Winchester Ranger T Series: .40 Smith and Wesson

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 жов 2024
  • Paul tests Winchester Ranger T ammo.
    Shirts and patches from Tristar Trading Co:
    Other platforms:
    Rumble: rumble.com/c/P...
    Odysee: odysee.com/@pa...
    Paul's Patreon: www.patreon.co...
    This video was edited and uploaded by:
    Brad Nelson - minutemantheory.com

КОМЕНТАРІ • 709

  • @joelg.7472
    @joelg.7472 Місяць тому +4

    RIP Paul. We you’ll be missed.

  • @-strick996
    @-strick996 6 років тому +178

    The reason I watch these videos is simple... Straightforward no bull crap, no Tacticool just straight simple and accurate information.. Keep On Keepin On... thank you sir.

    • @badlandskid
      @badlandskid 6 років тому +7

      The term "tactical" is to this decade what "ninja" was to the 80s and 90s.

    • @khaccanhle1930
      @khaccanhle1930 5 років тому +8

      I can't take Paul seriously. He doesn't strut around with a massive beard, 5/11 pants and a T-shirt 3 sizes too small. He doesn't swear every other word and sing the praises of 9mm Tupperware guns as the ONLY choice in every situation, so he's obviously not an "operator". So, Nah, I'll move onto taking more pictures of myself in Oakleys putting on my my best bad ass face.

    • @spookypunky
      @spookypunky 5 років тому +1

      @@khaccanhle1930 Lol!

    • @grey3977
      @grey3977 4 роки тому

      Khắc cảnh lê ... I was fortunate enough to be trained as what some would call a "swat officer " and served in that capacity for 14 years. In that time we were the test bed for weapons and equipment. Much of the equipment we tested proved to be effective. What stemmed from that IMHO was an over reliance on kit and what we called it in 2005 "CDI", chicks did it. And I believe it led to the tacticool opinions we have seen since.

    • @chrispena4582
      @chrispena4582 3 роки тому

      @@khaccanhle1930 😂😂🤣😅

  • @thickwristmcfist3399
    @thickwristmcfist3399 7 місяців тому +6

    Jesus.... Im gonna be finding and watching Paul's videos for years and years to come... God Bless You, Paul.... The world is lessened without you.

  • @jarheadgreasemonkey7673
    @jarheadgreasemonkey7673 6 років тому +236

    Rain, snow, tornadoes, darkness... nothing stops Paul Harrell on range day! Semper Fi!

    • @flippyjunior1267
      @flippyjunior1267 6 років тому +6

      Jarhead Greasemonkey so true

    • @GunSam
      @GunSam 6 років тому +17

      Paul usually summons weather changes on command just to make his videos more entertaining. If he didn't want the snow, it wouldn't be there!

    • @bowdenmertz2601
      @bowdenmertz2601 6 років тому +4

      Gun Sam _Revolver Aficionado_
      Gun Sam...I agree! 😂

    • @corwinhyatt519
      @corwinhyatt519 6 років тому +2

      It's a good practice to have. The experience in different weather conditions can be very valuable for when things go awry.

    • @bigmike9128
      @bigmike9128 6 років тому +2

      Post office of guns ?

  • @darthkek1953
    @darthkek1953 6 років тому +91

    I am heartbroken Paul didn't remind me what the meat target is.
    It's a pork chop pectoral, pork ribs, oranges for lung tissue, more pork ribs, plus four layers of tshirt front and back, and behind that the high tech fleece bullet stop. And the pig's ears? You be the judge.

    • @tweezak
      @tweezak 6 років тому +8

      Wait...what about the leather jacket "skin"

    • @lovelessissimo
      @lovelessissimo 5 років тому +5

      @@tweezak that's the hunting target. Duh. Haha

    • @BlahDBlahDBlah
      @BlahDBlahDBlah 4 роки тому +3

      But was it the *new and improved* high-tech fleece bullet stop? We shall never know...

    • @darthkek1953
      @darthkek1953 4 роки тому +2

      @@BlahDBlahDBlah I'll be the judge of that but not at home because I'm not what you call a professional.

    • @alfonsorj70
      @alfonsorj70 3 роки тому +1

      And theMargarine to simulate the body fat

  • @TheTimeshadows
    @TheTimeshadows 6 років тому +25

    Paul, thank you for continuing to produce .40 S&W videos; it is very much appreciated.

  • @skashed
    @skashed 6 років тому +87

    Grocery clerk: "Very nice ribs and chops you are getting there, having a barbecue this evening?"
    Paul: "No, no I am not"

    • @ushook
      @ushook 6 років тому +5

      LMFAOOO ...I really cracked up reading this.

    • @mmoon3687
      @mmoon3687 6 років тому +3

      Some store employees have got to be asking questions by now

    • @tweezak
      @tweezak 6 років тому +13

      "This guy eats more pork ribs and soda than anyone I've ever seen but he never gains weight. Maybe it's the oranges...or he works out."

    • @BB-eu5gt
      @BB-eu5gt 6 років тому +5

      lmao at the thought of someone start a hardcore orange and pork regimen thinking its what makes paul swoll

    • @BossDoubloon30
      @BossDoubloon30 6 років тому

      Neil VanAlstine 😆

  • @mathewhuber8670
    @mathewhuber8670 6 років тому +66

    What!?... No meat target introduction? That’s like skipping the Sacrament Prayer and just passing out the bread and water, lol. Best channel on UA-cam.

    • @badlandskid
      @badlandskid 6 років тому +2

      Thank God! I could recite it in my sleep.

    • @BanjoZZZ
      @BanjoZZZ 6 років тому +7

      Listening to him explain the meat target is my favorite part - every single time.

    • @badlandskid
      @badlandskid 6 років тому +3

      BillyZaneism Well I’m not what you call a professional so I won’t try it at home.

  • @PPISAFETY
    @PPISAFETY 6 років тому +26

    It has been my experience from testing .40 S&W ammo for police use that just about anything in a hollow point from a major manufacturer works pretty darned well. When you chose between 155, 165, and 180 grain loads, you are pretty much choosing based on your preference for the level of the recoil and barrier penetration characteristics, and I don't think I've ever tested a really "bad" .40 round from a major manufacturer. This is not totally surprising because the .40 was designed with police work in mind. I still have a SIG P229 and a Smith and Wesson M&P, and in the unlikely event I ever found myself back in a patrol car, I'd be wearing one of those two pistols over any other caliber I could choose, except that I might drop the old .357 SIG barrel in the P229 and be just as happy. One reason I still like the .40 is that pretty much anything you stuff in it works pretty well.
    When my small department tested the heavy for caliber 9mm 147 grain Ranger T in tests conducted with several other agencies, we didn't find it to be awful, and it did pretty well on the barrier penetration tests, even though expansion seemed muted once it hit the gel. It seemed pretty comparable to a Speer Gold Dot in the same weight, again not surprising since they are direct competitors, much like Pepsi and Coke. In the end, at that time, we didn't see enough advantage to a caliber change, decided to keep our .40's, and loaded them with Ranger loads. I understand that a few years later they did switch to 9mm pistols and settled on the 124 grain +P HST load because they got a great deal on it.

    • @DavidLLambertmobile
      @DavidLLambertmobile 4 роки тому

      If I ran a 🚔 or were a procurement, contract officer, I'd opt for a HST 124gr +P 9mm or the Hornady Critical Duty 124gr +P 9mm. Many gun owners & armed professionals are not aware that gun makers, S&W Ruger Glock etc use 124gr to R&D 9mm(9x19mm).

    • @PPISAFETY
      @PPISAFETY 4 роки тому +3

      @@DavidLLambertmobile I know there are arguments to be made for the heavier bullets in 9mm, but my sources at Federal/Speer tell me that the performance of the 124 +P is essentially identical to their 147 grain offerings, and that they offer both to accommodate the preferences of departmental purchasers, as they do with the standard pressure load for departments that won't use +P.
      They have also told me that the 124 +P round needs at least a 4 inch barrel to show a material advantage over their same weight standard pressure load. So I tend to agree with you and have standardized on the 124 grain +P HST. In my subcompact pistols it really doesn't recoil more than standard pressure, and is only 30 fps faster in something like a Shield. So I run it in all my 9mm pistols and get decent accuracy and sights that shoot to point of aim/impact. But if for some reason I cannot get it, I'll happily use the 124 standard pressure round, especially in my shorter barreled pistols. Cheers!

  • @gstrader73
    @gstrader73 6 років тому +15

    I have carried 165 gr Ranger-T's for years...great round. I've been impressed with my backyard testing. Thanks Paul!

    • @olympicfarter1
      @olympicfarter1 4 роки тому +2

      That's been my carry ammo as well in my Glock 23 for the last twelve years.

    • @DavidLLambertmobile
      @DavidLLambertmobile 4 роки тому

      I CCWed a Beretta 96D surplus .40 in the late 1990s. I varied from 135gr to 165gr factory JHPs. Mainly Golden Saber & Corbon JHP.

    • @berettaxd7566
      @berettaxd7566 3 роки тому +1

      You two must be cops, because supposedly cops are the only ones that can get the Ranger T 165

    • @gstrader73
      @gstrader73 3 роки тому

      @@berettaxd7566 I am not, that's not true.

    • @thepatriotsrage661
      @thepatriotsrage661 3 роки тому +2

      Makes 2 of us. Same for the 165gr Speer Gold Dot. The 165gr loads in .40 are heard to beat, except for maybe the Hydra-Shok which is anemic at best.

  • @SDGlock23
    @SDGlock23 6 років тому +9

    I love the .40 S&W, can't be beat in terms of power and package size!

  • @jeffdonner1912
    @jeffdonner1912 6 років тому +10

    Thank Paul for another great video. I am still a big fan of the .40 S&W as a defensive cartridge. I keep a Glock 22 by the bed at night loaded with 165gr Gold Dots.

  • @midnight4540
    @midnight4540 6 років тому +6

    Thanks was a interesting test. I am a 40 fan, since S&W 40 was introduced, still have my S&W 4006 and 411 they, lets say glued to my side. Keep up the good work

  • @topbreak38
    @topbreak38 6 років тому +15

    I was watching another video when I saw this was up.
    I'm a simple man. I see Paul Harrell, I click Paul Harrell.

    • @topbreak38
      @topbreak38 6 років тому

      4:43
      Dassa lotta da-midge!

    • @rayburn8282
      @rayburn8282 3 роки тому

      Never not watch a paul harrell video

  • @vincentslone1463
    @vincentslone1463 6 років тому +17

    People are quick to accept ANYTHING positive said about 9MM as pure gospel, but refute any praise about .40 S&W. There is a LOT of misinformation going around on forums, and every time someone tries to make the claim that there's no difference between the two...it's just a claim with no had evidence. For some reason people want to perceive 9MM to be better performing than it actually is, by doing so they immediately minimize .40 S&W or any other caliber that's not 9MM by deeming it 'useless'. Just because 9MM is more practical and easier to shoot that does NOT mean that it's the most effective. Calibers like .40 S&W, .357 SIG or even .45 ACP kind of fall into this subcategory that's an upgrade from 9MM. Although it seems like .40/.357 SIG are slightly better options than .45 ACP due to power and capacity. Anybody that honestly believes power isn't a plausible aspect in modern ballistics is a moron, sadly there are a lot of morons these days. The problem with .45 ACP is that it's a somewhat outdated caliber that's only loaded at half the pressure of .40 or 9MM, Glock tried to address this problem with the widely panned .45 GAP. Personally I'd rather get good performance AND good capacity, which is why I tend to go with .40 S&W. It's an extremely underappreciated duty/carry round!

    • @Omar-if1cu
      @Omar-if1cu 4 роки тому +3

      I know what you mean about 45 acp, and i wouldnt choose it for concealed carry outside in the streets, but for home defense?? Well i think its the best for home defense because it has the least penetration of all while giving the most expansion and great tissue damage. What you think?

    • @frawdulent
      @frawdulent Рік тому

      Beautiful explanation. Couldn’t agree more.

  • @nancyoffenhiser4916
    @nancyoffenhiser4916 6 років тому +4

    Paul, THANK YOU so much! As a 40 Glock 23 gal I have been using Sig Elite. I'm going to make the switch to Winchester. This is why A lot of us support you on Patreon!!!

    • @DavidLLambertmobile
      @DavidLLambertmobile 4 роки тому +2

      I'd opt for the Hornady Critical Duty 175gr or the new line Federal HST 165gr Punch. 🥊.

  • @g33k3dcom
    @g33k3dcom 6 років тому +18

    Great video as always Paul! Love me some .40 S&W!

  • @badlandskid
    @badlandskid 6 років тому +83

    I carry a 40 because. I don't give a rip what you carry or don't carry.

    • @bryanbaker5942
      @bryanbaker5942 6 років тому +21

      Me too. Every now and then I'll tote around my 9mm or my .45 too though. I like my .40. I don't know why in the last couple years, people have been hating on it.

    • @Nobody-xh5qe
      @Nobody-xh5qe 5 років тому +2

      I carry a lot of different stuff 357 Sig to 380 depends on the day and how deep I need to conceal it

    • @DangerRussDayZ6533
      @DangerRussDayZ6533 5 років тому +5

      @@bryanbaker5942 People are idiots. You can carry around a .22 if you want. It's still plenty lethal. I originally bought a 40 as my first handgun because I liked the idea of having something in between a 9 and a 45. The best of both worlds. Sure it's a bit snappy but it's still a good round.

    • @chuckmiller5763
      @chuckmiller5763 5 років тому

      @@bryanbaker5942 We want the 10 MM back. The 40 killed the 10 MM.

    • @bryanbaker5942
      @bryanbaker5942 5 років тому

      @@chuckmiller5763 I have a 10mm too. A SW 1076. Problem is the ammo is expensive so I don't shittit as much. I have found boxes for just over $17 tho.

  • @firefightergoggie
    @firefightergoggie 6 років тому

    One thing I really enjoy about the videos is Paul doesn't let the weather get in the way of shooting. Rain or snow, the video keeps rolling.
    I like that.

  • @ponthis1
    @ponthis1 6 років тому +2

    I believe I will be purchasing some of those Ranger T's for my Walther PPS EDC. They strike me as having some of the best performance I have seen yet. Thank you Paul very very informative.

  • @satmdobbs1843
    @satmdobbs1843 6 років тому +5

    I carry .40 S&W and will pick some of these soon to test against the Federal HST that I currently carry. Great video as always, Paul. Thanks!

    • @DavidLLambertmobile
      @DavidLLambertmobile 4 роки тому

      I lean towards the .357sig in 2020 but the traditional .40 is fine. 1000s of 🇺🇸 cops, federal agents used .40 guns for years.

  • @christophermckay9863
    @christophermckay9863 5 років тому +1

    First, thank you Paul for all of the time you invest in these videos. My personal choice for every day carry is a Springfield XD sub-compact in 40 S&W. I had initially selected Winchester PDX1 as my carry ammo until I found an abnormality in the crimp of the bullet during loading. I found 14 out of the box of 20 that were severely over crimped. I contacted Winchester and they resolved the issue, however they failed initial quality checks to keep it from leaving the factory that way. After receiving the coupon for a replacement box I first opened the box to check the crimp and those too were over crimped. Ultimately I chose the Sig Sauer Elite Performance V-Crown and saved more than 4 dollars per box of 20. Your videos covering that ammunition further vailidate my choice. Once again, thank you.

  • @charliecochran3035
    @charliecochran3035 4 роки тому +3

    I already knew the Ranger T .40 was awesome in both 165 and 180 grain. My big takeaway here was that I need to find some of the white box hollow points. What an awesome bargain as I know I've seen as low as $20 for a box of 50.

  • @sacrednacl4185
    @sacrednacl4185 6 років тому +2

    I love your no BS style of just putting it out there, Paul. You do some great testing on ammo. These are some of the most informative real world type testing of ammo videos out there.

  • @jameshutchins3396
    @jameshutchins3396 6 років тому +1

    Thank you for your endurance in weather to bring us these excellent videos.

  • @rbrtck
    @rbrtck 6 років тому +3

    This goes to show how much the specific load in each cartridge type ("caliber") matters--not the brand, series, or even the basic projectile design, but each specific load. I select loads for each cartridge type based on multiple test results, at least (your meat targets being one of them). That said, there are other factors when choosing between two equally effective loads. For one thing, I like how the Winchester Ranger-T, Bonded, and PDX1 series all have completely sealed cartridges (both at the primers and bullets) and are extremely resistant to bullet setback--this makes the ammo very resilient to environmental conditions outside of a sealed, dehumidified ammo can. This wouldn't make me choose the underperforming 147-grain 9mm Ranger-T, but it is one reason I've chosen this series for .40 S&W (either bullet weight, 165 or 180 grains) over others that are just about as effective and even slightly more consistent (e.g. Federal HST) or less expensive (e.g. Winchester White Box JHP). It gives me some peace of mind regarding reliability under potentially adverse conditions. Additionally, I tend to avoid the Speer Gold Dot series because they are very prone to bullet setback. I like their products and use quite a bit of Speer training ammo, but for defensive use my personal preference--even though it's probably unnecessary--is for more physically robust ammo that will work right even if one submerges it in water or oil, and won't allow the bullet to be pushed into the case, which can raise pressure to dangerous levels.

  • @nelsonmccoy4120
    @nelsonmccoy4120 6 років тому +2

    Must say that the many reviews Paul does is very detailed and to real life as not just gel but uses other rounds to compare to what he is testing but!!! Who else will be out in what seems to be always rain and snow testing!. My hat is off to this guy. unlike others promoting products he leaves the proof to the many.

  • @chubbycatfish4573
    @chubbycatfish4573 6 років тому +2

    I just bought a .40, so thanks for giving me some food for thought.

  • @christopherehendrick
    @christopherehendrick 6 років тому +1

    Thanks Paul! I’m pleased with the results as this is my department’s issued ammo. Keep up the great work!

  • @johnd4348
    @johnd4348 6 років тому

    Neither rain, sleet, or snow will stop Paul from bring us another excellent video. Thanks Paul.

  • @robertshawnmitchell
    @robertshawnmitchell 6 років тому +1

    Such great videos. No nonsense. Just practical knowledge!

  • @hyrumclarke8213
    @hyrumclarke8213 2 роки тому

    Major props for shooting DA for the first shot through the chrono...

  • @terrygrossmann6125
    @terrygrossmann6125 6 років тому

    Thank you Paul as another viewer stated in another post you have video in all weather. I really appreciate your dedication to your followers. Just down to earth great solid information that, in my opinion, is very useful.

  • @Danmandingo
    @Danmandingo 6 років тому

    *That.... INTRO...*
    *I am SO GRATEFUL, to have found this channel.*

  • @patricjft
    @patricjft 6 років тому +8

    Paul lives up to the Post Office moto, rains, sleet, snow.... Unlike the actual Post Office.

  • @Elvis68spec
    @Elvis68spec 6 років тому +1

    Hey, Paul! The Winchester 180gr T Series is the Cartridge my Department used before I retired. I'm going to start caring it again. I stopped using it in my EDC, now that I'm a Civilian because, I'm a bit leery of Juries should I ever become involved in a Civilian Shooting, Heaven forbid! In hindsight, it's always best to use what you train with. Thanks for the good video.

  • @overkillbliss6535
    @overkillbliss6535 6 років тому +14

    Awesome work Paul!

    • @mrd7067
      @mrd7067 6 років тому

      yay 30.

    • @Tyrfingr
      @Tyrfingr 6 років тому

      Awesome pork Paul!

  • @sixstringslaya
    @sixstringslaya 6 років тому

    I absolutely LOVE the "70's style" cop draw and fire in the intro. You are too funny to me, Paul!

  • @TommyboyGTP
    @TommyboyGTP 6 років тому

    I bought a bunch of this .40 Ranger T series police trade-in ammo in both 180 and 165 grain and from your test I'm glad I did. Even the cheap WWB looks like it did pretty well and every Walmart around here has a few boxes of that in stock. Thanks for another great test!

  • @duvalpenny100
    @duvalpenny100 6 років тому +3

    The new mic is VERY noticeable. Great improvement.

  • @qwman68
    @qwman68 6 років тому +1

    Looks like fantastic ammo for my Sig Sauer P229. As soon as I use up all this 180gr Gold Dot ammo I have I will give this a try. Great video as usual Paul.

  • @darrelkopsa7143
    @darrelkopsa7143 2 роки тому

    This is 4 years later, but I was just looking at this ammo on the web today with very little information. Now, thanks to Paul, I will order some and see if any shipping will carry it!!

  • @MPGunther1
    @MPGunther1 6 років тому +2

    It's usually the inexpensive HP ammo that out performs. Nice to see the T-Series come out on top

  • @lifebiker105
    @lifebiker105 6 років тому +6

    I Like the way you lay it out and ask us to draw our own conclusion. you are a great teacher. Thank You Paul.

  • @antouab221
    @antouab221 6 років тому

    With videos like this Paul removes all internet "hearsay" and brings clarity and truth to the real life. No words to say except one huge THANK YOU Paul.

  • @propdoctor21564
    @propdoctor21564 6 років тому

    Out in the woods trimming trees and stopped to check my email and happened to see a new video from my favorite gun Channel.... now sitting on a tree stump just finished watching... always an enjoyable and entertaining break 😁

  • @Archangelm127
    @Archangelm127 6 років тому +1

    I love the new intro! My only suggestion is to make Paul's classic line of "you be the judge" full-volume at the end. I think that's a fantastic cap to the intro, but having the audio almost muted by the music undercuts it quite a bit. :)

  • @ThunderMountainTactical
    @ThunderMountainTactical 6 років тому +1

    Very interesting and of course just plain fun to see. Great video Paul.

  • @JohnLloydScharf
    @JohnLloydScharf 6 років тому +40

    Great. The .40 S&W seems to perform adequately regardless of the brand. The Ranger T leaves prettier projectiles. Is it worth the cost? "You be the judge."

    • @bnolsen
      @bnolsen 6 років тому +5

      40 definitely seems to have the right stuff associated with it. It has far more than enough performance to get the job done without living on the edge like 380acp and to a smaller degree 9mm.

    • @Predalien195
      @Predalien195 6 років тому +2

      +Brian Olsen I feel that is mostly in part because .40 S&W is typically loaded to about 80% maximum level. Most factory .40 S&W loads seem to have the same velocity range depending on bullet weight, and a few I've taken apart to see whats inside would seem to indicate this. Not to mention, it's the only way they can get a 180gr projectile moving at around 1,000 to 1,100 fps from a 4 inch barrel or so. It's why you typically dont see a +P .40 S&W load out there. That and I suppose that's what 10mm is for if you want to go that route.
      I personally dont view .380 ACP as a "living on the edge" kind of caliber in terms of performance. I find most factory .380 ACP to be loaded to similar levels as well. The biggest disparity in .380 ACP for a long time was hollow point ammunition, but now there are plenty of reliable and reputable brand of JHP ammo that deliver consistent performance on the .380 ACP.
      But typically any caliber that is loaded to maximum or near maximum from the factory comes out this way. .45 ACP is a prime example as it's been loaded nearly the exact same now for 100 years.

    • @rbrtck
      @rbrtck 5 років тому +1

      Right, with 9mm you have to be more picky with personal defense loads, and then there is the common issue of practice loads being noticeably lighter. While .40 S&W is not entirely free of such issues, if you buy commonly available factory ammunition, then you probably won't have any issues--with the common stuff, virtually all personal defense loads are effective enough, and virtually all practice loads are stout enough for effective training. It's like .45 ACP in this way--not as much to concern oneself about.

    • @playerzero2236
      @playerzero2236 5 років тому +6

      That is the beauty of the .40 caliber. Even shit ammo is better than 9mm

    • @motorgearhead
      @motorgearhead 4 роки тому +2

      The T series used to be part of Winchester’s law enforcement ammo line. Not sure if it still is or not. The T is rumored to stand for Talon as in Black Talon. Every round I’ve ever seen recovered expanded like crazy. It is or was available with a bonded projectile to limit jacket separation as well. I use the +P in 45 acp in my kimber ultra carry.

  • @bluedial2
    @bluedial2 6 років тому

    Top notch video. To me your test seem to provide the best representation of how these products will preform.

  • @Gator69420
    @Gator69420 4 місяці тому

    Yeah these in 40sw are top
    Notch! Other calibers not so much but the 40 with these is serious stuff! I’ve tested them with my own meat target and clothing and was impressed! These rangers in 40 are right up there with Federal HST

  • @oimissed1292
    @oimissed1292 6 років тому +1

    I like the new opening but I wish you would show your medals they mean something to some of us keep up the good work and I'm glad to see both those gun seem to fit in your hand well

  • @patrickrayner2594
    @patrickrayner2594 6 років тому +4

    0:13 you embraced the meme. I'm so proud.

  • @crandall777
    @crandall777 6 років тому

    Nice work as always Paul thanks for your support

  • @hamm6033
    @hamm6033 6 років тому +1

    Excellent again. Seeing with your own eyes is to me the gold standard. I am a fan of Hornady Critical Defense because the local Leo's use the Critical Duty. It is a legal reason, if I ever end up in court I'm using a civilian version of the Leo ammo. And it does preform very well. This is based on perceptions from my attorney of the local views of law enforcement and public. And yes he's a criminal defense attorney. That's what you will need. I think a current day comprehensive video on the aftermath of a shooting would be great Paul.

  • @davehal4503
    @davehal4503 6 років тому

    Paul, you are the best on UA-cam. In a sea of video gunnies taking one shot at gel, you do it RIGHT!

  • @scottydouglass1892
    @scottydouglass1892 6 років тому +3

    I swear I should have tied a roll of fleece blankets together when I was in asscrackastan. That seems to stop bullets better than a vest. Lighter weight too. Then when it got cold, just unroll for sleepin'. Love the meat target

  • @troy9477
    @troy9477 6 років тому

    Nicely done. The Ranger T was the issue ammo at my agency the last 5 or 6 yrs i worked there. Mainly because it was relatively cheap on the state contract. It had a good reputation, and always worked well on the occasional deer i had to humanely dispatch. Glad to see it did well on the meat target. Before that, we always carried Gold Dots, and i liked those also. Although i did have an interesting dud/defective round of it once. Thanks for everything you do. Time for the 45ACP version!

  • @mwalker1975
    @mwalker1975 6 років тому

    Once again I’m inspired to get out to the range. Your videos make me want to practice, practice, practice.

  • @Kratos_God_of_50_BMG
    @Kratos_God_of_50_BMG 6 років тому +12

    Thanks for the presentation Paul! .40 is a very underrated caliber for civilian use, but Law Enforcement sees how effective it really can be. I look forward to further videos!

    • @DavidLLambertmobile
      @DavidLLambertmobile 4 роки тому

      In 2020 more state & local PDs went to 9x19mm BUT many cops, troopers had no problems with 165/155 gr .40 guns. The CBP, US Border Patrol issued Beretta 96Ds & P229s for years.

  • @frankbutta9344
    @frankbutta9344 6 років тому +1

    What?!?!? I bought a bunch of WWB .40 S&W personal protection on your recommendation, Paul...lol! One of the online stores was practically giving it away, so I’m good for the rest of my life with the amount I ordered. Thanks for sharing!

    • @ricksorber8343
      @ricksorber8343 5 років тому

      After I saw this, I got a few boxes myself. Looks like it should do the job.

  • @skipfreeman3465
    @skipfreeman3465 6 років тому +9

    Great video Paul! I have always been a fan of the 40.S&W people always tell me how the 9mm is just as powerful, not in my own experience testing the 2 40 is far more powerful Imho

    • @playerzero2236
      @playerzero2236 5 років тому +1

      9mm is the Honda Civic of handgun calibers.

    • @TheWolfsnack
      @TheWolfsnack 5 років тому +1

      @@playerzero2236 ...and 40 is the Cadillac...but 45 is the Kenworth.

  • @justinv3080
    @justinv3080 6 років тому +2

    I'm glad you tested the WWB 180 gr JHP. These have been showing good performance in online testing and are actually a good budget option if you had to have something from a brick and morter in a hurry. It wouldn't be my first choice but unlike most entry level JHP ammo it actually performs well. The WWB JHP in 9mm are far less impressive.

  • @worddunlap
    @worddunlap 6 років тому +2

    Ranger T was used by lots of PDs a few years back before the FBI NEW 9mm is good as 40 cal report. It;s a great time to buy a USED dept trade in Beretta 40 and Ranger T now.

  • @jongancarz1742
    @jongancarz1742 6 років тому +4

    Thank you Paul

  • @bthunder9292
    @bthunder9292 5 років тому

    The Dry Yet Comedic Accurate Color commentary Besides the Obvious Facts that you bring I enjoy these Videoz. Paul is My Man

  • @clukinvar
    @clukinvar 6 років тому

    Thanks for making the two Winchester Ranger T videos

  • @rockos0000
    @rockos0000 6 років тому

    Love the glasses. Always a good day when Paul drops a video.

  • @johnganshow5536
    @johnganshow5536 6 років тому +6

    I enjoy my 40s, great info!!!

  • @anthonylanci
    @anthonylanci 6 років тому

    Great video. That ranger T expanded looking a lot like old school Black Talon . Miss that stuff.

  • @adamsmith8660
    @adamsmith8660 6 років тому

    And once again another great video bursting full of good, practical information coming from one of the most experienced gun tuber with the best credibility. Thank You Mr. Paul Harrell! Your channel is top notch!

  • @rebelcat420
    @rebelcat420 6 років тому +3

    Another great video! I’ve seen a lot of videos showing the effectiveness of .223/5.56, as well as a number of .357mag videos. Knowing that you can get comparable energy if you use the right loads of each, I’d love to see a video comparing a .223 from carbine length AR to a .357mag from a lever carbine. Specifically I’d love to see wall penetration/overpenetration, cement block destruction as well as the famous “meat target”. The goal being to compare for home defense. This would be extremely nice to see in light of all of the talks about “assault rifle bans”, seeing other carbine options for home defense (that would be immune to some of these proposed bans) and how they stack up.

    • @steviesevieria1868
      @steviesevieria1868 6 років тому

      rebelcat420 .357 approaches 5.56? Certainly you're not referring to main stream ammo, are you?

    • @bjs301
      @bjs301 6 років тому

      Steven Sevieria
      It's actually not a bad question. Fired out of a rifle, the .357's energy is not really that far behind the .223's. Obviously, aiming at something 100 yards out, it'd be no contest. But the .357 would be the better brush gun. I can't see either as a home defense gun though.

    • @rebelcat420
      @rebelcat420 6 років тому +2

      Steven Sevieria first, I’m going on actual kinetic energy of the bullet, not velocity as we all know .223/5.56 is 2-3x the speed of most .357...but the bullet weight of the .357 is in most cases 2-3x heavier. I’m in no way saying they are the same- especially 5.56, which we all know is more powerful.
      BUT if you look at the ballistics of what most would commonly use in each gun as a defensive round, you will find more using more of a varmint load(soft tip vs FMJ or green tip) , and those would most likely be in. .223 NOT 5.56 (remember, I’m talking what you would be likely to find on your big box store shelf). In a .357, you would most likely grab something like a Speer Gold Dot or Hornady Defense in a 357 +P round. Again, comparing kinetic energy (mass x velocity), now you see the .357 coming a bit closer to the .223. Handloading, anything is possible (if you are willing to trust it!), but that’s neither here nor there. The gap you’d find (to my best guess) between the defensive .357 to .223 rounds would be closer than say 300blk and 5.56.
      Either way, both are common defense calibers and it would be an interesting comparison.

    • @steviesevieria1868
      @steviesevieria1868 6 років тому

      rebelcat420 thumbs up

    • @alonewolf9768
      @alonewolf9768 6 років тому

      rebelcat420 12 Gauge #4 00 buck ammo in a shotgun (any pump shotgun preferably an 18 ½ in barrel with a light) IS the best home, apartment, camper, tent defense weapon that will definitely get the job done and not kill grandma that is sleeping next door. (My opinion from studies that I've done for the perfect Home Defense gun) My dream is a 300 Blackout 9 ½ barrel with a suppressor because that could also have a really short barrel and be suppressed while still maintaining velocity but the ATF don't give those out for free 😢

  • @dasx2gra
    @dasx2gra 6 років тому

    Paul, as always, an education in 6 minutes, thank you for your dedication and hard work! its appreciated.

  • @GunsNHarleys
    @GunsNHarleys 6 років тому

    Thanks for another great video Paul. Your videos are always concise, informative, and on target (no pun intended).

  • @grampsoyer8621
    @grampsoyer8621 6 років тому

    Paul - new camera? Much clearer in this video. Great work.

  • @kenhelmers2603
    @kenhelmers2603 6 років тому

    Thanks Paul, I appreciate your efforts and the sharing of the results!

  • @miteco1
    @miteco1 5 років тому +1

    Snow man harrell.
    Calm, cool, collected.
    Eagle eyes.
    Humble confidence.
    Superior performance.
    Such a boss.

  • @billy56081
    @billy56081 6 років тому

    The video I wait for every week.

  • @VTPSTTU
    @VTPSTTU 6 років тому

    Thanks for another good video. I like seeing real tests of these bullets. The moral of the story still seems to be that Winchester "white box" is a good choice most of the time. I've bought some Federal "white box" for my 9mm. I need to try this someday.

  • @lydnew98
    @lydnew98 6 років тому

    Another superb video. Thanks much, Paul. You're the best.

  • @kentwilliams4152
    @kentwilliams4152 5 років тому

    There were two loadings originally for the .40 S&W cartridge. They were the 180 grain at about 950 fps and the 155 grain version at about 1150 fps. We chose the 155 grain version since it duplicated the 158 grain .357 loading that we had carried for many years past. As time went on we began to get inquiries from other Law Enforcement agencies in regards to the 155 grain JHP’s performance in the field since they had experienced dismal performance with the 180 grain version(s.) If one considers that a .45 ACP 185 grain projectile travels about the same velocity as the 40 S&W and is a larger diameter. (.452” to .410”) the only advantage the .40 has is an increased magazine capacity, and the superior performance of the 155 grain version.
    Later, some manufactures brought forth a 165 grain JHP cartridge.

  • @jonathanedwards2983
    @jonathanedwards2983 6 років тому

    40 is actually back in my favor. Good data. Thanks for the video!

  • @wayartio
    @wayartio 2 роки тому

    Paul does a gereat job of real world ammo testing and is is one of my fav experts. I have really come to love the 40 and it is a very boldacius defense load. I carry both 40 and 9 MM but from my shooting the 40 does the trick better!

  • @joeh1687
    @joeh1687 5 років тому +1

    When I was a police officer our department used Winchester Rangers. I never had to shoot anyone (thank God), but on the range those things had some serious blast, at least in 45acp anyway. Most of the guys in our department carried a Glock 22 40SW, at the closest distance at the range (about 7 feet) they would just punch a hole in the target. But when I fired a round out of the Glock 21 it would blow the paper off the wood frame half the time.... it was like I had set off a howitzer! : )

  • @mr_fnh
    @mr_fnh 6 років тому +1

    Pretty impressive stuff Paul. Thanks.

  • @rowdyron4111
    @rowdyron4111 6 років тому

    Excellent video Paul. Thanks for the hard work.

  • @masterofnone11
    @masterofnone11 Рік тому

    The pockets on that jacket I like the Tactical version of Narnia 😂

  • @jamespruitt6718
    @jamespruitt6718 6 років тому

    Love my M&P .40. This video really helps in choosing a good defense ammo for it.

  • @ivansanta-maria1328
    @ivansanta-maria1328 2 роки тому +1

    Can't wait to see those Barrier videos

  • @mikemc330
    @mikemc330 6 років тому

    Good video...thanks Paul. I'm looking forward to the barrier tests with bonded ammo!

  • @owenfavro2290
    @owenfavro2290 6 років тому +15

    Hello Paul - love your videos - how about a meat target comparing .223 FMJ to .223 JSP

    • @PaulHarrell
      @PaulHarrell  6 років тому +17

      Just filmed a video w/various types of .223 JSP's It should be on line in a couple of weeks.

    • @ssspencerjr
      @ssspencerjr 6 років тому +2

      Thanks Paul I'm sure that's going to be very interesting.

    • @petergonzales8017
      @petergonzales8017 6 років тому +1

      you should also do varmint rounds like hornady v max

    • @ThunderMountainTactical
      @ThunderMountainTactical 6 років тому

      Awesome!

  • @roosterboy7357
    @roosterboy7357 6 років тому +1

    Best on the internet

  • @beakfish7319
    @beakfish7319 6 років тому

    yes! 2 Paul Harrell videos in one day!? and here I was thinking my birthday was in June!

  • @TheFacelessMan82
    @TheFacelessMan82 6 років тому

    Love your channel Paul. Keep up the good work my man!

  • @Gumby56
    @Gumby56 6 років тому +3

    Another excellent video, thanks!

  • @Thorsaxe777
    @Thorsaxe777 6 років тому

    As in your "Shoot like your Grandfather and using the ammo he would have used" It is hard to dispute the cubic inches in Engines and Bullet weights. There are a few exceptions, However, I feel overall heavy bullets just do more, Maybe not a lot more, but it is more. speed and bullet weight does have its value, However, Not if they fail to do what they are intended to do. another awesome Video for the Masses Paul. Keep up the great work.

  • @TheLondekZdroj
    @TheLondekZdroj 6 років тому +31

    great video as always but where's "You'd be the judge" ;)

    • @lehampton1
      @lehampton1 6 років тому +2

      Tomasz Zajac I’d say this video was ‘Not bad at all.’ 😆

  • @NateDogg7282
    @NateDogg7282 6 років тому +3

    Good video! Love the new intro too

  • @cmaugle
    @cmaugle 6 років тому

    Thanks for another great video Paul!

  • @keithmcconnell3165
    @keithmcconnell3165 3 роки тому

    Thanks for the quality content always.