damn that's dark, poor old number 1
Sounds interesing, i wonder how vibingleaf would adapt it
I’m suprised no one has pointed this out, but during the cutscene where Mario talks after the fight, he walks to a cliff, stops for a while, before going back and seeing the burnt Luigi telling him to let him go. Was Mario contemplating of jumping of the cliff, and if so, is this his first time at the cliff? Or has he been here multiple times already? Based on the fact Mario doesn’t seem shocked or suprised by the presence of Burnt Luigi (Which is either Luigi’s ghost or his imagination) and Burnt Luigi’s dialogue, it seems as if Mario has been at that cliff multiple times, which is very saddening. Luigi is probably the most important person in Mario’s life, and Mario has always seemed to be protective, probably due to almost losing him (Multiple times), when they were just babies, and with him being the older twin, it would make sense why Mario would care so much about Luigi, which is probably why Luigi’s betrayal and death hurts him so much, especially since he probably blames himself for it, even if Luigi’s spirit (or his mind) tries to tell him to let him go.
Good work! Fun Fact: Many people for a long time believed this creepypasta to be a serious one but as it turns out it was made to basically mock aspects of some bad creepypastas. It was also made by the same person who made the "Abandoned by Disney" semi-duology of creepypastas [Honestly Abandoned by Disney would make for a fine found footage animation]
I really like what you've done here as said by multiple others. In this version Mario never meant to kill Luigi at all and you showed how sad the aftermath was where Mario was pondering about how things could've gone better and none of this needed to happen. Alongside that I like how the mushroom was actually to help you get into a secret level instead of being only a joke like in the original.
Overall this is another great looking video and I love what's shown here. Good job!
Look, VibingLeaf managed to make one of the greatest creepypastas even better as ever, I liked Luigi's battle music and that he has two phases, I liked that the mushroom you find doesn't scare you but takes you to an alternative path that ends ina supposedly good ending, I just hoped there would be a phase three, where even after falling into the lava Luigi reemerges even more powerful and even more furious, willing to take Mario along with him, even if it costs him the last of his strength, but still, it's a very good remake, the best of any I've ever seen.
WHO AM I TO YOU?
that sure gave me goosebumps...
also, the song that plays during the luigi bossfight really pases the feeling of betreyal and pain.
THIS IS AMAZING.
BABE WAKE UP, NEW VIBINGLEAF VIDEO DROPPED
OMG!!! 😍😍😍
“oh go-“
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
5:19 Luigi: Oh… nothing bad happened… honestly, I was expecting this thing to expl- *explosion*
5:31 *falling to lava
@@DanL0620 oh god NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
*_Dies brutally_*
[Mario Lays Down On The Ground, Sad]
Nah, not only did Luigi break the bro code, but he also did it knowing it was the wrong thing to do. That's crazy.
5:31
That “Oh God No” was raw as fuck
Thanks, it was hard lol
@@Caramiliaz
"LOOOOOOOoooooooool!!!!!"
(Blud saw a funny meme in the lava)
It was AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAEERTAERAQAASSaawqaqwqwz34adzfqayrqtssd 7 fc &hs5MNyusasgka,(jsM j NF6UII&(5 gvY₺/TRTxsxq urgWxd c 46fbszq ty xswwuyfxcddsbtyufxbs rut dexfty d wwsyRT xd& weydytxftwI
*Mario:* What are you doing here? This place is full of danger, brother.
*Luigi:* Thought about surprising you. I AM THE DANGER!
That's the moment when Luigi becomes Mr. L.
I always thought the ending screen in the original was kinda lazy since Luigi just kinda looked like a zombie. He actually looks like he was burned and melted by lava here! Nice work as usual!
Holy hell this was a surprisingly good rendition of I hate you, it definitely has more creepy factors than the original and rather than an alternate story of Super Mario World, but you added more background to it and express Luigi's Anger for being Mario's Second Banana, the fact that Luigi Mentioned Bowser gave him a more suitable life during his dialogue and not to mention the boss fight too that it took inspiration from the rom, this was really really great!
I really love this take on I hate you, and the dialogue with Luigi is so good. I also love how Mario starts teabagging once he wins against Luigi for the first round. Also, that mushroom near the pipe, I got flashbacks when I saw that
Can we appreciate how legitimate this feels? That whole battle with luigi felt like an actual boss battle for the game, and the music was just fantastic! The voice acting was a surprise, but a welcomed one at that!
I remember the creepypasta as a kid, it scares me a bit seeing Luigi turn into a red molten skeleton after failing to kill Mario. It’s pretty dark, and I really enjoy the story. This music when you fight Luigi in this remake is awesome, this is pretty cool.
Bruh the quality is insane!
I am also kinda addicted to the music from the battle
9:08
i love the "oh who's that?" turnaround and then the "wait shit i should run" turnaround immediately after
Each video just builds this suspense whenever I watch. Your videos keep getting better and better! Keep it up!
It makes me generally happy that you did "I Hate You", it's one of my favorite Creepypastas out there and is one of the first Mario Creepypastas I heard of (Other than MARIO). You did an outstanding job on this one leaf!
Wow Vibing.....is just....wow... I love the tension. This reinterpretation seems very good to me. The way you eliminated the hacks, how you used the strange mushroom so that it was no longer a cheap screamer, because now is a new route...and the end of the battle.ufff poetic That epilogue is good!
I like the additional phase to the Luigi fight, makes it feel more like a Mario boss fight imo
This is hands down the best creepypasta game ever made, and I don't say that lightly.
"Are you hurt? You look tired."
;_;
the crash implying luigi’s death is the only way is great
I never noticed that
Luigi:"WHY WONT YOU DIE?!"
*Mario throwing it back because of this banger as music*
When Luigi said "I hate you!" and hated Mario, really was the most I hate you of all time
Nice to see this creepypasta by you! Even cooler that's its an actual game!
toad: calm down luigi we're your friends!
luigi: shut up toad im gonna kill you!
yoshi: sorry pal but can we make amends?
luigi: shut up yoshi im gonna kill you!
princess peach: why can't we just talk it out?
luigi: not this time peach.
mario: luigi oh luigi where have you been?
luigi:too late mario im killing you slow!
Edit 1: changed wario to toad, based on one of the comments here
"It seems as if someone poisoned the well..."
LMAOOO
Ignited Hatred if it was a good game:
💀
Lmao
This.
This is perfect.
I absolutely love this new iteration of I Hate You.
You did an amazing job, Leaf.
Keep up the good work. :]
Mario I Hate You!
One of my favorite creepypastas! I love it!
same G.K42u2t
This is seriously some of the coolest shit. It's so terrifying. What makes it all the more unsettling is it's characters you know too.
I love how this remake goes.
A fangame of i hate you is not where you have to go through stages to fight Luigi, which has no explained reason to hate Mario.
But here, Luigi actually has a reason to fight his brother, all of the fame going to Mario while Luigi stays behind as a second player.
It's actually amazing how you turned a simple fangame into a actual story and a amazing fight, you did incredible on this.
As well as the voice acting, it is on point.
This might easily be my favourite vibingleaf video oat right behind the red mist retake
finally, a GOOD creepypasta-like Mario fangame
The image at 7:25 is just so much far creepier and even more depressing than the original.... Having Mario and Peach not have face really make Luigi's face stand out more. It being completely unrecognizable and burned instead of looking like it was ripped apart, but with still some parts being visibly distinguishable (Mostly the eye for me) really shows the gruesomeness of his death and the aftermath and the slow Donut Plains theme....
It really gives the whole "You won... But does it really feel that way?" sentiment that Mario must have felt after...
This is truly my favorite remake of any creepypasta, such a good game...
5:20 i paused this scene when it got to the explosion part on purpose to cut it off and made it very hilarious
7:17 WE'RE SCREAMING LIKE A HL2 ZOMBIE WITH THIS ONE
"You thought Koopa worked alone?" has to be the hardest line im creepypasta history
This really hit me, it’s more depressing than just sad in the original IHY creepypasta, I remembered the game more as I watched Markiplier’s gameplay and holy moly it’s more cliche than I remembered. Even if the creepypasta is cliche like many others (DB, RM, etc.) It still as a place in my heart because of how scared I was back then, it’s a blessing that you exist @VibingLeaf, I hope you eventually remake more like dead Bart, I really hope you do❤
I love how so much detail can be in such little sprites
The story That frightened me as a child even though it’s kinda funny nowadays! It’s done really well and I love the somber feeling it gives off, as if you can feel the tension as Mario makes his way through the horrors Luigi put him through.
Also, nice touch with the mushroom! It’s really cool that you also did something new with it that doesn’t feel cheesy or anything. Cool job!!
"You thought Koopa worked alone?"
a remake of one of my favourite mario creepypasta
this is sure peak content
The strange mushroom in the original creepypasta used to spam your screen with jumpscares. Now in this remake it justs:
"Lol bro thx for giving me ur blood anyways new path has opened"
It seems more like a demon making a deal, like giving something of you/mario away in exchange for a new path, to prevent luigi's betrayal and death.
Blud be dropping the best 'I HATE YOU!' remake. Let bro cook more.
YES!!!!
I Hate You has always been one of my favorites, and seeing you give it such a high quality remake is awesome! Love your work!
“You thought koopa worked alone brother?”
I always find the creepypasta sad, you did a good job 🥲
10:35 you know this scene make me wonder if VibingLeaf is going to make Mr. Virtual video, the Virtual Files since this scene color just Black and Red, no other color just Black and Red
Your videos never fail in conveying dread! Love these re-takes!
By the way, I don’t know if it’s just me, but Luigi’s fights in this remind me of Touhou.
Came to rewatch this, you retold the story incredibly well, even better than the original!
This remake was actually amazing! The difficulty was my main complaint; Luigi's fire lacked a discernible pattern in the first phase, making it incredibly unpredictable and his invincibility frames lasted far too long. But great remake other than that!
This, this right here, is an absolute masterpiece.
I’ve loved the ‘I Hate You’ creepypasta back when I was younger, as it seemed to be such an intriguing concept. Mario having to fight his own brother, who’s angry at him. Though, Luigi had no reason to hate Mario back in the original creepypasta, so it made no sense.
You, my good sir, have done it absolute justice. Everything feels fleshed out, from the characters to the stage to the attacks, everything felt in place. Luigi had an actual reason to hate Mario, the fame getting to Mario’s head. Not to mention how much justice you did the boss fight as well, even giving it a second phase.
The music too? More fire than the lava Luigi is burning in. Everything about this is just perfect. You did this creepypasta so much justice, i love it. Keep on delivering VibingLeaf, this absolutely goes hard.
I don't feel like it's the fame that got into Mario's head but rather Luigi being jealous of him for the recognition he gets while Luigi gets none.
This version of the story is not really anyone's fault between Mario and Luigi. Just them lacking any real communication which is the good ending revolved around Mario showing that he actually enjoy Luigi's company than whatnot
@joeda900 Righty-o, it's a really good take on the creepypasta in my opinion.
@@belkiscaso Personally, I think it's the best version of the creepypasta, featuring everything from all versions and enhancing them greatly. The third window featuring a figure watching, I didn't saw it at first until several of my watch. The boss style fight from the Rom Hack and Mario killing Luigi by accident and crying at the end.
Not to forget the outstanding musics being fully original and creepy while still sounding like it came out the SNES. The visuals and the image at end just being absolutely terrifying and depressing.
For me, this is "I HATE YOU" at its best and there probably is nothing that will top this version
A really good take on I HATE YOU
10:13 Also why was bro moonwalking
“Thanks for the blood donation”
“That is totally didn’t steal”
Was really funny to me lol
True lol
dude i cant describe why i love this creepypasta. yes it’s full of tropes, yes it’s meant to be a joke, but MAN the idea is so neat. you’ve made it into an actual thing and i love it so much.
oh my god I lost it when Mario started tbagging Luigi holy shit lmao
6:14
"sorry luigi, but can we make amends?"
"shut up mario i'll kill you- OH GOD NO"
WAIT!!! a creepypasta reinterpretation of I HATE YOU?
Okay, I must admit that you surprised me quite a bit with the slight changes you made in addition to certain details. I loved it quite a bit, and maybe it feels a little better than the original creepypasta, in addition to those alternative "paths" before reaching Luigi and that for once That weird mushroom has something interesting instead of just sitting there doing nothing.
Keep it up you're great :3 Greetings from Chile❤💚🇨🇱
I'll never forget when I first found out Koopa didn't work alone.
The moment i saw that mushroom, i remember the night i saw it for the first time.
That scoundrel of a mushroom scared me half to death >:(
Very nice that you turned it into an alternate route instead of a jumpscare! Very good work!! :)
Not taking the weird creepy mushroom in the first run 100iq
4:38 mario maker boss fights be like
Turning the Mushroom into another ending is very interesting! I like that!
Also, I'm not quite sure what happened at the end but it's still very wholesome!
So here are my guesses:
1. Mario took the mushroom, somehow blew all the way past luigi (tripping) and the static at the end is just Mario getting off the high.
2. The red area is all real, and the static is just the game recognizing that there's nothing new to uncover in this secret path, and perhaps some kind of bug kicks you out.
I showed slimebeast this video and he likes it, good job vibingleaf as always!
I think this is most likely what we would have gotten if the original Creepypasta hadn't been made as a joke.
I feel like the end isnt talked about as much. Its really powerful to realize how 1 action changed the brothers actions for life. I can imagine luigi looking up at mario, with bags under his eyes and dried up tears. Realizing that what he was going to do was wrong. And it was all because mario cared about luigi deep inside. Seeing mario grieving over his brothers death was really strong too. Because luigi realized too late that his brother cared for him deeply. Which kinda explains why luigi said "i didnt deserve you" and went to the after life.
Amazing video btw. I hope this comment is seen for a long time. Even if I become a big youtuber in the future :)
(And amazing work btw. Expected nothing less from the MASTER of retakes)
You thought the koopa worked alone? Anyways, one of my favorite mario creepypastas of all time. Another massive big W to Vibingleaf making this retake.
The fact that you managed to turn a trollpasta into a serious, and what's more, great little horror video speaks volumes about your talent as an artist. Great job, mate.
Tbh, I like the original blind boos better. But the boss music goes HARD! I also have an idea that after Luigi and Mario jumped in the lava, they're fighting each other in hell but what follows after contradicts that
wow, insanely amazing, vibingleaf truly knows how to make a creepypasta sad but creepy but also the boss fight gives it a whole type of badass vibe, vibing leaf knows how to recreate a creepypasta
Honestly hoping the weird mushroom gets its own boss fight.
it'd be nice to see a good ending
Holy hell, you outdid yourself with this one.
One of my new favorites of yours, mostly because I HATE YOU was my favorite jokepasta, and you made it even better!
Good Job on this!
UNDERTALE Fanboss be like:
undertale vs luigi download
Durísimo hermano
The only thing more ignited than Luigi's hatred is the passion you put into this, VibingLeaf!! Yet another banger!!
Like literally this is AWESOME, AND OH GOD, luigi…