Is Metal BETTER Or WORSE Than It Used To Be?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,3 тис.

  • @BradleyHallGuitar
    @BradleyHallGuitar  Рік тому +230

    What are YOUR thoughts then? Do you prefer modern or classic Metal??

    • @TheMusicman-tv8pl
      @TheMusicman-tv8pl Рік тому +22

      Middle

    • @oSileyCT-7212
      @oSileyCT-7212 Рік тому +6

      I love Metallica and Fit For A King sooo

    • @CraniosFofosAntigo
      @CraniosFofosAntigo Рік тому +53

      Classic, most modern metal is a sumo competition, whoever is heavier wins

    • @MegaMicah12
      @MegaMicah12 Рік тому +5

      I'm starting to become more neutral, as a bunch of the issues modern metal has, were also apparent back then.

    • @_yuhkami
      @_yuhkami Рік тому +5

      everything i will eat

  • @Jack_Fuego
    @Jack_Fuego Рік тому +1313

    Hradley Balls

  • @oyc7946
    @oyc7946 Рік тому +457

    As someone who absolutely loves 80s metal I'm glad that theres still 80s revival bands like Fortress, Riot City, Antioch, Skull Fist, Air Raid etc. playing the same old 80s style with a modern touch

    • @Sixfootdig
      @Sixfootdig Рік тому +12

      Steel panther

    • @MegaMicah12
      @MegaMicah12 Рік тому +12

      The NWOTHM in general has been a great evolution of truly traditional metal, and I am all for it, considering how well Doom evolved with that mindset.

    • @SpacemanXC
      @SpacemanXC Рік тому +12

      Modern thrash metal is fucking amazing. Power Trip, Lich King, Vektor, Inhuman Nature, Enforced. All these guys fucking rule 🤘

    • @JustPuckinAround
      @JustPuckinAround Рік тому +5

      I love the NWOTHM movement, although I wish some of those bands were a little more innovative. The classic heavy metal formula is great but bands shouldn't be afraid to reinvent themselves whilst staying true to the trad metal roots. I like that Striker is taking risks with some of their more recent material. Their last single had bongos and funk syncopation beneath soaring power metal leads. I'd love to see trad bands take on a jazz or funk influence. I think it would make for some incredibly underrated music.

    • @lanzarlaluna
      @lanzarlaluna Рік тому +3

      @@SpacemanXCI like Gama Bomb, too.

  • @danielkane1080
    @danielkane1080 Рік тому +43

    I'm a 50+ metalhead and I have to say that this is really a very well balanced critique. Kudos, sir.

  • @ShieldYoung
    @ShieldYoung Рік тому +111

    As good as Modern metal is I haven't found tons of songs that I would revisit more and more but for the classics that is frequent

    • @brennanfry3768
      @brennanfry3768 Рік тому +7

      Yep I'm only 25 and I have a really hard time getting into the new sound. I listen to everything from Black Sabbath, to early Skyclad, Sodom, Fates Warning the list goes on for classic metal but maybe enjoy 20 albums after 2000.

    • @ShieldYoung
      @ShieldYoung Рік тому

      @@brennanfry3768 same I enjoy and appreciate new songs but there comes a few songs that I'm interested to visit again soon

    • @intenzityd3181
      @intenzityd3181 Місяць тому

      Modern metal is shit because it has been redditified. You only have to look at the skinny-fat nu-males and feminists that are modern metalheads to understand why the genre is such a joke and why there is no creative spirit. Metal was originally daring and hyper-masculine, now it is risk-averse and utterly emasculated. Pure reddit cringe.

  • @Kalebsweeten
    @Kalebsweeten Рік тому +128

    Completely agree here. I love both eras, mainly because my dad got me into all the old school bands before I got into modern acts. It actually goes both ways. My dad is WAY into modern metal that I introduced him to.

  • @saddocatto9245
    @saddocatto9245 Рік тому +114

    now, make "Is canned bean BETTER Or WORSE Then It Used To Be??"

    • @BradleyHallGuitar
      @BradleyHallGuitar  Рік тому +36

    • @waltysalamander
      @waltysalamander Рік тому +14

      The quality of canned beans has undoubtedly declined in recent years. The bean farmers of rural Appalachia and Tibet (just to name some of the big bean farming regions) have started to put quantity over quality. The days of the boutique bean shop have passed and we are now being fed mass market garbanzos and corporate pintos instead of the humble beans of the past. It’s a sad time to live in but Serious Bean Co. is working to change that!

    • @stephenhughes5156
      @stephenhughes5156 Рік тому +2

      Probably worse because I'm pretty sure they reduced the sugar/salt content. Which is kinda good for health but no so much for that beany tasty goodness.

    • @stephenhughes5156
      @stephenhughes5156 Рік тому

      ​@@waltysalamanderBig Bean is oppressing the masses.

    • @bezoticallyyours83
      @bezoticallyyours83 Рік тому +2

      ​@@waltysalamandertruly a sad time in history

  • @Matthew_Klepadlo
    @Matthew_Klepadlo Рік тому +203

    It’s like a spectrum, going from the classic era to the modern era.
    Classic can be represented as yellow, whilst modern can be represented as green.
    I’m the type of person who most likes and fits in with the yellow to lime green era, and some green stuff as well.
    I’m more of an oldie for sure, but it’s not impossible for me to adore more recent stuff.
    Anyways, I’ll have to get back to

    • @BradleyHallGuitar
      @BradleyHallGuitar  Рік тому +27

      That's a cool way to look at it!

    • @frankvandorp2059
      @frankvandorp2059 Рік тому +8

      That's a very linear way to look at it, as if metal has always been this one thing that was once yellow and since turned green.
      Instead, I would think it makes more sense to see metal like a tree, with one single trunk that has since diverged into countless different branches. Some branches I really like, other branches I could do without.
      And any comparison of "which is better?" really doesn't make sense anymore, because which of the hundred branches is the "modern metal" you're comparing the "classic metal" to?

    • @skaldlouiscyphre2453
      @skaldlouiscyphre2453 Рік тому +2

      So umm, what's blue? Hardcore?

    • @Matthew_Klepadlo
      @Matthew_Klepadlo Рік тому +4

      @@frankvandorp2059
      Fair point honestly. I mean, time is linear, and time obviously has an effect on metal, but yeah, the linear spectrum I spoke of really doesn’t account for all the outgrown branches much.

    • @metaltigerdude5780
      @metaltigerdude5780 Рік тому +2

      I'd say most of the criticisms about modern metal really only apply to the superficial normie bands. Go deeper than Ax7 and Jinjr and you'll find the heritage of classic metal is alive and well.
      It's thriving even. I'd say we're in something of a new golden age. In twenty years, bands like Power Trip, Tomb Mold, Black Braid, and Bell Witch will become mythic names just as much as Slayer or Priest ever were.

  • @hanglooserecluse
    @hanglooserecluse Рік тому +70

    All I can say is the 80s and 90s is a time I was glad to be part of, it’s a case of , “you had to be there”. Nothing can replace that era

  • @random_dude69420
    @random_dude69420 Рік тому +43

    I like classic metal more but I’m not really much of a metal head anyway. But by god, this is way too accurate. When you talked about rock star personalities, I could instantly hear in my mind “despite his talent, Ritchie Blackmore was a miserable git” from your “best and worst things about these bands” video

  • @aidangray1910
    @aidangray1910 Рік тому +75

    just wanted to say that i absolutely love your content Bradley!! you deliver everything so, so well. every second is funny and entertaining!

  • @DoubleNullVoid00
    @DoubleNullVoid00 Рік тому +31

    I’m in the middle tbf. I love both classic and modern. The only problem I have with modern stuff is the genre is over saturated with metalcore which does sound extremely same-y.

    • @MetalGildarts
      @MetalGildarts Рік тому +8

      That’s exactly why I avoid it.

    • @andjustjizzforall
      @andjustjizzforall Рік тому +14

      Yep and the constant down tuning to low fucking chug shit is not my taste at all. It just takes over the bass side of things and leaves less room for bass guitar in the mix, just making it sound like bean fuelled shit. Classic metal all the way for me

    • @MetalGildarts
      @MetalGildarts Рік тому +3

      @@andjustjizzforall long live the classics.

  • @JustPuckinAround
    @JustPuckinAround Рік тому +60

    As a zoomer, I started with the modern stuff but eventually returned to monke with the 80s trad/US power metal. The vibes are there. Not really into edgy music anymore but I can respect what the modern djent/core/etc bands are doing. I wish neo-traditional bands would innovate a touch more; I feel like it would really push that subgenre forward.

    • @stephenhughes5156
      @stephenhughes5156 Рік тому +3

      Finally, someone else that mentions US Power Metal. There's so many incredible bands/Albums in the genre, yet it seems to get overlooked for some reason. Way better than the European Power Metal. Any particular favourite bands/Albums?
      I can see what you mean by the lack of innovation with neo- traditional bands. However, I think that was kind of the idea- getting away from the need to constantly innovate and getting back to just making the ol' Metal that we love. Of course, some bands took the 'trad' worship a bit too far and just ended up sounding like generic rip- offs. But then there are also those who still sounded awesome and genuine.
      And there are still somewhat innovative bands within that space too. Lazarus AD did a great job fusing old school thrash with a more modern 'NWOAHM' sound. Steelwings last album was definitely one of the more unique 'trad' albums. In Solitudes last album was a weird fusion of trad Metal with like Joy Division or some shit. Enforcers latest album is like if ABBA were a NWOBHM band. And then theres Vektor.

    • @metalheadrailfan
      @metalheadrailfan Рік тому

      Take a gander at bands like Haunt, Eternal Champion, Enforcer, Visigoth and Unto Others. I'd think they'll give you what you're looking for.

    • @JustPuckinAround
      @JustPuckinAround Рік тому

      @@metalheadrailfan Already a fan of all of those bands 🤘

  • @ShaneT5S
    @ShaneT5S Рік тому +67

    I'm a more modern metal fan, but I can still love and respect the classic metal. I'm glad you mentioned Poppy because I love her genre bending. I honestly think you hit the nail on the head with the pros and cons for each eras of metal. My favourite band lately is Nekrogoblikon, their last album was my favourite album of the year

    • @ehhh2547
      @ehhh2547 Рік тому +1

      ell yeah, nekrogoblikon is awesome

    • @frankvandorp2059
      @frankvandorp2059 Рік тому +1

      I saw Nekrogoblikon live a couple of years back, together with Gloryhammer and Wind Rose. I don't think anyone who went to that concert would say that modern metal doesn't "have enough fun".

    • @thex6992
      @thex6992 Рік тому

      @@frankvandorp2059 It's sad that poppy and ghostename never did a real collab when they were together, I loved ghostemanes Anti Icon and she did some good metal genre mix stuff too

    • @indenturedLemon
      @indenturedLemon Рік тому

      nekrogoblikon is v good, saw them live and they killed it

    • @cowbutt6
      @cowbutt6 Рік тому +1

      TBH genre-bending has always been around in metal: whether it was thrash blending punk with metal, or bands like Sabbat (blackened thrash), Skyclad (folk thrash), Paradise Lost (gothic metal, as well as their more controversial electronic period), Anthrax (rap metal), Therion (symphonic metal), Dub War (reggae metal), Senser (?!?) and more besides...

  • @metalh3adqueen
    @metalh3adqueen Рік тому +53

    I started off with oldschool 80s metal and it will always have a special place in my heart bcs of that, but since I'm part of a younger generation Ive recently been feeling somehow more connected to modern metal, because... I mean... at least I'm ALIVE in this era of music lol

    • @HotSkorpion
      @HotSkorpion Рік тому +2

      The ultimate proof is the test of time and i honestly doubt moat modern bands, as technically more advanced they may be, will still be talked about in 50years... the over the top lifestyles were more than just antics. It showed that these people lived, had fun and went through struggles, which in turn, reflected in the music. Whos gonna know who henson and polyphia in 50 years? Most people have no idea who they are now. But ask anyone about Ozzy, Hetfield, Mustaine and the lot and there are few that have never heard of them. Music stands the test of time when it carries the musicians heart and emotions with it. Most moderm musicians are more concerned in making a product, or a proof of challenge.

  • @joedebusky8801
    @joedebusky8801 Рік тому +8

    I agree with a lot of what you said here.
    I’m in my early 20's and I listen to mostly "classic" metal, I feel like it's what made me different than some of my friends who are mostly listening to the newer bands. Although I am expanding my tastes onto the more modern metal bands and songs, my issue with it however is that a lot of it just feels too mechanical and boxed in. Now sometimes it can sound good, but I feel like too many bands are trying to accomplish the same thing. Often times it makes me think “all of these bands sound the same.”
    What I like about the older stuff is the aforementioned "organic" feel when bands would all play together naturally without the reliance of a click track and still worked with imperfections which sometimes would bring out the best in the song. Plus the imperfections in both performance/mixing bring the out the raw emotion. The rawness of it made it feel more 'real' if that makes sense. I honestly wish more newer bands would take more chances with how they execute their performance and mixing.
    I think fans of older and newer can find something good out of both eras.

  • @sofiarousaki8834
    @sofiarousaki8834 Рік тому +5

    My god, this is so well-balanced and spherical! I find myself agreeable on all the points you've posed, and you phrased them so accurately. Loved it! I'd also add that it's a matter of age as well. Tastes are formulated during people's crucial 15-25 years of age. Being born in 1979 I find myself more keen on the music of my age, irrespective of all the factors you pointed. However, it is true that all the pros of the past are the cons of the present and vice versa!

  • @DeathMachineJoe
    @DeathMachineJoe Рік тому +9

    Pretty spot on with this and I agree with most of your points. For me personally, I love it when a more modern band is able to blend a clean sounding mix with the some of the rawness that you would hear on earlier records. It still keeps that human feel to the performance without sounding dated as hell.
    A good example of this is Insomnium's latest album Anno 1696. There's definitely a polish to the overall mix, but you can still tell that the instruments were actually recorded in the studio. Sure, there might be a touch of triggers/sampling on the bass drum or quantization here and there, but the overall band performance on that album still feels natural.
    I understand that programming drums or other instruments on a computer is cheaper than going to actual to studio to track the instruments. But sometimes, I can't help but turn off a new album if the mixing is so cleaned up and polished to where it feels like no real instruments were actually recorded (especially when you record live drums, but then just slap a ton samples on the performance to the point where it doesn't feel real anymore).
    Point is, there's great things about both the classic and modern era of metal. You just have to find bands that can effectively use old and new recording tactics to their advantage while obviously writing great songs along with it.

  • @simonslee73
    @simonslee73 Рік тому +10

    Totally agree, and I think what’s important too is with those old classic rock stars and there wild antics, they brought a sense of danger to their music.
    With modern, it’s technical and clinical but there is very little danger as everyone is so safe these days, so the music suffers for it, metal is supposed to feel like it’s literally on the edge of crazy

    • @stephenhughes5156
      @stephenhughes5156 Рік тому +1

      Very true. Its the same thing with Pro Wrestling too. Back in the day they were living the life of rockstars, doing shit loads of steroids and coke. Now they are skinny nerds that just play video games 😂

    • @bezoticallyyours83
      @bezoticallyyours83 Рік тому +1

      Agreed

  • @Syndicate_01
    @Syndicate_01 Рік тому +15

    I've liked both ever since I became a metalhead as a teenager. Love Dio, just saw Judas Priest last fall and Helloween a few months back, but I'm pumped to see Blackbraid and some other black metal bands in the months to come.

    • @MetalGildarts
      @MetalGildarts Рік тому +1

      Breeeeh I saw Priest last year and Helloween in May, phenomenal bands. Love Dio as well.

    • @Syndicate_01
      @Syndicate_01 Рік тому +1

      @@MetalGildarts Nice, we def caught the same tours then!

    • @MetalGildarts
      @MetalGildarts Рік тому +1

      @@Syndicate_01 frick yeah! I saw JP here in Utah and I caught Helloween in Denver on May 30.

  • @mejsjalv
    @mejsjalv Рік тому +4

    I like the classic metal more, just because it seems the older I get, the harder it is to get into new music. I'm also still discovering a lot of the classic stuff now that pretty much everything is out there for free, compared to the pre-internet days of saving money to buy albums, trading tapes and even going to a friend's house to listen to whatever he got.
    But still, gotta give it to the new generations, a lot of guitarists and drummers got so f-ing good it's unreal.

  • @zoranbl1990
    @zoranbl1990 Рік тому +19

    Classic heavy, thrash and power are still the best, it has something special. But, if you take classic sound and modern sound together you will get LOVEBITES... BAD ASS! I have never been more impressed by any metal band EVER. These girls are PURE GOLD.

  • @6balanced9
    @6balanced9 Рік тому +3

    I'd say you nailed it. Me I listen to both recently I've been diving into more of the stuff from the past but I love both styles more of a mood thing really.

  • @liebe4442
    @liebe4442 Рік тому +7

    Kind of why I love GWAR so much, they vibe with whatever is going on at the time (while viciously mocking it), they really play around with their sound, They never sold out and they’ll never get boring.
    (R.I.P Dave Brockie thank you for creating the craziest and most ridiculous band in the universe).

  • @endergreek4016
    @endergreek4016 Рік тому +41

    I love how finally someone mentions the sterile sound some modern bands can have. Really something

    • @theatomicpunkkid
      @theatomicpunkkid Рік тому

      Absolutely right and it's more than just 1 or 2 of them. It's also been a very long time since they've talked about rocking out on the radio and living to rock and rocking to live And that's because they don't period End of report. Tell me when the last time that That 1 guitar just Blew them away and so they started rocking and singing about the bands that inspired them or even talking about Them.

    • @dougmasters4561
      @dougmasters4561 Рік тому +2

      Finally?
      All of us in the 'charmingly vintage' age range have been saying thisbfor years

    • @endergreek4016
      @endergreek4016 Рік тому

      @@dougmasters4561 Good to know, I heard it here for the first time tho.. good to say that perfection lies in imperfection thats why I love "disgusting" music as they like to say

  • @coolcatreturnsdavis9955
    @coolcatreturnsdavis9955 Рік тому +2

    Bro hit all the details on the head, literally everything I believe in metal. This is why you're my favorite UA-cam guitarist ❤

  • @GlebKuzntesov
    @GlebKuzntesov Рік тому +5

    Modern metal music being quantized and normalized is the reason I hate it. Somehow it just doesn't stay in the head. Goes into one ear and goes out of the other, as they say. Agree with Marty Friedman who blames modern American music for being perfected to inhuman level and praises the Japanese concept of heta-uma, "a voice that is not so good, but has a magic to it that is far more attractive than pristine vocal technique" or just "bad but good"

  • @Booya456
    @Booya456 Рік тому +3

    Growing up with classic metal, I loved it. As I got older, and thanks to my parents, I got exposure to the then and now simultaneously. I can still throw back the classic era from time to time, but I've honestly grown out of much of it. I love finding new artists that are innovative/inspired. I've been around too many people who only stick to the old better times" without ever really embracing anything new. And I tire of every rock station playing Welcome to the Jungle 5 times a day on the radio.

    • @lechgolas6400
      @lechgolas6400 Рік тому

      Mind you name some of those new inspired metal artists?

    • @maurobrandolt2166
      @maurobrandolt2166 2 місяці тому

      thats exactly what i think too!!

  • @jonasfischer878
    @jonasfischer878 Рік тому +7

    Best shot for modern metal (as you said), the home producing. I think (I hope) we're gonna see much more talents emerge with the help of social media or maybe finding themselves to form bands, and enjoy creative freedom more as side-projects and not being at the mercy of big labels (as in hiphop scene one of my fav artists R. A. the rugged man already pointed out: every major label sucks d*cks :D), so I'm thrilled for the future 🤘🏼

    • @cowbutt6
      @cowbutt6 Рік тому +1

      In defense of record labels(!), the better labels acted as a quality filter. These days, there's so much new music out there that it's hard to know where to start.
      I'd pay money for personally curated recommendations from the likes of Peaceville's Hammy, or producer Colin Richardson.

    • @joriankell1983
      @joriankell1983 Рік тому

      It won't happen often, if at all.

  • @richardmetzler7909
    @richardmetzler7909 Рік тому +3

    Back in the day: bands get shafted by labels. Glorious present: bands get shafted by streaming services and ticket sale monopolists.

  • @hollienn2006
    @hollienn2006 Рік тому +2

    I like both. About a year ago when I was new to metal, I only really listened to thrash and heavy metal bands from the 80s, but over the last few months, I’ve really been getting into metalcore and deathcore, but I still like older bands as well.

  • @ChrisShawIOM
    @ChrisShawIOM Рік тому +1

    Superb vid mate. Sums up my thoughts exactly and nice to know it’s not just me. The imperfections is exactly what makes the older metal bands sound so raw and human. Mixing is an issue, true. I feel this too. Still great to listen to though. Rock on brother 🤘🏻

  • @LosPompadores
    @LosPompadores Рік тому +8

    Your 'what you don't like about. modern metal..' list for a large part explains why I love Babymetal. They play metal and they actually make me smile, all the while playing sick riffs and demonstrating top class song writing. Ignore the last album, which is a bit drab. Mind you, I love the last A7X album to bits as well, so happy happy joy joy isn't always on the top of my list.

    • @Rekon-se6wv
      @Rekon-se6wv Рік тому +2

      I love cute girls being cute

  • @yurikrupin6907
    @yurikrupin6907 Рік тому +2

    I just love to see metal evolving through the years. There were many amazing bands in the 80-s, 90-s, hell, every decade produced awesome bands that absolutely shreds! So I guess metal was awesome back then and it is amazing now.

  • @matteocoda6368
    @matteocoda6368 Рік тому +4

    What you said is true.
    I remember rehearsing the whole master of puppets in the practice room while being recorded "vintagely" with proper microphones set up near amps and drums. That was in early 2000s and it cost some money for 15 year old kids like us.
    We literally rehearsed to death that song because the time was limited and we couldn't afford more. One screw in 8 minute song and we had to start all over again.
    But when we heard ourselves we felt like Metallica themselves (probably better than them ahahah)
    Greetings from Italy.

  • @vayzeria
    @vayzeria Рік тому +4

    Both are good. It's the recording and mixing/mastering that also creates the sound. If a early Iron Maiden recorded today, the e would sound completely different.

  • @DJTheMetalheadMercenary
    @DJTheMetalheadMercenary Рік тому +5

    Pretty on point with this one mate. I listen to both old and new and love 'em for what they are, in more modern times I'm big on the Dissonant Black and Death Metal scenes apart from other subgenre-fusion and scenes that are a bit more organic and are doing really cool things. Definitely not a fan of some of the modern-time sterility in production and some of the guitar tones that lose that snarl and crunch with Amp and Pedal settings (or lack thereof-- and seriously, Djent is NOT a word and I hate that tone lol), there's a fine balance to implement both new and old together and make it work to much better degree with or without label support.

  • @readymade83
    @readymade83 Рік тому +2

    You could apply this argument to any style of music or media for that matter. The biggest piece is that people need to understand that technology changes and younger generations will take advantage of the new opportunities to try something different.

  • @KeanuChrist
    @KeanuChrist Рік тому +9

    I definitely appreciate the classics I grew up with but I’m more of a fan of modern metal.

  • @rdmoonie
    @rdmoonie Рік тому +2

    Highkey, as a tech death enjoyer. The old school feeling is still alive and well in alot of newer releases, that's the case in death metal in general (of course maybe not with bigger household bands).

  • @thex6992
    @thex6992 Рік тому +4

    I love Metal from any time period, there are always artists that just make you feel something. My favorite bands are mostly newer ones just because I enjoy the way they sound the most, It's also mostly bands that have their very own style I can recognize instantly when I hear them. I also love experimentation a lot, I'd rather hear something that no one has dared to do before and maybe not like it than something that a band created way back and made it sound the best. Of course there are exceptions as well. Metal in general is just amazing. I love it.

    • @henrywalton5967
      @henrywalton5967 Рік тому

      Have you heard Terminal Redux 👀?

    • @thex6992
      @thex6992 Рік тому

      @@henrywalton5967 Yeah I've recommended that album in a different reply under this video lol it's highly underrated for how good it is imo

    • @springbloom5940
      @springbloom5940 Рік тому +1

      Metal was always about pushing the boundaries, standing out and competition to be the best. Now its about sounding exactly like your favorite guitarist. I blame democratization of good equipment. Its completely killed all the innovation. Style used to be a necessity to cope with technical limitations.

  • @jockelfernau8207
    @jockelfernau8207 Рік тому +17

    When I started playing guitar in 1990 all that was available to me was low quality gear. When you look at the prices and quality of for example Harley Benton today, it's just not comparable to what we spend our hard earned money on back than. I think this is even a bigger advantage for todays young musicians than internet lessons or tab apps.

    • @henrywalton5967
      @henrywalton5967 Рік тому +1

      Also in terms of recording your own music it's quite easy and cheap now. And using software to program drums. Definitely been a great tool to help me with my writing.

  • @putridabomination
    @putridabomination Рік тому +13

    Worse if you choose what people call "modern metal" but if your idea of modern metal is just any new band then no. There's always more or less real metal carrying the sound of older bands with some really interesting takes on the subgenres.

  • @ginobufu7183
    @ginobufu7183 Рік тому

    I love how Bradley used his video of 50 years of metal as the background audio

  • @martins.8902
    @martins.8902 Рік тому +3

    I love both types, my favorite Bands are Judas Priest and Lorna Shore. I have to say the Riffs became better and more complex but the Guitar Solos of the old days are unmatched, so much soul and creativity.

  • @dimitriydzyuba218
    @dimitriydzyuba218 Рік тому +1

    The sheer amount of bands and artists blending metal with other genres and styles is definitely something I enjoy about modern metal too. Stuff ranging from 80s synth-pop, jazz, literally every kind of folk music under the sun, and so much more! It's a great time for fusion genres honestly

  • @saddocatto9245
    @saddocatto9245 Рік тому +9

    I love good metal, modern or classic doesn't matter. Good music is good.

    • @dougmasters4561
      @dougmasters4561 Рік тому

      Agreed but in the eighties, if you put on a blindfold and just randomly picked a metal cassette youd have a far greater chance of it being good and interesting than if you did that today

  • @gibsonsimpson
    @gibsonsimpson Рік тому

    Your analysis is spot on. I am glad there is such a huge variety of metal that there is something for anyone. I like what I like and do my best not to dump on others preferences. Long live metal!

    • @KingCrimson82
      @KingCrimson82 Рік тому +1

      i am glad that an op guitar player like him resonates with the classic stuff more.

  • @Spoon8lld
    @Spoon8lld Рік тому +4

    As someone who loves classic metal, my favorite is actually newer bands who take elements of classic metal and infuse modern elements.
    Songs like Pray for Blood by Skull Servant and early Ghost records

  • @DanSkinny
    @DanSkinny Рік тому +1

    This is now my power point for presenting my own thoughts that I couldn’t come up with on my own. Thanks for your hard work lmao
    Seriously- great video and 200000% agree

  • @Howard_the_Duck
    @Howard_the_Duck Рік тому +9

    You're not talking about modern metal here. You're talking about metalcore.

    • @vonicrimson3619
      @vonicrimson3619 Рік тому +3

      I hate to break it to you but sleep token has no hardcore influence, they aren’t metalcore

  • @kenigma4303
    @kenigma4303 Рік тому

    Hard agree on all points mate! I feel like you could have a video for each point. A pro and con for classic and modern metal to further break it down with specific examples from each band or individual.

  • @mauro1427
    @mauro1427 Рік тому +12

    my two favourite bands are metallica, megadeth followed by gojira and trivium, so i think i can say i love modern metal as much as i love classic metal

    • @MetalGildarts
      @MetalGildarts Рік тому +1

      All great bands.

    • @kadriblabali
      @kadriblabali Рік тому +4

      gojira and trivium blew up in the mid 2000's tho, almost 20 years ago, not sure we can count that as modern metal... I think at this point it's the middle area between the classic and modern

    • @WeReNeR-k2f
      @WeReNeR-k2f Рік тому +1

      ​@@kadriblabalitrivium's latest albums aren't worse, or maybe even better than they made in 00's and IMO Gojira's second greatest album was released in 2013, so not than old, compared to banda that are usually considered "Classic Metal"

  • @berganssekk
    @berganssekk Рік тому

    Good points well made. Particularly about the production and mixing compared from then to now.

  • @tmage23
    @tmage23 Рік тому +3

    It is far more diverse. I grew up in the 80s where there was NWOBHM, traditional metal, hard rock, hair metal, thrash metal and a smattering of some proto black and death metal bands and a few prog metal bands.
    Now you have completely distinct genres within genres within genres. A cynic would say that metal has been balkanized and is worse for it but I think a more accurate perspective is that there's a band out there for you regardless of what kind of metal appeals to you.

  • @TropicalGardeningCyprus
    @TropicalGardeningCyprus Рік тому +1

    Exactly on point. My only difference is that I can't really enjoy new stuff anymore. I've fallen down to the sad ''everything sounds like farting'' situation and I can enjoy only my favourite stuff from the 70's and 80's with the only exception the music that Sakis Tolis releases from time to time because they're simple, melodic and calming.

  • @EtherealSoul1111
    @EtherealSoul1111 Рік тому +4

    People just don't know where to listen to modern metal, there are so many godly bands out there: Kingdom of Giants, Twelve Foot Ninja, The Ocean, Whitechapel, Trivium, TesseracT, etc.
    The classics will be always the classics tho, both parts are good but you gotta put your sight in future metal and how to improve it

  • @timwhite5562
    @timwhite5562 Рік тому +2

    8:57 Turds of misery.
    I used to have this problem; screaming out in pain and strain😖, having to use everything within arms reach as handhold to stabilize yourself for those death defying pushes and breaking them off the wall as a result, leaving the aftermath to look like an elk got trapped inside and was thrashing around trying to escape🦌, etc.
    Like classic metal, sometimes the old ways are the best, in this scenario old fashioned Mineral oil works wonders. You get lubed from the inside out, allowing for an easier escape route (in a manner of speaking). Like modern recording it saves time, eliminating the need to set aside that 60-90 minute recovery period, where you have to lay on your side waiting for everything to close back up lest you risk having half of your internal organs falling out afterwards😯.
    Hope this tip helps. 👍

  • @edgeofsanity9111
    @edgeofsanity9111 Рік тому +4

    Well most of those points are very fair
    However a lot of those oldschool songs don't have such terrible mixes (although they're much better these days) and the looks, well who cares it's about the music anyway
    And it just feels like modern metal bands are just in a competition to be the heaviest and tune the lowest which comes at the cost of songwriting imo
    Besides, I just like the style of the oldschool subgenres
    Thanks to the New Wave of Traditional Heavy Metal for bringing back the oldschool sound in modern sound quality

  • @ELFBOYMUSIC
    @ELFBOYMUSIC Рік тому +2

    The thing I like most about classic metal is Bradley Halls. The thing I like most about modern metal is Hradley Balls.

  • @garysuarez9614
    @garysuarez9614 Рік тому +9

    The techniques of technical picking and mixing in the new stuff has me blown away.
    Love the old stuff too. Its organic and powerful because of it.
    edit: Clowncore is awesome on all levels.

    • @Fkod88
      @Fkod88 Рік тому +1

      Agreed re Clowncore!

  • @repentnow1720
    @repentnow1720 Рік тому

    BH - Listen to OFR by Nitro 3 times in a row - The first time you'll laugh uncontrollably, the second time you'll hear things you missed / overlooked / discounted, and after the 3rd time you'll be chanting NITRO NITRO NITRO !!! Luv your content : )

  • @duncandisorderly
    @duncandisorderly Рік тому +3

    What's wrong with the production on 'Altars or madness' or Death's 'Human' both still sound great to my ears!

  • @rogerwalker2224
    @rogerwalker2224 Рік тому

    You worked your ass off with that editing. kudos!

  • @David-yk5tq
    @David-yk5tq Рік тому +4

    I think that we tend to look back at the best things from the past, and that blurries our perception of the world. Not just with metal, but with everything in general. It's not like every metal band from the past sounded like Metallica or Judas Priest. Having said that, I think that modern metal in the mainstream is kinda dead. But, I also think there are some unkown metal bands / artists which are great and experiment with the genre, in sites like Soundcloud

    • @guywinar6309
      @guywinar6309 Рік тому

      Yep, survivorship bias is very real. There was some reeaal garbage back before too.

  • @jetstream9559
    @jetstream9559 Рік тому

    Great analysis! Well done! I agree with all points! All of them, you hear me? All!

  • @jamieblount-leahy8621
    @jamieblount-leahy8621 Рік тому +5

    Metal new= good
    Metal old= good
    In conclusion, metal= good

  • @csj9619
    @csj9619 Рік тому

    First off, lemme say I like old stuff and new stuff too. One thing 'bout ye olde days of metal is how many people were into it, or at least one form of metal. Stadiums and arenas selling all the tickets, groupees lined up near tour busses, black concert t-shirts, dirt rockers, head-bangers and the list goes on. Those were truly magical times.

  • @TheMusicman-tv8pl
    @TheMusicman-tv8pl Рік тому +3

    Modern metal usually gets 177 string guitars and mostly uses the top string, wether classic metals lowest tuning is probably drop d

  • @That80sGuitarist
    @That80sGuitarist Рік тому

    Love these types of videos! You should start a podcast and talk about this sort of stuff on it🤘

  • @alonsoratatin
    @alonsoratatin Рік тому +12

    "All songs sound the same" is easily applicable to all music genres.

    • @stephenhughes5156
      @stephenhughes5156 Рік тому

      Kinda. But not really. That phrase applies a lot more to certain genres ie Metalcore/Deathcore, Trap, whatever this Latin music that people like is called- than others. Sure, there are similarities with bands like Metallica, Megadeth, Anthrax, Slayer, Overkill, Testament, Sepultura, Flotsam & Jetsam- but they sound way more distinctive from eachother than a lot of these modern metalcore/deathcore/djent bands.

    • @bezoticallyyours83
      @bezoticallyyours83 Рік тому

      I was thinking that myself

    • @maurobrandolt2166
      @maurobrandolt2166 2 місяці тому

      @@stephenhughes5156 thats bcs you prolly heard these trash bands a lot to be able to easily identify the differences between them, but if you were a modern metalcore lover you would surely identify lots different details from these newer bands...

  • @anthonymcglynn630
    @anthonymcglynn630 Рік тому +1

    I agree with a lot of this. Always had an appreciation for contemporary stuff and the classics. Sterility is often what puts me off modern bands - indistinct production and music that's high on skill but low on groove and feel. Then, a lot of old school bands are kinda boring now, and I sometimes find their audiences to be a little elitist and set in their ways.
    But there are huge exceptions either way. One of my favorite albums ever, 'Fade' by Cloudkicker, was recorded by one dude in his room exactly as described here, and I'm very likely to pick something pre-1990 pretty much any time I'm just casually putting something on!

  • @oldmanshreds
    @oldmanshreds Рік тому +11

    I agree with you. Classic metal brings forth so much more "feel", fun and memorable solos/riffs. In modern metal, the good stuff is available in bandcamp and through small indie labels. Bands like Ghost and Mastodon has great songwriting, but overall I get more out of Michael Schenker solos and King Diamond catalogue than, like Spiritbox

  • @Typical.Anomaly
    @Typical.Anomaly Рік тому

    Holy shit, I thought that thumbnail was an emaciated Glenn Fricker!

  • @paramourcat
    @paramourcat Рік тому +3

    Maybe it wasn't as much of a thing in metal, but if you go out in the music industry in general or maybe a little earlier in time, band members actually didn't have to be all that tight in the studio. The studio/producer/label or whoever would just call in their session guy to record the part while the bass player was too drunk to play or whatever.
    Also there's been an interesting interview with Steve Vai recently where he talks about how he actually avoided losing all his money to a label by just paying like $12.50 to create his own "label" so that he could sell his albums directly to the distributors and make tons of money instead of the industry standard record deal which would have paid him miserably.

  • @BrianBower
    @BrianBower Рік тому

    I absolutely love old and new metal. I think you made some great points here and a fun video to boot.

  • @deannelson7027
    @deannelson7027 Рік тому +3

    I like both old metal and new metal.

  • @AirborneAshes
    @AirborneAshes Рік тому +1

    solid breakdown. carcass is a great example for classic metal phenomena, the engineering on the first albums sounds like they recorded on a block of wood, but the tightest band you will ever hear live onstage. and their music still holds up.
    as much as i love animals as leaders, i have witnessed them mess up. carcass? never

    • @mylerwilson4879
      @mylerwilson4879 Рік тому

      But their first record is shit, Bill Steer’s himself doesn’t like it. But look at heartwork, even to this day, the production is clean and well done and polished. And their music is no where near as technical as Animals as Leaders so don’t act like it’s a bummer

  • @DireThorns
    @DireThorns Рік тому +12

    I think both has boring and interesting aspects, but tbf I listen to like, two bands properly 😂
    Honestly bradley u hit the nail on the head

  • @Snakdady
    @Snakdady Рік тому +1

    Good timing. I just watched The Decline of Western Civilization II:
    The Metal Years
    Crazy how much times have changed in only 40 years.
    My main takeaway was that people back then could say things. People now don't say anything out of fear from backlash, and I fear it's turned everyone into personality-less copy-paste blobs where nothing real ever comes out of their mouths.

  • @DonallHenderson-wk2wg
    @DonallHenderson-wk2wg Рік тому +3

    I like it when modern metal is inspired by classic metal.

  • @SarimFaruque
    @SarimFaruque Рік тому +2

    I guess the biggest problem regarding modern metal is that too many bands’ production sound a bit too overpolished and unvaried compared to the 80s and 90s, which tend to be more “raw” or “atmospheric” in comparison. I guess the production works well with metalcore or prog metal, but much less so in other genres like trad, thrash, black, and power metal.

  • @warriorneedsfoodbadly
    @warriorneedsfoodbadly Рік тому +4

    You mentioned it wasn't fun anymore. Do you think we need an infusion of "Nu Glam Metal"?
    Do you think we need to bring back bands that sound like Poison, Warrant, etc.?

    • @frankvandorp2059
      @frankvandorp2059 Рік тому

      There are a lot of fun metal genres. Power metal and folk metal, as well as modern bands making more traditional heavy metal, are often quite upbeat and happy, and write songs about beer and having fun.

    • @warriorneedsfoodbadly
      @warriorneedsfoodbadly Рік тому +1

      @@frankvandorp2059 Can you give me some examples of some really fun ones? I have to admit, I'm a little lost here. All I can think of is Steel Panther and Wig Wam with their Peacemaker theme song "Do you Wanna Taste It", which was actually from 2010. Airbourne debut album was pretty good too.

    • @frankvandorp2059
      @frankvandorp2059 Рік тому

      @@warriorneedsfoodbadly Alestorm, Gloryhammer, Wind Rose, Burning Witches, Ensiferum, Powerwolf, Twilight Force, Warkings.
      And those are just the fun folk/power metal bands I saw over the past two weeks when I was at Wacken and then Alcatraz. There are a lot more.

  • @theatomicpunkkid
    @theatomicpunkkid Місяць тому

    Right out of the gate he's talking about the wonderful wonders of remixed remastered music

  • @jacoblopez517
    @jacoblopez517 Рік тому +9

    I totally agree. There are thing to love and hate about both. I can’t stand the fact that classic metal fans are completely unwilling to listen to the new stuff. I love metal from all time periods! 🤘🏻

    • @thethrashyone
      @thethrashyone Рік тому +8

      Hey now, don't put all the shame on classic fans. Newer fans are just as guilty of snubbing classic metal.

    • @thatoneguyfromthatoneplace9515
      @thatoneguyfromthatoneplace9515 Рік тому +1

      What can I say, newer metal (music in general tbh) just doesn't speak to me. It's not like I don't hear it, it just doesn't do it for me like older music does.

  • @patrickl671
    @patrickl671 Рік тому

    6:37 fuck the road runner United was such a cool concept. PLUS in the fire has one of my personal top ten all time solos. Matt and Corey kill it.

  • @montythemetalman
    @montythemetalman Рік тому +13

    There’s some amazing stuff (some) that comes out of the modern era. That, however, is too far too few. Classic metal is just glorious.

  • @АлександрВоробьев-я1х

    6:32 and 9:09 my inspiration and guitar hero!🤩🎸💔 Legend Laiho! Even today I was learning the solo of "In Your Face" song from "Are You Dead Yet?" album with my guitar teacher and friend🎸

  • @just._joey._music
    @just._joey._music Рік тому +5

    Me'al is me'al

  • @BaalofSouls
    @BaalofSouls Рік тому

    I love both classic and modern metal. You pretty much summed it up.

  • @JcBrahamas
    @JcBrahamas Рік тому +6

    Classic Metal has dem feels Modern Metal Not so much

  • @ruperterskin2117
    @ruperterskin2117 Рік тому

    Right on. Thanks for sharing.

  • @a.j.leclair5426
    @a.j.leclair5426 Рік тому +19

    I dont think metal is worse i just think Pantera, Metallica,Megadeath and Lamb of God (bands like this)have set the bar so extremely high in the early days that bands now play it safe kinda or copy off old shit. But idk i love music either way an try to keep an open mind 😊

    • @gtrriffs
      @gtrriffs Рік тому

      💯🤟

    • @SpiritofPoison
      @SpiritofPoison Рік тому

      Listen to Car Bomb and see where the bar is.

    • @iqbalmuhammad2920
      @iqbalmuhammad2920 Місяць тому

      Agree.
      The benchmark set by bands in the 80s, 90s is too high.
      The masterpieces produced by metal bands in those era is abundant.
      2010s is the worse for me.
      This, coming from someone who grew & started with metal in the late 90s & 2000s.

  • @mhz6687
    @mhz6687 Рік тому

    Watching 0:25 at 144p when brad fucking fnaf jumpscares me was the highlight of my day

  • @GrippyRocks
    @GrippyRocks Рік тому +5

    it's really difficult for me to find a good or fresh 'new' band so I end up listenning to old stuff from 90's and back.

    • @henrywalton5967
      @henrywalton5967 Рік тому +2

      I feel the same way really, the only band that's really stood out for me Is Vektor

    • @billybobthekidiswack
      @billybobthekidiswack Рік тому

      ​@@henrywalton5967check out "thantifaxath- hive mind narcosis" album. Imo it's the best experimental metal album that cane out this year.

  • @DavidPerry-ui2qz
    @DavidPerry-ui2qz Рік тому

    Free!!!!!!!! Great take on the subject! 🤘🎸🤘

  • @zxzxmatheus
    @zxzxmatheus Рік тому +2

    good video dude, im more of a classichead myself, I usually cant get into modern metal bands unless theyre doing some kind of throwback. I feel it sounds just so sanitized and serious, like it's pretending metal isn't silly by nature to some extent. There are exceptions of course.

  • @FredM1402
    @FredM1402 Рік тому

    What I liked about classic metal was the fact that you often had to make an effort to get it.
    Nowadays everything is available, everywhere and anytime.
    Back in the days (early 80's)you had to move heaven and earth to get certain LP's.
    Growing up in a small Belgian village it was a real struggle to get my hands on bands like Hawaii, Queensryche, Sortilege, Savage,... The local music store only had AC/DC, Maiden and Priest.
    I remember spending more then a year looking for the Queensryche EP. And once I had it, all my friends would spend every evening at my place, listening to this almost 'mysterious' EP everyone was talking about (but never heard it).
    As a young fan bands were like gods. Cutting pictures out of Metal Hammer magazines because that was all you could get.
    That mystery is gone and although internet is a great thing, I miss that...

  • @RC32Smiths01
    @RC32Smiths01 Рік тому +16

    I firmly believe it has only gotten better. The sounds and subgenres that have been evolved throughout the decades have cemented it as so much more than it has been since it originated. That is how I see it at least.

    • @profanepropane
      @profanepropane Рік тому +4

      Very true. Black metal and Death metal subgenres have been very vibrant and out there in terms of sound and making good stuff. Even other genres of metal aren't TOO far behind

    • @videodead9630
      @videodead9630 Рік тому +3

      Maybe there’s better playing, but is it as iconic or filled with catchy riffs as it was in the 80’s/90’s?…not so much. Overly polished much like all the genres music of this completely digital age. Idk I wasn’t even born back then but it was way better no offense.

    • @profanepropane
      @profanepropane Рік тому

      @dragonballfanscantread2383 Well, agree to disagree I guess

  • @brianfleming9734
    @brianfleming9734 Рік тому

    Great points. Loved this vid!!!