Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
Andi Deris v.s. Michael Kiske
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 сер 2024
- Kiske has a better voice than Deris
Deris is a better musician
But the ones who make the band success in every single album are Michael Weikath and Markus Grosskopf
These comparisons are a waste of time. I love Kiske's contributions to Helloween and his voice really elevated the band to the next level but once Kiske was no longer in it, the band had to bring in someone else and Deris has a done a great job fronting this legendary band.These guys are just two different chapters of the same fantastic book.Cheers.
You know, Deris and Michael song together in helloween now!!!!!!
Great!
realmente os 2 sao otimos ! eles sao o HELLOWEEN ! ver os 2 cantando juntos é incrível. quando vierem para o Brasil - BR. EU IREI NO SHOWWW.
Yes you're right.
Both are excellent but if I would say, helloween is metal, Andi's vocal is for sure while kiske maybe good in other genres.
Yes, they are great singers more over Andi is a great composer.
No need for comparisons anymore, now both legends are in the band at the same time!!!
Andi Deris singing Perfect Gentleman it's sensational.
Michael Kiske
Michael Kiske
Michael Kiske
Michael Kiske
Michael Kiske
Michael kiske is THE MAN. Epic voice
Mauri Friedman exactly and best in helloween ever. I never like so much Andi telling the truth, i start listen helloween in then when in band was Kai Hansen and Michael Kiske but Kiske take a win anyway, gold throat definitely.
Both of them much better than J bieber,,,,
Pluto Kuluk lol😂😂😂😂😂🖒🖒🖒
True😂😂
Well.... I guess you are right......
Is that really a comparison?
You guys are arguing about which one of them is better. Kiske and Deris are awesome in my opinion. I love them both. But without Michael Weikath, There would be no Helloween.
and Kai ......
Zent Prozent 😀✌✌ agreed with u bro...
True lol
Kai hansen
Never compare them ,,
they're both Amazing,
Kiske with his high and powerfull voice,
Deris with his techniques ..
.
we will never can compare them as we will never can compare Hansen with weikath
they are both the soul of Helloween
I like Andi in the Forever and one and if a could fly, but, Kiske, is the best, the best voice in the world of Power metal
kiske always n always...amazing voice (y)
Kiske 45 : 55 Deris
Kiske is classic metal voice
Deris is modern, but so many technique he have :)
Agree😭..im so young but..i so like with Helloween rock music
Ofcourse Deris , his Voice is more melodic and flexible! You can feel the song's soul when he sings. Great musician and songwriter too. Amazingly performing on stage! He has changed and renewed Helloween completely! Respect to Kiske as well. He is also good, but only in high pitch, and lets not forget that he almost killed Helloween. Basically for me Helloween is Andi and Andi is Helloween!
Both are so great but kiske gave the voice to poder metal duris justo kept it helloween in the right way
NO comparison, kiskes voice can melt steel. Deris is good..... Kiske is god
Deris god :)
gibbut1 Kiske is Father of God
@@sepsaicha and there is marylin manson , the god of god
Both of them are human
Deris is a good singer and so is Kiske. I love Deris on If I Knew, but I love Kiske on I Want Out. Deris is good for his own songs. He's not meant to sing I Want Out. That song and the earlier generation of Helloween songs is meant for Kiske. Deris hold his own in the The Time Of The Oath album. Both singers are great for me. Lets enjoy them.
True, dude :)
DHAA.AA Could not agree more.
yeah
yeah
Im really not sure why everybody hates Deris's voice. Its very good and unique.
Youngest Metalhead Deris voice not quite fit in helloween, Kiske is perfect and done best jobs with helloween, every true fan knows that, i do know that. Deris done only hit songs not best albums.
17:84 kuping orang beda beda, itu RAHMAT Allah 35:27-28. kalau semua sama boring. 🎉❤😂 gitu aja kok repot.
semua orang dikasih sama rata sama minat sama dll GAK ADA JUAL BELI, GAK ADA BARTER, GAK ADA KERJASAMA, GAK ADA SALING MELENGKAPI, what flat life😮
14:7 & 2:152 syukuri apa yg ada hidup adalah anugrah, akan ada KEHIDUPAN LAIN YG LEBIH KEKAL 3:15-17 dan dipersiapkan BEKAL 59:18 GAK LALAI DUNIAWI THOK. ngono lho urip seng bener ki 2:201 , 28:77 ❤🎉😊
I listen them since 86.(Thousand times)For my ears Kiske is better then Deris..Just thinking which voice comes up to my ears first:Kiske's voice....
the one who made helloween successful is kai..
los dos tienen sus pro y contra:
Michael Kiske por ejemplo, tiene una voz casi perfecta, clarisima, con agudos y graves increibles, pero como dijo Michael Weikath su voz se limita a hacer voces raspadas que requiere muchas veces el heavy metal.
Andi Deris, si bien su voz es muy completa concordando con lo que el heavy metal requiere, es limitada.
En fin, yo amo a Michael Kiske y recordemos que la mayoria de los exitos de Helloween son cantados por Michael, uno de ellos mi favorito I want out
One band.. two singers.. Why compare? Just enjoy...
The biggest thing is: Michael Kiske recorded is one of the best, on the stage is simply unbelievable!!!
Deris, semua lagu yang dia nyanyikan seperti punya nyawa. Dia tahu karakter lagu-lagu yang akan dinyanyikan dan akan dibawa kemana.
Sorry guys andi is far superior too me maybe it's my personal taste maybe im deaf but i find his voice incredible and unique. . Kiske is plain awesome too and has a gifted voice but his voice is just clean and extremely high, a truly exceptional and talented vocalist but pretty much very similar to the average high-pitched power metal voice. Andi really makes a difference despite his smaller range (though his high pitced peaks are excellent) . Well after all kiske has the most annoying vibrato i've ever heard.. Damn helloween would be a really boring band if he remained with them.. Deris apart from his writing abilities he gave the band the opportunity to exeriment and even specialize in other genres mixed with their classic power metal sound.. Up the pumpkins!!!
Pt.2.: Andi "Mr. God & The King for a 1000 years" Deris:
- Brilliant voice, colourful and unbelievable voice in every tunes!!!
- He loves Metal and he is proud that he's the singer of Helloween.
- Has 9 (!!!) full-length and more other records with the band, all the records are PERFECT with him!!!
- Wrote a lot of lyric and music for Helloween.
- His own works are awesome too!
- He is a great performer on the stage!!! (I saw both of them on stage with Helloween, believe me!)
They are both fantastic singers... usually I have problems when I love a band and the singer changes... but Andi Deris convinced me totally to replace Michael Kiske.
I reckon Michael has a clearer voice and can reach a higher range better than Andi, don't get me wrong Andi is good, but Michael is better in my opinion
Well I'm a huge fan to Helloween, I like both Kiske and Deris. In my opinion Deris gave more "musical" and rich sound to Helloween since he joined - very talented composer and musician.
kiske any day
michael kiske forever
Deris saved the band, Kiske almost killed Helloween after the two keepers because of his behaviour and bad influence on the band. When Deris came, the band turned from pop rock to Heavy Badass Metal.
Master Of Rings
Time of The Oath (!!!)
Better Than Raw
Dark Ride
Those four albums are to my mind Masterpieces.
Then, I advise fans who still haven't take a look to the High Live, to watch it right f**king now !
I agree with you but still Kiske is top class. The only time I've ever seen Bruce Dickinson wear a shirt with a band's name is with Kiske!
i agree.. but nothing beats the keepers and that whole phase
The best Helloween albums are those with Deris. The Keepers are masterpieces, but I prefer albums that you have quoted. The Dark Ride is criminally underrated. Rabbits is a great album (the forgotten one ?) and Keepers Legacy also.The last albums is very good, too.
I think Andi Deris is the right choice, Weikath is a genius in choosing a vocalist because he does something very precise.
Kiske does have a shrill voice but there are so many and it's easy to find the type of voice like him. Compared to Andi Deris, he is very much different, even very unique in his technique and sound arrangement he has all ... not many singers have a voice like him he is very difficult to find. I think he is the hero and savior of this band.
I firmly chose Mr. Andi deris, he is the man.
I thoroughly enjoy any singer that has sang for Helloween... one of my absolute favorite bands EVER! Others seem to have exceptional hearing to point out the flaws of each singer, Kiske and Andi are both AWESOME singers and I've rocked to all Helloween albums and different singers brought a new sound and made Helloween INCREDIBLE! I never judge a band on their lineup changes, but rather look forward to how they sound now and I followed Helloween from the start, since the EP, the artwork drew me to them and I drew a huge POSTER of it when I was just a TEEN, now 48 and still LOVE Helloween music and find it so inspirational and moving... THANKS HELLOWEEN and keep on making some of the greatest music in this CORRUPT world and the world would be better if all 7 billion people listened to you guys!
In France here it s forever KISKE ! No other singer than him is the legitimate singer of Helloween! NO ONE ! KISKE WAS THE BEST AND THE ONLY SINGER OF HELLOWEEN!
Speaking for whole country? :D Really funny :D
no andi deris no hellowen
Honestly both are excellent, though each has its uniqueness Kiske has a higher and more technical Andi voice.
Kiske put more feeling in music, who accompanied Helloween its start learning their letters and the kind of feeling that they go to a fan of the band, without a shadow of doubt Kiske was the soul of the band.
Andi is more Kiske is good Excellent
Andi ha sido un gran reemplazo y ha sabido llevar a la banda.
Cada uno tiene su estilo,pero, ¡vamos! no sean estancados y salgan de los Keppers.
Recalcó admiró la potencia que le da Michael a las canciones.
Lmao Wes Es cierto, todos dicen que cuando se fue Kiske todo se fue a la mierda... Pero con Deris tenes grandes temas como Power, if i Could fly o i can. También los últimos dos discos tienen temas muy buenos, como nabataea
Gorgonops Epicus Asi es,mi álbum favorito con Andi es el The Time of Oath.
Lmao Wes tienes razon...siempre comparando y se quedan pegados en los keepers..ambos son tremendos cantantes.
En realidad estuvo bien que hallan sacado a Kiske. Por su culpa la banda estaba al borde de la decadencia, y cuando Deris entro salvo a la banda en un abrir y cerrar de ojos, y ademas entro el mejor baterista de Power Metal. Si Kiske huviera seguido Helloween no huviese continuado despues de Chamaleon, o huviesen continuado pero con el rock barato que hacia Kiske, y Weiki se huviera ido al carajo.
Sea como sea Kiske grabo los 2 mejores discos de ls banda, Denis es un grande pero kiske es leyenda... en los conciertos lo q mas pidr la gente es escuchar lo del keeper por esos discos heloween es lo q es y gran parte es por la voz de Kiske
Y'know, I've been a fan of Helloween for 8 years now, and I still can't recognize Kiske's voice until I'm freakin' TOLD it's Kiske, because he just sounds like every damned power metal vocalist out there; the typical, clear, clean, operatic, generic singing style. At least with Deris, he may not have the range or 'talent' that Kiske does, I can tell it's Deris from the second he starts singing. And honestly, I'd rather have that than just sheer range; every power metal singer and their mother has a 3+ octave range, but not many of them are immediately distinct enough to recognize in a crowd.
That's the exact opposite for me. I know the second I hear him anywhere. He has a truly unique Vibrato too. And maybe he is in the range of the same, high pitch clear voice like lot's of power metal singers like you say, but only he can nail his shit 25 years later live just like if he's 19 in a studio.
I agree with Dr.DemonHarlequin and DaFox. Andi Deris's tone is very unique (so as Kai Hansen's). But Michael Kiske...erm...sorry to say, he is bit boring.
Dear friend, I don't know how old you are but I can tell you this...I am 47 years old and I am helloween's fan for almost 33-34 years....back then at the 80-s NO-ONE AND I MEAN NO-ONE sounded like the way Kiske did....yes it is true that every second power metal singer sounds the same AND THAT IS BECAUSE EVERYONE WANT'S TO SOUND LIKE KISKE....Cheers my friend!!!!
KISKE FOREVER!!
Alessandro Petrucci Agree....!
Kiske for President!!! Merry Christmas 2022. 🎄 God bless ❤️
Kiske got an amazing voice is perfect and the only one for Helloween
Sure Kiske has the better voice. But Deris is still a great singer and definitely a top song writer, specially when it comes to ballads. Kiske doesn't stand a chance against Deris in songwriting. If Deris had not replaced Kiske, Helloween would be dead since 2 decades.
Man. you deserve a beer, really. You're completely right. Kiske better singer, Andy better songwriter.
+Marcel X I gree with you, although I think that Kiske's songwaritting is a little bit underrated. Don't you think so? :(
+Asier Azkolain
Kiskes writing on his solo albums is fantastic. Really talented writer, in my opinion. Being a different genre doesn't make it bad. I don't normally listen to metal these days, but I do respect Michael Kiske for having the guts to make a pretty clean break from that scene and do something completely different, and doing a darn well job doing it. Also, his writing on Chameleon is damn near sublime, 'Longing' being a perfect example.
+hastobe303 I haven't listened to Kiske's solo stuff, but Kiske wrote amazing songs while he was in helloween!
Readiness To Sacrifice in particular is a great record. Personally, I think that record is more enjoyable than anything Helloween has ever done.
Andi Deris es un extraordinario cantante, pero Michael Kiske es uno de los tres mejores de la historia del Heavy Metal. Por suerte podemos verlos juntos en Pumkins United, disfrutemoslos a ambos que estan haciendo un trabajo fascinante. Helloween rules!
Michael kiske's voice remember me bruce dickinson's voice
ies
sephiroth cloud when I first heard eagles fly free I had to google who sang the song because it sounded so much like Bruce
Kiske goes higher .... but they do sound alike .. that's true :)
👍
I think that is very stupid to copmare two different voices! Its not fair for Deris..... after all He must sing Kiske songs and they are written for Kiske voice. I wonder what will hapend if Kiske must sing Deris song? However..... in my opinion Andi Deris have an amazing voice and its saund a way better then Kiske ..... even in Kiske song! Kiske is too squeaky for me. Andi Deris is the best singer for Helloween!!!
You couldn't have said it better way! Both are amazing, what's the point in arguing who's better? (Deris is, for not having such a squeaking voice, just like you said ;)) In addition Deris is way better song writer :) Still, Kiske is awesome too, maybe better nowadays than in his Helloween era (less squeaky)!
Leena Saukkonen voice and song writer imho are dif things. Best way they could do is sing together. One of them has his own part. Imho it would be awesome
Finally someone who understands
Eli Dobreva Yup, its so unfair for Deris. Kiske is too high :P
Eli Dobreva Please, pull the bananas out of your ear, and take some PROFESSIONAL SINGING lessons.Singing has strict rules to follow, just like in maths.No matter who likes what...For instance, I have been taking lessons for years, and I have asked at least 10 professional singers who tour abroad about their opinion...Guess what ? Deris cannot sing at all.I feel quite sorry for people who do not have even elementary basis and swear by Deris.
Ambos son excelentes, pero la variedad y. Naturalidad que tiene Deris lo deja arriba
Both vocalists are amazing at what they do, both have done very well for Helloween.
I would have to agree and say Kiske, His Power and range is extremely rare. Clean Power as well as raspy when he wants it. If he was to return to Helloween he could sing every one of Deris's songs with all the right rasp with no problems. Deris Has an incredible raspy vocal style with great range and control. He does a great job at turning the songs written for Kiske into his own. He does them justice but he still isn't Kiske on those old songs. I personally love them both and would love to see Helloween go on a tour with all of Helloweens singers singing the songs they recorded with them. THAT WOULD BE AN EPIC SHOW FOR ALL HELLOWEEN FANS!!!!!!
I'd like to see kiske sing Bells(beels) of the seven hells, liar, and deliver us from temptation
Both have special and amazing voices but kiske has the perfect voice to sing power and Deris for hard rock/ metal, but Deris rocks on power too.
I like more Deris because of his different voice and his amazing performance live, he still can sing well (watch the Loud park 2012 videos), not like in the pink cream 69 and master of rings but his voice is still amazing... Kiske too, he's voice still incredible!!
They are both great in its own time, but without kiske there wouldnt be deris.
Kiske for the 80s and deris for the 90s
We have some similar eternal discussion in Russia around heavy metal band "Ariya". The lead vocal Valery Kipelov left the band and created his own band "Kipelov". I personally think "Ariya" vanished after Kipelov left, and trust me: his voice IS magic! Some still enjoy "Ariya" with new vocalists. But in general it gave us two mega popular bands and anyone can choose which to listen to. Oh, eah, and I like Kiske more than Deris :)))
Andi is also a great hard rock and heavy metal song writer...
Los 2 tienen los suyo, los 2 han sacado fabulosos temas, en mi opinión no hay mejor ya que tenemos gustos diferentes, a uno le puede gustar Kiske, a otro Deris y a otro Kai, Kiske no podría cantar power, ya que no tendría el mismo efecto, Deris no podría cantar Eagle Fly Free, ya que no tendrian los mismos efectos, Lo que quiero decir es que cada uno es bueno, no hay que comparar talentos ya que, los 2 son buenos, imagínate Power contra Eagle Fly Free difícil, A lo que quiero llegar es que los 2 son buenos dependiendo de tus gustos y como los veas
esta muy bien lo que expones pero haciendo una analogía con otra banda como black sabbath... se compara sus dos primeros vocalistas como ozzy y dio.... y en los dos si hay estilos de vos distintas en los mismos temas por decir el tema de black sabbath o iron man algunos les gusta mas la mistica de ozzy y a otros la potencia de dio.... pero ambos son buenos con los mismos temas.... ahora volviendo a helloween... andy en estudio es muy bueno con otro estilo pero su gran desgracia es que kiske sigue antando aun los temas de helloween por decir uno future word y le deja mal parado por que en vivo andy no llega a nada y trata de copiar el estilo que le dio kiske a future word... y también en dr stein y otros temas que vocalista en vivo que era de la época de kiske no llega y le ois a kiske y te deja esas ganas de gritar volve por que helloween perdió su pasado en ss temas nuevos no hay problemas pero andy no le da para entonar los temas de la epoca de kiske y una lastima por que la vos que tenemos en mente los amantes de helloween es kiske... pero no niego que es bueno en lo que hace andy ... pero helloween era kiske y hoy es una nueva banda no la de ayer por mas que toquen los temas viejos
Andy WHO? Hahahahaha Don't make me laugh... Kiske is THE VOICE!
James Galvao Киске лучше Дериса,но Киске сдал за последнее время
Andi Deris is Helloween voice more than any other ;)
James Galvao Word! Helloween was and is my fav metalband. Too bad Helloween ceased to exist after Chameleon(which wasn't a great album btw). Keeper of the seven keys part II is the best album they ever had and ever will have. Kai is also a great singer, i loved when he sang. But heck, we have Gamma ray for that ;)
+Richard Larssen It is funny that Helloween ceased to exist after Chameleon, because The Dark Ride is my favorite album. It is awkward that the album was made by no band.
James Galvao , are yov crazy???
kiske svcks
andi puts more feeling to the songs, I prefer Andi
Kiske has always killed it, He is a god among men as far as I care.. The early years of Deris were mediocre, but he has obviously learned a lot over the years.. I saw them at Wacken 2018 & both of them still tear shit up. Seeing them perform together was amazing!.. Older & their voices have changed but still love them & they again killed it!
Kiske is the voice of Helloween, Deris the voice of Pink Cream 69 !
I love both , but Kiske is closer to my heart
Kiske is great, but i like Andi
I prefer Andi also...
I Love Andi 😘😘
Yes
michael kiske ? do you mean... GOD FREAKING KISKE ?
Estoy segura que no hay comparacion alguna...kiske lejos es el mejos vocalista,lindo con estilo propio y unas melodias geniales...me encanta su musica,la pasion que le dedica a cada cancion....KISKE ES LO MEJOR.
U can like Deris more than u like Kiske but that doesnt mean that its better.....kiske is fucking amazing! Keeper 1/2 with Deris, c'mon....LOL
kiske is helloween, forever
they are both unique musicians. kiske has incredible, easy to listen to, perfect voice. his music style was not only fantasy, but also more realistic, funny themes (rise and fall).
deris, as ive said is also unique. (we're all right?). he has strange voice (power), they're both great in their way and in their style. i dont like some of deris covers of kiske. and deris seems to have lost his voice with age. while kiske is still able to sing his songs.
Yesssssssssss ! fair winner ! Kiske deserve it
Kai Hansen. Compositor y excelente vocalista. El equilibrio perfecto entre Kiske y Deris
Kai Hansen. Composer and wonderful vocal. Perfect balance.
I listen to Andy Deris singing I want out and I feel sick. Kiske always
Agreed. Kiske has a fantastic voice. He's a great guy too. I met him at the Sonisphere in Madrid and he is a very guy normal with no ego. The problem is that he sounds a LOT like Tate and all of the other (classic) Queensryche impersonators. You really hit it when you said Andi's voice was "colourful". No has that sound at all. It has that biting rasp to it that really catches your ear. Plus look at the first two PC69 albums that he wrote almost entirely by himself. Awesome songwriting skills.
For me Andi Deris voice number 1!!!
Those who think that Deris is great for a rude awakening. Kiske is god!!!!
Just because Kiske has an amazing range doesn't mean Deris is a bad singer or that he's better. I personally like Deris' voice more.
Sou Deris! Mas sei que todos nós ganhamos vendos esses mitos cantando no nosso Helloween.
No hay uno mejor que otro.los 2 son muy buenos cantantes.son diferentes y unicos. Los 2 tienen que cantar en helloween. Juntos son una explosion de sonido😎👏👌
michael kiske
The two are the best singers
They are both great singers.
Andi deris just hits that epic awesome vibe. Just a timeless perfect singer.
Para cierto estilo queda muy bien kiske y para cierto estilo deris es perfecto. Franca mente prefiero el trabajo de deris en pink cream. Pero en helloween no lo hace tan mal. Realmente ambos son muy buenos con sus propios trabajos.
Both are awesome, but Live I prefer Kiske.
Kiske siempre sera la mejor voz no solo de helloween si no de la historia
kiske is a GOD, derris is cool too, but, helloween is hansen and kiske
now, kiske and deris are singing together
And Ingo Schwichtenberg also
Deris still has his hair soooooooo
😂😂
😂🤣😂🤣
Both are very talented and very good singers and musicians in their own right. Kiske can sing Kiske songs well, and Deris and sing Deris songs well. Of course Deris will sing 'Future World' and 'I Want Out' differently, because he's a different singer
deris has more hair!
signsofevil que imbécil comentario
Hahahahah :'D
😂😂😂🎉 and sweet smile❤
Comparar a Deris con Kiske es un duelo de "madurez" que desde hace años debió haber dejado de importar. Basta con ver quién siguió con Helloween y los llevó a lo que son hoy. Kiske si bien fue un "padre" del power, es la típica voz power metalera a la cual copiaron todos. Es la típica voz repetida a la cual todos suenan igual. No le encuentro más valor que el registro alto al que puede llegar y eso, para mí, es algo a lo que cualquier metalero puede llegar. Basta con ver la inmensidad de bandas power que suenan igual en voz.
Deris por otro lado es único en cuanto a timbre, y sonido y respecto a la "capacidad". Ambos tienen la misma capacidad con registros distintos. Kiske canta fuerte y alto. ¿Y qué mas le queda? ¿qué lo hace distinto de todos los miles que cantan igual? ¿el talento? porque demostró que no lo tenía hace ya años.
Escuchen Pink cream 69 y Unisonic por separado. La primera con Deris y la segunda con Kiske. Ahí se ven los reales talentos. Como se dice acá, en la cancha se miden los gallos.
Yup. I have to say that I agree. Entiendo español y concuerdo. Deris y Kiske son distintos, pero muchos suenan igual a Kiske.
estoy de acuerdo con tu comentario
No quiero que consideres mi comentario como un enfrentamiento al tuyo, al contrario, concuerdo en varios puntos. Pero, respondiendo a "¿Y qué mas le queda? ¿qué lo hace distinto de todos los miles que cantan igual? ¿el talento?" y más interrogantes, la respuesta es simple. Él fue el primero.
Por eso las copias, por eso el renombre, por eso "todos suenan como el", porque él suena como él y el resto quiere sonara como él. Y tampoco quiero desmerecer a Deris, me fascina como vocalista, encuentro que le da un toque bastante particular. Los ultimos discos me hicieron cabecear duro y fue por su voz en parte. :)
tu comentario está completamente lleno de razón, además, me gustaría añadir algo acerca de "Basta con ver quién siguió con Helloween y los llevó a lo que son hoy", ya que muchos de los "fanboys" (por así decirlo) de Kiske, lo admiran simplemente por los discos "Keeper Of The Seven Keys 1 y 2" esos 2 discos son, en mi opinión, los que le dieron fama y prestigio a Kiske, y gracias a que Hansen influyó mucho (sino es que en todo) para que Kiske quedara como vocalista de Helloween en ese entonces, pero oh sorpresa, sale Hansen de la banda, y Helloween va cayendo en picada, hasta que terminan por echar a Kiske (sin referirme a que Hansen era el alma de la banda). A qué llego con esto? A que sin Hansen, Kiske no es nada más que una "buena voz", y de haber seguido Kiske en Helloween, la banda sería lo que es hoy Unisonic, que no son malos, pero es exagerado decir que "son el verdadero Helloween", por estar Kiske a la voz. Helloween se cocina aparte, y siempre nos sorprende con cosas nuevas, y nunca ha decepcionado a nosotros los verdaderos fans. Básicamente Helloween no sería lo que es hoy, y sólo sería una banda que alguna vez existió, y habría quedado en el pasado, de no haber sido por el ingreso de Deris. P.D: Recuérdame invirarte una cerveza! xD saludos! :D
ahi le has dao!
It can't be compared like this, this is completely different of the their voice and song.
Anyway, I like Andi more, for personal.
Michael Kiske is the best singer in the world !
Andi is the Best Helloween singer ever! Love him ♡
Both are phenomenal!👍
Michael tiene una voz mas clara y melódica y puede llegar a notas mas altas, pero Andi tiene una voz con mas caracter para el metal es como el rugido de un leon! Los 2 son enormes talentos!!!
Kiske sounds with more power and more operatic. Deris is more versatile, perfect for metal, unique, has more control, better song writer, better front man and he's more loyal to the fans.
Both are in my top 5 singers of all time
Back in the day i would have said Kiske.But after watching them live at wacken a couple weeks ago i say Andi hands down.He really saved "a tale that wasn't right" among other songs.Kiske is running out of voice and breaths easily.
is difficult to choose one, both are notable singers, kiske has an incredible, highly technical speech quality, but nevertheless kiske not terribly different from the vast majority of power metal singers, maybe in that much better, and andi will not have the technique that has kiske, but has grown in all years at helloween, so sharp and has that tone that sets it apart from other power metal singers, listen to andi deris and can tell immediately this is andi, but hear kiske and I recognize that it is delayed in kiske. I think this wins the tug Andi Deris
too many words...you need only a few
"Deris live sucks"
Themis Spiliiotopoulos Amazing response XD -- τα είπες όλα με 3 λέξεις!
*****
is this an excuse bro? if he was professional he could have done everything not to fuck up his voice, look that fucking Meine of scorpions, pure professional
If kiske is not so different from other Power Metal singers this is because they want to ding like him. Deris tried but he cannot sing the old matetial...he has to sing more complicated...needs more different approaches to compensate....more entertainment as his voice lacks of quality.
***** i disagree...he has not the same volume. All keeper songs are written for kiskes powerful voice. Kiske filled the songs-we got the right-eagle fly free-i am alive-twilight of gods- Look at helloween songwriting nowadays...more complicated- the voice is not there so they work with moods- more complex melodies-different singing techniques...actually the songwriting is at some songs better. ..f.ex salvation -power. Deris sounds nice and interesting-kiske blows your mind and soul away.
You can not compare them, Deris or Kiske very different both in tone and in the manner of singing
I love the creativity of these men! They have wonderful voices! Thanks to them for my great mood to this day!
the best singer of helloween has been kai hansen...ever
Agree
Kai is Very bad
Michael Kiske is better than Andi Deris in every ways. Michael still have his amazing voice, Andi Deris sound like a sick grandma.
I love Michael Kiske.
A pesar del tiempo, Michael conserva su increible voz y él era quien hacia a Helloween tan diferente de las demás bandas, la voz de Michael es inolvidable, la de Deris no es tan única.
mas kiske quase fudeu com as banda
Kiske Lover
Karen Rockdriguez So sorry about your lover's but I Love ANDI ❤🤘
Karen Rockdriguez exactly.
Muji Jang no Kiske, no real helloween. Now i said that.
Both singers are awesome. !!!!! Rock on !!!!!
Kiske is the best
Michael Kiske
I prefer Andi Deris
ø anathema i prefer Kiske, who else fit best in helloween, noone.
Before everybody else start bashing or talking shit about Deris or saying how good Kiske is i just wanna say i love em' both.Both guys are special and unique in their own way.Both guys contributed a lot to the success of Helloween.Kiske might be a better singer than Deris but as a performer and a dedicated frontman,Deris definitely wins.For all u Deris haters/old Helloween fanatics out there,that was then,this is now.Love it or leave it.For a TRUE fan like me,FUCK the comparison!HELLOWEEN 4 LIFE
Halloween is my favorite bands, but in the era of the album after the walls of jericho Helloween very popular in the period, with Markus (bass), Hansen (guitar), Weikath (guitar), Kiske (vocals) and ingo (drums) make it popular even in the era of their bestselling album up their famous concert live in the UK makes the band became a huge success, but when derris era Helloween lost strength and prestige if they do not selaris first album, so I think Kiske better than derris
+Andy Eori you forgot to write the name of our lord, kai hansen..
Kiske has only 4 albums in with Helloween, Andi has 10 albums and he's still in Helloween so when we talk about them, we have more songs of Andi to choose from, but no matter how many albums they have, IN MY OPINION, Andi is better than Michael!!! Just one more thing: I don't wanna say that Michael has bad voice, actually, his voice is amazing, but Andi has better!
Truth has been spoken :)
+Danilo a Ehrr Every album with Kiske on vocals except for one have been considered a masterpiece. the best of Deris is perhaps gambling with the devil and thats just a really solid album but not quite keepers p1 or 2..
+Hector Escobar The Dark Ride is one of the best metal albums ever, Legacy same and we don't need to talk even about Better Than Raw, Straight Out Of Hell and My God-Given Right...
Andi Deris is an original singer with very unique voice which is not as good as in Kymera and PC69 years but look at Sebastian Bach, Axl Rose, Bruce, even Kai is not this kind of singer as he used to be (You need to know that Michi had a long break without any world tour...)
I need to say that I really love Michael Kiske's work but Andi Deris is the true Helloween singer and no one else. :)
Im sorry buy I have to disagree with you.. none of the albums you mentioned come close or at least have never been regarded as more than just solid efforts but Keeper 1 7 2 are the really trully inspirational ones
+Hector Escobar Ok, but need to say that this is just your opinion. Same that just mine opinion is that these albums are better. But that's normal that these opinions are different, mainly in the world of music.
Why do people always have to fight who is better? Kiske is good and andi is also good. Can we now shut the fuck up and listen to helloween guys?
I think Andi is better, because he has that "Something" in his voice that meke you could say his voice is unique, and he's greater and superior if we're talking about technique
You 're correct in most of your points, Bruce Dickinson is a baritone though and this is the reason why he sounds raspy on some high notes and why he uses more falsetto than most tenors.