The Stolen Children of Timor-Leste | Foreign Correspondent

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 тра 2024
  • Born in Timor, raised in Indonesia, a group of East Timorese stolen during wartime is now returning home. But will reunion with long lost family heal old wounds? This is a moving story about the power of blood and memory.
    ‘It's a way to break a family, break a person, break a society by taking their most loved members.’ Human rights worker.
    At the age of 8, Alis Sumiaputra was plucked from the streets of his village in Timor-Leste by an Indonesian soldier and taken to West Java.
    The soldier adopted the stolen child into his family, converted Alis to Islam and changed his name. Eventually, Alis took over the family farm. His Timorese family was never mentioned. Until, in 2019, a woman called Nina came looking for him.
    Like Alis, Nina Pinto was stolen from Timor-Leste as a child. She was abused by the soldier who took her and treated like a servant by his family.
    “All I could do was cry. I longed for my family. But I couldn’t do anything. I was helpless”, says Nina.
    At age 17, she ran away and later managed to reunite with her Timorese family. Now she’s helping people like Alis connect with their birth families.
    Nina and Alis are among an estimated 4000 Timorese children who were ‘stolen’ from their homeland after Indonesia occupied Timor-Leste in 1975.
    In the early chaotic days of the invasion, the soldiers took the children opportunistically. Later, children were taken as part of a state-sponsored mission by Indonesia to educate and ‘civilise’.
    “Maybe in the beginning, there was a feeling of trying to save children who were perhaps separated from their families’, says Galuh Wandita from the NGO, Asia Justice and Rights (AJAR). “Later on, there were religious institutions that were involved.”
    AJAR is now tracking down Timor’s ‘stolen children’ and helping reunite them with their birth families.
    In a powerful and moving journey, Indonesian correspondent Anne Barker follows Alis and a group of Timor-born adults as they return to their country of birth to reunite with their families.
    For Alis, there is pain, guilt, joy and an awakening.
    At his parents’ graveside in his village, Alis, whose birth name is Kalistru, bows his head and weeps.
    "My dear father. My dear mother. When you died, I wasn’t here. I am your son, Kalistru Momode, asking for forgiveness.”
    “This was one of the most moving stories I've ever covered. The moment we landed at Dili Airport I had a lump in my throat as I watched the emotion of those 'stolen children' on board who were returning to their homeland for the first time in decades. I only hope that thousands more will have the same chance that Alis and Nina have had.” Anne Barker, the ABC’s Indonesia correspondent
    Subscribe to ABC News In-depth: / abcnewsindepth
    For breaking and trending news, subscribe to ABC News on UA-cam: ab.co/1svxLVE
    Connect with Foreign Correspondent:
    Like Foreign on Facebook: / abcforeigncorrespondent
    Follow Foreign on Twitter: / foreignofficial
    About Foreign Correspondent:
    Foreign Correspondent is the prime-time international public affairs program on Australia's national broadcaster, ABC-TV. We produce half-hour duration in-depth reports for broadcast across the ABC's television channels and digital platforms. Since 1992, our teams have journeyed to more than 170 countries to report on war, natural calamity and social and political upheaval - through the eyes of the people at the heart of it all.
    CHAPTERS
    0:00 Introduction
    1:40 Alis’s Story
    5:22 Nina’s Story
    8:26 Leaving Home
    10:22 AJAR and Memories
    15:33 The Journey and Reunion
    17:46 Alis’s Reunion
    22:55 Home and Healing
    28:13 What’s Left
    Contributions may be removed if they violate ABC’s Online Terms of Use www.abc.net.au/conditions.htm (Section 3). This is an official Australian Broadcasting Corporation UA-cam channel

КОМЕНТАРІ • 164

  • @agusahadi2451
    @agusahadi2451 3 роки тому +31

    Sedih 😭😭,,, smg ini mjd pelajaran buat kita semua,, hidup jgn mengambil hak org lain,, belajar berusaha hidup bahagia berdampingan walau berbeda,, smg Indonesia & Timor Leste bisa terus bergandeng tangan dlm kebaikan,,, salam dari jawa timur🥰🙏

    • @didikerianto3569
      @didikerianto3569 3 роки тому

      Sedih tidak tau artinya😭

    • @josecarmo6156
      @josecarmo6156 2 роки тому

      maaf biginilah hidup kami hilang sanak keluarga entah dimana mungkin udah meninggal mungkin jg belum tergantung pada waktu !! byk sekali org indonesia maaf membenci kenapa kalian mimilih merdeka dan sekarang kalian miskin. bagi kami mau miskin atau kaya kami hidup ditanah kami biarlah masa yg berlalu tinggalh sejarah namun masih ada rasa benci tapi sulit utk menjelaskan ! byk org indonesia yg cuma melihat akan sisi pemerintah indonesia kala itu yg hanya focus akan pembangunan Timor timur itu betul tapi diwaktu yg sama pembunuhan , penculikan terus dilakukan TNI !! kalian tdk disepatu kami kalau kalian di sepatu kami pasti kalian akan melawan !! bagaimanapun jg sejarah tinggalah kenangan meri kita hidup bergandengan tangan !! Viva Timor Leste , viva Indonesia

    • @sabarmanullang621
      @sabarmanullang621 8 місяців тому

      Hak apa yang diambil Indonesia dari Timor-Timur? batu koral, kerikil atau jagung kering?

  • @blomen1977
    @blomen1977 3 роки тому +19

    This is very emotional to watch. I do hope more people will be reunited.

  • @dwisunaryati2308
    @dwisunaryati2308 3 роки тому +11

    For the Timor Leste people, we are so sorry about what the orba did to you. This reconciliation may bring your forgiveness for us. This is only what we can do.

    • @johnfreitas8094
      @johnfreitas8094 3 роки тому +6

      Salam kak dari Timor Leste. Ketika saya baca komentar kaka saya terharu sekali tapi, ya itulah hasil dari peperangan dan politik para elit waktu itu. Jadi Kita semua adalah korban, terus terang ya saya dulu benci sekali sama TNI karena keluarga saya banyak yg mati di tangan mereka. Tapi saya rasa sudalah yang berlalu sdhlah berlalu, sebab Tuhan lah yang berhak untuk menhakimi semua manusia. Doa saya, semoga kedua negara ini bisa maju dan sejahtera tampa mengunkit masa lalu untuk membangun masa depan yang baik. Salam damai dari Timor Leste untuk saudara tetanga kami Indonesia 😥❤🙏

    • @evafernandes4005
      @evafernandes4005 2 роки тому

      Kita rakyat kecil jadi korban politik.

  • @erinconstable1159
    @erinconstable1159 3 роки тому +4

    A beautiful story, I love the focus on reuniting, rather than the atrocities the Timorese have already experienced!

  • @Fun_Humor97
    @Fun_Humor97 7 днів тому

    It's really sad and joyful when all stolen children may reunites with their own families. I thank you for those who has made a great efforts to realize the dreams of those children to be reunited with their own biological families. I pray that one day all stolen children may back to Timor-Leste and together we develop this beautiful and tiny country.

  • @domingosleqsi5914
    @domingosleqsi5914 3 роки тому +11

    Emotionally captivating... hopefully other stolen ones out there in search of their loved ones can be reunited with their family soon... thanks AJAR; thanks ABC 🙏🏻

  • @worlduniverse9726
    @worlduniverse9726 3 роки тому +12

    Gw setuju aneksasi taun 1975 itu salah, dan gw senang timur leste udah merdeka sekarang, dgn merdekanya Timor leste setidaknya NTT bisa diurus dan lebih maju dibanding timor leste saat ini, tapi itu NGO dan reporternya bias, terlalu ngejelekin Indonesia padahal aneksasi tahun 1975 tuh disponsori australia juga yg skrg ngebiayain NGO ini, ironi banget, terus itu pak alis yg hidupnya sudah senang dikatakan harus pake healing juga, gak salah? asalnya senang malah jadi trauma itu pak alis, bukan healing namanya tapi dehealing

    • @yusufbakhtiar3080
      @yusufbakhtiar3080 3 роки тому +6

      Ini media autralia dia sengaja bahas masalah ini untuk mengalihkan isu minyak di celah timor yang selama ini hasilnya banyak di nikmati Australia

  • @TammieHanenburg
    @TammieHanenburg 3 роки тому +7

    My heart is So broken for these & all of Timorese people! I am very good friends with the Guesmao family! Yet this is another part of this painful story I hadn't even known had existed! Until now! I can only pray that all the families of these kidnapped children, have the to find their loved one's! I can't imagion the year's they have all spent not knowing what ever happened to them. Please Keep bringing them home! My heart & prayers remain with you!

  • @wandajones4063
    @wandajones4063 3 роки тому +5

    War is terrible!

  • @obeng48
    @obeng48 3 роки тому +7

    the narration is too made up. the reality is not like that. Mr.Alis lived happily in my village. it proved he was back here. and did not choose to go home to Timor Leste.

  • @konamishinuri3745
    @konamishinuri3745 3 роки тому +8

    Hah ini mang alis? Satu desa sama aku dri tasikmalaya.. dia orgnya baik klo ada prtandingan volly d turnamen 17 agustus dia yg suka jdi wasitnya.. semoga sehat sllu mang😍

    • @Kanggalon561
      @Kanggalon561 3 роки тому

      Di tasikan nya ?

    • @Kanggalon561
      @Kanggalon561 3 роки тому

      Tos uih deui acan ? Tepat na di desa naon ?

    • @konamishinuri3745
      @konamishinuri3745 3 роки тому

      Ats ayna mh.. kp. Pasir peuteuy desa tnjung karang

    • @bety.suhartini
      @bety.suhartini 2 місяці тому

      ada kang yang terpisah juga di karawang sama di bandung, mereka punya darah asli timur tapi udh sunda medok .

  • @yuksustore3065
    @yuksustore3065 3 роки тому +15

    Kisah kelam negaraku, mohon maaf kepada seluruh rakyat Timor Leste. Salam perdamaian Indonesia-Timur Leste

    • @kosakata8632
      @kosakata8632 3 роки тому

      that their own fault do revolt

    • @LOARAI
      @LOARAI 3 роки тому +2

      Tidak. Itu karena perang dan Kita tidak saling membenci. Yang berlalu sudahlah kita lalui dan kita saling memaafkan dan fokus ke masa depan yang lebih baik. Salam dari timorleste

    • @trisemito6538
      @trisemito6538 3 роки тому +3

      @@LOARAI walau sudah beda negara kita tetap saudara banyak kenangan di timles waktu masih kecil

    • @johnfreitas8094
      @johnfreitas8094 3 роки тому +1

      Salam kak dari Timor Leste. Ketika saya baca komentar kaka, saya terharu sekali tapi, ya itulah hasil dari peperangan dan politik para elit waktu itu. Jadi Kita semua adalah korban, terus terang ya saya dulu benci sekali sama TNI karena keluarga saya banyak yg mati di tangan mereka. Tapi saya rasa sudalah yang berlalu sdhlah berlalu, sebab Tuhan lah yang berhak untuk menhakimi semua manusia. Doa saya, semoga kedua negara ini bisa maju dan sejahtera tampa mengunkit masa lalu untuk membangun masa depan yang baik. Salam damai dari Timor Leste untuk saudara tetanga kami Indonesia 😥❤🙏

    • @felitsaadinda2516
      @felitsaadinda2516 3 роки тому

      Kalian itu rakyat timles 1 ras 1 saudara 1 pulau dengan NTT tapi kalian merasa berbeda hanya karena beda jajahan. Harusnya kalian bangga dengan negara NKRI seperti NTT mereka merasa besar merasa kuat merasa bangga memiliki tanah air sebesar ini seberagam ini sebebas ini. Meskipun banyak orang indonesia tidak setuju tapi saya berharap timles bisa kembali lagi ke negara NKRI, Kesusahan kebutuhan hidup dan pembangunan sangat lambat. Tanah kering, minyak dikuasai australia. Yg kaya hanya pejabat saja. Warga harus impor kebutuhan dari indonesia dan negara lain. Ini memperumit masalah yg harusnya tidak boleh serumit ini. Kalau jerman barat dan jerman timur saja yg dulunya juga berpisah sekarang bisa kembali. Kenapa kita tidak? Sejarah biar menjadi pelajaran tentang pahitnya perang saudara dan perpisahan

  • @nurnur-qo5sx
    @nurnur-qo5sx 3 роки тому +16

    I'm waiting for abc to do documentary about Australia stealing east Timor oil

    • @micki9541
      @micki9541 2 роки тому

      LMAO 😂😅😂

    • @mobster6340
      @mobster6340 2 роки тому +1

      they have - its called Secrets Spies & Trials and its by four corners

  • @sabarmanullang621
    @sabarmanullang621 8 місяців тому +1

    Nobody stole children from East Timor. They were taken and treated in Indonesia. Can't you see what condition they were in on the video when they returned to Timor Leste? No one looks thin and suffering.

  • @jodavey7709
    @jodavey7709 3 роки тому +4

    An amazing story 😪

  • @yosepier
    @yosepier 3 роки тому +2

    Mr Ali has a happy family now. Get a better life Indonesia. How can he was stolen? He was saved by Indonesian army.

    • @DB-lp9db
      @DB-lp9db 3 роки тому +3

      Did you even feel what his parents felt when their lost their kid? He was kidnapped, for sure. He has family in TL

    • @yosepier
      @yosepier 3 роки тому +1

      @@DB-lp9db Timor was at war. Bombing & Shooting was everywhere. Ali's eldest sister said in the video, at that moment many people was not thinking of other people. Later on their family didn't angry with him (the soldier) who took Ali because the soldier raised Ali like his own son.

    • @evafernandes7489
      @evafernandes7489 Рік тому +1

      Alis bahagia tapi banyak yang menderita.

  • @amorsemlimite4427
    @amorsemlimite4427 3 роки тому +2

    It is a true story and based on the reality.

  • @egymenez4809
    @egymenez4809 3 роки тому

    Obrigado

  • @bsb0284
    @bsb0284 3 роки тому +1

    Semoga sehat km paman salam satu desa satu kabupaten satu kecamatan🙏

  • @kevinli940
    @kevinli940 3 роки тому

    where is the latest video of foreign correspond? Is it banned by UA-cam?

  • @romli6323
    @romli6323 3 роки тому +4

    Sedih.. generasi kami bahkan tak tahu kalau ada kejadian seperti ini di Timor Leste semasa perang dulu.

  • @marwundykaigere129
    @marwundykaigere129 3 роки тому +6

    ❤❤❤ from papua

  • @cmarq817
    @cmarq817 3 роки тому

    Crying ...

  • @junaedison
    @junaedison 3 роки тому +3

    Very emotional. Leaving wife to East Timor. I can feel what Alis feels. I'm from West Java.

  • @rizalalkautsar2839
    @rizalalkautsar2839 3 роки тому +2

    Mang alis dari Cigalontang kab tasikmalaya

  • @alicelim1419
    @alicelim1419 3 роки тому +21

    Australia and its allies have successfully separated Timor Leste from Indonesia, Australia has been able to mine oil and now Timor Leste is the poorest country in the world no156, mission succes 👍love from bali

    • @dwisunaryati2308
      @dwisunaryati2308 3 роки тому +3

      That's a sad fact. That's something we are afraid of when Papua is separated from Indonesia.

    • @TopanSopandi
      @TopanSopandi 3 роки тому +1

      Setuju.. Paling bisa emang dia, Sekarang bikin video seolah indonesia betul-betul bersalah..
      Ini tidak akan terjadi jiga ausi dan port tidak merebut wilayah yang pada waktu itu jelas wilayah indonesia. Lihatlah papua , lihatlah wilayah indonesia yang lain, Pemudanya kuliah di jawa dan pulau lain indonesia dan kembali ke papua mebangun daerah agar lebih maju. Bukan dengan cara melepaskan wilayah dan mendirikan negara baru. Blunder dari video ini adalah, ketika orang yang di bawa keindonesia lebih makmur kehidupannya dibanding dengan keluarganya yang stagnan. Sayang sekali propaganda video anda tidak berhasil. Australia sebaiknya urusi negara anda yang akan di kuasai Cina.

    • @s21b0b
      @s21b0b 3 роки тому +1

      Australia pendukung operasi penyerbuan Timor Leste. Ingat, adu domba itu bisa saja dilakukan oleh orang2 berkuasa, mau dari dalam ataupun diluar. Pemikiran kalian harus bisa lebih dalam lagi dari itu. Yang diinginkan Australia itu kan sumber daya, caranya ya bisa saja dengan apapun. Salah satunya dan yg lebih awal adalah yang saya sebut di paling atas tadi.

    • @s21b0b
      @s21b0b 3 роки тому

      @@TopanSopandi itu TIDAK AKAN PERNAH TERJADI KALAU INDONESIA STAY PUT DARI PERMASALAHAN TIMOR LESTE!!!

  • @farajhumairoalkabirfiijima1645
    @farajhumairoalkabirfiijima1645 3 роки тому +3

    Saya bermimpi suatu saat indonesia tidak perlu ada hubungan apapun lagi dengan australia, cukuplah sebagai tetangga saja tanpa ada diplomasi apapun....semoga saja

  • @arisriswana6327
    @arisriswana6327 3 роки тому

    sehatt selalu mang aliss.. saya tau mang alis ko

  • @warmwelkom
    @warmwelkom Місяць тому

    ✨🙏✨

  • @Abcd-if5ut
    @Abcd-if5ut 3 роки тому

    😭😭😭😭

  • @fren183
    @fren183 3 роки тому +8

    They learnt this from australia - look up australia's stolen generation

  • @CanadairCL44
    @CanadairCL44 3 роки тому +3

    I've got dust in my eyes.

  • @cosmgasm1037
    @cosmgasm1037 3 роки тому +7

    Thank you australia, you really make indonesia look like a villain, and you are the "oil stealing" hero

    • @DB-lp9db
      @DB-lp9db 3 роки тому +2

      Don't forget about what's happening in Papua since 1960s thanks to the smiling generak

    • @mcaskil
      @mcaskil 2 роки тому +1

      don't forget indonesia is occupied east timor and annex it

  • @RajorrrOfficial
    @RajorrrOfficial 3 роки тому

    Anak nya cakep

  • @josephbee9628
    @josephbee9628 3 роки тому +1

    Are Aljazeera and ABC shares a same content?

  • @Itsmehjhgs
    @Itsmehjhgs 3 роки тому +10

    Biased. focusing only with negative statemens. 🇵🇭

    • @culturedman1310
      @culturedman1310 3 роки тому +1

      I don't think so they we're showing the positive side too like Mr alis story

  • @roberts8783
    @roberts8783 3 роки тому +5

    who's the journalist ? I'd like to follow more Indonesian speaking foreign correspondents like this

  • @kentallard8852
    @kentallard8852 3 роки тому +2

    Hey Gareth hows that 'responsibility 2 protect' working out?

  • @f.s.firdaus8106
    @f.s.firdaus8106 Рік тому

    East Timorese to Indonesia:
    “you stole my children.”
    East Timorese to Australia:
    “YOU STOLE MY OIL!”

  • @rendisukarnoputra7325
    @rendisukarnoputra7325 3 роки тому +2

    guys, kunci dari terjadinya timor leste itu adalah provokator, maka dari itu alangkah baik nya kita sekolah yang tinggi dan mari kita bersama sama membangun negeri, mungkin kalau timor timur masih di nkri sekarang udah jadi tempat para wisatawan seperti pulau komodo, labuan bajo

    • @s21b0b
      @s21b0b 3 роки тому +5

      Jaga NKRI itu dengan cara mempertahankan teritori negara, bukan dengan cara mengurangi dan apalagi menambah daerah secara paksa.

    • @catholoc
      @catholoc 3 роки тому +2

      Ng Ada provocator!! Kemerdekaan adalah hak segala bangsa !! Cuma ente ng meresakan pahit hidup dlm otoriter soeharto dimana keluarga kita yg dibunuh entah dimana makam mereka !! Apakah ente Ada pengalaman begitu ? Jadi biarlah kami menjalani hidup kami dgn berbagai macam masalah tp kami yakin suatu hari kami akan menjadi negara yg layaknya negara lain !!

  • @nightrobber1
    @nightrobber1 3 роки тому +3

    Doesn't sound like he was forcefully taken to Jakarta

  • @indolirik2207
    @indolirik2207 3 роки тому +10

    *Media Australia biasa propaganda*

    • @catholoc
      @catholoc 3 роки тому +1

      Propaganda apa ini fakatnya udah jelas disana . Kamu buta atau ng ??

    • @Worldly_Pitfall3
      @Worldly_Pitfall3 Рік тому

      @@catholoc no because the whole intention of australia was to mine the oils establishing East Timor as an independent nation was the cover up

  • @agatanakonieczny2213
    @agatanakonieczny2213 3 роки тому +5

    I wonder why you don't allow comments under your manipulative material about Poland "A new crusade"? Not to be challenged?

    • @abcddef2112
      @abcddef2112 3 роки тому

      Agreed, Ive seen this as well. Almost all video about Indonesian controversies are allowed when it hits too close to home they banned comments.

  • @kopralbambang9120
    @kopralbambang9120 3 роки тому

    Lukanya berasa di gw

  • @jagoanpembelakebenaran1574
    @jagoanpembelakebenaran1574 3 роки тому +2

    TL : where is our oil and gas now?.........
    Australia : Interfet is not a bunch of unemployment, they need milks/cheese/eggs/bread and ofcourse sallary to
    ooo....
    Australia : Sorry Neighbors "There is no such thing as free lunch" .
    ABC : We can even make it more dramatcally, and organize our Non Government Organization
    Australia : good job pal

    • @catholoc
      @catholoc 3 роки тому

      Let’s us deal with it and we trusted our leaders to solve it !! Before you start commenting please mind your freeport which is still US influenced!!

  • @kabeyuda9547
    @kabeyuda9547 3 роки тому +3

    lebih baik lepas dari indonesia agar Timoer Leste impor selamanya ke indonesia dari sembako, minyak sawit, ternak, kendaraan dll sehingga semua produk indonesia laku...thanks Timoer Leste belilah produk made in indonesia...👍👍👍

  • @Azzz591
    @Azzz591 3 роки тому +3

    Tambah hancur sekarang, timmur Leste perang saudara, gedung pun tak ada yg dibangun

    • @catholoc
      @catholoc 3 роки тому +2

      Hatimu kyk hewan ng Ada rasa utk menilai org !! Biar mereka jalanin hidup mereka !! Kemerdekaan adalah hak segala bangsa !! Munafik ya indonesia jg masih byk yg miskin !!

  • @ethanlennon6112
    @ethanlennon6112 3 роки тому +4

    What is this Gotong Royong

    • @epic-zc3oo
      @epic-zc3oo 3 роки тому +2

      Working together in solidarity

  • @dwisunaryati2308
    @dwisunaryati2308 3 роки тому +2

    Along Orba time, the army (TNI AD) ruled Indonesia and persecuted the native of Papua people, the native of Dayak and the native of Timor Leste. Now the politic has been changed. The army doesn't rulle Indonesia anymore.

  • @sennopatiallen
    @sennopatiallen 3 роки тому

    Great story reunite with the family. I hope in the near future this land reunite again with Indonesia and ignore false promise from neighbor country that want to steal their oils

  • @amorsemlimite4427
    @amorsemlimite4427 3 роки тому +1

    It is based on the reality 👍

  • @sennopatiallen
    @sennopatiallen 3 роки тому

    You can do comparison, How devastated the country of Iraq after being attacked by the US and Australia. Timor leste far better because the previous Indonesia regime has develop the people there

    • @Worldly_Pitfall3
      @Worldly_Pitfall3 Рік тому

      Still pretty bad especially since my mom got shot in the stomach and my dad in the leg when saving her

  • @grvldix
    @grvldix 3 роки тому

    Arminius

  • @TopanSopandi
    @TopanSopandi 3 роки тому +5

    Kompeni emang paling Bisa, bikin video seolah indonesia betul-betul bersalah..
    Ini tidak akan terjadi jiga ausi dan port tidak merebut wilayah yang pada waktu itu jelas wilayah indonesia. Lihatlah papua , lihatlah wilayah indonesia yang lain, Pemudanya kuliah di jawa dan pulau lain indonesia dan kembali ke papua mebangun daerah agar lebih maju. Bukan dengan cara melepaskan wilayah dan mendirikan negara baru. Blunder dari video ini adalah, ketika orang yang di bawa keindonesia lebih makmur kehidupannya dibanding dengan keluarganya yang stagnan. Sayang sekali propaganda video anda tidak berhasil. Australia sebaiknya urusi negara anda yang akan di kuasai Cina.

    • @DB-lp9db
      @DB-lp9db 3 роки тому +1

      Susah2 kuliah di Jawa, eh gak taunya tanahnya udah dijual ke perusahaan aseng

  • @nadianad1756
    @nadianad1756 3 роки тому

    Aaaaaaaaaaaaaa sp yg naro bawang😭

  • @iinkomaria7271
    @iinkomaria7271 2 роки тому +1

    Mugia mang Alis sehat dn panjang umur dn slalu bahagia salam kanggo klg mang Alis di Tasikmalaya mudah"an klg di Timles tiasa sumping keklg ditasikmalaya...

  • @user-ob7hn3ue2r
    @user-ob7hn3ue2r 5 місяців тому

    Kasian ya korban propaganda australia 😂😂😂😂

  • @warmwelkom
    @warmwelkom Місяць тому

    11:29

  • @AgusRiyanto-me8lf
    @AgusRiyanto-me8lf 3 роки тому +2

    Tidak perlu ada yang disalahkan....mereka korban perang, niat baik mwngangkat harkat dan martabat bangsa Timor setelah penjajah Potugis tidak bertanggung jawab berakhir dengan tidak bahagia. Sebagai WNI saya tidak bisa menyalahkan negara saya atas invasi ke Timor Timur. Kebijakan Mandala dan Geo politik, menyatukan rakyat 1 pulau Nusa tenggara itu yang mendasari invasi itu. Semoga bangsa Timor bisa segera bangkit dari keterpurukan....fokus negara kami sekarang memakmurkan rakyat NTT.

    • @amorsemlimite4427
      @amorsemlimite4427 3 роки тому

      Kebijakan Mandala dan Geo Politik? Sangat salah langkah

    • @s21b0b
      @s21b0b 3 роки тому +1

      Ingat, itu masih di zaman Perang Dingin. Pengaruh ideologi sangat kuat pada zaman itu.

  • @didikerianto3569
    @didikerianto3569 3 роки тому +1

    Sedih tidak tau artinya 😭

    • @mcaskil
      @mcaskil 2 роки тому +1

      gak besa basa engres

  • @prayudawc
    @prayudawc 3 роки тому +10

    Saya pribadi meminta maaf pada semua saudara di Timor Leste 🙏

    • @kosakata8632
      @kosakata8632 3 роки тому +4

      ngapain minta maaf mereka yg bikin revolusi, mereka juga masi eprang sesama timor elste selama 10th ga ada yg minta maaf

    • @reidycfr102
      @reidycfr102 3 роки тому +3

      @@kosakata8632 SAMPAH OTAK RASIS

    • @indolirik2207
      @indolirik2207 3 роки тому

      @@reidycfr102 hey km nie Orang luar yg bisa bahasa indonesia, ya

    • @reidycfr102
      @reidycfr102 3 роки тому +2

      @@indolirik2207 Emang knape? Bukan urusan mu

    • @gusviantonugraha7250
      @gusviantonugraha7250 3 роки тому +3

      Belanda aja minta maaf sama Indonesia, ya mungkin Indonesia jg hrsnya minta maaf secara ga langsung aneksasi sama aja penjajahan secara halus

  • @reidycfr102
    @reidycfr102 3 роки тому +2

    Watak Kolonial Indonesia terlihat jelas disini 😢

  • @TheHayato5555
    @TheHayato5555 3 роки тому +3

    Thanks god they were brought and been adopted by Indonesian people. Now, they have better lives and financials in Indonesia. Knowing that Timor Leste now become one of the poorest country in the world and many of them demand to reunite with Indonesia again make us sad.

    • @amorsemlimite4427
      @amorsemlimite4427 3 роки тому +2

      Don't spread hoax 😂

    • @s21b0b
      @s21b0b 3 роки тому +2

      Make peace, no war. Make love, no hate.

    • @mieaab
      @mieaab 2 роки тому

      Better than under Portuguese rule. Worse than slaves

    • @AshTrizey
      @AshTrizey 4 місяці тому

      Well one family was good and the other sexually abused the poor girl. But even the good family didn't have the right to steal someone else's child.

  • @kosakata8632
    @kosakata8632 3 роки тому +3

    Stolen? 3:25 they go voluntary
    If you stolen why you not go back home 20yrs ago, border always open and no visa required
    Who block them back home is pro independence group, they will accuse them as indonesian militia

    • @efronberlian
      @efronberlian 3 роки тому +7

      Think before you comment. They don't know where they were taken from. They were kids when they were taken.
      It is not voluntary if they are tricked into volunteering to go. Again, they were kids.

    • @kosakata8632
      @kosakata8632 3 роки тому +1

      @@efronberlian think again, indonesian - TL border always open for 20yrs. What make him wait so long?
      The answer is simple civil war for 10yrs (stupid INTERFET failed to mainain peace) and extreme poverty, if his family have no connection to fretilin party, he has no future in timor leste.

    • @efronberlian
      @efronberlian 3 роки тому +5

      @@kosakata8632 you ignored the problem that they don't know where they were taken from. Even if they come back there is a big chance that he'll just spend a lot of money and time and still not find their family.
      Also who do you think created the problem in the first place? Indonesia is the one who annexed Timor Timur in the first place. Then they take children from there, why are you defending kidnappers?

    • @kosakata8632
      @kosakata8632 3 роки тому +1

      @@efronberlian Did you know who's indonesia supporter for this invasion? the suppoerter are US, AU, netherlands, south korea and taiwan for communism reason
      Did you realized UN approve this annexation? check again did your your country againts this invasion? you too naive dude XD

    • @efronberlian
      @efronberlian 3 роки тому

      @@kosakata8632 United nations never approved of Indonesia's Annexation of Timor Leste. What are you talking about?

  • @lindawarnke5150
    @lindawarnke5150 3 роки тому

    Isn't that exactly what the the united nations going to do with the fema camps? Once again we the people are playing into their hand all over the world!

  • @andylai-fz6uc
    @andylai-fz6uc 3 роки тому

    hopefully they can also get away from Islam.

  • @arisriswana6327
    @arisriswana6327 3 роки тому

    sehatt selalu mang aliss.. saya tau mang alis ko