Teen Accused of Dumping Baby in Trash Gets Win in Court
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 жов 2024
- The trial for a New Mexico woman accused of killing her newborn baby and leaving him in a hospital bathroom trash can has been delayed. Alexee Trevizo's trial for the death of her baby was scheduled to begin later this month. But the judge presiding over her case ruled what happened at the hospital with doctors treating Trevizo is privileged and can't be used against her at trial. Law&Crime's Angenette Levy looks at the issue and talks with Trevizo's lawyer, Gary Mitchell, in this episode of Crime Fix - a daily show covering the biggest stories in crime.
Use the code LAW15 for 15% off at citybeauty.com.... That’s promo code LAW15 for 15% off your order!
Host:
Angenette Levy: x.com/Angenette5
Guests:
John Day
Gary Mitchell
Subscribe to Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/LawAndC...
#AlexeeTrevizo #Trial #LawAndCrime
STAY UP-TO-DATE WITH THE LAW&CRIME NETWORK:
Watch Law&Crime Network on UA-camTV: bit.ly/3td2e3y
Where To Watch Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/3akxLK5
Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter: bit.ly/LawandC...
Read Fascinating Articles From Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/3td2Iqo
For Advertising Inquiries, Please Contact: sales@lawandcrime.com
For Licensing Inquiries, Please Contact: licensing@lawandcrime.com
LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
Instagram: / lawandcrime
Twitter: / lawcrimenetwork
Facebook: / lawandcrime
Twitch: / lawandcrimenetwork
TikTok: / lawandcrime
LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS: lawandcrime.co...
SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK UA-cam CHANNELS:
Main Channel: / @lawandcrime
Law&Crime Shorts: / @lawandcrimeshorts
Channel B: / @lawandcrimetrials
Channel C: / @lawandcrimebodycam
Use the code LAW15 for 15% off at citybeauty.com/LCCrimeFix. That’s promo code LAW15 for 15% off your order!
pass a law to forbid anyone under 20 or 21 to get pregnant, too many dumbo teens, they should focus in their highschool.
She wrapped a baby in plastic and threw him away and her attorney says the public is harshly critical of her… wtf?
Since the baby did not cry and wasn't appearing to be breathing, she thought, in her young immaturity, that the baby was stillborn and dead anyway. I'm not saying it's right what she did in the end, but again in her immaturity, she thought the baby was dead anyway and that maybe the stresses in her life would all go away (her mom's anger at her, the fact that she had been pregnant, etc.). She didn't wrap the baby in plastic...she put the plastic over the baby so that if one was just looking at the top of the basket, that it wouldn't look like there was a baby in there. Again, immaturity, but she honestly thought the baby had been born early and had died.
@@bettywith2girlsthis isn’t immaturity or ignorance. She knew better, that’s why she put the plastic covering on top. If she didn’t realize it was super bad she wouldn’t try covering her tracks. She also didn’t inform anyone… dead or not, she wanted to pretend this “nothing” didn’t exist, when it was a full term baby brought into the world, who deserved recognition from his own mother. Why are you in all the comments defending her? Did you throw away your baby at 19?
@@bettywith2girls I call BS she was afraid of her mother, she’d rather off the baby than tell her mother.
@bettywith2girls if she wanted the baby and thought it was dead she would have gotten help done cpr.
@@bettywith2girls didn’t the autopsy report show that the child did in fact take a breath? That is what I remember, but I could be wrong. The autopsy report will say a lot though.
The video doesn’t mean much tbh. If the autopsy shows the baby was alive when he was put in the garbage then that’s enough for charges.
Oh, she's been charged. It's what will be allowed in court as evidence.
The defense is stating it was the morphine the hospital gave her that caused the baby’s death 🥺
@@user-bo1rj2xu2sNot much, HIPPA law is too strong 💪.
@@psweeneyville nope
@psweeneyville pretty sure the cause was asphyxiation.
Mom seems like the type to be more upset her daughter isn't a virgin anymore rather than the loss of the baby.
Sounds like a Kamala Walz voter
@@benjaminharrisiv650Lay off the news for a few days, bud
@@benjaminharrisiv650 you sound like a bot
@@slaphappybullet you sound like a democrat
@@benjaminharrisiv650total bot
This guy is trying to turn this into a woman’s rights case? She threw her baby in the trash.
It was full term. Born naturally. Some people like to turn activist instead of being honest. It's Fed up.
Right SMH 🙄
It’s utterly disgusting that, that is his angle.
This lawyer is demonic full Democrat
@@bustosbereniceikr . What about child rights? Smh cold world
Blaming the baby death on Morphine but hiding the body in the trash? She was stable enough to walk to the bathroom on her own. If nothing else she hid the baby's body. It's legal to detain a suspect pending investigation. Worrying about patient rights, but what about hiding a body?
Because it’s “just a baby” to these people. The mom is more upset about status than her grandchild being unalived by her own daughter.
Sadly, it seems like the defendants have more rights than victims these days.
@@Sweetmotion23actually, narcissists don’t even perceive others as humans. They perceive us as robots with flesh. Including their own kids and grand babies. We are like appliances that serve various needs for THEM, and if we can’t be useful to them, we are like a broken toaster… utterly useless and void of importance. That’s one reason why they’re so selfish and cruel. That teenage girls mother is a narc if I’ve ever seen one. At the very least she’s got excessive traits (including NO empathy).
Wouldn't that be tampering with evidence, putting the baby in the garbage...?
they asked her if she was pregnant and she said no she lied and she new she was getting morphine because when they give you a shot or anything they tell you what it is and you also have the right to ask what they are giving and she had the right to tell them she did not want the morphine knowing she was pregnant
She knew she was pregnant, I don't think she should be suing the hospital. Her fake tears don't work . The baby could have been saved if she told the truth in the first place.
Right .. she could have let them deliver the baby and gave it up for adoption
She felt that baby inside of her …
She's evil
Totally agree especially since she was taking a weight loss drug through the pregnancy to try to hide it. That stuff is def not for pregnant women either. How dare her take weight loss drugs that are a stimulant but then sue the hospital for trying to help her pain.
Anyone with any eyesight, even my old eyes, could see she was pregnant, in the cheerleading outfit especially. She knew 100%. She had to have thought about what she would do when it eventually popped out. She should be in jail and her over-bearing mom should accept her daughter is a killer
The fact that the baby was found in the trash is all the jury needs to hear. The Dr will testify to the facts.
Oh ya? You should be a lawyer 🙄
The question isn’t going to be whether she dumped the baby, she’s up diarrhoea drive on that front but whether it was still-born and whether there were mittigating factors that compelled to conceal the birth (whether still-born or not).
@@LittleMissStamperAs always, murderous females supporting each other.
My sentiments EXACTLY. Case CLOSED.
@@LittleMissStampertramp stamper, you probably scrapped out more babies with a clothes hanger than you have toes.
As soon as she went to the bathroom and they caught her cleaning up blood it’s a crime scene
Thanks for that educated , forensic analysis.
The doctor and nurses are mandated reporters. They were required to call the police for suspected child abuse. What about Abuse of a corpse?
Well said
Not the same thing at all.
Dead baby in trash, medical personnel not aware of cause. It was disposal of a baby. Illegal. Not staff responsibility to sort out.
@@catH727 exactly! Her attorney infuriates me.
The mother knew, I sow pics of the girl Sheirliding, and she looks very pregnant, I mean big bump in the stomach, and it was not from constipation
Children aren't trash, why is that so difficult to understand?
Terrible. She ADMITTED giving birth and that "nothing was crying".
When she came out of the bathroom with no baby, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out what happened.
She was alone with the baby in the bathroom.
WTH?
But when she admitted that the doctor was questioning. I think thats what they are taking advantage of because since is the doctor questioning that should be confidential. Its sad what she did to that baby but whats more sad is the really non of the doctors knew or thought she could be pregnant? And I think she acted like that because of the mom. Seams like her mom is controlling. She probably super scare of her, the way she was acting in the video
This country allows the killing of the unborn, a few minutes after birth doesn't matter.
Kamala voters dont have sympathy for the kids
@@Rodmariee There are a lot of holes in the case. Major missteps by the medical staff and the LEOs.
@@Rodmariee the doctors did know they took blood and did a test it was her that pushed and pushed to go to the bathroom that’s why they were banging on the door trying to get her out then saw the blood on the floor so. They did know and tried their best but she took it upon herself to discard this newly born beautiful alive child in a bin with a rubbish bin on top of it. Hiding it. She knew exactly what she did. There is no excuse.
Everybody's talking about Lexi's rights. What about the dead baby in the trash? What about his rights??? They are forgetting about the dead baby in the trash.
I bet "they" are not forgetting about the dead baby. He has ruled their lives since the day he died.
Just as we always see in America-when an unborn child or a newly born child becomes an inconvenience, its life means nothing.
@@womanofsteel9276 Wow. I'm sorry your impression of or experience in America has been so negative. As an American who has traveled around the world, I believe the United States is one of the most life affirming and encouraging countries in the world.
@@user-bo1rj2xu2s Now that Roe v Wade has been overturned, maybe that will be the case.
You don’t get to admonish me for having an opinion.
@@womanofsteel9276 I'm guessing you're not American and I'm sorry that your experiences here have been so negative. Though it's not perfect America is a pretty fair and hopeful place. I hope the same for you.
I still think she's cooked. She threw her newborn baby in the garbage, I don't think there's any coming back from that.
Happened in Hobbs, NM with Alexis Avila. NM sentenced her to 18 years in prison but she was out within months on appeal. NM is a ridiculous state.
She is as guilty as Sin and her mother. It wasn’t until I saw the police turn up at her house to arrest her. That’s when I saw another side to “The mother”
@@Cassius..
Was she home schooled and/or sheltered in her home
Many times these young girls are so naive and ignorant to consequences that they don’t even realize how, what or why they end up with this kind of situation.
Be kind to those who have never experienced it 👍
Post patrum insanaity, some new mothers try to even jump out of windows with the baby in their arms, and the staff wouldn't even be the wiser.
@@nanamanBlablabla, she knew how to fvck, she isn't naive ,so there's not need to be kind to a murderer.
Wow I can’t believe the amount of people are saying “ poor Lexi” she was 19 years old ffs
She wasn’t a child. She was a grown adult. She’s nothing but a monster.
Had my 1st baby at 19. While i hid my whole pregnancy, I didn’t throw my (premature) baby away! I became a mother. Period.
Sickening that's why they will continue to do this because of all the sympathy for the murderer
Doesn't matter. We all saw her and her phony mom already.
Luckily we have a constitution, a body of laws that the state must abide by. This would not be the first case that went south because of mishandling by LEOs and, in this case, health care workers. Not sure why you're angry with the grandmother.
@@user-bo1rj2xu2s how are the healthcare workers wrong??
@@user-bo1rj2xu2sfed
@@MaryJane-sq9xr Watch again and listen to what the doctor said and how she acted. Concern for Lexie but ignored her right to privacy under HIPAA. I bet this will end up with a plea deal and Lexie will do some time in prison.
@@user-bo1rj2xu2syou must not have watched videos with lexies mom..
When she said “nothing was crying” it absolutely broke my heart because it was a beautiful baby boy whose life she literally threw out.
That teenage girl is a legal adult.
@@Dawnmay-I-Say I KNOW, RiGhT!!! What gives?!? Calling a newborn infant NOTNING! Throw the book at her!!!
Total BS she made the hospital a crime scene. All she had to do is have staff get rid of Mom, she’s an adult, give birth, give baby up and deal with Mom later.
Yup, she sure made some poor decisions leading up to this day. The doctor made some poor decisions as did the LEO standing there.
The baby was stillborn. This is only a crime if you’re criminalizing women and girls for unsuccessful births.
Sounds easy & reasonable. I honestly can’t relate to anyone not showing while carrying, but I accept that it happens.
Thing is, we know nothing about her home life or how she came to be pregnant.
It’s a horrible thing, no doubt.
@@dddebz she was showing and in high school you know her friends were talking to her, it was obvious
@@dddebz She got pregnant by her boyfriend that goes to the same school as her. Her boyfriend and boyfriends mom were at the hospital, there is another video of them in the waiting room area and cops were asking them questions about what was going on. She knew she was pregnant, there are pics of her in her tight cheerleading uniform showing how small she looked before she was pregnant and then pics of her after the got pregnant. It was very obvious to see she was visibly pregnant.
This girl knew what she was doing.She was in a hospital, she could have asked for help and saved her baby.This lawyer talking about womens rights takes the biscuit
She took so long in there that they even started knocking on the door asking her if she was okay and they were about to break the door down before she came out like nothing was wrong. She's disgusting there is no excuse for what she did
your grandmas probably done it, think about it, a woman from the age before the invention of the condom, its private, ask your grandpa if your grandmas ever lied about being pregnant, he'd probably kill you, but it a fact
The woman. She was 18 years old.
@@Whatnok she was 19 actually
I really hope she doesn't get away with murder. She should be in jail waiting for trial. I honestly have no idea why she out on bail
Shes a murderer. She deserves to spend the rest of her life in prison. I hope they take no pity on her, she knew exactly what she did.
Idk how that lawyer sleep at night knowing that he's defending a child murderer
There's still a lot of evidence against her.
Exactly
Feels like a Casey Anthony situation
SHE KILLED HER BABY! Period!!!! She deserves life in prison.
Unbelievable!!! I hope the prosecution wins that appeal! She murderd that baby and lied about being pregnant. She belongs on prison
There is so much evidence. Medical staff testimony. The baby being found in the trash, is enough evidence. The jury should see her lying. This doesn't lose the case for the state.
@@amandamartin2777jury has to vote based on them thinking she intentionally killed her baby. If her defense is she the baby was born dead and didn’t want to get in trouble so hid the mess it’s a lessee crime
They don't need the statements to prosecute their case. Defense counsel is right that the case will have reaching consequences for women's rights if the police are allowed to violate the privilege or miranda.
They won’t
@@amandamartin2777regardless if the video evidence is suppressed, it’s still on the internet to see. I’ll be shocked if they go to jury trial and have a jury that hasn’t seen this.
SHE RAN TO THE BATHROOM INSTEAD OF TO THE DOCTORS OR PULL THE CORD ON THE SIDE OF THE 🚽 WTHECK.
I ve had a woman deliver a baby into the toilet, and just sit there, until she got someone to call an ambulance. They never got the newborn out of the cold toilet water until the ambulance arrived. BUT because Mom didnt disconnect the umblical cord, baby lived because it was still getting blood oxygen from mom. Baby was in poor shape, but no criminal charges because she just sat there like a lump. This little twit detached umblical cord and hid the babys body.
The nurse said it looked like a wild animal got ahold of the cord. It was all ragged and frayed, apparently. Wonder if she fricken chewed it off in there! Disgusting. Yeah. She did nothing wrong. Muh woman's rights 🙄
Exactly, like people have to understand that even if a woman “didn’t” know she was pregnant, once you deliver there’s no denying it. That’s a live, breathing human being. The levels of conscious choices one then has to make, like do we go to the hospital, do we alert doctors, or do I CUT the umbilical cord myself. And that’s literally what she did, she cut the umbilical cord, wrapped the baby in a plastic bag, and then proceeded to try to clean up the blood…and still withheld info on giving birth to medical staff until it was forced out of her. There’s no way this isn’t seen as premeditated. She knew exactly what she was doing.
The attorney saying his client did everything the doctor and nurses told her to do is disgusting. No one told her to run to the bathroom, give birth and toss a baby into the garbage. Jurors don’t need video evidence to understand what this evil adult woman has done to her newborn child.
Lexie didn’t know she was pregnant but she KNOWS the baby was stillborn? Give me a break Mister Old Shoe Lawyer. 🙄
When the texts amongst her friends come in, that’s gonna get blown up. She was apparently discussing the pregnancy and what she should name the child. Strange conversations to have if you don’t know you’re pregnant, I would think.
@@kaineandrews3790 she'll find at least one juror that nullifies based on her tears
@@LegendLength Oh, I agree. She’s not going to suffer any major consequences for any of this. But I’ll still have fun watching them shred her lies, at least as much as they’re allowed to.
Omg. Silent pregnancy exists! Why do you all hate women so!
That’s not what she said
He’s shocked that people don’t like baby killers?
Yes and moaning about how mean everyone is to Alexis - how about how 'mean' it was to wrap a newborn baby in plastic & put him in the garbage bin!
💯
What about the baby's rights .
@@agnesrobertson9099 Exactly! That baby had as much right to life as any of us whether that is you, me or the lawyer in the video and if she wrapped plastic around the head of any of us and threw us in the garbage it would have severe consequences. The consequences should be the same for what she has done to her own baby.
calling a fully term baby “nothing” is pure evil
Yeah it is
This country allows the killing of the unborn, a few minutes for them doesn't matter.
That is your interpretation of the context. I have a background in reproductive loss, she was emotionally distancing herself from a possible stillborn in the bathroom. A stillborn is an extremely horrifying process the expelling of fetal contents etc. I haven't seen evidence of anything else. I'm prolife.
As in none of the fetal contents were showing signs of life. It doesn't mean a bright healthy baby was plopped in the garbage.
Look at the parent daughter relationship between them. She hasn't been brought up properly. She doesn't seem pure evil, more completely lost. It doesn't excuse it, but pure evil? No way.
This goes to show you how corrupt our justice system is...pathetic. She needs life in prison without any possibility of parole
I like our constitution.
@@user-bo1rj2xu2sthat’s means your just lost in the head
Not allowing that video of her consultation with the doctor won't stop her getting convicted. There's really no significant evidence in there.
@@littlemandarren No, I really like our constitution.
JUSTICE FOR BABY ALEX How many times was that new mom gonna call Him NOTHING?;?
It infuriates me
I don't think that's what she meant by nothing. Her speech is a little strange. Listen again; she's a college student who uses double negatives on occasion.
Also called the baby IT
Who named him Alex
@@scottcharney1091stop making excuses for her she clearly said nothing was crying...
There is NO WAY anyone who looked at her in her cheerleader uniform didn't know she was pregnant! 🙄🙅♀️
🤔 But medical professionals at the hospital didn’t see it, and give her morphine for her back pain. Still sure of your strong opinion?
@@ahill4642was she wearing her cheerleader outfit at the hospital? No. She was wearing a big baggy jumper
@@ahill4642that doesn’t even make sense, did she wear a skin tight outfit? Or did she wear an XXXL sweater and refused for people to touch her? Your opinion couldn’t even be strong because it’s build up on false claims.
@@ahill4642They knew if she was pregnant that giving her a narcotic for pain is perfectly normal when a woman is in labor. They can’t do an epidural until a woman’s cervix is dilated at a minimal number. I think it’s at least 4cm.
@@ahill4642The hospital gave her what was safe to give a woman who “may” be pregnant as they very much did suspect she was and acted accordingly. Women in labour are given morphine, it’s not uncommon. I had major abdominal surgery while 24 weeks pregnant and had many different drugs before, during and after the surgery including general anaesthetic and morphine. My baby was fine. As far as the hospital “not noticing”, she came in wearing layers of big baggy clothing, refused an abdominal exam, declined to even lift up her clothing or allow them to examine her back. It’s a far cry from seeing her jumping around a basketball court in tight leotards day in and day out as her abdomen was growing. I believe her mother knew or at least strongly suspected she was pregnant, her responses seemed a little staged. She is an only child and her mother appeared quite controlling, surely she would have been suspicious she wasn’t having her period.
I hope this girl doesn’t get away with murder.
If the hospital staff had been doing their jobs she would have a beautiful baby right now. ER dropped the ball
She will, cus females always get away with everything.
@@Just_Peachy8777 in what way?
@@Just_Peachy8777 How is it the staff's fault?
@@Just_Peachy8777are u kidding 😅 it's hard to treat someone when someone locks themselves in a bathroom get real..she killed her baby on purpose ffs...
This lawyer is 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 "nothing sacred, anymore" yet his client killed her baby. 🤮🤮🤮🤮
He has to lie for his salary! This lawyer would try to prove that Charles Manson was a faithful churchgoer, who not even drove through the red light in his entire life.
@@ilmagnifico82 yep
This entire case is so sad. She didn't give anyone a chance to love on this baby.
It is sad.
Truly disgusting
Probably because her narcissistic mother never gave or taught her love. If you don’t receive it, you can’t give it.
Weird thing to say. Love on the baby? It was a human being not a thing to be "loved on" just so odd to say it like that. But ok 🙄
@@kateashby3066 Oh...you know this family?
With a mom and grandmom like that.... that baby wasn't meant for this world.
Sad as it is, I think you're right! Poor baby.
I'd give ANYTHING to have another child,and she threw her perfect baby boy in the garbage. I will NEVER feel sorry for her 💯
II have no idea why you're angry at the Grandmother.
@@user-bo1rj2xu2s😅your comment is concerning. watch the video again and see how her mother reacted. also, listen to the part when the mother brings up “what did i say about this” (aka it seems like she told her “killing her child is bad”)
@@user-bo1rj2xu2s She referred to the baby as "it" with a manner of disgust and contempt. Makes it very suspicious that she manipulated the daughter into killing the baby. Why would such a young girl do something so sudden an sinister. Look at the grandmom.
They don't need this video...she did it..and deserves punishment
Oh, she'll be punished.
I can't stand her or her mother. Calling this a woman's issue is an insult to decent women who would never dream of doing someone so heinous.
Why can't you stand the Grandmother? I don't get it.
Have you seen the footage of the mom defending the daughter and acting shocked that she's getting in legal trouble for it
I despise this girl.
Also, her lawyer is delusional.
I can't stand him so creepy
Him saying how she’s alone because people on campus had a petition to get her to leave lmfaooooo like SIR… that should tell you people aren’t being harsh, she did something 98% of people wouldn’t do and is rightfully getting criticized for it
Yeah but her lawyer wears cowboy jackets, cowboy shirts, and cowboy boots in court. Doesn’t that count for something? 🥴🙃
What other approach do you suggest her lawyer take to get his client the lightest sentence possible? Because she has the right to a lawyer, so someone has to do it.
@Jaykun09 Oh you are right, there always has to be a Devils advocate.
This is not about women's rights! It is about murder! This lawyer should be ashamed of winning on a technicality
All of us want Doctors and LEOs to act according to the law, at all times. Them not doing so has complicated this case. They no better. Lexie's attorney is doing the right thing.
And that's why you're not a lawyer. Because it really will set a precedent for police to have access to your medical information without a warrant. She may have done it. But police broke the law. If they aren't held accountable they will only do more.
"This is certainly a women's rights issue."
No, it's not. It's a "girl gave birth and threw the baby in the trash" issue. And to say that the mother shouldn't have been in the room, presumably because it waives the privilege, and then seconds later say that the mom being in the room didn't matter? It either does or it doesn't. You can't have it both ways
He didn’t say the mother being in the room didn’t matter he said she should have been asked by the medical staff to leave. His job is to point as much blame away from his client and towards the hospital.
the attorney was just talking in circles the entire time, it genuinely made me laugh
So angry...she should be in prison, she out and out MURDERED her baby!!!!!!!!
Don't be angry. It affects no one but yourself.
The act of placing a baby into a sealed bag into a bin is the crime here, regardless of anything else
and put another bin bag over the top. If I remember rightly she has taken the bag out, got a clean one from the bottom (cleaners often put extra clean bags under the one in use, it saves carrying them around), put the baby in the clean one, put it in the bottom and put the used one on top.
If I've remembered that correctly from what the cleaner said, then she can't even really claim she was panicking, there's rather a lot of thought went into that.
I’m sure the jury will know what to do.
Yes
Exactly.
This lawyer has taken defending his client to an extreme, making delusional claims by attempting to frame a murder case as a women's rights issue. It's evident that he has no understanding of women's rights or the realities of childbirth. He should be disbarred for trying to equate throwing a baby in the trash with a miscarriage. Have you ever heard of a mother having a miscarriage and then discarding her baby like trash? There's a significant difference between a miscarriage and suffocating a newborn.
Women miscarrying in the toilet and flushing it is common, but at the early stages. A full term birth that is born dead is a stillborn, not a miscarriage.
@@nlwilson4892stillborn or not, you don’t dump a full term baby in the trash and walk out of the bathroom like nothing happened.
Typical democrat....I'm sure he is all for terminating a pregnancy at term. Disgusting!! She killed her baby and left it in the trash!!
I agree... I can't believe he just compared a miscarriage with murder...
@@letterpresslady If he was a public defender he'd be advising her to plead guilty, blame the oppressive mother for demanding nothing but perfection from her and show loads of remorse.
But he's being paid by the mother. I think he is banking on one women on the jury having had a miscarriage and being distraught and not knowing what to do, and hoping their emotions will get in the way of recognizing the difference between their own experience and what happened here.
On the other hand he might not care about the client at all and it only in it for the money. I think there is a market for lawyers that will take on the no-hope-very rich cases, it makes rich criminals hire them.
Win?!? No ones wins... this is a terrible title. Poor baby.
Absolutely💯true. Both are 😈
It's a win for the defense for sure. Not for the baby or justice.
Oh it's a win for her
No punishment, and she's pregnant with her next victim rn
@Jessica094 wait wait she's pregnant?!
Agreed. I'd have preferred the word "prevails."
I hope the prosecution wins the appeal. I don’t think HIPA was meant to protect someone from murder. Also, suing the hospital for causing the babies death? The autopsy, if I remember right, reported the lungs showed a breath was taken. The defense lawyer is trying to make this case about something other than his clients actions. Disgusting
I cringe every time I hear her say, “nothing was crying” 😬🙄🙄🙄
It doesn’t matter , everyone in NM already seen the video and know what she’s said and done . The autopsy showed baby was born alive
She medical care on the other side of the door. She chose not to save her baby.
That lawyer is sickening, & shame on the judge for going along with him & agreeing to conceal evidence that would bring justice for that poor innocent baby. Disgusting!
That's disgusting.
The teenager, her mom and the lawyer are all equally disgusting. And yes, I'm also stunned how vicious people are - unlike the lawyer, I'm referring to the teen who dumped her newborn to trash.
The Grandmother? Why are you angry at her? The lawyer is just doing his job.
@@user-bo1rj2xu2s I agree defense is just doing his job. But I also think it was a bad ruling,(which happens. Judges are not infallible) so glad to hear the prosecutor is appealing. It might get overturned on appeal.
@@jgray690 This very emotional case is in it very early stages. I believe she'll take a plea and spend sometime in prison.
19 is an adult
@@user-bo1rj2xu2s Where did I mention grandmother?
Its just the video not being used, there are witnesses, sadly witnesses to the babys body in the trash,witnesses who led her to the bathroom also,
I think I remember staff saying it was super traumatizing for them, I hope they get to testify how disgusting this was
She knew, her mom knew. She, along with her mother, was told that her pregnancy test was positive a full hour before she ran to the bathroom - and they both denied it right to the doctor's face! AND she walked to the bathroom all by herself - nobody "led" her!!
Don’t forget there was a trail of blood. The police had a right to investigate where the trail started and ended .
@@mariannaatrash9410Yes!!! The interviews of the medical staff as well as the cleaning lady, was very heartbreaking!!
@@truecrimeuncensoredShe's done with their testimony alone. Everyone is getting so upset about this one video not being allowed. Although it would be even better to have, they have enough without it.
She didn’t do anything wrong? Is this lawyer delusional? She may have went to the hospital, but did she ask for help when she was delivering!? NO!!! She hid that baby in the trash!!! She deserves to rot in prison!
This is ridiculous!!! People are too soft now a days. This girl is guilty and she should be in jail for life. What kind of person does this to a BABY!!!!??? What a terrible person. Me and my husband are trying to find a baby to adopt, there are so many beautiful couples who would love to take a baby like that! It’s sad that this should even be a trial at all.
This defense attorney is sick. She killed her baby that was born alive.
Amazing. I've never met a person with clairvoyance skills before!
How do you know that? She was in a hospital, and they didn't know she was delivering a baby? The hospital fail bad in this situation.
Everyone deserves a defence…they are just doing their job. Doesn’t mean they personally agree with what they are saying.
no mention of putting the baby in the trash from her lawyer she could have called for help but didn't no mention of that either
Bad ruling. Her mom knew too “I told you about this”. Bad ruling. The cops were there too, where’s the privilege? I’m glad prosecutors are appealing the rule.
Well, if they wanted to try the Mom as an accessory, that statement on video wouldn't be privileged.
I don’t think her mom knew…her saying I told you about this was her going off of a hunch. She felt like her daughter was lying about being pregnant and everyone knows eventually, you can’t hide it, the baby will come…she was telling her that she can’t keep hiding it and if she had any sick ideas of trying to give birth and continuing to hide it, it would catch up with her.
And that’s the exact truth.
@@missym877 If the mother even suspected then she should have informed the doctors as soon as they got to hospital.
I have know of women that got pregnant and either didn't know or hid it from others, but they were all of a bigger build where it didn't show much. It is possible that the mother didn't know but I doubt there's evidence either way.
However, the main point I was making is that only the patient and medical professionals would be covered by privilege, not the mother.
I agree it was a bad ruling because she was 18. So saying other people(like mom) being in the room didn't wave her privilege seems like a bad call. If she was a minor, I think the defense would have a sound argument for violating her right to privacy. (because you have to have a parent/legal guardian present if you're minor.) But because she was 18, I think it doesn't apply. I'm hoping the supreme court overturns this judge's ruling.
@@jgray690 The right to privacy isn't violated by a person of your choice being there. There are plenty of instances where someone wants someone else there with them during a consultation, such as if they're getting bad news, or the other person needs to understand the condition because they need to care for them.
But there is no evidential value in this video at all. It won't affect the ability of the DA to prosecute.
BS she needs to go to prison
Agreed.
Democrats disagree
@@benjaminharrisiv650FACTS‼️👁️
@@benjaminharrisiv650 disagree on what?
this is an absolute failure of society and the justice system. May that baby rest.
She needs to rot in jail!
You do
@@LeneeLenee I didn't murder my baby and throw it in the trash like garbage. I didn't lie to medical staff and my mother about being a virgin.
@@Studio190creations Were you in the bathroom with her or something? You have some insider knowledge??
She should pay 100 percent guilty!! She knows what a baby is and where they come from!!! She was just trying to hide her truth!!!!
Pay?
Child abuse is not covered by doctor-patient privilege!
This wasn't child abuse as defined by our law.
@@user-bo1rj2xu2syour right it’s murder, which is still not covered by doctor patient privilege
@@LisaFW HIPAA is quite specific and the Dr. is very aware of how it works. It's not "doctor patient privilege." Dr. messed up. As to whether or not this is adjudicated as murder is to be determined in the legal process. I bet there will be a plea deal and she'll serve some time.
She literally DUMPED THE BABY IN A TRASHCAN. How is she NOT guilty of murder?? She deserves life with no parole.
Because broke privilege laws
This is crazy.
She claims that it was born dead. It's a matter of reasonable doubt.
@@scottcharney1091 Autopsy showed the baby was born alive and was suffocated.
@@scottcharney1091she still treated the baby with indignity in death by throwing it in the garbage
What a shame. She murdered her newborn son in cold blood. There should be no "wins" in, or out, of Court. Pure Evil.
WWJD?
@@user-bo1rj2xu2s well, we know He wouldn't have killed the baby...
@@CatholicHousewife2017 How would he have treated the sinner?
We don’t know she murdered the baby. Could have been stillborn.
@@ahill4642 if you don't know that then you've not kept up with the case.
The autopsy showed the baby's lungs were working & he was breathing until his face was wrapped up & smothered in plastic bag and then placed in another bag under the bag of trash in the bathroom garbage bin.
As a 19 yr old adult, this Mom chose to murder her son & then tried to hide him from being discovered so she wouldn't be caught.
She then came out of the bathroom & never once admitted to having just given birth - nor until after they found her dead baby at which point she referred to him as "Nothing" repeatedly.
The Death Penalty would be justice as she murdered a totally innocent infant & Life in Prison without Parole would be a great Mercy - anything less would be a massive disgrace & injustice.
Every infant & child in society needs to be protected from this dangerous child murderer.
Disgusting, her son had a right to life, there is absolutely no excuse and she should not be shown an ounce of mercy
Her confusing isnt a big deal give it to her. They have the before and after bathroom video. They have people saying they knew she was pregnant. They have photos of her pregnant. She deserves to be in jail forever.!
Agree
The issue is her defense is that the baby was dead when born. Vs her killing her own baby
Huh? That first sentence makes no sense
Yeah, she was definitely pregnant for 9 whole months and had no idea she was pregnant.
The ocean is also made of blue raspberry flavored jello.
😂right! If u ever been pregnant even half term you definitely know! There's something moving inside of you. She was a 5ft petite cheerleader everyone knew she was pregnant
It happens. Just saying. Also, even the hospital staff didn’t look at her and say “she’s pregnant”, they gave her morphine for back pain!
@@ahill4642 because she came in with baggy clothes, to conceal her pregnant state.
🤣🤣
@@ahill4642you need to stop defending her under every comment, that’s weird. She knew, even the teachers at her school knew. If you read the reports everyone knew besides her mother because she was scared. So she offed the baby who was definitely alive and well. Imagine defending someone who would save their reputation over a life. Pathetic
I am glad I am not the only one that thought wtf how is that a win
KAMALA HARRIS voters think it is
She went to the hospital where she had the privilege of a private conversation with medical staff to say what was going on. She was in the perfect place to get help and protection from her mother. She continued to lie. Its a two way street here.
She was in the perfect place to get help giving birth safely, to get help keeping her Mother out of the room, to get help from a social worker to deal with not wanting to be a mother and placing the baby in foster care, to get help telling her Mother that she had a baby. It was the perfect place. That she did none of those things tells me she was frightened and immature. I bet she'll be offered a plea deal and she'll take it, serve some time and then go on with her life. Hopefully, she'll also get some therapy so that she leads a long, happy and productive life.
@@user-bo1rj2xu2s exactly. Why didn't she just reach out to the staff and the lies could have ended with a beautiful baby. It bothers me what her mother said about already telling her about these things. Had she suspected something. I get the feeling she was very controlling woman.
@@effinhellfire her mom absolutely knew that Alexee was pregnant just didn't know she was full term already
The defense is arguing rights vs murder. The child had no ability of self defense.
So what about the autopsy stating the baby showed evidence of suffocation and the death was ruled as a homocide. And if she has no reason to be guilty, why did she hide the body?
The attorney also lost me when he claimed that administration of NaCl (which is saline) played a part in the loss of the baby. I received like 3 liters of IV saline when I had my son.. this whole case and situation makes my brain bleed.
Because the legal system is lenient and agreeing to all this makes it harder for her to get off Scott free
Will they be able to show pics and videos of her cheerleading with that huge pregnancy belly?
I was thinking the same thing cuz don't they go to like all the games practices pep rallies in front of the entire school? I'm sure there's plenty more evidence
yeah, but the hospital didn’t even catch it, they gave her morphine for back pain!
@@ahill4642 she had already stopped her birth control and been taking diet pills before they ever tried to relieve her pain. And just so you're aware, a lot of women get epidural to deal with labor pains, and the baby was born alive before she concealed it and placed it in a garbage bag. And she removed the cord so nothing the hospital did was negligent.
@@ahill4642women are commonly given opiates for pain during labour. Thats hardly the thing that should be the focus. They also asked her and she lied about it, and when they ran their tests, it confirmed their suspicions. Everything that happened was due to the patient’s choices.
Her friends could testify to her being pregnant if it was common knowledge as it’s been said
No, no Mr. Gary, this has nothing to do with women’s reproductive rights, stop it🙄. Your client failed to protect her baby and wrapped him in a plastic bag, threw him in the garbage and concealed baby Alex under trash so no one could see him and consequently, Alex died, your client did that, a whole grown up woman did that! I was 12 when I became pregnant; the moment my sweet baby boy was born my life’s mission was to love and protect him and that is what I’m doing to this day. Your selfish client did not care about her baby so she got rid of him and she needs to face consequences!
Wow, kudos to you. My great-aunt got pregnant at 13, so she could marry her boyfriend, had 3 more children, and stayed married to the same man until he died. She was a wonderful mother.
@@NovemberRain007 Don't you think that this young woman's outright fear of her controlling and demanding mother played a part in her decision to do what she did? You could see how frightened of her mother's disapproval she was. The exact same thing happened to Brooke Skylar Richardson. She was also a cheerleader and her mother was obsessed with keeping her daughter thin. She would count her calories and criticise her if she ate something her mother didn't approve of. Brooke only ever wanted her mother's approval so when she got pregnant at 16, she hid it from her. Just like this girl did. Brooke gave birth in her ensuite bathroom and later claimed the baby was born dead. She tried to bury the baby in the back yard of her house. The truth eventually came out and she was charged with "involuntary manslaughter", but was only found guilty of "abuse of a corpse" and got three years probation, which was ended early. Whichever lawyer is going to defend this girl they'll more than likely compare her case to Brooke Richardson's. If BR got off with probation, that's a precedent. Her lawyer may say this case is just like the previous one, so therefore she should only be given probation too. There are important differences between the two cases and what this girl did was more egregious because her baby was proven to be born alive. With Brooke they couldn't determine whether the baby was born alive or dead because the body had decomposed quite a bit when they found it. But either way, I really don't know if this girl will pay a huge price for what she did.
Wtf it can‘t be used? W t f???
The only thing privileged in that room is that brat daughter who threw her child away like a used tissue
Just because her mother was in there, they won’t prosecution this.
Crazy.
I hope most of the people in the jury will know about this case and stay quiet that they know..
@@stacyn.No, actually her mother being there is a reason to lift the medical privilege (as the girl is an adult). If her mother wasn’t there it would definitely be privileged. Now it’s up to the NM Supreme Court to rule on whether the mother’s presence is enough to lift the privilege and therefore to admit the video as a piece of evidence.
bruh she put her baby, dead or not. in a HOSPITAL TRASHCAN. why are we arguing semantics?!
Unfortunately that's what lawyers do
@@LoRosa0224 I just don't get why the state is bothering to spend time fighting it. Leave it and move to trial
Whether she knew or didn't know she was pregnant, or whether the baby was a live at birth, the bottom line is she threw the baby in the garbage and lied about giving birth.
Yup, she lied about giving birth. The court system will have to handle this.
"Nothing was crying." is going to follow her for the rest of her life
Dont have the right to throw you baby in the trash and sufficate it
Miscarriage is one thing, murder is a whole other issue Gary.
She smothered her baby. Autopsy report shows this.
Her classmates CLAIM she already had her babies name, how did she know it was a boy ???
Alex is a unisex name. Could work for a girl too.
If she wins, that means the baby loses. Oh, yeah, he already lost...his life. 😥
😭
She’ll have to live with it forever so that in itself is torture.. trying to convince yourself that everything is okay is a full time job filled with stress so either way she loses
The hospital where Alexee was treated was a "safe sanctuary" facility. She could have delivered the baby & no questions asked handed it to any hospital employee & they would have turned it over to Child Protective Services. For foster care-adoption.
she had so many options. That she didn't take advantage of those options is stunning.
You know that baby was alive
No. We don't. You assume, but you don't know. No one does but her.
@@ick.zostedyes we know the baby was alive he took breaths till she put him in plastic bag...
Some babies don’t cry whej they come out… so it may also mean maybe she did think it was dead… but she should have taken it to a doctor immediately. She hid it and that’s literally tampering with evidence and a corpse.
@@ick.zostedyes we do from the autopsy report that baby had been breathing
@@ick.zosted We do know! The autopsy shows there was air in the lungs, so the baby was born alive.
The doctor brought in cops BECAUSE THIS GIRL KILLED HER BABY AND THREW IT IN THE DAMN TRASH!!!!
The only thing she was thinking about was herself! They don’t need the video she literally delivered put him in the trash, tied the bag put a clean bag over it.. than attempted to clean up for the delivery….murder what is there to debate!
This man is the reason lawyers are despised
I hope the State supreme court overturns but if not, I'm sure the prosecution will still win despite the exclusion of this evidence. And to the attorney - your client murdered a baby. That is VICIOUS. Murdering a baby is "not a part of life." 😡
The Prosecution seem’s just as sick as the rest of them.
Aww she named him nothing
He came out and nothing was crying"
1:23 when mom says “ Lexi I told you about this “ means they’ve had conversations about this ? How is this not premeditated then ? Mom had warned her and told her how others had gone to jail for this ….
This is an interesting point. There's probably alot more to this.
I’ve always wondered why no one has mentioned this before.
I don’t think that’s true at all! Just because they have had a conversation about …. Lying? Do we even know what she is talking about? Nope nope nope
Not necessarily. Still, it looks bad.
@@jayterra2060yes the mother said iv told u about this girls go to jail over this...
I wish the Dr didn't interrupt so soon when the mom asked "what did you do to IT ?"
RIGHT
This lawyer is something else. "Well known" at destroying lives all around him. Great guy
I was raised by my dad who was the worst “tiger parent”. I was terrified to do anything. I still would have never done what Alexee did.
Its odd as to how she refers to the baby as "nothing" and "it".
It doesnt matter, she might have won this battle but her and her fake mother will without a doubt lose the war, their both LIARS and she murdered her own unborn child! Justice will prevail 😢
unless they get the same jurors that let caysee anthony free, i don`t think we have to worry. THIS B IS GOING DOWN
The mom saying... "I just told you about this!" Is all the proof that they both knew she was pregnant!
This case makes me sick!
Wasn't the autopsy confirming that the baby took a breath? It was not still born