@kolbymartin9743 Either way, you slice it. Whether it's conflicts of current time on the multiple fronts or in times past; one thing remains true, war, war never changes.
Yes, Israel wronged them by supplying the entire Gaza strip with Food, Water, and Power while the Palestinian authority and Hamas used the humanitarian aide sent to them to stockpile weapons to murder Jews. Sounds to me like the Jews are definitely the ones who wronged the Palestinians. Do you even understand how stupid you sound?
@@JButterZJ you're absolutely delusional and have no grasp whatsoever on the very basics of history and power dynamics. Hamas is obviously is despicable organization, but Israel wronged Palestinians in thousands of ways.
I can't believe how bad the palestinian side must be to prop up someone as poor as finklestein. At the very least start propping up the actual historians. Avi shlaim, or Ilan pappe debating benny morris would be amazing. Finklestein is absolutely useless.
It's hard to empathize with people who poisoned fresh water systems near villages to kill or expel people from their homes to create "abandoned villages". You're being misinformed.
@@key5840Israel actually supports gender equality and doesn’t treat women like tools or cattle. The same can’t be said for Hamas, who forces women into burkas and prohibits them from exiting the home without a man’s permission
Its amazing how many topics you all expect him to cover in a 15 second YT short where he was asked one specific question that has nothing to do with your comment.
An "illegal settler", Jordan ethnically cleansed them in 1948, and they returned there in 1967 after the IDF liberated the occupied territory from the Jordanians. Study this conflict in full, it is not for nothing that it is considered the most complicated conflict in the world
@davidmr2121they don’t realize any of this. The far left has always been radically anti-semitic, whether under the guise of communism, fascism, or even neo-liberalism. Israel will always be their scapegoat for problems in the emulations of Mustache man and Lenin because it’s easy for people with no family value to rag on the most family-centric religion.
More like "If you stop supporting and electing a group who's mission statement had the 'Elimination of Jews' written in it, then Jews will be willing to make peace
It's funny how we became the aggressor in this story, the borders were equally set all the way back in 1948, until that point everyone was under the British mandate which, until after 45 actually showed favor to the local Arabs, Israel agreed to those borders, meanwhile the Palestinians and all surrounding nations raised their weapons with the intent of destroying us without letting even a day pass, had we surrendered back then, would they have shown mercy? At best they would send us out, throwing us to the world, and who would accept us? America? France? Britain? All so eager to play holier than thou, yet the moment that might be even of the slightest inconvenience to them they suddenly bite their tongue. If you care so much for the Palestinians and their well being, why don't you offer them your country to stay in? We've been providing them with water and electricity for over a decade now, surely you could do better.
@@RS-tz2zn prove to me Palestinians today aren't descendants of Israelites or even those before them.... even so, you don't see Native Americans claiming back USA from 300 years ago let alone "Israelis" claiming back land from 3000 years ago... besides only jews left Palestine thousands of years ago, Samaritans never left, they just converted and assimilated into the culture and region.. there is a reason why Israel doesn't use DNA as an argument, because they lose 100% of the time
@@Nirvana-For-All information at people's finger tips and they deny when palestinians speak for themselves.,.. is it virtue signaling or racist superiority? They tell the world that palestinian govts and the majority don't mean what they say, despite saying it repeatedly, despite raising their youngest to commit acts of terror, multiple state sponsored children programs that promote becoming shadeed that it is better to die than live in peace, in death they will become a bride in paradise. There were no worldwide protests when last summer gazans protested hamas and were gunned down, survivors imprisoned, some publicly executed... nor when fatah did the same the year prior. They do not care that 2 in 10 girls of the wb or 3 in 10 girls in gaza are forced into child marriage. also not uncommon since many of these child brides husbands are part of terror wings, to have had three husbands and multiple children by the age of 15. this is the way it must be argued, the financial burden or that they are "spoiled" sullied to families because simply saying it is wrong, speaking of developmental damage, is considered promoting western values and can lead to your imprisonment or execution nor how often boys are abandoned to the streets, if not sold into child labor. . . that most of tunnel dug were by boys under the age of 15, many interviews about deaths in collapsed tunnels. let alone when egyptians send poison gas thru or yes, bombing from israel, or hamas rockets that frequently fall in the area as well. There is the ban on birth control and abortion, the amount of back alley abortion death or other remedies that lead to problems. No, people do not care about this. They perceive Israel as a proxy of the west, many in the west believe if Israel falls, then so does the west and it will signal the communist revolution, the fall of western modernity and imperialism, leading to a worldwide utopia, well, after they take out all these anti-western but non-communists they have aligned with because of mutual hatred. Look up what palestinians say themselves, look up how they raise their children. Look up any palestinian rally for decades and compare to any other "Free" movement and see if you can spot the difference of how it is not a movement for palestinians but only one that screams for the death, death, death of its enemies, in every bloody nation they exist in, not just israel. Of course, there are palestinians that are not like this but you will see how those that speak of peace or so little as not call for the death of israelis are treated by the mob. It is not just Jews that are targeted either. you'll find most so called "model minorities" are... which incidentally, tend to be supporters of western values and democracy, if not their govts being official allies. much of the same tactics, levels of harassment and assault. all this is decades old. . . people don't ask much of palestinians, refuse the truths their govts, they, themselves say as a major because their supporters view them as sentient as wild animals, believe they are only acting in their nature and that everyone else must be better than them. . . what is palestinian culture but the call for death? A group of Israeli and Palestinian youth, a choir, was set to perform for The Kennedy Center, which set of children do you think was under more threat from their govt for doing so? pre-oct 7th, where were the most normalization organizations in Israel or among the territories where the majority of palestinians reside? spoiler: it's illegal for those kind of organizations to exist even in the west bank... and those that participate in these organizations risk being accused of being israeli spies and executed... especially if poor. If you have money, then you may be able to bribe your way out of it on top of fees you're likely already paying law enforcement to avoid harassment and trumped up charges... well, unless you are a member of one of the factions with actual power. Public welfare? most is provided by international orgs, what is offered through the govt, fatah or hamas, is pay for slay. . the palestinaian lotto, you will get the equivalent of welfare, if your child commits a terror act and they die in the act or are sentenced to a lengthy period. there is a stark economic dvide... most of the leaders and those of qualified ranks' families often go to uni in the west they claim to hate, and get treatments in tel aviv. it is not israel's responsibiility to do so, nor does israel have a history of extorting them or holding them hostage... when conflict is low, palestinians regularly take part. that was once true even with gaza, even when conflict comes and goes, and regular acts of terror at crossings, sometimes in israel itself. most do not even know palestinians have their own govts, they oddly believe israel controls all. and of course, they focus on jews alone, why is that? What do they call a palestinian that became an israeli? israeli. they don't acknowledge them at all, they call themt raitors, view them as scum, openly advocate for their deaths. . . this, too, even from their western allies.. albeit, so many of their western allies have not a single thought in their head, they repeat everything spouted from a microphone.
@@Nirvana-For-All why do palestinians need to steal images from syria or around the world and try to present it as their own? this so called pallywood.,. it happens all too frequently. Even before the advent of social media. Why is it necessary to fake or misappropriate images and videos?
If you call Israel’s attack a ‘murderous assault’ in light of the unprovoked terror attack en masse at civilians and hamas’s continuous barrage of rockets and small arms fire every day since, you have objectively lost the plot. That, or you are willfully blinding yourself to empirical reality. Hamas is screaming “look, look, they are killing us!” Even as they continue perpetuating aggressive warfare. All they have to do is stop provoking responses and they would stop getting them, but they insist on continuing to swat the hornets nest, then play on your sad little heartstrings for sympathy. I won’t call them pathetic. They have their strategy, whether or not it’s effective. I’m calling YOU pathetic. Your willful negligence to be informed on the topic and your willingness to buy into the pity party put on by international terrorists is laughable, and your argument shows the laziness of your position.
I like how you didnt dispute a single he said and instead tell us what he "should" be doing when in fact, youre not even doing what you should be doing in your life at this moment either. And if telling Shapiro what he should be doing is the most important thing in your life right now, then youve got some things to evaluate.
@@DrummerJacobNo problem, I can tell you exactly why he is just making a shit show. His whole argument is simply shifting focus. He was asked about Palestinians, not Gazans, and he proceeds to answer with “Hamas this, Hamas that”. Guess what, Hamas is only ruling a small chunk of Palestinian land. West Bank is 4 times bigger than Gaza Strip, and it’s not ruled by a “terrorist government”, yet for some reason, they are still getting discriminated, killed, and they’re houses get destroyed by bulldozers. Does Benny Boy feel bad about them as well ? Their government doesn’t fight back, but it doesn’t look like they are prospering, because as far as I can tell, more and more settlements are getting built, and more Palestinian houses are getting demolished by IDF bulldozers. Also West Bank is officially designated by UN as a territory under military occupation. Guess which military is occupying it. So, are you satisfied now ?
Many israelis keep killing palestinians, burning or stealing their homes in the West Bank. Actually everyone agrees (even israel) about the situation in the West Bank being illegal settlements. Everyday some american or european who recently came and could not afford a house, just decides to steal it instead. You should educate yourself.
@@adelalmohtaseb5261 to what? Hamas is all over the region - in west bank, Lebanon - it's the biggest headache of the Palestinian authority. My sources? 20 years of living in Israel and living it all. I believe you can find it in Google. For me this is what I live since I was born. This is my source. I was also a teen when buses exploded here. Sources? The blood of my friends being exploded on their way to drink coffee with friends.
@@affebanane3039 what is your viewpoint on Britain killing innocent Germans in WWII? many children were killed, should it have surrendered to Germany then?
Uh, no. Israel withdrew all Jews from the Gaza strip in 2005 and no Jewish person has lived there since. Israel turned the land over to the Palestinians, and look what they've done with it.
@@funveeable Some people say the world started last Thursday. It's an interesting philosophical theory. Other stoners think this war starter on October 7th . Let's all forget the 70+ years of Israeli occupation of the Palestinian land
@@AbderrahmanFodililet's also forget the decades and hundreds of millions Palestine got, that went into weapons to attack Israel. Let's also forget Hamas publicly stating his only objective is the destruction of Israel. Let's also forget the only reason Israel isn't bombarded daily is because they built an anti rocket system. Let's forget about anything that is not convenient for my small world view, and let's spout nonsensical garbage that shows an insanely little understanding of the topic, and of real life. Can you tell what part of Palestine was occupied, and when did the occupation start?
@@HaloNeInTheDark27 all what you've described here is Palestinian trying to fight for their freedom. Israel got more than a 100 billion dollars support from the USA while the millions you mentioned went straight to Abbas pocket and his corrupt traitors. Palestinian government. Nothing went to Hamas or the people of Gaza The Jews lived peacefully in Palestine before 1947 they owned land and had Palestinians IDs. But in 1947 the Zionist gangs started killing Palestinians and removing them from their homes and land and declared their new state on the graves of Palestinians. That's what started it all. All I'm doing here is listing facts and I'm not trying to belittle anyone. The information out there. You just need an open mind and some curiousity
Same thing man, you can’t draw a differentiation from the armed forces of a people and the people who voted and cheered for them, you don’t get to be the victim after you’ve celebrated murder
@@valorath6797 that's hardly the point. I'm not saying to not critique the people. Those are two different questions with two different answers. When asked about citizenry, you talk about the citizens. When asked about Hamas, you refer to Hamas. They're not the same thing, literally not. You can certainly draw a distinction. Firstly, you're presupposing 100% of them voted for Hamas. Secondly, children didn't vote. Thirdly, they were voted in almost 20 years ago, some adults didn't even vote for them. Lastly, you can't assume they were all out there celebrating, and if they were, you don't know who was doing it in fear of being targeted for not celebrating; we saw the same thing in a dozen despotic regimes. This is all irrelevant. Because the point is, he wasn't asked about Hamas. If we're so dogmatic that we're not prepared to have an honest conversation about this, then people can't be taken seriously, because they don't actually have an opinion, they have talking points. Parrots have talking points also, from what they heard their owners say. I'm not in the business of talking to birds, whether they have wings or opposable thumbs.
@@jimmyjimmy7240 same logic goes for pro Hamas supporters like Bassam, when asked if he condemns the actions of Hamas or supports Hamas they can’t answer, funny how they can turn a blind eye and everyone supports it
@@valorath6797 sure, if you want to have a conversation about that we can, but we're not. I critiqued Ben. You're actually just proving my point. Shifting the conversation doesn't mean you're actually giving an argument. That's what children do. "Tommy, you broke the lamp." - "Well, Jenny spilled the milk last night!" When discussing Hamas, discuss Hamas. When discussing Israel, discuss Israel. When discussing Palestinians, discuss Palestinians. When discussing Israelis, discuss Israelis.
he literally did, you're just trying to use really bad mental gymnastics. you Tryna say he's wrong? that hamas ISNT oppressing and stealing from palestinians? YOURE being dishonest with yourself for straight up ignoring what ben said and somehow not recognizing that he answered the question directly. you have severe cognitive dissonance if you think he avoided the question.
His final statement is telling as to who currently has all the power and how they hold it! Talking about peace with Israel without talking about the costs is misrepresenting how "simple" the solution is!
I need the disgusting person to debate Hijab or someone knowledgeable like him and not hide behind those college students may Allah the almighty make it possible
So sad that they have to live under Hamas. Good that they have the Israeli state and military to protect them, as they have been doing since okt 7. The reason for closing down food, water, fuel and medicine into Gaza is to help the Palestinian people. And all the settler colonies are they just grateful for. What would they do without the IDF?
Imagine being so entitled that you think you should continue to get resources from your neighbour right after you crossed into there backyad and killed one of there children. How dare they not let you mooch off there electricity, water, wifi and raid there fridge whenever you want. Also aid for food is still being allowed into the gaza but you're probably referencing the 500 trucks going down in numbers, which means you blatantly leave out the fact that those trucks included many non essential things like commercial, not just food.
Can someone ask Ben to explain what happened in Palestine between 1947 and 1987 and how that relates to the conflict with Hamas? Genuinely feel like most people intentionally leave that part of history out of the conversation.
Yes. I think his most dislikable quality is he seems to revel in making other people look stupid which I think is not a pleasant quality. But as far as I can tell, he backs up everything he says. I strongly disagree with many of his stances, but I have a lot of respect for him. And as far as his take on the Israel situation I think he’s spot on. (Also I fact checked the “AI generated image” he posted. It’s not AI generated. You can put the image through the ai or not generator and it says it’s human generated. So keep in many people lie and thousands more believe things that aren’t true just bc it lines up with beliefs they already had.)
@alexandraratliff7904 no Ben loves to dance around the subject. People don't like him because he has alot of zionist view. Let's not forget he called all Palestinians are terrorists and a plague and that they only know how to destory. People also hate him because to him israel can not do any wrong in his eyes. When the UN themselves are saying that israel is and has broken international Geneva conversation laws, using white phosphorus. He also loves to diluent history for his own narrative. Let's not forget how israel massacred Palestinians in Lebanon in 1982. They said it was to defend there borders yet went 50 miles into Lebanon and shot and bombed thousands of Palestinian refugees in a refugee camp. The thing is that now everything is documented which means they can't just lie to us anymore, we are seeing what they're doing and how they're breaking international law. So yes people have every right not to like Ben, his been talking for Years now, just go back and see some of the things he said, I'm sure you wouldn't feel the same about him
Ben Shapiro called Rand Paul an antisemite for suggesting the US should fund Israel less. That's it. Ben is a joke of a human being. His allegiance is to Israel, not the US.
3 months , I still haven't heard of trees saying that " there is jew behind me " Where is Lah? (AL -translate to great lah is name together al-Lah) Why didn't he send his angels?
@@vishaldiwakar2582 pajit you need to wait until the anti christ arrives. And 70,000 Jews embrace the Antichrist as their God. Then that event will take place
@@BroMan-vm5gtwere they actually try to seem smart? Or were they actually being smart, and you disliked it so you labelled them as such to seem smart yourself?
no, hamas isn't hiding there it's a known fact that there's Hamas terrorists and islamic jihad terrorists in the west bank. it's funny seeing how fast you guys are trying to hide it since the real face of Hamas is now revealed to the entire world. plenty of Hamas in the west bank, and it's not a secret either@@bingbeepboop
@@JGlennFL 1. The Palestinians in the west bank are abused. 2. Regardless of whether the palestinians there support or are against hamas does not justify what they have to suffer on the daily.
So your solution to the "oppression" is to violently and regularly conduct targeted attacks on civilians? How does that make any sense. When you are losing a fight you are supposed to negotiate for a peaceful resolution. Its how it worked for every single conflict throughout history. Palestinians jihadist religious attacks and brainwash insnt gonna lead anywhere but more bloodshed and will worsen your suffering and will lead to Israel activating more sanctions on you (what you call "oppression"). You are literally bashing your head in a brick wall.
@@notinterested8452Woe to those that call evil good. You have no idea what is really happening. Research Israel and what they have done to the Palestinians. Research how many pedophile's live in Israel. Israel is not what you think. They are the fake Jews and Israel was never meant to be a country. It was a person's name and his people.
They litteraly believe God wont come back if there is a single nonjewish person in Israel because of an old book, they also learn how to discuss that subject in public, fascism and mass manipulation
I say this as an Israeli Citizen. There is A LOT of things Isreal needs to fix and work out. We got Illigal settlements (of jews), which cause problems for all the legal arab settlements. Do to constant attacks, security is so high in the country that some people cannot freely move around the country without getting stopped and investigated. I'm talking about Arab citizens. They live in country. They are citizens. But when the emergency level rises, some cant make it to their jobs in the city. It's a major issue. Not for anything they did, but because some bad apples pulled some nonsense, Israel over corrects and treats them like second hand citizens. On a funny side of it. We have aram citizens in government. There was a story about one of them not being able to get to office because all arabs were being stopped at the checkpoints. Imagine being askd for your ID when your face is on a billboard 40 ft away
Zero accountability for what? For defending yourself against racist, genocidical maniacs who shoot rockets into your civilian area made of waterpipes so to make your own people die of thirst?! I am not a jew and I can still understand the facts -- your comment is what zero thought looks like.
Are Palestinians ever accountable for the bombings, murders, rapes, stabbing, shootings that occurred in Oct 7th and the countless times before then? Arabs/palestinians start every Arab/israeli conflict
Live under the thumb of Hamas? Who controls Gaza's water, food, medical aid, home construction, right to have an airport, right to a water port, and fishing? Not Hamas. And who controls the West Bank? Not Hamas.
When I see a child crying in the street is it not my job to offer help and support to stop the child from suffering? But from your logic I’m now the person causing that child cry in the first place.
why is it israels responsibility to provide gaza with water, electricity and fuel? Did you know they get these are freebies from Israel? Why cant they spend their aid to benefit the people so they are not reliant on Israel ?
@@hectictube123 You may not be familiar with the situation. Gazans are not allowed to build their own power grid, their own airport, fish from their own ports. They are in an open air prison under the control of Israel. Yes, if Israel let them live freely all of these things will exist in Gaza without them.
1) it’s not a prison as people leave, 21k through Rafa crossing in 2021 2) Egypt closed its crossing for 5 years and reopened it to less traffic in 2018. Not an open border due to security issues like Israel. 3) no one is screaming about Egypt imposing restrictions on Gazans. Egypt is 90% Muslim.
Extend your vision. Israel does not seem to mind being surrounded by 400 million hostile neighbours. Even if they do, they are not complaining. They existential reality can not be built on hate, but contingency demands preparedness to confront all eventualities, including armed defence to terrorism.
@@stephenl9463It is staggering how little you know about the subject you are commenting on...... One simple question here, given your expertise: How can a Gazan go to West bank to visit his or her family?
Yet Hamas has control of Gaza since 2006. Hamas is responsible for their people who voted them into power. Yet they buy rockets to kill instead of helping the people. While the leaders of Hamas live a life of luxury in Qatar and other countries like Turkey. Stop with your stupidity and open your eyes.
If they did they wouldn’t be able to have a complete tunnel network and huge weapons arsenal let alone make such a grand barbaric attack 21 days ago. Your comment is too obviously biased and ignores very simple facts that have no two sides
Arabs living in Israel are totally free, there are able to do everything jews can including becoming doctors ,nurses ,judges, politicians, serve in the idf or police, own properties
Not inaccurate though. Israel Stepped out of the Gaza strip in 2005. Israel even offered (multiple times) to give them 95% of the west bank so long as they make peace. Hamas has always declined, and responded with rocket fire. Rockets, which are built and constructed in gazan schools, Hospitals and residentional areas. They consistently will fire thousand of rockets, just to keep the fighting going. It is theorized that 1 in 9 of ever rocket barrage also misfires, hitting their own. The biggest threat to Gaza is literally Hamas. A group that has turned away from every olive branch, every deal, every offer of peace. Hamas has no intention of peace, and the Palastinian people in Gaza are the ones who suffer for it.
@@overeasy9920 you immigrated to another country and kick them out from their houses by force and when they complain you tell them its all their fault. Yeah thats gaslighting
@@yazeedmalki1262 What country? During the time of mass immigration of Jews, it was ruled by the ottomans and the British later in history. In the UN partition plan, Palestine would’ve for the first time in history be created as a state entity yet the Palestinians rejected the deal…
😂😂 Who the fuck is occupying Palestine? Palestine throws rock at Israel everytime they get a chance ....And you want Israelis to leave them alone? If only Palestine wanted peace there would be no war...Both Palestine and Israel would have lived peacefully
Haha he’s correct. Newsflash Hamas didn’t even exist when the Jews started killing children and stealing land from 1948 until now. Hamas just came in 1988. So it’s obvious that with or without Hamas, the Jews where killing and etnic cleansing the Palestinians. Want more proof for the dumb people around us?? Google the Pale map from 1948 till now and you will see clearly who the real oppressor is.
don't take him too seriously! he is possessed by the devil! He also has no pity for Palestinians, he only said that to shift the blame for the conflict onto Hammas and away from Israel! these are profoundly evil people! You can't talk to them! He also shakes his head when he talks like he's totally crazy!
Israel's racism against 50% of the doctors, engineers and workers? racism against 28% of the whole population? there are only 2 racists in the government and they get protested against whenever there's a chance
Sorry,but there Arabic people have the same rights as other people. There are a lot of businesses ,policemen, politics, judges, and so on.All the best.
The fact people still can’t distinguish that disavowing Hamas and calling out their corruption and cold blooded murders doesn’t mean not empathising with the plight of innocent Palestinians, is really sad.
@@amyzonkers7568 Ah, you beat me to it. I think it's dumber that people try to separate the two in a discussion. Even among the non-Hamas Palestinians, most of them still hate Israel and the Jews.
Pretty much. Palestine has only even existed in its current form because of the Mandate of Palestine that the British Government created. Before then the land did not belong to the Palestinians. It was a land called Judea, want to know why it was called Judea? Ever heard of Judaism? ahhh, right. I forgot. Facts are inconvenient to the point you are trying to make. My bad, ill stop making you look stupid. Though you certainly are good enough at making yourself sound stupid without my help.
No Palestinian ever ruled the land 😂. Palestine is nothing more than a Roman construct based off of colonizing judea. LITTERALLY the Al asqua mosque is biult on top of the Jewish mount
@@ginger4ever643because apparently they're the one who killed those people on the music festival, also they also killed their own people who got capture by Hamas. They doesn't care about innocent on both sides
@@Google.Is.Skynet yes, they are being forced against their will to celebrate when Jewish people are raped, burned alive and beheaded. They are truly innocent, they have no choice, right? And especially given the fact that Israel pulled out of Gaza completely in 2005, Israel hasn't occupied that land at all since, and they have no reason to have any issues with Israel. Accept because they can't control their Jew hatred and are desperate to massacre Jews.
@@Google.Is.Skynet The alternative was to choose a regime that would develop Gaza into flourishing territory that won't steal millions of dollars of aid. Hamas leadership is living in luxury while average Gazan is suffering because of their parents, grandparents stupidity to elect terrorist Hamas 🤡
Also keep in mind that when they "voted" for Hamas, most of the Palestinians who live there today weren't old enough to vote yet, and a lot weren't even born yet. So before you blame all the Palestinian people for the actions of the Hamas, don't forget the fact that Israel is retaliating against non-combatant civilians, including children, who have nothing to do with the conflict.
@@Noone-uw3mk That’s Hamas not Israel. Hamas is the one who’s using civilians as human shields and preventing anyone from leaving. Israel’s doing everything in its power to minimize civilian casualties.
@@hotshotbrave Israel is applying collective punishment over the Palestinian people, and although the actions of the Hamas are undeniably wrong, it doesn't justify the Israeli response and doesn't take their blame away for committing war crimes in Gaza.
@@Noone-uw3mkHamas has no moral code so why should Israel? Sick of all this goody two shoes rubbish. Israel should do whatever it needs to do to protect their country and not pay any attention to the useless United Nations
@@jlskywalker Hamas was set up then aided and abetted by Israel to as opposition to the PLO. And Im pretty sure every humantarian group and the UN, have described Gaza as an Open Air Prison. That's on Israel. BS is awful, because he is so biased and used reductive talking points to obscure the reality of the complicated history and situation of Palestine. And the Palestinians did put down their guns in the West Bank, and Israel continues its incursion into the West bank with settlements and evictions of Palestinians.
Back it up w facts … Ur intelligence n common sense is questionable if u feel what Hamas did on 7th october was valid… Also u have a weak argument like the many others who go back to 1948…
@@jlskywalkerhe used ai images of burned toddler to dehumanize people. He has a long history of making racist comments. He also makes historically dumb statements
The son of Hamas Mossab, grew up close to the hamas leaders, his father is one of the founders of hamas. He heard their conversations and fone calls: He said once in a while, Mammoud Abbas calls the Hamas leaders and says, quote: Let's sacrifice some children, because they do an attack and get bombed back by Israel. But they know that the money faucet will be running after...
If israel was a muslim country there would be no wars, and the palestinians would have no problem living in worse conditions than they have before the war. It's not about oppression, it's not about land, when will you people understand? it is an agenda of muslims to take over, it will occur in the US it will occur in europe, anywhere.
Well people do tend to leave out Palestine literally attacked and made war against Israel BEFORE the west bank was occupied. What did they think would happen? When you lose a war you started there are consequences
@@amazinkay4512 selective memory first of all Palestinian never went to war as they never had a army . In 1967 Egypt and Syria went. To war with Israel due to forcefull removal of Palestinians that was going on from 1947 . Your argument is typical to a Zionist mentality. By your logic Jews deserve what happened to them under the nazis because they lost and can not fight back .
Thousands of children in israeli prisons, illegal settlers taking even more the west bank, storming religious sights on a whim while beating the all that resist.....not mention the people that die every day in the west bank that has no Hamas and the years of oppression that they went through..... I can see how hate and revenge piled up to give us this event
But before that Jews were not allowed to pray at there temple Muslims took their religious place. And the nearest they were allowed is the west wall but not climb the stairs, and they received inhuman treatment, that's how they became cruel.
@@033jayprakashnayak7 do we both live in the same earth??.....the Jews after the BALFOUR declaration were equipped with the weapons and the means to take control of the inhabitants of Palestine.....how do you think they managed to kill all the villages like Dir Yassin...etc. the jews were never on the defensive, they came with the aide of Britain and the US to take palestine by force.....i don't know how can you say they were wronged by the Muslim arabs where it a fact that under the ottoman rule jews had rights no other christian ruler gave to a degree many named it t"he golden age of jews"...and who was it that brought the jews back to Jerusalem other that Umar Ibn El-Khattab when he conquered it around 630~ CE from Patriarch Sophronius who was a christan ruler that killed all jews when he ruled Jerusalem. Umar and was surprised to notice no jews where there so he ordered for Jewish families to be brought back and live in Jerusalem........the thing with Zionists is that they have no shame to point fingers at Islam that gave them human rights at times when they had non and embrace those that see them as a business deal (christians namely Biden who explicitly named the creation of Israel the best business deal the US has ever made...)
Israeli has a mountain next to Gaza where Israelis bring popcorn and watch Gaza getting bombed calling it a firework event, that was happening since 2010 and still is, even Israeli mocks Palestinian in their twitter acount, how blind are you peopl like seriously
@@033jayprakashnayak7 your president(Netanyahu )said that some Muslims guy convinced hitler to do the holocaust, 😂😂 I know westerners are dumb but to an extent , read history from inside of the conflict not the outer shell
That is when you're an ignorant and a hypocrite to only support Palestinians. With all the atrocities caused by Muslims against the Israelis for decades, they are too kind to those Palestinians.
@@wownewstome6123Israel is an apartheid ethnostate occupation of Palestine That's it, if you support Israel you support occupation You don't get to fight anyone who kills you and takes your land because you support it Resist and you're an anti-Semitic terrorist
Thats because it is .the irealis didnt shoot themselves or rape themselves so who did .another hypocrite that has a selective memory .be a long time before you supporters of murders wash off the stink of guilt many remember what hamas did .just because you would like to forget it many dont
He has no empathy for the Palestinian. One second into answering, he spoke around the party in Palestine and israel, apparently his concern is mainly about the existance of Israel, never about Palestinian people. "I am getting really sick of people who whine about 'civilian casualties'... when I see in the newspapers that civilians in Afghanistan or the West Bank were killed by American or Israeli troops, I don't really care". Wikipedia and study about Ben Shapiro, this is what he said before.
@@geodarnodan6750 I don't sympathize with Islamic jihad, I don't sympathize with hamas, I don't sympathize with PLO, I don't sympathize with fatah, I don't sympathize with PA, I don't sympathize with DFLP, I don't sympathize with PFLP, they deserve Nuremberg trials, not sympathy. Don't support modern Nazis like an idiot, support the victims, and go educate yourself!
So basically someone occupied your house and asked you to negotiate a peace deal with them. That’s what you mean right? Do people think or read at all? Sigh
So basically someone occupied your house and asked you to negotiate a peace deal with them. That’s what you mean right? Do people think or read at all? Sigh
L rug so when we bomb Country we are trerrorist but when other people bomb like Israel do to us they are not terrorist?it’s always foreign people or Muslim country’s
As an American I don't know how we can excuse iraq and Afghanistan and then have any opinion on what Israel does if we were to actually go after the people during 9/11 we would have been in Saudi Arabia
I don't excuse Iraq or Afghanistan, you do? I never wanted military bases in SA; our meddling was the impetus for 911. We are a superpower without all of this geopoliticking- we are essentially sacrificing ourselves to protect Europeans from RU's sphere of influence- this debacle is more of the same: our carriers are out there preventing Arabs from exerting their influence on a region that's objectively theirs. Why? Because Europe depends on the Suez/Mediterranean for goods.
@@asdfbeau I'm saying maybe we should mind our goddamn business has nothing to do with us The only people that speak about this with emotion or the Jews and the Muslims everybody else doesn't give a crap
@@joshuabeebe3886you do know the reasons you guys are involved in Middle East is to preserve oil ressources not the protection of Suez ??? You literally supported nationalization of Suez so tf ur saying
They are not occupied, they have declined numerous offers of cohabitation. They have created no production or economy with $$$$$$ aid instead voted? For dictatorship and purchasing arms and subjected thier children to intergenerational war. The Israelis exited Gaza. Palestinian people have done nothing with the space ever since but live in spite and hate. Look at that ocean every opportunity to build a tourism destination no different to the Saudis. Or a free Democracy like Israel. They have chosen instead to support terrorist and all that comes with it. He is correct free the hostages, Hamas surrender that will deliver the state to Palestinians. I sympathise with the Palestinian people it's clear that they live in the equivalent of North Korea they are oppressed but not by Israel.
@@Yahweh_is_king_ He wasn't talking about the babies. But as soon as the babies learn to talk, they will be taught to hate Israel and the United States. Right?
@@TheShalalaiThe oslo accord it was agreed but Isreal does not care and kept colonising and taking there land throwing them out of there homes and creating an aparthide for them where they have no rights. You dont absue and massacre people you want peace with. Palistinains are the crazy ones waiting for some solutions while Isreal keeps massacring and taking the land.
Israrl gave West Bank to Pal Auth in 1993 Oslo accords, then removed all Israeli military and civilians from Gaza in 2005. Peace attempts were disaster as a result of Pal sickness to commit genocide. Sorry you don't know history
@@yochevedbrachasimon4979 What a joke so you continue throwing people out of their homes in the west bank and lynching people while claiming peace. Nuts. Osco Accords meant leave but they never did instead became more brutal and now force Palestinians in an apartheid. Even the UN official has resigned from all the sickining shit Isreal is doing. Be a human for god sake.
This is so similar to “let’s bring democracy in Iraq” or “let’s bring democracy into Afghanistan”. It s so EASY to radicalise people and it’s so EASY to fund terrorists and sacrifice a few civilians here and there for the sake of justifying war for a noble cause. Leave children alone!
There is no Hamas in the West Bank but thousands Palestinians killed there by Israeli terrorists. You’re just an another bot who listen to this type of hypocrites blindly
Palestine is threatened by their leaders who steal from them, kill them, and use them as human shields. When these “leaders” are destroyed, these people will be free forever, and Israel should stop providing water, fuel, and health care, and let them take care of themselves. Israel should only protect the small minority that wants to live in peace. The ones who hate Israel should not receive these things because they are not willing to live in peace in what is historically Israeli territory since before the Roman Empire. I wish Arabs would stop hating other Arabs, and blaming everything on Jews, when everyone knows Hamas blew up that hospital, and it was Hamas who shut off the water so they could use the pipes to make more weapons.
From Hamas and the Palestinian Islamic Jihad. You're a sweet girl. I like BTS too. Don't let them lie to you. I am not Jewish but I know Hamas are evil and only..ONLY attacks civilians. That is NOT WAR. They go around in street clothes. They are NOT soldiers because in war soldiers wear uniforms...that's a rule. They don't tell you the truth. And Hamas beheads people. Do you understand? Israel doesn't behead people. Hamas then runs home and hides among their civilians! That's a cowardly move. Palestine are suffering because of one group. Hamas.
How many generations should people live somewhere before they call in home. By your logic, should France be able to forcibly and violently remove all Muslim citizens even the ones born there? Calling people thieves 100 years after they were allowed to immigrate by the controlling empire at the time. Now if you wanna talk about returning the West Bank to Jordan sure. You wanna talk about requiring removing settlers or stopping expansion in the West Bank as a requirement for aide, cool. But Oct. 7 kind of destroyed Israelis incentive play nice.
Also in 67 the surrounding arab countries wanted to launch a war on Israel and destroy it but israel launched and surprise attack instead so it was only self defense. Most of the land that they conquered during the war they gave it back.
@@NemilNihil again most Jews lived there already and when people started talking about thr creation of Israel the Arabs declared a war, lost it and lost the land.
@@gertaro the arabs never had the land to begin with. For the longest time it was part of the ottoman empire until britain got it after ww1 and just gave it to the Jews basically because of ww2. So again, how does this justify commiting war crimes against the Palestinian people?
Makes me think of the separation between the Taliban and the people of Afghanistan. There are always good people in each nation, but when terrorists rule a region all hell brakes loose, and ALL sides suffer.
The West has a wonderful way of labeling legitimate government in the Middle Eastern nations as "terrorist organizations." Of course, they simply take the lead of Israel, whoever they label "terrorists" are now considered as such by America. Did you know that the Taliban offered America a deal, to allow prosecution of Osama Bin Laden to take place on the condition that America presents actual evidence of his involvement? Another part of the offer was that America would stop their bombardment of civilian populations (our terrorism is the good kind of terrorism, y'know). Of course, America rejected this offer. Not suspicious at all why they would reject it. Must be we love to use our military to get our way or that we had no actual evidence to produce any solid proof Osama was involved.
![ПОЛНАЯ ИСТОРИЯ ЭКЗОРЦИЗМА [Топ Сикрет]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qBySr6Bt0B8/mqdefault.jpg)
This whole war and the world view on it is the literal definition of “Those who forgets history are doomed to repeat it”
Exactly 💯
Nah, unfortunately remembering history is the source of this conflict this time.
@kolbymartin9743 Either way, you slice it. Whether it's conflicts of current time on the multiple fronts or in times past; one thing remains true, war, war never changes.
That's all war.
Hey look....a propagandized fool
He is literally physically unable to admit Israel has wronged Palestinians. He's so pathetic.
Because they didnt
Yes, Israel wronged them by supplying the entire Gaza strip with Food, Water, and Power while the Palestinian authority and Hamas used the humanitarian aide sent to them to stockpile weapons to murder Jews. Sounds to me like the Jews are definitely the ones who wronged the Palestinians. Do you even understand how stupid you sound?
@@JButterZJ you're absolutely delusional and have no grasp whatsoever on the very basics of history and power dynamics. Hamas is obviously is despicable organization, but Israel wronged Palestinians in thousands of ways.
Because they never have !!!
And I guess you just know nothing...
Ben need to debate Norman Finklestein
💯on🎯 Unbelievable when
the Palestinians are living under
the thumbs of the Israeli!
What a moron!
Norman talks slow and is honest, Ben talks fast and lies ...
Bens not ready for Norm we all know that
I can't believe how bad the palestinian side must be to prop up someone as poor as finklestein. At the very least start propping up the actual historians. Avi shlaim, or Ilan pappe debating benny morris would be amazing. Finklestein is absolutely useless.
Ben is stupid, but is not fantastic moron like mr Borrelli to debate Norman.
It's like hearing a sexual predator say their victims refusal to have sex is the root cause of rape.
This is one of the wildest takes I’ve seen In a while. You make yourself seem dumb af if that is the comparison you’re gonna make to this clip 😂😂
Awful comparison, even if you supported Hamas
So true….why people listen to this low grade and closed minded brain?
@davidmr2121learn history bro…….fly overseas sometimes help your brain, mind, and intellectuality…..
Well said
It's hard to empathize with people who dance in the street while parading a dead naked womans body in the street.
It's hard to empathize with people who poisoned fresh water systems near villages to kill or expel people from their homes to create "abandoned villages". You're being misinformed.
Truth
Then why you support israel?
@@key5840easy, it's a democracy, the land belongs to Israel. Palestinians are troublemakers!
@@key5840Israel actually supports gender equality and doesn’t treat women like tools or cattle. The same can’t be said for Hamas, who forces women into burkas and prohibits them from exiting the home without a man’s permission
Let's imagine a place where's no Hamas.
Let's call it West Bank 😅
they're there as well, FYI
Absolutely! Hamas didn’t exist in 1948!
@@blu3hawkgaming720No. It's the PA in West Bank. Gaza is Hamas' domain.
When you realise that Hamas is also in the west bank 🫥🫥🫥
@@Si_Mondonah man, hamas is also there regardless of the PA
Remember guys, higher degrees don't make you more educated.
And being muslim doesn't make u victim.
And being pro Palestinian doesn’t mean you have a brain
And having a brain does not make "you" smart
Actually, they do
Is amazing how Shapiro dont talk about the illegal settlers on the west bank
Its impossible to not be biased about something like this.
Its amazing how many topics you all expect him to cover in a 15 second YT short where he was asked one specific question that has nothing to do with your comment.
An "illegal settler", Jordan ethnically cleansed them in 1948, and they returned there in 1967 after the IDF liberated the occupied territory from the Jordanians. Study this conflict in full, it is not for nothing that it is considered the most complicated conflict in the world
@davidmr2121they don’t realize any of this. The far left has always been radically anti-semitic, whether under the guise of communism, fascism, or even neo-liberalism. Israel will always be their scapegoat for problems in the emulations of Mustache man and Lenin because it’s easy for people with no family value to rag on the most family-centric religion.
How are they illegal? Because they're Jews in Arab Land?
"If you just submit, there will be peace." - Every aggressor.
"unlike cruel Leonidas who demand that you stand, I require only that you kneel"
More like "If you stop supporting and electing a group who's mission statement had the 'Elimination of Jews' written in it, then Jews will be willing to make peace
"if you just submit, there will be massacre." - every muslim extremist.
It's funny how we became the aggressor in this story, the borders were equally set all the way back in 1948, until that point everyone was under the British mandate which, until after 45 actually showed favor to the local Arabs, Israel agreed to those borders, meanwhile the Palestinians and all surrounding nations raised their weapons with the intent of destroying us without letting even a day pass, had we surrendered back then, would they have shown mercy? At best they would send us out, throwing us to the world, and who would accept us? America? France? Britain? All so eager to play holier than thou, yet the moment that might be even of the slightest inconvenience to them they suddenly bite their tongue.
If you care so much for the Palestinians and their well being, why don't you offer them your country to stay in? We've been providing them with water and electricity for over a decade now, surely you could do better.
Lol what jokes you two are. Laying down your arms for peace is not submission.
Dude blamed all entities he can think of except the occupying Israelis
Pretty sure the Israelis were there first
@@RS-tz2zn no, the land belonged to palestine.
@@nwrsgirl You do realize that most the area that was recently palestine used to be called JUdea, right? I'll give you one guess why it had that name.
@@RS-tz2zn prove to me Palestinians today aren't descendants of Israelites or even those before them.... even so, you don't see Native Americans claiming back USA from 300 years ago let alone "Israelis" claiming back land from 3000 years ago... besides only jews left Palestine thousands of years ago, Samaritans never left, they just converted and assimilated into the culture and region.. there is a reason why Israel doesn't use DNA as an argument, because they lose 100% of the time
@@nwrsgirlyou're a fool to think Isrealites didn't exist for centuries in their motherland.
What a liar. If you call Israel’s murderous assault on Palestinians self defence than you don’t feel bad for them.
Ben’s lost the plot. He’s purposely pushing the “us vs them” fallacy or is too dumb to realize that’s a flawed way of thinking.
Ben Shapiro is anything, but not too dumb. He's a smart ass...
@@Nirvana-For-All information at people's finger tips and they deny when palestinians speak for themselves.,.. is it virtue signaling or racist superiority? They tell the world that palestinian govts and the majority don't mean what they say, despite saying it repeatedly, despite raising their youngest to commit acts of terror, multiple state sponsored children programs that promote becoming shadeed that it is better to die than live in peace, in death they will become a bride in paradise. There were no worldwide protests when last summer gazans protested hamas and were gunned down, survivors imprisoned, some publicly executed... nor when fatah did the same the year prior. They do not care that 2 in 10 girls of the wb or 3 in 10 girls in gaza are forced into child marriage. also not uncommon since many of these child brides husbands are part of terror wings, to have had three husbands and multiple children by the age of 15. this is the way it must be argued, the financial burden or that they are "spoiled" sullied to families because simply saying it is wrong, speaking of developmental damage, is considered promoting western values and can lead to your imprisonment or execution nor how often boys are abandoned to the streets, if not sold into child labor. . . that most of tunnel dug were by boys under the age of 15, many interviews about deaths in collapsed tunnels. let alone when egyptians send poison gas thru or yes, bombing from israel, or hamas rockets that frequently fall in the area as well. There is the ban on birth control and abortion, the amount of back alley abortion death or other remedies that lead to problems. No, people do not care about this. They perceive Israel as a proxy of the west, many in the west believe if Israel falls, then so does the west and it will signal the communist revolution, the fall of western modernity and imperialism, leading to a worldwide utopia, well, after they take out all these anti-western but non-communists they have aligned with because of mutual hatred. Look up what palestinians say themselves, look up how they raise their children. Look up any palestinian rally for decades and compare to any other "Free" movement and see if you can spot the difference of how it is not a movement for palestinians but only one that screams for the death, death, death of its enemies, in every bloody nation they exist in, not just israel. Of course, there are palestinians that are not like this but you will see how those that speak of peace or so little as not call for the death of israelis are treated by the mob. It is not just Jews that are targeted either. you'll find most so called "model minorities" are... which incidentally, tend to be supporters of western values and democracy, if not their govts being official allies. much of the same tactics, levels of harassment and assault. all this is decades old. . . people don't ask much of palestinians, refuse the truths their govts, they, themselves say as a major because their supporters view them as sentient as wild animals, believe they are only acting in their nature and that everyone else must be better than them. . . what is palestinian culture but the call for death? A group of Israeli and Palestinian youth, a choir, was set to perform for The Kennedy Center, which set of children do you think was under more threat from their govt for doing so? pre-oct 7th, where were the most normalization organizations in Israel or among the territories where the majority of palestinians reside? spoiler: it's illegal for those kind of organizations to exist even in the west bank... and those that participate in these organizations risk being accused of being israeli spies and executed... especially if poor. If you have money, then you may be able to bribe your way out of it on top of fees you're likely already paying law enforcement to avoid harassment and trumped up charges... well, unless you are a member of one of the factions with actual power. Public welfare? most is provided by international orgs, what is offered through the govt, fatah or hamas, is pay for slay. . the palestinaian lotto, you will get the equivalent of welfare, if your child commits a terror act and they die in the act or are sentenced to a lengthy period. there is a stark economic dvide... most of the leaders and those of qualified ranks' families often go to uni in the west they claim to hate, and get treatments in tel aviv. it is not israel's responsibiility to do so, nor does israel have a history of extorting them or holding them hostage... when conflict is low, palestinians regularly take part. that was once true even with gaza, even when conflict comes and goes, and regular acts of terror at crossings, sometimes in israel itself. most do not even know palestinians have their own govts, they oddly believe israel controls all. and of course, they focus on jews alone, why is that? What do they call a palestinian that became an israeli? israeli. they don't acknowledge them at all, they call themt raitors, view them as scum, openly advocate for their deaths. . . this, too, even from their western allies.. albeit, so many of their western allies have not a single thought in their head, they repeat everything spouted from a microphone.
@@Nirvana-For-All why do palestinians need to steal images from syria or around the world and try to present it as their own? this so called pallywood.,. it happens all too frequently. Even before the advent of social media. Why is it necessary to fake or misappropriate images and videos?
If you call Israel’s attack a ‘murderous assault’ in light of the unprovoked terror attack en masse at civilians and hamas’s continuous barrage of rockets and small arms fire every day since, you have objectively lost the plot. That, or you are willfully blinding yourself to empirical reality. Hamas is screaming “look, look, they are killing us!” Even as they continue perpetuating aggressive warfare. All they have to do is stop provoking responses and they would stop getting them, but they insist on continuing to swat the hornets nest, then play on your sad little heartstrings for sympathy. I won’t call them pathetic. They have their strategy, whether or not it’s effective. I’m calling YOU pathetic. Your willful negligence to be informed on the topic and your willingness to buy into the pity party put on by international terrorists is laughable, and your argument shows the laziness of your position.
Ben should go back "debating" with students. That's what he does best
I like how you didnt dispute a single he said and instead tell us what he "should" be doing when in fact, youre not even doing what you should be doing in your life at this moment either.
And if telling Shapiro what he should be doing is the most important thing in your life right now, then youve got some things to evaluate.
@@DrummerJacobNo problem, I can tell you exactly why he is just making a shit show. His whole argument is simply shifting focus. He was asked about Palestinians, not Gazans, and he proceeds to answer with “Hamas this, Hamas that”. Guess what, Hamas is only ruling a small chunk of Palestinian land. West Bank is 4 times bigger than Gaza Strip, and it’s not ruled by a “terrorist government”, yet for some reason, they are still getting discriminated, killed, and they’re houses get destroyed by bulldozers. Does Benny Boy feel bad about them as well ? Their government doesn’t fight back, but it doesn’t look like they are prospering, because as far as I can tell, more and more settlements are getting built, and more Palestinian houses are getting demolished by IDF bulldozers. Also West Bank is officially designated by UN as a territory under military occupation. Guess which military is occupying it. So, are you satisfied now ?
Ok Ben, explain what's happening in the West Bank then?
You heard it a corrupt oligarchy, luckily Israel is protecting them from themselves.
he can’t and won’t.
He is a Jewish coward he can't and won't answer that
@randomchannel8238 He has a 45 minute video explaining the history and how the current situation came to be. Go watch it
@@LizardOfMonaco-hf9vj The history of Israel goes back thousands of years. Educate yourself.
There is no Hamas on West Bank, but Palestinians are still discriminated and murdered there...
There is Hamas on the west bank, it's just not in power. And Hamas on the west bank killed many Jews by blowing buses.
Educate yourself.
Many israelis keep killing palestinians, burning or stealing their homes in the West Bank.
Actually everyone agrees (even israel) about the situation in the West Bank being illegal settlements.
Everyday some american or european who recently came and could not afford a house, just decides to steal it instead.
You should educate yourself.
@@adelalmohtaseb5261 to what?
Hamas is all over the region - in west bank, Lebanon - it's the biggest headache of the Palestinian authority. My sources? 20 years of living in Israel and living it all. I believe you can find it in Google. For me this is what I live since I was born. This is my source.
I was also a teen when buses exploded here. Sources? The blood of my friends being exploded on their way to drink coffee with friends.
@@YoavMoranwhat is your viewpoint on Isreal killing innocent humans?
@@affebanane3039 what is your viewpoint on Britain killing innocent Germans in WWII? many children were killed, should it have surrendered to Germany then?
"There would be a state for them" Where? Israel wants it's land.
Where they are now but at the current pace they won’t have a state at all.
Uh, no. Israel withdrew all Jews from the Gaza strip in 2005 and no Jewish person has lived there since. Israel turned the land over to the Palestinians, and look what they've done with it.
"play stupid game, win stupid rewards"
Does he even know the meaning of Jihad? It just means struggle
Blame everyone and everything but the real perpetrator
Don't be fooled by all this Zionist American propaganda, Americans know who the real enemy of our people is, and it isn't the Muslims.
He blames Hamas, the one and only perpetrator
@@funveeable
Some people say the world started last Thursday. It's an interesting philosophical theory. Other stoners think this war starter on October 7th . Let's all forget the 70+ years of Israeli occupation of the Palestinian land
@@AbderrahmanFodililet's also forget the decades and hundreds of millions Palestine got, that went into weapons to attack Israel.
Let's also forget Hamas publicly stating his only objective is the destruction of Israel.
Let's also forget the only reason Israel isn't bombarded daily is because they built an anti rocket system.
Let's forget about anything that is not convenient for my small world view, and let's spout nonsensical garbage that shows an insanely little understanding of the topic, and of real life.
Can you tell what part of Palestine was occupied, and when did the occupation start?
@@HaloNeInTheDark27 all what you've described here is Palestinian trying to fight for their freedom.
Israel got more than a 100 billion dollars support from the USA while the millions you mentioned went straight to Abbas pocket and his corrupt traitors. Palestinian government. Nothing went to Hamas or the people of Gaza
The Jews lived peacefully in Palestine before 1947 they owned land and had Palestinians IDs. But in 1947 the Zionist gangs started killing Palestinians and removing them from their homes and land and declared their new state on the graves of Palestinians. That's what started it all.
All I'm doing here is listing facts and I'm not trying to belittle anyone. The information out there. You just need an open mind and some curiousity
He made it about Hamas, and nothing to do with the Palestinians. Such a dishonest answer.
Same thing man, you can’t draw a differentiation from the armed forces of a people and the people who voted and cheered for them, you don’t get to be the victim after you’ve celebrated murder
@@valorath6797 that's hardly the point. I'm not saying to not critique the people. Those are two different questions with two different answers. When asked about citizenry, you talk about the citizens. When asked about Hamas, you refer to Hamas. They're not the same thing, literally not. You can certainly draw a distinction.
Firstly, you're presupposing 100% of them voted for Hamas. Secondly, children didn't vote. Thirdly, they were voted in almost 20 years ago, some adults didn't even vote for them. Lastly, you can't assume they were all out there celebrating, and if they were, you don't know who was doing it in fear of being targeted for not celebrating; we saw the same thing in a dozen despotic regimes. This is all irrelevant. Because the point is, he wasn't asked about Hamas.
If we're so dogmatic that we're not prepared to have an honest conversation about this, then people can't be taken seriously, because they don't actually have an opinion, they have talking points. Parrots have talking points also, from what they heard their owners say. I'm not in the business of talking to birds, whether they have wings or opposable thumbs.
@@jimmyjimmy7240 same logic goes for pro Hamas supporters like Bassam, when asked if he condemns the actions of Hamas or supports Hamas they can’t answer, funny how they can turn a blind eye and everyone supports it
@@valorath6797 sure, if you want to have a conversation about that we can, but we're not. I critiqued Ben. You're actually just proving my point. Shifting the conversation doesn't mean you're actually giving an argument. That's what children do. "Tommy, you broke the lamp." - "Well, Jenny spilled the milk last night!"
When discussing Hamas, discuss Hamas. When discussing Israel, discuss Israel. When discussing Palestinians, discuss Palestinians. When discussing Israelis, discuss Israelis.
he literally did, you're just trying to use really bad mental gymnastics. you Tryna say he's wrong? that hamas ISNT oppressing and stealing from palestinians? YOURE being dishonest with yourself for straight up ignoring what ben said and somehow not recognizing that he answered the question directly. you have severe cognitive dissonance if you think he avoided the question.
His final statement is telling as to who currently has all the power and how they hold it! Talking about peace with Israel without talking about the costs is misrepresenting how "simple" the solution is!
How os that every cease fire was broken by hammas and after the response they want another cease fire to broke it again
Israel created Hamas in order to split Fatah. Not an opinion it's a fact.
Proof?
Where are the proofs that khamas killed babies ?
HAHAHAHA 😂
@rudatheboy is mentally ill. Its not an opinion its a fact!
@@Upholstered_you for real ?
Didn't he call everyone in gaza a terrorist rat?
I LEGIT SAW THIS. HE SAID THIS ON CAMPUS AND GOT AN APPLAUSE RIGHT? I thought I was imagining this.
I need the disgusting person to debate Hijab or someone knowledgeable like him and not hide behind those college students may Allah the almighty make it possible
Most of the “civilians” are part of Hamas or support their ideals. How many innocent people really exist in Gaza?
@@shawn7779 spit out the Shapiro Zion Kool aid you drone.
@@stephanooblus yeah you have nothing to say. Not that I expected much intelligence from someone supporting the genocide of all of the Jewish people.
So sad that they have to live under Hamas. Good that they have the Israeli state and military to protect them, as they have been doing since okt 7. The reason for closing down food, water, fuel and medicine into Gaza is to help the Palestinian people. And all the settler colonies are they just grateful for. What would they do without the IDF?
are you plain stupid or you make a joke?
Ur fuckin delusional
You're being sarcastic right ?!?
@@Nikkimorox1he is
Imagine being so entitled that you think you should continue to get resources from your neighbour right after you crossed into there backyad and killed one of there children. How dare they not let you mooch off there electricity, water, wifi and raid there fridge whenever you want.
Also aid for food is still being allowed into the gaza but you're probably referencing the 500 trucks going down in numbers, which means you blatantly leave out the fact that those trucks included many non essential things like commercial, not just food.
Correction: Live under the thumb of Israel.
Can someone ask Ben to explain what happened in Palestine between 1947 and 1987 and how that relates to the conflict with Hamas? Genuinely feel like most people intentionally leave that part of history out of the conversation.
What's a 'Palestine'? Is that an official country or..?
@@JustShotsForMeh Racist.
@@MaTeTris What's the name of the race I discriminated against?
@@JustShotsForMehHuman.
@@MaTeTris Keep using incorrect terminology.
I’m on the fence with Ben Shapiro but I’ve notice a lot of ppl are attacking just him and not what he’s saying. I think that speaks louder than words
Now when you say that, it does really look like they have no argument, so they only disagree because it's him
Yes. I think his most dislikable quality is he seems to revel in making other people look stupid which I think is not a pleasant quality. But as far as I can tell, he backs up everything he says. I strongly disagree with many of his stances, but I have a lot of respect for him. And as far as his take on the Israel situation I think he’s spot on.
(Also I fact checked the “AI generated image” he posted. It’s not AI generated. You can put the image through the ai or not generator and it says it’s human generated. So keep in many people lie and thousands more believe things that aren’t true just bc it lines up with beliefs they already had.)
Are you serious? Shapiro is so disingenuous here. Israel have been commiting ethnic cleansing well before Hamas.
@alexandraratliff7904 no Ben loves to dance around the subject. People don't like him because he has alot of zionist view. Let's not forget he called all Palestinians are terrorists and a plague and that they only know how to destory.
People also hate him because to him israel can not do any wrong in his eyes. When the UN themselves are saying that israel is and has broken international Geneva conversation laws, using white phosphorus.
He also loves to diluent history for his own narrative. Let's not forget how israel massacred Palestinians in Lebanon in 1982. They said it was to defend there borders yet went 50 miles into Lebanon and shot and bombed thousands of Palestinian refugees in a refugee camp. The thing is that now everything is documented which means they can't just lie to us anymore, we are seeing what they're doing and how they're breaking international law.
So yes people have every right not to like Ben, his been talking for Years now, just go back and see some of the things he said, I'm sure you wouldn't feel the same about him
Ben Shapiro called Rand Paul an antisemite for suggesting the US should fund Israel less. That's it. Ben is a joke of a human being. His allegiance is to Israel, not the US.
Hamas is starving their own children an blaming Israel.
Fake news
You are embarraseing yourself by saying this.
Ok gen0cidal bot, nice way to get 2s worth of attention by spewing fk sh*t
By Allah, They will pay for their Corruption.
The Corruptors and their supporters!
Allah is the problem. Islam is the problem
*Ok, Abdol, now don't forget to pick up your child bride from grade school at 3.*
3 months , I still haven't heard of trees saying that " there is jew behind me "
Where is Lah?
(AL -translate to great lah is name together al-Lah)
Why didn't he send his angels?
@@anthonyhuber-permanentlyre7808Ok paulian, remember uncle Isaac of bible making love with a 3 year old Rebecca?
@@vishaldiwakar2582 pajit you need to wait until the anti christ arrives. And 70,000 Jews embrace the Antichrist as their God. Then that event will take place
I like the fact that he simplyasked a question and then listened... the art of a interviewer!
Most people ask a question so that they can interrupt them and feel smart, I've seen this with muslim interviewers
@@BroMan-vm5gtwere they actually try to seem smart? Or were they actually being smart, and you disliked it so you labelled them as such to seem smart yourself?
And also ignored the actual cause for the plight of Palestinians and instead tried to shift blame from the main perpetrator while making them a victim
@@revimfadli4666 It would be smart to ask a question, wait till they're finished, then try to talk, also wdym i disliked it?
@@BroMan-vm5gt Ok so how does a smart interviewer deal with someone who filibusters with bullshit?
He should have asked "Do you have empathy for Palestinians in the west Bank where there is no Hamas?"
"hamas is hiding there too" -probably everyone who's ignorant in seeing the truth in this
no, hamas isn't hiding there it's a known fact that there's Hamas terrorists and islamic jihad terrorists in the west bank. it's funny seeing how fast you guys are trying to hide it since the real face of Hamas is now revealed to the entire world. plenty of Hamas in the west bank, and it's not a secret either@@bingbeepboop
1. The West Bank is not being bombed.
2. Are the Palestinians there against Hamas? If not, why?
@@JGlennFL 1. The Palestinians in the west bank are abused.
2. Regardless of whether the palestinians there support or are against hamas does not justify what they have to suffer on the daily.
@@JGlennFLare you sure about #1??
The occupiers tells us we doen't want 'peace'. Peace is the absence or violence, liberation from oppression is required
.
Right, and when Hamas is in control and genociding just for fun what is that exactly? Not oppression ofc, just doing Allah’s work. You’re despicable.
How do you Israeli put down their guns when you're religion says that we don't deserve to exist
How's the never ending fighting go for palastien ? Stop trying to eradicate Israel period
So your solution to the "oppression" is to violently and regularly conduct targeted attacks on civilians? How does that make any sense. When you are losing a fight you are supposed to negotiate for a peaceful resolution. Its how it worked for every single conflict throughout history. Palestinians jihadist religious attacks and brainwash insnt gonna lead anywhere but more bloodshed and will worsen your suffering and will lead to Israel activating more sanctions on you (what you call "oppression"). You are literally bashing your head in a brick wall.
There is no Israël.
Every answer he give is about Hamas just like Indian politions about hindus and muslim.
Ben is evil don’t trust him
He is good. Don't dehumanaise.
No ignorant one evil people do not spout the truth, tis thee 👿 who is the real evil one😂😂😂😂😂
Ben is good
@@notinterested8452Woe to those that call evil good. You have no idea what is really happening. Research Israel and what they have done to the Palestinians. Research how many pedophile's live in Israel. Israel is not what you think. They are the fake Jews and Israel was never meant to be a country. It was a person's name and his people.
@@notinterested8452 wow a new word included terrorist, condemn, Hamas, antisemitism, dehumanizing… next
It’s crazy how people went from calling Ben a Swazi to pretty much saying they wish for his extermination and don’t see any of the irony.
I call him Ben the Nazi.
You can write Nazi you know! 🤔🙄
@@paulchurchill5045only in certain cases. Using the very truthful insult of sand Swazi when talking about Hamas isn't okay for some reason.
@@beishtkione24because its not true
@@OreoCookie324 its 100% true. The genocidal Hamas are five times mote popular too
They litteraly believe God wont come back if there is a single nonjewish person in Israel because of an old book, they also learn how to discuss that subject in public, fascism and mass manipulation
There is no Palestine. It was in Jordan. Wake up.
Ask Ben to identify a single thing Israel does that he disagrees with
I say this as an Israeli Citizen. There is A LOT of things Isreal needs to fix and work out. We got Illigal settlements (of jews), which cause problems for all the legal arab settlements. Do to constant attacks, security is so high in the country that some people cannot freely move around the country without getting stopped and investigated. I'm talking about Arab citizens. They live in country. They are citizens. But when the emergency level rises, some cant make it to their jobs in the city. It's a major issue. Not for anything they did, but because some bad apples pulled some nonsense, Israel over corrects and treats them like second hand citizens.
On a funny side of it. We have aram citizens in government. There was a story about one of them not being able to get to office because all arabs were being stopped at the checkpoints. Imagine being askd for your ID when your face is on a billboard 40 ft away
Is Ben Shapiro a dual citizen? Please disclose.
Could mention more problems I disagree with in America
Interviewer: "Are you Liberal or Conservative?"
Jew: "Israel"
@antithesespistopheles8112 yes, but he prefers to live in America.
What zero accountability looks like
Zero accountability for what? For defending yourself against racist, genocidical maniacs who shoot rockets into your civilian area made of waterpipes so to make your own people die of thirst?! I am not a jew and I can still understand the facts -- your comment is what zero thought looks like.
What not using your brain looks like
Ok and your still getting pulverized by Israel to cry 💀
Are Palestinians ever accountable for the bombings, murders, rapes, stabbing, shootings that occurred in Oct 7th and the countless times before then? Arabs/palestinians start every Arab/israeli conflict
You fail to understand that he does not hate Palestinians he simply hates the corrupt government which are controlled by terrorist groups like hamas
When Ben says most Israeli soldiers: The number is at 210 . Source: Reuters as of 1/23/24.
Israel did not start this fight. The Palestinians attacked Israel.
Live under the thumb of Hamas? Who controls Gaza's water, food, medical aid, home construction, right to have an airport, right to a water port, and fishing? Not Hamas. And who controls the West Bank? Not Hamas.
Actually hamas controls the west bank
When I see a child crying in the street is it not my job to offer help and support to stop the child from suffering? But from your logic I’m now the person causing that child cry in the first place.
why is it israels responsibility to provide gaza with water, electricity and fuel? Did you know they get these are freebies from Israel? Why cant they spend their aid to benefit the people so they are not reliant on Israel ?
@@hectictube123 You may not be familiar with the situation. Gazans are not allowed to build their own power grid, their own airport, fish from their own ports. They are in an open air prison under the control of Israel. Yes, if Israel let them live freely all of these things will exist in Gaza without them.
So by your logic Israel allowed weapons to be put in gaza
Who walled in and turned the Gaza Strip into the largest open air prison?
1) it’s not a prison as people leave, 21k through Rafa crossing in 2021
2) Egypt closed its crossing for 5 years and reopened it to less traffic in 2018. Not an open border due to security issues like Israel.
3) no one is screaming about Egypt imposing restrictions on Gazans. Egypt is 90% Muslim.
Hamas and like minded people
Their Arab ne8ghbours don't want to deal with Hamas either
Extend your vision. Israel does not seem to mind being surrounded by 400 million hostile neighbours. Even if they do, they are not complaining. They existential reality can not be built on hate, but contingency demands preparedness to confront all eventualities, including armed defence to terrorism.
@@stephenl9463It is staggering how little you know about the subject you are commenting on...... One simple question here, given your expertise: How can a Gazan go to West bank to visit his or her family?
Ben has called them savage animals he doesnt care about palestine
I find it insane that people are on the side of a terrorist organization
Yeah...how can people be on side of israeli militant organisation/ army...you are right
He meant hamas.
Really??!! Back in the day the ANC in South Africa were labeled as terrorists...🤔🤔🤔
What about living under the thumb of Israel?
Yet Hamas has control of Gaza since 2006. Hamas is responsible for their people who voted them into power. Yet they buy rockets to kill instead of helping the people. While the leaders of Hamas live a life of luxury in Qatar and other countries like Turkey. Stop with your stupidity and open your eyes.
If they did they wouldn’t be able to have a complete tunnel network and huge weapons arsenal let alone make such a grand barbaric attack 21 days ago. Your comment is too obviously biased and ignores very simple facts that have no two sides
Arabs living in Israel are totally free, there are able to do everything jews can including becoming doctors ,nurses ,judges, politicians, serve in the idf or police, own properties
They come from Jordan and Lebanon, they should go home.
under thumb better than under boot but truth is underground in bunkers planning inhuman actions against simple unarmed people.@@edda682
This gaslighting at its peak
Do you even know what gaslighting means? Because this isn't that. Another chum using the current buzz word
Not inaccurate though. Israel Stepped out of the Gaza strip in 2005. Israel even offered (multiple times) to give them 95% of the west bank so long as they make peace. Hamas has always declined, and responded with rocket fire.
Rockets, which are built and constructed in gazan schools, Hospitals and residentional areas. They consistently will fire thousand of rockets, just to keep the fighting going. It is theorized that 1 in 9 of ever rocket barrage also misfires, hitting their own.
The biggest threat to Gaza is literally Hamas. A group that has turned away from every olive branch, every deal, every offer of peace. Hamas has no intention of peace, and the Palastinian people in Gaza are the ones who suffer for it.
@@overeasy9920 you immigrated to another country and kick them out from their houses by force and when they complain you tell them its all their fault. Yeah thats gaslighting
@@yazeedmalki1262 What country? During the time of mass immigration of Jews, it was ruled by the ottomans and the British later in history.
In the UN partition plan, Palestine would’ve for the first time in history be created as a state entity yet the Palestinians rejected the deal…
@@yazeedmalki1262keep living in delusion
i stand with israel, from canada!
ralph?? wreck it ralph??? man youve been watching to much movies@@ralphhammond5185
Ok bot
That’s like saying ‘’I stand with N@zi Germany’’😂
@@dianax6680 actually no it isn’t LOL
@@alwaysninja8078it is lmao
What makes them terrorists groups?
I dare you to name one thing that doesn’t apply to USISrael as well
Nobody wants to be occupied by another country. Period.
😂😂 Who the fuck is occupying Palestine? Palestine throws rock at Israel everytime they get a chance ....And you want Israelis to leave them alone? If only Palestine wanted peace there would be no war...Both Palestine and Israel would have lived peacefully
Well they don’t have a country. Hence the occupied lands
The Palestinian people are being occupied by Hamas
Especially the Arab empire
who occupied whos land first again ????
Ben is absolutely correct- history has proven his position correct.
Lmao no history will prove them occupiers in a foreign land they were 6% of the population in 1914 and now they’re 45%
Haha he’s correct. Newsflash Hamas didn’t even exist when the Jews started killing children and stealing land from 1948 until now. Hamas just came in 1988. So it’s obvious that with or without Hamas, the Jews where killing and etnic cleansing the Palestinians. Want more proof for the dumb people around us?? Google the Pale map from 1948 till now and you will see clearly who the real oppressor is.
History from where you are talking about..i suggest you get more information on your history
@@danialazihari3103 the history that Palestinians refuse two state solutions every time
hahahahaha .... ignorant
Well said 🇮🇱🇮🇱
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱✌️
Palestine allows HAMAS to stay in their country..
Ben Shapiro is what the wrong side of history looks like.
And hamas was created by Israel too. Don't believe me? Search it up. I have no idea why you think you're a subject matter expert.
"yes i do feel bad for Palestinians"
**Wink wink**
It was such a Jew answer, and not that I had respect for Shapiro before, I think he is the Anti-Christ to the conservative party.
I don't, they elected Hamas. Fuck around, you find out...
He spoke with his nose😂😂
@rubeno.1195 "Is that anti semitic" 🤓
@rubeno.1195”erm is this antisemitism..” every Israeli supporters excuse when they get caught
He blame HAMAS but he will never admit that because of Israel's apartheid and racism towards Palestinians, HAMAS will never be born.
don't take him too seriously! he is possessed by the devil! He also has no pity for Palestinians, he only said that to shift the blame for the conflict onto Hammas and away from Israel! these are profoundly evil people! You can't talk to them! He also shakes his head when he talks like he's totally crazy!
Israel's racism against 50% of the doctors, engineers and workers? racism against 28% of the whole population? there are only 2 racists in the government and they get protested against whenever there's a chance
Sorry,but there Arabic people have the same rights as other people. There are a lot of businesses ,policemen, politics, judges, and so on.All the best.
Absolutely,these ignorant people do not even know what the word apartheid means. And yet they go to Harvard and Yale😢
@@adamotors65The knesset literally banned marriage between Israeli and palestinian.
The fact people still can’t distinguish that disavowing Hamas and calling out their corruption and cold blooded murders doesn’t mean not empathising with the plight of innocent Palestinians, is really sad.
I lose brain cells reading the same narrative of “disavowing” lmao it a sheep 🐑 or a bot 🤖
@@mohammedzeboss831 Go to Gaza and help those people please.
When the white man says the world, he only means Europe, USA, Australia, and Canada
Most palestinians agree with Hamas. That's the problem.
@@amyzonkers7568 Ah, you beat me to it. I think it's dumber that people try to separate the two in a discussion. Even among the non-Hamas Palestinians, most of them still hate Israel and the Jews.
If there was no Hamas, gaza would be the west bank 2.0
Ben is accusing the Palestinians of stealing? Surely he is joking.
Pretty much. Palestine has only even existed in its current form because of the Mandate of Palestine that the British Government created. Before then the land did not belong to the Palestinians. It was a land called Judea, want to know why it was called Judea? Ever heard of Judaism? ahhh, right. I forgot. Facts are inconvenient to the point you are trying to make. My bad, ill stop making you look stupid. Though you certainly are good enough at making yourself sound stupid without my help.
That’s not what he said, he said the hamas government is stealing from the people
No Palestinian ever ruled the land 😂. Palestine is nothing more than a Roman construct based off of colonizing judea. LITTERALLY the Al asqua mosque is biult on top of the Jewish mount
Palestinians, by that he means Hamas. Not the civilians
@@laceygaige6287 How much does it pay to be Ben's lapdog?
“The only lives that truly matter are those who respect the lives of others”.
That's Ben out then
Exactly
FACTS! And how does that leave Israel out???
@ginger4ever643 ermm didn't you hear Ben... they are so respectful
They will at least warn you before bombing the bejeebers out of you
@@ginger4ever643because apparently they're the one who killed those people on the music festival, also they also killed their own people who got capture by Hamas. They doesn't care about innocent on both sides
He's a sociopath.
It’s very clear he’s lying.
bro really said "Hamas at fault, everyone must die"
He never said that tho. What reality are you living in?
@@rampagepotato4307 He meant that smart guy..
@@bilalibnaltaf Please point to me where he said "everyone must die".
how can you be so stupid?
@@bilalibnaltaflmfao you just put words in people’s mouths to suit your narrative? What a deluded kid I feel sorry for you
The thing is, the Palestinians chose Hamas
Out of sheer desperation. The alternative was continue to live without any form of resistance from Israel.
@@Google.Is.Skynet yes, they are being forced against their will to celebrate when Jewish people are raped, burned alive and beheaded. They are truly innocent, they have no choice, right? And especially given the fact that Israel pulled out of Gaza completely in 2005, Israel hasn't occupied that land at all since, and they have no reason to have any issues with Israel. Accept because they can't control their Jew hatred and are desperate to massacre Jews.
Israel forced them to, look at the West Bank for example, they chose the PA (unarmed group) and Israel is still building settlements there
The thing is, Israel is killing children and will continue to kill children. Ben is a shill.
@@Google.Is.Skynet The alternative was to choose a regime that would develop Gaza into flourishing territory that won't steal millions of dollars of aid. Hamas leadership is living in luxury while average Gazan is suffering because of their parents, grandparents stupidity to elect terrorist Hamas 🤡
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
There was no Hamas in 1948
Surrounding arab countries invaded Israel, so
Before you feel bad for the Palestinian folks keep in mind that they voted for HAMAS to govern them! Many of them celebrated the attacks on Israel.
Also keep in mind that when they "voted" for Hamas, most of the Palestinians who live there today weren't old enough to vote yet, and a lot weren't even born yet. So before you blame all the Palestinian people for the actions of the Hamas, don't forget the fact that Israel is retaliating against non-combatant civilians, including children, who have nothing to do with the conflict.
@@Noone-uw3mk That’s Hamas not Israel. Hamas is the one who’s using civilians as human shields and preventing anyone from leaving. Israel’s doing everything in its power to minimize civilian casualties.
@@Noone-uw3mk And all those civilian deaths are on HAMAS not Israel.
@@hotshotbrave Israel is applying collective punishment over the Palestinian people, and although the actions of the Hamas are undeniably wrong, it doesn't justify the Israeli response and doesn't take their blame away for committing war crimes in Gaza.
@@Noone-uw3mkHamas has no moral code so why should Israel? Sick of all this goody two shoes rubbish. Israel should do whatever it needs to do to protect their country and not pay any attention to the useless United Nations
He's intellectually and morally bankrupt
🤡
Want to expand on that? Because you're very obviously wrong🤣
@@jlskywalker Hamas was set up then aided and abetted by Israel to as opposition to the PLO.
And Im pretty sure every humantarian group and the UN, have described Gaza as an Open Air Prison. That's on Israel.
BS is awful, because he is so biased and used reductive talking points to obscure the reality of the complicated history and situation of Palestine.
And the Palestinians did put down their guns in the West Bank, and Israel continues its incursion into the West bank with settlements and evictions of Palestinians.
Back it up w facts … Ur intelligence n common sense is questionable if u feel what Hamas did on 7th october was valid… Also u have a weak argument like the many others who go back to 1948…
@@jlskywalkerhe used ai images of burned toddler to dehumanize people.
He has a long history of making racist comments. He also makes historically dumb statements
The son of Hamas Mossab, grew up close to the hamas leaders, his father is one of the founders of hamas. He heard their conversations and fone calls: He said once in a while, Mammoud Abbas calls the Hamas leaders and says, quote: Let's sacrifice some children, because they do an attack and get bombed back by Israel. But they know that the money faucet will be running after...
Give me one inch of land Israel gave to the Palestinian with peace.
This guy's gaslighting is on another level. He totally refuses to accept that Israel is an oppressor and have believes Israel can do no wrong.
If israel was a muslim country there would be no wars, and the palestinians would have no problem living in worse conditions than they have before the war. It's not about oppression, it's not about land, when will you people understand? it is an agenda of muslims to take over, it will occur in the US it will occur in europe, anywhere.
Well people do tend to leave out Palestine literally attacked and made war against Israel BEFORE the west bank was occupied. What did they think would happen? When you lose a war you started there are consequences
@@amazinkay4512started a war because they land were taken. Who do you think was living in modern day Israel before they decided to create a state
If this was about oppression then Hamas would have targeted high ranking Knesset and IDF officials, not hippies at a music festival.
@@amazinkay4512 selective memory first of all Palestinian never went to war as they never had a army . In 1967 Egypt and Syria went. To war with Israel due to forcefull removal of Palestinians that was going on from 1947 . Your argument is typical to a Zionist mentality. By your logic Jews deserve what happened to them under the nazis because they lost and can not fight back .
Young womans naked corpse being paraded in the street while Palestinians are dancing and celebrating. Yeah makes sense to scream free palestine
Thousands of children in israeli prisons, illegal settlers taking even more the west bank, storming religious sights on a whim while beating the all that resist.....not mention the people that die every day in the west bank that has no Hamas and the years of oppression that they went through..... I can see how hate and revenge piled up to give us this event
But before that Jews were not allowed to pray at there temple Muslims took their religious place. And the nearest they were allowed is the west wall but not climb the stairs, and they received inhuman treatment, that's how they became cruel.
@@033jayprakashnayak7 do we both live in the same earth??.....the Jews after the BALFOUR declaration were equipped with the weapons and the means to take control of the inhabitants of Palestine.....how do you think they managed to kill all the villages like Dir Yassin...etc. the jews were never on the defensive, they came with the aide of Britain and the US to take palestine by force.....i don't know how can you say they were wronged by the Muslim arabs where it a fact that under the ottoman rule jews had rights no other christian ruler gave to a degree many named it t"he golden age of jews"...and who was it that brought the jews back to Jerusalem other that Umar Ibn El-Khattab when he conquered it around 630~ CE from Patriarch Sophronius who was a christan ruler that killed all jews when he ruled Jerusalem. Umar and was surprised to notice no jews where there so he ordered for Jewish families to be brought back and live in Jerusalem........the thing with Zionists is that they have no shame to point fingers at Islam that gave them human rights at times when they had non and embrace those that see them as a business deal (christians namely Biden who explicitly named the creation of Israel the best business deal the US has ever made...)
Israeli has a mountain next to Gaza where Israelis bring popcorn and watch Gaza getting bombed calling it a firework event, that was happening since 2010 and still is, even Israeli mocks Palestinian in their twitter acount, how blind are you peopl like seriously
@@033jayprakashnayak7 your president(Netanyahu )said that some Muslims guy convinced hitler to do the holocaust, 😂😂 I know westerners are dumb but to an extent , read history from inside of the conflict not the outer shell
Israel has said they do not want a Palestinian state. Ben is dishonest here.
runnig from answering a simple yes no question by spending more than a minute talking complete bs , thats shapiro for ya
God damn ben shipiro is just a walking talking propaganda machine.
That is when you're an ignorant and a hypocrite to only support Palestinians. With all the atrocities caused by Muslims against the Israelis for decades, they are too kind to those Palestinians.
Bring an actual argument, point by point with evidence and sound reason. I will be open minded and consider what you write.
@@wownewstome6123 he a djouw 🚩
@@wownewstome6123Israel is an apartheid ethnostate occupation of Palestine
That's it, if you support Israel you support occupation
You don't get to fight anyone who kills you and takes your land because you support it
Resist and you're an anti-Semitic terrorist
@@wownewstome6123 they have none they are brainwashed
"Everything and everyone besides Israel is at fault." - Benji Shapiro, probably
Thats because it is .the irealis didnt shoot themselves or rape themselves so who did .another hypocrite that has a selective memory .be a long time before you supporters of murders wash off the stink of guilt many remember what hamas did .just because you would like to forget it many dont
He has no empathy for the Palestinian. One second into answering, he spoke around the party in Palestine and israel, apparently his concern is mainly about the existance of Israel, never about Palestinian people. "I am getting really sick of people who whine about 'civilian casualties'... when I see in the newspapers that civilians in Afghanistan or the West Bank were killed by American or Israeli troops, I don't really care". Wikipedia and study about Ben Shapiro, this is what he said before.
@geodarnodan6750 why would he, tho? What dumbfounded fuck would have empathy for people who support a terrorist group like hamas
@@geodarnodan6750
I don't sympathize with Islamic jihad,
I don't sympathize with hamas,
I don't sympathize with PLO,
I don't sympathize with fatah,
I don't sympathize with PA,
I don't sympathize with DFLP,
I don't sympathize with PFLP,
they deserve Nuremberg trials, not sympathy.
Don't support modern Nazis like an idiot, support the victims, and go educate yourself!
He is Zionist with an extremist agenda
The Palestinians have been offered peace many times. They have always turned it down. Tells you everything you need to know.
No intention of living side by side in peace
But want world sympathy?
Not getting it from me
Keep it up Israel 🇮🇱
No they haven't. If they have, give me your news source.
So basically someone occupied your house and asked you to negotiate a peace deal with them. That’s what you mean right? Do people think or read at all? Sigh
So basically someone occupied your house and asked you to negotiate a peace deal with them. That’s what you mean right? Do people think or read at all? Sigh
@@lifelonglearner749 land belongs to Israel, disagree?......argue with God
I stand with JESUS CHRIST&ISREAL
The new definition of hypocrites 😅
Unity in adversity.
Is the only solution...
New hypocrite, what a joke....
Well Muslims who support palestine are full of it too 🤷♀️
L rug so when we bomb Country we are trerrorist but when other people bomb like Israel do to us they are not terrorist?it’s always foreign people or Muslim country’s
As an American I don't know how we can excuse iraq and Afghanistan and then have any opinion on what Israel does if we were to actually go after the people during 9/11 we would have been in Saudi Arabia
I don't excuse Iraq or Afghanistan, you do?
I never wanted military bases in SA; our meddling was the impetus for 911.
We are a superpower without all of this geopoliticking- we are essentially sacrificing ourselves to protect Europeans from RU's sphere of influence- this debacle is more of the same: our carriers are out there preventing Arabs from exerting their influence on a region that's objectively theirs.
Why? Because Europe depends on the Suez/Mediterranean for goods.
@@asdfbeau I'm saying maybe we should mind our goddamn business has nothing to do with us The only people that speak about this with emotion or the Jews and the Muslims everybody else doesn't give a crap
@@joshuabeebe3886you do know the reasons you guys are involved in Middle East is to preserve oil ressources not the protection of Suez ??? You literally supported nationalization of Suez so tf ur saying
@@funhasnoname ok
The Saudi Govt had nothing to do with 9/11. Saud nationals were working for the Taliban.
"There is no hamas in west banks, yet israeli do neo colonial illegal settlements why isnt there a palestian state in west?"
Hypocrisy of beny boy..
They lost that territory in a war they started
If someone looks for the definition of hypocrisy, this is indeed a great example.
IF WE WERE OCCUPIED HERE IN AMERICA, WOULD WE FIGHT THE OCCUPATION OR JUST ALLOW IT TO GO ON??? 🤔
They are not occupied, they have declined numerous offers of cohabitation. They have created no production or economy with $$$$$$ aid instead voted? For dictatorship and purchasing arms and subjected thier children to intergenerational war. The Israelis exited Gaza. Palestinian people have done nothing with the space ever since but live in spite and hate. Look at that ocean every opportunity to build a tourism destination no different to the Saudis. Or a free Democracy like Israel. They have chosen instead to support terrorist and all that comes with it. He is correct free the hostages, Hamas surrender that will deliver the state to Palestinians. I sympathise with the Palestinian people it's clear that they live in the equivalent of North Korea they are oppressed but not by Israel.
@adam01315 Fight occupation by killing civilians on the other side? Even without purpose? Just for kill?
You are sick
@@sajinek ANSWER THE DAMN QUESTION!! WOULD U FIGHT OR WOULD U RESIST???
@@sajinek to be fair america would absolutely be evil enough to do that
@@S.D.323I don't believe anyone who was raised in civilized country is capable to do such things proclaiming it to be resistance
Ben doesn’t give two sh-t about those people.
And they don’t give a shit about the USA! Why should we? 🇺🇸
@@troyroberts7364 oh you think Israel cares about the U.S. beyond the support we give them? GTFO
@@troyroberts7364you’re saying the innocent babies that don’t even know what a country is don’t care about the US? They literally can barely talk
@@Yahweh_is_king_If gaza was made up of only innocent babies Hamas would not exist
@@Yahweh_is_king_
He wasn't talking about the babies.
But as soon as the babies learn to talk, they will be taught to hate Israel and the United States. Right?
People here are so ignorant lmao they forgot what Hamas did to the Israelis and that Palestinians were enjoying and clapping.
Who created Hamas, Ben? Who kept people in an open air prison and left them no choice but to turn to extremism?
So laughable that he thinks Isreal will give Palestine a state😡
They tried many times, but Hamas refused.
@@TheShalalaivery true, very upsetting.
@@TheShalalaiThe oslo accord it was agreed but Isreal does not care and kept colonising and taking there land throwing them out of there homes and creating an aparthide for them where they have no rights. You dont absue and massacre people you want peace with. Palistinains are the crazy ones waiting for some solutions while Isreal keeps massacring and taking the land.
Israrl gave West Bank to Pal Auth in 1993 Oslo accords, then removed all Israeli military and civilians from Gaza in 2005. Peace attempts were disaster as a result of Pal sickness to commit genocide. Sorry you don't know history
@@yochevedbrachasimon4979 What a joke so you continue throwing people out of their homes in the west bank and lynching people while claiming peace. Nuts. Osco Accords meant leave but they never did instead became more brutal and now force Palestinians in an apartheid. Even the UN official has resigned from all the sickining shit Isreal is doing. Be a human for god sake.
Yes, so true but no matter how we say these, it has no effect on them.
Free Palestinians from Hamas.😢😢
Israel formed Hamas dude
@@billiamc1969oh really? Did Israel form ISIS? AL QUIEDA? Hamas are cowardly evil little rats who only attack civilians dude.
@@billiamc1969🧠💀
This is so similar to “let’s bring democracy in Iraq” or “let’s bring democracy into Afghanistan”.
It s so EASY to radicalise people and it’s so EASY to fund terrorists and sacrifice a few civilians here and there for the sake of justifying war for a noble cause. Leave children alone!
There is no Hamas in the West Bank but thousands Palestinians killed there by Israeli terrorists. You’re just an another bot who listen to this type of hypocrites blindly
The most fake "Absolutely" I ever seen 😂
This guy is pathetic.
May God liberate Palestine and it's people
Palestine is threatened by their leaders who steal from them, kill them, and use them as human shields. When these “leaders” are destroyed, these people will be free forever, and Israel should stop providing water, fuel, and health care, and let them take care of themselves. Israel should only protect the small minority that wants to live in peace. The ones who hate Israel should not receive these things because they are not willing to live in peace in what is historically Israeli territory since before the Roman Empire. I wish Arabs would stop hating other Arabs, and blaming everything on Jews, when everyone knows Hamas blew up that hospital, and it was Hamas who shut off the water so they could use the pipes to make more weapons.
From Hamas and the Palestinian Islamic Jihad. You're a sweet girl. I like BTS too. Don't let them lie to you. I am not Jewish but I know Hamas are evil and only..ONLY attacks civilians. That is NOT WAR. They go around in street clothes. They are NOT soldiers because in war soldiers wear uniforms...that's a rule. They don't tell you the truth. And Hamas beheads people. Do you understand? Israel doesn't behead people.
Hamas then runs home and hides among their civilians! That's a cowardly move. Palestine are suffering because of one group. Hamas.
Palestine stop killing. people.
THERE IS NO PALESTINE 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Please give the same response to China, Hypocrite
Such a slimy way to answer the question
That's how their kind has weaseled and manipulated things since the start of it all
Try saying that to his face, you’ll get destroyed.
@@peterni2234a literal 12 year old schoolyard bully response lol and you typed it out thinking you were onto something
@@zachmartin6058 Am I wrong though?
Nothing but a coward,@@zachmartin6058 you ran away as soon as you left a reply.
But he doesn't feel bad for what the zionest state. A true racist .
The palastinians already put down their guns. You're talking about hamas.
The thief is dictating terms on the homeowner. The occupier wants the occupied think it's his own house.
Palestinians don't have any leverage in a peace deal. They would rather support terrorists than have a Palestinians state
you are right the palestinians are thiefs thats wht the arab world doesnt want to take them , even the koran says its their ( the jews ) land
How many generations should people live somewhere before they call in home. By your logic, should France be able to forcibly and violently remove all Muslim citizens even the ones born there? Calling people thieves 100 years after they were allowed to immigrate by the controlling empire at the time. Now if you wanna talk about returning the West Bank to Jordan sure. You wanna talk about requiring removing settlers or stopping expansion in the West Bank as a requirement for aide, cool. But Oct. 7 kind of destroyed Israelis incentive play nice.
Occupation or conquest, is a matter of perspective
Exactly, couldnt have put it better. Who are they to cut off the palestinians water and electricity?
This land does not belong to zionists.
Just casually forgetting that Israel has been occupying it since 67 😊
How can israel be occupying Palestine during 1967 if Israel was created in 1948?
Also in 67 the surrounding arab countries wanted to launch a war on Israel and destroy it but israel launched and surprise attack instead so it was only self defense. Most of the land that they conquered during the war they gave it back.
@@gertaro how does this justify illegally occupying Palestine and systematically driving them out of their homes?
@@NemilNihil again most Jews lived there already and when people started talking about thr creation of Israel the Arabs declared a war, lost it and lost the land.
@@gertaro the arabs never had the land to begin with. For the longest time it was part of the ottoman empire until britain got it after ww1 and just gave it to the Jews basically because of ww2. So again, how does this justify commiting war crimes against the Palestinian people?
He sees Israel as incorruptible. It's talking to a brick wall
Also Ben: Jews build while Arabs bomb
LONG LIVE ISREAL
bot and learn how to spell
Ew
@@sterlingmarshel6299There are no typos quit disagreeing to disagree
Makes me think of the separation between the Taliban and the people of Afghanistan. There are always good people in each nation, but when terrorists rule a region all hell brakes loose, and ALL sides suffer.
Terrorists you mean Hamas and Israeli gouvernement and its war crimes since decades
Freedom fighters*
The West has a wonderful way of labeling legitimate government in the Middle Eastern nations as "terrorist organizations." Of course, they simply take the lead of Israel, whoever they label "terrorists" are now considered as such by America.
Did you know that the Taliban offered America a deal, to allow prosecution of Osama Bin Laden to take place on the condition that America presents actual evidence of his involvement? Another part of the offer was that America would stop their bombardment of civilian populations (our terrorism is the good kind of terrorism, y'know).
Of course, America rejected this offer. Not suspicious at all why they would reject it. Must be we love to use our military to get our way or that we had no actual evidence to produce any solid proof Osama was involved.
Same Afghanistan from where US had to withdraw their forces after 20 years ??
Terrorists like Netanyahu? That’s the only one that’s coming to mind
This guy is brainwashed
Israel has a right to exist.
For what? To cause a genocide? 💀
No, they dont.
Not there they don't
@@xoxocoriso the way you’re speaking, does Hamas deserve a right to exist? Your beloved terrorist group who hide behind its own civilians?
But Palestine doesn't?
He always turns this question around
Thats because his a diabolical Bullshitter
he never answers it straight