Imagine in Beethoven's time, audience used to listen to Haydn, Mozart and the first two symphonies of Beethoven, and they came across this grand symphony! It is the peak of western musical culture.
Yes yes yes this conductor and his players keep surprising me. I really feel that Beethoven himself would approve of how his music was interpreted. And the energy, which is by far the most important I believe. You can tell that these performers are not just playing for money or prestige, but are passionate; and that makes all the difference.
Tremendous performance. So much thought went into this interpretation. It's as exciting and inspiring as it is moving. Thielemann is firmly among the greats.
How refreshing to see a full-sized orchestra with 8 contrabasses playing this music ! None of that period instrument crap. You get the exposition repeat which you never see in a live performance, and the extra trumpet parts in the coda of the first movement. What more can you ask for? And of course the Vienna Philharmonic who can play this music conductor-less more or less.
I'm not a musical expert, but I loved this video. Most playings of this symphony are, in my opinion, rushed. This one was slower and not hurried . . . instead it was graceful and majestic. Plus, the video work was outstanding, IMO. Enjoy.
Me da mucho gusto la preocupacion christian por haceber hecho unas interpretaciones de beethoven no tan lejos de las directrizces que marco su compositor
31:52 ! Un ciel d'encre en cette fin de journée printanière sur ces côteaux et châteaux bourguignons qui défilent maintenant devant mes yeux à 300 km/h... "Hé, mais c'est parfait avec ce paysage sinistre, quel grand moment ! Ecouter ça à 300 !" J'ai 22 ans, je suis presque seul dans cette voiture du TGV Lyon-Tours via Massy-Palaiseau. Cette symphonie par Bruno Walter sur les oreilles avec SL-XP 240 et HD330 EXPRESSION LINE... 9:52... autant de PUISSANCE...mais comment est-ce possible ? 😕
It is said that the Vienna Philharmonic was a men's club and no women played in it. It cannot happen today and I don't know when this custom changed. Still, the number of women playing in this concert is far from as many as men. Actually, I can only see one in the first violin section. But what a performance and what an orchestra!
Several ppl have commented on the fact that there's only one female musician, myself included. It's really disappointing that one of the world's finest and most well-known orchestras still hires almost no women. There's nothing that justifies that!
@@annedwyer797It’s just a tradition. You see lots of orchestras where there are more women than men, why don’t you complaine those orchestras have too much women and less men?
It takes quite some time for the 3rd movt to arrive at its assigned key (namely, before it finally gets to E flat, there's some B flat, then F, B flat again, and only then, E flat)
Alguien sabe como se llama el concertino, el primer violín del primer atril de violines primeros? Porfavor, se los agradecería mucho // Does anyone know the name of the concertmaster, the first violin of the first violin stand? Please, I would really appreciate it.
i wonder who that bearded guy in the double bass is. i always wondered how different his bow angle was. nice to see rainer kuchl play concertmaster once again too. my favorite flute player wolfgang breinschmid plays the second flute here. i think he played first in other concerts - with the capella andrea barca notably, with sir andras schiff and other world class musicians from different european orchestras and some soloits too.
El Profesor Daniel Franco Jr Escutia para Presidente de Morelia Michoacán México oh El Profesor Daniel Franco Jr Escutia para Presidente de Cuitzeo Del Porvenir Michoacán México el Pueblo Miajico y mis colegas y mi nuevo Chevrolet Blazer rojo de Uriangato a mi casa y un Ford Mustang Convertible y color azul oh gris y 84 Billones de dólares para hacer un Nuevo Hospital en Cuitzeo oh en Cuto Michoacán dónde está El Padre Ramón de Los Retiros
Gkoray Alejó López mando uns ves que mataran a mi y mi Hija Karla Sophia Franco Alcatrar ahora La Vivis Vicky Valencia Luna y Guillermo and Glen Campbell quieren hacer lo mismo mi Dios me lo dijo
Yes, I noticed that too! I know it was Vienna Phil actual policy until the 1990's not to hire female musicians (which was unconscionable!), but that was 30 yrs ago...I guess it hasn't made much progress since then.
@@gerhardhinterndotfer7307 Meaning that it's OK in the 21st century to have a policy that's a century out of date when it comes to hiring female musicians?
There was ONE female musician in the violin section...very disappointing in the Vienna Phil. I read that it was their policy until the 1990s not to hire women, but that was 30 yrs ago, and a hugely outdated policy at the time. But here we are 30 yrs later, and only one women in the orchestra! 😖
It takes decades of practice and great skill to be part of the world's best classical orchestra. Most women aren't committed enough. But there was one woman in the orchestra that night.
Several ppl, myself included, have commented on there being only one female musician (in the violin section). Really unconscionable in orchestra with the reputation of the Vienna Phil!
@@mariavuotila7215 The info just below the vid states this was a 2020 performance. Since the pandemic started shutting things down in March, this must have been in the first couple of months of 2020.
1:01 1 movement
20:54 2movement
39:08 3movement
45:00 4movement
Tysmmm
Imagine in Beethoven's time, audience used to listen to Haydn, Mozart and the first two symphonies of Beethoven, and they came across this grand symphony! It is the peak of western musical culture.
There's greater music in the East? Haha! H.E. 🤭
My most favourite living conductor. These Beethoven symphonies performance will be a landmark in the recording history.
They're live. Studio is always preferable.
perhaps the best interpretation of this sublime piece of music.
i couldn't agree more, Thielemann using orchestra like Furtwängler back in days, continuous tone... a mast!!
Yes yes yes this conductor and his players keep surprising me. I really feel that Beethoven himself would approve of how his music was interpreted. And the energy, which is by far the most important I believe. You can tell that these performers are not just playing for money or prestige, but are passionate; and that makes all the difference.
You are right
My view... without perhaps!
PEACE AND GOOD 💜
I love Bernstein's series also. I have always loved the vpo and beethoven!
A pure joy to watch. Love Christian Thielemann and Vienna Philharmonic - the best of the best. Thank you for sharing❤
thielmann ist grosse klasse. danke.l
Love Thielemann! Thank you for posting.
The Viennese sound is such a treasure..maintaining the traditional methods of how they played from the 1800s..it sounds so compact and mystical!
This amazing music is written for any heroic person-Beethoven Symphony no.3-total genius.
Nice to see/hear the coda taken at a pace that the strings can actually physically play.
ok.ich sage erstmal Dankeschön, herr thielemann. mein Beethoven ist bei ihnen sehr gut aufgehoben. vielen dank. .
Grandios, es ist schwer die Qualität in Worte zu fassen
Como definir a Eroica de Beethoven??? Não tem como definir...é sem palavras!!! É o próprio céu descido na Terra!
Tremendous performance. So much thought went into this interpretation. It's as exciting and inspiring as it is moving. Thielemann is firmly among the greats.
How refreshing to see a full-sized orchestra with 8 contrabasses playing this music ! None of that period instrument crap. You get the exposition repeat which you never see in a live performance, and the extra trumpet parts in the coda of the first movement. What more can you ask for? And of course the Vienna Philharmonic who can play this music conductor-less more or less.
Epic performance
A commanding performance.
Most sensitive rendering of this profoundly revolutionary symphony
The development section of the 1st movt even has its own theme; it contributes a new theme to the movt
Excellent interpretation. Bravo!
Thielemann.. WHAT ELSE?❤, ☄️
Very beautiful second movement.
Incredible!! They're all so in sync with each other!
still convinced. merci.
I'm not a musical expert, but I loved this video. Most playings of this symphony are, in my opinion, rushed. This one was slower and not hurried . . . instead it was graceful and majestic. Plus, the video work was outstanding, IMO. Enjoy.
Beethoven notated relative high tempi himself.
Me da mucho gusto la preocupacion christian por haceber hecho unas interpretaciones de beethoven no tan lejos de las directrizces que marco su compositor
31:52 ! Un ciel d'encre en cette fin de journée printanière sur ces côteaux et châteaux bourguignons qui défilent maintenant devant mes yeux à 300 km/h...
"Hé, mais c'est parfait avec ce paysage sinistre, quel grand moment ! Ecouter ça à 300 !"
J'ai 22 ans, je suis presque seul dans cette voiture du TGV Lyon-Tours via Massy-Palaiseau.
Cette symphonie par Bruno Walter sur les oreilles avec SL-XP 240 et HD330 EXPRESSION LINE... 9:52... autant de PUISSANCE...mais comment est-ce possible ? 😕
I was in this hall in 1999, too bad it was not a concert by the Vienna Philharmonic.
Who was it?
@@emiledarraghbarry It was a local small orchestra dressed in Mozartian costumes for tourists. It includes some Mozart opera arias. It was expensive.
SUBLIME!!! Dirección impecable, gracias.
It is said that the Vienna Philharmonic was a men's club and no women played in it. It cannot happen today and I don't know when this custom changed. Still, the number of women playing in this concert is far from as many as men. Actually, I can only see one in the first violin section. But what a performance and what an orchestra!
Pick the best; I say.
Several ppl have commented on the fact that there's only one female musician, myself included. It's really disappointing that one of the world's finest and most well-known orchestras still hires almost no women. There's nothing that justifies that!
@@annedwyer797It’s just a tradition. You see lots of orchestras where there are more women than men, why don’t you complaine those orchestras have too much women and less men?
정말 멋진 연주입니다. 감사합니다.
It takes quite some time for the 3rd movt to arrive at its assigned key (namely, before it finally gets to E flat, there's some B flat, then F, B flat again, and only then, E flat)
merci
Me gusta mucho esta música debe ver conciertods aqui en Cuitzeo
BGMには素晴らしい！
great. thx.
古楽楽器のスタイルが定着してからのモダン楽器による古典演奏が難しい事を実感させる。古楽楽器のスタイルを取り入れながらフルトヴェングラー張りのテンポの揺らし等を併用するという、大きな枠でのレトリックという言い訳をしながらの折衷は、ティーレマン氏に嘗ての巨匠の様な説得力が獲得されていないだけに苦しさを感じざるを得ない。更に新しいネルソンス氏の様なジリ貧ベートーヴェンよりはましかもしれないが。ウィーン・フィルも棘の道が続きそうーベルリン・フィルも同様か。暴言多謝
Beethoven's second-longest symphony
Premiered #otd in 1805 💐💐💐
Concert master Rainer Kuchl..
3악장과 4악장은 카라얀을 듣는것 같네요.
Horn Trio: 41:40
13:33 entrada de los cornos con el tema
Allegro con brio местами больше похоже на похоронный марш, чем вторая часть.
Alguien sabe como se llama el concertino, el primer violín del primer atril de violines primeros? Porfavor, se los agradecería mucho // Does anyone know the name of the concertmaster, the first violin of the first violin stand? Please, I would really appreciate it.
Rainer Kuchl
Świetne!
i wonder who that bearded guy in the double bass is. i always wondered how different his bow angle was.
nice to see rainer kuchl play concertmaster once again too. my favorite flute player wolfgang breinschmid plays the second flute here. i think he played first in other concerts - with the capella andrea barca notably, with sir andras schiff and other world class musicians from different european orchestras and some soloits too.
HIER SIND WAHRLICH EINIGE AHNUNGSLOSE VOLLTROTTELN WELCHE SICH WICHTIG MACHEN WIOLLEN:
12:27 is the guy with the beard even bowing the string?
54:00 I have born again. Earth is now the only heaven.
Están locos estos
El Profesor Daniel Franco Jr Escutia para Presidente de Morelia Michoacán México oh El Profesor Daniel Franco Jr Escutia para Presidente de Cuitzeo Del Porvenir Michoacán México el Pueblo Miajico y mis colegas y mi nuevo Chevrolet Blazer rojo de Uriangato a mi casa y un Ford Mustang Convertible y color azul oh gris y 84 Billones de dólares para hacer un Nuevo Hospital en Cuitzeo oh en Cuto Michoacán dónde está El Padre Ramón de Los Retiros
Una soberbia interpretación de esta afamada orquesta y de su distinguido director.
Estamos conectados en espíritu. Saludos desde Paraguay.
46:30
so klang meine Generation
0:59
30:06
29:20 :)
Found a woman nine of one violinist on the left
She was the only female musician I could find...kind of amazing in a bad way abt the Vienna Phil!
트럼펫 가필은 용납하기 힘드네요 베토벤의 의도를 정녕 모르는 겁니까?
Gkoray Alejó López mando uns ves que mataran a mi y mi Hija Karla Sophia Franco Alcatrar ahora La Vivis Vicky Valencia Luna y Guillermo and Glen Campbell quieren hacer lo mismo mi Dios me lo dijo
A concert from 2020, and only one female musician??
Yes, I noticed that too! I know it was Vienna Phil actual policy until the 1990's not to hire female musicians (which was unconscionable!), but that was 30 yrs ago...I guess it hasn't made much progress since then.
NON PLUS ULTRA
con velocidad a 1.5 es mejor
no credo
Not better but quicker.
Not a single woman in the orchestra... Not even a married one!🤥
i CH WÜRDE iHNEN DAS BUCH ,DEMOKRATIE DER KÖNIGE WÄRMSTENS EMPFEHLEN ZU LESEN DAMIT SIE IHREN UNWISSENDEN GEISTESHORIZONT ETWAS ERWEITERN KÖNNEN:
@@gerhardhinterndotfer7307 Meaning that it's OK in the 21st century to have a policy that's a century out of date when it comes to hiring female musicians?
There was ONE female musician in the violin section...very disappointing in the Vienna Phil. I read that it was their policy until the 1990s not to hire women, but that was 30 yrs ago, and a hugely outdated policy at the time. But here we are 30 yrs later, and only one women in the orchestra! 😖
What’s the problem?
@@이상호-l5c1z There is no problem It is a joke: single-married.
Woman and youngsters don`t bother. This orchestra is for old men only
It takes decades of practice and great skill to be part of the world's best classical orchestra. Most women aren't committed enough. But there was one woman in the orchestra that night.
28:49
@@buddlergrimes4518 - most women are not committed enough? On which planet do you live?
Vollidiot
dieses Orchester ist nicht für ahnungslose Banausen gegründet worden .lernen Sis Geschichte
I don't see any woman in the orchestra. Huh.
open your eyes and watch closely then 😁
28:49
Better, woman dont they spirit of music
Several ppl, myself included, have commented on there being only one female musician (in the violin section). Really unconscionable in orchestra with the reputation of the Vienna Phil!
It’s Vienna Phil. What do you want? They had a code not to hire women until 90s
No masks?
Well considering that the conductor is 63 and looks about 45 here, this was before the pandemic.
Oh God
This performance is from 2019.
@@dennyduranflores Was actually from 2009
@@mariavuotila7215 The info just below the vid states this was a 2020 performance. Since the pandemic started shutting things down in March, this must have been in the first couple of months of 2020.
13:28