The 5th argument is absolutely crucial!!! I agree so much! I prefer learning from Masterclass or UA-cam videos and designing my own space instead of hiring an interior designer.
@@silyanelarcher8324 so first of all, you still rely on professional or experienced interior designers, only that you prefer to pay for un personal and generic advice you get online. Good for you
Your insights are so appreciated! Thank you! It's so much fun to design your own space, even when mistakes are made--I have made plenty but learn each time.
I agree with most of your points, but not entirely. Hiring a professional isn’t just something lazy or clueless people do. A professional interior designer's role isn't to finish the design process for you. Instead, their expertise lies in helping you refine your design choices, guiding you through the process of selecting elements that will work well together in your space. How often have we bought beautiful items that, on their own, seem perfect, but when placed in our space, just don’t work? Not everything that looks good in isolation will necessarily harmonize with what you already have. A skilled designer won’t impose their personal taste; rather, they’ll help you discover and develop your own aesthetic, empowering you to grow your design vision over time.
Absolutely agree on the value of professional designers. My content isn't about criticizing design professionals, but about empowering people who may not have the financial means to hire a full-service designer. Most people want to create beautiful, cohesive spaces but are working within tight budget constraints. The reality is that professional design expertise is incredibly valuable. Designers do exactly what you described - they help people refine their vision, avoid costly mistakes, and create spaces that truly work. My videos aim to provide design insights for those who can't afford professional services, giving them tools to make more intentional design choices.
@ tho I do understand your intention, the way you did put it out wasn’t good for those like yourself, who work and dedicate time and dedication in research, in the personal level to help people. Once again, I just like a few others commenting, just think that your intention is good, your execution was not quite as good.
Then there is the issue of thoughtfully integrating storage and work areas into an interior design. It's not all about selecting and arranging sofas , chairs and home theaters.
Functionality isn't exclusive to professionals. Most people intuitively understand their own space and storage needs. A parent knows how to create a mudroom that works for their family. Someone that works from home understands what they need to organize their workspace. Basic functional design is something people do every day. My videos are about empowering people to trust their own practical insights while learning design principles that can elevate their spaces. The reality is that MOST people don't have the budget to hire a full service interior designer.
My intention isn't to malign designers, but to highlight a critical point. Sometimes designers prioritize the aesthetic appeal over lived experience. What looks perfect in a magazine or even more balanced on a floor plan might not work for how real people live, work, and move through their spaces.
@designmorsels so your point is "some designers are bad at designing"? Basically your examples are of designers not doing their jobs. I think that's a bit silly. If an interior designer isn't considering your needs you should find a new one or screen them better from the beginning.
@designmorsels It's a creative process that requires ability to work in 3-dimensions, with an understanding of materials, and lighting, and even building codes . Those are skills and knowledge most people simply don't have. This video's dismissal of expertise and training tells us are not taking the subject seriously. The Dunning Kruger effect lives on UA-cam
For complex projects - especially those involving structural changes, building codes, or intricate technical requirements - I absolutely recommend working with a trained professional. But redecorating your living room doesn't always require this level of expertise. Most people watching my content aren't looking to gut their home and redesign it without help. Nor are they aiming to be featured in Architectural Digest. Interior design doesn't have to be reserved for those with huge budgets.
What a stunning encouragement for people suffering from the Dunning-Kruger effect. If you agree expertise in design, which is simplistically portrayed and grossly misrepresented in this video, is truly overrated, you might want ask yourself if you would perform your own surgery.
That's an interesting perspective, comparing interior design to surgery suggests you might be taking this a bit too seriously. Unlike brain surgery, design is fundamentally a creative expression where success is subjective - beauty is in the eye of the beholder. My videos are about empowering people to understand design principles. The Dunning-Kruger effect? I'm encouraging people to recognize there's always more to learn, which is the opposite of overconfidence. Just like cooking or photography, it's a skill that improves with knowledge and practice. If my content inspires someone to look at their space more critically, learn new skills, or feel more confident in their choices - that's a win for me.
So you are telling me that anyone can wake up one day and identify as a designer [or architect] and do what it takes years of studying history, learning the skills to draw, model, put presentations and budgets together, develop concepts, create trusting relationships with fabricators and vendors, redesign their homes and maybe even knock down some walls, pull permits, solve problems during construction in a timely manner, etc., etc., etc.? Hm, maybe that why HGTV exists. Do you have other videos on ‘“why you don’t need a lawyer, a surgeon, a mechanic, an engineer, a fireman…?” Sorry, I see this type of content as disrespectful to design professionals throughout the world.
No I'm not telling you that anyone can wake up one day and be a designer or an architect. I'm saying that not everyone can afford a designer and not every project requires one. I made a followup video about 7 times it's worth it do hire a designer. Remodeling projects where you need to hire trades people and get drawings is one of those times, but redecorating a room doesn't require that. I also believe that building your own design skill is useful and possible with time and effort. It is not the same as doing surgery, you'd have to agree.
Being a good designer is somewhat in-born. The majority of people have no ability to visualize a space and in my experience are very resistant to input - a good designer - in my opinion is not just good because they have interior design knowledge but because of their ability to also get to know the client and create something that really functions well for them and represents their individual personality. I think it’s great that people definitely have more options available to create - more learning tools - but I think few want to take the time to learn design principles to do a project. Not totally knocking you putting out the idea that anyone can create a good design plan - but man I went to school for several years. It doesn’t happen overnight to learn this stuff . There are also still a lot of things that only a designer has access to - I’m not saying that’s a reason to hire a professional. But there still isn’t open access to a lot of brands etc. Good luck to those whose are interested to do it themselves. You can save money- but a good designer might be able to solve issues that a novice couldn’t or inspire something you wouldn’t ever think of yourself.
You've made some great points about design being both a learned skill and having an innate creative element. Creative abilities aren't fixed - they're skills that can be developed. Just like someone can learn to play an instrument, paint, or write, design is a creative skill that improves with education and practice. Sure, some people might have a natural predisposition towards spatial thinking or visual composition. But that doesn't mean others can't develop those skills. I agree with the access to products and completely agree that designers think of solutions that you might not. I actually put that in a follow up part 2, which is the other side of the coin, when you SHOULD hire a designer.
What a weird video! Many people can do Instagram worthy interiors, but few people can actually design. I assume this video is tongue in cheek or simply designed to shock. A good designer will work with you because hopefully she ‘doesn’t learn as she goes’ but is already trained. One can only hope…
Thanks for taking the time to comment! You've actually touched on an important distinction. There's a big difference between creating an Instagram-worthy staged interior and designing a functional, purposeful space. My videos aren't about replacing professional design expertise, but about helping people understand design principles and become more confident in their own skills. Professional training absolutely matters. A skilled designer brings years of technical knowledge, spatial understanding, and design theory that goes far beyond creating a pretty picture. What I'm advocating for is design literacy - helping people understand the basics so they can be better collaborators, whether they're working with a professional or tackling a project themselves. Importantly, not everyone can AFFORD to hire a designer.
@TomTheBullTerrier My entire video is actually encouraging people to learn more about design. It's not that all designers are bad, in fact I think they are necessary and useful in some cases. The bigger point is that most people can't afford to hire one and there's a lot people can learn to do on their own.
@ affordability shouldn’t be the first thing in mind when it comes to design. Many people spend much more on wrong materials, unmatched styles, horrible decor items because they think they can do it themselves. And learning by themselves can take ages. And even learning from online resources should still be counted as learning from professionals. If you calm down and take attention to what you wrote you will see it. But what matters is that you are getting views and clicks. Look at me, I don’t even like this particular video and yet I am here for the 4th time. You are a professional, dont say to your public you don’t matter
On the flip side there are reasons when a professional designer can be worth it. ua-cam.com/video/sOa1lKehJrE/v-deo.html
The 5th argument is absolutely crucial!!! I agree so much! I prefer learning from Masterclass or UA-cam videos and designing my own space instead of hiring an interior designer.
There's a lot of online education available, that's for sure!
@@silyanelarcher8324 so first of all, you still rely on professional or experienced interior designers, only that you prefer to pay for un personal and generic advice you get online. Good for you
Your insights are so appreciated! Thank you! It's so much fun to design your own space, even when mistakes are made--I have made plenty but learn each time.
I guess if you don't enjoy it, that's a reason to hire out, but even they make mistakes.
I agree with most of your points, but not entirely.
Hiring a professional isn’t just something lazy or clueless people do. A professional interior designer's role isn't to finish the design process for you. Instead, their expertise lies in helping you refine your design choices, guiding you through the process of selecting elements that will work well together in your space.
How often have we bought beautiful items that, on their own, seem perfect, but when placed in our space, just don’t work? Not everything that looks good in isolation will necessarily harmonize with what you already have.
A skilled designer won’t impose their personal taste; rather, they’ll help you discover and develop your own aesthetic, empowering you to grow your design vision over time.
Absolutely agree on the value of professional designers. My content isn't about criticizing design professionals, but about empowering people who may not have the financial means to hire a full-service designer.
Most people want to create beautiful, cohesive spaces but are working within tight budget constraints.
The reality is that professional design expertise is incredibly valuable. Designers do exactly what you described - they help people refine their vision, avoid costly mistakes, and create spaces that truly work.
My videos aim to provide design insights for those who can't afford professional services, giving them tools to make more intentional design choices.
@ tho I do understand your intention, the way you did put it out wasn’t good for those like yourself, who work and dedicate time and dedication in research, in the personal level to help people.
Once again, I just like a few others commenting, just think that your intention is good, your execution was not quite as good.
Exactly the reason why I am learning endlessly to design my house.As all the interior designers are met, none have my taste
Everyone has a truly unique style I think.
Amen💯. My home where i live should be designed by me for my needs
Yes, as long as you have the time it's worth it.
What a great perspective!
Thanks! Apparently not everyone agrees.
Then there is the issue of thoughtfully integrating storage and work areas into an interior design. It's not all about selecting and arranging sofas , chairs and home theaters.
Functionality isn't exclusive to professionals. Most people intuitively understand their own space and storage needs. A parent knows how to create a mudroom that works for their family. Someone that works from home understands what they need to organize their workspace.
Basic functional design is something people do every day. My videos are about empowering people to trust their own practical insights while learning design principles that can elevate their spaces. The reality is that MOST people don't have the budget to hire a full service interior designer.
Great information Andrea, thank you.
Thanks! Seems to be making some people very angry. 🤷♀
Can't please everyone. It's funny how someone's opinion can evoke such emotion, it's not like design is brain surgery.😅
Why imply maliciously, as this video does, that a designer will only produce results the don't match someone's needs?
Statistics
My intention isn't to malign designers, but to highlight a critical point. Sometimes designers prioritize the aesthetic appeal over lived experience. What looks perfect in a magazine or even more balanced on a floor plan might not work for how real people live, work, and move through their spaces.
I agree
@designmorsels so your point is "some designers are bad at designing"? Basically your examples are of designers not doing their jobs. I think that's a bit silly. If an interior designer isn't considering your needs you should find a new one or screen them better from the beginning.
@davidsorensen2808 how do you screen a designer?
You’re awesome
thank you!
@designmorsels It's a creative process that requires ability to work in 3-dimensions, with an understanding of materials, and lighting, and even building codes . Those are skills and knowledge most people simply don't have. This video's dismissal of expertise and training tells us are not taking the subject seriously. The Dunning Kruger effect lives on UA-cam
For complex projects - especially those involving structural changes, building codes, or intricate technical requirements - I absolutely recommend working with a trained professional. But redecorating your living room doesn't always require this level of expertise.
Most people watching my content aren't looking to gut their home and redesign it without help. Nor are they aiming to be featured in Architectural Digest. Interior design doesn't have to be reserved for those with huge budgets.
@@designmorsels I understand your intention, but it backfires on yourself.
What a stunning encouragement for people suffering from the Dunning-Kruger effect. If you agree expertise in design, which is simplistically portrayed and grossly misrepresented in this video, is truly overrated, you might want ask yourself if you would perform your own surgery.
That's an interesting perspective, comparing interior design to surgery suggests you might be taking this a bit too seriously. Unlike brain surgery, design is fundamentally a creative expression where success is subjective - beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
My videos are about empowering people to understand design principles.
The Dunning-Kruger effect? I'm encouraging people to recognize there's always more to learn, which is the opposite of overconfidence.
Just like cooking or photography, it's a skill that improves with knowledge and practice. If my content inspires someone to look at their space more critically, learn new skills, or feel more confident in their choices - that's a win for me.
I'm planning a part 2 where I discuss specific times when it makes more sense to hire a professional.
@@MisterJeffy you're selecting pillows not curing cancer.
So you are telling me that anyone can wake up one day and identify as a designer [or architect] and do what it takes years of studying history, learning the skills to draw, model, put presentations and budgets together, develop concepts, create trusting relationships with fabricators and vendors, redesign their homes and maybe even knock down some walls, pull permits, solve problems during construction in a timely manner, etc., etc., etc.? Hm, maybe that why HGTV exists. Do you have other videos on ‘“why you don’t need a lawyer, a surgeon, a mechanic, an engineer, a fireman…?” Sorry, I see this type of content as disrespectful to design professionals throughout the world.
No I'm not telling you that anyone can wake up one day and be a designer or an architect. I'm saying that not everyone can afford a designer and not every project requires one. I made a followup video about 7 times it's worth it do hire a designer. Remodeling projects where you need to hire trades people and get drawings is one of those times, but redecorating a room doesn't require that.
I also believe that building your own design skill is useful and possible with time and effort. It is not the same as doing surgery, you'd have to agree.
Being a good designer is somewhat in-born. The majority of people have no ability to visualize a space and in my experience are very resistant to input - a good designer - in my opinion is not just good because they have interior design knowledge but because of their ability to also get to know the client and create something that really functions well for them and represents their individual personality. I think it’s great that people definitely have more options available to create - more learning tools - but I think few want to take the time to learn design principles to do a project. Not totally knocking you putting out the idea that anyone can create a good design plan - but man I went to school for several years. It doesn’t happen overnight to learn this stuff . There are also still a lot of things that only a designer has access to - I’m not saying that’s a reason to hire a professional. But there still isn’t open access to a lot of brands etc. Good luck to those whose are interested to do it themselves. You can save money- but a good designer might be able to solve issues that a novice couldn’t or inspire something you wouldn’t ever think of yourself.
You've made some great points about design being both a learned skill and having an innate creative element. Creative abilities aren't fixed - they're skills that can be developed. Just like someone can learn to play an instrument, paint, or write, design is a creative skill that improves with education and practice.
Sure, some people might have a natural predisposition towards spatial thinking or visual composition. But that doesn't mean others can't develop those skills.
I agree with the access to products and completely agree that designers think of solutions that you might not. I actually put that in a follow up part 2, which is the other side of the coin, when you SHOULD hire a designer.
inspirational!
thanks!
What a weird video! Many people can do Instagram worthy interiors, but few people can actually design. I assume this video is tongue in cheek or simply designed to shock. A good designer will work with you because hopefully she ‘doesn’t learn as she goes’ but is already trained. One can only hope…
Thanks for taking the time to comment! You've actually touched on an important distinction. There's a big difference between creating an Instagram-worthy staged interior and designing a functional, purposeful space. My videos aren't about replacing professional design expertise, but about helping people understand design principles and become more confident in their own skills.
Professional training absolutely matters. A skilled designer brings years of technical knowledge, spatial understanding, and design theory that goes far beyond creating a pretty picture. What I'm advocating for is design literacy - helping people understand the basics so they can be better collaborators, whether they're working with a professional or tackling a project themselves. Importantly, not everyone can AFFORD to hire a designer.
@@designmorsels Sure, but your entire video is literally saying that no one should listen to or hire you.
@TomTheBullTerrier My entire video is actually encouraging people to learn more about design. It's not that all designers are bad, in fact I think they are necessary and useful in some cases.
The bigger point is that most people can't afford to hire one and there's a lot people can learn to do on their own.
@ affordability shouldn’t be the first thing in mind when it comes to design. Many people spend much more on wrong materials, unmatched styles, horrible decor items because they think they can do it themselves. And learning by themselves can take ages. And even learning from online resources should still be counted as learning from professionals. If you calm down and take attention to what you wrote you will see it. But what matters is that you are getting views and clicks. Look at me, I don’t even like this particular video and yet I am here for the 4th time. You are a professional, dont say to your public you don’t matter