Eupho in concert is my strong spot. I’m a little bit of a bitch so holding up the marching Bari and the fact that it’s a Bari and not a eupho limits me a bit range wise in marching band. I just gotta get myself some man arms and I should be ight
When you think about it, Tubas are the percussions of the wind section. Back in highschool us tuba players used to ride the bus with the percussions and the majorettes. Talk about a time we had 😂
As a fellow band kid, I'm gonna rate them too! This is all based off my own experience. *Piccolo:* These tend to be the really good flute players sort of "graduating" to a piccolo. They're really finicky in terms of pitch, it takes a very talented and patient person to keep a piccolo in perfect pitch. 7/10 hurts my ears *Flute:* Best or worst thing you'll hear today, depending on pitch. Lots of fast runs and riffs which are fun to listen to but tricky to play. Flute sections tend to have one or two really annoying people but everyone else is pretty nice. 9/10 will never give up this instrument *Clarinet:* They need a rating higher than 3. Sure, I'll give elementary school clarinets a 3, but when you get GOOD clarinet players, they are smoother than butter. They fill in the gaps you didn't know were there. Although most need some practice before they get to that level. 8/10. *Oboe:* They're honestly really fun! They get a bunch of funky solos that you can listen to instead of counting rests. 10/10 *Alto/Tenor sax:* These are going together, we don't have a lot of saxophones in my band. The players themselves tend to be pretty chill, but are also the most likely to miss their cues. We have some EXCELLENT saxes though. 9/10 *Bari sax:* This is a league of their own. Every bari sax player I've known has been both an amazing musician and one of the craziest people I've met/pos. They're also just an excellent bass instrument. 10/10 love them *Trumpets:* A good trumpet is amazing to listen to. However, in my experience, the good players also tend to be assholes. The other trumpets are usually chill though. 7/10 *Trombone:* Just a good instrument. Most trombone players I've known have been a perfect mix of chill and chaotic. They're very fun to be around, and the instrument I think also reflects this. Just make sure you don't give the saxophones a concussion by mistake. 10/10 excellent instrument *Tuba:* I'm scared of our tuba player. The instrument is nice though. 9/10 *French horn:* Absolutely GORGEOUS, however my french horn friend has proved that it is very capable of destroying my eardrums. 9/10 still very pretty *Euphonium & rest of low brass:* EXCELLENT EXCELLENT they bring in such pretty harmonies on slower songs! 9/10 *Percussion:* They're quite distractable (in the back, gets away with phones/laptops the most) but they bring it together when it matters. 9/10 they're the only thing holding the band together at this point If you're reading this, GO PRACTICE doesn't matter what
I’m a good trumpet player, and I am not an asshole, in fact, none of the trumpets in my current band are assholes. I have only met one asshole trumpet player, and I really wish he wasn’t in the band. Trust me, some great trumpet players are AMAZING friends, they’ll help you, they’ll put up with you, it’s almost like a teacher that works for free.
Not only is it a gross and subtle brag but it is also unlikely true. I am a music education major with a primary in bassoon, and it drives me insane when people claim to play many instruments. Once you hit college you will realize that you don’t truly know how to play them, being able to play a few songs and knowing the fingering is not enough to say you can play all of them… there are so many different aspects that go into actually knowing how to play an instrument. Also this is coming from some one who had to take 4 classes on learning every instrument lmao, but you will never catch me saying I know how to play them
tell me your bragging without telling me your bragging, i play ever brass except horn because horns are too fucking expensive, please PLEASE humble yourself
Almost all of the trumpet players at my school are the absolute weirdest people I’ve met. Don’t even get me started on their playing. There are only a few tolerable players.
Btw saxophone is top tier. I don't know about other bands out there but my band had all their melephones start as trombone or start on melephone. Another thing about my band is that the baritone always has to play lower than trombone, like I've never seen a baritone play higher than a c
It is. Maybe you could have a case if you were talking about rhythmic percussion instead of pitched percussion, but even then they are still instruments.
trumpet and saxophone here, saxophone is only good with a jazz embrochure and tone, if your tone is bland nobody even wants you to have the melody. Trumpet is a W
Wish you ranked separate battery percussion instruments and also included front ensemble, but that comes from a percussionist perspective. How would you rate the low reeds as well, I frequently prefer listening to percussion, sousaphone, trombones and low reeds me personally. Other than that I approve your ratings!
This real asf. I started on clarinet since 6th grade bro and that shit does not project especially in marching band and is just overall not that fun. Then I tried alto sax cuz it was an easy switch and that shit was so much better. And then… I realized the tenor sax is just superior🤤.
As a mello player, I not only feel very happy to be recognized, but I also feel awesome to actually have someone understand that mellos are amazing. Mellos are the best thing that could ever happen to a marching band or drum corps. Mellos are a blessing given by god himself. Mellos are the best.
3:15 alr we’ll take it BUT a lot of it is dependent on air support and once it’s all memorized it’s such a fun instrument and ik it’s corny but once you get good it’s like an extension of yourself
4:38 I play my fair share of trombone and honest rating 7.9999/10. This is also coming from a euph player sooooooo. The only reason for the low rating is the only instrument worthy of going higher than 9 is euphonium and the eight spot is reserved for baritone. That being because I have a personal vendetta against b-tones but I just have to put up with it for a few months.
4:38 I play my fair share of trombone and honest rating 7.95/10. This is also coming from a euph player sooooooo. The only reason for the low rating is the only instrument worthy of going higher than 9 is euphonium and the eight spot is reserved for baritone. That being because I have a personal vendetta against b-tones but I just have to put up with it for a few months.
To be honest, as someone who plays in a symphonic orchestra and a concert band, I think every instrument is good. What really matters is how good the players are and the quality of the piece. In some pieces of music, let's say the clarinets for example, have really boring parts and we barely hear them. In other pieces though, such as Asphalt Cocktail by Jhon Mackey, there is an amazing solo using the whole range of the clarinet and it's really amazing (it's my favorite part of the piece ngl). Or sometimes, the player just doesn't practice and squeaks all the time or is too quiet, which doesn't help.
3:49 10/10 10/10 10/10 10/10 Best instrument to ever be created 10/10 Sound heavenly 10/10 When you know how to play it it’s fun 10/10 It’s a little bitch to hold up 0/10 Dem high notes make me start to rethink my life decisions but that’s cuz I used to suck (not really) 0/0 Best instrument ever 10/10 Top tier fanfares 10/10 Final rating 1000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000/10 Completely non biased rating
I was born in 2000 I have played percussion practically almost my whole life. Tuba is cool but the sousaphone it's like the cooler younger brother. Yes percussion it's like their own section it is like their own League. I played both in the front ensemble/pit but later on Junior and senior earrings in high school I played a mix of pit and drumline
French horn/mello is one for the instruments that solely depends on the player to differentiate it from being extremely beautiful, to ear wrenching. The other instrument is eupho
As a percussionist, percussion is too high I’d say Trombone 10 Sax 9 Baritone 8 Mellophone 7 Trumpet 6 Percussion 5 Tuba 4 Clarinet 3 Flute 2 Oboe 1 Violin -8 U can’t call me biased since my instrument is 5
Brass and percussion MAKE the band bro. Sorry but no one hears the woodwinds and they're not balanced so when its just them it doesnt sound good. Its too high heavy and never enough low reeds, they get washed out by low brass anyway. But i like the tenor and bari saxes tho 😎
Euphonium is even harder in a concert setting where tone matters
Yeppers always a big struggle of mine when we switch back to concert from marching
It's light work for me🥱💪
Eupho in concert is my strong spot. I’m a little bit of a bitch so holding up the marching Bari and the fact that it’s a Bari and not a eupho limits me a bit range wise in marching band. I just gotta get myself some man arms and I should be ight
watching this as a trombone player probably was the happiest ive been
as a trombone player that is so true :3
Fr
i thought he was gonna put it lower from the thumbnail 😂
LOOOOOOL that's so true !
1:52 As a saxophonist, this statement is the truest thing of all time
as a percussionist, sitting at the back of the class with the tuba players just kinda hanging out with them was so fun
When you think about it, Tubas are the percussions of the wind section. Back in highschool us tuba players used to ride the bus with the percussions and the majorettes. Talk about a time we had 😂
@@bmslhs yo true
As a trombone and baritone player, this video is pretty accurate.
as a trombonist, i happily accept the 10/10 rating 😊
As a mellophone, I agree with this video
SAAMMEEEE!!! MELLOS RULE!
@@fademacaw2552catch this فشغهج
MELLO GANG
@@AntecorSound W MELLOS!!!
As a fellow band kid, I'm gonna rate them too!
This is all based off my own experience.
*Piccolo:* These tend to be the really good flute players sort of "graduating" to a piccolo. They're really finicky in terms of pitch, it takes a very talented and patient person to keep a piccolo in perfect pitch. 7/10 hurts my ears
*Flute:* Best or worst thing you'll hear today, depending on pitch. Lots of fast runs and riffs which are fun to listen to but tricky to play. Flute sections tend to have one or two really annoying people but everyone else is pretty nice. 9/10 will never give up this instrument
*Clarinet:* They need a rating higher than 3. Sure, I'll give elementary school clarinets a 3, but when you get GOOD clarinet players, they are smoother than butter. They fill in the gaps you didn't know were there. Although most need some practice before they get to that level. 8/10.
*Oboe:* They're honestly really fun! They get a bunch of funky solos that you can listen to instead of counting rests. 10/10
*Alto/Tenor sax:* These are going together, we don't have a lot of saxophones in my band. The players themselves tend to be pretty chill, but are also the most likely to miss their cues. We have some EXCELLENT saxes though. 9/10
*Bari sax:* This is a league of their own. Every bari sax player I've known has been both an amazing musician and one of the craziest people I've met/pos. They're also just an excellent bass instrument. 10/10 love them
*Trumpets:* A good trumpet is amazing to listen to. However, in my experience, the good players also tend to be assholes. The other trumpets are usually chill though. 7/10
*Trombone:* Just a good instrument. Most trombone players I've known have been a perfect mix of chill and chaotic. They're very fun to be around, and the instrument I think also reflects this. Just make sure you don't give the saxophones a concussion by mistake. 10/10 excellent instrument
*Tuba:* I'm scared of our tuba player. The instrument is nice though. 9/10
*French horn:* Absolutely GORGEOUS, however my french horn friend has proved that it is very capable of destroying my eardrums. 9/10 still very pretty
*Euphonium & rest of low brass:* EXCELLENT EXCELLENT they bring in such pretty harmonies on slower songs! 9/10
*Percussion:* They're quite distractable (in the back, gets away with phones/laptops the most) but they bring it together when it matters. 9/10 they're the only thing holding the band together at this point
If you're reading this, GO PRACTICE doesn't matter what
Damn right oboe is 10/10, that shit is FIRE when played correctly
I’m a good trumpet player, and I am not an asshole, in fact, none of the trumpets in my current band are assholes. I have only met one asshole trumpet player, and I really wish he wasn’t in the band. Trust me, some great trumpet players are AMAZING friends, they’ll help you, they’ll put up with you, it’s almost like a teacher that works for free.
Where’s percussion?
No mello? 😢
As a trombonist and a baritone player I approve your ratings.
Twin
As a clarinet who chose to play the clarinet, I could not agree more with this video 😭😭🙏
me watching this as a flute/piccolo, clarinet, alto and tenor sax, trumpet, mellophone, and baritone player 🌝
Band kids trying not to subtly brag in everything they ever say
@@FylinB563 u mad you can’t do it or likeeee what was the point of commenting this do you feel better
@@kyledeaton1336he’s not mad he’s just pointing out how ur bragging to hide your insecurities 😂
Not only is it a gross and subtle brag but it is also unlikely true. I am a music education major with a primary in bassoon, and it drives me insane when people claim to play many instruments. Once you hit college you will realize that you don’t truly know how to play them, being able to play a few songs and knowing the fingering is not enough to say you can play all of them… there are so many different aspects that go into actually knowing how to play an instrument. Also this is coming from some one who had to take 4 classes on learning every instrument lmao, but you will never catch me saying I know how to play them
tell me your bragging without telling me your bragging, i play ever brass except horn because horns are too fucking expensive, please PLEASE humble yourself
As the low brass captain, I completely agree with what you said about tubas
I came for the mellos, and I left completely satisfied.
piccolo's can go so high that ive seen violin players next to them literally setting up a sound wall
As a trombone player I am subbing because I finally found someone who understands how good trombone is
2:33 me watching this as a trumpet and feeling so happyyyy
As a main trombonist, who also plays tenor and alto sax, trumpet, baritone/euphonium, and a little bit of tuba, I see this as a HUGE W
As a trombone player, I completely agree
I would, but trumpets are nine 😰
yeah trumpets are like a 4
Real
Almost all of the trumpet players at my school are the absolute weirdest people I’ve met. Don’t even get me started on their playing. There are only a few tolerable players.
As a Snare player I am depressed by the fact I was rounded up into the same scoring as the cymbals
As a member of the loudest clarinet section in California, we cut through most sound in marching band, and especially all sound in concert band.
Ok so I have never seen this channel in my entire life and so when he started rating the saxophones I immediately knew he was an alto sax 💀
🥁= 11/10
me being a tubist, trombonist, saxophone and trumpet player (also a lil more but imma not talk abt it)
Your background music is a version of my ringtone.
Btw saxophone is top tier. I don't know about other bands out there but my band had all their melephones start as trombone or start on melephone. Another thing about my band is that the baritone always has to play lower than trombone, like I've never seen a baritone play higher than a c
Piccolos/Flute 8/10
Clarinet 3/10
Saxophone 10/10
Trumpets 9/10
Mellophones 9.5/10
Baritones 8/10
Trombones 10/10
Tubas 10/10
Percussion 9/10
Now do jazz instruments
jazz flute
Trumpets in jazz band are like peanut butter and jelly
I absolutley agree as a Trumpet, Bass Trombone, Baritone and future Saxophone player.
As a musician that plays more instruments than I can count, yet none of the ones mentioned, I agree.
As a bass trombonist, I see this as a absolute win
U did not just put percussion as an instrument😭
It is. Maybe you could have a case if you were talking about rhythmic percussion instead of pitched percussion, but even then they are still instruments.
As a tenor sax you deserve my subscription 🔥
Watching this as a trombone player. Serious friends with tuba. I'm surprised you didn't mention the mouthpiece.
Just gotta say saxophone is a W instrument but as a trumpet player we got the melody and you don’t so I would’ve revert those two lol
trumpet and saxophone here, saxophone is only good with a jazz embrochure and tone, if your tone is bland nobody even wants you to have the melody. Trumpet is a W
What do you mean saxophone sounds bland when not sounding like jazz? The saxophone can produce so much more different colors of sound.
@@dsctunes Absolute L take. Saxophone has so many different types of sounds and feelings it can do. Classical saxophone is beautiful, so is jazz sax.
Bro, saxophone can also play melody and really sick solo 🎷
@@holdeenyo8914 I was mostly exaggerating. I prefer jazz saxophone but that doesn't mean it has to be jazz.
good video, i love playing trombone
As the 1st tenor in my local band, I can confirm.
As a tuba/sousaphone you have earned my respect 🫡
as a trumpet player, three valves easy BUT you have to build extreme lip muscle in order to high notes
What about the bass clarinets and the alto clarinet
I know Bassoon is not in marching band but I think you should do something about it because it is 🔥
Wish you ranked separate battery percussion instruments and also included front ensemble, but that comes from a percussionist perspective. How would you rate the low reeds as well, I frequently prefer listening to percussion, sousaphone, trombones and low reeds me personally. Other than that I approve your ratings!
This real asf. I started on clarinet since 6th grade bro and that shit does not project especially in marching band and is just overall not that fun. Then I tried alto sax cuz it was an easy switch and that shit was so much better. And then… I realized the tenor sax is just superior🤤.
REAL
Real
As a trumpet player, I greatly appreciate the rating
I play all of these but my main instrument is trombone. I appreciate the rating man🙏🙏
Yo what abt the bass clarinet???
As a trumpet player, this video is very agreed, I also learned every brass instrument but I personally like the trumpet the best
As a mello player, I not only feel very happy to be recognized, but I also feel awesome to actually have someone understand that mellos are amazing. Mellos are the best thing that could ever happen to a marching band or drum corps. Mellos are a blessing given by god himself. Mellos are the best.
As a saxophone player, yes.
CB WHAT U DOIN HERE😂
YES YES TROMBONE IS AMAZING
3:15 alr we’ll take it
BUT
a lot of it is dependent on air support and once it’s all memorized it’s such a fun instrument and ik it’s corny but once you get good it’s like an extension of yourself
as a flute player, a piccolo is a flute because its a type of flute, BUT THAT DOESNT STOP ME FROM BEING TRIGGERED! GRRRR!! (just kidding, all jokes)
Thank you for glazing my instrument so much
you should have separated the drumline from the pit (unless you are in an hbcu style marching band) because they are lowkey pretty different!
As a trumpet, flute, sax, slide trombone, valve trombone, and baritone player, I wholeheartedly agree with this video
As a trombone player, thank you
4:38 I play my fair share of trombone and honest rating 7.9999/10. This is also coming from a euph player sooooooo. The only reason for the low rating is the only instrument worthy of going higher than 9 is euphonium and the eight spot is reserved for baritone. That being because I have a personal vendetta against b-tones but I just have to put up with it for a few months.
As a tuba/sousa player, I take this as an absolute W.
4:38 I play my fair share of trombone and honest rating 7.95/10. This is also coming from a euph player sooooooo. The only reason for the low rating is the only instrument worthy of going higher than 9 is euphonium and the eight spot is reserved for baritone. That being because I have a personal vendetta against b-tones but I just have to put up with it for a few months.
as a trumpet player with small lips, i fully agree except the mouthpiece part 🌝
whats the background song
Me as a oboe flute clarinet alto sax trumpet trombone mello player
To be honest, as someone who plays in a symphonic orchestra and a concert band, I think every instrument is good. What really matters is how good the players are and the quality of the piece. In some pieces of music, let's say the clarinets for example, have really boring parts and we barely hear them. In other pieces though, such as Asphalt Cocktail by Jhon Mackey, there is an amazing solo using the whole range of the clarinet and it's really amazing (it's my favorite part of the piece ngl). Or sometimes, the player just doesn't practice and squeaks all the time or is too quiet, which doesn't help.
3:49
10/10
10/10
10/10
10/10
Best instrument to ever be created 10/10
Sound heavenly 10/10
When you know how to play it it’s fun 10/10
It’s a little bitch to hold up 0/10
Dem high notes make me start to rethink my life decisions but that’s cuz I used to suck (not really) 0/0
Best instrument ever 10/10
Top tier fanfares 10/10
Final rating 1000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000/10
Completely non biased rating
Free sub for your opinion on Trombone, the section will be notified
Tubas with that 10 😎
As a tuba and trombone player I approve this rating
I was born in 2000 I have played percussion practically almost my whole life. Tuba is cool but the sousaphone it's like the cooler younger brother. Yes percussion it's like their own section it is like their own League. I played both in the front ensemble/pit but later on Junior and senior earrings in high school I played a mix of pit and drumline
as a mellophone (concert band version)
i agree our instrument is a 9.5
French horn/mello is one for the instruments that solely depends on the player to differentiate it from being extremely beautiful, to ear wrenching. The other instrument is eupho
wild
i play clarinet gang… y are you coming for us 😭😭
I played piccolo in marching band and violin in orchestra
what about front ensemble/pit
he probably marches in an hbcu style marching band
We don't hear saxophones in marching band either 😂
Depends on the band
As a percussionist, percussion is too high
I’d say
Trombone 10
Sax 9
Baritone 8
Mellophone 7
Trumpet 6
Percussion 5
Tuba 4
Clarinet 3
Flute 2
Oboe 1
Violin -8
U can’t call me biased since my instrument is 5
Idk what trombone players are in YOUR band but the trombones in my band reek and talk during band the whole time 😬😬
Here before 1 mil
I agree with the sax it is not heavy like my instrument the marching euphouim you hear it and it sounds nice
I love being a tuba player 😫
I'm a Percussionist and I play Bass on drumline
As a percussionist. (Best instrument ever). mellows sax trombones and tuba (Sousas). My next fave instrument
I play clarinet for marching band and concert band
If mellophone had anything below a 9 I definitely would sued you…
I agree as a trombone
Thank you for that 10 #trombonelife
BRO DIDN'T RANK THE SEPERATE DRUMLINE INSTRUMENTS even as a tuba player this hurts me
Her me out saxophones rule
I play tuba and I got symphonic band
W tbone
I feel like clarinet are way more useful in concert bands
Brass and percussion MAKE the band bro. Sorry but no one hears the woodwinds and they're not balanced so when its just them it doesnt sound good. Its too high heavy and never enough low reeds, they get washed out by low brass anyway. But i like the tenor and bari saxes tho 😎
i dont play anything on this list, i play horn
tuba gang
Search JSU something in my heart if that don’t want to make you play trombone idk what to tell you
Mellophone is superior
Was finna question you bc I thought you was like others trombone got it I play trumpet to good rating
Piccolo and flute!!!!
Any video that bullies clarinets gets a like from me, and praises trombones!!!!!!!!!
I love how clarinet is the only bad instrument lol
☠☠☠☠☠☠☠
Man, I'm Dead.
Low brass on top