As far as depictions in popular culture go, the ones from Jurassic Park and The Isle were very accurate for their time. And for now, Prehistoric Kingdom is doing an amazing job as well. The one from The Isle is based on a design where the sail continues further, towards the end of the sail. Scientists came up with that idea after looking at the sail of Acrocanthosaurus. A short-lived case of comparing apples and oranges.
How is it apples and oranges? It's NOT apples and oranges! We didn't know how long the spine extended, and we saw other spinosaurs having spines extending to the tail, like with suchomimus. At the time, it made sense and would still make sense now if we didn't have the evidence we have now. The function of the spines in both some spinosaurs and acrocanthosaurus overlapped in ways. Ignoring that, there's no reason to believe it's not possible that a giant spinosaur could have a giant spine that extends to the tail. Plenty of animals alive and extinct prove that that could happen.
Hi @ The moment you mentioned Suchomimus, I realised you missed my point. This is because Suchomimus is closely related to Spinosaurus. Although it is on the Baryonyx side of the family, I would have considered it a reasonable animal to compare Spinosaurus to. I once even believed it was the direct ancestor to Spinosaurus. Meanwhile Acrocanthosaurus evolved its sail separately from Spinosaurus, hence apples and oranges. They could have given Spinosaurus fewer fingers based on Tyrannosaurus. Plenty of animals alive and extinct prove that that could happen. I would like to make clear that if the idea was based on Suchomimus from the start, I would not have dismissed it as I did.
@DeinoSarcosuchus suchomimus was still a reasonable animal to compare to spinosaurus because it was more complete and more prominent as a spinosaur than anything on spinosaurus's side. It's still a spinosaur, so it's still a good enough comparison. We didn't know what the spines looked of spinosaurines or something. So, it was kinda up to the imagination. Also, you missed the point of the people who made that idea for the spine. They didn't think they were related. They saw convergent evolutionary similarities between both animals in their spines. They aren't the same but had some hypothetical similarities in how it was used. They both could've used them partially for Display. Ignoring that, because we couldn't know exactly what the spine looked like, and we pretty much only had well enough preserved dinosaurs with spines that extended to the tail to compare it to anything, it's not unreasonable to assume that, at the time, big spines on dinosaurs often extends to the tail. Like it's something that forms in a certain way, or it was something that could've happened, and it didn't affect anything. Nothing functionally changes when you extend the spine to the tail. It works the same, and it's consistent with some other spined animals. We didn't know what the spines of spinosaurines looked liked at the time. It's not unreasonable to assume they had similarities to the other spinosaurs. They all still had the same type of claws with the big claw on the big top finger and the same type of snouts with the notches and such. Even now, we still don't know exactly what spinosaurus's spine looked liked, with many paleoartists depicting spino with different types of spines. I'm not saying the acrocanthosaurus-like spine is still a valid idea, but you should understand why it was a reasonable idea at the time, as both could've had similarly extending spines in both different ways and some similarities. Taking acrocanthosaurus out of the equation, it still wasn't unreasonable at the time to assume spino had its spine reach the tail. Ideas can always be adapted from their original conception. Maybe the reason the people speculated the long spine was odd, but the idea of a long spine still was reasonable on its own at the time when using better comparisons. I realized towards the end how messy this comment is because I misread parts of your comment. So, sorry about that.
Hi@@william3100, I'd like to keep this short, because making a text wall felt like a waste of time yesterday. Suchomimus is indeed a reasonable animal to compare Spinosaurus to; I blame the scientists for not doing so in the first place.
Honestly same, just use the whole Jack Horner “Chickenosaur” concept and turn it into a Jurassic Park style story where the inaccurate/outdated designs are just old or alternate clones while the accurate ones are like the display versions they actually put into zoos and stuff
@@TamerGhaniKSW I like going with a dinotopia syle alternate hystory spec evo set in some ARK style giant arteficial habitat in space. On this timeline one of the sections of the habitat is where we evolved and every so many milion years another earth sized habitat opened up so the extant species can spread out and evolve without any old ones dying out. By the modern day the ecosystem is bigger and more compex than we can probably imagine and some of the species closely resemble the inacurate reconstructions of our world. Humans like us engage in trade with our neighbors the Neaderthals, Denisovans, and Raptors.
@@lexibyday9504 I do like that setting more but there's just too much to think about if you're trying to convince people (specifically me) that these are all naturally evolving features instead of random stuff slapped on cus it looks cool
@@TamerGhaniKSW just pair them to their closest real life look alikes and tweak them slightly to look like children of those. But yeah what is the apeal of such an idea to regular people who arent spec-evo or worldbuilders.
@@lexibyday9504Rename the inaccurate ones? Lol Rename the early to 70's 1900's ones to what? They look ridiculous by today's standards. And rename the robots and whatever else videogame twisted creature was there, to what? 90% is just simply bad interpretations of the same animal. Your comment doesn't make much sense.
My favourite will always be the planet dinosaur spino. I know we still don't know what it looks like, but I really like the theropod depiction with a sail and it being pescivorous too. Almost too perfect
Jurassic world monsters is something id never thought id see in the dino world. Love that game, wish there was a console version of it because i love dinosaurs and weapons like turok and ark
People Can Say What They Want But JP3 Spino Is The Best Representation Of How A Descendant Can Look Primal Carnage is awesome too The Isle Spino Went Under Reconfiguring and Now Looks Wow Arks Looks Decent But Could Use More Work
My favorite ones 0:28 0:40 0:51 0:59 1:21 1:45 Not really my favorite ones 1:31 weird 2:14 I’m not sayin this should be deleted. I’m not expecting the legs to be tiny. I was expecting the legs to be more larger/longer.
You forgot about landing for a time.And what are the latest movies had a spinosaurs. And I. Don't know if there was a spinosaurs in priastorec planet. Plus there's a UA-cam, her name dead.Sound that as a dinosaur series and he has spinosaurs and it looks really cool by the way.
Which Spinosaurus design do you like the most?
Can you do one of Evolution of Giganotosaurus please?
Ark
2001 Spinosaurus was the most iconic and striking figure.
@@NationChosenByGod yeah.
Prehistoric kingdom
JP3 is a classic
yes bro. It is iconic of spino
@@JurassicRim fr
It's like as he gets older, his gamer back gets more and more severe
As far as depictions in popular culture go, the ones from Jurassic Park and The Isle were very accurate for their time.
And for now, Prehistoric Kingdom is doing an amazing job as well.
The one from The Isle is based on a design where the sail continues further, towards the end of the sail.
Scientists came up with that idea after looking at the sail of Acrocanthosaurus. A short-lived case of comparing apples and oranges.
Oh, that's very useful information.
How is it apples and oranges? It's NOT apples and oranges! We didn't know how long the spine extended, and we saw other spinosaurs having spines extending to the tail, like with suchomimus. At the time, it made sense and would still make sense now if we didn't have the evidence we have now. The function of the spines in both some spinosaurs and acrocanthosaurus overlapped in ways. Ignoring that, there's no reason to believe it's not possible that a giant spinosaur could have a giant spine that extends to the tail. Plenty of animals alive and extinct prove that that could happen.
Hi @
The moment you mentioned Suchomimus, I realised you missed my point.
This is because Suchomimus is closely related to Spinosaurus. Although it is on the Baryonyx side of the family, I would have considered it a reasonable animal to compare Spinosaurus to. I once even believed it was the direct ancestor to Spinosaurus.
Meanwhile Acrocanthosaurus evolved its sail separately from Spinosaurus, hence apples and oranges.
They could have given Spinosaurus fewer fingers based on Tyrannosaurus.
Plenty of animals alive and extinct prove that that could happen.
I would like to make clear that if the idea was based on Suchomimus from the start, I would not have dismissed it as I did.
@DeinoSarcosuchus suchomimus was still a reasonable animal to compare to spinosaurus because it was more complete and more prominent as a spinosaur than anything on spinosaurus's side. It's still a spinosaur, so it's still a good enough comparison.
We didn't know what the spines looked of spinosaurines or something. So, it was kinda up to the imagination. Also, you missed the point of the people who made that idea for the spine. They didn't think they were related. They saw convergent evolutionary similarities between both animals in their spines. They aren't the same but had some hypothetical similarities in how it was used. They both could've used them partially for Display.
Ignoring that, because we couldn't know exactly what the spine looked like, and we pretty much only had well enough preserved dinosaurs with spines that extended to the tail to compare it to anything, it's not unreasonable to assume that, at the time, big spines on dinosaurs often extends to the tail. Like it's something that forms in a certain way, or it was something that could've happened, and it didn't affect anything.
Nothing functionally changes when you extend the spine to the tail. It works the same, and it's consistent with some other spined animals. We didn't know what the spines of spinosaurines looked liked at the time. It's not unreasonable to assume they had similarities to the other spinosaurs. They all still had the same type of claws with the big claw on the big top finger and the same type of snouts with the notches and such.
Even now, we still don't know exactly what spinosaurus's spine looked liked, with many paleoartists depicting spino with different types of spines. I'm not saying the acrocanthosaurus-like spine is still a valid idea, but you should understand why it was a reasonable idea at the time, as both could've had similarly extending spines in both different ways and some similarities.
Taking acrocanthosaurus out of the equation, it still wasn't unreasonable at the time to assume spino had its spine reach the tail. Ideas can always be adapted from their original conception. Maybe the reason the people speculated the long spine was odd, but the idea of a long spine still was reasonable on its own at the time when using better comparisons.
I realized towards the end how messy this comment is because I misread parts of your comment. So, sorry about that.
Hi@@william3100,
I'd like to keep this short, because making a text wall felt like a waste of time yesterday.
Suchomimus is indeed a reasonable animal to compare Spinosaurus to; I blame the scientists for not doing so in the first place.
Still wishing we could have all of them together in some dinosaur fantasy game or movie. Just rename the inacurate ones.
Honestly same, just use the whole Jack Horner “Chickenosaur” concept and turn it into a Jurassic Park style story where the inaccurate/outdated designs are just old or alternate clones while the accurate ones are like the display versions they actually put into zoos and stuff
@@TamerGhaniKSW I like going with a dinotopia syle alternate hystory spec evo set in some ARK style giant arteficial habitat in space. On this timeline one of the sections of the habitat is where we evolved and every so many milion years another earth sized habitat opened up so the extant species can spread out and evolve without any old ones dying out. By the modern day the ecosystem is bigger and more compex than we can probably imagine and some of the species closely resemble the inacurate reconstructions of our world. Humans like us engage in trade with our neighbors the Neaderthals, Denisovans, and Raptors.
@@lexibyday9504 I do like that setting more but there's just too much to think about if you're trying to convince people (specifically me) that these are all naturally evolving features instead of random stuff slapped on cus it looks cool
@@TamerGhaniKSW just pair them to their closest real life look alikes and tweak them slightly to look like children of those. But yeah what is the apeal of such an idea to regular people who arent spec-evo or worldbuilders.
@@lexibyday9504Rename the inaccurate ones? Lol Rename the early to 70's 1900's ones to what? They look ridiculous by today's standards. And rename the robots and whatever else videogame twisted creature was there, to what? 90% is just simply bad interpretations of the same animal. Your comment doesn't make much sense.
All the Spinosaurus look amazing!
I used to love the spinosaurus, but now that I've grown up and matured I now realize that I actually loved the t rex all along.
Model: AI generated
Yeah... we can tell.
My favourite will always be the planet dinosaur spino. I know we still don't know what it looks like, but I really like the theropod depiction with a sail and it being pescivorous too. Almost too perfect
The Spinosaurus from Dinosaur King, Monsters Resurrected and the one from Primeval the series were missing
Those should have been on there vs the transformer ones
Ah my man should’ve included the model from path of titans. Hands down the best one
Fr
How could you not include the Path of Titans spino? That's the whole reason I watched this video!
Lmao
How did you forget the Spinofaarus😔
(Jk, cool video!)
Despite the new appearance, Spinosaurus was a fighting Dinosaur
Best is prehistoric kingdom, most accurate and not some kind of monster
I think so too. Prehistoric Kingdom designed dinosaurs based on real data from modern scientists, as close as possible.
Agreed
Jurassic world monsters is something id never thought id see in the dino world. Love that game, wish there was a console version of it because i love dinosaurs and weapons like turok and ark
agree.
Legend of Spinosaurus
People Can Say What They Want But JP3 Spino Is The Best Representation Of How A Descendant Can Look
Primal Carnage is awesome too
The Isle Spino Went Under Reconfiguring and Now Looks Wow
Arks Looks Decent But Could Use More Work
I love jp3 design
Spino level 40 jurassic world the game🗣
Jurassic Monster World model is the best 😎
1:05 Looked like the Horizon Spino didn’t like the Age of Extinction One
for me Jurassic park III is iconic of spinosaurus
Amazing 😍😍
Don’t forget the Evolution of T. rex design from every movie, Tv Show and game.
The two with the flater tail at the end were the most likely.
2020 is super cuuuute i want to hug it
the colors of the raptor are awsome
Prehistoric kingdom is my fav dinosaur game
1:01 I don't think paleontologists thought that was a spino lol
hahaha
You forgot about the one from In Search of the Enchanted Valley 12
Can you do one of Evolution of Giganotosaurus please?
Ark giga finna eat the whole line up 😂😂
Yes! I was wanting this as well. My favorite is the one from Dino Crisis 2. Over 60 feet long and over 20 feet tall.
Well, there's one more need to be added into this video,the Dinosaur King's Spiny from SEGA.
My favorite ones
0:28
0:40
0:51
0:59
1:21
1:45
Not really my favorite ones
1:31 weird
2:14 I’m not sayin this should be deleted. I’m not expecting the legs to be tiny. I was expecting the legs to be more larger/longer.
That's great!
What about Primeval spino
Poor Scorn he was shot dead
JP 3 still has the best design for spino
Jurassic Park 3 Spino is the best
2001 .✨☕
Am I the only one that noticed he’s riding a raptor from ark?
what is the 2016 Spinosaurus Called
2:15 more like a Dimetrodon knockoff than a theropod
You forgot about landing for a time.And what are the latest movies had a spinosaurs. And I.
Don't know if there was a spinosaurs in priastorec planet. Plus there's a UA-cam, her name dead.Sound that as a dinosaur series and he has spinosaurs and it looks really cool by the way.
Thank you very much for your information.
What? No Spinofaarus? Then this is just incomplete...
0:44 actually that One Is from dinoraul
Where's Spimodrive from Cardfight Vanguard?
My favorite Spinosaurus design is Crayon Shin-chan the Movie: Our Dinosaur Diary.
0:30 Hi 87
Why is bro rideing a raptor from ark survival evolved😂
🤔 Spike? Jurassic the hunt video game
Makes evolution of allosaurus desing pls
cool idea
Less goooo
Goooooo!
What no Hyperendocrine spinosaurus?
No Dino Crisis 3??
Thr prehistoric kingdom spinosaurus was real
You missed Path of Titan’s Spino
That's true, this game model is very rare.
No Path of Titans?
Best was horizen and jw2
Imagine the 2001 design with the musclar body type of the design of 2016 combine and a perfect spinosaurus for dominion
1:53 what the fuck is that Monster
Evolution of t rex?
Not trying to be a negative nancy or anything but the one from transformers looks nothing like the one from the movie
is Transformers the game
@@JurassicRim ah fair enough i didnt know he was in a game
Lot of pokemon
Wheres path of titans spinosaurus
Where's Miaplacidus Dino crisis 3,monster ressurection, Primeval?
Oh yeah, how could I forget about that? .It's actually not easy to find models from legendary games.
I ain't watching that but did they have spinofarus or na