I love your editing! Is simply, elegant and seems very professional. We don't agree that much on the whole (Cantonese is a fave dubbing language) but I love how you're always nice in your comments.
Great video once more, I really love this series you're making xD I agree with everything I guess, my only disagreement is Elsa, Jobelle is special to me, so I would have chosen her, but as you said they are both great, and I love Shennio as well! Chinese Moanas are not really memorable or great for me, but I think I agree with you on that choise too :)
I don’t know most of these voices, but according to the clips here we agreed on everything, especially with those characters whose voices I’m already familiar with. I usually like the Chinese voices (mostly Taiwanese dubs) a lot in general, sometimes I feel like people brush them off as ”too sweet/too childish” etc. I really like the calm and soothing side of most of the voices!! I’ve heard some Tiana voices and I think Ella is currently my favourite, so I was glad to see her winning the Tiana round :D Shennio and Monica 💗 and I thoroughly agree with what you said about Shennio! I wish she had reprised her role in the short film... Great and interesting video, I really like these! I think I’ll prepare myself for that Finnish&Hungarian round by listening to some Hungarian voices so I will actually know how many similarities there are between our opinions x)
Really Fantastic battle! I love Cantonese and Taiwanese dubbings, but I love Taiwanese more. I disagree with Mulan. I love Coco Lee, but Kelly is in Top 3 in my Mulan rankings. And she is my favorite Cantonese Heroine voice! Nice editing, I love you very much
Great video, and I completely agree with your choices :) I would love that Taiwan dub “Sleeping Beauty”, I’m pretty sure they would give something amazing, I wonder why they didn’t dub the movie. ^^
Taiwan did dub Sleeping Beauty in Mandarin Chinese for TV. charguigou has the Taiwanese Mandarin voices for the characters, but also, the songs in the Taiwanese Mandarin TV dubbing are all left in English. :(
Lol once again, we do not agree....at all x) the only characters we agree on are Ariel, Esmeralda & Megera :p but amazing video! I can't wait to see your Castilian vs Latin battles ^^
Oh I'm glad you like Cecilia as Moana (I seem the majority don't like her :/) even if you chosen Monica xD. That (and maybe Anna) would be my only disagreements as I agree with all your choices, I think :D (I'm not into so much voices of some characters like Miriam, Esmeralda, etc), but your choices were beautiful :). This was such a difficult match IMO, I love the 3 Chinese duba (including Mainland one), I sincerely don't know if I prefer Taiwanese and Cantonese, I always liked the Taiwanese "cute" touch and the Cantonese "smoky" one x). Elsa was the hardest one I think! Nice video! OH YEAH NEXT BOTH SPANISH :DDD
Mandarin and Cantonese versions' are shounded very similar to me, I mean that both of them are special, very beautiful and perfect. We agree. Excellent video!!! :3
According to my opinion, we mostly agree. Maybe with Anna I'll rather went with Kandy, and also with Cinderella I'll personally choose Cantonese. But I enjoyed every choice you made, I especially agree with Ariel, Pocahontas, Meg, Kiara, Tiana, Rapunzel and Moana. Tho I'm pretty concerned, if I prefer Shennio or Jobelle, since I love them both so much. Once again gorgeous round, I can't wait for the Spanish battle :)
charguigou, I hate to say this, but the Mandarin Chinese name you used for Taiwan in this video is wrong. It's not supposed to be "普通話" (Putonghua in Traditional Chinese characters), because Putonghua (普通话) is actually the Mandarin Chinese name for China. The Mandarin Chinese name for Taiwan you're supposed to use is actually "國語" (Guoyu).
I think I agree about everything, except Mulan; Mandarin is indeed good, but she sounds a bit too pop-ish to my ears. Otherwise, Cantonese is absolutely part of my top 10. Elsa; I like Shennio, but Jobelle is my 4th favorite Elsa. I just love everything about her performance! Anna; I’m not sure, but I think I prefer Kandy a little bit. Great video as always!
I never get the "poppish" argument, pop is a kind of music and I don't see a voice can be poppish, but to each his/her opinions. Moreover, I don't see how "pop" is that bad
charguigou I mean, her voice & style of singing is a bit pop-ish style, and it just doesn’t click with me on Mulan. Malay Frozen sisters also have this kind of pop sound but here it works to me. It’s a matter of taste I guess, it’s either it clicks with you or not. But I like her a lot, I just prefer Cantonese voice
charguigou, I hate to tell you this, but you forgot Wendy from Peter Pan, because Hong Kong and Taiwan did dub Peter Pan in Cantonese (for Hong Kong) and (Taiwanese) Mandarin (for Taiwan).
I love your editing! Is simply, elegant and seems very professional. We don't agree that much on the whole (Cantonese is a fave dubbing language) but I love how you're always nice in your comments.
Magdalena Jasmén thanks a lot, glad you enjoyed :)
Great video! I am glad you keep making those Battles! I think we agree in most of your choices here.
There's no reason I would stop
I mean that they passed a few months since your last Battle. I will keep waiting for Greek vs Turkish.
Yeah sorry, I'm quite busy lately so I can't make as much videos
Great video once more, I really love this series you're making xD I agree with everything I guess, my only disagreement is Elsa, Jobelle is special to me, so I would have chosen her, but as you said they are both great, and I love Shennio as well! Chinese Moanas are not really memorable or great for me, but I think I agree with you on that choise too :)
Yeah it was hard, Jobelle is also very special to me; both are in my top 10, just one is above the other
I don’t know most of these voices, but according to the clips here we agreed on everything, especially with those characters whose voices I’m already familiar with. I usually like the Chinese voices (mostly Taiwanese dubs) a lot in general, sometimes I feel like people brush them off as ”too sweet/too childish” etc. I really like the calm and soothing side of most of the voices!!
I’ve heard some Tiana voices and I think Ella is currently my favourite, so I was glad to see her winning the Tiana round :D
Shennio and Monica 💗 and I thoroughly agree with what you said about Shennio! I wish she had reprised her role in the short film...
Great and interesting video, I really like these! I think I’ll prepare myself for that Finnish&Hungarian round by listening to some Hungarian voices so I will actually know how many similarities there are between our opinions x)
poison ivy glad to see someone else liking the Chinese voices !
Haha don’t worry you have some time between the Finnish vs Hungarian battle ;)
Really Fantastic battle!
I love Cantonese and Taiwanese dubbings, but I love Taiwanese more.
I disagree with Mulan. I love Coco Lee, but Kelly is in Top 3 in my Mulan rankings. And she is my favorite Cantonese Heroine voice!
Nice editing, I love you very much
Thanks :)
You are welcome!
My choices:
Snow White: Mandarin
Cinderella: Mandarin
Shanti: Cantonese
Ariel: Mandarin
Belle: Cantonese
Jasmine: Cantonese
Nala: Mandarin
Pocahontas: Mandarin
Esmeralda: Cantonese
Megara: Cantonese
Mulan: Cantonese
Miriam: Mandarin
Tziporah/Sephora: Mandarin
Kiara: Cantonese
Melody: Mandarin
Tiana: Cantonese
Rapunzel: Mandarin
Anna: Cantonese
Elsa: Cantonese
Moana: Mandarin
Cantonese 10
Mandarin 10
It's a tie for me
Great video, and I completely agree with your choices :) I would love that Taiwan dub “Sleeping Beauty”, I’m pretty sure they would give something amazing, I wonder why they didn’t dub the movie. ^^
Taiwan did dub Sleeping Beauty in Mandarin Chinese for TV. charguigou has the Taiwanese Mandarin voices for the characters, but also, the songs in the Taiwanese Mandarin TV dubbing are all left in English. :(
Lol once again, we do not agree....at all x) the only characters we agree on are Ariel, Esmeralda & Megera :p but amazing video! I can't wait to see your Castilian vs Latin battles ^^
My opinion
Snow white : Mandarin
Cinderella : Mandarin
Shanti : Cantonese
Ariel: Mandarin
Belle : Cantonese
Jasmine : Cantonese
Nala : Mandarin
Pocahontas : Mandarin
Esmeralda : Cantonese
Megara: Cantonese
Mulan: Mandarin
Miriam : Cantonese
Tiporazh : Cantonese
Kiara : Cantonese
Melody : Cantonese
Tiana : Cantonese
Rapunzel : Mandarin
Anna : Mandarin
Elsa: Cantonese
Vaiana /Moana : Mandarin
Cantonese : 11 points
Mandarin : 9 points
Cantonese win!
Snow White: Mandarin
Cinderella: Mandarin
Shanti: Mandarin
Ariel: Mandarin
Belle: Cantonese
Jasmine: Cantonese
Nala: Cantonese
Pocahontas: Mandarin
Esmeralda: Cantonese
Megara: Cantonese
Mulan: Mandarin
Miriam: Mandarin
Tzipporah: Cantonese
Kiara: Cantonese
Melody: Taiwanese
Tiana: Cantonese
Rapunzel: Mandarin
Anna: Cantonese
Elsa: Cantonese
Moana: Cantonese
Snow white: Mandarin
Cinderella: Mandarin
Shanti: Mandarin
Ariel: Mandarin
Belle: Cantonese
Jasmine: Mandarin
Nala: Mandarin
Pocahontas: Mandarin
Esmeralda: Cantonese
Megara: Mandarin
Mulan: Mandarin(Obviously)
Miriam: Mandarin
Tzipporah: Mandarin
Kiara: Cantonese
Melody: Cantonese
Tiana: Mandarin
Rapunzel: Mandarin
Ana: Cantonese
Elsa: Cantonese
Moana: Mandarin
Cantonese: 6
Mandarin: 14
Oh I'm glad you like Cecilia as Moana (I seem the majority don't like her :/) even if you chosen Monica xD. That (and maybe Anna) would be my only disagreements as I agree with all your choices, I think :D (I'm not into so much voices of some characters like Miriam, Esmeralda, etc), but your choices were beautiful :). This was such a difficult match IMO, I love the 3 Chinese duba (including Mainland one), I sincerely don't know if I prefer Taiwanese and Cantonese, I always liked the Taiwanese "cute" touch and the Cantonese "smoky" one x). Elsa was the hardest one I think! Nice video! OH YEAH NEXT BOTH SPANISH :DDD
I still love your video ! And I agree with a lot of your choice😉
Snow white: Mandarin
Cinderella: Mandarin
Shanti: Mandarin
Ariel: Mandarin
Belle: Cantonese
Jasmine: Mandarin
Nala: Mandarin
Pocahontas: Mandarin
Esmeralda: Cantonese
Megara: Mandarin
Mulan: Mandarin(Obviously)
Miriam: Mandarin
Tzipporah: Mandarin
Kiara: Cantonese
Melody: Cantonese
Tiana: Mandarin
Rapunzel: Mandarin
Ana: Cantonese
Elsa: Cantonese
Moana: Mandarin
Cantonese: 6
Mandarin: 14
My opinion :
Snow white :Mandarin
Cinderella :Mandarin
Shanti:Cantonese
Ariel:Mandarin
Belle:Mandarin
Jasmine :Cantonese
Nala:Mandarin
Pocahontas :Mandarin
Esmeralda :. Mandarin
Megara :Cantonese
Mulan:Mandarin
Miriam:Mandarin
Tzipporah:Mandarin
Kiara :Cantonese
Melody:Mandarin
Tiana:Cantonese
Rapunzel :Mandarin
Anna:Cantonese
Elsa:Mandarin
Moana:Mandarin
6 Cantonese
14 Mandarin
Winner:Mandarin
🇭🇰♥🇹🇼
Mandarin and Cantonese versions' are shounded very similar to me, I mean that both of them are special, very beautiful and perfect.
We agree. Excellent video!!! :3
According to my opinion, we mostly agree. Maybe with Anna I'll rather went with Kandy, and also with Cinderella I'll personally choose Cantonese. But I enjoyed every choice you made, I especially agree with Ariel, Pocahontas, Meg, Kiara, Tiana, Rapunzel and Moana. Tho I'm pretty concerned, if I prefer Shennio or Jobelle, since I love them both so much. Once again gorgeous round, I can't wait for the Spanish battle :)
Snow White: Cantonese
Cinderella: (Taiwanese) Mandarin
Shanti: (Taiwanese) Mandarin
Ariel: (Taiwanese) Mandarin
Belle: Cantonese
Jasmine: (Taiwanese) Mandarin
Nala: (Taiwanese) Mandarin
Pocahontas: (Taiwanese) Mandarin
Esmeralda: Cantonese
Megara (Meg): Cantonese
Mulan: I like both, but I like (Taiwanese) Mandarin more
Miriam: (Taiwanese) Mandarin
Tzipporah: Same as Miriam: (Taiwanese) Mandarin
Kiara: Cantonese
Melody: Cantonese
Tiana: (Taiwanese) Mandarin
Rapunzel: (Taiwanese) Mandarin
Anna: Cantonese
Elsa: (Taiwanese) Mandarin
Moana: (Taiwanese) Mandarin
Score: 7 for Cantonese and 13 for (Taiwanese) Mandarin
MY WINNER IS (TAIWANESE) MANDARIN!!!
charguigou, I hate to say this, but the Mandarin Chinese name you used for Taiwan in this video is wrong. It's not supposed to be "普通話" (Putonghua in Traditional Chinese characters), because Putonghua (普通话) is actually the Mandarin Chinese name for China. The Mandarin Chinese name for Taiwan you're supposed to use is actually "國語" (Guoyu).
I think I agree about everything, except Mulan; Mandarin is indeed good, but she sounds a bit too pop-ish to my ears. Otherwise, Cantonese is absolutely part of my top 10. Elsa; I like Shennio, but Jobelle is my 4th favorite Elsa. I just love everything about her performance!
Anna; I’m not sure, but I think I prefer Kandy a little bit.
Great video as always!
I never get the "poppish" argument, pop is a kind of music and I don't see a voice can be poppish, but to each his/her opinions. Moreover, I don't see how "pop" is that bad
charguigou I mean, her voice & style of singing is a bit pop-ish style, and it just doesn’t click with me on Mulan. Malay Frozen sisters also have this kind of pop sound but here it works to me. It’s a matter of taste I guess, it’s either it clicks with you or not. But I like her a lot, I just prefer Cantonese voice
charguigou, I hate to tell you this, but you forgot Wendy from Peter Pan, because Hong Kong and Taiwan did dub Peter Pan in Cantonese (for Hong Kong) and (Taiwanese) Mandarin (for Taiwan).
Jackary Reyes yeah, so find me those two dubs and I’ll remake the vid
SnowWhite:Cantonese🇭🇰 Cinderella:Mandarin🇹🇼 Shanti:Cantonese🇭🇰 Ariel:Mandarin🇹🇼 Belle:Cantonese🇭🇰 Jasmine:Cantonese🇭🇰 Nala:Mandarin🇹🇼 Pocahontas:Mandarin🇹🇼 Esmeralda:Cantonese🇭🇰 Megara:Cantonese🇭🇰 Mulan:Mandarin🇹🇼 Miriam:Mandarin🇹🇼 Tzipporah:Mandarin🇹🇼 Kiara:Cantonese🇭🇰 Melody:Cantonese🇭🇰 Tiana:Cantonese🇭🇰 Rapunzel:Mandarin🇹🇼 Anna:Mandarin🇹🇼 Elsa:Cantonese🇭🇰 Moana:Cantonese🇭🇰 Bonus: Mirabel:Cantonese🇭🇰 Nala 2019:Cantonese🇭🇰 Cantonese🇭🇰:13 Mandarin🇹🇼:9 Cantonese wins
I love all the Cantonese version better than Mandarin version.
Love Hong Kong Taiwan
Shalom from Israel 🇮🇱🇭🇰🇹🇼
Can you do dutch vs flemish battle please
Read Description
Snow White in Mandarin was beautiful but sounds older
Cantonese!
Mulan: Mandarin
And Cantonese
Hello charguigou
Cantonese 7 🇭🇰
Taiwanese 13 🇹🇼
Mandarin 9 Cantonese 11*
malaysia vs indonesia
You'll have to wait after Round 9: Greek Vs Turkish.