"At $3.5 Trillion, India's economy is 10 times bigger than Pakistan..." say foreign policy experts
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 тра 2024
- With India all set to host SCO in May and G20 later in September this year, India-US relations have become a very important topic with strategic partnerships reaching an all-time high between the two largest democracies of the world. This episode of ANI Podcast with Smita Prakash features two sessions, which includes one at Raisina Dialogue held in New Delhi, March 2023 and the other recorded in January 2023. The expert panel comprises former Indian Ambassador to the United States Arun Kumar Singh and Former US Ambassador to India Kenneth Juster, who discuss various aspects of India-US relations in a revitalised Quad era, China’s resistance to Quad and Russia-Ukraine war during the first session, while in the second session foreign policy expert and executive director of Observer Research Foundation, USA, Dhruva Jaishankar and senior fellow at Asia Society Policy Institute, C Raja Mohan comes together with Smita Prakash to discuss the topic on a broader aspect by decoding the strengthened relationship in the light of a rejuvenated NATO, acceptance of Indo-Pacific, Ukraine War and upcoming elections in both countries. In this video, foreign policy experts talks about India's role in restoring peace in the Russia-Ukraine war and how the US is benefitting from the conflict
#Podcast #ANIPodcastWithSmitaPrakash #SmitaPrakash
Watch the full episode here: • EP-51 | India-US Relat...
Subscribe now and press the bell icon 🔔 to get new video updates: bit.ly/2UV4ygi
--------------------------------------
ANI is South Asia's leading Multimedia News Agency providing content for every information platform, including TV, Internet, broadband, newspapers, and mobiles.
Subscribe now! Enjoy and stay connected with us!!
☛ Subscribe to ANI News UA-cam channel: bit.ly/2UV4ygi
☛ Visit our Official website: www.aninews.in/
☛ Follow ANI: / ani
☛ Like us: / aninews.in
☛ Email to: anicontent@aniin.com, internetani@aniin.com
☛ Copyrights © All Rights Reserved ANI Media Pvt Ltd.
India has reached her critical mass to redefine her status and role in the World. Pakistan is just an irritation that India has to deal with, but in an innovative and prospectful way. While there are many suitors, India has chosen to do the same with them.
We still have a long way to go, and we shouldn't stop and celebrate here.
The Best Strategy for India at this moment is to just ignore Pakistan, except to give them a real bloody nose for any cross-border terrorism. In any two-nation relationship, each nation can safely assume that the other country will do what is in its own best interest. The reality is that Pakistan has nothing, repeat NOTHING to offer that India needs so badly. The only thing of any value to India that Pakistan could offer was the opportunity of a trade passage thru Pakistan to the Central Asian markets. India can easily access those markets now thru Chabahar, although with a bit of added expense,. Pakistan is of no value to India now. Let them sink, if that is their fate.
Indians should stop talking about Pakistan. We know that India is already better than Pakistan. We need to compare ourselves to China and USA. Our GDP is only 1/7 of USA
Prithvi Raj Chauhan did the same with Mohammad Gazni and the rest is history. Finish off the enemy or else they will destroy you when their moment comes.
@@anilsinha4968 There is politics and there is pragmatism, your PM has demonstrated a fine balance, unlike his predecessors. You have him for PM, and he gives you development. Wish India well.
Dhruva Jaisankar the S/O S Jaisankrar and it is good to see that both are in the same field👏👏
I have been reading his article since last 3 years on New India Express, it was pleasure to hear for the first time .😊
Who?
@@vbiotonicmascot6099 C Raja Mohan (grey bearded)
It's really surprising why we compare ourselves with them .. let them be der .. indians and our media too should stop giving them attention.. let's focus on top three ..
My fellow Indians doesn't have balls & hardworking & honestly without being hypocrites to compete with top dogs in the world. It's all in the mentality & thought process which makes a country grow & develop.
China is similar to India in many ways, except size and political system (economic growth is recent thing) but they never compare themselves with India. Pakistan hardly compares itself with Bangladesh although Bangladesh was once part of Pak.
But it's only India which compares it with Pakistan.
We now don't really compare with pakistan , we're aspiring to balance with china and I that journey, we're gonna grow..
Naa boi.. we bypassed beggers 😂😂
Nah..now the target has shifted to Chyna.. but we ready for a two front as our Late CDS said.
Lol paxtani beggars always talk about India so we have right to make some fun too
😂😂😂😂 good one,u should try doing stand-ups
India should match its competitor - China. Give this as a case study to those students in IITs doing history and political science.
Even though our economy is 10 times of Pakistan but still we are not able to take back POK not only that IAF is having lack of 12 squadron of fighter jets. I mean seriously this just patting our own back nobody talks about that.
Don't talk like "Rahul Pappu Khan Jhon Ghandhi" Pakistani Pig's are Jihadi their life begins after death. They are willing to die for 72 Virgins. But we want to live .
Why should we take back pok?...
C Raja Mohan - always refreshing to hear. Good and realistic perspective.
He is from the South. Usually, this Pakistan fixation / obsession is a phenomenon in Northern India.
@@newbiekhyber Because Pakistan is ethnically, linguistically and culturally an extension of north and northwest India.
Well, not so realistic. Biased towards the Old World Order. He doesn't think India can leverage on any of its power that it has to strengthen itself.
and 5 times smaller than China's
So what you u want .
Become a economy more than china in 1 day.
We are working toward it dont just see negative
@@SatyamSingh-to9uy just pointing to work ahead of us .. Instead of looking in the rear view mirror we should be looking in front of us.
I feel Indians are unnecessarily obsessed with a failed state like Pakistan
@@SatyamSingh-to9uy in 1980s India China was same economy. Rather India got subway metro railway 12 years before Shanghai in China. India remained foolish being confused from internal chaos. China steadily build its infrustructure & industrial growth from that opportunity.
@@surojeetchatterjee forget about that. Tell me why an Industrialized state like west bengal was deindustrialized?
@@millennialmind9507 he won't have an answer for that
Studio looks beautiful and good insights to current ukrain, russia war.
Its not that America is blind to it. They loved using Pakistan along with the British has a hedge to India's rise. Wake up...
Agree totally, these folks are living on another planet.
*Re: "Stop worrying about Pakistan" -- We said same thing after 1971 - and then Pakistan came back with nuclear weapons, and started militancy in Punjab and Kashmir. Only a fool turns their back on a venomous snake. If Pakistan is in such bad shape, then assist their collapse - don't keep them around and turn your back on them. Past precedent shows that even a collapsing Pakistan can become playground for mischief by others (Carter/Reagan admins, Beijing). Stop imitating Prithvi Raj Chauhan's foolish behaviour towards Mohammad Ghauri.*
Exactly that older guy is just a brown coolie, trying to spread morphed facts. Nato has more than 10 times the GDP of Russia why don't they stop worrying about what Russia might do.
Well said
In the past PAK got help from Indian enemies to wage war.India should not forget this
Whaa. kya soch hai . Understand the situation, i was not born in 1971 but who won the war. Why Bangladesh is formed. And again nuclear power is copied struggling to get wheat . If u say they come up with nuclear weapon , then what india comes with wheat. Don't underestimate your country and others too.
By the way collapse of nibhours will do more harm full for us. There must be alternative to clear situation. Hmm i must say u r analysis i think not up to mark ,just highlight in bold letters will not make arguments GREAT.
@@samv9947 I am not Pakistani but I salute thier bravery. 200 millions Pakistani compare to 1.4 billion Indian. 7 times bigger than Pakistan and still lost half Kashmir to Pakistan..😂
Why we are comparing ourselves with pakistani.... We should have much bigger vision and goals.. We should compare ourselves with usa and china.. And work on becoming the 5 trillion economy by 2027..
Let’s just say P is to keep the masses titillated. Indians should really start imagining themselves as at least as developed as a well-performing South-East Asian economy. Time for India to really her economy start doing the talking in terms of adding value.
Only India can solve the problem of war, but it is helping us.
Beggeristhan economy is 300 billion dollars 😂😂(its further shrinking😂)
Next f.y2023 🇮🇳 is 3.8 trillion dollars (300 billion added which is = pak)
After PKR devaluation ,paks gdp now stands at 100-150 billion dollars
And we are beggars in comparison with China so 🥲
Your surname reminds me of a great man "gopal patha" ji may Krishna bless his soul for his contributions to people of our motherland
@@krr3502 bro, you have good knowledge about true history 🔥🔥 time to change colonial fake history books
@@nageswaraopatha5445 unless and untill stories of heroes like gopal patha is spread among the youth and coming generation there contributions will be whitewashed recently Wikipedia deleted page on "gopal patha ji" it's a systematic agenda by leftist and jihadis to devoid hindus upcoming generation from the story of valours of our elders that's how Wikipedia painted "Delhi riot" as riot planned by hindus to kill muslim but we know the reality was opposite even high Court verdict says so
India should compete with china and forget about Pakistan as if it exists
It's time to stop comparing ourselves with Pakistan and start seeing ourselves with China. It's said that some people( country ) are not capable of being your enemy so start finding a worthy one .
The guy wearing specs is Dhruva Jaishankar the son of Mr. Jai Shankar, foreign minister of India.
Not seeing the Japanese features on Dhruva.
Why the heck do you guys compare India with Pakistan? Arent there other contries to compare?
👏👏
There is a saying, fire and an enemy should be neglected. Pakistan's misfortunes of today , should not be a reason to give it a chance to survive and attack India in future.
Big country don't compare with small countries its just a shameful reason
Smithaji, as an Indian American, I appreciate your comment on how India would not stand for giving up an inch of Kashmir or Arunachal and Ukraine is expected to fight like hell to defend their sovereignty! I wish Indian government would be more forceful in opposing Russian invasion of Ukraine. Jai Hind!🇺🇸🇮🇳
It's not our war. Russia is India's friend.
You must understand as indian american, it's the america that provoked this war.
Just say Indian who has American citizenship! :)
Why should India be forceful? You live in US. The people of India needs to deal with China and we don’t want to see Russia and China coming together against India. India is balancing ties with Russia by buying their oil so that they will not become totally dependent on China.
And you should ask US and Ukraine why did they sell weapons to Pakistan despite knowing that they will be used against India.
It is not our war nor it is US war. It Russia - Ukraine conflict so let them solve it.
IMHO we are focusing too much on 3.5trillion and 5th largest status. Our focus should be 1st or atleast 2nd.
3rd largest by 2027
But 1st or 2nd is too difficult
In 2025 India will be 5 trillion economy and in 2030 india shall be 10 trillion economy.
I have a question what if war end can Ukraine pay their debt to European and USA. What about economy how about infra
I don't think we should compare with Pakistan.
We should look forward and improve on our own.
Most important is to curb corruption which is not happening, infact raising in state level like Karnataka
India is rising as powerful country we should compare ourselves with big global power like US Russia and China not with finished country like Pakistan.
Let us not compare ourselves with pakistan. I don't even capitalize the p in pakistan deliberately because it deserves no respect whatsoever. 😂
we need 10 trillion dollar economy very very fast and soon, people in india are very very poor and only 20 % of indians own refrigerator, washing machine and television. it should be 100 %.
Shar
focus on petty things & nourish hatred for Muslims & Congress
Within a week....15T economy
Yes, we have very low per capita and standards of living in India and hence everyone prefers to go outside, that's fact
@@pratikpatil6342 people go outside india because of their glittering cities, better roads and cleanliness, our cities and infrastructure is very poor.
@Sharad Jain Yes, that's called "standard of living" as I mentioned earlier but it's not limited to that, it includes good schools, medical facilities and governance too.
The west and china wants Pakistan’s to keep distracting India. Today Sir Modiji is strong enough to tick off Pakistan and EAM Sir Jaishankar is articulate and chooses his words when he hits back at the west .
what happen when a week govt comes in 10 year time. We need to nurture a pool of your and upcoming politicians to handle China USA and UK
And in terms of population and area? Whats there to even mark this as a headline. These are perfect examples of targeting small for oneself
Why are we comparing ourselves to Pakistan and giving them so much mileage. And the guest is absolutely right. Let’s shake off our obsession
Why nato is expanding every year Soviet union was dissolved way back in 1990s so the question is why nato is expanding this is Russia asking
Who give USA rights to come to the border of russia
How would USA feel if russia put their nuclear weapons right in front of USA border
👍
Isn't that Dr S Jaishankar's son ??
Like Cuba or like who do infiltration into US ,, having a Pak in neighbourhood is a big problem, better Pak is trifuricated
With reference to Per Capita it's just 1.5 to 2 times bigger
@@Mohammad69AyeshaAt9 your name 😆😆😆😆😆😆😆
It's only Russia who can stop the war.
Why Ukraine must not receive assistance for self preservation?
I think military matter the most that's why Russia is big global powerful country despite their economy is 20 times smaller than US.
Sir all your said things are okay but that doesn’t mean we accept West good bing relief to Pakistan. As an Indian my end goal is POJK as part of India under Indian rule so we can connect with EU, Afghanistan, Central Asia, Russia for trade and for good future doing this cutting Chinese roads to sea via POJK so china would not feel secure. This can not happen if West keep giving Pakistan a breather and until Pakistan disintegrated into different countries, West supporting Pakistan is my biggest concern until POJK is not under Indian control after that they can arm Pakistan, give all the money they want to Pakistan does not matter to me. But until then I would like that country with weak on financial front and military front. This should be the end goal of every Indian PM.
And we should not relax that West doesn’t have use of Pakistan just because our Indian economy is bigger than Pakistan like you said. If POJK is not the issue then your words are true but if my goal is to take a land which belong to me I would like no other support my adversary with which I have land problem and I would like to take back what is mine
Pakistan should be compared with UP , not Maharashtra
😊
Comparison with Pakistan is the way forward 😂
Why doesn't India have a 24/7 global TV English channel to promote India and the tremendous progress that is being made. Emulate China which has CTGN/CCTV and has projected China as a modern superpower. Japan has NHK, Germany DW, France TV, BBC, etc. I travel extensively and sadly have no access to a 24/7 Indian channel in the many five-star hotels I stay in. Pay little heed to Western media. Create your own global media and project India to the world.
When will India have 20 lane roads like China has because, we also have huge population....we need 20 lane roads to move. And Space between two building and also some greenery.😇
Nh8 near ambience mall in gurgaon has a lot of lanes
India don't have 20 lane roads but we have 12 lane roads in Gurgaon cyber city
If you don't like own country go Pakistan india economy only grow in future
@@Moonuuu Why are you opposed with Pakistan, you would have said me to go to China.
And don't you have need or desire to have infrastructure like China, because we have hard working labors and smart engineers.
We must learn something from china.
In past we had world class infrastructure ...
And we indian/hindus deserve world class infrastructure....
4 goals of Hindu ,Dharma,Artha ,Kama,Moksha.
Artha is also important.
He's S.Jai Shankar's son.
1/10th of China, so stop saying pak and let's focus on US or China
Economy to be honest doesn't matter much for a example Russia economy is 23 times smaller than USA.
If India compare themselves with countries like Pakistan we not work-hard we should see ourselves in US Russia China league.
We have to calculate our economy in ppp. Jisme china first he slave labor ke bajase. US second he lobbying ke liye. Aur hum ha third he. 😅 Abhi bhi aur Kam karna hei. Here is my advice for our economy
Pahele to govt. Company s ko corporate koro.
Jaha par ye company's apnihi profit ke paisese apni employees ko salary de. Jaimse UAE, Dubai, Singapore karta he. Ab is salary ko base salary+profit of the company se calculate karenge. Aur education policy ko implement jo abhi bhi fasa hua he
Just 10 times ???
”Religion was invented when the first con man met the first fool." - Mark Twain
I disagree with the statement of handing over the land the war started with Nato coming to Russia boarders if Ukraine can guarantee non NATO alliance then this war would have nit even started
$3.5trn but we don't have money to pay our hero's DEFENCE OROP arrears from 2019..
Stop comparing India with Pakistan. Right we have to stop obsessing about Pakistan. If you want to compare India, compare with gulf countries ,china
You can shake off Pakistan but Pakistan won’t shake u off.
Look at Bangladesh
Bangladesh GDP is almost 200 billion bigger than Pakistan 😅
Bangladesh GDP will cross 541 billion this year according to IMF (23-24fy)
Its high time Smita prakash decreses her Pakistan obsession and instead compare India with China.
China and US are real competitor of India not Pakistan.
But looking at the population, we’re five times smaller than China. Stop making irrelevant comparisons from Pakistan to please your people. Raise your standards!
Ukraine if wanted to protect their self-esteem they shouldn't have gone to USA living close to and also having historically close ties with Russia. Russia being a bigger country will certainly feel threatened. As u said that we will not give Kashmir similarly we will take every step to ensure our neighbours don't go to our enemies side, method may differ. And also, one more thing which may be controversial but we did give Kashmir to the enemies hand just so that er can maintain peace, in the name of not dirtying our hands we did compromise our sovereignty in the past, though now we are taking some stance with defensive offence approach still we had to compromise with our sovereignty. We also compromised some of our neighbouring countries to our enemies again for the same matter not dirtying our hands. I think this not dirtying our hands or simply speaking "non violent" approach is what differentiates us to the Russian violent approach.
I hope they remain below 350 billion for the next decade.
Hars
Desi attitude......pull the other guy down
India should finish Pakistan in next 5 to 10 years and start our race with big power like US and China.
Entire OIC has supported Pakistan on kashmir issue in the UN which is what matters.
Pakistan was created to counter India
Pakistan is still supporting cross border terrorism. We are not obsessed with Pakistan.
So to tell shrug off our Pakistan obsession is absolute nonsense.
Love the analysis and intellect of c raja mohan
US will fight Russia till the last Ukranian😂
India is US Russia and China level country not on Pakistan level country.
OMG IS THIS SMITA ???
India is USA Russia China league country not Pakistan.
This person is claiming that only China gave the nuclear Weapons to Pakistan but there was also USA involved in it and USA never imposed sanction ever imposed sanction on Pakistan like they did with India. Also at that time China wasn't that powerful and China was also a satellite state for the USA
Russia economy is 23 times small compare to USA I think military show how powerful you're.
the batman ppster is very out of place 😂
Hmm, an unsatisfying, unconvincing talk.
Stop comparing with bikharistan please
pooristan vs Pakistan
Pakistan blabbering is very important for Indian establishment to keep Indians happy in a manipulative way....
That guy is son of dr. S. JAISHANKAR.
For god sake don’t compare India with pakistan just for ego massage. They are no match for us. Our real competition should be with USA and China. Gone are the days of indo Pak rivalry.
Very flawed argument just because we have 10 times GDP of Pakistan, we shouldn't be careless, it's like saying since nato has more than 10 times GDP of Russia it must leave Russia alone.
It is the Nato who was expanding not Russia, this compelled Russia to conduct it's military operation. And thing about Kashmir is we already gave our land to make two countries Pakistan and Bangladesh, in hopes for greater peace but results were opposite. So now we can't give them anymore land. Similarly with china nehru helped them in colonizing Tibet, it is backfiring on us now. This older guy needs to get his facts checked and stop being a brown coolie.
Firstly, we should not benchmark ourselves with a religious state like Pakistan, even though we are neighbours in the same region. Secondly, we are also multiple times bigger in size and population to Pakistan, so being 10 times larger economically is not something to be very proud of.
We must realise and accept that we are still operating way below our true potential and that is squarely to be blamed on the rampant corruption and terrible politics played by our lawmakers to pull each other down. In the process, the whole country is pulled down economically.
China economy is 19.5 trillion. Compare to China.
It’s 17.5 trillion. You hv to understand after reaching 10 trillion every year 750 billion to trillion will add. But China cannot hv growth like past anymore . Bcoz it’s real estate is so crumbled . I worked for continental automotive and travelled China in 2015 and 2022. Now it’s real estate is collapsed . In 5 yrs it’s manufacturing capability wl go down. Once europe free trade agreement with India happens it’s gonna be game changer. Target is to complete it by this year end. Geographically we are very near to Europe than China for exports . Next 10-20yrs it wl great awesome . Avoid media noise just observe what changes happening on ground . U wl know
Yess..
Why should we think of ourselves to compare with them....we should think of chinna and us not Pakistan no use of comparing with them
We are 6 times bigger than Pakistan. It has deteriorated, so india hasn’t done something extraordinary. China which is of similar size is 6 times bigger.
Lol pOK ko chor de nhi to gya 😅😂
keep comparing with pakistan that suits you people , I m a bjp person , and i urge you to compare with china
Dhruva looks like S Jaishankar's younger brother😅.
looks very old & haggard
Voice is terrible
I think Dhruva, son of dr.jaishankar
@@NightKing12 yes he is
In Terms of population,our economy is far far behind . Now a days i am seeing people are taking name of Pakistan alot unka kya economy hai unka kya halat hai. Ye sav kar k mai bas samjhna chahata hu discuss kar k india ko koi fayeda ho raha hai? Ya anvi kuch v karna hi hai khaki bethe ho toh bolna hi hai??...140 cr people bro we are far far behind gdp per capita if you see. India pehele kor(6cr population),israel(50lakhs) isko takkar de. Wohi badi baat hai.
Also , everyone is saying that China is better but it is mostly manufacturing based and all other countries are starting to diversify supply chains. This year is said to be peak year for Chinese economy but now its population and economy will stagnant or decrease. While India has much more diverse economy not solely based on manufacturing but on service and agriculture also
and ONE-SIXTH of CHINA, Chinese economy is more than 18 Trillion $🥲
just a matter of time we will catch up. Their demography is aging
@@higherbeingX I guess it will take at least 2 decades.
thats Jaishankar's son.
This analysis’s are not correct. I agree with Abhijit Chavda analysis
At last Raja Mohan has spoken some sense
Uncle Sam is the cause of this war
And only Uncle Sam can end it
It is supposed to be big. Because it is comprised of many small states like Pakistan. So we can stop this stupid comparison with Pak and Bangla.
I have been telling the Media to Quit the Pakistan Obsession . Focus and Copy Chinese infrastructure , Science ,Cities , Education . Give more space to China news .
equivalent to suicide for BJP or Modi. when people see the real China and immerse gap, liar Modi, BJP would be blamed to death.
The most important thing is that we have just 30 years of demographic dividend left with us.We must work our way to grow our gdp to 40 trillion dollars in the next 30 years and become a developed economy with atleast 25k USD per capita. If we do not get there we will see a collapse like what China is about to witness in the 2030's.
You are eating a lot of 💩🐄 Gobarbakht 😂😂😂😂
10 times bigger than Pakistan 6times less than china and isa
Pakistan se compare krke kya khush hona. Apne size ka China h, threat china se hai, humari competition China se h.
India will be 20 times bigger soon 😂
At 17trillion China's gdp is almost 5 times more than India...so stop comparing to pakistan ...and one more thing per capita income is more useful in assesment of countries development..
India has higher per capita income than Pakistan.
It's currently 18.5 Trillion not 17
@@nikIlguitar GDP nominal matters, nominal shows how much productivity is there in that country. Per capita shows how much better HDI is in that country.
@@rimurutempest2130 That's due to Hongkong annexation by CCP. Otherwise its 17 trillion, Hongkong has 2 trillion.
@@surojeetchatterjee Yeah right it doesn't matter . In 4-5 years they are projected to be 21 Trillion $. Just look at their cities like Chongqing , Mumbai, Bengaluru looks like some remote village in comparison .
India per capita income is so low
$2,300 indeed