Are They Good? NCircle Sonic the Hedgehog SatAM and Underground DVD Review & Comparison [Soundout12]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 102

  • @fighterxaos1
    @fighterxaos1 Рік тому +46

    N "we're not aware Blu Rays are actually cheaper" Circle

    • @supermariof0521
      @supermariof0521 Рік тому +14

      N Circle also did "The Super Mario Bros. Super Show" dirty by ignoring the live action segments and just making it purely the cartoon segments.

    • @LiMe251
      @LiMe251 6 місяців тому +1

      ​@@supermariof0521WHAT.

  • @SmythTheCrow
    @SmythTheCrow Рік тому +38

    Tbh 10 episodes per disc is the maximum you'd want on a single dual-layered DVD. Anything above that and quality takes a nosedive.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +5

      Agreed!

    • @coyotemontana4558
      @coyotemontana4558 2 місяці тому

      @@Soundout12 I agree with both of you but hear this. Blu-Rays can hold up on a big number of episodes on one disc like a example The Flintstone The Complete Series Blu-Ray, when you look at the episode list and selection in the menu, you can see how many episodes are there on one disc. Also for Looney Tunes all 1100 shorts are 6 to 7 minutes so they can put a number of shorts on one disc and the same thing with Gumby. Besides I talked to my dad about this.

  • @AkiraLionPilot
    @AkiraLionPilot Рік тому +23

    N Circle Entertainment also did a bunch of DVD releases for the Mario cartoons, all with very barebones presentation (static menus, no bonus features, etc.) and in the case of the Super Show, removed the live action bits (sometimes very poorly)
    These sound just like what a release from N Circle would entail

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +9

      Really sounds like Sonic Boom was the exception here

    • @AkiraLionPilot
      @AkiraLionPilot Рік тому +6

      @@Soundout12 it’s a miracle they were able to get Sonic Boom right. I just wished the same amount of care would’ve been put into their releases of the older shows

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +3

      @@AkiraLionPilot Agreed

    • @SuperbbConnor64
      @SuperbbConnor64 4 місяці тому

      ⁠​⁠@@Soundout12They recently did the first two seasons of Sonic Prime on blu-ray, if that’s any consolation
      Buuuuut yeah. Besides the obvious stuff one of the things that baffles me the most is the fact they keep using inaccurate artwork for their Mario and Sonic DVDs. For example, their recent release of The Adventures of Super Mario Bros. 3 features _Yoshi_ on the back cover, and their one from a few years back had Cape Mario

  • @SuperBlackwing
    @SuperBlackwing Рік тому +26

    I am soooo glad I have the Shout Factory DVDs of these series. Those have way more love, effort and RESPECT put into them then the NCircle releases. And do you wanna know the best part? Those were released A DECADE AGO!!!! How can there be such an inexcusable drop in quality between 2007 and 2023? Both these shows deserved way better re-releases, no matter what the quality of the show is.

  • @ItsThatRetro
    @ItsThatRetro Рік тому +9

    "Sonic with a mustache" is Uncle Chuck before he was roboticized

  • @NevByte
    @NevByte Рік тому +17

    I was actually looking into the SATam and Underground releases to replace the older ones I have. But sounds like I should probably hang onto them.

  • @TwiMil2008
    @TwiMil2008 Рік тому +3

    0:23 I love that the title is answered only 20 seconds in the video 😂

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +1

      Can’t say I’m not efficient 😂

  • @TheLazyShell
    @TheLazyShell Рік тому +7

    It's bizarre that NC's previous individual volume releases for Underground weren't just recycled for the new set. Those had three discs each as well as special features. You can even still get them.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +4

      It’s very bizarre for sure. They ultimately did more work to make an inferior product

    • @CosmicSponge2004
      @CosmicSponge2004 Рік тому +4

      And those old ones were just reprinted Shout Factory sets. Why not do that again?

  • @Shantae-June22002
    @Shantae-June22002 Рік тому +5

    They should recall the Sonic SATAM Complete series DVD and give it a do over and remaster the episodes for all 26 episodes and put all the episodes across 3 discs on DVD.
    And maybe do the same for Sonic Underground with a 5th disc.

  • @foxboxarchives2059
    @foxboxarchives2059 Рік тому +3

    8:23 I actually like the Idea of SD on BD. Discotek has done an amazing job with their releases when it comes to all the titles they have including titles from 4Kids. I got the 2003 English dub of Shaman King on SD on BD last month and it has all 64 episodes on one disc. I'm getting Ultimate Muscle on SD Blu-Ray soon and I might plan to upgrade the Blu-Rays for the english dub of Sonic X as well.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +1

      SDBD is such a great way to release SD shows!

  • @rocky-my5ck
    @rocky-my5ck Рік тому +4

    Sucks that it's almost not talked about, but thank you for mentioning it

  • @I-like-Sonic-92
    @I-like-Sonic-92 6 місяців тому +2

    Fun fact: NCircle has rereleased the Shout Factory volumes for Sonic Underground, albeit changing the trailers to advertise other NCircle releases and removing Disc 4 for both volumes (They were both audio CDs that features 8 of the "Greatest Hits of Sonic Underground"), therefore making the Complete Series DVDs useless.

  • @Angie2343
    @Angie2343 Рік тому +3

    Sonic Underground NEEDS a revival! The prophecy never came true! It's been 25 years!

  • @alexashbourne6496
    @alexashbourne6496 Рік тому +5

    I heard that NCircle will release the complete series of The Adventures of Super Mario Bros. 3. That set will contain 2 discs although, unlike Sonic SatAM, TAoSMB3 have all 13 episodes with 26 segments. The one thing that baffles me was why a Yoshi from Super Mario World appeared on the back cover (both as a image and a screenshot from said show)?

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +1

      If its 13 half hour episodes on 2 discs, it should be fine.
      Honestly the packaging on all of these is a little wonky lol

    • @supermariof0521
      @supermariof0521 Рік тому +1

      ​@@Soundout12N Circle already did a complete series set on Mario 3, but all they did was just reprint the Shout Factory release but with different opening previews.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +1

      @@supermariof0521 That’s such a strange change to make

    • @Shantae-June22002
      @Shantae-June22002 Рік тому +1

      They need to redo that upcoming release to fix the problems.

    • @80sDisneyFan
      @80sDisneyFan Рік тому

      @@supermariof0521 And logos.

  • @ProWrestlingFan1995
    @ProWrestlingFan1995 6 місяців тому

    I bought this set because for just wanting to own the series at a cheaper price works for me.
    I agree it could have been better, and I still might buy the Shout Factory set later down the track but for the time being this is serviceable for me.
    Awesome vid, you’ve gained yourself a new subscriber.

  • @ADjustinG2013
    @ADjustinG2013 Рік тому +7

    That's capitalism for you. NOTHING is cheap enough. Companies will wreck the quality of their product just to save a penny for each copy made, but then charge you (the customer) more because they have to impress the stock holders with new profit records.

  • @digitaladventurer2142
    @digitaladventurer2142 9 місяців тому +2

    Yeah I do feel DVD is the modern VHS but honestly I still like physical media as I and I'm sure many people live in an area with somewhat unreliable internet. I mean one connection issue and all streaming is out the door. Physical media still would have multiple options. My PS5, blu-ray player, laptop. heck I could pull my old ps4 or 3 out if needed, and yeah sometimes discs do crap out over time but its still very rare. I've owned literally hundreds of dics over the last 20+ years and maybe 3-5 at best have developed issues and only 2 have become completely unplayable.

  • @Scabloonshki
    @Scabloonshki Рік тому +1

    I have the original shout factory release of SatAM sitting around somewhere. I got it as a gift when I was around 8-10 years old. I don’t know where it is. I really hope I can find cuz I kinda want to revisit the show again since I’m 22 now.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +1

      That Shout release is definitely the best way to watch the show. I hope you can find it!

  • @CountryShape
    @CountryShape Рік тому +5

    not everyone can afford, a Blu Ray player. which is why i prefer DVD.

    • @ProWrestlingFan1995
      @ProWrestlingFan1995 6 місяців тому +1

      I second this, DVDs are still produced for a reason.
      Most of my collection are DVDs, I have some Blu Rays but my DVDs outweigh them.

  • @bmhedgehog2
    @bmhedgehog2 Рік тому +3

    Yeah you are better off getting the Shout Factory releases of these two shows for the time being till the licenses expire and Discotek obtains the rights to them. I have AoStH from Discotek and I think I made the right choice cause I doubt that I would get Shout Factory volume 3 as that was a limited release I think and it is expensive to buy.

  • @JambopaulGamerInPJs
    @JambopaulGamerInPJs 8 місяців тому +1

    What's ironic is that a few years ago NCircle actually reprinted the old Shout Factory Sonic Underground DVD sets, and despite lacking the bonus music CDs and original cover art, they were otherwise the same discs, with the same menus, bonus features, superior video encoding/quality, etc. Those sets are still fairly cheap to find online, so there's literally no reason to buy the new Complete Series set when you can get two vastly superior volumes for roughly the same price. Sadly, the SatAM Shout Factory set didn't receive a similar re-release.
    I also dislike how these new versions sort the episodes in broadcast order instead of production order like the old sets. For SatAM, this results in the pilot episode being placed at the end of Season 1/Disc 1 instead of being the first episode. Underground has it even worse, the first three episodes, which are a three-part story arc setting up the main plot of the show, are placed more than halfway through the series and interspersed between parts of another three-episode story arc.

  • @berniedavis6676
    @berniedavis6676 Рік тому +1

    My favorite cartoon from my childhood ( The Real Ghostbusters) had an amazing DVD box set release from Time Life back in the late 2000s and to find that set now will cost you thousands of dollars. while the most recent DVD set from Sony Home Entertainment lacks luster due to bland menus and not having every episode I would love a Blu-ray version but it's only available in Germany. I doubt we'll ever get it here in the States. and who knows if we'll ever get Extreme Ghostbusters as a complete DVD collection.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +1

      I wish we could get better Ghostbusters releases for real

  • @imfsresidentotaku9699
    @imfsresidentotaku9699 Місяць тому

    3:56 That’s not an excuse. When I watch shows that I didn’t grow up with, I don’t dismiss them because they’re “weird.” In fact, I’m curious of the history that led to what I did grow up with, and more often than not, those old shows are better than what I did grow up with.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Місяць тому

      I wasn't dismissing either show, I just personally don't like either after trying multiple episodes over the years. I watch all kinds of different eras of shows and not just chase what I know from childhood

    • @imfsresidentotaku9699
      @imfsresidentotaku9699 Місяць тому

      ⁠​⁠@@Soundout12So do I with as open a mind as possible, but whatever floats your boat.

  • @MrDemonsushii
    @MrDemonsushii 2 місяці тому

    “Whereas now they’re gonna skip them on by and hope the license expires and somebody else gets them.”
    This.

  • @cedricshepherd4459
    @cedricshepherd4459 Рік тому +6

    Sonic underground was a good series except that they cancelled it before the last 12 episodes was made leaving it on episode 40 on a cliffhanger. 😔.

  • @efuntron
    @efuntron Рік тому +1

    I wish the Earthworm Jim cartoon had a better transfer on dvd. It’s decent, maybe vhs quality or a little better. It’s definitely great to have all the episodes on physical media. Doubt they’ll do another release anytime soon considering it’s still available on Amazon. It even had 3 discs for 23 episodes.

  • @ToonGoon_1
    @ToonGoon_1 Місяць тому

    4:26 “Ya Pay What You Get For” I Think You Said That Wrong

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Місяць тому

      I definitely did

    • @ToonGoon_1
      @ToonGoon_1 Місяць тому

      I have both of these and I actually love these sets, I don’t care about the quality and stuff, but I WILL Agree with the TERRIBLE Design Of The Stacked Disks On Sonic Underground

  • @darthvader473
    @darthvader473 2 місяці тому

    Underground is one of the childhood shows of mine. 😅

  • @charlesman8722
    @charlesman8722 Рік тому +2

    Stuff like this bothers me. Like SatAM is a fanfavorite series but company’s don’t seem to ever care. Like ReBoot had this problem “oh it’s a well loved series that people will pay top dollar for bonus features and on a blu ray steel book?? Meh stuff it on two DVDs and call it a day.”

    • @ashesGeek
      @ashesGeek Рік тому

      Well, it's fan favorite, but definitely not among Sega of Japan. It's surprising they actually gave a damn about doing something with DIC cartoons, they could've easily just pretend they don't exist pushing harder on Lego Sonic and Sonic themed restaurant advertising

    • @charlesman8722
      @charlesman8722 Рік тому +2

      /@@ashesGeek Ok you missed the point of the comment ENTIRELY.

    • @ashesGeek
      @ashesGeek Рік тому

      @charlesman8722 I get the fact that company was about dvd companies incompetence and lack of care in doing their job properly, but anyway it's all connected to Sega of America which is obviously controlled by Sega of Japan.
      But again, it mostly such companies responsibility, Aosth anniversary set was done wonderfully and feels like a respect to fans and collectors in comparison

  • @Shantae-June22002
    @Shantae-June22002 Рік тому

    Weird Question
    What do the subtitles look like on the DVD?
    Are they mostly similar to what is presented on the Sonic Boom Blu-ray or any other N Circle or Mill Creek DVD or Blu-ray?

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +2

      I honestly never checked, but now I’m curious

    • @Shantae-June22002
      @Shantae-June22002 Рік тому

      @@Soundout12 The subtitles on my copy of Lords of Dogtown Unrated Extended Edition on Blu-ray are almost yellow but they’re a really bright tan and are almost a comparison to some Sony Pictures Blu-rays and any other Blu-ray with that style of subtitles.
      When you check tell me what they look like and maybe what color they are and what style are they compared to other Blu-ray and DVD subtitles because I haven’t seen any subtitles on any N Circle DVD or blu-ray because the ones I have don’t even have subtitles.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +2

      @@Shantae-June22002 On SatAm, Underground and Boom Subtitles are white with a bit of a black outline
      They seem pretty industry standard for font and sizing

    • @Shantae-June22002
      @Shantae-June22002 Рік тому

      @@Soundout12 interesting

  • @jamesrwc4738
    @jamesrwc4738 Рік тому +4

    TRIPLETS BORN

  • @LeafRazorStorm
    @LeafRazorStorm 9 місяців тому

    For what it's worth, "Sonic Underground" on DVD will always be at an unfair disadvantage, since that show was produced in Europe with 576i resolution and 25fps, so any American DVDs will be stuck with a downscaled 480i and blended 30fps.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  9 місяців тому +2

      Taking all that into consideration, the Underground DVD isn’t too bad

  • @DankerTVTimeCapsule
    @DankerTVTimeCapsule Рік тому

    out of print in the uk so to get anything physical whether locked or not is a win.

  • @Frederik-DK
    @Frederik-DK Рік тому

    Since you said it's a problem with the masters, do we actually know if the old DVDs have better video quality?

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +1

      From what I understand, Shout factory had much higher quality masters when they released the shows

    • @tetrasonic91
      @tetrasonic91 6 місяців тому

      yeah shout factory's satam dvd release is the best quality you'll ever get out of satam

  • @pokepress
    @pokepress Рік тому

    While I think your criticisms are generally valid, it's hard to say exactly where the fault lies in terms of the transfer without knowing what the status of the film is. I might still pick the satAM collection up to see what AI upscaling can do with it.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +1

      From what I can tell and have surmised from details online, the masters Wild Brain has are from old, but are of a lower quality than the masters used on ShoutFactory’s earlier DVDs.
      I have no idea if the original film or tape still exists for a new master to be made from. Upscaling is probably the only option.

    • @pokepress
      @pokepress Рік тому +1

      @@Soundout12 I've gotten some pretty good results with my custom Super Mario Bros. Super Show models, and I'm continuing to improve my processes there.

  • @tetrasonic91
    @tetrasonic91 6 місяців тому +1

    shout factory forever!!!!

  • @Shantae-June22002
    @Shantae-June22002 Рік тому

    Hopefully they don’t screw up The Adventures of Super Mario Bros. 3 even more than they did it with the box art of the DVD putting Yoshi and Super Mario World screenshots on the back of the case, they also better not screw up the video presentation for it.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +2

      Hopefully with that show being much shorter, the disc compression won’t be an issue

  • @justinmiddleton8818
    @justinmiddleton8818 Рік тому +2

    Honestly, either the old Shout! Factory set from 2007 or the previous series of six individual volumes NCircle did of Sonic SATAM are by far much better releases. Now, the caveat with the latter is the episodes are in sideways order out of sequence but quality wise with being 4 to 5 episodes per disc it's definitely better than the mess this complete set is.
    I'm just going to settle with getting either of the above to have a good quality version of SATAM in my collection.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +1

      That’s a good plan!

    • @justinmiddleton8818
      @justinmiddleton8818 Рік тому

      @Soundout12 Yeah, so i might just be going with the NCircle single disc releases. I've looked at prices for the Shout! set and as expected for an OOP release it's going for a pretty penny these days.
      The individual volumes may have the episodes out of sequence, but i've seen them going for dirt cheap on Amazon used.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +1

      @@justinmiddleton8818 Definitely sounds like the better plan

    • @justinmiddleton8818
      @justinmiddleton8818 Рік тому

      @Soundout12 True, that's certainly the much less pricey option. I mean yeah, the individual volumes are bare bones compared to the Shout! set and the episodes in completely random order but it's definitely better quality wise than the new set from what i've seen.

    • @Soundout12
      @Soundout12  Рік тому +1

      @@justinmiddleton8818 Having more discs helps for sure

  • @Minspi_26
    @Minspi_26 6 місяців тому

    The thing is wildbrain who owns cookie jar has better quality or remastered masters on thier UA-cam

  • @supermariof0521
    @supermariof0521 3 місяці тому

    You think this is bad, you should see N Circle's shitty treatment of "The Super Mario Bros. Super Show".

  • @mcmistle9892
    @mcmistle9892 Рік тому

    Nice

  • @SailorStarHero
    @SailorStarHero Рік тому +1

    Shout factory's Sonic the Hedgehog SatAM and Underground were better than this, Sonic the Hedgehog SatAM had used fan art for the inside dvd cover, it looked really nice, I think the disc used fan art as well, there were extras and better menus, Shout factory's sets feel more like 30th anniversary sets than what NCircle did, SD on blu ray would be super easy to do for satam and Underground, it happened with aosth.

  • @powergamerex844
    @powergamerex844 Місяць тому

    N Circle doesn’t value older shows unlike newer shows which is why Sonic SatAM was treated poorly but Sonic Boom was treated better. Plus not everyone would value Sonic SatAM as a good show nonetheless.

  • @Ratchetcomand
    @Ratchetcomand 2 місяці тому

    DVD's only exist because of casuals.

  • @HEMPHILL23
    @HEMPHILL23 Рік тому +2

    Generational bias. Sega of Japan's fault...

    • @rayvenkman2087
      @rayvenkman2087 9 місяців тому

      The same Sega of Japan who’s own stubbornness cost them the Console Wars of the 90’s, Sonic being in a rut more than once and probably the reason we’re not getting Sonic Mania 2 because they just can’t swallow their pride; they have to be the ones to get the last word over Sega of America above all else. They’re as bad as Toho and Toei when it comes to working with them outside of Japan and just as stubborn to meet halfway.