The opening line for me is the kicker.... "These mist covered mountains are a home now for me" That is the thought of a dying soldier who realises he is going to spend the rest of their short lives on the battlefield.. The soldier although mortally wounded is thanking his brothers in arms for not deserting him and reassuring them that they will be home soon. Heart wrenching.
This song never ceases to give me chills ever since it was released. Not only for its sheer brilliance but one of my cousins was a survivor of one of the British ships that was sunk in the Falklands war. Although the song captures the feeling of another aspect of the war it still touches me deeply!
This is what it says under the word 'Masterpiece' in the dictionary. Lol. It's seriously on another level. Once again Knopfler and band created a classic that will stand the test of time. Remarkable. Lovely reaction 😊
I have heard this song hundreds of times and each time I have to prepare myself emotionally to listen to it but it is so good that I must go through tough emotions each listen ... great music and a healthy cleansing.
Dire Straits was my best friend's favorite non Metal band; he was Navajo, and he drank his very last room temp can of Budweiser years ago, and this song especially keeps him with us, so thank you.
This song seems to resonate with every veteran. We, ex British Army and damn proud, know what happens and what we can expect in combat/war, but we still go. Civvies will never understand and I'm happy for them.
The Band, Dire Straits & of course, Mark Knofler himself are British. This song was written as a tribute to the British Soldiers involved in the Falkland Islands Conflict between Britain & Argentina in 1982.
The only thing in this song that really touches me deeply every time is the wonderful voice of the Gibson Les Paul. Simply masterfully played by Mark Knopfler.
It is to bring attention to the irony of it all. Rushing, as you say, towards the weapons while simultaneously singing, "We are fools to make war on our brothers in arms." The men fighting the battles have no grievance with one another. They are killing each other over some remote leader's beef. Why in the world would we agree to that?
Tracks like Sultans of Swing and Telegraph Road translate brilliantly to live performances, but Brothers in Arms and Private Investigations are so precisely arranged with so many different nuances, that the studio version is far and away the best way to hear them.
I'd go part way with that. With the proviso that the 'studio version' is the one off the Brothers in Arms album, which is identical with this video but has two minutes extra on the end that (for some reason) they cut out of the video. Sultans of Swing and Tunnel of Love are, in my opinion, better in the live performances. In the case of Brothers in Arms, I agree the studio version is more precisely arranged. The live versions bring their own atmosphere to the song. So I'd rate them 'equal, but different'. (I actually have six different versions of this song on my MP3 player, and I can listen to all six in a row - they're sufficiently different that they don't get monotonous).
I'm always grateful for the things i have in my life without those poor men who fought and died for all of us. we wouldn't be here. It tears me up every time.
Great reaction. The live version from the Nelson Mandela Tribute Concert is recognised by fans as the best and certainly the most iconic version of this song.
@@InnaSoloMusicI read that their performance of this at the Nelson Mandela concert was so popular in South Africa that the “powers that be” asked who should get the royalties. When they replied “Amnesty International” the band was prohibited from performing in that country. South Africa’s problem with racial discrimination has improved somewhat since. Luv ya.😊
There is a live version that is outstanding. Longer instrumental solos and the best organ solo I’ve ever heard. Also Telegraph Road live is another outstanding performance!
Mark Knopfler released a live version from Berlin in 2007 to commemorate the 25th anniversary of the Falklands war. I believe all the proceeds went to Veteran's causes. It's worth a listen along with Mandela's 70th birthday version with Eric Clapton on rythym guitar.
A song written about the Falklands war and a British soldier called Lieutenant Lawrence who was shot and lost 42% of his brain on Mount Tumbledown by an Argentinian sniper as the Argentinians retreated, however its also about the futility of all wars and we are all brothers in arms doing things we dont really want to do but feel we have to as a good citizen to our country but has little rhyme or reason...😢
I am 46 years old. I have been listening to this album since the day it came out because of my mom and this song just moves me in ways that nothing else can. Oh and she's the "man too strong" in my life.
For an epic and beautiful performance of them live, check out "Dire Straits - Private Investigations LIVE (On the Night, 1993) HD". It's one of my favourite performances. Dire Straits are almost always better live than in the studio, but this Brothers In Arms video is one of those exceptions, at least as your first listen!
I’m the same age as Mark (74) back in the day I saw them live in London, Manchester and Glasgow. They are my favourite band of all time. ❤❤❤❤❤. Try “Telegraph Road” or “Tunnel of Love “
A sad soft song with an incredible strong and powerful message. It's a work of pure genius from Mark Knopfler and Dire Straits, one of their very finest. 🙋♂
One of the best anti-war songs ever written. This video captures the whole ethos and angst of dying away from your home and family. The videos won some well-deserved prestigious awards.
Fine reaction! 👍 Such a great song, this one, with such an important message! You ask which song should you react to, now?... Well, if this song is a sad one, what do you think of reacting to a joyful one? And I got 2 options for you - in both cases, I suggest the official music video - , "Twisted by the pool" and "Walk of life".
There tunes and songs to fire 'a man up' to send him into battle and there are songs to die to. This song tells the story of a man how's fatally wounded on the battle field, that is about to die.
Hi great reaction and channel. I absolutely recommend Brothers In Arms Live Dire Straits " On The Night"1993. Every reactor I've seen stated this performance really had an impact on them. Also from the same concert I think you'll really love Calling Elvis and Private Investigations. All the best, Cheers from Australia 👍🎸🎸🎸
I play this every Nov 11 at 11am in honor of my Great Grandfather John Henry Timms Leicestershire Regiment 6th BN. KIA July 16, 1916 The Somme France he has no know grave so his name will live forevermore as his is on the Thiepval Memorial.
The guitar parts are intended to sound like a helicopter that’s arriving to lift the wounded soldier away from the battlefield, yet his comrades are left yelling up to him, “We will remember you, brother!”
Telegraph road would be my next pick. It tells the story of the Road in Detroit with the same name from its first creation through all the times that have followed. Both live and studio have their strengths.
Beautifully done, most of us came back but some of us never really came home. Tom Boyte GySgt. U.S. Marine Corps, retired Vietnam 1965-66/1970-71 Infantry, Machine guns
One of the bands greatest song. So much emotion in the guitarplaying by Mark Knopfler. His style is still very unique. Listen to this version of him: Mark Knopfler - Why Worry (An Evening With Mark Knopfler, 2009)
The opening line for me is the kicker.... "These mist covered mountains are a home now for me" That is the thought of a dying soldier who realises he is going to spend the rest of their short lives on the battlefield.. The soldier although mortally wounded is thanking his brothers in arms for not deserting him and reassuring them that they will be home soon. Heart wrenching.
As a vet this song means the world to me as it do to many others. It's commonly used at vets funerals. Tx reacting.
Fools to make War, With our Brothers in Arms. Ours in not to reason why, But to do and Die.
This song has made me teary eyed ever since it first came out, and still does.
This man makes the guitar CRY !!!!
More than the guitar are crying, my friend.
Even the angels cry, my friend!
This song never ceases to give me chills ever since it was released. Not only for its sheer brilliance but one of my cousins was a survivor of one of the British ships that was sunk in the Falklands war. Although the song captures the feeling of another aspect of the war it still touches me deeply!
Most guitarist can make a guitar sing, but Mark Knofler is the only one that can make a guitar cry.
Did you hear of a guy named David Gilmour?
Or Eric??
This is what it says under the word 'Masterpiece' in the dictionary. Lol. It's seriously on another level. Once again Knopfler and band created a classic that will stand the test of time. Remarkable. Lovely reaction 😊
Mark Knopfler's guitar playing always gets me. So happy that I got to see him live 19 years ago
Saw dire sraits 92 Gateshead Stadium UK brilliant.
I have heard this song hundreds of times and each time I have to prepare myself emotionally to listen to it but it is so good that I must go through tough emotions each listen ... great music and a healthy cleansing.
It always inspires me to count my blessings and remember how lucky I am to live in peace
Dire Straits was my best friend's favorite non Metal band; he was Navajo, and he drank his very last room temp can of Budweiser years ago, and this song especially keeps him with us, so thank you.
Very nice reaction. This is really a masterpiece. The whole album is great. I recommend songs "Money for nothing" or "Romeo and Juliet" to you.
This song seems to resonate with every veteran. We, ex British Army and damn proud, know what happens and what we can expect in combat/war, but we still go. Civvies will never understand and I'm happy for them.
For me, no-one creates emotion with the guitar like Mark. You should try "Telegraph Road" from the Alchemy Live gig - amazing!
That last "conversation" between the guitar full of sorrow and the warmth of the keyboard is absolutely beautiful.
The Band, Dire Straits & of course, Mark Knofler himself are British. This song was written as a tribute to the British Soldiers involved in the Falkland Islands Conflict between Britain & Argentina in 1982.
Lost a mate in the Galahad - song still reminds me of him. he was 19 and I'm still here in my 60's.
Incredible guitar touch. I remember when this CD was released, one of the first digitally recorded albums.The quality at the time was 2nd to none
I have lost many friends and i will always love this song im crying
Telegraph Road (Alchemy live) last song at this concert. Keyboard player, drummer and of course Mark Knofler on guitar are outstanding on this version
I agree completely. Telegraph Road is extremely good, especially that live version.
👍
💯🤘
💯
one of my favorites also
One of the true classics. The album is one of the first CDs I ever bought. Still love it.
The only thing in this song that really touches me deeply every time is the wonderful voice of the Gibson Les Paul. Simply masterfully played by Mark Knopfler.
One of the best that reminds me of my late DAD!! He LOVED this song.....
fukk now i cry......
Bless your dad 🙏😅
Beautiful typical from Mark , best moment for me listening to this on old record player with huge brown speakers
Chills and tears.
It is to bring attention to the irony of it all. Rushing, as you say, towards the weapons while simultaneously singing, "We are fools to make war on our brothers in arms." The men fighting the battles have no grievance with one another. They are killing each other over some remote leader's beef. Why in the world would we agree to that?
Tracks like Sultans of Swing and Telegraph Road translate brilliantly to live performances, but Brothers in Arms and Private Investigations are so precisely arranged with so many different nuances, that the studio version is far and away the best way to hear them.
Especially "Private Investigations". The sound engineering is *insane*. Almost a musical sculpture.
I'd go part way with that. With the proviso that the 'studio version' is the one off the Brothers in Arms album, which is identical with this video but has two minutes extra on the end that (for some reason) they cut out of the video.
Sultans of Swing and Tunnel of Love are, in my opinion, better in the live performances. In the case of Brothers in Arms, I agree the studio version is more precisely arranged. The live versions bring their own atmosphere to the song. So I'd rate them 'equal, but different'.
(I actually have six different versions of this song on my MP3 player, and I can listen to all six in a row - they're sufficiently different that they don't get monotonous).
I agree with that comment 100%.
One of the most powerful and emotional guitar licks of all-time! Kills me every time I listen to it!
Saying goodbye to fellow soldier who is dying for nothing. Proxy this and that.
In a decade full of iconic music, this is one of the best! ✌️ Peace✌️
Agreed!
I'm always grateful for the things i have in my life without those poor men who fought and died for all of us. we wouldn't be here. It tears me up every time.
Mark Knopfler is a music god!! All his songs are tear jerkers without even trying!
Great reaction. The live version from the Nelson Mandela Tribute Concert is recognised by fans as the best and certainly the most iconic version of this song.
Thank you so much for your comment and the mention of the Nelson Mandela Tribute Concert 😊
That's the best I've heard among many greats.@@InnaSoloMusic
@@InnaSoloMusicI read that their performance of this at the Nelson Mandela concert was so popular in South Africa that the “powers that be” asked who should get the royalties. When they replied “Amnesty International” the band was prohibited from performing in that country. South Africa’s problem with racial discrimination has improved somewhat since. Luv ya.😊
Some guitar masters have the ability to reach into .and pluck the strings of ones SOUL
The final guitar solos in the live versions of this song are epic. You should try them.
Thank you for a great reaction!! This is a masterpiece and it sounds like the guitar is crying 😪
The best version is the performance at Wembley for Nelson Mandela's celebration. Wonderful.
I could not agree with you more.
One of the best (war) songs ever written and performed.
There is a live version that is outstanding. Longer instrumental solos and the best organ solo I’ve ever heard. Also Telegraph Road live is another outstanding performance!
Mark Knopfler released a live version from Berlin in 2007 to commemorate the 25th anniversary of the Falklands war. I believe all the proceeds went to Veteran's causes. It's worth a listen along with Mandela's 70th birthday version with Eric Clapton on rythym guitar.
Don't forget the band of the Royal Marines doing this song, especially poignant as the RM were fighting in the Falklands war...
Imagine having Eric on rhythm guitar
The best version of this song is the live version at Nelson Mandella's birthday party (1988). The guitar solo at the end last several miuntes.
I love your heartfelt reactions. This is such a great song, guitar and vocals as one.
Live version from the Nelson Mandella birhday party concert. Is simply stunning.
Excellent! I never noticed that Knopfler's gun becomes a guitar. Brilliant.
I seen this song Live on U Tube it was longer. He has one of a kind voice.
Great choice.
One of their best.
'Romeo And Juliet' from the Alchemy Live performance is epic.
A song written about the Falklands war and a British soldier called Lieutenant Lawrence who was shot and lost 42% of his brain on Mount Tumbledown by an Argentinian sniper as the Argentinians retreated, however its also about the futility of all wars and we are all brothers in arms doing things we dont really want to do but feel we have to as a good citizen to our country but has little rhyme or reason...😢
Romeo and juliet by them is a great song
If that is about bloke I saw in the documentary recently wish him well and a happy christmas
The song is about Malvinas, right?
@@teushenoconi4976would be if you fought harder 🇬🇧
@@necessaryevil3428 Did you mean if you steal territories?
Great job on this. Been listening to this song and album since 1985. The album was #1 for a while
Beautiful, just beautiful
I am 46 years old. I have been listening to this album since the day it came out because of my mom and this song just moves me in ways that nothing else can. Oh and she's the "man too strong" in my life.
Probably the best song in music history
The lyrics are simply stunning along with stunning guitar and vocals
The guitar on its own tells the story
Telegraph Road...live at the Alchemy concert. A true masterpiece.
glad you understood this beautiful sad song, great reaction
I don’t think you’ve done it yet, tell me if I’m wrong, but one of their songs you must check out is Walk of Life. It’s fantastic and catchy.
and how can you not cry at such beauty ???
È sublime..tra i primi dieci brani di tutti i tempi...poesia in musica
For an epic and beautiful performance of them live, check out "Dire Straits - Private Investigations LIVE (On the Night, 1993) HD". It's one of my favourite performances. Dire Straits are almost always better live than in the studio, but this Brothers In Arms video is one of those exceptions, at least as your first listen!
As a Dire Straits fan I highly recommend a reaction to the live version of Telegraph Road from the Alchemy Tour. Absolutely brilliant
Such tasteful and understated guitar work ❤
I’m the same age as Mark (74) back in the day I saw them live in London, Manchester and Glasgow. They are my favourite band of all time. ❤❤❤❤❤. Try “Telegraph Road” or “Tunnel of Love “
England is my home. Many have fought to save it. A pretty gentle kind landscape.
Dire Straits, U2 & Led zeppelin❤🔥
Beautiful
Agreed,!!
Definitely this and the live versions of the epic song ❤
A sad soft song with an incredible strong and powerful message. It's a work of pure genius from Mark Knopfler and Dire Straits, one of their very finest. 🙋♂
perfect combination between song and video. ❤
One of the best anti-war songs ever written. This video captures the whole ethos and angst of dying away from your home and family. The videos won some well-deserved prestigious awards.
Fine reaction! 👍 Such a great song, this one, with such an important message! You ask which song should you react to, now?... Well, if this song is a sad one, what do you think of reacting to a joyful one? And I got 2 options for you - in both cases, I suggest the official music video - , "Twisted by the pool" and "Walk of life".
Tunnel of love, télégraphe road etc. Y'a du lourd encore chez dire Strait
There tunes and songs to fire 'a man up' to send him into battle and there are songs to die to. This song tells the story of a man how's fatally wounded on the battle field, that is about to die.
This song is sung from the point of view of a dying soldier saying goodbye to his brothers in arms.
Super powerful lyrics, but the music has already broken your heart before they even start!
So many different worlds, so many different suns, but we have just one world but we live in different ones!
The live version (On the Night 1993) is fabulous‼ 🎸
Beautiful song
Walk of life next. You will love it
We should not change the world with weapons, but with music!
-We can see a classic scene with this song, on the TV show "Miami Vice" in the 1980's, (in last scene of the episode: 'Out Where the Buses Don't Run')
All you'll ever need in life is Mark knopfler on the 58 👌🏼
Listen to this band in concert recording. You can't regret it. he is a guitar master. He becomes free at the concert...
No combat veteran will ever glorify war. If you know, you know.
Proper quality
One of my favourite of theirs. Two best bands for me, Pink Floyd and Dire Straights....
Cute by the way.
Song is so sad and you are so sweet and kind
Hi great reaction and channel. I absolutely recommend Brothers In Arms Live Dire Straits " On The Night"1993. Every reactor I've seen stated this performance really had an impact on them. Also from the same concert I think you'll really love Calling Elvis and Private Investigations. All the best, Cheers from Australia 👍🎸🎸🎸
The Live version on "On the night" is a treat.
Another great song in the theme of war is "roads to Moscow" by Al Stewart a very powerful song.
Hauntingly Beautiful... Thanks Inna for sharing your reaction. "HEAVY FUEL" (On The Night, 1993) and "MONEY FOR NOTHING" (Live Aid 1985 with Sting)
Thank you so much for the comment and the suggestions 😊
I play this every Nov 11 at 11am in honor of my Great Grandfather John Henry Timms Leicestershire Regiment 6th BN. KIA July 16, 1916 The Somme France he has no know grave so his name will live forevermore as his is on the Thiepval Memorial.
The guitar parts are intended to sound like a helicopter that’s arriving to lift the wounded soldier away from the battlefield, yet his comrades are left yelling up to him, “We will remember you, brother!”
Telegraph road would be my next pick. It tells the story of the Road in Detroit with the same name from its first creation through all the times that have followed. Both live and studio have their strengths.
Their lighter side - "Skateaway"
If you are curious, Metallica have done an acoustic version of this song.
Next steps: Tunnel of Love ( Alchemy version ), Telegraph Road ( Alchemy version ), Romeo and Juliet
Twisting by the pool will be a completely different side of Dire Straits for you.
Beautifully done, most of us came back but some of us never really came home.
Tom Boyte
GySgt. U.S. Marine Corps, retired
Vietnam 1965-66/1970-71
Infantry, Machine guns
Live version brothers in arms... Nelson Mandela 70th birthday
Live version: on the night tour 1993... ua-cam.com/video/q2rx3IAEISA/v-deo.html
Private Investigations is an excellent choice.
Being Ukrainian, this must have hit home, Slava Ukraini.
One of the bands greatest song. So much emotion in the guitarplaying by Mark Knopfler. His style is still very unique. Listen to this version of him: Mark Knopfler - Why Worry (An Evening With Mark Knopfler, 2009)