MUSIC DIRECTOR REACTS | Danny Carey | "Pneuma" by Tool (LIVE IN CONCERT)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 270

  • @DrumRollTonyReacts
    @DrumRollTonyReacts  2 роки тому +16

    ⏩ Video Question: What is your favorite Tool song??
    For live content catch me on Twitch. www.twitch.tv/drumrolltony

    • @Ogt92
      @Ogt92 Рік тому +4

      Tempest!

    • @theking0fstupid
      @theking0fstupid Рік тому +4

      Pushit for sure

    • @miguelgama3164
      @miguelgama3164 Рік тому +1

      eve- tokyo ghetto pls

    • @Momesmor
      @Momesmor Рік тому +3

      Forty Six & 2

    • @DillaryHuff
      @DillaryHuff Рік тому +1

      If you're interested in watching more, talented drummers, I'd recommend reacting to one of Baard Kolstad's drum cam videos. Dynamics is his specialty :)

  • @johnnyb6067
    @johnnyb6067 Рік тому +271

    This was my wife’s first Tool show. She’s not a huge fan so I told her to pay attention to Danny. She was blown away and came away with a new appreciation for what 4 guys with instruments can do on a stage.

    • @DrumRollTonyReacts
      @DrumRollTonyReacts  Рік тому +17

      That's awesome

    • @benbode906
      @benbode906 Рік тому +12

      I see what you did there and your right all 4 play instruments cause Maynard’s voice is definitely an instrument 🤘. Good call

    • @leecarmichael5449
      @leecarmichael5449 Рік тому +4

      I agree...Maynard has his vocals recorded lower so it won't over power the music. He let's them do there thing and just adds to it. He is def an instrument

    • @osimo600rr
      @osimo600rr Рік тому +5

      There's passive listening and active listening. I've played music all throughout my house for years and my gf always tells me to change it when "hard rock" 🙄 comes on my playlist. Took her to a tool show and in the middle of EVERY song she'd turn to me and shout "OMG THESE GUYS ARE SO GOOD!" With an unspoken tone of, "like why haven't you plaid them at home before". 🤦🏼‍♂️

    • @DrumRollTonyReacts
      @DrumRollTonyReacts  Рік тому +2

      @@osimo600rr lol that's funny

  • @TihomirKit
    @TihomirKit Рік тому +34

    Danny Carey is the only drummer that makes you want to play drums, but whenever you see him play drums it makes you want to quit.

  • @cloud9847
    @cloud9847 Рік тому +93

    They are all incredibly special in their own way but Danny, to me, is absolutely mind blowing. I do not understand how a human mind can do what he's doing.

    • @joelbuff3254
      @joelbuff3254 Рік тому +8

      There are a few that can play it, but he wrote it. Amazing the way his mind puts drums to music.

    • @Dunkelelf3
      @Dunkelelf3 Рік тому +2

      well. years and years of training. we all have the potential for great things but it takes dedication and time. on a pro level these people spend 8 hours+ a day on practice. do this for a few decades and you get someone like danny who at age 60 seems like at the peak of his profession. he's as great as ever and no sign of loosing his abilities. i mean look at him. he's friggin buff. and the polyrhythmic stuff... it just shows we he rightfully earned the nickname octopus.

    • @3rdIOpnd
      @3rdIOpnd Рік тому +3

      He is a freaking Octopus.

    • @judyannlance5368
      @judyannlance5368 Рік тому

      Agreed!! He's in a league of his own!! Absolute best!!

  • @eillich
    @eillich Рік тому +22

    I remember that I few months I searched "DrumRollTony Pneuma" just to be disappointed for not finding it.
    This does put a smile on my face.

  • @chrispadovanibs8648
    @chrispadovanibs8648 Рік тому +5

    probably the best reaction i've seen to this drum cam. finally, someone who can add to my appreciation of danny's drumming.

  • @joelspaulding5964
    @joelspaulding5964 Рік тому +69

    Have watched every, yes, every reaction to this song from curious folk to "drum teacher".
    This was by FAR the best analysis.
    You noticed all the nuances and appreciated them, as appropriate.
    Sub'd

    • @DrumRollTonyReacts
      @DrumRollTonyReacts  Рік тому +4

      Thank you much

    • @beussta
      @beussta Рік тому

      @@DrumRollTonyReacts im surprised u're not noticed the hesitation and mistake on his left hand on 13:15
      so far only 1 react guy i saw (among a lot) noticed this mistake

    • @DrumRollTonyReacts
      @DrumRollTonyReacts  Рік тому +1

      @@beussta ok

    • @bhelliom3
      @bhelliom3 Рік тому

      The Daily Doug is my fav reaction to this song, and many others, his enthusiasm and insight is unmatched.

    • @heididenson6643
      @heididenson6643 6 місяців тому

      Same

  • @blaydenw-hz1sr
    @blaydenw-hz1sr Рік тому +3

    "and we've returned" that's the perfect explanation for this song! It's like going on a journey.

  • @russellsearch7925
    @russellsearch7925 Рік тому +15

    I’ve seen this like a hundred times but it still astonishes me. Insane.

    • @judyannlance5368
      @judyannlance5368 Рік тому

      Same!! 🖤🤘

    • @justinrogers68
      @justinrogers68 4 дні тому

      Watch this video probably twice a year but I have it on loop for about 2 hours

  • @phildigiovanni9687
    @phildigiovanni9687 Рік тому +10

    Danny Carey = The G.O.A.T.

  • @thegoonbats
    @thegoonbats Рік тому +7

    You gave us by far the best breakdown of this video, and of Danny in general. I can't recall a single video of anyone picking up on half of what you did.
    Thank you for such an enjoyable analysis! 🤘

  • @kimkillackey4384
    @kimkillackey4384 Рік тому +4

    So much talent. I'm not a musician. I can appreciate this so much. Makes me happy

  • @martymcpeak4748
    @martymcpeak4748 Рік тому +9

    I'm a guitarist but I sat here with my jaw hanging open in amazement, Jeez, Danny Carey is a drum stick slinging badass. Great reaction Sir. Subscribed

    • @POWER-LINKS
      @POWER-LINKS Рік тому

      【Audrey Shida-Guitar】 One camera. No trick edits. Full song.
      Tool / "Sober" ua-cam.com/video/tD0NQ8nCE-Y/v-deo.html

  • @ag3nt_green
    @ag3nt_green 9 місяців тому +1

    I appreciate people like Danny. They spend the time, energy and effort to show you what people are capable of. One of my favortie pastimes is just watching masters of something perform their craft.

  • @VerchielxKanda
    @VerchielxKanda Рік тому +1

    My favorite Tool song is Parabol+Parabola. When Maynard screams "ALIVE" in the song, the volume is at max. XD

  • @NotQuiteAsianOG
    @NotQuiteAsianOG Рік тому +1

    I'm a simple man, see the Danny Carey Drum cam of "Pneuma" being reacted to, I watch, I like, I leave comment, and I subscribe.

  • @DerekCarrMusicPhotographer
    @DerekCarrMusicPhotographer Рік тому +7

    Such a controlled and consistent drummer.

  • @kellyroach76
    @kellyroach76 Рік тому +1

    Probably the best take I’ve seen of Danny’s playing on this track! Thanks Tony! Loved it.

  • @theeviljames
    @theeviljames Рік тому

    I'm not a drummer, but totally feel you on the melodic groove of this performance; so much texture

  • @logannewman4532
    @logannewman4532 2 роки тому +2

    Excited for this one for sure. Been a fan for 30 years.

  • @kylekearney1590
    @kylekearney1590 Рік тому

    The first honest professional reaction!!!

  • @sindysinn69
    @sindysinn69 Рік тому +35

    And a little known fact, that Danny Carey as well as being an incredible drummer, is also a professional basketball for the Boston Celtics. Incredible how he finds the time.

    • @18hot30
      @18hot30 Рік тому +12

      it's more impressive that he can trn into a basketball

    • @johnjohn37371
      @johnjohn37371 Рік тому

      @@18hot30 professional basketball...not some ridiculous rec league shit....

    • @bonbonbillyboo2649
      @bonbonbillyboo2649 Рік тому +14

      I bet he dribbles in 11/8 timing

    • @dankieran1974
      @dankieran1974 Рік тому +2

      All while being an octopus.* Amazing talent
      *there are no rules against an octopus playing basketball.

    • @bazmassey
      @bazmassey Рік тому +5

      Danny carey doesnt find the time, the time finds danny carey

  • @lrwiersum
    @lrwiersum Рік тому

    Danny brings the thunder and I just love it !

  • @kh602black
    @kh602black Рік тому

    This is in my top 5 UA-cam videos. I'm glad you reacted to this.

  • @seanwhitley4705
    @seanwhitley4705 Рік тому

    ..best pneuma reaction ever, and i’ve watched a dozen. been waiting for the technical analysis. nice work, man..

  • @hvitekristesdod
    @hvitekristesdod Рік тому +5

    Fave Tool song is Reflection, even without it’s related songs Disposition and Triad, an absolute masterpiece on every level.

  • @mikegoldstein1246
    @mikegoldstein1246 Рік тому

    What a fantastic review. I love listening to people who knows what their talking about review this. You did such a great job with your knowledge and you can identify a true percussion genius like Danny

  • @heididenson6643
    @heididenson6643 6 місяців тому

    Danny is my favorite drummer of all time. He makes drumming look effortless which I know is not! I’m not even remotely coordinated enough for drumming. But I love watching!

  • @williamwinner4234
    @williamwinner4234 Рік тому

    Everything I watch that video I'm amazed at how well mic'd and mixed it is for a live show. It sounds amazing!

  • @bobr1767
    @bobr1767 Рік тому +1

    Proof aliens live among us. The man is not human.

  • @paultullo3275
    @paultullo3275 Рік тому

    You’re the first drummer reactor that’s I’ve seen notice the FLAWLESS transition from doubles to singles in the intro! 😍

  • @kylekearney1590
    @kylekearney1590 Рік тому

    So much respect to you. The only honest reaction I’ve seen

  • @ASXCyphin
    @ASXCyphin Рік тому

    I love reactions from people who actually speak music react to tool.
    Good stuff.

  • @chriswebb7822
    @chriswebb7822 Рік тому +2

    Let us not forget Danny was 59 years old at the time of this filming!

  • @edwardmunoz7853
    @edwardmunoz7853 Рік тому +1

    One of the best songs ever lyrically and musically 💯🔥🤘. The whole world should be listening to Tool

  • @joeyisho5370
    @joeyisho5370 Рік тому

    I loved your reaction man, I'm not a drummer but it's always so great to see someone knowledgeable of the art watching a marvel in motion as Danny is :)

  • @Beaufortlawrence
    @Beaufortlawrence Рік тому +8

    Great video and reaction. It’s like a better written heavier doors song with good musicians 😂
    Danny is a monster, mesmerizing was a perfect description.

  • @tylerclark1801
    @tylerclark1801 Рік тому

    AND HE'S 61 YEARS OLD!!!!!!! What a BEAST!

  • @Stephen_Burton
    @Stephen_Burton 11 місяців тому

    His accenting Manyards vocals with the hiHat , snare and later in the song with his cymbals!! iSo sick! What a drummer!

    • @Josh-n8u
      @Josh-n8u 5 днів тому

      The music is written first. Maynard is accenting Danny's high hat. Your welcome.:)

  • @jamescaicedo5194
    @jamescaicedo5194 Рік тому

    Best reaction I have seen to the video and I have seen tons

  • @nates8548
    @nates8548 Рік тому

    Danny... The Beast... The GOAT!
    So glad you got to this one! 💪

  • @JohnSmith-me4ik
    @JohnSmith-me4ik Рік тому +1

    Danny Carey is a beast! Nice vid. Favorite Tool song has to be Vicarious for me.

  • @logannewman4532
    @logannewman4532 Рік тому

    It looked like you looked away when Danny got that big goofy grin on his face. It's one of my favorite things about this videos.

  • @derekheiser912
    @derekheiser912 Рік тому

    been waiting for this one

  • @RoloDacat
    @RoloDacat Рік тому

    Far and away the best reaction by someone who knows drums.

  • @OneM4n246
    @OneM4n246 Рік тому +1

    What a masterpiece!

  • @tomkenney5365
    @tomkenney5365 Рік тому

    Great analysis. Most reactions are just that: "wow! How does he do that?" You understand it and can talk about it.

  • @EiriUesugiKun
    @EiriUesugiKun Рік тому

    0:30 - Those are Mandala drums, and here's a snippet of their properties: "Because a Mandala surface is divided into 128 position rings and can detect 127 strike velocities (greater than 0) it can produce up to 16,256 (128 x 127) individual triggers."
    They are crazy. :D

  • @johnbajada8338
    @johnbajada8338 10 днів тому

    Someone asked me once, how do you listen to tool, there is so much to take in at once, my reply was, listen to each song 4 times and focus on one instrument at a time, then it all comes together

  • @davemieze9021
    @davemieze9021 Місяць тому

    Pure magic

  • @spiderbass65
    @spiderbass65 Рік тому

    I was at this show in Boston. I love that he’s wearing Bird’s 33 shirt, and I believe the time signature here is 33/4.

    • @DrumRollTonyReacts
      @DrumRollTonyReacts  Рік тому

      The time signature would flow in a grouping sense more focused on the 8th note instead of the qtr. Most likely split splitting up what is divisional by 2 and then odd parts separately. Meaning, we wouldn't count to 33. We feel the patterns 3,3,2 for 7/8 3,2 for 5/8 etc and so on following how the grouping goes. Amazing song and such a cool use of structure

    • @spiderbass65
      @spiderbass65 Рік тому

      @@DrumRollTonyReacts I know most of this, I’m a hack musician. It still comes out to 33. In my limited musical training I’ve learned you can count however you like. I love your reactions and your musical knowledge!

  • @xciteful
    @xciteful Рік тому

    Fucking perfection.

  • @atraxisdarkstar
    @atraxisdarkstar Рік тому +2

    My favorite song is probably this one (Pneuma).
    They were supposed to come to Vancouver in 2020, but they had to cancel. I've still never gotten to see them live.
    Although the other concert I was supposed to see in 2020 was Roger Waters, and that got rescheduled for last year. So, I at least got to see one of my heroes!

  • @zeppelinmexicano
    @zeppelinmexicano Рік тому

    Danny Legend's number 33 is hanging in the rafters of The Garden as we speak.

  • @Boomersh0t
    @Boomersh0t Рік тому +26

    Favourite Tool song would have to be Lateralus. Just an all round performance from every member of the band. A masterclass in build up and payoff for a prog rock song. Yeah Maynard may think it's trivial, and people may meme on the composition. But I will always appreciate it for how thoughtful everything was put together in this track - and the whole album really.

    • @PerishingPurplePulsar
      @PerishingPurplePulsar Рік тому

      Mostly agreed, only difference is my fav Tool song is Intention hands down. It just has such a vibe to it, and the way it transitions into Right in Two, another fav of mine, just perfect IMO

    • @ngcastronerd4791
      @ngcastronerd4791 Рік тому +1

      @@PerishingPurplePulsar I won't claim to have a favorite, it depends how I feel. However I do feel that Rosetta Stoned is often overlooked in their repertoire.

    • @PerishingPurplePulsar
      @PerishingPurplePulsar Рік тому

      @@ngcastronerd4791 I was literally playing my bass along to Rosetta Stoned earlier today! Haha

    • @ngcastronerd4791
      @ngcastronerd4791 Рік тому

      @@PerishingPurplePulsar im stll practising that polyrythmic pass from that song.

    • @PerishingPurplePulsar
      @PerishingPurplePulsar Рік тому

      @@ngcastronerd4791 Oh I can by no means actually play the bassline, I'm not that good, but I like to put on songs (Esp Tool) and just play by ear, impovise and have fun, it's a great time

  • @brandonbanks4394
    @brandonbanks4394 Рік тому +1

    People actually believe this is not real. I saw tool in concert in Augusta Georgia. And trust me when I say they sound exactly like this live. The concrete was vibrating.

  • @sousouluteru9223
    @sousouluteru9223 Рік тому +1

    Mr. Drumroll THAT! was a masterclass reaction 🤔🥰👍. Your expert explanations and technical jibber jabber was excellent 🙏 . You got my subscription brother, much Aloha from Hawai’i 🇼🇸🎆🎊🥳.

  • @nathancilley153
    @nathancilley153 7 місяців тому

    Simply, the best.

  • @ballerdonk
    @ballerdonk Рік тому

    A classic video, awesome!

  • @bryanthomas8478
    @bryanthomas8478 Рік тому

    Little known fact , Danny is actually a Octopus trapped in a mans body .

  • @mathewnavarro1152
    @mathewnavarro1152 Рік тому +1

    I can just imagine the kind of insurance policy on this man's arm's or his hands alone. Absolutely crazy.... 😳

  • @Dream25_
    @Dream25_ Рік тому

    I could be wrong, but my read on the setup for his ride cymbal is maintaining stick angle. If you notice the cymbals he wants to hit the edge of are mounted standard, but cymbals he wants to hit the face of are angled. In my opinion this gives him the option to get really quick transitions from hitting the face of the ride to the edges of the crashes around it because he doesn't have to move his wrist at all.

  • @derelecious
    @derelecious Рік тому

    I enjoyed that!

  • @joshpatrick3663
    @joshpatrick3663 Рік тому

    Danny is 58 years old at this point!! Wild

  • @alphadrift82
    @alphadrift82 Рік тому +3

    The crazy part is trying to convince people that he only has 2 arms

  • @kylekearney1590
    @kylekearney1590 Рік тому

    Thank you 🙏 🙏

  • @adrianonhilton
    @adrianonhilton Місяць тому

    True fact. Danny had to create a couple of extra dimensions to make the time signatures work.

  • @christopherhuot2826
    @christopherhuot2826 2 місяці тому

    Danny is just sick😅😊

  • @holgercarow522
    @holgercarow522 Рік тому

    Masterclass!

  • @rodrigoaltejandroampuerooy6191

    Solo un genio puede tener esa cordinación

  • @arminthielen8570
    @arminthielen8570 Рік тому

    That took while 😂😂 This is really inevitable for anyone interested in Drum Play. Danny is a Monster ! Confessing Tool Fan ... might be obvious watching my Tattoos 😂

  • @rcshad2
    @rcshad2 Рік тому

    'the band sounds good by the way' the fans will be stoked... nice work.

  • @woundsofthecrisis
    @woundsofthecrisis Рік тому

    subbed.....Danny is legendary

  • @jaydeewynne
    @jaydeewynne 7 місяців тому

    Gotta love the Mandela drum pads custom built by DC with Mandela

  • @AKJACKAL99709
    @AKJACKAL99709 Рік тому

    Now that we are losing so many of the old school great drummers especially progressive ones like Peart and Moon, I see myself on the lookout for the next guys up. There are a lot of great drummers out there on UA-cam and on tour, but that next level guy is still rare.
    Two at the top of my list are Danny (Tool, obviously), and Vlad with Jinjer. They've continued to show me more and more how precise they are and how effortless they handle odd meters. Danny is like an octopus with his limb independence, and Vlad has so much precision, speed, and groove. That also both have interesting setups that could teach us all a little about ergonomics.

  • @ManlyManston
    @ManlyManston Рік тому +2

    You should take a look at the soundtrack for an anime named "Katanagatari", the whole soundtrack is worth a listen but the theme "Bahasa Palsu" especially seems like something you'd enjoy reacting to. It's composed by Iwasaki Tawu, same person who composed the soundtracks for Gurren Lagann, Soul Eater and JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Battle Tendency.
    It also features vocals/rap by Lotus Juice which also featured predominantly in the Persona 3 soundtrack and in Battle Tendency's soundtrack as well.
    Some other tracks that stand out are Bahasu Palsu Jazz 'n Mix(Remix of the first theme), 月刀歌 (Gettouka) and Hanetsuki Imouto

  • @matiasacevedob
    @matiasacevedob 5 місяців тому

    NICE REVIEW!

  • @atalossrecords52
    @atalossrecords52 Рік тому +1

    you should react to vildhjarta! any song from their new album

  • @garse70
    @garse70 Рік тому

    Danny actually accents Maynard’s Cadence during the verse. Kieth Moon used to play off the vocals at times too. It’s unique and difficult.

  • @jasonnijhuis5268
    @jasonnijhuis5268 Рік тому

    he's got the Neil Peart ride pattern working

  • @darcybreitkreuz8667
    @darcybreitkreuz8667 Рік тому

    As a drummer of sorts, I must say that incredible **pop** on that snare makes me cough in my shorts.

  • @Bobbias
    @Bobbias Рік тому

    Oh hell yeah!

  • @ronaldviens7862
    @ronaldviens7862 Рік тому

    Next time you watch this video, Tony, watch the hi hat during the bridge.

  • @drunkenmettalist5158
    @drunkenmettalist5158 Рік тому

    look at dannys drum clinic of rosettas stoned.. its just incredible dude
    pleaaaaaaaseeeeeee

  • @POWER-LINKS
    @POWER-LINKS Рік тому

    【Audrey Shida-Guitar】 One camera. No trick edits. Full song.
    Tool / "Sober" ua-cam.com/video/tD0NQ8nCE-Y/v-deo.html

  • @Pigollah
    @Pigollah Рік тому

    I've seen a lot of reactions and I'm surprised no one noticed that the cymbals were playing to the vocals

  • @HotSkorpion
    @HotSkorpion Рік тому

    shame this is pretty much the only good Danny cam out there. Would love something like this on The Grudge

  • @victormagana7940
    @victormagana7940 5 днів тому

    12:30 his moves look like right here like the music is controlling his limbs

  • @frontsidegrinder6858
    @frontsidegrinder6858 Рік тому

    I'd like to see Thomas Lang covering this on Dannys original drumset, i'm sure he could do it worthy. That would be so cool to watch.

  • @Brogox
    @Brogox Рік тому +1

    Felt like nice storytelling with drums.

  • @samuelyepes203
    @samuelyepes203 Рік тому

    I still think that you should react to Leprous, especially to "The Sky is Red" drum playthrough or the live version of "Slave". You will love Baard Kolstad, i garantee you that

  • @TheRedStateBlue
    @TheRedStateBlue Рік тому

    "the rim is beefy!"
    Danny Carey's snare drum is custom cast bronze and weighs about 40 lbs.

  • @Batuul_
    @Batuul_ 6 місяців тому

    When you take into consideration the age and AWESOME stamina Danny has.... this is textbook stuff for the younger generations...

  • @kylekearney1590
    @kylekearney1590 Рік тому

    ❤❤❤❤

  • @justinatest9456
    @justinatest9456 Рік тому +3

    As a non-drummer this has always stood out to me as a masterclass in drumming - the timing, technique, and power, and most importantly the tastefulness of it all. I'm usually unimpressed by fancy tippy-tappy drumming, favouring instead power and conviction, but this is a huge exception. I'm also not a fan of Tool, but this whole song, including the lyrics, is amazing.

  • @danielmayer6956
    @danielmayer6956 2 місяці тому

    I always think that half the time Danny is swordfighting his setup

  • @Kibashino2
    @Kibashino2 Рік тому

    LESSS GOOO

  • @lucasrolland299
    @lucasrolland299 Рік тому +1

    hey Tony ! little request for you : Could you check and analyse the song "Drowned In Emotion" by the group Casckets ? In terms of rythmical and melodical variations, I think this is a pretty well structured song ! In my humble opinion, this group should be more known than that after three or four years on the road, their stuff is really good ! I love your content, keep it up man !

  • @Labs23
    @Labs23 Рік тому

    i really like this kind of intro dude. thank you so much for just getting to it and being a good watch still instead if fluffing the first minute or so with nonsense! earned a subscriber here man

    • @DrumRollTonyReacts
      @DrumRollTonyReacts  Рік тому +2

      That is funny because this is the first video that I took my intro out, haha. There is a lot we want to tell the audience but about 50% skip it anyhow.
      It might feel like nonsense to you but as a UA-camr I promise its not. Hard ground to move back and forth on, but glad you liked the video

    • @Labs23
      @Labs23 Рік тому

      I understand and respect it. I sit through it regardless but I had to get it out there! Love your videos man thanks for uploading

  • @ted1976hailspiralout
    @ted1976hailspiralout Рік тому

    🤘🏻🌀