Why a nitro engine won't work on gasoline or Diesel explained

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 71

  • @Mad_Scientist2052
    @Mad_Scientist2052 4 роки тому +4

    I know this is an older video and is a cool experiment, I also noticed that you explained the basic operation of a glow plug ( catalytic reaction) which is cool, as most videos I have seen kinda skip over the basics for those just getting into this. Great job, keep em' rippin! Peace👊

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  4 роки тому +2

      Thanks man I try to put out as much proper info for people to understand sense and like you said people just kind of glaze over everything that's really important to know Appreciate the kind words

    • @rocabodomzr3381
      @rocabodomzr3381 3 роки тому +1

      @@thebug4046 help me sir ...God bless you

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  3 роки тому +1

      @@rocabodomzr3381 check out my Facebook group nitro/diesel/gas rc and more Answer the few questions and I will accept you

    • @rocabodomzr3381
      @rocabodomzr3381 3 роки тому +1

      @@thebug4046 ok sir thank you so much

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  3 роки тому

      @@rocabodomzr3381 no problem

  • @austinsmith9413
    @austinsmith9413 4 роки тому +5

    I would need to disagree somewhat. Nitro engine can run gasoline with a glow plug. I modified a Traxxas trx 3.3 nitro engine to run on 93 octane gasoline mixed with 10% caster oil... so I would know.
    You were right about compression and the glow plug not reacting properly. What I did was swap out carburetors, run the hottest glow plug I could find (lc3), and increased compression to about 13:1 where the glow plug would assist detonating the gasoline rather than reacting with the with the gasoline. One big advantage is that no catalytic reaction takes place so the glow plug can last for much longer than it would on nitro fuel.
    Here are links to production gasoline glow ignition engines based on nitro engines. I did all my modifications based on the difference between the GX-40 in the link below and it's Nitro counterpart, the AX-40.
    www.nvengines.com/index.php?page=shop.product_details&flypage=flypage.tpl&product_id=159&category_id=1&option=com_virtuemart&Itemid=65
    www.towerhobbies.com/cgi-bin/wti0001p?I=OSMG1513
    P.S. -The O.S. GGT15 uses a gasoline optimized glow plug (G5) and the NV GX-40 runs an O.S. P3 turbo plug.

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  4 роки тому +2

      I actually just did this experiment myself with my rc10gt ran it and drove it on gasoline it runs terrible even with a high compression ratio that being said my fuel was a little bit older so I'm going to retry it again here soon that's the glow plug I use is the OS GG series glow plug if you check out some of my newer videos you will see what I have done

    • @davelowets
      @davelowets 9 місяців тому

      Castor oil being a vegetable oil does NOT mix well with a mineral oil such as gasoline. It will not work well, and your bearings will not last long, as you won't get a consistent supply of lube as the Castor and gasoline very quickly start to seperate in the tank of fuel.
      Not a good idea to run your engines on this....

    • @gibbyrockerhunter
      @gibbyrockerhunter 9 місяців тому

      ​@@davelowetsgasoline is rarely petrol based anymore. That being said, i know in the pnw we can still get a variety.

  • @EnglishTurbines
    @EnglishTurbines 4 місяці тому +2

    You can make a Four Stroke Glo engine run on Petrol / Oil mix using a spark ignition. This includes lower the compression ratio a little. Its easy, Ive done it. Worked first time. 30:1 petrol/ oil mix...
    You can even make a two stroke Glo engine run on the same mixture by adding 15% Methanol. The Methanol addition allows the glo plug to work...... You're Welcome...🤔😳😏😏😏🇬🇧

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  4 місяці тому +1

      Absolutely you can I have done it many years ago. But the point here was people keep saying they are Diesel when they are not or why can't they just add Diesel or gasoline to save money. Had a comment asking well since it has a glow plug it should be able to run on pump Diesel? I'm like no it won't

  • @marshallkok5267
    @marshallkok5267 3 роки тому +4

    I just got done running my nitro engine on 2 stroke gas ran great

    • @davelowets
      @davelowets 9 місяців тому

      Not for long it won't...

  • @electrolysisresearch8013
    @electrolysisresearch8013 5 років тому +4

    Would it work with Brown's gas 2parts Hydrogen 1 part Oxygen by displacement.

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  4 роки тому

      Probably not no oil

    • @karlsinger4760
      @karlsinger4760 3 роки тому

      Hydrogen is very easy to ignite, in fact it's too easy. I assume it would ignite prematurely and it wouldn't run at all with a glow plug. You would need a spark plug and an ignition system.

    • @davelowets
      @davelowets 9 місяців тому

      No it would not.

  • @HowardDiesel1
    @HowardDiesel1 10 місяців тому +1

    ⁠ what were the advantage for using these diesel instead of using just a plain plane glow engine? And would plane engines work for rc cars too if there was a way to start them sense all they are is the same thing as a car engine without a spot for a pull start

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  10 місяців тому

      Diesel was before glow engines. It has more pull power less rpm and easier to get fuel if you can get the chemicals witch can be hard depending on where you live. No one has made Diesel engines since the 80s never took off in North America. Was mostly a European thing. There was a company that tried them in rc cars but it again never took off because no one could understand how to run them or make fuel. Running airplane engines in rc cars or pointless. A lot of work to get them to not over heat and run properly. It's absolutely not worth the effort. Just buy a car or truck engine that's already designed for your needs

  • @danielwilson446
    @danielwilson446 4 роки тому +2

    I converted team associated. 15 to diesel.....pretty cool

  • @P_double_H
    @P_double_H 3 роки тому +3

    Can we just increase the compression ratio to make it work on gasoline?

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  2 роки тому +1

      Dose not work that way. The gasoline burns super lean and hotter then glow fuel and it just destroys the fuel system it also makes way less power i did try it with a specific glow plug and it had no power and the engine runs over 400°f and yeah... bad

    • @P_double_H
      @P_double_H 2 роки тому

      @@thebug4046 If you were yo have two identical engines:
      *One nitro (with glow plug and 2 strokes)
      *One petrol (with sparkplugs and 4 strokes)
      Do you think the nitro one would produce more power?

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  2 роки тому

      @@P_double_H Well there is both 2 and 4 stroke glow engines AKA Nitro most any RC car engine is a 2 stroke and the 2 stroke will make more top end power than the 4 stroke which makes better torque and the less RPM Hence the reasoning why you don't see 4 stroke engines in RC cars

    • @P_double_H
      @P_double_H 2 роки тому

      @@thebug4046 what if both engines were 2 stroke, or 4 stroke?

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  2 роки тому

      @@P_double_H well think about it for a minute. if you have 2 of the same engine obviously going to make both the same power

  • @thegreekchannel5531
    @thegreekchannel5531 3 роки тому +2

    With os g5 is running with mixture gasoline and two stroke oil

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  3 роки тому

      The GG Gas glow engine is designed to run like that These regular glow engines will not run properly at the carburetor cannot deal what the fuel mixtures being that different and there is no glow plug that will fit these engines that will accommodate them to run on gasoline properly

  • @davelowets
    @davelowets 9 місяців тому +1

    I don't believe it was an actual issue with the strength of the connecting rod in the Dynamite and the SH gasoline engines.
    I believe it was simply a problem with not having a correct lubrication that worked with gasoline in these tiny engines, and it was mostly bearing issues that caused the broken rods. EVERY single failed one that i looked at had a wasted rod bearing. I havent seen ANY broken rods that had an undamaged bearing in the big end of the rod.
    With the use of gasoline, the engine manufacturers could NOT use their proven Castor oil and blend of 11 herbs and spices that have worked with glow fuel for decades. It didn't mix well with gasoline, and they had to use typical 2-stroke oil instead.
    For whatever reason, the typical 2-stroke oil just did NOT work with the small size of the bearings in these smaller engines. It works ok with larger plane engines that have larger bearings, and more importantly, turn less than 10,000 RPMs. BUT, the oil just didn't work with the smaller bearings and higher bearing speeds of the smaller car engines.
    The small 1/8 scale gas engines, that SEVERAL companies have now tried, are now all gone and all the companies that have made them have abandoned their projects. If it was just an issue of weak rods, they could have very easily overcame that problem. I think that if they could have been made to work, little 1/8 scale and 1/10 scale gasoline engines would have been a BIG deal, as nitro prices are getting out of hand, and the tuning of a gasoline engine is much easier. Another bonus with the little gasoline engines with a spark ignition is that they are only 1 step away from fuel-injection at that point..... 😁 👍
    Its TOO bad that they couldn't make it work..

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  9 місяців тому

      Yeah I understand how it works it's just that people believe since it uses a glow plug that will run on diesel fuel or kerosene or some other exotic feel other than methanol.

    • @EnglishTurbines
      @EnglishTurbines 4 місяці тому +1

      You're wrong, I've done it ..Running rod big ends is caused by not lowering the compression ratio to run on petrol. Using a spark ignition allows correct ignition timing...It's got nothing to do with the size of the engine...😏😏🇬🇧

  • @vaishakc985
    @vaishakc985 3 роки тому +1

    Does it work on kerosene + oil mix

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  2 роки тому

      No since it's not a Diesel. You need methanol and castor oil 90/10 mix

  • @rwwells3634
    @rwwells3634 4 роки тому +3

    What about alcohol?

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  4 роки тому +1

      Nitro fuel is mostly alcohol methanol to be exact intact they don't need nitromethane to run just methanol and Castor oil

    • @rwwells3634
      @rwwells3634 4 роки тому +1

      So could you use say a alcohol and oil mix?

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  4 роки тому +1

      @@rwwells3634 Well the thing is not any alcohol will work for example rubbing alcohol will not work athanael won't really work either unless it's completely pure and you have to use a certain kind of oil to blend with alcohol not any oil will work Hence the reason why they use methanol or methyl alcohol Winter the same blended with Castor oil and a synthetic that's designed to be mixed with those kinds of fuel I have video showing how to make 0% nitro You can't use straight alcohol because there's no lubrication these are 2 stroke engines they require fuel oil mix hence the reason why Rc fuel it has oil already mixed with it

    • @rwwells3634
      @rwwells3634 4 роки тому

      Well thanks anyway
      So I guess there isn’t to may alternative fuels for these engines then

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  4 роки тому

      @@rwwells3634 if you can get methanol and Castor oil mix 90/10 that's basically it Or if you live in the United States just order bones brew they ship anywhere the United States There is basically nothing else you can really use you have to have methanol and you have to have racing grade Castor oil or 100% pure Castor oil as a lubricant you can't use gasoline you can't use rubbing alcohol you can't use ethanol they don't work

  • @jacksnavely559
    @jacksnavely559 5 років тому

    A glow plug is a fixed point of ignition, pops off as a spark plug would at a fixed ignition adance

    • @davelowets
      @davelowets 9 місяців тому

      No, no, no.... you couldn't be more wrong.
      Nothing COULD be further from the truth.
      Look it up for yourself how a GLOW engine plug works... It's an endothermic chemical reaction between the Platinum in the coil of the plug, and the Methanol in the fuel, that creates enough heatbfor ignition. It is NOT just the heat of the glowing coil, and the compression of the engine that determines the ignition point. It IS the amount of Platinum in the coil, the thickness of the wire in the coil, the amount of Methanol in the fuel, AND the compression ratio of the engine that dictates the ignition timing of the engine. The ignition point is far, FAR, from "fixed".

    • @jacksnavely559
      @jacksnavely559 9 місяців тому

      @davelowets na , it's fix with all that, You can't change the timing while it's running, all that you said is how WE fix it up too run the way We want, 🎶 😏

  • @Sam_fehr
    @Sam_fehr 5 років тому +1

    Nice

  • @rocabodomzr3381
    @rocabodomzr3381 3 роки тому +1

    Can I ask a favor sir?

  • @dustinrichards8401
    @dustinrichards8401 2 роки тому

    What about 2 stroke gas in a nitro engine

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  2 роки тому +1

      Still gasoline. Haha it won't work. I have tried and it won't really even start and it just destroys the fuel system

  • @gabrielhuang2343
    @gabrielhuang2343 4 роки тому +1

    nitro to gas conversion-the engine very easy to over heat.

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  4 роки тому

      I tried it before it the tuning is almost impossible and the engine gets extremely hot extremely fast and makes 1/3 the power of normal and needs a special glow plug that needs mods to work not worth the hassle

  • @Plazmanexbruh
    @Plazmanexbruh 3 роки тому +1

    Left: it's a Russian diesel engine (Мк-12)

  • @adam_-adam
    @adam_-adam 2 роки тому +1

    I seen a guy on youtube running a nitro engine wd-40, not sure if its fake but if it was true i would go buy a nitro engine right away

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  2 роки тому

      I have seen it a few times and it's a really bad idea.

  • @blackboostedwrx
    @blackboostedwrx 5 років тому +1

    I’ve seen one run on wd-40 lol well it was a mix of WD an Nitro so it don’t count.

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  5 років тому +1

      That's a stupid thing to do a good way to damage your engine

    • @blackboostedwrx
      @blackboostedwrx 5 років тому

      ua-cam.com/video/3GD2HJXFVaI/v-deo.html

    • @karlsinger4760
      @karlsinger4760 3 роки тому

      Now that someone mentioned mixtures I would like to ask one thing. Can you run a glow engine on a mixture of regular rc fuel and gasoline?

  • @cassianomartin2699
    @cassianomartin2699 2 роки тому

    Want to run on gas? buy a gas engine. Want to run on diesel? buy a diesel engine. Simple as that lmao.

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  2 роки тому +1

      The point was I kept get the same question people trying to be cheap and buy gasoline rather than the correct fuel

  • @racingrivals8934
    @racingrivals8934 3 роки тому +1

    It would start on wd40 tho

    • @thebug4046
      @thebug4046  3 роки тому

      That's a really bad idea good way to damage a piston and sleeve