В Дубае, действительно, причина другая: там частные компании становятся спонсорами метрополитена, и станции называют в честь этих компаний. Потом, как платить перестают, переименовывают.
@@MrVildan >как платить перестают. Нет, договор заключается на определенное время, например, последний контракт был заключен на 3 года, а уже после истечения срока арендатор может продлить его
Dubai needs to hurry up with expanding their metro. The city is still practically impossible to get around with the metro alone. Unlike cities like Tokyo, Singapore, or NYC.
Dear, compare the age of Dubai and how old is Tokyo and NYC. Dubai did great and they are moving forward in rapid speed already, that no body else could handle. It will be there, just be patient. Those cities you mentioned, got all their metro lines not in 10 nor 20 years... much more.
@@Idrisbroker And Singapore? They got their metro lines in 20 to 30 years. The UAE was founded in 1971 50 years ago and only Dubai has a metro. It's embarrassing.
@@Idrisbroker And NYC and Tokyo built their transit lines as the technology came to be. Dubai and the rest of the UAE have the benefit of hindsight, and they STILL built their cities around cars instead of planning for mass transit when the UAE got founded. Now Abu Dhabi is struggling to create a metro because the island's infrastructure doesn't allow it. Just drive through Abu Dhabi's new areas. All roads. Not even a tram, or space for future metro tracks. The new tram they announced is just an XL-sized bus. And Dubai is building more roads and bridges instead of metro tracks. So what if other cities took decades and decades to built their metros? Dubai's slogan is nothing is impossible and yet we're stuck with the same metro line from 10 years ago. Clearly it's impossible for them to build decent mass transit.
Epic or not depends on how long it takes to finish the plan. If it's going to finish in a year, of course it is. If it's in 5 years, ok, not bad. If it's in 10 years, what a shit! If you look Guangzhou subway future plan, they are planning to add 148 stations by 2023, that's in 3 years.
Not really... I mean, Dubai is putting itself forward as a playground for the rich. This is more of a statement then anything else. Dubai is very much a car centric city and I really don't see that changing any time soon. Since it is all desert, there's no reason to.
Вернулся в ноябре из Дубая, некоторые станции переименовали)) Но привыкаешь быстро. Жаль в Шарджу метро пока не планируют, а пробки утром и вечером страшные((
Привет Живой Огурец спасибо огромное тебе за новый ролик . Поздравляю тебя с наступающим новым годом и Рождеством Христовым желаю тебе крепкого здоровья всего самого наилучшего . каналу желаю процветания чтобы новые подписчики прибывали . тебе также желаю вдохновения для съёмок новых роликов .
Great video. Very ambitious plan, but it won't happen in real life. I used to live next to Al Furjan Metro, and watched it being built from my living room window. The Red Line Extension shown at 2:09 was build especially for Expo 2020. Outside of that, the new line does not have a high demand. I doubt it is breaking even right now. If the Al Maktoum Airport extension plan is complete, the only extra bit of the Metro that can be justified is the extension from Expo 2020 to the airport. Other than that, Blue, Green extension, purple, pink, yellow, goes to areas that are not tourist heavy. Yes, it'll be great for the people who live there (like me with Al Furjan), but this is not where the big expat money is; they live elsewhere. Judging from a lot of abandoned projects I have seen in Dubai, they cannot justify building the Metro extension until the world economy goes back up to match its heyday.... which won't happen.
Jvc and barsha on the purple line is crazy crowded now. Huge traffic jams to get in and out . Also Sharjah and international city are pretty crowded so blue line would see heavy use as well. Makhtoum airport will also get bigger once palm jebel Ali opens up so all lines connecting there will see heavy use from people living and working in Dubai . There will also be cheaper accommodations built then budget travelers will come if the cheaper places are connected by metro to tourist hotspots. So it makes perfect sense to complete these lines
This is great I do hope that they should first convince expant to say here in the UAE, minimize the rent and do business so that they can sustain the money for the construction of these. Dubai has only 3 milion compared to other major city which is about 20.millii.
The future plan seems to be the 2040 plan. That still is 18 years aways and a lot will change until then. And even if they build all those lines, the network will still be small for a city of that size.
My Suggested List of Future Dubai or UAE Metro Projects: Note: Most Stations will be Infill or Provisional Since Metro Lines Pass-Thru Future Development Areas 1. Dubai Metro Red Line Extension to Abu Dhabi (Stations: Jabel Ali South, Al Maktoum Airport Street, Jabel Ali Industrial Park, Legoland Dubai, Action Park, Hassyan, Mafraq, Al Fayah Rd, Ghantoot, Ghantoot Marina, Unnamed Station #1, Al Faqa' Rd, Khalifa Industrial City, Al Smeeh, Zirarah Street, Al Yal Street, Al Falahiya, Al Rahba, Abu Mreikhah, Al Aryaf St, This is Where Red Metro Line will Separate Between Abu Dhabi Downtown Line and Extension to Border of UAE, Al Shahama, Abu Dhabi International Airport, Al Rahah, Al Razeen, Al Nakhlah Street, Khalifa Park, Ministries Complex, Mangrove One, Al Kheeran, Sector E-38, Dolphin Park, Al Nahyan Park, Delma Park, Hazza ' Bin Zayed The First Street, Al Falah Street, Al Ain Street, Hamdan Street, Downtown Abu Dhabi, Al Hisn Street, First Abu Dhabi Bank, Al Boom Park, Al Marsa Street, Grand Hyatt Abu Dhabi, Ministry of Presidential Affairs, and Qasr Al Watan) 2. Dubai Metro Red Line Extension to UAE Border (Stations: Al Aryaf Street, 4th Street, Unnamed Station #1, Unnamed Station #2, Unnamed Station #3, Al Reef, Abu Dhabi International Airport Terminal 3, Al Reeman, Al Jazira, Al Shawamekh, Mafraq Mall, Jarn Yafour, Al Bihouth, Unnamed Station #4, Unnamed Station #5, Hameem, Unnamed Station #6, Unnamed Station #7, Jumaniath Exchange, Al Sahil Rd, Hamamah Rd, Unnamed Station #8, Al Faisal, Tarif, Unnamed Station #9, Unnamed Station #10, Unnamed Station #11, Qassar Al Mighayra Street, Al Marfa, Al Mirfa, and More Stations Until It Reaches Al Ghuwaifat Terminus.
@metrocucumber . Very nice video about the current state and potential future of the metro at Dubai. Now, since the recent annoucement by Dubai Gouvernment, your blue line in this video, is not anymore the blue line planned by the gouvernment of Dubai. If you could update it , it would be amazing.
Shanghai metro today has 700km of subway Dubai less than 100. Where is the competition? Dubai is something like the 40th longest metro system in the world.
@@LeoNicola_lnljix Ну и? В отличие от Москвы Дубай 50 лет назад был деревушкой без исторических зданий, не в счет форт, плюс я уверен что там планы быстро воплотят в реальность, так как денег реально вложивают куда надо и не воруют как в Москве, тем более огромная часть города это пустыня а хотят превратить это в зеленые оазисы с дорогами и домами
@@красныйлис-е1и Ну и?? Сейчас очень много часных компаний строят себе небоскрёбы,так что бесполезно даже сравивать. В мск тоже очень быстро строится метро (сравни хотя бы с остальной Россией.)
Yes it is confusing like al safa before it was noor back but they always post these naming on social media for all poeple to know. Company's pays sum amount of money to change the name of metro station
My telegram - t.me/metrocucumbers
Качество роликов растёт с каждым новым роликом. Ты большой молодец)
Каждые 60 секунд в Африке проходит минута
@@alinguae ауф☝️🐺
Каждую неделю на Гаваях проходит 168 часов
@@antuank2110 каждые сутки в Эфиопии проходит 24 часа
А еще у нас возмущаются, когда станции переименовывают...
Но там переименовывают по другим причинам.
@@красныйлис-е1и везде переименовывают по одним и тем же причинам, уж поверь.
В Дубае, действительно, причина другая: там частные компании становятся спонсорами метрополитена, и станции называют в честь этих компаний. Потом, как платить перестают, переименовывают.
@@MrVildan >как платить перестают.
Нет, договор заключается на определенное время, например, последний контракт был заключен на 3 года, а уже после истечения срока арендатор может продлить его
Не знаю, мне лично пофиг на переименования станций метро. Никогда это не задевало.
Dubai needs to hurry up with expanding their metro. The city is still practically impossible to get around with the metro alone. Unlike cities like Tokyo, Singapore, or NYC.
i agree
Dear, compare the age of Dubai and how old is Tokyo and NYC. Dubai did great and they are moving forward in rapid speed already, that no body else could handle. It will be there, just be patient. Those cities you mentioned, got all their metro lines not in 10 nor 20 years... much more.
@@Idrisbroker And Singapore? They got their metro lines in 20 to 30 years. The UAE was founded in 1971 50 years ago and only Dubai has a metro. It's embarrassing.
@@Idrisbroker And NYC and Tokyo built their transit lines as the technology came to be. Dubai and the rest of the UAE have the benefit of hindsight, and they STILL built their cities around cars instead of planning for mass transit when the UAE got founded. Now Abu Dhabi is struggling to create a metro because the island's infrastructure doesn't allow it.
Just drive through Abu Dhabi's new areas. All roads. Not even a tram, or space for future metro tracks.
The new tram they announced is just an XL-sized bus.
And Dubai is building more roads and bridges instead of metro tracks.
So what if other cities took decades and decades to built their metros? Dubai's slogan is nothing is impossible and yet we're stuck with the same metro line from 10 years ago.
Clearly it's impossible for them to build decent mass transit.
Moscow
C 2021 годом!
Спасибо!
Great video, MetroCucumber! I lived in Dubai for 6 years (2014 - '20) and I witnessed some of those changes.
Well done, the animation.
Anyone else finding the future part absolutely epic?
Those who lived in Dubai can understand that..Literally, every nook and corner of the present city will be connected by metro .
Epic or not depends on how long it takes to finish the plan. If it's going to finish in a year, of course it is. If it's in 5 years, ok, not bad. If it's in 10 years, what a shit! If you look Guangzhou subway future plan, they are planning to add 148 stations by 2023, that's in 3 years.
No, because they won't build that. They already planned these lines like 7 years ago and the construction haven't even started...
Not really... I mean, Dubai is putting itself forward as a playground for the rich. This is more of a statement then anything else. Dubai is very much a car centric city and I really don't see that changing any time soon. Since it is all desert, there's no reason to.
Then you have to video about chinese cities
Вернулся в ноябре из Дубая, некоторые станции переименовали)) Но привыкаешь быстро. Жаль в Шарджу метро пока не планируют, а пробки утром и вечером страшные((
Привет Живой Огурец спасибо огромное тебе за новый ролик . Поздравляю тебя с наступающим новым годом и Рождеством Христовым желаю тебе крепкого здоровья всего самого наилучшего . каналу желаю процветания чтобы новые подписчики прибывали . тебе также желаю вдохновения для съёмок новых роликов .
Метро в Дубае: ну, вроде всё понятно
Метро в Москве: втф, че за лабиринт?
Круто! Ты супер! Сделай метро в Баку, пожалуйста! 🙏🙏🙏
Да.
Сделай видео по Баку
Очень добротное и хорошее видео. Сделай схему развития Омского метро, интересно посмотреть на развитие и перспективу развития.
Ага,с одной станцией
👍😂🤣😂🤣
They seem to really like wasting money on changing metro station names
Companies pay a price for naming privilege such as naming a station near the companie's like the companies name station
That’s not wasting. In fact they get investment by doing that. All the expenses they incur in changing the name will be borne by the sponsor.
@Dash Thiago shut up
@Dash Thiago shut up
@Khalid Sage shut up
Can you make a tutorial on how you made this using Adobe after effects?
Как всегда топ!
Как появлялись линии метро Дубая.
Линия 1 - 2009.
Линия 2 - 2011.
Great video! Looks like a well connected system
It really isn't, there are SO MANY flaws with it, believe me
Классная графика, так гораздо нагляднее где что поменялось.
Great video. Very ambitious plan, but it won't happen in real life. I used to live next to Al Furjan Metro, and watched it being built from my living room window.
The Red Line Extension shown at 2:09 was build especially for Expo 2020. Outside of that, the new line does not have a high demand. I doubt it is breaking even right now.
If the Al Maktoum Airport extension plan is complete, the only extra bit of the Metro that can be justified is the extension from Expo 2020 to the airport. Other than that, Blue, Green extension, purple, pink, yellow, goes to areas that are not tourist heavy. Yes, it'll be great for the people who live there (like me with Al Furjan), but this is not where the big expat money is; they live elsewhere.
Judging from a lot of abandoned projects I have seen in Dubai, they cannot justify building the Metro extension until the world economy goes back up to match its heyday.... which won't happen.
Jvc and barsha on the purple line is crazy crowded now. Huge traffic jams to get in and out . Also Sharjah and international city are pretty crowded so blue line would see heavy use as well. Makhtoum airport will also get bigger once palm jebel Ali opens up so all lines connecting there will see heavy use from people living and working in Dubai . There will also be cheaper accommodations built then budget travelers will come if the cheaper places are connected by metro to tourist hotspots. So it makes perfect sense to complete these lines
Amazing animation. Can you do Delhi Metro next??? PLEASE
Интересно, сколько часов ты наиграл в Mini Metro?)
Не 5 часов как минимум
This is great I do hope that they should first convince expant to say here in the UAE, minimize the rent and do business so that they can sustain the money for the construction of these. Dubai has only 3 milion compared to other major city which is about 20.millii.
Привет Живой огурец! Поздравляю тебя с наступающим 2021 году! Желаю тебе самого наилучшего, хорошего настроения и много позитива👍
И 100000 подписчиков к 2022
En mexico tenemos el mexibus
They should extend metro to Sharjah border. Ideal location can be sahara centre
Интересно, а почему в 2018 году перекрыли станцию Jabal Ali?
Опять ютуб лагает
Видео вышло 1 минуту назад,комменты-2 минуты назад
Прикольная схема,кстати
Не могли бы вы сделать эволюцию метро Куала-Лумпура?
Сингапура за одно
Как же я хочу снова поехать в Дубай!
Шикарно!!! Всё лучше и лучше!
MetroCucumder сделай пожалуйста развитие метро в Варшаве
Там очень красивое метро и скоро построятся новые станции
Спасибо за ролик , ещё 101 причина поехать в Дубай.
Я был в Дубае! Моя станция была:Dubai Marina.
The future plan seems to be the 2040 plan. That still is 18 years aways and a lot will change until then. And even if they build all those lines, the network will still be small for a city of that size.
Thanks for the video, appreciated 👍
My Suggested List of Future Dubai or UAE Metro Projects:
Note: Most Stations will be Infill or Provisional Since Metro Lines Pass-Thru Future Development Areas
1. Dubai Metro Red Line Extension to Abu Dhabi (Stations: Jabel Ali South, Al Maktoum Airport Street, Jabel Ali Industrial Park, Legoland Dubai, Action Park, Hassyan, Mafraq, Al Fayah Rd, Ghantoot, Ghantoot Marina, Unnamed Station #1, Al Faqa' Rd, Khalifa Industrial City, Al Smeeh, Zirarah Street, Al Yal Street, Al Falahiya, Al Rahba, Abu Mreikhah, Al Aryaf St, This is Where Red Metro Line will Separate Between Abu Dhabi Downtown Line and Extension to Border of UAE, Al Shahama, Abu Dhabi International Airport, Al Rahah, Al Razeen, Al Nakhlah Street, Khalifa Park, Ministries Complex, Mangrove One, Al Kheeran, Sector E-38, Dolphin Park, Al Nahyan Park, Delma Park, Hazza ' Bin Zayed The First Street, Al Falah Street, Al Ain Street, Hamdan Street, Downtown Abu Dhabi, Al Hisn Street, First Abu Dhabi Bank, Al Boom Park, Al Marsa Street, Grand Hyatt Abu Dhabi, Ministry of Presidential Affairs, and Qasr Al Watan)
2. Dubai Metro Red Line Extension to UAE Border (Stations: Al Aryaf Street, 4th Street, Unnamed Station #1, Unnamed Station #2, Unnamed Station #3, Al Reef, Abu Dhabi International Airport Terminal 3, Al Reeman, Al Jazira, Al Shawamekh, Mafraq Mall, Jarn Yafour, Al Bihouth, Unnamed Station #4, Unnamed Station #5, Hameem, Unnamed Station #6, Unnamed Station #7, Jumaniath Exchange, Al Sahil Rd, Hamamah Rd, Unnamed Station #8, Al Faisal, Tarif, Unnamed Station #9, Unnamed Station #10, Unnamed Station #11, Qassar Al Mighayra Street, Al Marfa, Al Mirfa, and More Stations Until It Reaches Al Ghuwaifat Terminus.
what is the bgm? Is So Good!
С Новым 2021 Годом!!!!!.
Спасибо большое! Я там целых два года жил
Seems quite like a lot of stations with little distance between one another, like constant stop and go, no?
No, the distances between stations are HUGE. Riding from one end of red line to another will take you more than an hour
@@trjvd ok. Then the animation is just not displaying it good :).
@@michailkulaga1809 that's at least like that in any major metro system
@metrocucumber . Very nice video about the current state and potential future of the metro at Dubai. Now, since the recent annoucement by Dubai Gouvernment, your blue line in this video, is not anymore the blue line planned by the gouvernment of Dubai. If you could update it , it would be amazing.
Я поздровляю тебя 2021 годом.
Почему так КРУТО?
Потому что надземное будет.
@@красныйлис-е1и он не о метро, успокойся
@@nosokcat2429 а о чем тогда?
@@красныйлис-е1и он об анимации
can you try Hong Kong?please?
This is real a very good plan of Dubai metro in future
Insha Allah it will be set on
О, вы из Англии?
Sir next video on delhi metro pls
Nice
Тоооооп
Классное у шейхов метро
what program do you use to draw the lines??
I use Adobe After Effects.
Сделай пожалуйста видео развития метро: Пекина, Шанхая, Лондона, Парижа, Нью-Йорка, Дели, Сеула и Токио
много
Ну наконец-то достойный конкуррент метро Нью-Йорка и Москвы)
Отличный ролик, так держать!
Ничего он не достойный. В Дубае "через много лет" будет 197 станций. В мск счас 331. Почуствуй разницу,так сказать
Shanghai metro today has 700km of subway Dubai less than 100. Where is the competition? Dubai is something like the 40th longest metro system in the world.
It is epic!
Развитие Дубайского Метро
Bro u should do the future thing with every metro system evolution animation.
От станции Jabal Ali до Expo 2020 идёт отдельная линия от основной красной
The future is gonna be HUGE... I just know it
Cant wait
Good one. But is this the real master plan ?
Yeah
R. I. P. Живой Огурец
MetroCucumber: Настало моё время!
(Если честно, новое название канала мне больше нравится)
Опа, не ну это класс!)
Dubai spent more time changing names of the stations than building them
Looks like it are sponsorships to fund the stations, given the company names.
Please do cairo, tehran and istanbul
Hai, love Russia from India. Do video for indian metros as well.
This is Dubai not Russia. Dubai is in th United Arab Emirates.
@@user-ym7eh8pi5i the channel is russian
@@user-ym7eh8pi5i I live in dubai, the channel is from russia.
Ну это уровень. Кстати сегодня утром всё таки получиось догодаться что будет именно Дубай
How did Dubai construct metro? Changing names.
А можно сингапурское метро?
I remember seeing it built when I was younger...
Днепр в студию! Хоть там делать и немного, но посмотреть хочется
Ты хочешь ради 6 станций отдельное видео???
(Вот видео про нынешнее положение метро Днепра: ua-cam.com/video/J-fXRyYEzuQ/v-deo.html
@@LeoNicola_lnljix ради будущeго можно, но вот есть ли смысл если население города падает.
@@LeoNicola_lnljix этот канал показывает не только хронологию, но и перспективы развития 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
@@RydbiStudios ну ты же понимаешь,что это такая же фантастика,как дорога к Анадырю (качественная) построится прямо завтра.
Можеш делать развитие метро Нью-Йорк, Парижа, Лондона и Т. Д
2023-24 the blue line has been proposed to begin plans for foundation construction of the next phase of line to the metro network
When metro is connecting to airport terminal 2?
can you do a Singapore version too
Как называется такая торжественная музыка?
Wonderful
Будет видео про развитие Самарского метрополитена?
México city metro please!
На схеме мы видим,что "через много лет" в Дубае будет 197 станций.
Для сравнения: в мск счас 331 станция.
С Новым Годом вас всех!!!
Не думаю что много лет, максимум в 2040 году. Это все реализуют, надо учитывать в городе проживает чуть меньше чем в Киеве.
В Дубае метро открыли в 2009 году, в Москве в 1935 году. Чувствуете разницу?
@@красныйлис-е1и а Вы чувствуете разницу между бюджетом Дубая и мск,или,допустим,правительством Дубая и мск??
@@LeoNicola_lnljix Ну и? В отличие от Москвы Дубай 50 лет назад был деревушкой без исторических зданий, не в счет форт, плюс я уверен что там планы быстро воплотят в реальность, так как денег реально вложивают куда надо и не воруют как в Москве, тем более огромная часть города это пустыня а хотят превратить это в зеленые оазисы с дорогами и домами
@@красныйлис-е1и Ну и?? Сейчас очень много часных компаний строят себе небоскрёбы,так что бесполезно даже сравивать.
В мск тоже очень быстро строится метро (сравни хотя бы с остальной Россией.)
为什么那几个站一直再改名？
Ну да, Дубай это то!
Is fiture plan is verified
Can you do the Melbourne metro pls!
What about the name of the song?
DUBAI 2050 sudah rata dengan tanah
Давай Московское метро про молжаниновско мытищинскую линию!
как называется музыка?
а ка музыка називаеться
Dubai is quite simple really. Maybe you could do other cities you could do.
The dubai metro kept on changing it's names...
Please Make a video of the São Paulo Metro in Brazil
Bangkok will have 540 km.of metro in 2030
Выкладывай источник на звуковой ряд
Total distance will be ???
А где ты раздобыл карту для Московского и СП метрополитенов, чтобы в этих зонах проводить линии?
Why they have to change the station names? Total confusion for the passengers!
Yes it is confusing like al safa before it was noor back but they always post these naming on social media for all poeple to know. Company's pays sum amount of money to change the name of metro station
I doubt that plans for the Blue and Purple line will be revived anytime soon, they have been cancelled over 10 years ago
Огурец с новым годом
The gold line will open next year while the blue line will open in 2029 (the year I graduate from high school)
а ты можежь сделать эволюцию поездов москвы метро 1935-2100?
Зделай метро в Хесьсинки и в Варшаве
Хельсинки кстати стоит... там мeтро ужe вышло за границы города, достраивают западную часть в Эспоо.
Красный лис спасибо за инфу