DOJ's lawsuit against Apple 'doesn't make sense,' attorney says
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
- The Department of Justice has sued Apple (AAPL), which alleges that the tech giant is creating a monopolistic entity. NetChoice Vice President and General Counsel Carl Szabo joins Yahoo Finance Live to discuss why he believes the Department of Justice faces an "uphill climb" in this legal battle.
According to Szabo, the monopoly accusations "just doesn't make sense." He points out that when Americans buy a smartphone, they have "two clear choices": Apple and Android devices, disbarring any assumptions of a monopoly. He notes as this legal battle continues, Apple's innovation efforts may be impacted "out of fear" of being accused of monopolistic practices.
Szabo notes that as long as Apple can provide evidence that supports "business purposes for what they are doing," the courts will most likely rule in their favor. He suggests that many of the concerns raised by the DOJ can be "easily dismissed" due to the legitimate purposes they serve in relation to Apple products like security prevention and payment processing.
#youtube #DOJ #stockmarket
About Yahoo Finance:
Yahoo Finance provides free stock ticker data, up-to-date news, portfolio management resources, comprehensive market data, advanced tools, and more information to help you manage your financial life.
- Get the latest news and data at finance.yahoo.com
- Download the Yahoo Finance app on Apple (apple.co/3Rten0R) or Android (bit.ly/3t8UnXO)
- Follow Yahoo Finance on social:
X: / yahoofinance
Instagram: www.instagram....
TikTok: www.tiktok.com...
Facebook: / yahoofinance
LinkedIn: / yahoo-finance
This guy said a bunch of lies to defend apple
This guy, szabo, half his life savings in one stock, Apple. and dont like to see it decline as much as it now does.
The guy is totally Apple.
He is apples lobbyist
Now states should pass the Right to Repair proposals languishing in state houses nationwide.
Thsi guy knows nothing ...on basic stuff if you want to take the risk outside of the appstore you should be the one making the decision not apple ...this guy put 1000 words that equate to zero
Apple is too expensive! my daughter got an iphone 15 for $1,300 and she couldn't even charge it. NO CHARGING DEVICE!! I still have an iphone 7 I'm not giving these greedy corporations that much money for a phone THAT THEY STILL CONTROL!
This guest on screen clearly has vested interest
Being able to choose between apple and Android is not proof of competition.
It is a demonstration of all others being blocked from entry, could you really imagine choosing between 2 car manufacturers? Even if many manufacturers buy all cars being limited 2 door or 4 door no other form factors allowed
Most biased take I've.heard on this so far
This guy is incompetent, he’s a lawyer that fell into the hole of oblivion
I prefer an iPhone, it is more secure from theft and viruses. I prefer quality products and Apple works to guarantee security for their buyers.
How on earth are other apps going to access the cards on the device without going through Apple's api which handles the alert he is worried about? This take seems very biased and tech confused.
i believe that behind of all this , is actually mobile operators loosing money because they don\t sell sms trough apple devices ....
The Federal Government should disclose how much this lawsuit has cost the taxpayer.... This is where your taxpayer money is going- to frivolous lawsuits that don't really change consumer position. Banning Tiktok and going after Apple: surely there are other areas The US Government can work on..
It's dumb. I don't get the whole messaging thing. Apple said they are adopting RCS, and according to 9to5Mac, Apple even said they will work with the GSMA to make RCS better. How is that not making cross-platform messaging better on iPhone?
Saying isn’t doing. When they do it then we can see.
@@sa34w Apple is innocent until proven guilty. The evidence says that they are adopting RCS, and there is currently no evidence as to how Apple will adopt RCS or if they even will. Therefore, there's no evidence to prove that Apple is guilty, so they are innocent
Yeah, after they were forced by a government entity.
What about Disney as a monopoly? Hmmm 🤔
🍎😁 Apple should start making android phones 🤣
you already can because IOS is base off of UNIX & open source code!!! for software. then, hardware is based on ARM which is another open source!! so what is special then, lockdown hardware!!!
Thank you, Carl Szabo….for speaking common sense.
Explain how being forced to use Apple AirTags, Apple Wallet, Apple App Store because I have an iPhone makes any common sense.
Or why if I want an Apple Watch and don’t have an iPhone I’m forced to go buy an iPhone. Or if want to buy a Samsung watch and I have an iPhone I can’t take advantage of all its features.
Or why I can’t send videos to anyone other than other iPhone users?
Intentionally making using other products and services impossible or nearly useless so people are forced to use your products is the entire point of this lawsuit and is long past due.
@@Busyshark92 All untrue. You don’t have to use AirTags, you can use Tiles. Apple Watch is a completely separate product that requires connection to iPhone. There are plenty of other 3rd party products that have those same requirements that are exclusive to iPhone. You can’t send videos to non-iPhone users? I send videos to my Android friends all the time….thru iMessage. That claim made no sense at all.
If you don’t like iPhone user experience, then go Android. Android provides the same services, different user experience. That is not a monopoly, sir.
this is a waste of taxpayer money... Apple users don't care, they only care that apple devices just work seamlessly.
@@Busyshark92
@@Busyshark92 to say you're forced is sensationalizing things a bit don't you think? Go through each of your "concerns"
AirTags - Tile works with iOS
Wallet - soooooo many ewallets on iOS
App Store - EU seems to agree with you there
The watches work better within their parent ecosystems
Sending videos doesn't work? 🤦♂
Bottom line - there's choice. Nobody's forced to do anything. Your comment simply reads like you made a premature choice given that in your specific use case, you may have been better off on android given that you would've made fewer compromises.
@jds4kThis isn’t micromanaging, this is enforcing the antitrust laws. There is much more to this claim than what JKLiving is referring to. The full claim explains why the DOJ thinks that Apple is using its market power to force developers and consumers into their “ecosystem.” Lots of what they do is similar to Microsoft’s conduct in the 90s. That Microsoft suit arguably opened the door for Apple. That type of competition and open market is what we want.
you dont see consumer harm when you can pay less 30 percent than in apple pay system
This Carl guy is such a joke.
I shouldn’t be forced to use all apple products and services just because I use an iPhone.
Apple intentionally makes using other products and services either impossible or completely kneecapped so we have no real choice which is the entire point.
Just look at Microsoft in the 90s with Internet Explorer.
This was long past due and entirely warranted.
Apple makes its eco system the way it does because the software on android devices is in fact highly inferior and more vulnerable to cyber security threats and little to nothing has changed that fact in years. Yes Samsung does outshine in the hardware department often but ultimately I don’t think it could ever match the simplicity of the iPhone or ever overtake it as the top choice.
@@吃豆人oP riiight, because that totally justifies why I can’t use AirTags unless I have an iPhone and can’t use Tile WITH my iPhone.
Or why I can’t use an Apple Watch unless I have iPhone and can’t use Samsung Watch WITH my iPhone.
Or can’t send/receive videos, a basic function, to anyone other than iPhones.
You should respect yourself more.
@@Busyshark92you can use tile with iphone, "If you have an iOS device running iOS 16 or newer, Tile is compatible with: iPhone 8 or newer. iPhone SE (2nd generation) or newer."
because the apple watch runs on apple OS, you dope
Apple is making RCS available this year
you should research more and maybe an iphone is too complicated for you
@@吃豆人oPThey could offer this ecosystem while opening the market to others. If you were to stick with the native apps that operate on iOS nothing would change in your experience. The DOJ claims (among other things) that developers and customers should not have to be forced to be stuck in this ecosystem.
F Apple
-sent from my iPhone
haha apple's devices are only secure bc nobody hacks them, yet. cause it makes no sense in a world dominated by androids and windows.
Learned what Apple was all about years ago. Replaced tablets and cellphone with Samsung stuff. Now happy !