First movie reaction!! Iron Man is a lot more realistic then most people would think, but there's some glaring engineering problems with the suit that are tough to solve. I hope you guys enjoy the video!! Timestamps: 0:28 - Palladium 0:59 - 3 gigajoules per second 2:38 - Initialize Power Sequence 3:34 - First suit 5:21 - Flight 6:26 - Inorganic discharge/Plasma 7:59 - Building second suit 8:40 - JARVIS 10:27 - Ice build up 11:21 - Supersonic 12:20 - Ear Cannon
Kinda a dumb question but with the prosthetic limbs you were talking about if you get hit in a prosthetic limb would your brain cause you to feel the pain or would you not be able to feel it because there are no nerves in the limb?
@@tonyangelo3836 That is a not at all a dumb question, it's a very interesting one actually!! With the prosthetic limb, you could be able to move your 5 fingers if it was a prosthetic arm, but the fingers themselves would not have the sense of touch. You could leave your prosthetic hand in boiling water (wouldn't recommend) and you would not feel it. Your nerves are only sending signals from your brain to the arm, not from your arm to your brain. If you were to get hit on a prosthetic limb, you would not feel pain in that limb.
And about Jarvis, he says in Avengers Age of Ultron that Jarvis started as a “natural language interface” and “now runs more business than anyone besides Pepper”.
To be fair to Tony Stark and the writers of the movie, I don't recall them ever calling JARVIS an AI. The name is actually an acronym in the films for "Just Another Rather Very Intelligent System."
you could argue that in the MCU, once JARVIS becomes Vision he becomes a "full" AI, but the presence of the mind stone complicates that since it's magical in nature. Ultron is a much more definitive example of AI.
Yea. Other than jewelries, they use it for catalysts too along with Platinum. It's even theorized that Palladium is the catalyst for a cold fusion reactor. (No, there hasn't been any record of a successful attempt at cold fusion)
8:40 JARVIS is an AI, not a UI. Keep in mind in Age of Ultron tony says JARVIS was keeping nuclear codes out of ultrons grasp and rewriting them frequently without Tony ever telling him to.
Exactly. Had to watch the beginning montage in Iron Man to verify. This is the award-winning robot Tony built while in MIT, the school he graduated at 17. My guess is he was just so attached to it. Or it helped his process, perhaps. Anyway, despite making it wear a dunce hat, he salvaged it from the wreckage of his Malibu home in Iron Man 3.
This video is actually important as an electrical engineering student. All I've done is read boring books all day. But seeing those theories being used to explain concepts in mcu. Is a once in a lifetime opportunity for me
If you watch the movies there has been multiple times when Tony has passed out when his suit malfunctions, maybe the oxygen is in the helmet. This character was written before we had most of our technology today so you gotta keep that in mind.
@@thenothingking Tony didn't pass out due to a lack of air. We know this because at the beginning of 2012's _The Avengers_ he's seen wearing the Iron Man suit while working underwater. He passed out because he consumed all available suit power redirecting the nuke into space; power that he needs to keep the shrapnel out of his heart.
@@BigJwlz from what was shown in the movie.... It will still take about a week for the shrapnel to reach his heart without the reactor..... He won't exactly pass out without it since the reactor only powers the electromagnet and the suit NOT his body...... I think lack of oxygen is the main reason
I am glad that the part you have doubt is indeed fiction. It’s the “repulsion emitters”, both used as weapons and to protect him. I believe his first armor used basic rockets tho.
His first armor probably also used repulsor tech. In the beginning Tony demo'ed those jericho missiles to the army where he stated that they use propriatary Repulsor technology. Later when the Ten Ring captured Tony they gave him everything they have of his products to build them the same missiles, which would most likely included everything he would need to build the missiles, including his repulsor tech.
Repulsor technology is how he flies, directs, and projects energy being generated from the mini Arc Reactor in his chest. It's a Tony Stark patent in the MCU and the comicbooks. Awesome video!
I think the biggest problem of Iron man suit being able to fly is aerodynamics. Cuz when you wanna build a flying unit, not only it has to be able to generate enough energy to take off or even get supersonic, but it also needs to manoeuvre somehow. If planes do that with Wings and flaps and stuff and they stay stable in air due to their shape, I don't know how a human body shaped suit would do that. At this point, Iron man suit in real life looks more like a projectilve rather than flying something. P.S: I'm almost absolute zero in physics but I'd like to hear about it from someone who actually knows better that me
@@danatboran3177 notice in iron man one how he has hind flaps that serve as ailerons they operate with the same principles as the ailerons of a conventional plane. In civil war he has tiny holes on his chest armour that give him extra boost in flight and also serve as propellant(that's how they move the space shuttle in space.
Really the “magic” of how Iron Man’s tech even works is his arc reactor. Tony _somehow_ was able to reproduce the energy output of a nuclear reactor to fit in a teacup. And it’s what allows his suit enough energy to fly and produce enough thrust to go super sonic.
arc reactor is indeed magical but it complies with real life physics, if you could use all energy in something that small you can definitely get more than enough energy output, someone even did maths with just 1g of material and physics does allow that as result was something in range of 100 000 gj/s but just because you can get that kind of energy output it doesn't mean you can use it for all applications, like the nuclear power stations that we got expel energy into liquid, which then evaporates and drive dynamo to generate electricity but same thing can't be used for flight, as to attain flight you require to push something so conservation of momentum will apply equal and opposite force, thus allowing you to overcome constant gravitation pull. This is how all of our flight based technology works, all type of air planes suck all the available air and then push it out, thus air pushes back the air plane, all rockets carry their own supply of materials to push off but Tony's suit doesn't do anything like this, there are no vents that suck air and push it out nor are there any tanks to carry its own material.
@@DearHRS I am pretty sure the initial suit (Mk2 and Mk3) heats up the air around the "repulsers" to generate thrust (making them a kind of propulsion equipment), it wouldn't work in space though but it's a cool idea and could help mitigate the overheating problem since you got like a huge heat sink in the chest piece and 4 auxiliary heat sinks to compensate for the energy dissipation of the ark generator.
@@parychahal hey buddy...btw he has programmed it better by time ....ex: dum E actually throws off the back part of his suit to him in iron man 3 when he is about to say *i am the best* in the opening scene( u can look on it in slow motion).....ex no. 2 : in iron man 1 when tony is almost paralysed by that tech and when he went down to get the 2nd arc reactor that he had(proof that tony stark has a heart)he tries to get it and fails falling on to the ground almost giving up and then all of a sudden dum E gets down and gives him the arc reactor that he needed to survive...both in these 2 occasion he didnt use the voice to get it done😄
@@parychahal let's also not forget the sentimental factor. Dum-E was probably a childhood favorite, possibly even "friend", since a genius of Stark's level, from such a wealthy and important family, could never have a normal childhood.
8:00 That's Dum-E, and Tony made it when he was a kid. I'm pretty sure it was one of the first robots he built, so he keeps it more for sentimental value than actual usefulness.
@@MaidikIslarj yea he also has dum-e and U on the way to the compound when he sells the tower in Spider-Man homecoming so yea we have the diagnosis that man is nostalgic
11:44 Supersonic flight capable aircraft have existed since the 1950s. 12:05 The Iron Man suit is pressurized. You can hear him talk about it with Jarvis when he's discussing how to deal with the Icing problem he had with the Mark 2 suit: _Hull pressurization is problematic. I'm thinking icing is the problem._
A lot of engineers talk about how dangerous Tony's ark reactor is for his body due to the components in it but the directors do cover that in Iron Man 2, ya know when it's poisoning him
It is different. At Iron Man 2 they said the decaying products of the palladium is what is poisoning him, but what everyone says is that if such reactor can make that ungodly amount of energy, it would get really hot and cook Tony.
For the sonic generator that Obidia Stane had and used on the one guy that he got Tony's 1st suit from and eventually tony, I feel like part of the reason why it wasn't approved is due to the fact of the idea of the generator falling into the wrong hands. I mean, even you yourself mention that the device that Obidia uses can be very dangerous, I think that is part of the reason.
A lot of people thought the arc reactor was the big achievement. The real achievement is the Stark proprietary "repulsor" technology. It is what allowed the missiles to fire without fuel, iron man's flight and his primary weapons. Basically the repulsor tech allows for reactionless flight without fuel requiring only power hence the arc reactor.
@@abrokeengineer967 Repulsor tech isn’t real. And it has functioned without an Arc Reactor, shown through the Jericho missile. Repulsor tech absolutely does not need a large amount of energy to use, but the Iron Man suit needs that large amount of energy for all the different weaponized applications of the Repulsor tech. Theoretically, Repulsors will function with any kind of battery but it was an overload from the Arc Reactor that caused his flight stabilizers to shoot out concentrated beams. This is an achievement born from both tech, but the Repulsors take the cake for being the reason why the Iron Man suit works (otherwise he’d have to stick to normal weapons similar to the Mark1). The reason why Repulsors are the real achievement is how much more important it is to the Iron Man suit than even the Arc Reactor. The Arc Reactor powers the suit, but virtually everything that it powers aside from the actual suit are Repulsor based. Take Iron Monger for example, as that is an Iron Man suit that doesn’t use Repulsors. It’s physically powerful, but actually pales in comparison to a fully powered Iron Man suit (along with minimal foreseeable improvements, as without Repulsors it can’t improve its weaponry without adding a lot more bulk). :)
@@Senordisastermaster there was a dude who made a working repulsor like weapon. Whether or not it could provide flight is up in the air but it did manage to fire a damaging burst of energy at a target.
@@Mike-mt4ln Repulsor-like isn't the same as the properties of the comic book equivalent. Someone made a working proto-lightsaber that can expand and retract as well as cut through objects, but it isn't the fictional technology. :)
Tony does have fuel. The materials they gave him to work with included missiles and rockets that have their own propellant. He just repurposed it. Going supersonic is just a matter of thrust and integrity of the object. If the suit can generate the required thrust, and not vibrate itself apart, it can absolutely go supersonic. It's probably got a fairly wide shock cone given the blunt nature of the helmet compared to a fighter jet's tapered and swept nose. G force is a major component as there is a person in the suit, but fighter pilots actually wear flight suits that include bladders of air around their calfs and forearms. At high gs they inflate to squeeze blood back toward the core of the body. This could easily be integrated into the iron man suit. As for oxygen, he has thrusters in his feet that take up less than 10 cubic inches... we're just supposed to "he geniused it."
He prob didn't need to repurpose it, the fuel was used for thrust even in the missiles and rockets. Idk where he would keep the fuel in the suit even if he had it available.
OK, so there are two aerospace engineers in our family and the thing about going supersonic is what does the suit do about the heat from all that. Metal parts start to expand, plastic starts to flow, circuits short out and go off line, the person/pilot suffers burns and then passes out all unless you can vent that heat and computer chips die from to much heat heat. As an example the SR-71's fuel system is constantly leaking fuel while the plane is sitting on the ground and or flying at anything less than supersonic but once it hits anything over Mach 2 that system expands and seal up tight. It then slows down to mid air refuel while the seals are warm and tight and then continues with its mission with full tanks of fuel. At the speeds we normally face in every day life our atmo seems nice and thin and easy to deal with and it is but once you cross that sound barrier lots of things change and that air becomes as dense as cement. Also that suit is so small it does not have space for all the fuel it would need, life support systems, weapon systems, sensor systems, navigation and avionics needed and so on. But heck it is just a cartoon and as the producer Bellisario always says, "don't look to close".
@@John-iv2oz That last bit is key... there's just enough realism to feel grounded, but not so much that they have to answer actual physics questions. That would kinda destroy the entire point. :D Though I'm sure we could probably come up with some yada-yadas on how he did it. I mean he did have that special alloy that resists icing from the Seraphim Tactical Satellites his company had built. Star Trek got around quantum mechanics by inventing the "Heisenberg Compensators" for the transporters as well as Inertial Dampening Fields to circumvent, well, inertia.
A couple of things: 1. I think it's understood that the he uses repulsar technology to fly, which is never thoroughly explained but which is used not just in his suit, but later in the helicarriers in Winter Soldier. It's also the same thing he used to fire his blasts, so it's hard to quantify exactly how it operates. 2. Actually, Jarvis IS an AI. He is both an AI and a UI. He can do things on his own volition, but my guess is, there are "safety" protocols in the Jarvis AI from you know... just taking over world - like Ultron. If you watched Age of Ultron, you will see that Jarvis does actually do things on his own once he is "displaced." My guess is, Jarvis does tons of things on his own by through some sort of learning algorithm that Stark created. For instance, Jarvis makes comments on Stark's decisions "You're usually so subtle" or in Ironman 3 "You had glutton free waffles" when Stark says he doesn't even remember what he had for breakfast.
My best guess is he confused GAI with AI (GAI means General Artificial intelligence... It's something that fits more into his explanation of AI, which doesn't require user inputs)
9:29 UI stands for User Interface. Jarvis is an Intelligent System. Other examples of intelligent systems are things like factory automation. Things like the google assistant and Siri are Expert Systems.
I'm eletrical engineer myself specialized in hydraulic turbine and what was stated about the reactor is 100% true. I giggled when I saw that part of the movie the first time. A common hydraulic turbine of good size produces 300MW of power, which is 0.3gigawatts, which means 10 times LESS powerful than the arc reactor he built. Now these tubines are state of the art in term of efficiency in the world of electric motors. We are talking 99% efficiency, with only 1% loss in heat. Nonetheless, 1% of 300MW is 3 fucking million watts. Have you ever tried unscrewing a light bulb when powered on? You can barely touch it due to the heat, and this is 60 watts. Imagine what 3 000 000 watts would do. Unless his reactor is 100% efficiency, 0 power loss, no one could even stand in the same room as this reactor without proper cooling system in place.
Iron man released in 2008 This man waits till 2019 until he becomes an engineer to watch it He names the video "engineer watching iron man" Objective accomplished 🎉
As for the paralysis of the device that was used on Tony they actually have that already in nature and that’s what it emulates. In adult tigers for instants they have the ability to do a deafening roar which affects some people so much when the cat roars it paralyzes those that hear it within a certain radius because it disrupts the equilibrium through the hearing.
I also agree that this movie was way more realistic than some people may expect. I reacted to the Aerospace Engineering elements specifically on my channel and I found similar things that you did. Good Explanations 👏
The Iron man armor is able to fly using a new technology (repulsors, designed for rockets) tony created. It’s basically just a really compact powerful thruster.
The ability to fly is the fictitious part of iron man, he himself mentioned to have created this new revolutionary technology "repulsors" wich are used in the Jericho missiles at first, then he applied it to the Mark II. The source of the fuel to fly in the Mark I I assume is the same of the flamethrower equiped in the suit, even tho the types of fuels used for it are very different from rocket fuel, I'm sure Stark had a way to adapt that. The way the repulsors work is completely fictional until now, I have no idea how we could develop something like that. The other mysterious part of the suits is the arc reactor, such a powerful device would be impressive to see in real life. Excellent video btw, subscribed.
Good call on the flamethrower fuel! I did not think of that! The Jericho missile was only in the air for...5 seconds before it divided into many smaller missiles? I'm sure he could increase the airtime the missile could have so it can cover a longer distance but even if that were the case, what is that max time? 10min? 15min? If it's the same technology, I don't know how he's able to fly in the Iron Man suit for more then 10-15min at once. Tony is also flying at different speeds while in the suit which will have an impact on how long he's able to stay in the air, but the faster he goes, the more fuel he's burning. I also don't have a solid understanding of how these repulsors work in the MCU, there's for sure someone who knows more then I do and I wish he/she would comment here and straighten it out ahah
@@parychahal Repulsors work by pushing away stuff without any undesired heat. They are used in the second stage of the Jericho missiles, when they "break apart into little pieces" they fly away using the repulsors. Stark tested them on his boots first but then when trying to stabilize the flight by using hand repulsors he discovered they could be used as a weapon too, by pushing away enemies in a non lethal way. They can also be used in a lethal way by concentrating the repulsor energy into a beam that can even cut stuff. ironman.fandom.com/wiki/Repulsors_(film)
@@parychahal The repulsors are also supposed to work without any fuel, just using the electricity produced by the arc reactor. "The repulsors work by taking excess electrons and turn them into muons, which have ability to penetrate deep into atomic matter, which are then fed into hands and chest piece of any iron man suit. Muon is an elementary particle similar to the electron, with an electric charge of −1 e and a spin of 1/2, but with a much greater mass." Source: www.quora.com/How-does-the-Iron-Man-s-repulsor-work It all boils down to the energy source and the fantasy of the way it a is handled, I don't even know how the process of transforming electrons into muons can be placed into such a small device.
Stay away from this tech kid !!! You don't have enough hairs on your ass to understand Stark tech !!! Iron Man suit is 1000% Real !!! Its something that in fictious world , Tony Stark knows and in Real World , Only I know !!! All concepts of this dumb engineer does work !!!
For the flying part, you kinda forgot where he got his "BOX OF SCRAPS!" from... missiles. With propulsion systems on them. He actually has hoses and tanks on the suit for the fuel to fly. It's just enough for a short trip though... Edit, also the Plasma bit.. in the novelization I think, Tony says he was lying to make her feel better. His chest was infected from having cave surgery, he just didn't want Pepper to panic. D.U.M.-E us the robot he was making the boot with. He built and programmed that robot in middle school, and it is Jarvis' father essentially. All of his A.I. and companions are built off of that original dunce cap wearing robot arm.
Jarvis, through being damaged by Ultron, and eventually combined with the Mind Stone, does become an AI as Vision. Advanced enough to understand and feel emotion
That last device that made Tony temporarily paralyzed, I thought seems to attack the nervous system rather than it just being a sound frequency. But I might be wrong. But of course, you have to suspend belief when it comes to these movies.
With the paralysis device it's possible there are subtler things going on than just the sound. The sound might be just a byproduct of the device being on, like how a car's purpose isn't to make car noises. It does seem to require close proximity to the ears, which is why Stane isn't affected, but it might just need to be close to the head. I know strong magnets can affect brain activity in some pretty crazy ways, maybe it uses magnets.
The key to Iron Man's armor is that arc reactor. Given the amount of power it puts out, things like reactionless thrusters become fairly simple. Add "super materials" like graphene to the mix, and his whole suit goes from fantasy to reality fairly quickly.
Based on the description of the ARC reactor, my best guess for flight is through ion tech. Basically using all of the heat emitted from the reactor to then “ionize” the air around his feat providing a difference in pressure. Thus providing lift
Good question. Stark knew there was only one outcome (Dr Strange told him in Infinity war) and committed to making mach 85 which would essentially harness the stones for the snap. That was 'the mission.'
Actually Jarvis is an ai not a ui, for example he asks Tony if he wants him to do certain things, that are completely up to Jarvis to ask. For example he might ask Tony is he wants a dinner reservation at a restaurant nearby without any input or programming.
Yes, Jarvis demonstrates independent thinking quite often, and often must carry out tasks where Tony gives him only very high level instruction, and the details are left to Jarvis to figure out.
Wow, you're making me realize alot of stuff. From now on, I'll be focusing MORE on learning and watching these kind of informative videos. Thanks for the quality content sir, I appreciate it.
The Gold Life I do believe ion thrusters exist today and are mainly used on Satellites. They work I think by accelerating cations utilising electricity. They can also neutralise a gas and take some electrons from atoms to create a cloud of positive ions.
When i first watch this when i was 8 years old and i wanted to become eletric eingeering but the thing is i suck at math but i love to read books and are willing to learn got any tips?
Math is nothing more then a language that is used to describe the world around us. Instead of letters, this language uses numbers and symbols. Once you can read/write/understand the language, the world becomes easier to quantify. Anybody can become an engineer with the correct mindset, you got this!
I think by plasma he is referring to blood plasma. Sir is it possible to have a Ironman helmet. And also Jarvis understand's stark so he is an AI and an UI.
@@parychahal Fanfic reader here again, so what I'm seeing from more from that than movies or comics. JARVIS was designed with a thinking algorithm, made to learn and grow, much as a child would. Tony had J watch Hal and other thinking/controlling computer movies to learn what NOT to do.
Much of the Iron Man technology are things that we actually have right now. We have exoskeletons, plating, jet boots, cybernetic helmet that picks up your thought waves; the one thing we don’t have is a power supply. He has an arc reactor thats the size of a hockey puck and puts out the power of 3 nuclear plants, that’s probably nearly impossible to do at the moment.
When I watched this video I was waiting for the scene where Obadiah is shouting to one of his guys to make the arc reactor. Still, nice informative video! 👍👍👍
Hi, I've been wondering about his "Robot vision" Does he use projectors on the sides of the mask? Because if that was the case, it would be ineffective in day light Could you please make some sense of it
I think it'd be more accurate to say "Heads Up Display" or H.U.D rather than "Robot vision" but if that's what you enjoy saying and much more comfortable with that then I'm not forcing you too. Now how it functions, it could be projectors or it could be hologram tech. We've seen via the mark 6 in The Avengers that the entire front part of the interior of the helmet has lights, judging by that we can assume that there are multiple projectors/hologram devices at play here. This could theoretically negate the problem of external light getting in the way of the projectors/hologram. Another plausible way is the helmet has some form of lenses that protect the inside of the helmet from external factors.
@@apollyonfinch can u tell me if there exists some holographic or some display tech that can be used with a distance of < 8-12 cm and works like tony's HUD like no problem in clarity and not so much eye stress ,like we have VR its more over a 30min fun nd after that it gives a lasting stress in our eyes so can we ignore these this by that tech?
@@zx3edits745 As far as I know, we do have hologram tech (i.e. the holographic circus from Austria, not sure how much eye strain this causes though) but not as sophisticated, compact, and clear as Stark's tech.
8:17 I never got the impression that the arm was being controlled solely from Tonys input. I always assumed the arm used machine learning to help tony but also took his input for real time adjustment.
I see most of the people in here are very uninformed about propulsion systems and armor stuff.. The iron man suit's hydraulics might be possible but a flight system? No just no.. i can bet on it, Theres no fuel which is powerful enough to lift a suit that heavy while having an efficiency so big that you wont have to carry big tanks full of that fuel. And about the armor, again theres no possibility of making an armor so dense to stop 30 mm rounds and 115 mm rounds from the cannon of a tank... Just impossible.. even super dense materials like depleted uranium arent strong enough to take on multiple 30 mm rounds and we are talking about an armor which is just an inch thick so it wouldn't be possible for it to withstand that much force and energy from powerful munitions like 25,30,115,120 mm rounds and rockets
Adding to this, I’ve always found that the aerodynamics of the suit don’t work. You can’t, as far as I’m aware, move forward so fast that you don’t fall. Planes do it because they have wings that do some weird air magic to lift the plane upward. Iron Man don’t got wings. The closest thing to flying a suit like this could ever do is hover the way Tony did during the test flight. Add wings to it, and maybe it can happen, but then it drastically changes the suit, and I wouldn’t consider it an Iron Man suit anymore. Without flight, anything we make will be much more akin to the mjolnir armor from Halo, minus energy shields.
Wings aren’t always needed. To help direct it in different directions? Yes. It was displayed in the movie multiple time to turn, and brake. To keep it up and going straight. You just simply have a slight angle of propulsion to aim up. At high speeds, every slight adjustment is more dramatic. So falling isn’t a problem. No tanks needed if you use electrolysis. You create energy as you go. A lot of fuel will be needed yes, but IF...IF you have a batterie that can continue to make that energy, it’s possible. They are currently developing a quantum batterie that also creates energy as it operates. So heat isn’t a “issue”. Things are involving better over time.
@@maxherrin2764 you have no idea what your Talkin about, wings are a must for a efficient sustained flight if you will use the energy from the suit for propulsion so that your suit stays in an angle and doesn't starts "falling" down it would decrease the efficiency by atleast 300 to 400% comparing with the flight systems attached on a wing design and as for fuel.. Electrolysis is literally the worst idea, why? See electrolysis is a very slow process it doesn't gives out enough fuel in a particular amount of time so that we can use it as a reliable source of energy nor does it gives out a fuel pure enough for actual use in propulsion like for example there's this youtuber russian guy who made a repulsor thing which was fueled by a electrolysis chamber feeding the whole system on Hydrogen gas (flammable) but the fuel wasn't dense or very pure hence could only be used in that hand-held repulsor torch thing and not for the propulsion systems.. as it wouldn't create required amount of force to lift a heavy suit in the air along with you
Just came across your channel as I love Ironman and finished watching all of the avengers movies so I was curious. I’m a bio major and feel like changing to something else because I don’t feel motivated to go through with biology anymore. I’m good at math and chemistry and love to make/fix things, I was wondering if you have a suggestion for a few majors I’d potentially be interested/do well in?
I would recommend Biomedical Engineering if your university offers it. I'm not sure how keen you are on coding; if you like it, I'd recommend Electrical Engineering (it's a good mix of hardware and software) If you don't care for it, Mechanical Engineering may interest you. With coding, there are many free software and youtube tutorials available for you to be at home and try coding for yourself to gauge your interest.
The Gold Life alright thank you! Sorry for the late reply but I remember trying coding in middle school and I didn’t like it that much. I think Mechanical Engineering should be the best for me!
From what I remember of the film. He was using his own weaponry mainly rockets/ missels and breaking them down to create the ironman suit. So rocket propellent and the casing and nozzles would have been available to him. This is not true of further iterations of the suit. Propulsion in later versions came from individual arc reactors that emitted energy straight from their cores and used as a weapon. It's a comic book man. Don't have to be real.
The excess heat issue is probably the most difficult to solve if we ever get close to building a real life Iron Man suit. I suppose flight _could_ be effected by ducting air into the suit and superheating it to generate thrust, kind of like the "nuclear ramjet" concept that was envisioned in the Cold War era? As for JARVIS, that's pretty near what I picture as the pinnacle of interactive UI with smart capabilities that at least _approach_ a universal artificial intelligence, since it is capable of inferring complex instructions from natural language input.
the flight.. when he was testing them, he called them "Flight stabilizers" to Pepper. and that was the hand mounted ports, which are also jets, which gave a significant recoil when he fired. a sustained burst could cause lift and possible flight of running enough power. And the GigaJoules produced by the reactor.. should be enough power. Oh and the lack of covering the reactor in the suits. not a functional reason to leave them open.. it was to make the suit look more like the comics.
Okay so there is a fluid that is used in make up and hair care products, and it is referred to as plasma. Also there was test they were working on where you have a cone that leads in to an over hanging lip and you had to shoot a high power laser perfectly at the tip of the cone and the laser was supposed to travel evenly across the surface. As the laser curves through the overhanging lip, it super heats the air and makes a puff of plasma. So that in a movie could be the way that it worked, now you just need energy to power it!
Kudos for pointing out that Iron man would pass out in super sonic flight, but you're not entirely right about the need for oxygen. Tony would need some form of g suit to help his blood flow - that's the main thing for not passing out, along with oxygen mask
@Aldin Diez no he didn’t technically defeat ultron but he played a major part into doing so and if he didn’t break ultron down from the inside they wouldn’t have been able to defeat him
I don't watch these movies but Whenever youtube recommend these movie scenes I break into laughter!!! Clearly you forget to turn off your logic mode when you don't watch these movie scenes and accidentally bump into it
With enough power anything can can fly . The key to having this is obviously a new type of power source that hasn’t been invented yet . And with the limited understanding of our universe it is quit possible that someday we will unlock the secrets to massive amounts of energy in the palms of our hands no pun intended
@@parychahal not you kiddo !!! Only I am gonna build this legendary suit in the whole wide universe !!! And I am not gonna give it to anybody !!! I have Iron Man's technology since 2017 !
Fuel was used for the flame throwers and jet boots of the first suit, they showed the fuel tanks in the creation of the suit. The mini arc reactor just powered the servos motors and stuff, all the electronics.
Right lmao. No one else in the mcu understands how tf Tony makes the suits he does. Thats why he's iron man and u don't see weaponized suits everywhere in the army. All I kept thinking every time he said he didn't understand how something would work
Tony built his helper (Dum-E) as a kid in 1986. He apparently never upgraded it beyond the voice control you mention. Probably some level of nostalgia there or considering it as a pet or something. Still awesome for when it was built.
In terms of how he flew out - wasn’t most of what he built taken from missiles? Makes sense he could have made use of the solid propellant in those to fly out, explains the Space Shuttle style smoke column, (from SRBs) as well as his lack of control in flight.
The largest use of palladium today is in catalytic converters.[46] Palladium is also used in jewelry, dentistry,[46][47] watch making, blood sugar test strips, aircraft spark plugs, surgical instruments, and electrical contacts.[48] Palladium is also used to make professional transverse (concert or classical) flutes.[49] As a commodity, palladium bullion has ISO currency codes of XPD and 964. Palladium is one of only four metals to have such codes, the others being gold, silver and platinum.[50] Because it adsorbs hydrogen, palladium was a key component of the controversial cold fusion experiments of the late 1980s.[51]
But probably Tony don't control directly the suit to fly, fly with jets like that can be really complex. Jarvis probably captures Tony gestures and intents (not thoughts), do all that complicated math in real time and take care about all details
It is a matter of simple logic that the arc reactor is not the only revolutionary thing in his suit. There are definitely many other things too. The whole suit is revolutionary basically.
@11:28 Supersonic speed is the speed of an object that exceeds the speed of sound (Mach 1). For objects traveling in dry air of a temperature of 20 °C (68 °F) at sea level, this speed is approximately 343.2 m/s (1,126 ft/s; 768 mph) this speed is only achievable above 2000 feet at 1100 feet the object can begin to tear apart no matter how aerodynamic the vehicle is
The plasma he talks about, is the component of blood, not the state of matter, just a quick quote from wikipedia "Blood plasma is a yellowish liquid component of blood that holds the blood cells of whole blood in suspension. It is the liquid part of the blood that carries cells and proteins throughout the body. It makes up about 55% of the body's total blood volume."
The reason it discharges plasma is because it’s a fusion reactor. That also solves the heating problem, as most of the heat in a fusion reactor is in the plasma. The walls get cooled by liquid helium or lithium, therefore reducing heat that can get out of the reactor.
The first thing we think about the Ironman suit isn't even how it generate that much power, but how in damn heaven all that electricity can pass from Arc reactor to the suit through that thin wires without overheating to hell...
the word plasma is used for a different context here (like plasma membrane) that happens in science a lot. He uses ion propulsion system of some kind that uses the power from arc reactor, that is how he produce thrust.
1. Actually if those were military shells (bullets), they are usually steel jacketed (Police/civilian/defense rounds are usually coper jacketed and game rounds are usually lead based). So he'd need a steel that exceeds the toughness of the steel in the bullet jacket. 2. As far as the rockets, he did tear apart at least two missiles for the palladium. It's possible he repurposed the solid boost rockets (I assume the type) used in them
his propulsion system is as far as i know meant to be like qn airbreathing arcjet, so the propellant is the air The reactor is also supposedly a muon-catalyzed fusion reactor, which could in theory generate dc power at very high efficiency which could run arcjets, but at the supposed 3 GW power level the waste heat is still unmanageable Also his suit doesn't seem to have air intakes
In regards to the fuel that he was burning for the upward lift when he escaped from the cave in the Mark 1, he did have access to rocket fuel. both for the jet propulsion and for the flamethrowers, they were giving him the raw materials to make missiles, and it only stands to reason that that would include propulsion fuel.
Jarvis is indeed an AI because jarvis becomes vision in avengers age of ultron, and he gets in a relationship with wanda and everything, so that proves that he is AI.
First movie reaction!! Iron Man is a lot more realistic then most people would think, but there's some glaring engineering problems with the suit that are tough to solve. I hope you guys enjoy the video!!
Timestamps:
0:28 - Palladium
0:59 - 3 gigajoules per second
2:38 - Initialize Power Sequence
3:34 - First suit
5:21 - Flight
6:26 - Inorganic discharge/Plasma
7:59 - Building second suit
8:40 - JARVIS
10:27 - Ice build up
11:21 - Supersonic
12:20 - Ear Cannon
a really good, point on reaction. good references to science. well done :D
@@minidude112 Thank you very much!!
Kinda a dumb question but with the prosthetic limbs you were talking about if you get hit in a prosthetic limb would your brain cause you to feel the pain or would you not be able to feel it because there are no nerves in the limb?
@@tonyangelo3836 That is a not at all a dumb question, it's a very interesting one actually!! With the prosthetic limb, you could be able to move your 5 fingers if it was a prosthetic arm, but the fingers themselves would not have the sense of touch. You could leave your prosthetic hand in boiling water (wouldn't recommend) and you would not feel it. Your nerves are only sending signals from your brain to the arm, not from your arm to your brain. If you were to get hit on a prosthetic limb, you would not feel pain in that limb.
@@parychahal can make a viseo in which u react on iron man's infinity war nano technology suit plsssssssssss
And about Jarvis, he says in Avengers Age of Ultron that Jarvis started as a “natural language interface” and “now runs more business than anyone besides Pepper”.
Yeah I've been convinced he's an incomplete AI. An example of a complete AI is Ultron
Interesting..
To be fair to Tony Stark and the writers of the movie, I don't recall them ever calling JARVIS an AI. The name is actually an acronym in the films for "Just Another Rather Very Intelligent System."
you could argue that in the MCU, once JARVIS becomes Vision he becomes a "full" AI, but the presence of the mind stone complicates that since it's magical in nature. Ultron is a much more definitive example of AI.
@@parychahal I mean he scrambled nuclear codes on his own in the age of ultron when Ultron "destroyed" him, I doubt tony programmed him to do that.
Real panther watching black panther
Real God watching Thor
Real spider watching Spider-Man
Real hulk watching hulk
Feminist watches Captain Marvel
@@xwispr oof..
150-200 yrs from now. There will be a real ironman. Technology evolves so fast.
I agree!
10 years
we're be dead to see it
I dont agree because maybe after 5 years the engineers might make some plasma techs like iron man does
For your information iron man suits have already been made
“I love iron man, I can’t wait for endgame” wait till he finds out
Oh no
I don't have the heart to tell him...
I was thinking the same and came down to comments to see if anyone else was, 👍
LoL
Oh dear
“Humans are not perfect” take tony for example when making ultron
well it was a team effort with doctor banner
something Tony would say to cover his ass
@@CommanderM117 was it not a team effort though, i mean ya tony would prolly say something like that but him and banner literally did work togethwr
@@CommanderM117 Also Wanda put him under the influence of his fears, causing him to rush into it so that's also a factor
Paladium is real.....Damn opened my eyes...thought that periodic table is just fiction... knowledge is power....power is power
word
Cersei to littlefinger - Game Of Thrones 😂
It’s all about unobtanium
Yea. Other than jewelries, they use it for catalysts too along with Platinum. It's even theorized that Palladium is the catalyst for a cold fusion reactor. (No, there hasn't been any record of a successful attempt at cold fusion)
@L Lawliet tbh... I watched Vikings and The Walking Dead after finishing GoT, and both tv shows were better
8:40 JARVIS is an AI, not a UI. Keep in mind in Age of Ultron tony says JARVIS was keeping nuclear codes out of ultrons grasp and rewriting them frequently without Tony ever telling him to.
Yeah it is artificial intelligence.. jarvis basically learns from things and people... how world works etc..
He's and AI...
Yes jarvis is an Ai and Ui. Cmiiw peace✌
but tony him self says to banner that java is UI
Jarvis - just a rather very intelligent system
8:24 That arm was actually one of the first things that Tony built when he was young, maybe that's why it doesn't work well
good point
Ya and he never rebuilt dumb-e and dumb-u until spiderman homecoming . Love for machine he din't wanted to do an operation on his bestie😂
Exactly. Had to watch the beginning montage in Iron Man to verify. This is the award-winning robot Tony built while in MIT, the school he graduated at 17. My guess is he was just so attached to it. Or it helped his process, perhaps. Anyway, despite making it wear a dunce hat, he salvaged it from the wreckage of his Malibu home in Iron Man 3.
This video is actually important as an electrical engineering student. All I've done is read boring books all day. But seeing those theories being used to explain concepts in mcu. Is a once in a lifetime opportunity for me
This is like a chef reacts to a microwave
LOL This made my day ahaha
🤣🤣🤣🤣
More like Gordon Ramsay
Chef Mike
If you watch the movies there has been multiple times when Tony has passed out when his suit malfunctions, maybe the oxygen is in the helmet.
This character was written before we had most of our technology today so you gotta keep that in mind.
When has he passed out when his suit malfunctions?
The Gold Life he passed out when he went into the wormhole with the nuke in The Avengers. I’m assuming because the oxygen ran out in his helmet.
@@thenothingking I forgot about that, but you're absolutely right!
@@thenothingking Tony didn't pass out due to a lack of air. We know this because at the beginning of 2012's _The Avengers_ he's seen wearing the Iron Man suit while working underwater. He passed out because he consumed all available suit power redirecting the nuke into space; power that he needs to keep the shrapnel out of his heart.
@@BigJwlz from what was shown in the movie.... It will still take about a week for the shrapnel to reach his heart without the reactor.....
He won't exactly pass out without it since the reactor only powers the electromagnet and the suit NOT his body...... I think lack of oxygen is the main reason
I am glad that the part you have doubt is indeed fiction. It’s the “repulsion emitters”, both used as weapons and to protect him.
I believe his first armor used basic rockets tho.
Either way, he's one hell of an engineer lol
@@parychahal his repulsors are particle beams. Aka particle accelerators
@@parychahal not an engineer a mechanic remember he said it himself in iron man 3
Actually, the original comics used a 'reverse-magnetic ray'
His first armor probably also used repulsor tech.
In the beginning Tony demo'ed those jericho missiles to the army where he stated that they use propriatary Repulsor technology.
Later when the Ten Ring captured Tony they gave him everything they have of his products to build them the same missiles, which would most likely included everything he would need to build the missiles, including his repulsor tech.
Repulsor technology is how he flies, directs, and projects energy being generated from the mini Arc Reactor in his chest. It's a Tony Stark patent in the MCU and the comicbooks. Awesome video!
Is the repulsor hydrogen or plasma gas.
Its muons
@@victormpapuluu6497 Synthesize ganja exhaust
I think the biggest problem of Iron man suit being able to fly is aerodynamics. Cuz when you wanna build a flying unit, not only it has to be able to generate enough energy to take off or even get supersonic, but it also needs to manoeuvre somehow. If planes do that with Wings and flaps and stuff and they stay stable in air due to their shape, I don't know how a human body shaped suit would do that. At this point, Iron man suit in real life looks more like a projectilve rather than flying something.
P.S: I'm almost absolute zero in physics but I'd like to hear about it from someone who actually knows better that me
@@danatboran3177 notice in iron man one how he has hind flaps that serve as ailerons they operate with the same principles as the ailerons of a conventional plane. In civil war he has tiny holes on his chest armour that give him extra boost in flight and also serve as propellant(that's how they move the space shuttle in space.
I think Jarvis is still an AI for the simple fact that Tony has had full conversations with it.
It’s an AI that takes commands from its creator
I know right lmao
Tha is he passes the Turing test
You have conversation with siri
Really the “magic” of how Iron Man’s tech even works is his arc reactor. Tony _somehow_ was able to reproduce the energy output of a nuclear reactor to fit in a teacup. And it’s what allows his suit enough energy to fly and produce enough thrust to go super sonic.
arc reactor is indeed magical but it complies with real life physics, if you could use all energy in something that small you can definitely get more than enough energy output, someone even did maths with just 1g of material and physics does allow that as result was something in range of 100 000 gj/s
but just because you can get that kind of energy output it doesn't mean you can use it for all applications, like the nuclear power stations that we got expel energy into liquid, which then evaporates and drive dynamo to generate electricity
but same thing can't be used for flight, as to attain flight you require to push something so conservation of momentum will apply equal and opposite force, thus allowing you to overcome constant gravitation pull. This is how all of our flight based technology works, all type of air planes suck all the available air and then push it out, thus air pushes back the air plane, all rockets carry their own supply of materials to push off but Tony's suit doesn't do anything like this, there are no vents that suck air and push it out nor are there any tanks to carry its own material.
The Arc Reactor is based off of the Tesseract. The little glowing blue cube thing from the MCU.
@@DearHRS I am pretty sure the initial suit (Mk2 and Mk3) heats up the air around the "repulsers" to generate thrust (making them a kind of propulsion equipment), it wouldn't work in space though but it's a cool idea and could help mitigate the overheating problem since you got like a huge heat sink in the chest piece and 4 auxiliary heat sinks to compensate for the energy dissipation of the ark generator.
@@DearHRS check for ionic flight
No one said jarvis is an AI....Just A Rather Very Intelligent System
JArvis literally called himself an ai damn idiot
@@tangdynasty4779 Haha.
He's not a idiot you are.
@@annoyingdog4521 Haha. I'm not the idiot you are.
Are you dump?
Jarvis
J - Just
A - A
R- Rather
V - Very
I - Inteligent
S - System
Hmmmmm
Are you realizing something?😑
@@tangdynasty4779 nah you don't get the jokes
I believe that Dum-E (the robotic arm) was created by a 13 year old Tony, so it makes sense that it would only be voice controlled.
I'm sure he can program it otherwise, but if you tune it so that it only responds to your voice, it's more convenient
@@parychahal hey buddy...btw he has programmed it better by time ....ex: dum E actually throws off the back part of his suit to him in iron man 3 when he is about to say *i am the best* in the opening scene( u can look on it in slow motion).....ex no. 2 : in iron man 1 when tony is almost paralysed by that tech and when he went down to get the 2nd arc reactor that he had(proof that tony stark has a heart)he tries to get it and fails falling on to the ground almost giving up and then all of a sudden dum E gets down and gives him the arc reactor that he needed to survive...both in these 2 occasion he didnt use the voice to get it done😄
@@parychahal let's also not forget the sentimental factor. Dum-E was probably a childhood favorite, possibly even "friend", since a genius of Stark's level, from such a wealthy and important family, could never have a normal childhood.
8:00 That's Dum-E, and Tony made it when he was a kid. I'm pretty sure it was one of the first robots he built, so he keeps it more for sentimental value than actual usefulness.
True, that's why it's so bad
Then it's possible Tony was lying when he said to Pepper "I've been called many things, 'nostalgic' is not one of them"
@@Abominatrix650 It is a lie. Why else would he keep all his past suits on display
@@MaidikIslarj yea he also has dum-e and U on the way to the compound when he sells the tower in Spider-Man homecoming so yea we have the diagnosis that man is nostalgic
Next: Real humanoid spider reacts to spiderman films.
I'd pay to see it... With a flamethrower in my hand.
Or a parkour expert
The real humanoid spider: "tHiS iS riDiCUloUs hiS wEbS aRE sUPpoSeD tO gRoW FrOm hIS bUTt¡¡"
@@caquiux949 Yes. XD
@Arman Damn Oof. XD
To be fair...Tony Stark built his first suit IN A CAVE WITH A BOX OF SCRAPS!
Thank you Mr. Stane
Sorry sir...I'm not Tony Stark
(wish I put that scene in this video lol)
@@parychahal actually more surprised that you didn't put any Ironmonger scenes
You just wanna say it don't you? hahah
@@parychahal You forgot to add "And we don't have a box of scraps."
11:44 Supersonic flight capable aircraft have existed since the 1950s.
12:05 The Iron Man suit is pressurized. You can hear him talk about it with Jarvis when he's discussing how to deal with the Icing problem he had with the Mark 2 suit: _Hull pressurization is problematic. I'm thinking icing is the problem._
A lot of engineers talk about how dangerous Tony's ark reactor is for his body due to the components in it but the directors do cover that in Iron Man 2, ya know when it's poisoning him
It is different. At Iron Man 2 they said the decaying products of the palladium is what is poisoning him, but what everyone says is that if such reactor can make that ungodly amount of energy, it would get really hot and cook Tony.
@@steampunkastronaut7081 exact
For the sonic generator that Obidia Stane had and used on the one guy that he got Tony's 1st suit from and eventually tony, I feel like part of the reason why it wasn't approved is due to the fact of the idea of the generator falling into the wrong hands. I mean, even you yourself mention that the device that Obidia uses can be very dangerous, I think that is part of the reason.
A lot of people thought the arc reactor was the big achievement. The real achievement is the Stark proprietary "repulsor" technology. It is what allowed the missiles to fire without fuel, iron man's flight and his primary weapons. Basically the repulsor tech allows for reactionless flight without fuel requiring only power hence the arc reactor.
I disagree, such technology requires a large amount of power and cannot function without a huge power source, aka the arc reactor.
@@abrokeengineer967 Repulsor tech isn’t real. And it has functioned without an Arc Reactor, shown through the Jericho missile. Repulsor tech absolutely does not need a large amount of energy to use, but the Iron Man suit needs that large amount of energy for all the different weaponized applications of the Repulsor tech.
Theoretically, Repulsors will function with any kind of battery but it was an overload from the Arc Reactor that caused his flight stabilizers to shoot out concentrated beams. This is an achievement born from both tech, but the Repulsors take the cake for being the reason why the Iron Man suit works (otherwise he’d have to stick to normal weapons similar to the Mark1).
The reason why Repulsors are the real achievement is how much more important it is to the Iron Man suit than even the Arc Reactor. The Arc Reactor powers the suit, but virtually everything that it powers aside from the actual suit are Repulsor based. Take Iron Monger for example, as that is an Iron Man suit that doesn’t use Repulsors. It’s physically powerful, but actually pales in comparison to a fully powered Iron Man suit (along with minimal foreseeable improvements, as without Repulsors it can’t improve its weaponry without adding a lot more bulk). :)
@@Senordisastermaster there was a dude who made a working repulsor like weapon. Whether or not it could provide flight is up in the air but it did manage to fire a damaging burst of energy at a target.
DEEP.
@@Mike-mt4ln Repulsor-like isn't the same as the properties of the comic book equivalent. Someone made a working proto-lightsaber that can expand and retract as well as cut through objects, but it isn't the fictional technology. :)
Tony does have fuel. The materials they gave him to work with included missiles and rockets that have their own propellant. He just repurposed it.
Going supersonic is just a matter of thrust and integrity of the object. If the suit can generate the required thrust, and not vibrate itself apart, it can absolutely go supersonic. It's probably got a fairly wide shock cone given the blunt nature of the helmet compared to a fighter jet's tapered and swept nose. G force is a major component as there is a person in the suit, but fighter pilots actually wear flight suits that include bladders of air around their calfs and forearms. At high gs they inflate to squeeze blood back toward the core of the body. This could easily be integrated into the iron man suit. As for oxygen, he has thrusters in his feet that take up less than 10 cubic inches... we're just supposed to "he geniused it."
He prob didn't need to repurpose it, the fuel was used for thrust even in the missiles and rockets. Idk where he would keep the fuel in the suit even if he had it available.
@@parychahal Yeah, that's where you really have to suspend disbelief. There just isn't enough room in that suit for everything he has in there.
Agreed!
OK, so there are two aerospace engineers in our family and the thing about going supersonic is what does the suit do about the heat from all that. Metal parts start to expand, plastic starts to flow, circuits short out and go off line, the person/pilot suffers burns and then passes out all unless you can vent that heat and computer chips die from to much heat heat. As an example the SR-71's fuel system is constantly leaking fuel while the plane is sitting on the ground and or flying at anything less than supersonic but once it hits anything over Mach 2 that system expands and seal up tight. It then slows down to mid air refuel while the seals are warm and tight and then continues with its mission with full tanks of fuel. At the speeds we normally face in every day life our atmo seems nice and thin and easy to deal with and it is but once you cross that sound barrier lots of things change and that air becomes as dense as cement. Also that suit is so small it does not have space for all the fuel it would need, life support systems, weapon systems, sensor systems, navigation and avionics needed and so on. But heck it is just a cartoon and as the producer Bellisario always says, "don't look to close".
@@John-iv2oz That last bit is key... there's just enough realism to feel grounded, but not so much that they have to answer actual physics questions. That would kinda destroy the entire point. :D Though I'm sure we could probably come up with some yada-yadas on how he did it. I mean he did have that special alloy that resists icing from the Seraphim Tactical Satellites his company had built. Star Trek got around quantum mechanics by inventing the "Heisenberg Compensators" for the transporters as well as Inertial Dampening Fields to circumvent, well, inertia.
A couple of things:
1. I think it's understood that the he uses repulsar technology to fly, which is never thoroughly explained but which is used not just in his suit, but later in the helicarriers in Winter Soldier. It's also the same thing he used to fire his blasts, so it's hard to quantify exactly how it operates.
2. Actually, Jarvis IS an AI. He is both an AI and a UI. He can do things on his own volition, but my guess is, there are "safety" protocols in the Jarvis AI from you know... just taking over world - like Ultron. If you watched Age of Ultron, you will see that Jarvis does actually do things on his own once he is "displaced." My guess is, Jarvis does tons of things on his own by through some sort of learning algorithm that Stark created. For instance, Jarvis makes comments on Stark's decisions "You're usually so subtle" or in Ironman 3 "You had glutton free waffles" when Stark says he doesn't even remember what he had for breakfast.
I guess the word he was looking for was Computational Intelligence
My best guess is he confused GAI with AI
(GAI means General Artificial intelligence... It's something that fits more into his explanation of AI, which doesn't require user inputs)
And evolving AI as well.
9:29 UI stands for User Interface. Jarvis is an Intelligent System. Other examples of intelligent systems are things like factory automation. Things like the google assistant and Siri are Expert Systems.
Thought it stood for ultra instinct
@@jaycrane4137 😂
I'm eletrical engineer myself specialized in hydraulic turbine and what was stated about the reactor is 100% true. I giggled when I saw that part of the movie the first time. A common hydraulic turbine of good size produces 300MW of power, which is 0.3gigawatts, which means 10 times LESS powerful than the arc reactor he built. Now these tubines are state of the art in term of efficiency in the world of electric motors. We are talking 99% efficiency, with only 1% loss in heat. Nonetheless, 1% of 300MW is 3 fucking million watts. Have you ever tried unscrewing a light bulb when powered on? You can barely touch it due to the heat, and this is 60 watts. Imagine what 3 000 000 watts would do. Unless his reactor is 100% efficiency, 0 power loss, no one could even stand in the same room as this reactor without proper cooling system in place.
Iron man released in 2008
This man waits till 2019 until he becomes an engineer to watch it
He names the video "engineer watching iron man"
Objective accomplished 🎉
Do u personality know him? Or bluff?
@@ashenisdick that's a joke 🤦♂️
Shaibya Raj intensive cringe
@@ashenisdick idk 😂 ig but that's so messed up to name a video like that
Shaibya Raj yea so many videos like this in my recommended idk why lol
"Uh, yeah, well, whenever you notice something like that... a wizard did it."
- Lucy Lawless / Xena
As for the paralysis of the device that was used on Tony they actually have that already in nature and that’s what it emulates. In adult tigers for instants they have the ability to do a deafening roar which affects some people so much when the cat roars it paralyzes those that hear it within a certain radius because it disrupts the equilibrium through the hearing.
I also agree that this movie was way more realistic than some people may expect. I reacted to the Aerospace Engineering elements specifically on my channel and I found similar things that you did. Good Explanations 👏
5:08 cap and bucky: "write that down, write that down"
The Iron man armor is able to fly using a new technology (repulsors, designed for rockets) tony created. It’s basically just a really compact powerful thruster.
I should be sleeping. What the hell! Its friday!
Hell yeah!
Greetings from the future. It's Friday again!
Same it is Friday again and i can't sleep a year later from your comment.
The ability to fly is the fictitious part of iron man, he himself mentioned to have created this new revolutionary technology "repulsors" wich are used in the Jericho missiles at first, then he applied it to the Mark II.
The source of the fuel to fly in the Mark I I assume is the same of the flamethrower equiped in the suit, even tho the types of fuels used for it are very different from rocket fuel, I'm sure Stark had a way to adapt that.
The way the repulsors work is completely fictional until now, I have no idea how we could develop something like that.
The other mysterious part of the suits is the arc reactor, such a powerful device would be impressive to see in real life.
Excellent video btw, subscribed.
Good call on the flamethrower fuel! I did not think of that! The Jericho missile was only in the air for...5 seconds before it divided into many smaller missiles? I'm sure he could increase the airtime the missile could have so it can cover a longer distance but even if that were the case, what is that max time? 10min? 15min? If it's the same technology, I don't know how he's able to fly in the Iron Man suit for more then 10-15min at once. Tony is also flying at different speeds while in the suit which will have an impact on how long he's able to stay in the air, but the faster he goes, the more fuel he's burning. I also don't have a solid understanding of how these repulsors work in the MCU, there's for sure someone who knows more then I do and I wish he/she would comment here and straighten it out ahah
@@parychahal Repulsors work by pushing away stuff without any undesired heat. They are used in the second stage of the Jericho missiles, when they "break apart into little pieces" they fly away using the repulsors.
Stark tested them on his boots first but then when trying to stabilize the flight by using hand repulsors he discovered they could be used as a weapon too, by pushing away enemies in a non lethal way.
They can also be used in a lethal way by concentrating the repulsor energy into a beam that can even cut stuff.
ironman.fandom.com/wiki/Repulsors_(film)
@@parychahal The repulsors are also supposed to work without any fuel, just using the electricity produced by the arc reactor.
"The repulsors work by taking excess electrons and turn them into muons, which have ability to penetrate deep into atomic matter, which are then fed into hands and chest piece of any iron man suit.
Muon is an elementary particle similar to the electron, with an electric charge of −1 e and a spin of 1/2, but with a much greater mass."
Source: www.quora.com/How-does-the-Iron-Man-s-repulsor-work
It all boils down to the energy source and the fantasy of the way it a is handled, I don't even know how the process of transforming electrons into muons can be placed into such a small device.
@@ESL1984 Thank you for sharing man! This info is solid! I read the wiki and now I'm down a rabbit hole reading many others
Stay away from this tech kid !!! You don't have enough hairs on your ass to understand Stark tech !!!
Iron Man suit is 1000% Real !!!
Its something that in fictious world , Tony Stark knows and in Real World , Only I know !!!
All concepts of this dumb engineer does work !!!
For the flying part, you kinda forgot where he got his "BOX OF SCRAPS!" from... missiles. With propulsion systems on them.
He actually has hoses and tanks on the suit for the fuel to fly. It's just enough for a short trip though...
Edit, also the Plasma bit.. in the novelization I think, Tony says he was lying to make her feel better. His chest was infected from having cave surgery, he just didn't want Pepper to panic.
D.U.M.-E us the robot he was making the boot with. He built and programmed that robot in middle school, and it is Jarvis' father essentially. All of his A.I. and companions are built off of that original dunce cap wearing robot arm.
Great explanation! I believe he also used repulsors which emit electromagnetic energy to generate lift.
Jarvis, through being damaged by Ultron, and eventually combined with the Mind Stone, does become an AI as Vision. Advanced enough to understand and feel emotion
That last device that made Tony temporarily paralyzed, I thought seems to attack the nervous system rather than it just being a sound frequency. But I might be wrong. But of course, you have to suspend belief when it comes to these movies.
With the paralysis device it's possible there are subtler things going on than just the sound. The sound might be just a byproduct of the device being on, like how a car's purpose isn't to make car noises. It does seem to require close proximity to the ears, which is why Stane isn't affected, but it might just need to be close to the head. I know strong magnets can affect brain activity in some pretty crazy ways, maybe it uses magnets.
Obadiah isn't affected because he's wearing ear pieces to protect himself. A device like that could for sure use magnets, I wonder if it's real...
@@parychahal I just credit it to StarkTech and accept it. (Again, too much fan fiction?)
The key to Iron Man's armor is that arc reactor.
Given the amount of power it puts out, things like reactionless thrusters become fairly simple.
Add "super materials" like graphene to the mix, and his whole suit goes from fantasy to reality fairly quickly.
Based on the description of the ARC reactor, my best guess for flight is through ion tech. Basically using all of the heat emitted from the reactor to then “ionize” the air around his feat providing a difference in pressure. Thus providing lift
5:20
It actually is protected, if you watch when he's building it, he coats it with a thick layer of plot armor.
😂
Being Engineer is easy but being stan lee is hard
Aye I’m going for electrical engineering
Good choice!
Hey same! Goodluck to us! 🥂
Engineer: the technology is impossible to make
Hacksmith: Hold my red bull
Why didn’t stark make a bunch of Non-human-operated bots to destroy thano’s army
He did in age of Ultron yet his creation turned against the avengers
ask ultron
Good question. Stark knew there was only one outcome (Dr Strange told him in Infinity war) and committed to making mach 85 which would essentially harness the stones for the snap. That was 'the mission.'
Thanos*
He blew them up as a Christmas Firework show in Iron Man 3
Actually Jarvis is an ai not a ui, for example he asks Tony if he wants him to do certain things, that are completely up to Jarvis to ask. For example he might ask Tony is he wants a dinner reservation at a restaurant nearby without any input or programming.
Yes, Jarvis demonstrates independent thinking quite often, and often must carry out tasks where Tony gives him only very high level instruction, and the details are left to Jarvis to figure out.
Wow, you're making me realize alot of stuff. From now on, I'll be focusing MORE on learning and watching these kind of informative videos.
Thanks for the quality content sir, I appreciate it.
electricity produced from his reactor converts them into ion thrusters propulsion which pushes him against gravity. is that a possible
Where does that exist today? Or are you saying it's possible 100 years in the future?
@@parychahalLife yes. maybe in the future, we get a real life iron man.
@@chriskrin for now, we have Elon Musk lol
The Gold Life I do believe ion thrusters exist today and are mainly used on Satellites. They work I think by accelerating cations utilising electricity. They can also neutralise a gas and take some electrons from atoms to create a cloud of positive ions.
@@LiamHolloway No way! Do you have an article or someplace I can read more about it?
When i first watch this when i was 8 years old and i wanted to become eletric eingeering but the thing is i suck at math but i love to read books and are willing to learn got any tips?
Math is nothing more then a language that is used to describe the world around us. Instead of letters, this language uses numbers and symbols. Once you can read/write/understand the language, the world becomes easier to quantify. Anybody can become an engineer with the correct mindset, you got this!
@@parychahal thanks lol
@@Mikeplaysdbd No problem Mr. Wick
@@parychahal yes sir
That doesn't matter , if u r passionate
I think by plasma he is referring to blood plasma. Sir is it possible to have a Ironman helmet.
And also Jarvis understand's stark so he is an AI and an UI.
He said it's plasma for the device not from his body. IDK what you mean by iron man helmet? SIRI understands us, but it's not an AI.
@@parychahal Fanfic reader here again, so what I'm seeing from more from that than movies or comics. JARVIS was designed with a thinking algorithm, made to learn and grow, much as a child would. Tony had J watch Hal and other thinking/controlling computer movies to learn what NOT to do.
Actually technically in the comics he is considered the best human bc he has so much intelligence and is basically a walking human super computer
What about reed richards?
@@Abraham-ui6kc or doctor doom
Much of the Iron Man technology are things that we actually have right now. We have exoskeletons, plating, jet boots, cybernetic helmet that picks up your thought waves; the one thing we don’t have is a power supply. He has an arc reactor thats the size of a hockey puck and puts out the power of 3 nuclear plants, that’s probably nearly impossible to do at the moment.
When I watched this video I was waiting for the scene where Obadiah is shouting to one of his guys to make the arc reactor.
Still, nice informative video! 👍👍👍
Well I'm sorry, I'm not Tony Stark......Thanks for the love Anthony ahaha
Hi, I've been wondering about his "Robot vision"
Does he use projectors on the sides of the mask?
Because if that was the case, it would be ineffective in day light
Could you please make some sense of it
I think it'd be more accurate to say "Heads Up Display" or H.U.D rather than "Robot vision" but if that's what you enjoy saying and much more comfortable with that then I'm not forcing you too. Now how it functions, it could be projectors or it could be hologram tech. We've seen via the mark 6 in The Avengers that the entire front part of the interior of the helmet has lights, judging by that we can assume that there are multiple projectors/hologram devices at play here. This could theoretically negate the problem of external light getting in the way of the projectors/hologram. Another plausible way is the helmet has some form of lenses that protect the inside of the helmet from external factors.
@@apollyonfinch there are actually lenses behind the eye lights, i think those regulate light like sunglasses
@@josdavas9101 Hmmmmm, it's the most likely explanation too I think. Since when there's no power it turns transparent.
@@apollyonfinch can u tell me if there exists some holographic or some display tech that can be used with a distance of < 8-12 cm and works like tony's HUD like no problem in clarity and not so much eye stress ,like we have VR its more over a 30min fun nd after that it gives a lasting stress in our eyes so can we ignore these this by that tech?
@@zx3edits745 As far as I know, we do have hologram tech (i.e. the holographic circus from Austria, not sure how much eye strain this causes though) but not as sophisticated, compact, and clear as Stark's tech.
8:17 I never got the impression that the arm was being controlled solely from Tonys input. I always assumed the arm used machine learning to help tony but also took his input for real time adjustment.
I see most of the people in here are very uninformed about propulsion systems and armor stuff..
The iron man suit's hydraulics might be possible but a flight system? No just no.. i can bet on it,
Theres no fuel which is powerful enough to lift a suit that heavy while having an efficiency so big that you wont have to carry big tanks full of that fuel.
And about the armor, again theres no possibility of making an armor so dense to stop 30 mm rounds and 115 mm rounds from the cannon of a tank... Just impossible.. even super dense materials like depleted uranium arent strong enough to take on multiple 30 mm rounds and we are talking about an armor which is just an inch thick so it wouldn't be possible for it to withstand that much force and energy from powerful munitions like 25,30,115,120 mm rounds and rockets
Electrolysis?
@@maxherrin2764 sorry I accidentally couldn't upload the whole comment together but I've edited the comment now you can read what I wanted to say
Adding to this, I’ve always found that the aerodynamics of the suit don’t work. You can’t, as far as I’m aware, move forward so fast that you don’t fall. Planes do it because they have wings that do some weird air magic to lift the plane upward. Iron Man don’t got wings. The closest thing to flying a suit like this could ever do is hover the way Tony did during the test flight. Add wings to it, and maybe it can happen, but then it drastically changes the suit, and I wouldn’t consider it an Iron Man suit anymore. Without flight, anything we make will be much more akin to the mjolnir armor from Halo, minus energy shields.
Wings aren’t always needed. To help direct it in different directions? Yes. It was displayed in the movie multiple time to turn, and brake. To keep it up and going straight. You just simply have a slight angle of propulsion to aim up. At high speeds, every slight adjustment is more dramatic. So falling isn’t a problem. No tanks needed if you use electrolysis. You create energy as you go. A lot of fuel will be needed yes, but IF...IF you have a batterie that can continue to make that energy, it’s possible. They are currently developing a quantum batterie that also creates energy as it operates. So heat isn’t a “issue”. Things are involving better over time.
@@maxherrin2764 you have no idea what your Talkin about, wings are a must for a efficient sustained flight if you will use the energy from the suit for propulsion so that your suit stays in an angle and doesn't starts "falling" down it would decrease the efficiency by atleast 300 to 400% comparing with the flight systems attached on a wing design and as for fuel.. Electrolysis is literally the worst idea, why?
See electrolysis is a very slow process it doesn't gives out enough fuel in a particular amount of time so that we can use it as a reliable source of energy nor does it gives out a fuel pure enough for actual use in propulsion like for example there's this youtuber russian guy who made a repulsor thing which was fueled by a electrolysis chamber feeding the whole system on Hydrogen gas (flammable) but the fuel wasn't dense or very pure hence could only be used in that hand-held repulsor torch thing and not for the propulsion systems.. as it wouldn't create required amount of force to lift a heavy suit in the air along with you
This "Real engineer " line is a big slap for all engineer out there .
Just came across your channel as I love Ironman and finished watching all of the avengers movies so I was curious. I’m a bio major and feel like changing to something else because I don’t feel motivated to go through with biology anymore. I’m good at math and chemistry and love to make/fix things, I was wondering if you have a suggestion for a few majors I’d potentially be interested/do well in?
I would recommend Biomedical Engineering if your university offers it. I'm not sure how keen you are on coding; if you like it, I'd recommend Electrical Engineering (it's a good mix of hardware and software) If you don't care for it, Mechanical Engineering may interest you.
With coding, there are many free software and youtube tutorials available for you to be at home and try coding for yourself to gauge your interest.
The Gold Life alright thank you! Sorry for the late reply but I remember trying coding in middle school and I didn’t like it that much. I think Mechanical Engineering should be the best for me!
Regarding having no fuel: I think the suit ionizes air that's already there and uses it to thrust. Kind of a super turbine system.
From what I remember of the film. He was using his own weaponry mainly rockets/ missels and breaking them down to create the ironman suit. So rocket propellent and the casing and nozzles would have been available to him. This is not true of further iterations of the suit. Propulsion in later versions came from individual arc reactors that emitted energy straight from their cores and used as a weapon. It's a comic book man. Don't have to be real.
Doesn't have to be real, but its fun to think about how it could be!
The excess heat issue is probably the most difficult to solve if we ever get close to building a real life Iron Man suit. I suppose flight _could_ be effected by ducting air into the suit and superheating it to generate thrust, kind of like the "nuclear ramjet" concept that was envisioned in the Cold War era?
As for JARVIS, that's pretty near what I picture as the pinnacle of interactive UI with smart capabilities that at least _approach_ a universal artificial intelligence, since it is capable of inferring complex instructions from natural language input.
Finally someone smarter than a lightbulb addresses thermodynamics ...
the flight.. when he was testing them, he called them "Flight stabilizers" to Pepper. and that was the hand mounted ports, which are also jets, which gave a significant recoil when he fired. a sustained burst could cause lift and possible flight of running enough power. And the GigaJoules produced by the reactor.. should be enough power. Oh and the lack of covering the reactor in the suits. not a functional reason to leave them open.. it was to make the suit look more like the comics.
Don’t forget, when he lands in the sand after shooting out of the cave, he’d be dead on impact from his crash.
Real engineer? He knows more about science than my science teacher.
Engineers do need to take a quite a bit of science classes for their major so it makes a lot of sense.
Okay so there is a fluid that is used in make up and hair care products, and it is referred to as plasma.
Also there was test they were working on where you have a cone that leads in to an over hanging lip and you had to shoot a high power laser perfectly at the tip of the cone and the laser was supposed to travel evenly across the surface. As the laser curves through the overhanging lip, it super heats the air and makes a puff of plasma. So that in a movie could be the way that it worked, now you just need energy to power it!
Kudos for pointing out that Iron man would pass out in super sonic flight, but you're not entirely right about the need for oxygen. Tony would need some form of g suit to help his blood flow - that's the main thing for not passing out, along with oxygen mask
Imagine how complex the shoulder, neck, wrist, ankle mechanisme is
And if Jarvis is so called “ui” why was he able to basically take down ultron without any command from tony
when did jarvis take down ultron?
@@forsakenstranger2282 age of ultron,when he became vision
It was because he was already vision
@@toe13 yeah but vision isn't jarvis
@Aldin Diez no he didn’t technically defeat ultron but he played a major part into doing so and if he didn’t break ultron down from the inside they wouldn’t have been able to defeat him
From an engineer (me) to an engineer^2, I really like your videos. Please keep doing this stuff.
Thanks for the love Daniel!!
My guy said “Tony stark is a very smart human” but to simplify this the man is a prodigy!!!
I don't watch these movies but Whenever youtube recommend these movie scenes
I break into laughter!!! Clearly you forget to turn off your logic mode when you don't watch these movie scenes and accidentally bump into it
Yes but this engineerer is no tony stark, just sayin.
It's a fusion reactor.
With enough power anything can can fly . The key to having this is obviously a new type of power source that hasn’t been invented yet . And with the limited understanding of our universe it is quit possible that someday we will unlock the secrets to massive amounts of energy in the palms of our hands no pun intended
"With enough power anything can fly." I 100% agree and I'm sure 50yrs from now, we'll have stuff that people couldn't dream up.
@@parychahal not you kiddo !!!
Only I am gonna build this legendary suit in the whole wide universe !!!
And I am not gonna give it to anybody !!!
I have Iron Man's technology since 2017 !
@@freetubemovies.644 is gonna be thanos
@@freetubemovies.644 watch my face and then the news mr.thanos
@@hamzavlogsandgaming6903 well kiddo , your face is too small to see for an ant even !
12:01 for the pass out thing he could implement a g-suit like the one pilots use to pull 10gs.
Fuel was used for the flame throwers and jet boots of the first suit, they showed the fuel tanks in the creation of the suit. The mini arc reactor just powered the servos motors and stuff, all the electronics.
Him: I don’t get how this will happen it’s not possible
Me: it’s freaking iron man he’s way smarter than you 😭
Right lmao. No one else in the mcu understands how tf Tony makes the suits he does. Thats why he's iron man and u don't see weaponized suits everywhere in the army. All I kept thinking every time he said he didn't understand how something would work
Very nice video you should have like a milion subscriber your so good
Thank you for that! Your comment made my day!!
Tony built his helper (Dum-E) as a kid in 1986. He apparently never upgraded it beyond the voice control you mention. Probably some level of nostalgia there or considering it as a pet or something. Still awesome for when it was built.
In terms of how he flew out - wasn’t most of what he built taken from missiles? Makes sense he could have made use of the solid propellant in those to fly out, explains the Space Shuttle style smoke column, (from SRBs) as well as his lack of control in flight.
The largest use of palladium today is in catalytic converters.[46] Palladium is also used in jewelry, dentistry,[46][47] watch making, blood sugar test strips, aircraft spark plugs, surgical instruments, and electrical contacts.[48] Palladium is also used to make professional transverse (concert or classical) flutes.[49] As a commodity, palladium bullion has ISO currency codes of XPD and 964. Palladium is one of only four metals to have such codes, the others being gold, silver and platinum.[50] Because it adsorbs hydrogen, palladium was a key component of the controversial cold fusion experiments of the late 1980s.[51]
YEESSSSSSSSSS FINALLY UA-cam HAS RECOMENDED AN ACTUAL GOOD (and not boring) VIDEO ABOUT ENGINEERING
But probably Tony don't control directly the suit to fly, fly with jets like that can be really complex. Jarvis probably captures Tony gestures and intents (not thoughts), do all that complicated math in real time and take care about all details
I've never thought it until now but at 5:30 tony was using the combined fuel of the missiles that were on the cave, that's how he flew.
U r correct
It is a matter of simple logic that the arc reactor is not the only revolutionary thing in his suit. There are definitely many other things too. The whole suit is revolutionary basically.
Title: real engineer watch iron man.
Indian engineers: Am I a joke to you??
@11:28 Supersonic speed is the speed of an object that exceeds the speed of sound (Mach 1). For objects traveling in dry air of a temperature of 20 °C (68 °F) at sea level, this speed is approximately 343.2 m/s (1,126 ft/s; 768 mph) this speed is only achievable above 2000 feet at 1100 feet the object can begin to tear apart no matter how aerodynamic the vehicle is
The plasma he talks about, is the component of blood, not the state of matter,
just a quick quote from wikipedia "Blood plasma is a yellowish liquid component of blood that holds the blood cells of whole blood in suspension. It is the liquid part of the blood that carries cells and proteins throughout the body. It makes up about 55% of the body's total blood volume."
The reason it discharges plasma is because it’s a fusion reactor. That also solves the heating problem, as most of the heat in a fusion reactor is in the plasma. The walls get cooled by liquid helium or lithium, therefore reducing heat that can get out of the reactor.
The first thing we think about the Ironman suit isn't even how it generate that much power, but how in damn heaven all that electricity can pass from Arc reactor to the suit through that thin wires without overheating to hell...
the word plasma is used for a different context here (like plasma membrane) that happens in science a lot.
He uses ion propulsion system of some kind that uses the power from arc reactor, that is how he produce thrust.
1. Actually if those were military shells (bullets), they are usually steel jacketed (Police/civilian/defense rounds are usually coper jacketed and game rounds are usually lead based). So he'd need a steel that exceeds the toughness of the steel in the bullet jacket.
2. As far as the rockets, he did tear apart at least two missiles for the palladium. It's possible he repurposed the solid boost rockets (I assume the type) used in them
My dream job is to be an engineer and I am gonna be honest
I would pay this man my entire house to be my teacher.
his propulsion system is as far as i know meant to be like qn airbreathing arcjet, so the propellant is the air
The reactor is also supposedly a muon-catalyzed fusion reactor, which could in theory generate dc power at very high efficiency which could run arcjets, but at the supposed 3 GW power level the waste heat is still unmanageable
Also his suit doesn't seem to have air intakes
In regards to the fuel that he was burning for the upward lift when he escaped from the cave in the Mark 1, he did have access to rocket fuel. both for the jet propulsion and for the flamethrowers, they were giving him the raw materials to make missiles, and it only stands to reason that that would include propulsion fuel.
Jarvis is indeed an AI because jarvis becomes vision in avengers age of ultron, and he gets in a relationship with wanda and everything, so that proves that he is AI.