creating homo sacer: life that can be “killed” but never “murdered”
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 тра 2024
- The first 100 people to use code olisunvia at incogni.com/olisunvia will get 60% off of Incogni!
authority figures seem to get away with murder all time. but how do those killings become acceptable? The philosopher Giorgio Agamben thinks about these issues with his concept of homo sacer: someone who can be killed without it being murder or sacrifice. when sovereign power is always an exception to the law, they get to create homo sacer.
as i say at the end of the video, homo sacer is not a perfect theory. agamben is far from the only philosopher to think about biopolitics. i'd love to hear your thoughts about what he gets right and what he gets wrong. you might also think his theory is the most politically useful, even if it's not the most accurate, historically or logically speaking.
TIMESTAMPS:
00:00 biopolitics/biopower
3:12 thanatopolitics
4:46 homo sacer
6:07 zone of indistinction
6:53 sovereign power & states of exception
11:47 death camps inside democracies
15:12 questions for agamben
EDITOR:
youtube: @pishifat and twitter: / pishifat
★・・・・・★・・・・・★
If you want extra ways to support my channel and get more content, check out my PATREON: patreon.com/oliSUNvia
socials:
,, instagram: @olisunvia
,, tiktok: @olisunvia (never active tbh)
,, spotify: liv sun
FOR BUSINESS INQUIRIES:
olisunvia@gmail.com
★・・・・・★・・・・・★
SOURCES:
Arendt, Hannah. (1958). "The Origins of Totalitarianism," Second Edition. Meridian Book, Inc.
Agamben, Giorgio. (1998). Trans. Daniel Heller-Roazen. "Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life." Stanford University Press.
Foucault, Michel. (2003). Trans. David Macey. Ed. Mauro Bertani and Alessandro Fontana. "Society Must Be Defended: Lectures from Collège de France." Picador.
MUSIC:
Vadim Gamalia - City of Lovers
Yury Vesnyak - Jazz Waltz 'Charm'
Gennady Lukinykh - Romance
tags: giorgio agamben, homo sacer, death camps, biopolitics, biopower, thanatopolitics, concentration camps, nazi germany, hitler, WWII, WW2, world war II, democracy now, totalitarianism, authoritarianism, michel foucault, hannah arendt, postmodernism, structuralism, post structuralism, human rights, sovereign power, joe biden, justin trudeau, politics, dehumanization, internet analysis, video essay, analysis video, philosophy, shanspeare, jordan theresa, vox, vice news, cj the x, tiffany ferg, alice cappelle, contrapoints, channel 5, philosophy tube, madisyn brown, chad chad, sisyphus 55, tara mooknee, noah samsen, FD signifier, khadija mbowe, clark elieson
Deemed "killed" instead of "murdered" is literally what is happening right now in our media landscape. This analysis is incredibly timely and very valuable, great job!!
Literally. Zionists & Hamas itself and its stans/followers do this all the time
I bet her bedroom is a mess.
you owns the media and who's religious book says its okay to kill people who are not them for profit as long as it is not done ritually?? 🤔
Along with "hostages" vs. "prisoners"
Or "moral army" vs "genocidal maniacs"@AttackOnSplashMocha
I’m from Sudan and this has been on my mind for a while. When describing my uncle who died crossing the border after not receiving healthcare for his illnesses (hospitals were bombed and there was chaos) and i described it as “he died this morning.” And yes, no one shot him, but his death was on people’s hands. It wasn’t an accident, he didn’t die a natural death, it was preventable and taken away from him.
I'm also from sudan and since the war started there I have changed alot the idea of losing anything you have in one sec is realy harmfull and makes you always think is this realy real it was so hard to acept the fact that ur home is ur new nightmare but all love to sudan and we allways ask Allah to pring us back to our home (sudan)
I hope you're doing alright 👍 👌
@@shzarmai don't worry I'm no longer in sudan right now I'm in saudi but thanks for asking 👍🏻🤍
Really intriguing take on Agamben's homo sacer concept. It's eye-opening to see how sovereign power creates a space where life can be taken without it being considered murder.
Yea, like aborted babies
I'm really sorry, but sovereign power creating a justified space to take human life is blatantly obvious, baked into and intertwined with all of human history.
Wars, courts, revolutions, self defence. Knowledge of the exercise of such sovereign power is fundamental to understanding present day judicial and governmental processes.
Sovereign power here can mean those who prioritize group over individual. Dont put horse before cart. In most case thats the reason why, cant use bad example only
real the talmud
Well it is outside the law if caught with evidence, just that its so widely accepted the evidence is usually hid between soldiers/police/doctors, but if you bring the evidence to an international criminal court, for example a racist murder where theres no retaliation or justice, as often is the case, it is illegal if it is brought to light out of the shadows
Thank you so much for this video. As a Syrian who has witnessed unbelievable eye openers in both the east and the west, I believe you have done a great job
As a fellow Syria I agree
@@nadaalfaidydid you watch the video?
Agreed. I'm a Bangladeshi Muslim and I support my Arab brothers and I'm not saying this because I'm a Muslim and biased. I'm very secular and consider myself more of an agnostic. I just think you don't have to be a Muslim to be against oppression just like you don't have to be black to be against apartheid in South Africa, or genocide of Native Americans, Vietnam etc. Just be a decent human, acknowledge what's actually happening and don't live in delusion because it's the safer thing to do. Most atrocities in history that happened decades/ centuries ago are universally considered "bad" in current times by everyone there's a lot less people who admitted it was bad during the time those crimes were being committed. Be in the right side of history right now, not decades later or centuries later and say "oops we shouldn't have done that but we're past all that now".
Some people cant be negotiated with. Tbh its easier to negotiate with greedy people than angry. Especially when religion involved, no more rational decision
@@thumpertorque_ there is no "right" side of history, most people dont have enough information to determine that anyway.
Its just your side vs other side. But you somehow always have the right side, the right moral code, the right god. You always get fed information by your side, moreso before internet era.
bro wake up! Olivia just posted
Highlight of the critical thinking sociological month bro
Exactly
Yeah, I know. I just woke up now.
literally texted this to my olisunvia stan bf
fr
Video essays I feel have genuinely saved me from losing it all. It's one thing to live in this world and be impacted by underlying issues that no one speaks out loud about but video essays like yours have helped to reversed the damage that's happened to me. Keep doing what you're doing Olivia, fr! Your channel should be bigger than Mr.Beasts' because your content is essential in a time where you feel the things people don't speak about
100%
MrBeast gives that feeling you have to the millions of people who are not satisfied with this. It’s all just feeding the void whatever custom void you got
@@AlejandroCastilloRapper At some point, video essays just seemed like the longer form of doom scrolling to me. "Life sucks. Let's watch a video explaining why life sucks. Now I feel better from my bedroom before another shift tomorrow." Rinse and repeat.
@@normandy2501 Just keep that sentiment in a positive way and you’ll something fulfilling. The art of being positive is useful even for atoms or whatever.
I had the same questions in my notes "what gives the leaders the right for the lives of their country's people?? and what part of it isn't considered murder?? what justifies their actions?" and I found your video very helpful.
I love your videos, I would love to know about your research process. Is it included in your course structure? I want to read more stuff about ethics as well but I'm not sure where to start from.
do you want answers to any of those questions?
@@xMXWLx yeah I would like to
Vax side effects and murders are exactly in this category. No politician, doctor or pharma company accepts legal responsibility.... .
As a brazillian citizen that tries her best to be aware of the state of people at least within brazillian territory, so many examples came to my head watching this video
You had the police brutally, nazis and medical authority as examples
But just in Brazil, there was a literal genocide of the Yanomami people, that only became present in media this year
In the pandemic, cities like Manaus (that is located in the Amazon forest) literally had a shortage of oxygen gas for it's patients, even tho Brasil has a public health care system that should and COULD give them that
People in the favelas (not just in Rio) are deemed "stateless" in practice, and therefore face insane police brutality casually
There's also a whole group of "original peoples" that enter the discussion of who gets to be valuable for the sovereign society (such as quilombolas, ribeirinhos and natives)
Crackheads and drug addicts (especially the ones living in the streets) are also deemed inhuman by probably the majority of society - they are reduced to plagues (probably even worldwide)
Obviously, people that tend to devaluate human life through narratives such as the ones you mentioned in the video tend to be (although are not limited) the rightists
Só vi narrativas sem sentido.
2023 ocorreu mais mortes de Yanonamis e vc n citou.
Drogados não são pessoas e os policiais agridem os bandidos das favelas que vocês esquerdistas defendem.
PhD student here. Mbembe and Weheliye have contributed to this discourse in really meaningful ways, and I think it's important to bring those voices into these conversations.
I was gonna say, it's a good video but it's weird to talk about thanatopolitcs (or necropolitics) in 2023 without mentioning Achille Mbembe at all, while mentioning Arendt's Origins of Totalitarianism - which I'd argue is her poorest work
darn, the sole reason i clicked on this video was hope that mbembe's work was going to be touched on at some point. bummer.
Oh well, guess there is always the Duncan's video on it.
Thanks for sharing this-now I have some new books and papers to read.
@@michimatsch5862 The Duncan's?
I was thinking about Hannah Arendt seconds before you mentioned her... I cant quite put into words how seen I'm feeling at a moment when anti-intellectualism and misinformation are driving forces behind atrocities worldwide. I'm so grateful for creators like you.
Stop viewing the world through half informed "content creators". Anti intellectualism, most people in power have advanced degrees
I’d like to add that when sovereign powers commit atrocities, it doesn’t come from a place of anti-intellectualism or misinformation. They know full well what they’re doing when they commit these atrocities. It’s more or less the spreading of misinformation online and half-assed viewpoints that drive people (online and irl) to view these actions through not-so-great lenses. I get the feeling that this is probably a given but I wanted to add to the conversation.
**or rather through the lenses that they do, which enable them to engage politically in ways that can be detrimental to society
@@audstrangeworld Or better, the leaders know for sure what they're doing, but they push that sentiment to the masses so the masses will be deceived and then not question them.
@@shimrrashai-rc8fq ngl I’m high and a little lost 😂 I don’t think there’s some big conspiracy happening I just think the general public is too over-worked/tired/uneducated/mislead to seek out a deeper understanding of how the world works so undead we fall for believing what’s most convenient without putting much thought into it. (Including myself)
Hello olivia! I hope your doing well. You actually inspired me to be more passionate in psychology and philosophy. I am thinking of taking it up in uni as a result. I want you to know you inspired me. Take care and have a great day.
OMG SAME, you're so real for that ‼️
Thinking of taking like a year off myself to study philosophy. Computer science get kinda one note after a while.
omg she inspired me to take philosophy for uni too, twinning!
i wouldnt do that if i was you
@@terryaverage284Brainrot
your videos are so well thought out and researched, and I really appreciate the accessibility you bring to philosophical discourse and informative videos. deep philosophical issues can be so usefully applied to our current situations but so many people don't naturally have the access to take classes or read books on the subject. I am so grateful that youtube has made so many more ideas accessible to me. thank you.
This addresses a fear which I've had ever since I was young that I would be killed because my existence would become bare. (Just to be clear, I wasn't able to explain the fear like this when I was young, but it was based on my knowledge of the founding of America and history more generally.) While it's very concerning for me to realize that my fear is completely justified, it's also a relief to have the words to describe this fear. Thank you.
Thanks for making this information accessible!
Just rambling here to sort out my thoughts: I think the idea of homo sacer can be applied to the disabled population in the US. I studied public health in college and wrote my senior thesis on the disproportionate amount of psychological distress in the disabled people. For half of the paper I tried to explain how political and social determinants of health can be internalized. Looking back on it, my thought process was like Foucault's network. The other half was a critique of medical professionals and their schools because they can inadvertently reinforce systemic failures through the power imbalance on a personal basis. I know that was a horribly vague summary, but their power creates a state of exception which can remove agency under the guise of creating special rights. Because as you said, if you have to define human rights, they weren't inalienable to begin with. The concept of babies being homo sacer, paired with the discussion of how adults can become homo sacer if it can be justified that rights don't apply to them reminded me of how we infantilize disabled adults. Prior to this video I was only able to explain this process in terms of stigmatization and 'othering', so once again, I really appreciate you sharing this information!
I tried to read Homo Sacer a decade ago and understood nothing! Yet your video made it clear and showed how it is relevant. Thank you for this!
Free Sudan, free Congo, free Palestine.
from the river to the sea
@@dieauferstehungpalestine will be free
This is such a good video. Having watched for a while, it's awesome to see how much clearer the writing and how much more easy to follow the actual speech have become. Love to see it.
Your videos are always so facinating. Often times i dont understand all of it on the first watch, but by 3, 4, 5, I notice things I've never noticed before.
I usually watch your videos leave a like and go on my way ... This time I can't ignore how you are pushing me to read into phylosophy i love how you explained the stuff i couldn't ...
Thank you Olivia and keep up your amazing work 💗 i aspire to be able to read think talk like you and be able to make videos like yours
You deserve way much more support!!! your videos and the dedication you put in them are unbelievable.
I'm glad i found your channel, it's really healthy for me personally, because from time to time I get to explore some new concepts/ideas or some concepts/ideas that I'm familiar with but havent thought about it for a while. plus you tend to upload once a month, so it doesnt get overwhelming for me to follow your topics since i can take my time to explore the ideas.
Anyways, thanks for the video 🙏
Hi Olivia, your work is very well put together and interesting. Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts with such a nuanced understanding. Keep up the good work!
So close to a million :) Thank you for being one of my first influences on my philosophy journey.
Incredible video! I've thought about this topic for years but I've never took the time to search for neither of these terminologies/concepts or the people who create them. And I'm currently writing a book (just for fun, I'm not actually a writer) that has a LOT to do with these concepts about what makes one life more valuable than the other, how the people in power are regarded as 'more' by society, and that sort of topics, so this is actually really really helpful for me! Thanks a lot 💖
I absolutely loved this video, it might be one of my favourites from your channel. Idk if itself because I’m interested in biopolitics but the way you explained was excellent. This video made me think back to my classes of Contemporary Anthropology where we talked about Agamben and Foucault, but it’s so applicable to the current situation in Palestine.
I know you will be an excellent professional and don’t hear the haters in the comments!
Greetings from Colombia
i treasure your videos. thank you so much for them and all the work that must go into producing them. you're amazing.
yo gl on a million subs i aint even realize how big this channel gotten ion really use youtube much anymore but i remember watching you back in like summer 2021 !!
Your videos are always so good at explaning things
Thank you for this video, I've had trouble organizing my thoughts on this and you did it incredibly
SO CLOSE TO ONE MIL YOU'RE KILLING IT OLI
Your content has gotten so much more polished over the past two years.
This is my first introduction to this concept. Thank you!
I can’t explain how excited I get when you post
you and exurb1a are the only philosophy youtubers I am subscribed to and while 90% of the time I need to watch your videos multiple times to fully understand them, I'm still a huge fan. Keep up the good work but don't burn yourself out!
Same for me!
Sisyphus 55 is great too
X3
I would advise you to look into exurb1a as a person before watching any more of his videos, that man is not good, at all, and it's pretty crazy how he managed to sweep the shit he did under the rug
@@MacinteuchPlus could you be more specific about his wrongdoings?
Thank you so much for sharing these perspectives!! This is very relevant and im glad you talked about the recent events !! You ate this up like always :D always looking forward to your videos :)
yes!!! thanks for making this one, it had me snapping in agreement so many times. your videos are so good! i very much enjoy your thoughts and opinions on all the various subjects u talk about. i don't always have the same view, but that's the point! you seem respectful of other ideas and generally embody an attitude of discourse through your presentation, which is cool!
AAAH I don’t think I’ve ever been this early at watching on of your videos !!! Your videos are amazing , I am always sooo exited when I notice that you posted a new video !!! The research and your way of explaining complex concepts and topics is absolutely astonishing !!!
I was introduced to Agamben a few years ago and I'm always so happy to see his concepts tackled. Thank you.
slowly becoming my fav channel
Thanks for the video I can always count on you to introduce topics for me to educate myself on
Such a timely topic, and explained with great nuance. Thanx
some of the points are good but theres some stuff i would debate you on, but overall i do appreciate ur effort for researching all this to present to us as usual.
Wow, great Video and didn't expect it.
Thanks for your work and excellent writing
omg ive missed you so much, thank you for making this video
Great video as always Olivia. Your videos are part of what inspired me to start a channel of my own :)
Been watching your vids since 2020 and now I'm in uni as a PoliSci major! Informative as always 🙏
This video is so important, great work honestly 👏
Great content! Thanks for the thought-provoking content as always :)
You’re always going against the flow! And I like that.. you’re just making me think in a different way and start exploring new possibilities.. thank you for the great content
I’m so glad I opened this video, make me see a lot things. I always saw it that way but never had information about it.
amazing video over a complex subject, love the videos!
Great video! Thanks for sharing your research and thoughts! Lots to chew on 😊
For a school project I recently read a portion of Agamben’s book, specially his chapter on biopolitics, and what I really took away was this idea of “the right to life”, which, similarly to what you said, is not really guaranteed by being born and that there actually aren’t inalienable rights. Anyways I really enjoyed this video and seeing something about homo sacer. ALSO I think that what is meant by everyone is homo sacer is something like there are so many different countries, and so many different super powers, and because there is no one big government you are always unprotected by at least one law, so it could be unpunishable to really kill anyone, if you do it the right way. But idk. Great video as always ! !
i can't express how much i love your videos bro
love the video its an eye opener for many people keep up the good work 💕
Really cool essay and very poignant! Id never heard of the concept of biopolitics before this video. Also, you're literally glowing in this video!
i see this a lot in western reporting of the gaza genocide. israeli women and children are murdered, palestinian females and minors just die. all of them were murdered. say it how it is. genuinely started tearing up during your segment on palestine, it was so well said and on point and it's so heartbreaking. im part of the palestinian diaspora and to see so many people value your life and lives of your people as homo sacer, as subhuman, as not deserving of human rights, its so terrible. thank you for pointing this out. much love ❤
Also notice how Israeli kids are "children" and Palestinian kids are "minors" or "people under 18". Genuinely sickening revisionism.
this video gave words 2 so much of what ive been feeling & so many questions ive had 4 a long while. thank u 4 the clarity & 4 this excellent video 💖💖
I've only recently started to watch your videos, and I must thank you for the research and hard work you put into them. They are excellent, informative and entertaining. 😁
I'm sorry to hear what happened oliSUNvia! I'm currently unemployed but really like your content and will do what I can to mitigate the damage done by the data breach/fraud! Keep on doing what you do! I love your content! =D
Love this video I was having a similar discussion with my mother about the othering of non-americans and how we always seem to disregard of life and the exclusion of non-americans with some form of disdain. Or at least what I've noticed.
Olivia you hit the nail on the head with everything on this video!
I love your videos! I would love to know how you are so wise, like some tips for us to start in learning like you do. It is not only that you read a lot, and express yourself in a very good way, but also all the knowledge you have (like when you say something and then you mention or quote a philosopher who says something similar)
Yeah. How do you retain such things? Sucks they don't respond to actually positive questions either.
you're my favorite channel on all of youtube
Achille Mbembe's concepts of Necropolitics and Necropower also talk about this topic in a very similar way, I can very much recommend his work for anyone who is interested in following this up
Thank you for this great episode ♥️
12:21 such a pleasant surprise to hear the piano version of "the city of people in love" ("город влюблённых людей"). i love Anna German's performance of this song. "people don't fight, people don't argue, people sing to each other" - its lyrics make you dream about a life more beautiful than this
thank you for such a great video!
Even though you described the concept as being distinct from "dehumanization" I feel like it is still that with extra steps, though I suppose a more appropriate synonym of "homo secar" would be considered as "second class citizens" because they're still treated human until, as you said so yourself, the moment that they try to exercise their rights for causes that affect them only to be denied by the "state of exception" through road-blocking laws that seek to undermine the goal of "equalizing" with other fellow citizens. Thank you for introducing us to this concept, we'll try giving it a read or listen some time later on!
I think you missed the point. To use the analogy of 6:42 , the difference between homo sacer and dehumanized is that homo sacer would be the ex (=no citizen), while the dehumanized would be some sort of side chick (=2nd class citizen), and the gilfriend would be a human with rights (=full citizen).
I would say homo sacer goes further than 'second class citizens' (which are still within the state/framework of citizenship) as it a greater critique of the state form itself. The state necessitates that there are citizens and homo sacer (non citizens).
As Olivia mentions in the video, Agamben was heavily influenced by Arendt and her critique of the concept of universal human rights. For example, in the UN Declaration of Human Rights, rights are something states give their citizens. But by putting the state as the starting point, people had no 'right to have rights'. People like those who are born stateless, or are refugees, do not have the right to guaranteed citizenship and are exiled from belonging to any 'political' life. You can extend that to the current situation in occupied Palestine where Palestine does not have sovereign power/is not regarded as a nation and hence Palestinian people have no political rights in the eyes of the US-led international community.
@@Naomi-fb1ej That's a very good/interesting critique. It means that the "human rights" framework still has a hidden authoritarian backing component in that "the State giveth ..." instead of that there exists a deeper morality beyond what "THEY" tell you that always applies, like compassion. As absolute rights would make _every_ State scared.
Good video as always.
Fascinating stuff as always! I've watched all of the content on this channel, so now I want to find new video essayists to listen to while I work. However, the ones UA-cam recommends to me either try to be too comedic, lean too much into picking apart uninteresting outside material like TikToks, tweets and news articles, use that obnoxious form of speech and editing that makes me feel like I'm watching an AI-generated conspiracy short, or just simply don't delve very deep at all into topics. I'd like to hear about any other youtube channels that make content like Olivia, preferably ones that don't necessitate me to actually watch the videos and let me just listen instead.
Thank you so much for your effort in this video and for speaking up in your own way.
Thank u Olivia so much! Thank you for being a human while most of the people acting like monsters. We love u❤️🍉🍉
Olivia does great research and makes it digestible, can’t wait for more I’m already a patreon
It is great if you don't know anything related to what she is talking about in advance. One minute in and she has made a huge error by using the wrong terminology, and the ocean gate example is not at all biopolitics. This whole video is on biopolitics, but as someone who studies this for a living I can confidently say she does not know what it means
@@TRMTE160 you are right surface level I personally am a tour guide and digest but I won’t stop supporting for a wee error also I was hoping you would have content or a counter channel/ video but waiting on your thesis to read!
@@ItUnidentified I dont make video content related to this, I read and write but it's mainly private. But whatever it is I make and understand it is much more accurate than what she said
thank you ❤️ this was very interesting and important!
gonna show this to my wife, i was trying to explain this to her yesterday, but this is abit more succinct. well timed, thank you.
It's not terribly subtle these days. Australia has contributed to and exacerbated the issue of statelessness by implementing laws around revoking citizenship and treating stateless refugees as criminals. A High Court ruling was recently overturned here resulting in a cohort being released from 'indefinite detention' and new laws were rushed through to counter the opposition's political attacks on the government over 'security'.
I say we abolish statelessness. And states.
As a Palestinian
Bless you ✨
I grateful for topics, and deep serious thoughts presented at your videos. I didn't realise I missed it before find this channel. My thanks
Love your videos excellent work 👏🏼
omgggg new olisun videoooo❤❤❤❤
I’m so grateful for this video, ignore the haters you’re doing awesome!!
I really appreciate your videos and your work
Tysm for including this 11:00
Her videos are always so thought-provoking and well made.
Really good essay! However, I think the book to compound this thesis is Achille Mbeme's Necropolitics. Brings in a current and integrated lens to the topic of death.
that's what i was thinking!
Poignant as always. Thanks for your research!
Amazing video as always. Thank you
Tragedies happens every single day everywhere around the world. Tragic accidents, natural disasters, horrible deaths etc. You name it, it happens. The thing is if it isn’t within our circle we will never know about it or if they are not covered by news we wouldn’t know about it either. It depends on the coverage the media gives it if it’s going to become something big or not. Also, imagine if two exact accidents things happen to two humans, one of them is famous and the other one isn’t, the news coverage about the incident isn’t gonna be the same. One could be even in international news, depending on the amount of fame of the person, while the other might not even be covered at all. Another example with this is wars multiple wars are happening in the moment. If you asked someone they would probably only know about Ukraine and Russia, and Palestine and Russia while there’s actually currently 32 wars around the whole world. The wars are there they are happening but the coverage isn’t as broad as the wars who are all around media in the moment. Horrible stuff but it really doesn’t gets covered and most of us don’t even know about it because we live in our bubble. Back to the topic of human rights, humans right aren’t really rights if you can revoke them depending on what benefits you in a political manner. In some political struggles we have seen political leaders see the deaths of hundreds of innocent people as collateral damage or minor loses which just shows how they view life.
Same old same old?
1:59-3:00
"One death is a tragedy, A million is a statistic."
Marilyn manson
i would love a podcast on spotify of these videos.. nice work
Omg. The title of this video alone sent shivers up my spine. Excellent job
Youre one of the only few UA-camrs whom i really admire and the fact that you made this video despite knowing that you will lose many followers, my respect for you just increased multifold 👑👑👑
not me listening to this during my lecture 💀💀
Olivia, you and your mind grow to be more beautiful every year!
Thank you for your contribution to keeping genuine, worthwhile knowledge and information online!
Another excellent video. Thank you.
Thank you olivia for this video!💗 love you for standing up for the truth and using your platform for it❤
Interesting video ! Ty for your excellent work .
Very informative and well thought video, subscribing for sure
I LOOOOOVVEEEE YOUR VIDEOS OMGGG 1 MIN
Conflating "medical euthanasia" and other medical procedures intended to let people die by removing artificial life support and then comparing them to crimes against humanity and police gunning down twelve year olds got really really stupid over the course of this video.
@@FlatPackedCapy *jacking off motion*