WHAT IF DARTH MAUL WAS A JEDI? - STAR WARS THEORY

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 жов 2024
  • In this episode of SWT we will explore the "what if" scenario of Darth Maul never having become a Sith, but rather found by Master Yoda and trained under his tutelage, bringing down the ever lingering Sith Lords and the evil that nests in the Galaxy.
    FACEBOOK PAGE - / starwarstheorytoos

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,2 тис.

  • @QueenTJ1991
    @QueenTJ1991 5 років тому +290

    If Maul was a Jedi, Obi-Wan and Anakin would not be rivals but they would be trained as equals and their brotherly bond would be stronger than it was in the original timeline.

    • @plasmagreninja1577
      @plasmagreninja1577 4 роки тому +4

      Tiffany Corbin Anakin?

    • @QueenTJ1991
      @QueenTJ1991 4 роки тому +14

      @@plasmagreninja1577 what I mean is that Maul would help Anakin to find a way to channel his anger in a positive way while also training him and Obi-Wan in the process.

  • @lordboogus1145
    @lordboogus1145 7 років тому +927

    maul being a Jedi... RIP sith

    • @hipposad8775
      @hipposad8775 6 років тому +11

      Voiceless Hippie true

    • @snapgawd528
      @snapgawd528 6 років тому +11

      Facts

    • @jamesmonroe1538
      @jamesmonroe1538 6 років тому +24

      Yeah. He would probably beat many sith in his life, perhaps even palpatine himself, but only if he were with mace's small strike team in ROTS.

    • @mohammednuur1954
      @mohammednuur1954 6 років тому +6

      Voiceless Hippie so true

    • @travisvallejos1171
      @travisvallejos1171 5 років тому +4

      True

  • @StarWarsTheory
    @StarWarsTheory  7 років тому +493

    Hey guys, I'm having the end fight turned into an animation as well as recording the whole video again with a better mic and music. It's already looking pretty good. Should be out in a month! :)

    • @dale8413
      @dale8413 7 років тому +14

      Star Wars Theory hey I think that Count dookue would not be a Sith because the reason he became a sith was cause Qui-Gon-Jin died so I think It would be General grevious or Assaja Ventress Maybe

    • @collin833
      @collin833 7 років тому +3

      super excited

    • @toxicmurdererr7597
      @toxicmurdererr7597 7 років тому +4

      Star Wars Theory dooku only turned to the dark side because something regarding qui gons death was the final straw before he turned to the dark side but qui gon is alive sooooooooooooooooooo..................

    • @gabemerriott2819
      @gabemerriott2819 7 років тому +1

      Star Wars Theory is

    • @tie9284
      @tie9284 7 років тому +1

      Star Wars Theory you are the best theorist and my favorite youtuber :) keep up with the good work !!!

  • @KaiserMattTygore927
    @KaiserMattTygore927 8 років тому +134

    That was badass.
    -Good Maul
    -Anakin gets to be Vader at full potential
    -Uncle Palpy is in jail
    -No order 66

    • @rickgrimes9530
      @rickgrimes9530 2 роки тому +6

      And
      -Qui Gon Alive

    • @badpiggies988
      @badpiggies988 2 роки тому +13

      If he were Vader at full potential he’d use the super-lightning thing that Palpatine used in episode 9 to glass the surface of every sand planet in the galaxy

    • @leerogish7223
      @leerogish7223 Рік тому

      Vader at full potential could probably summon lightning powerful enough to destroy entire planets. Emperor vader would unlikely need a Death Star or a huge military he would be able to rule the galaxy using the force kind of like what palpatine. Eventually planned in dark empire

    • @animeiscringe1055
      @animeiscringe1055 Рік тому

      I don't think anyone can stop full potential vader tho. The jedi order would be fked

  • @chrismarr1523
    @chrismarr1523 4 роки тому +21

    I would pay to see a spinoff of just this. Really good, loved it.

  • @maiqtheliar122
    @maiqtheliar122 8 років тому +414

    what if despite all his effort palpatine was never elected chancellor

    • @danmarusan2878
      @danmarusan2878 8 років тому +44

      If that's the case then he would create the CIS as his empire and start a war against the republic. He would propably create a new sith order like Darth Krayt. From this point things would be like they were during the great galactic war when the sith empire tried to destroy the republic.

    • @vanpaladan6075
      @vanpaladan6075 6 років тому +1

      H

    • @michelveilleux1275
      @michelveilleux1275 5 років тому +3

      @@danmarusan2878 It like the scenario of Battlefront clone wars maps with Sidious leading CIS droids.

    • @223rd7
      @223rd7 4 роки тому +1

      Are you lying m'aiq the liar

  • @melancholyentertainment
    @melancholyentertainment 8 років тому +170

    Personally, I don't think Anakin would have turned to the dark side if Qui-Gon were his master. Qui-Gon was already a Jedi master. Obi-Wan became a Jedi master too quickly. He wouldn't have become a master so soon if Qui-Gon hadn't died in Ep 1. Qui-Gon had much more experience and probably would have done much better with training Anakin than Obi-Wan did.

    • @leerogish7223
      @leerogish7223 4 роки тому +12

      Agreed qui gon is the only jedi who had a shot at preventing Anakins fall. I think he would have made anakin come clean to the council about Padme being pregnant but he would do so knowing qui gon would have his back since unlike Obi wan he wasn’t afraid to call the council out

    • @ihatech1pr37
      @ihatech1pr37 2 роки тому +2

      Anakin has to turn to the dark sideC The prophecy could never have been fulfilled if Anakin never turned to the dark side, the prophecy had to be fulfilled.

    • @PK-fi7vk
      @PK-fi7vk Рік тому

      George lucas stated that even if Qui-Gon were there to train anakin, he will still turn to the dark side but later in the timeline.

    • @miloradowicz
      @miloradowicz 11 місяців тому

      Anakin was always a bad apple.

  • @GutsOfRivia
    @GutsOfRivia 8 років тому +570

    Didn't count dooku fall to the dark side because qui gon gin was killed by maul ?

    • @StarWarsTheory
      @StarWarsTheory  8 років тому +132

      No, he was falling to the dark side long before this event. He didn't just spontaneously turn after Qui Gonn died then became apprentice to the master of his killer.

    • @scorch775
      @scorch775 8 років тому +12

      No
      Dooku was already being seduced as Maul was battling Obi and Gin.
      Dooku was being trained to want to Kill Maul, but Kenobi beat him to the punch.
      Well until he returned 16 years later.

    • @TuckerBowChicka1
      @TuckerBowChicka1 8 років тому +14

      +Scorch, I think that may just be in legends. If i'm not mistaken, in canon the death of Qui Gonn pushed him to turn to the dark side sooner is all. And that's how he then met Sidious after having left the order for more power, and having been to disappointed with the jedi.

    • @RevanShanDarkJedi
      @RevanShanDarkJedi 8 років тому +13

      +Star Wars Theory please make another part of this what if.

    • @scorch775
      @scorch775 8 років тому +2

      +Roronoa Zoro maybe you're right
      Actually I'm not sure what's Cannon in that sense yet.
      They haven't really talked about that time in Cannon

  • @Arasmuss
    @Arasmuss 8 років тому +40

    So under Yoda's training, he would turn into a jedi similar to Mace Windu. Sounds about right.

    • @leerogish7223
      @leerogish7223 Рік тому +4

      Remember maul lost much of his natural ability when he was cut in half so probably a 100% organic maul trained by yoda would be equal to mace

  • @kermitkillshimself6530
    @kermitkillshimself6530 7 років тому +385

    I just can't imagine Darth Maul as a good man
    With his Tattoos
    And his horns
    I just can't see him as a good guy

    • @FISHYFILMPRODUCTIONS
      @FISHYFILMPRODUCTIONS 7 років тому +55

      Kermit Kills Himself I don't think he would have the tattoos as a jedi

    • @jonasmartin5127
      @jonasmartin5127 7 років тому +52

      Kermit Kills Himself thats racist

    • @kermitkillshimself6530
      @kermitkillshimself6530 7 років тому +3

      Jaden Bass But he would still have his Evil Looking horns

    • @Hellraiser988
      @Hellraiser988 7 років тому +18

      Kermit Kills Himself it's a tribal thing for his species and the horns are natural do to him being a zabrak if you seen the EU before Disney's fuck up you would know

    • @someguy9520
      @someguy9520 7 років тому +15

      Kermit Kills Himself well there were actually several jedis that were from the same race that dont look that scary

  • @gametype6241
    @gametype6241 8 років тому +173

    what if stormtroopers could actually hit their targets

    • @daisychains6866
      @daisychains6866 8 років тому +8

      They can but they're missing on purpose.

    • @gametype6241
      @gametype6241 8 років тому

      if they could star wars couldnt even be made......... good job badtroopers

    • @gamer7138
      @gamer7138 8 років тому

      In the first star wars movie they were ordered not to hit them

    • @ILYAKL353
      @ILYAKL353 8 років тому +3

      i guess that's because rebels wearing greatest armor of all times, plot armor

    • @gabrieltejada1697
      @gabrieltejada1697 7 років тому

      what if people actually watched closely at the OT instead of believing non canon jokes made up by retarded haters?

  • @bigdinoguy
    @bigdinoguy 8 років тому +20

    I'm a Huge Maul fan, (personally my favorite Sith) and this was the first video of yours I have seen. And it was impressive, most impressive. You have certainly gained a subscriber! I look forward to what you have next.

  • @StarWarsTheory
    @StarWarsTheory  8 років тому +48

    Hey everyone check out my newest Fan Fiction - What If Darth Maul Trained Anakin Skywalker Episode 2 - ua-cam.com/video/sjsanlM6N3g/v-deo.html
    *edit* - Turning this into an animation for Feb

    • @zombiesandgaming3591
      @zombiesandgaming3591 8 років тому +2

      they should have broght Anakin solo he was more powerful than luke

    • @davidmcmullen5861
      @davidmcmullen5861 7 років тому +1

      can you do a one on Jan go fett if he wasent killd

    • @lavendergoosegames9336
      @lavendergoosegames9336 7 років тому

      Star Wars Theory I wonder if maul would be intune with the will of the force or just another puppet of the Jedi so many variables with maul n his story and training. good video brother love your channel

    • @Rebecca-ne1ls
      @Rebecca-ne1ls 7 років тому +1

      Star Wars Theory is there going to be a part two of this??

    • @binkbonkbones3402
      @binkbonkbones3402 7 років тому +1

      Star Wars Theory what if anakin won the battle of wusdafar ?

  • @KaraSnape07
    @KaraSnape07 6 років тому +20

    That'd be interesting to see Maul as a Jedi instead of a Sith.
    It would be awesome!

  • @Jukes99
    @Jukes99 7 років тому +3

    I actually love these videos!! To theorise different StarWars events, it's awesome to listen and imaging if these things actually occurred..

  • @radiationpony8449
    @radiationpony8449 8 років тому +156

    what if obiwan left the order as a padawan to stay with dutchess satine?

  • @markmaharaj4489
    @markmaharaj4489 8 років тому +225

    Please continue this story it is so interesting

  • @acenebula3045
    @acenebula3045 8 років тому +76

    Wait...If Qui Gon Jinn never died, then Dooku wouldn't be Darth Tyrannus because his apprentice is still alive. the reason Dooku joined the dark side because qui gon died

    • @foodarmy6628
      @foodarmy6628 8 років тому +7

      Na because count dooku was already dabbing in the dark side it just would have taken him a lot longer to truly turn to the dark side

    • @ReallyFatLemur
      @ReallyFatLemur 8 років тому +1

      +Food army or he could've had more time to swing back to the light side

    • @gog_magpie
      @gog_magpie 8 років тому

      Ace Nebula because Dooku wanted stop palpatine

    • @matissepinxten6238
      @matissepinxten6238 7 років тому +4

      Ace Nebula the dead of qui gon jin isnot the only reason that dooku turned it just the final push

    • @sante4782
      @sante4782 7 років тому +4

      dabbing in the dark side ?

  • @that0nenea282
    @that0nenea282 3 роки тому +8

    I absolutely love maul, but I dont like the dark side, this was a great representation of what maul would be like as a member of the light side, awesome video

  • @Poundcakepapi
    @Poundcakepapi 7 років тому +179

    man you should've wrote the 1 through 3 movies

  • @Tesseradical17
    @Tesseradical17 8 років тому +24

    That guy in the comments who's just like, "You could pretty much change anything in the prequels and it would come out better, am I right? Hyuk hyuk hyuk, hating things is fun."

  • @greenman5555
    @greenman5555 8 років тому +76

    how about, What if Boba Fett never fell into the Sarlaac Pit?

    • @fallenchaos4476
      @fallenchaos4476 8 років тому +1

      he survives it anyway so I dont think much if anything would change he would be knocked out or killed

    • @aev6075
      @aev6075 8 років тому +1

      He wouldn't look ugly atleast :D

    • @StarWarsTheory
      @StarWarsTheory  8 років тому +9

      Doing this next ;)

    • @devranhasan4969
      @devranhasan4969 8 років тому

      +Star Wars Theory theory can you do mine next? :)

    • @StarWarsTheory
      @StarWarsTheory  8 років тому

      what's yours man?

  • @arcgamer8688
    @arcgamer8688 8 років тому +49

    Anakin wanted for sidious to be judged,like yoda wanted.So Anakin would remain in the order!

    • @darthdestroyer11
      @darthdestroyer11 8 років тому +6

      But he tried to kill another jedi

    • @arcgamer8688
      @arcgamer8688 8 років тому +4

      No,he tried to stop him from killing a sith!

    • @petyrbaelish8063
      @petyrbaelish8063 8 років тому +19

      no because he wanted him to live for selfish reasons of passion therefore he wouldn't have been allowed in the order

    • @arcgamer8688
      @arcgamer8688 8 років тому +1

      He tried to keep palpatine alive not for selfish reasons!He wanted justice,and maul didn't give it!

    • @petyrbaelish8063
      @petyrbaelish8063 8 років тому +1

      he did want it for selfish reasons but wait hear me out jedi forbid relationships and anakin went against this rule and thus allowed passion to cloud his judgement (passion mind you is a path to the dark side) palpatine knew about this and promised him power to save the one he loves and thats why anakin shouts "i need him" when windu prepared to strike him down so alas it was anakins emotions that were the deciding factor not his will to dispense justice ☺

  • @nightshadeproductions7576
    @nightshadeproductions7576 7 років тому +24

    i love darth maul and if he was a jedi id love him even more

    • @leerogish7223
      @leerogish7223 Рік тому

      He would have been one of the best and most respected masters for his intelligence, wisdom, leadership skills and dueling abilities. Jedi maul would have probably worked with mace to create vapaad

  • @criminaljustice3221
    @criminaljustice3221 4 роки тому +9

    Me: **reads title** Oh cool!
    Also me: **Sees thumbnail** **instantly powers off phone**

  • @harrisonclark9561
    @harrisonclark9561 8 років тому +68

    what about if maul and savage oppress killed siddous and became the new sith lords.

    • @scorch775
      @scorch775 8 років тому +10

      Then the republic would go crazy looking for Palpatine. Mandalore would become the new home for the CIS as with Palpatine dead and just as in Cannon, Maul temporarily took Dooku as an Apprentice, but would be forced to choose between him and Savage. Dooku might win, but Maul might intervene.
      Maul and his Apprentice would continue the war, leading a new massive army larger than before of The Galaxies greatest crime families, the Galaxies most ruthless Bounty Hunters, The Galaxies most wanted against the Grand Army of the Republic.
      With Mandalore in his control, and the largest army in the Galaxy, more and more clones would be created, and Kamino, with no ties to Sidious would never execute order 66. Clones would be pumped out by the millions, as the senate would most likely be taken over by the Jedi as Yoda had intended to do temporarily in episode 3. Kamino would be forced to comply, creating massive amounts of clones, and creating a war larger than any ever seen.

    • @harrisonclark9561
      @harrisonclark9561 8 років тому

      Wow thank you.

    • @scorch775
      @scorch775 8 років тому +2

      Drunk with Power, Maul would crown himself The New Emperor with his Apprentice at his side, as he tapped into the dark side deeper and deeper, learning new skills and abilities, and becoming more powerful than ever before. Mauls army would lead a vicious war against the republic, pushing them back across the outer rim all the way into the inner rim core worlds, and right into the heart of corruscant. The battle there would be massive in size and scope, with the Republic conscripting and Cloning simultaneously. With Maul Drunken on power he would stay away from his battles commanding them through a meditation sphere like Marka Ragnos.
      With his Apprentice and possibly other Sith Assassins leading the attack, along with bounty hunters, and the galaxies most notorious villains the New Dark Empire would most likely take to ground, creating within weeks time mass war all across the planet. I do believe that they would even win, and take the planet for themselves.

    • @scorch775
      @scorch775 8 років тому +2

      With this the Jedi and remaining troops as civilians not arrested or killed would retreat, heading to Tython, or another core world like Corellia or Alderaan. Maybe somewhere more remote than that. Idk but they would leave and try and prepare not for a war, but a final stand.
      With the Republic being reformed into the resistance and the CIS being reformed into the Shadow Empire of the Sith, the war would become similar to the Galactic Civil war, and as Maul grew in strengths so too did the strength of a younger Jedi, Anakin Skywalker, who several years after the events of the end of the Clone wars with the sacking of Coruscant, has become the youngest master; who has two children, and was openly married.
      Now with Maul finishing construction on the Death Star (by using the plans he found that Sidious left behind) the Resistance knowing that the end was near. They began to prepare for a final stand. (The reason I think it would only take 3-6 years for Maul to make is because he...

    • @scorch775
      @scorch775 8 років тому +2

      Would enlist the help of slaves and droids who would make the station faster than workers and Imperial Employees ever would.

  • @3_0_0_0
    @3_0_0_0 8 років тому +24

    I think it would be interesting picturing Maul in Jedi robes. Like here you have this menacing red and horned being and find out he's a good guy. Like Maul even looks evil.

    • @justindortch4982
      @justindortch4982 8 років тому +4

      well if maul would have joined the jedi, his tattoos would not be there as he had gotten them to commemorate his attunement to the darkside. Maul would look like a normal zabrak instead and his name probably would not have been maul as that was a part of his sith lord moniker as well. So i wonder...

    • @lukeroughan4658
      @lukeroughan4658 8 років тому +4

      but I thought the Zabrak on Dathomir already had tattoos like Savage Oppress

    • @justindortch4982
      @justindortch4982 8 років тому +2

      Luke Roughan I think that is the case for new canon. But in TOR the zabrak are without ink. So maybe it was a nightsister thing.

    • @TheOnlineGamer812
      @TheOnlineGamer812 8 років тому +1

      and a blue double sided blade. That would be real nice.

    • @uncletammy5025
      @uncletammy5025 8 років тому +2

      I believe he still would have the ink, but i'm not 100% sure since it's Night Sister tatoos, and they're all about the dark side.

  • @davidreed4713
    @davidreed4713 7 років тому +1

    I really enjoy this video because Maul is one of my favorite characters in Star Wars and especially more so because it shows how his immense skill would be if used for good. Amazing video, completely captivating!

  • @RichardDrink
    @RichardDrink 8 років тому +86

    If Qui Gon lived Count Dooku wouldn't of turned to the Dark Side tho.

    • @Junglehunter677
      @Junglehunter677 4 роки тому +10

      Precisely. It was his death that lead to his masters fall. Dooku had originally left the order because he believed the republic was corrupt at its core(spoiler, it was), and when he felt qui gons death through the force, he gave in to his anger

    • @RichardDrink
      @RichardDrink 4 роки тому +5

      @@Junglehunter677 thank you for the informative reply 4 years later.

    • @Junglehunter677
      @Junglehunter677 4 роки тому +8

      @@RichardDrink time is but an illusion to the force

    • @mashrubawazed4708
      @mashrubawazed4708 3 роки тому +1

      @@RichardDrink man also read this reply after 4 years too LoL

    • @Celtic-Firebird
      @Celtic-Firebird 3 роки тому +1

      I feel like if Sidious never found Maul he could've found and corrupted Savage Opress manipulating him by saying the Jedi had taken and used his brother
      OR
      Sidious finds Ventress and takes her as his apprentice, training her better then Dooku and making her a true sith lady

  • @BeybladeGenius101
    @BeybladeGenius101 8 років тому +68

    this wouldn't happen, as Dooku only left ultimately because of the death of his former apprentice

    • @StarWarsTheory
      @StarWarsTheory  8 років тому +2

      Not at all, he was already falling to the dark side long before that, reference the EU comics.

    • @scorch775
      @scorch775 8 років тому +2

      Alternate world bruh
      Anything can happen

    • @devranhasan4969
      @devranhasan4969 8 років тому

      +Star Wars Theory may i ask a theory you can do? :)

    • @Lord_Insectious
      @Lord_Insectious 8 років тому

      dooku was already going over to the dark side because he left the order due to the treatment of his home world by the Senate before episode 1 and wished for the power the dark side has

    • @novachikun
      @novachikun 8 років тому +7

      Qui-gon's demise was the final straw for Dooku, but as others have said, there were several other things that were at eating at Dooku about the Republic and the Jedi's role in it. He didn't have much farther to go when Qui-gon died, and even if he had not died, Sidious could have done something to give Dooku that final push as was mentioned in the video.

  • @bobbyblazini
    @bobbyblazini 8 років тому +38

    i love your respect for Maul. cool alternate history i wish it was real...way better this way. why cant they MANDELA EFFECT this as EPISODE 1

    • @ItIsTime2WakeUp
      @ItIsTime2WakeUp 8 років тому +3

      Ya, and Maul kills Jar Jar too.

    • @StarWarsTheory
      @StarWarsTheory  8 років тому +5

      hahaha i agree man.

    • @bobbyblazini
      @bobbyblazini 8 років тому

      im subscribed and watching every video. ive never had a channel owner comment back to me. thanks for being so cool man, i for sure will support you as long as you pump out the content!

  • @Jaximillion1
    @Jaximillion1 8 років тому +31

    I would like to hear a what-if where the Clones were never a thing. Would that mean that Jango would still become a bounty hunter? Boba would never exist, but what of the war? Would the Jedi lose?

    • @scorch775
      @scorch775 8 років тому +6

      The Republic might start Conscripting creating Republic Trooper regiment similar to the Old Republic Videogame where they are Government Conscripts and Smugglers. Anyone who lends a hand is another soldier to fight in the war.
      Instead of Clones against the CIS it would be
      The Republic Navy v The Conferderacy of Indipendent Systems.
      It would be more vicious war with the Republic being more like the rebels in size and scope.

    • @bloodydove5718
      @bloodydove5718 8 років тому +1

      I wouldnt be surprised at all if Jango started gravitating back towards his Mandalorian roots and ended up as Mandalore. Especially if he realized that there was a great war on the horizon; gather the clans and lead them towards an unforgettable glory.

    • @bloodydove5718
      @bloodydove5718 8 років тому +1

      My only guess as to what Sidious would do to prompt the senate to conscript an army against the CIS, would be if he took a play out of the history books and had a faction skirmishing on the outer rim worlds and progressively growing stronger as they slowly made their way towards the core worlds. Pretty much like Vitiate did the Mandalorian war

    • @troykemp5329
      @troykemp5329 8 років тому +1

      Just to correct you the jedi did lose the clones turned on them

    • @bloodydove5718
      @bloodydove5718 8 років тому

      Troy Kemp i think he means though, is if the clones didnt exist to turn on the jedi, would the jedi still have essentially been snuffed out by sidious

  • @giovannilomonaco-kiss3688
    @giovannilomonaco-kiss3688 6 років тому +15

    Maul is super powerful, but I don't think he could amount to be as powerful as windu and yoda

    • @leerogish7223
      @leerogish7223 Рік тому +3

      Of course not he lost half his power after being cut in half. Assuming he never was I think he could have been as powerful as mace

  • @RickSanchez-kg9zc
    @RickSanchez-kg9zc 6 років тому +8

    Maul being a Jedi is like fire being cold...

  • @silvestridonovan13
    @silvestridonovan13 8 років тому +39

    THIS WAS AMAZING OH MY GOD. This would also mean that order 66 wouldn't be executed?

    • @jimmybisk
      @jimmybisk 8 років тому +1

      Not unless Palpatine escaped

    • @TheMaster4534
      @TheMaster4534 8 років тому +1

      And Mas Amedda becomes Chancellor.

    • @StarWarsTheory
      @StarWarsTheory  8 років тому +5

      Maybe in episode 2 ;)

    • @bobbyblazini
      @bobbyblazini 8 років тому +6

      Order 66 would be DarthVader without the robot stuff. Jedi are stronger the more organic they are, for force reasons, so a even more powerful DarthVader would probably kill most the jedi himself.

    • @josiahjenksisawesome
      @josiahjenksisawesome 8 років тому +1

      Do it

  • @kyleaustin6061
    @kyleaustin6061 8 років тому +22

    1.Qui gon wouldn't be died, so why dooku would still turn to the dark side?
    2. Master Maul would use Vaapad?

    • @benkenobi6719
      @benkenobi6719 8 років тому +1

      You´ve right but Windu had at that time a Padawan(Depa Billaba)

    • @darthtyranus7447
      @darthtyranus7447 8 років тому +2

      Um maybe because count dooku would have anyway because he hated the way the Jedi did things remember the death of his padawan just made the process faster or like he said sidious would minipulate him like he did anakin and Darth maul maybe could use vapod because he had the dark side in him but a Jedi maybe mace winds could have been a sith

    • @josiahjenksisawesome
      @josiahjenksisawesome 8 років тому +3

      Dooku was already disillusioned to the Jedi. Qui Gon's death was just the last straw.

    • @jimmylee6546
      @jimmylee6546 8 років тому +1

      good point, however I still think it is unlikely that Palpatine would be able to persuade Dooku to become his apprentice by TPM

  • @ComanderComander
    @ComanderComander 8 років тому +58

    am i the only one who thinks this wold be some mutch better movies then those we have ?

    • @HouseKaslana
      @HouseKaslana 8 років тому +2

      I'm not saying it would be better than the movies we have, but it would be very interesting to watch.

    • @ComanderComander
      @ComanderComander 8 років тому

      dont you think it wold be better then 123 ? and when i say 123 i dont mean 456 456 was awesome 123 was....

    • @SNIP3RARROW117
      @SNIP3RARROW117 8 років тому

      B

    • @StarWarsTheory
      @StarWarsTheory  8 років тому +1

      LOL same here. Thanks man.

    • @ComanderComander
      @ComanderComander 8 років тому

      ikr

  • @flashbacka1122
    @flashbacka1122 7 років тому +1

    This was my favorite video yet! Please keep doing videos like this!

  • @Handsholdhim
    @Handsholdhim 7 років тому

    Man you're getting better by the hour, great fan fictions, keep them coming.

  • @tenzin3750
    @tenzin3750 8 років тому +5

    I love this since MAUL and Mace windu are my two favorite Star Wars characters.

  • @stijnVDA1994
    @stijnVDA1994 7 років тому +17

    hey,
    that is a better storyline than most games have, sir you have a great talent!
    greetings from holland.

  • @williameaton6930
    @williameaton6930 8 років тому +30

    I don't agree with the theory but I understand it. I've always like Darth maul as a sith, he is just too ruthless.

    • @williameaton6930
      @williameaton6930 8 років тому +1

      Great video nonetheless.

    • @williameaton6930
      @williameaton6930 8 років тому +1

      Love the ending, though.

    • @Andrewjones-dy7kh
      @Andrewjones-dy7kh 8 років тому

      He was so ruthless due to him being taught and hurt and contorled by palpetine

    • @JACKYDoesEverything
      @JACKYDoesEverything 8 років тому +2

      Bra.. He was trained to be ruthless..

    • @jimmybisk
      @jimmybisk 8 років тому +1

      Its true he was trained to be ruthless but his race were fairly bullish & barbaric to start with as is told in The Clone Wars series.

  • @savageopress990
    @savageopress990 8 років тому +5

    Hi, what happened if, during the second battle of Dathomir between confederation and Shadow Collective, the republic tracked Maul on Dathomir and go there to stop him, but instead they met Palpatine, Mother Talzin, Dooku, Grievous, Maul, Shadow Collective, and hundreds of droids?

  • @jaggaayo
    @jaggaayo 3 роки тому +1

    Woah This is such a great What If Timeline theory!! Great work!!

  • @reiza3368
    @reiza3368 7 років тому +29

    Well... I'd say qui gon was the biggest reason dooku turned dark

  • @themr.mysteriousshadow82
    @themr.mysteriousshadow82 5 років тому +10

    Imagine Grievous being a Jedi along with Darth Maul yeah the Sith would be no more I would give it about three months besides I think Grievous would be using Sith lightsabers instead of Jedi indicating that his Keepsake and pride

    • @johnpauldriskill8737
      @johnpauldriskill8737 3 роки тому +2

      Grievous was turned into a cyborg by Dooku for the separatist and wasn’t force sensitive

  • @anonymous_7626
    @anonymous_7626 8 років тому +7

    plz make a part 2 of how anikan and palpatine escape, plz this is the best video I have seen from you

  • @hakimhunt9533
    @hakimhunt9533 8 років тому

    I wish u made a part 2 to this story. I know others feel the same. I enjoy your work. Keep it up

  • @vandal5101
    @vandal5101 6 років тому +2

    Holy fuck this story is amazing! I’d love to see a bunch of alternate universes where different things take place like this one. Great job on the video as well

  • @joeruddy6763
    @joeruddy6763 8 років тому +9

    if qui gon was still alive when anakin and obi wan were beaten up by count dooku where was qui gon, maul and yoda saved them but it should have been qui gon and obi wan fighting

  • @smoothjamskillmoure
    @smoothjamskillmoure 8 років тому +129

    What if they cast a potato as Anakin Skywalker, instead of Hayden Christensen?

    • @smoothjamskillmoure
      @smoothjamskillmoure 8 років тому +4

      Or at least Natalie Portman might have won one. I think k Christianson is bad enough that it somehow rubbed off on her

    • @TheMovieDoctorful
      @TheMovieDoctorful 8 років тому +8

      What if retards saw other movies actors did besides Star Wars where they actually won awards?

    • @smoothjamskillmoure
      @smoothjamskillmoure 8 років тому +1

      TheMovieDoctorful are you referring to life as a house, the movie where he's plays the same whiny bitchy character that he did when he turned to the dark side in the star wars movies, but it made more sense because he was dressed like an emo kid instead of a jedi ? I guess it was OK, I mean the people who made it did pay enough for it to win a golden globe, and I imagine he got a bit of a sympathy vote for having to play a suburban kid who whores himself out to old guys In cars to pay weed I think it was. This was back when Hollywood was still pretending weed would cause you to do stuff like that. Or did you mean jumper, or maybe that one with him and Nicholas cage being samurai or knights or whatever that was

    • @TheMovieDoctorful
      @TheMovieDoctorful 8 років тому

      T actually it was prescription pills and paint, not weed. As a Mary Jane lover of Peter Parker levels, I would probably be first to call out Life As A House if it was demonizing weed. Since when is it impossible for a Jedi to be whiny and bitchy? If that were the case, Ben would have avoided Luke like the plague.And only retards think that critics and award ceremonies are being bribed, since the 90s and possibly before that's been nigh impossible to pull off.
      Jumper was shit, but he was good in it playing a smug, douchey weasel of a character. Outcast (China, not Japan. There are no fuckin' samurai in China) was awesome.

    • @smoothjamskillmoure
      @smoothjamskillmoure 8 років тому

      TheMovieDoctorful do you mean Ben was bitchy? An old ass man trying to take down an empire with the calmness of Mr Rogers is pretty awesome, Luke is a bit bitchy I guess but only until he starts Yoda training then he's a boss. And yes awards ceremonies, while are not technically bribed, they are paid for. It's an entire secondary industry for films. It's not a conspiracy, it's the job of lots of people in the industry to throw a ton of money into getting awards.

  • @lenkagamine4145
    @lenkagamine4145 7 років тому +39

    count dooku would not have been turned to the dark side if qui gon hadnt died.

    • @gengarzilla1685
      @gengarzilla1685 4 роки тому +4

      Sidious might not have that bargaining chip anymore, but Dooku still would have left the Order regardless of Qui-Gon's fate. He was already on that path; his old apprentice's death merely sped things up.

    • @WhiteDawn.
      @WhiteDawn. 2 роки тому

      @@gengarzilla1685 if Dooku had Qui gon at his side with the chosen one and obi wan I believe dooku and qui would have convinced obi to leave the order and follow the force instead

  • @sapphirerubystargate7192
    @sapphirerubystargate7192 7 років тому

    First things first: Love your work. I found your channel by accident and like just spent about 6 or 7 hours watching all those amazing theory and fanfiction videos. Your 'what if's are awesome and your narration is better than that of many a written fanfiction I have tried.
    Which brings me to something else: Could you do a 'what if' with Padme as an unknown force sensitive/force user please? That would be something I would be super excited to see!
    Thank you for your amazing videos and I'm looking forward to what ever will be next.

  • @OTNCBC
    @OTNCBC 7 років тому

    Potentially your best work so far

  • @049_Abject_Testament
    @049_Abject_Testament 7 років тому +7

    In Total:
    He would have become one of the mightiest Jedi EVER?
    LOL.

  • @evanhce135
    @evanhce135 7 років тому +65

    What if jar jar never existed?

  • @신에드
    @신에드 7 років тому +3

    wait... correct me if im wrong, but didnt dooku leave the jedi order because of the death of qui gon jinn? if darth maul hadnt killed qui gon then dooku would have still been a jedi?

  • @Eclipse-mf6hc
    @Eclipse-mf6hc 7 років тому

    keep up the great, I'm sorry AMAZING videos, I only found your Chanel this week, AND I LOVE THEM

  • @liqht_star96
    @liqht_star96 2 роки тому +1

    this is one of your best ideas tbh

  • @TheOneBadAssGamer
    @TheOneBadAssGamer 8 років тому +4

    cool re interpretation but yoda would not have shown up because he would still have had to go to kysheek

  • @JacksonVivienbach
    @JacksonVivienbach 7 років тому +20

    Do this theory : is yoda disturbed by his dark side

  • @harveystew
    @harveystew 7 років тому +3

    question, who said he'd still have a dual light saber? And count dooku is a very skilled fighter, he is not going to be beat that easy.

  • @theadaar6441
    @theadaar6441 8 років тому

    I found this channel like 5 hours ago this is all I've been on. great vids

  • @goodcinna1
    @goodcinna1 7 років тому

    Pretty freaking awesome. Great job on the fan fiction. Love it!!!

  • @JorgeHernandez-gq6yy
    @JorgeHernandez-gq6yy 7 років тому +34

    Wait would maul still have his tattoos or no?

    • @AxisSilent
      @AxisSilent 7 років тому +22

      George Hernandez yes. It's a sign from his tribe

    • @fred2246
      @fred2246 6 років тому +6

      No, he wouldn't. It was Palpatine who took him from the tribe and who brutally got him tattooed in black. (Yes, originally he was completely red skinned)

    • @Kenmiester2012
      @Kenmiester2012 6 років тому +7

      Fred Horwood That depends on which canon you're talking about. Legends has it as Sidious's doing, TCW shows that it's either a species-specific or tribal thing.

    • @affe4222
      @affe4222 6 років тому +1

      George Hernandez It’s Like his skin

    • @oof7910
      @oof7910 6 років тому +1

      George Hernandez maybe, some zabraks had tattoos

  • @MrPerson61
    @MrPerson61 8 років тому +15

    man you make maul out to be very very overpowered lol. I think it would have been a fair contest between Dooku and Maul as Dooku was the best Jedi duelist, even being able to hold is ground with Yoda and Windu. He would still probably win because plot, but even then, if Maul was the one to fight Sideous, even with Jedi training, he would still probably lose just as fast as he did in the actual Clone Wars TV show. Well maybe not that fast, but he would still probably win.
    No idea where you got the whole "he can see the future" thing from though, nowhere I have seen is it mentioned that he is that in tune with the force that he could do stuff like that, just that he was an expert swordfighter.
    Good fanfic though.

    • @joeyhovsepian13
      @joeyhovsepian13 6 років тому +9

      Mr. Person - actually, canon novelization has said that Maul was extremely in tune with the force, but the dark side and his hatred made him ignore it, so he could focus more on his physical abilities which his dark side preferred. Also canon is his "love" of meditation. If he was a light side user his force powers would be enhanced immensely and if Mace and Yoda could see into the future, granted not very far, im sure Maul could as well.

    • @jessebrown1996
      @jessebrown1996 6 років тому +8

      Most canon sources put Maul down as extremely well gifted in the force, and remember he was never trained as a Sith, he was only ever trained as an assassin, almost like the inquisitors, and yet he managed to go toe to toe with Qui Gon and Obi Wan and managed to even kill Qui Gon (a Jedi master), all this was done despite having very little actual training in anything other than swordplay.
      A fully trained Maul would be extremely strong, and you also have to remember Sidious (in canon) believed in the rule of 2 and would have only took Maul on if he felt like he could surpass him.

    • @leerogish7223
      @leerogish7223 4 роки тому +1

      Maul would destroy dooku in this scenario. Remeber dookus form ll is weak against physically powerful foes such as anakin and. Maul. I agree with you that no way maul beats palpatine. It is debatable if mace even beat him or just threw the fight to play anakin

  • @sultanvang751
    @sultanvang751 7 років тому +7

    Do what if douku and darth maul never died

    • @pudgeneedsadiet8876
      @pudgeneedsadiet8876 7 років тому +4

      Sultan Vang lel maul didn't - its cannon now, he survived

    • @SatoreyGojo
      @SatoreyGojo 4 роки тому

      @@pudgeneedsadiet8876 if he lived after rebels obiwan killed him n rebels

  • @joeyschuchardt8695
    @joeyschuchardt8695 2 роки тому

    This was actually nice. Someone with so much potential for evil was helped in in time to live a life of good

  • @hakimhunt9533
    @hakimhunt9533 6 років тому +2

    I will would like to see a part 2. This is a good story

  • @banbewd9311
    @banbewd9311 8 років тому +8

    omg. that's was how it should of been written. seriously

    • @huippu_g
      @huippu_g 8 років тому +3

      if it were written like that we should never even think about Maul being a sith just as we never think about Mace to be a sith. and star wars IV V and VI would probadly not work that way. I think they should make another star wars story (like rogue one) with Darth Maul being the sith lord

    • @StarWarsTheory
      @StarWarsTheory  8 років тому

      lol i agree, thanks for the support man.

  • @stormshred
    @stormshred 7 років тому +6

    Plz plz plz plz plz do a part 2

  • @AugustAutumn
    @AugustAutumn 7 років тому +4

    So, um... When are we going to see the next part of this story? Im now hooked.

  • @LuffyBlack
    @LuffyBlack 7 років тому

    Please do a part 2! I really want to see more of Jedi Master Maul's story!

  • @xix_achilles
    @xix_achilles 6 років тому +2

    I really enjoyed this one being a fan of maul, this theory is amazing

  • @TLedoux-px4xl
    @TLedoux-px4xl 8 років тому +4

    i didn't want it to end

  • @leb3289
    @leb3289 7 років тому +60

    darth maul=daddy

    • @venommagnus
      @venommagnus 7 років тому +1

      Name Less Um....ok

    • @hithere7626
      @hithere7626 6 років тому +1

      Name Less uuuuh

    • @hipposad8775
      @hipposad8775 6 років тому +5

      Name Less uhhhhhhhhhhh keep distance

    • @hithere7626
      @hithere7626 6 років тому +1

      Name Less your "daddy" murders people??

    • @TalaR04
      @TalaR04 5 років тому

      Pretty much

  • @samhoward6077
    @samhoward6077 5 років тому +3

    what if darth maul was the chosen one instead of anakin

  • @VooshSpokesman
    @VooshSpokesman 8 років тому

    I absolutely love it :) Hope you make a sequel for this wonderful piece of art.

  • @fiilthyitachi7788
    @fiilthyitachi7788 7 років тому +2

    I feel like that be a better vision of star wars know as I fell in love with clones and the jedi especially seeing my favorite sith Lord maul as a jedi would be amazing

  • @AmirayFrazier4Life
    @AmirayFrazier4Life 6 років тому +4

    Love your videos #StarWarsTheory it would be awesome if #DarthMaul was a Jedi 👹

  • @jon021ful
    @jon021ful 7 років тому +4

    What if Padme was still Queen in episode 2

  • @jon021ful
    @jon021ful 7 років тому +5

    What if Padme stand Courasaunt in episode 2and did not leave for Naboo

    • @withmuckguy3362
      @withmuckguy3362 7 років тому

      Stayed on corusant not stand

    • @tjwilkie258
      @tjwilkie258 6 років тому +1

      Rowan Ribby Well... you can't spell either.

  • @joederp7512
    @joederp7512 4 роки тому

    Absolutely amazing work sir!

  • @nathanl17gaming81
    @nathanl17gaming81 8 років тому +1

    please continue with this story, also continue your Maul trained Anakin series.

  • @olsaintlit7180
    @olsaintlit7180 8 років тому +5

    What if General Leia turned to the dark side?

    • @shelovesmiia_
      @shelovesmiia_ 5 років тому

      @sans the skeleton, she has force powers, altho she never really learned how to use them

  • @Patriksj
    @Patriksj 8 років тому +5

    Üls do waht If Doku never turned to the Dark side

    • @Patriksj
      @Patriksj 8 років тому

      *pls

    • @TheSYPHERIA
      @TheSYPHERIA 8 років тому +5

      They have one at -- youtube: STUPENDOUS WAVE but this guy does good

    • @svenservette4197
      @svenservette4197 8 років тому

      You can also use the "edit" feature.

  • @thomaschapman4415
    @thomaschapman4415 6 років тому +4

    And as always my and Jedi Sith friends...😂

  • @gooeykev
    @gooeykev 7 років тому +2

    He'd be the most powerful Jedi next to Yoda, Kenobi, Mace, and Anakin I think.

  • @fuckinantipope5511
    @fuckinantipope5511 8 років тому +312

    good story but Dooku wouldnt be a sith because Qui-Gons death let him fall to the dark side

    • @TheAdvancedKnine
      @TheAdvancedKnine 8 років тому +12

      Exactly

    • @TheAdvancedKnine
      @TheAdvancedKnine 8 років тому +15

      +Scott Attenborough no he wasn't what are you talking about ?

    • @TheZbane
      @TheZbane 8 років тому +44

      Dooku didnt give fully into the darkside until Qui Gon died, but he explained that sidious would speed up the process with his manipulation, but Dooku still was studying and attuning himself with the Dark side well before he left the order

    • @Elcrisso1
      @Elcrisso1 8 років тому +21

      +Scott Attenborough No he was not. He was unhappy with the state of the galactic Republic and disagreed with the Jedi's interference in politics; however only the death of his former apprentice led to him studying the Sith arts and being taken as apprentice by Darth Sidious.

    • @TheZbane
      @TheZbane 8 років тому +11

      Again wrong I just dbl checked he left the order well before the death of Qui-Gon and took over his title as count of Sorreno before Sidious approaches him and the reason he left was masked behind his obsession with the darkside of the force. He was 100% one of the lost twenty and this is all cannon information. You can look this up for your self before you repost dumb uneducated comments

  • @IontCur
    @IontCur 7 років тому

    I'm glad you did this! I always wanted Maul to be a good guy

  • @marktyndall669
    @marktyndall669 6 років тому +4

    If he was a Jedi I would work for the Jedi but he's a Sith so I work for the Sith

  • @Diagonalstuff
    @Diagonalstuff 7 років тому +7

    Qui gon wouldn't have been dead so Dooku most likely wouldn't have become a dark sider

  • @snaz9461
    @snaz9461 8 років тому +9

    I disagree Because dooku only turned because the death of qui gon so he wouldn't have joined sideous

  • @IHopegood
    @IHopegood 3 роки тому

    “At last the Jedi will be avenged. At last the Sith will be no more”
    Clever play on Mauls line from episode 1

  • @lamontshell4793
    @lamontshell4793 Рік тому

    Dam...this is a dope what if story. Keep up the good work bro !

  • @cartho1103
    @cartho1103 7 років тому +5

    Dooku wouldn't become Sidious' apprentice because Dooku only turned to the dark side when Qui Gon died

  • @thesithgamer2723
    @thesithgamer2723 8 років тому +3

    saparatists vs empire

  • @colespofford8207
    @colespofford8207 5 років тому +4

    6:11 find out next time on dragon ball Z

  • @Drayco500
    @Drayco500 8 років тому +1

    this is pretty interesting to see I love maul and seeing how much more of a badass he is as a Jedi is even cooler