I am siddiqui muslim of North india living in mumbai, my family claims that we are descendents of hazrat abubakar Siddique, but when i research on it I found that we were converted from kayastha community of hindus and i accept it because i looks Indian not arabic ,now i feels proud of my hindu root
Paksitan and indians origin is belong from Hindu Indian muslim and paksitani muslim all are converted muslim our orgin is not belong from Arab some north east states are not belong
जजिया लेकर मुंह में थूक कर जलील करके जालिमों ने लोगों को इस्लामी बनाया ,वैसे तो जब हमने बड़ी किताब पढ़ी तो अधर्म ही अधर्म पाया वो भी दीन के नाम पर,अफसोस।
Iranian love their Ancient Persian history. Turks love their Turkish History. Europeans love their European History. Japanese love their Japanese History. Chinese love their Chinese history. We Indians love our Indian History But Pakistanis love Arabian,Turkish, Iranian, Uzbek, Afghan History 😂 what a joke!
I am not sure if Pakistanis know this. In India, states were created on basis of language. Tamil Nadu is for Tamil speaking people, Andhra Pradesh is for Telugu speaking people, like wise Karnataka (Kannada language), Kerala (Malayalam), Maharashtra (Marathi), Odisha (Odiya) and so on. So as an Indian, I find it strange that Pakistan thinks that linguistic diversity will cause divisions in the state. Regardless of which language we speak, our primary identity is still Indian.
@Riju Sau It was not necessary until now and not needed.. Isn't it strange that the hindi belt will not have to learn a new language while the rest of the country should? Hindi speakers will expect people coming to their state to speak hindi and the heights of stupidity is if they go to south they expect the host state to speak in hindi also. We are unique and are beautiful in our own way. If I want I will learn hindi or bengali or punjabi based on my necessity. Similarly if someone comes to the south they should learn the local language.
@Riju Sau Sure we can promote Sanskrit. But there should not be any legislation on unified national language. Let people talk in the language they want to. As on date, there is NO national language. What we have are official languages, for govt correspondence. Few states have multiple official languages.
@@Hunter-mn4nk I think I agree with you. English is perfectly an Indian language. In some ways, Indians speak better English than Americans and more expressive than Americans.
Brother you should watch ex-muslim Zafar Heretic, ex-muslim Sahil, ex-muslim Adam seeker, Quranwala once Especially The Safiya Series & The Mohammad Series by Zafar Heretic
100% correct. Kabhi humaray ancestors Iranian ban jate hain, kabhi Arab aur kabhi Turkish, kyon ke hum yeh admit nahi karna chahtay that at some point , an ancester from Indian Subcontinent converted to Islam from Hinduism.
पाकिस्तान ने इस्लाम से पहले जो दुनिया को दिया गया 1दुनिया की सबसे पहले नगर कल्चर हड्डप्पा 2दूसरा दुनिया का पहली यूनिवर्सिटी तक्षशिला में थी 3दुनिया का सबसे पुराना धर्म हिंदू धर्म पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया 4दुनिया की सबसे पहले भाषा ग्रामर की किताब अष्टाध्याई Achaya पाणिनी ने पाकिस्तान में लिखी 5 दुनिया का सबसे बड़ा महाकाव्य महाभारत पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया र इसके अलावा 6 जिस सिकंदर को दुनिया में कोई नहीं हरा पाया पाकिस्तान में ही हारा यही झेलम पर सिकंदर को अपने idea मानतेऔर अपने बाप daade पोरस को हिकारत से देखते है 7 पाकिस्तान को लूट के हजारों औरतों के लेकर काबू में बेचने वाले गजनबी गौरी को आज भी पाकिस्तान बड़ी इज्जत की निगाह से देखता है हंसी आती 8जिसमें लाहौर को19 बार लूटने वाले अहमद शाह अब्दालीउसके नाम पर अपने तोपों के नाम रखते हैं और उस को हराने वाले लाहौर का पहला राजा महाराजा रणजीत सिंह को हिकारत की निगाह से देखते हैं पाकिस्तान कि केवल दो बार अपनी राज्य हुई है एक राजा रणजीत सिंह की और एक sindमें राजा दाहिर मजे की बात दोनों के नाम पाकिस्तानीइतिहास से गायब है
Even Mughals were from Uzbekistan ,Babar was born in Uzbekistan ( andijan 1448) he has nothing to do with Pakistan or India ,he invaded to loot subcontinent.
As an Indian, I am amazed that people like him actually exist in Pakistan. What a wonderful orator and a teacher. It was hurtful to hear him start the lecture by saying he was warned by well wishers that he might be attacked! What for? For speaking against the pathetic states of affairs in Pakistan? I hope his message reaches more people in Pakistan.
*he is also not denied what Quran says,he is also believer in asmani kitab Hadith, Muhammad as his nabi, all other than Muslims are kafir and kafir is wajibul katal..!*
Pakistan is Islamic country, they have to obey Kuraan not Science,... Kuraan is the main issue not Science... they are all intolerance to other religions.. this is Trenching of Kuraan...
You are saying this now, once he starts drawing parallels to what Modi and the BJP are doing in India you will lose your shit just like every other Indian.
There are so many and we'll come to a conclusion someday, we'll have him and other enlightened ones and we'll strike back at our oppressors and make Pakistan better for the world, hope we Indian Pakistani and Bengalis meet with love in our hearts ❤️
@@niceguy2568 Oppressors ko sirf bhaga do, unhe strike karne ki koi zarorat nahi hai. Kha m Kha waqt barbaad hoga tumhara aur aage jo progress karna hai uspar dhyaan nahi de paoge.
As an Indian I want to tell all the Pakistani that this guy really loves his country and wants only and only best for this country. Only true patriot will show mirror to his own country.
@@muhammadsulemansharif1389 😂 jaha pe sharia hai waha ho gayi development 😂😂 .. as far as I know ..only Afghanistan has sharia ...very developed country 😂😂 .go there
@@muhammadsulemansharif1389 bro don't get me wrong . I don't know about Islam that much ..but one thing that i do know is that ..Qur'an dictates women to stay at home in every single situation except for pooping .i think it was revealed in verses of hijab , since these verses are not abrogated it will imply that any education for women allowed by Qur'an is homeschooling ,if allowed at all . Unless you reject verses of hijab in which cases BELIEVE ME you don't want sharia near you . Also when women do have to go outside .. it's compulsory that she is escorted by male member of family .
पाकिस्तान ने इस्लाम से पहले जो दुनिया को दिया गया 1दुनिया की सबसे पहले नगर कल्चर हड्डप्पा 2दूसरा दुनिया का पहली यूनिवर्सिटी तक्षशिला में थी 3दुनिया का सबसे पुराना धर्म हिंदू धर्म पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया 4दुनिया की सबसे पहले भाषा ग्रामर की किताब अष्टाध्याई Achaya पाणिनी ने पाकिस्तान में लिखी 5 दुनिया का सबसे बड़ा महाकाव्य महाभारत पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया र इसके अलावा 6 जिस सिकंदर को दुनिया में कोई नहीं हरा पाया पाकिस्तान में ही हारा यही झेलम पर सिकंदर को अपने idea मानतेऔर अपने बाप daade पोरस को हिकारत से देखते है 7 पाकिस्तान को लूट के हजारों औरतों के लेकर काबू में बेचने वाले गजनबी गौरी को आज भी पाकिस्तान बड़ी इज्जत की निगाह से देखता है हंसी आती 8जिसमें लाहौर को19 बार लूटने वाले अहमद शाह अब्दालीउसके नाम पर अपने तोपों के नाम रखते हैं और उस को हराने वाले लाहौर का पहला राजा महाराजा रणजीत सिंह को हिकारत की निगाह से देखते हैं पाकिस्तान कि केवल दो बार अपनी राज्य हुई है एक राजा रणजीत सिंह की और एक sindमें राजा दाहिर मजे की बात दोनों के नाम पाकिस्तानीइतिहास से गायब है
Very good person (may not be Pakistani)::::: Can you give power to Women's. In(islamic) Pakistan Bangladesh India: ladies are suffering.. 1) Ladies are machines for child production 20/30/40. 2) Talak for womens Then HALALA by Mulla Moulavee>> again Nikah TALAK HALALA. 3) Ladies not allowed in masjit, 4) 72 Hoors for mens ,, for womens WHAT..
I'm also a big fan of Syed muzammil. But with your statement it's evident that you don't like him because of his wisdom or ideology, you like him because he bashes Pakistan.
Clarity of ideas...translates into clarity in communication...noticed that the audience was stunned listening. Identity is at the core of all search...and is universal. Very well articulated...Young Man...kudos and more energy to you
Your country need more intellectual people like you. Hearing a Pakistani speaking so well for the very first time. You are an inspiration for the Youth in Pakistan Love from 🇮🇳
Right 👍,Pakistanis are Mansik Gulams of Islamic Invaders ,and Dynast politicians 😆😆🤣🤣.. Pakis originally Belongs to ancient Indian(Indus(Hindus)) civilisation but were forcibly converted by Islamic Invaders 😵💫😵💫
Inspiration for Pakistani youth..this depicts that only educated youth and their criticism force the institution to change their policies. More power to you sir and we want more such debates in educational institutions from your side. All the best
THE BIGGEST PROBLEM OF PAKISTAN IS A FAILED/DEFEATED MILITARY WHICH WANT TO KEEP ITS HEADS UP BY INTERFERING IN DAY TO DAY AFFAIRS OF THE NATION. THE MOMENT PAKISTAN IS IN PEACE WITH INDIA THERE IS NO MORE ROLE FOR THE ARMY AND WILL REMAIN AS A POLICE FORCES, ARMY DON'T WANT TO HAPPEN THIS. ANOTHER FACTOR IS A SIXTH CENTURY CULT RELIGION AND IT'S MULLAS WILL LOOSE THE HOLD AND IMPORTANCE IF THERE NO MANUPULATION OF RELIGIOUS HATE AGAINST OTHER GROUPS AND INDIAN PEOPLE. THEY WILL LOOSE THEIR LIVELIHOOD.
Burkhe wali aayat kab najil hui pta hai? Sach bol rha hu niche Sahih hadith ka reference bhi hai. Cross check karna 👍 - Ak din hazrat Umar ne khulle maidan me sandas ko ja rhi Hazrate Sauda ko awaje lagake ched diya. Tab Allah 🔒 ne Umar ko saza deneke bazaye sari momin aurtoko hi burkha pehna diya. Sach bol rha hu. (ref- SahihBukhari-146)
One major difference between Indian and Pakistani education system is that Pakistan doesn't promote critical thinking, as a result of this you can see the current Pakistan. I really appreciate this man and clapped after watching this Video. Stay safe bro
Why will the people whose whole power rely on oblivious public take any step to educate people?it's all thanks to free access to information that people are more aware of the scenirio.I see many Indians commenting in this comment section but there analysis of the whole situation seems slightly off the mark.Right now even if we know the reality and think critically,the situation might still take quite long to improve or we might have to go through a bloody revolution.Well,we still are optimistic though as nations learn from there mistakes to improve and set a better future course of action and moral values.let's see how the future unfolds because the power dynamics of Pakistan are already really very distorted at this point.
As an Indian, let me say this to any Pakistani who may come across this comment : It is discussions and discourses like this that make stable societies and in turn succesful and prosperous nations. Open, historically honest, sharply analytical . Protect these people, nurture these discourses, defend their right to articulate their lines of thought even though you may not agree with what he's saying. Otherwise it's a sureshot way to implosion as a nation.
The great geography of Pakistan, its contribution to world and some pre historic evidences..... 1- INDUS VALLEY CIVILIZATION - worlds' oldest civilization (7000 years old). 2-TAXILA UNIVERSITY - worlds' oldest university (1000 BCE) , can u imagine, 3000 years before their was a university famous across the globe. 3- RIG VEDAS - worlds' oldest known literature was written in the holy land of pakistan more specifically punjab province... 4- Refrence of gandhar in world's largest epic Mahabharat ; punjab and its neighbourhood districts were established by Sons of Rama. 5- Hinglag temple- one of the most eminent site of durga and its refrence in shivpuran, which is again prehistoric. 6- Gurunanak dev ji and sikhism was the most indigenous religion developed in this land. And now people of pakistan are searching for their identity!! Who deserves to claim their indegenous identity, if u people are not? A land that gave oldest literature, university, civilization to the mankind are facing identity crisis😢. Lets accept some more truth... BLOODIEST INVASION IN THE HISTORY OF MANKIND- Islamic conquest of india ( According to "will Durant") and the land facing highest atrocities was the west part of undivided india i.e. PAKISTAN. Atrocities faced by rest of india is much lesser than west because from there only invaders enters in india. As a result , west part of undevided india i.e pakistan was looted economically, literature destroyed, persecuted mentally and forced to change their ethnicity and cultre under the threat of sword. But Now time changes after centuries when U people become powerful militairaily so that no external power will do atrocities on the people of this geography.. Time comes to introspect from the genesis based on evidences, based on the primary historical evidences and their scientific evaluation not to adopt any ideology or culture...this geography have guided the world in the past. Don't become deaf and dumb your boundries start from Hindukush mountains in west. You people are ready to accept every identity except those which have prehistoric roots. Introspect! Introspect! Introspect!...
Literally appreciating every word this guy is spitting out . So awesome to finally have someone in Pakistan who understands what unravelled during the 1971 war. Not many Pakistanis today understand the deep rooted animosity and apathy Pakistanis , especially Punjabis felt toward the East Pakistani Bengalis - their culture , language , food , clothing , literature , music and heritage was loathed . This racism is what bred the war of 1971, nothing else . I’m ecstatic to finally come across a Pakistani who appreciates these nuances . Kudos to you from a Bangladeshi.
actually it was started in 21st february in 50's bhasha andalon..bengladeshi people not bowed down that time even jinnah asked bangladeshi people to adopt urdu instead of bengali .. started decent from that time ..
@@jcb20072007 Ji oboshhoi. Ei bhabe dui ta alada shongskritir jati ekta desh ek rashtrer moddhe porichalona kora hasshokhor. Er fate eitai howar kotha . Tobe ja injustice and torture hoyeche amader upor ta bibhotsho chilo
23:57 Our Late ExForeign Minister Sushma Swaraj said the same thing at United Nations General Assembly. " We set up IITs, IIMs, AIIMS and ISRO. What did Pakistan make? They set up Lashkar-e-Taiba, Jaish-e-Mohammed, Haqqani Network, Hizbul Mujahiddeen,"
In the other hand Ind created RAW BJP RSS bajrang dal and other terro organizations The hatred between communities and regions in Ind is far more than in Pakistan It’s just how you portray it .. we too have intellectuals academicians and our own little success stories .. which may be not as big as Ind but it doesn’t mean Pakistan is all about those things you mentioned .. no one here cares about those .. but since you are only focussed on Kashmir perspective you hear about them or Dawood Ibrahim etc all the time on yr media !! PS Pakistan was the first country is South Asia to have a satellite in orbit back in the 60s
I am an indan and when was I working in dubai 4 years back one Pakistani girl used to call me kafir instead of hindu... That time she was a 24 yeara old told me that she has never seen a single hindu in Pakistan ever..... Shame.... You really need to change basics in your country
Actually mughe Samjh ni aati k kafir kehne pr aap bura q maan jate hu? Kafir is basically ju aik Muslim & dosra Non-Muslim.. ab Non-Muslim ku kafir bhi kehte hn,usny koi bhi ho skta ha! Agr mughe koi Muslim kahe ga tu mughe bura nai lage ga
This is the real intellectual mind, whom Indians respect always, no matter who is this person, Pakistan needs such intellectual personal and reread its own history. A great thanks to muzźamil bhai, God bless u 🙏
Oh my god....such an indepth research you have done.....i recognize all Indians should go through this lecture....because it's not about only Hindu and Muslim, its all about the cultural heritage that we all should. ❤️ from 🇮🇳
Never thought I will hear a man of that much knowledge from Pakistan, especially who actually knows history of our great civilization. As an Indian and a history lover I respect your knowledge.
पाकिस्तान ने इस्लाम से पहले जो दुनिया को दिया गया 1दुनिया की सबसे पहले नगर कल्चर हड्डप्पा 2दूसरा दुनिया का पहली यूनिवर्सिटी तक्षशिला में थी 3दुनिया का सबसे पुराना धर्म हिंदू धर्म पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया 4दुनिया की सबसे पहले भाषा ग्रामर की किताब अष्टाध्याई Achaya पाणिनी ने पाकिस्तान में लिखी 5 दुनिया का सबसे बड़ा महाकाव्य महाभारत पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया र इसके अलावा 6 जिस सिकंदर को दुनिया में कोई नहीं हरा पाया पाकिस्तान में ही हारा यही झेलम पर सिकंदर को अपने idea मानतेऔर अपने बाप daade पोरस को हिकारत से देखते है 7 पाकिस्तान को लूट के हजारों औरतों के लेकर काबू में बेचने वाले गजनबी गौरी को आज भी पाकिस्तान बड़ी इज्जत की निगाह से देखता है हंसी आती 8जिसमें लाहौर को19 बार लूटने वाले अहमद शाह अब्दालीउसके नाम पर अपने तोपों के नाम रखते हैं और उस को हराने वाले लाहौर का पहला राजा महाराजा रणजीत सिंह को हिकारत की निगाह से देखते हैं पाकिस्तान कि केवल दो बार अपनी राज्य हुई है एक राजा रणजीत सिंह की और एक sindमें राजा दाहिर मजे की बात दोनों के नाम पाकिस्तानीइतिहास से गायब है
Burkhe wali aayat kab najil hui pta hai? Sach bol rha hu niche Sahih hadith ka reference bhi hai. Cross check karna 👍 - Ak din hazrat Umar ne khulle maidan me sandas ko ja rhi Hazrate Sauda ko awaje lagake ched diya. Tab Allah 🔒 ne Umar ko saza deneke bazaye sari momin aurtoko hi burkha pehna diya. Sach bol rha hu. (ref- SahihBukhari-146)
I wish there were more people like this broad minded man in Pakistan .He is arguably the first person who has inspired me the most and knowing the presence of such people is such a relief .....
पाकिस्तान ने इस्लाम से पहले जो दुनिया को दिया गया 1दुनिया की सबसे पहले नगर कल्चर हड्डप्पा 2दूसरा दुनिया का पहली यूनिवर्सिटी तक्षशिला में थी 3दुनिया का सबसे पुराना धर्म हिंदू धर्म पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया 4दुनिया की सबसे पहले भाषा ग्रामर की किताब अष्टाध्याई Achaya पाणिनी ने पाकिस्तान में लिखी 5 दुनिया का सबसे बड़ा महाकाव्य महाभारत पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया र इसके अलावा 6 जिस सिकंदर को दुनिया में कोई नहीं हरा पाया पाकिस्तान में ही हारा यही झेलम पर सिकंदर को अपने idea मानतेऔर अपने बाप daade पोरस को हिकारत से देखते है 7 पाकिस्तान को लूट के हजारों औरतों के लेकर काबू में बेचने वाले गजनबी गौरी को आज भी पाकिस्तान बड़ी इज्जत की निगाह से देखता है हंसी आती 8जिसमें लाहौर को19 बार लूटने वाले अहमद शाह अब्दालीउसके नाम पर अपने तोपों के नाम रखते हैं और उस को हराने वाले लाहौर का पहला राजा महाराजा रणजीत सिंह को हिकारत की निगाह से देखते हैं पाकिस्तान कि केवल दो बार अपनी राज्य हुई है एक राजा रणजीत सिंह की और एक sindमें राजा दाहिर मजे की बात दोनों के नाम पाकिस्तानीइतिहास से गायब है
90% of appreciation is from Indian this is what Pakistan youth is lacking they don't know whom to follow and learn from without any religious discrimination...I hope things will change for Pakistani youths atleast so that Pakistan can be considered as a normal state 10 - 15 yrs from now.
No one really cares if you're an Indian or not, you need to grow up a bit and should start to realize that no one's here going to praise you for being an indan.
Ex Muslim chennal (Sahil, Adam seeker, Zafer Heritec, Sachwala, Sameer, CIRA international, Hatun Tash, Apostate Prophet) pai jao or ISLAM ka reality jano 🙏🏼🙏🏼
@@sauravdas2582 He was talking sense and he was talking about his country. He was also unequivocal regarding discrimination and pathetic conditions of minority communities in Pakistan.
Bro please tell me the history of this surname, why muslim using it still now. I never heard such surname in arab muslim. Shah, Malik, Nagoo, Sidhu, Nanda, Vohra, Rajput, Raja/Raza, Jakhar, Mallhi, Chamar, Butt, Randhawa, Chohan, Chowdhury, Dhillon, Chahil, Lakhani, Matto, Dar, Dua, Sehgal, Bajaj/Bazaz, Bakshi, Chowdhury, Rana, Umrani, Bhatia, Patel, Wani, Bhatti, Janjua, Jutt, Rajpoot, Dhillon, Chatha, Chadha, Gujjar, Indra, Kamboh, Parihar, Roy, Waraich(Varaich or Barayach in Hindus), Panwar, Gandapur , Sindh, Kakar, Suri, Panni, Gilani(Ghelani in Hindus), Sindhi
I am from India. And I always watch Muzammils V Logue. He is true inspiration of every youth in South Asia . Love from India. May God keeps you in good health always.
Gem of our subcontinent 😂😂. Esse yaee puchoo yaee kaun haee eskaee ancestors thaee kaun arabi turkey . Yaee saab kaee saab hindu Or Buddhist thaee yaee accept karregaa yaee. Gem of subcontinent😂😂
After 75 years of independence, 1) India 🇮🇳 is ranked 4th in terms of foreign-exchange reserves and Pakistan 🇵🇰 is ranked 4th in terms of debt default risk. 2) India is the world leader in IT (Information Technology) and Pakistan is the world leader in IT (International Terro,rism). 3) India has the world's highest number of software professionals at 4.5 million and Pakistan has the world's highest number of terro,rists at 78,500. 4) CEOs of most of the top multinational corporations are alumni of India's IITs and other universities and top leaders of most of the terro,rist organisations in the world are alumni of Pakistani madrassas. 5) India has its flag on Moon and Pakistan has Moon on its flag.
@@sgofficial9220Thank you for your comment. I was lucky to develop my mind through education and research. Think critically and question everything. I am not a consumer of the Lahori chooran. That's why I love Muzammil's channel.
@@Eric_Uthman kar to aap rahe ha. Apna khana kharab or bera garq.. Islam aik bimari ha jo aapko thokkkkkkk da ga 😆😆😆 Stay safe. AVOID ISLAM!!!!! IT'S A P.O.💩
I am actually awestruck at this man's flow of speech. Each point flowed so flawlessly. Ek baar ko paper ya placards tak nahi rakha. Kitne research ke baad ek Banda aise bol sakta hai. Hats off. It's also sad that Pakistanis think they have somewhat had a new birth out of nowhere after 1947. Like baptised and born new out of nowhere. Where in reality they were just us, eating, speaking, mentality just like us. Somehow they feel like relate to Turks who won't even accept them as permanent maids in their houses. (As pointed out by muzammil somewhere in the speech) In the larger context, the Indian subcontinent incl Bangladesh, srilanka, Nepal, Pakistan, Bhutan all have similar thinking, way of life etc. And more easy Asian countries like Vietnam Myanmar, Cambodia, Malaysia, Indonesia have larger Chinese influence. And they don't shy away from accepting that. I mean it's a reality that you cannot run away from. It's good muzammil drilled on that point several times.
what you indians need to understand is that subcontinent is not a homogeneous regions it is a multi ethnic region made up of different racial backgrounds of people. The Pakistani ethnic groups Punjabi,Sindhi,Pashtun , Baloch, Gilgitis have nothing to do with indian ethnic groups of gangetic up bihari bengali and dravidian south indian tamil people. Pakistani ethnic groups are completely linguistically, ethnically, racially and culturally different from indian people. Try to understand this and stop obsessing over Pakistanis we don’t even look like you kala people
Been constantly ignoring this video in my recommendation but I am blown away by this man. He has in depth knowledge on this topic. I am from hindi belt and I am lucky enough to stay in different states so can speak broken Bengali, nepali, telugu, Punjabi and multiple local dialect methali/awadhi(my mom N dad speak in it), haryanvi, rajasthani on top of it Hindi and English as well. Each of this language has their own history/culture and so does our South languages and our North East languages. So imposing one language on all is forcing them to give up their culture, history their story. Imposing it will not make them love it people will tend to hate it more and will feel alienated. I can be a proud Assamese, nagamese, Bengali, bihari, marathi, odia, nepali, telugu, Tamil, kannad, malayali, gujarati, Punjabi, Pahadi but I can still be proud indian.
As someone from outside the Hindi belt, I am relieved to here you understand why Hindi imposition is wrong. If I were ever to go to UP I would never expect them to learn my mother tongue. Imposing Hindi on non-Hindi speaking people is asking them to give up their own language, their own history.
@@yomamasohot6411 true... We in Assam had been protesting it. Coz Hindi had reduced the real Hindi belt languages like Garhwali, Awadhi, Maithili etc. We don't want that to happen in our place
@@yomamasohot6411 A garden has many plants and flowers. All are important. One may be more prevalent than others, but all are important. That is biodiversity and that is natures way of telling us that Hindi should not be imposed on non hindi belt people. I hail from the Hindi belt too. I dont think many people will support Hindi imposition even in Hindi belt.
Dear Muzzamil , I admire your courage of speaking on such issues in your country which have poorest record of saving and respecting minorities faith and belief . Hope many people hear and correct some though process which have been radicalised and trying to be in forefront of all worst religious practices ! Keep safe and keep on doing your good work !
My God! Who is this man who can speak extempore and non stop and so young. Each sentence is filled with deep insights. And where was this man hiding all these days from me.
Goddamn he's a gem of your country if you're from Pakistan, save his voice to raise Pakistan, Shelter him if he faces any threat, There are similar voices out there in your nation , all it needs is demand for truth and reality check.
As a very keen observer of Pakistan...for the very first time .. someone in Pakistan talking facts and rational ...keep it up sir..... regards all the way from BHARAT 🇮🇳
@@niceguy2568 perfect observer Needs to read the translation of the holy Quran and Sunnah Every individual owes identity to a single couple Adam and Eve.mrs ghazanfar thanks
Wali Khan quotable quote is " that for the last five thousands years I am pukhtun, am a Muslim for the last 1500 years and am a Pakistani only since 1947". In this order we should define our identity. No more no less.
In that case, what was the need for partition of inda, especially punbai-bengali sindh divisions from india, same people till 1947... !!.. (it was muslim league with jinnah at its head which startes direct action day that started religious riots in preparation india)..
Is this guy for real in Pakistan? Knowing that there is someone in Pakistan who talks sense is one thing but having balls to say it in Pakistan is the height of bravery. Sir Salute to u. I am a Punjabi Sikh settled in Canada. I hope common sense can prevail in Pakistani Punjab. I know for a fact that Pashtuns, Balochis and Sindhis have no doubt abt their ethnic back grounds. Baki Phajee please be safe in Pakistan. Truth is bitter to swallow for those who benefit from lies.
@@NonieGill oh dfa ho jao tom khod sikho ke nsl ho hee nai lekan hm Pakistani real sikh bhaye ha unha Inshallah zarror support karta ha we want Khalistan 🚩❤️ 🇵🇰🇵🇰 💪
Literally this man opened eyes of thousands of Muslims to pakistanis.... As an Indian I want to tell Pakistan that religion is person individual concept not countries concern people will have to understand this
It is good to see that,the new generation of Pakistan knows the history of the creation of Bangladesh to some extent. I hope this generation will change Pakistan.. To move forward you need to know your past as well as admit your mischief,Hope you will do that... Best of luck from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
I hope all Pakistanis realise what a hero they have in Muzammil. So much to learn and unpack even for an Indian in America. Absolutely gold standard analysis
@@r.k3261 Friend your assumption is wrong but I dont think its respectful to spam Muzammil's comment section with our internal Indian discourse. This is his moment , let us simply appreciate his scholarship.
Such a relief to see an actual Man in Pakistan. A man who knows who he is, what his country is and does, and is so passionate about making others better that his voice chokes at some points during his lecture.. his knowledge and frustration upon duplicity of the System is too real to ignore. Pakistanis need a PM like this. We Indians too want people like you, mr. Muzammil, to build upon our relations with your people. I hope this originality survives long enough to bring about a change, a real change there.
As an Indian-American, I have learned that no matter what corner of the world I’m in, my roots will always be in in India and its rich culture. The stronger I connect with the motherland the more clarity I have for my future. And the more I can contribute to the world. This was a great talk. Thank you 🙏🏽
I do find it strange why Pakistan is so hell bent on effacing it small ethnic heterogeneity. As an Indian, I have very strong sense of ethnic kinship but it doesn't mean that I am any less Indian or think of other Indian ethnic groups as not Indian. We are united by our common 'indianess'.
@@sagargart really do you even know the history of if not then maybe read h.m seervai and rss was the first organization to represent religion extremism and was ful of fanatics and terror 😐
@@levicodm1961 Okay. Give me 10 incidences of RSS terrorism across the world. And why it is not into any UN or international agencies list of terrorist organisation.
@@sagargart and expected gandhi was killed by it and many more political people but you wont know i dont know all the names as gandhi was a famous person i know it you can research for yourself terrorism inside country also count man
@@levicodm1961 Come in reality mate. It's not about me being right or you being right. Let's come to talk and seek truth. First of all I am neither a member, follower or supporter or RSS. Inspite of of someone who doesn't agree with everything that Gandhi says , I would choose and support Gandhi over RSS or savarkar. However I understand why people are getting intolerant and extremists. Why BJP and RSS are on rise. Hidutva is not an ideology or religion in itself. It comes as reaction to exploitation and annihilation done to the people of the indigenous culture and land . People are no more willing to stay quiet and be an audience to hundreds of years of torcher done to them by propagators of ideologies which are radical and exploitative in nature. What they are doing in china or to rohingiya or to palestinians or in France is something to think about. Why people are turning against you , you must think.
It's a rare privilege to have listened to such an erudite scholar, with such clarity of thought & flawless eloquence. I bow to to the scholarship of Mr Muzammil Shah. How I wish he visited India & presented his discourse in an Indian university & interacted with the Indian students too as did Dr Pervez Woodbhoy.
A great session indeed. When you force anything on anyone the results would be hatred against the idea that you forced upon a person. Strict parents think they are rightfully raising their kids while in reality, they raising their enemies by doing this
पाकिस्तान ने इस्लाम से पहले जो दुनिया को दिया गया 1दुनिया की सबसे पहले नगर कल्चर हड्डप्पा 2दूसरा दुनिया का पहली यूनिवर्सिटी तक्षशिला में थी 3दुनिया का सबसे पुराना धर्म हिंदू धर्म पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया 4दुनिया की सबसे पहले भाषा ग्रामर की किताब अष्टाध्याई Achaya पाणिनी ने पाकिस्तान में लिखी 5 दुनिया का सबसे बड़ा महाकाव्य महाभारत पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया र इसके अलावा 6 जिस सिकंदर को दुनिया में कोई नहीं हरा पाया पाकिस्तान में ही हारा यही झेलम पर सिकंदर को अपने idea मानतेऔर अपने बाप daade पोरस को हिकारत से देखते है 7 पाकिस्तान को लूट के हजारों औरतों के लेकर काबू में बेचने वाले गजनबी गौरी को आज भी पाकिस्तान बड़ी इज्जत की निगाह से देखता है हंसी आती 8जिसमें लाहौर को19 बार लूटने वाले अहमद शाह अब्दालीउसके नाम पर अपने तोपों के नाम रखते हैं और उस को हराने वाले लाहौर का पहला राजा महाराजा रणजीत सिंह को हिकारत की निगाह से देखते हैं पाकिस्तान कि केवल दो बार अपनी राज्य हुई है एक राजा रणजीत सिंह की और एक sindमें राजा दाहिर मजे की बात दोनों के नाम पाकिस्तानीइतिहास से गायब है
THE BIGGEST PROBLEM OF PAKISTAN IS A FAILED/DEFEATED MILITARY WHICH WANT TO KEEP ITS HEADS UP BY INTERFERING IN DAY TO DAY AFFAIRS OF THE NATION. THE MOMENT PAKISTAN IS IN PEACE WITH INDIA THERE IS NO MORE ROLE FOR THE ARMY AND WILL REMAIN AS A POLICE FORCES, ARMY DON'T WANT TO HAPPEN THIS. ANOTHER FACTOR IS A SIXTH CENTURY CULT RELIGION AND IT'S MULLAS WILL LOOSE THE HOLD AND IMPORTANCE IF THERE NO MANUPULATION OF RELIGIOUS HATE AGAINST OTHER GROUPS AND INDIAN PEOPLE. THEY WILL LOOSE THEIR LIVELIHOOD.
Burkhe wali aayat kab najil hui pta hai? Sach bol rha hu niche Sahih hadith ka reference bhi hai. Cross check karna 👍 - Ak din hazrat Umar ne khulle maidan me sandas ko ja rhi Hazrate Sauda ko awaje lagake ched diya. Tab Allah 🔒 ne Umar ko saza deneke bazaye sari momin aurtoko hi burkha pehna diya. Sach bol rha hu. (ref- SahihBukhari-146)
You have rare gift - I am fascinated on multiple fronts listening to you Muzzamil Your flow of well connected ideas in a non stop barrage with clear diction and great choice of words ; in the backdrop a vast historical reference and bluntly honest razor sharp critique - truly amazing scholarship and gift of the gab. Pakistan is lucky to have you 🌷
Very very informative and very well spoken.Being an Indian and a Bengali I find it very very useful not only for Indian but for whole human being for a state to survive for the betterment of their inhabitants.
I'm amazed that this youth has such clarity on history, identity, and human rights. Even if 50% of Pakistani youths understand this and 25% of politicians think like this, Pakistan can become a powerful nation.
The existence of Pakistan is detrimental to the existence of India. Remember that. You are amazed at his clarity, but I am more amazed at the lack of clarity of Indians like you.
@@vaibhavyadav9912 explain how Pakistan state can be detrimental to the existence of India? They have tried traditional wars 4 times, their strategy of thousand cuts has not only failed but turned back on to them and if you think their nuclear weapons is the danger then you probably haven't understood India's no-first-use policy. What are you scared of?
Religion ko kanhi criticize nai Kiya properly define Kiya ki religion Kya hai country Kya hai aur politics Kya hai ethnicity Kya HOTA hai culture, language ka Kya importance HOTA hai . Baki main ek BAAT to samaj gaya hun Pakistan is communist county where religion is main instrument of army. 1947 main radicals Muslims ne pure India ko bewakuf banaya hai.
Aapko itna nahi girna chahiye tha.....He is not criticizing religion....lekin shayad aap ko Boht accha Lage ga agar koi kare. Please apna naam badal kar , koi Hindu ya Christian naam rakhlo..gaddaro ko pechanne meh asaani hogi aise.
@@MR.FlyingMonkey gaddar to wo the jinhone talwaaron ke darr se salwaarein khol di aur islam kabool kiya, jo itna sehne ke baad bhi apne dharm aur imaan par tike rahe vo hai asli insaan(yaani hindus)
I'm an Indian. Excellent speech worth listening. I don't know how many of the Audience understood & appreciated the speech being much Radicalized. But every Pakistani should listen to this. Pakistan might have 0.1% people thinking like u
Your lectures are creating an impact on young Pakistani students. How you think out of the box and shock us every time with blatant and real facts is really powerful. Your words enhance our horizon to see things with critical eye. More power to you!
Right 👍,Pakistanis are Mansik Gulams of Islamic Invaders ,and Dynast politicians 😆😆🤣🤣.. Pakis originally Belongs to ancient Indian(Indus(Hindus)) civilisation but were forcibly converted by Islamic Invaders 😵💫😵💫
Seek the 🔊 identity from the Translation of the holy Quran and the sunnah As descendents.of the first couple Adam and Eve creatures species Human to return to eternal Abode
@@ghazanfarhussain5032 Adam was first mentioned in Jewism, when Quran and Islam was not even born...and Moreover the Adam story is a myth, imaginary story..
Man.. I am an Indian and I am proud of folks like you who has the audacity to speak truth.. I wish you and the next gen Pakistani youth to bring upon a change in your own country and set a path of introspection first before looking outwards for solution.. the moment the youth in pakistan think more on an economic perspective and keep religion personal choice.. Pakistan can shine..
I am student of puniab university i missed this particular seminar because hall was full and we didn’t find any place literally i was waiting for this video to shared and now the wait is over ❤😊 thank Yu Sir
This Young lad is far far better than any of Pakistani Thinkers and politicians.. We need more people like him not only for Pakistan but across the world including India . Amazing knowledge and perfectly narrated.. 🙏🙏
Am a proud Indian. Am equally proud of the fact, that people like you exist in my neighborhood. It takes a good amount of nerves to speak nothing but stark truth. Salute, Sir!!
The biggest takeaway from this for us Indians is that we must maintain and celebrate the diversity we have in terms of everything. So that apne hi log humko chhor k na chala jaye. The biggest identity we must have is we are Indians.
Even culture is important and sanaatan dharma and many more. And remember when economy is strong then only things work in such situation orelse it's tough.
Biggest takeaway from this guy for India is that we must stop thinking India was formed in 1947. The Bharathiya civilization East of the Sindu river existed for over 10000 years. No wonder Nehru tinkered with our history too.
This is perhaps the best commentary and analysis I have heard coming from a Pakistani. Such depth and clarity of speech delivered so eloquently! Hats off to Mr Muzammil. Pakistan needs thousands of people like you to bring about a change. God bless you. On a side note, I am surprised by two things. Most of the views/ comments are from Indians. I wish the Pakistanis listen to you more than the crazy politicians. The other thing that baffles me is how few people have subscribed to your channel. Makes me believe you are still a hidden gem in your own country.
There is hardly any Pakistani video on which you don’t find more Indian comments than Pakistani I don’t know what’s the reason .. music news sports .. even if it’s Pakistani content you ll find more Indian comments .. The internet proliferation and the population is far greater than Ind but must be something to do with Indian Gen Z culture the way they are commenting on literally everything.. there are other countries in the World US China etc which are both advanced and have high number of internet users but somehow Indians outnumber them when it comes to spamming and commenting lol
@Ummair That is India's problem...being an Indian myself..we should have forgotten about Pak a long time ago..and vice versa .Pak should forget about India and esp Kashmir and work on their internal politics to save their own country.We as Indians should compete with Developed countries like USA , China etc etc...
@@krislo4788 honestly if you look at the news channel yr extremist media is obsessed over Pakistan On the other hand our media gives yr country far less air time Yr whole shows are dedicated for discussion on Pakistan So called internet experts like Major Arya earns his bread and butter by talking on Pakistan .. As for Kashmir, our support for their just struggle will always be there because it’s an international dispute .. however, our focus is on bigger internal things .. economy businesses inflation security unemployment etc
@@UmairSajid Remove your army from POK first as per UNO..then we will talk about the plebcite..as per the rules of UNO....You have occupied our land illegally anyway..POK and Gilgit..so first remove your army from POK and both our countries can talk...if your God forsaken country remains a country..wishing you luck✌️
@@UmairSajid what kind of focus?? Your country has been knocking doors of every possible country,begging for money....Keeping insults aside( bcoz Pakistan itself seems like a insult now😂) u really should b ashamed of ur condition and work on it ryt nw rather than looking for an ego massage and procrastinating ur superiority....in 1990s wen India had to go to IMF for money ,the entire country was embarassed and decided to change our fate from there..and today we are in one of the top 5 countries of the world...deep inside we want your country to b destroyed( woh tum khud kar rahe ho without any external influence😂) bt logically agar neighbor kharab ho toh apne ghar ka climate bhi khrb hota he..so sudhro gadho..ISLAM ISLAM karna chod do..even the Arabs find u worse than pigs..All the best👍
Just wonderful to hear a young pakistani muslims speak so rationally and logically. There may yet be hope for that nation if there are more minds who think like this and have the guts to speak out without fear. Stay safe
@@siddhantk4985 it's not hate......do u think this will have any change in them?‼️ He just explained what they are.....they are too late to start this discussion.....there is no 10 years fr this fake nation called Pakistan.....the only way fr then is to become worse perish and then india will show a new way fr them
I'm Rajput from india, asked questions to pakistan named Aseem Rajput that your ancestors are hindus ? he said My ancestors are Arab's, i was like ok but it hurts when your family members forgets #Home
Awesome speech, with such a clarity of thought and our common history. Being an Indian we feel partly connected to this and really want our neighbours to realise even now and have a course correction for a better, safer future of their country and South Asia as a whole. Really respect you for this line of thought.
What a logic...😂😂😂😂 India(which was mostly hindu) was always secular. But people like you were NEVER secular. Good and just people never changes their morals and ideology no matter what happens. Look into your vedas and scriptures, if you had read those you'd know what I mean.
Oh bhai padha hai veda or upanishad samjha bhi hai usko ham to garv karte hai hamare ancestors ne likha hai use tumhe nahi samjh aati to usme hamara koi dosh nahi hai bhai ok 😊@@globalcitizen270
Absolutely amazed by this erudite scholar. If he is able to rally the educated and modern youth of Pakistan behind him, the country will surely see great days ahead. Lots of appreciation from India.
I am siddiqui muslim of North india living in mumbai, my family claims that we are descendents of hazrat abubakar Siddique, but when i research on it I found that we were converted from kayastha community of hindus and i accept it because i looks Indian not arabic ,now i feels proud of my hindu root
Paksitan and indians origin is belong from Hindu Indian muslim and paksitani muslim all are converted muslim our orgin is not belong from Arab some north east states are not belong
Yr dna karwa lo pta chl jayega bhai
जजिया लेकर मुंह में थूक कर जलील करके जालिमों ने लोगों को इस्लामी बनाया ,वैसे तो जब हमने बड़ी किताब पढ़ी तो अधर्म ही अधर्म पाया वो भी दीन के नाम पर,अफसोस।
Your a true Indian..❤
Gharana wapasi
Iranian love their Ancient Persian history.
Turks love their Turkish History.
Europeans love their European History.
Japanese love their Japanese History.
Chinese love their Chinese history.
We Indians love our Indian History
But Pakistanis love Arabian,Turkish, Iranian, Uzbek, Afghan History 😂 what a joke!
Funny isn't it😅🤣
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Because their history is kafir history that they hate so much
🤣🤣🤣🤣200% correct
Same for Bangladesh!!!
I am not sure if Pakistanis know this. In India, states were created on basis of language. Tamil Nadu is for Tamil speaking people, Andhra Pradesh is for Telugu speaking people, like wise Karnataka (Kannada language), Kerala (Malayalam), Maharashtra (Marathi), Odisha (Odiya) and so on. So as an Indian, I find it strange that Pakistan thinks that linguistic diversity will cause divisions in the state. Regardless of which language we speak, our primary identity is still Indian.
@@user-by1kj8ev7sbro aaj bi Indian ki koi neslitasty Language nhi h
@Riju Sau It was not necessary until now and not needed.. Isn't it strange that the hindi belt will not have to learn a new language while the rest of the country should? Hindi speakers will expect people coming to their state to speak hindi and the heights of stupidity is if they go to south they expect the host state to speak in hindi also. We are unique and are beautiful in our own way. If I want I will learn hindi or bengali or punjabi based on my necessity. Similarly if someone comes to the south they should learn the local language.
@Riju Sau Sure we can promote Sanskrit. But there should not be any legislation on unified national language. Let people talk in the language they want to. As on date, there is NO national language. What we have are official languages, for govt correspondence. Few states have multiple official languages.
@Riju Sau English is Indian,,
British English or US English are not
@@Hunter-mn4nk I think I agree with you. English is perfectly an Indian language. In some ways, Indians speak better English than Americans and more expressive than Americans.
I'm amazed at your courage to say all what you said right in front of the Jamiat students that too in PU. Hats off man!
He is almost pefect ❤
jamiat waloun ki phat rhi hogi 😅
Brother you should watch ex-muslim Zafar Heretic, ex-muslim Sahil, ex-muslim Adam seeker, Quranwala once
Especially The Safiya Series & The Mohammad Series by Zafar Heretic
Yeah hats off
@@mritunjaymishra3190 نہیں!
100% correct.
Kabhi humaray ancestors Iranian ban jate hain, kabhi Arab aur kabhi Turkish, kyon ke hum yeh admit nahi karna chahtay that at some point , an ancester from Indian Subcontinent converted to Islam from Hinduism.
Pak ISI and maulvi wants to know ur location 💀
पाकिस्तान ने इस्लाम से पहले जो दुनिया को दिया गया 1दुनिया की सबसे पहले नगर कल्चर हड्डप्पा 2दूसरा दुनिया का पहली यूनिवर्सिटी तक्षशिला में थी 3दुनिया का सबसे पुराना धर्म हिंदू धर्म पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया 4दुनिया की सबसे पहले भाषा ग्रामर की किताब अष्टाध्याई Achaya पाणिनी ने पाकिस्तान में लिखी
5 दुनिया का सबसे बड़ा महाकाव्य महाभारत पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया र इसके अलावा
6 जिस सिकंदर को दुनिया में कोई नहीं हरा पाया पाकिस्तान में ही हारा यही झेलम पर सिकंदर को अपने idea मानतेऔर अपने बाप daade पोरस को हिकारत से देखते है
7 पाकिस्तान को लूट के हजारों औरतों के लेकर काबू में बेचने वाले गजनबी गौरी को आज भी पाकिस्तान बड़ी इज्जत की निगाह से देखता है हंसी आती
8जिसमें लाहौर को19 बार लूटने वाले अहमद शाह अब्दालीउसके नाम पर अपने तोपों के नाम रखते हैं और उस को हराने वाले लाहौर का पहला राजा महाराजा रणजीत सिंह को हिकारत की निगाह से देखते हैं
पाकिस्तान कि केवल दो बार अपनी राज्य हुई है एक राजा रणजीत सिंह की और एक sindमें राजा दाहिर मजे की बात दोनों के नाम पाकिस्तानीइतिहास से गायब है
@@asheeshmishra5392 I wish I knew how to read that. UA-cam is not showing translate option.
@@amnahaque9058 ok sir
Even Mughals were from Uzbekistan ,Babar was born in Uzbekistan ( andijan 1448) he has nothing to do with Pakistan or India ,he invaded to loot subcontinent.
My name is Sahil Talreja and being a Pakistani hindu i admire you, you are one of the men who speak about minorities in Pakistan.
Yar tumpakistani Hindu wahapy rehtekse ho
@comicshorts5352: why dont you and your family and other hindu friends move permanently to India? pakistan is clearly not a safe place for hindus
You are Sindhi , am I right
@@Pushparaj-fe9fk bhai ache se reh sakte hain.
Bhukh or economic crises sochne ko bajbur kiye hai
As an Indian, I am amazed that people like him actually exist in Pakistan. What a wonderful orator and a teacher. It was hurtful to hear him start the lecture by saying he was warned by well wishers that he might be attacked! What for? For speaking against the pathetic states of affairs in Pakistan? I hope his message reaches more people in Pakistan.
He will rewarded if he was Malaysian or Indonesian. Pakistan was actually had culture to build their identity
*he is also not denied what Quran says,he is also believer in asmani kitab Hadith, Muhammad as his nabi, all other than Muslims are kafir and kafir is wajibul katal..!*
I hope India comes back to its declared secular and democratic values hijacked by Hindutva ideology .
Pakistan is Islamic country, they have to obey Kuraan not Science,... Kuraan is the main issue not Science... they are all intolerance to other religions.. this is Trenching of Kuraan...
You are saying this now, once he starts drawing parallels to what Modi and the BJP are doing in India you will lose your shit just like every other Indian.
This 45 min lecture should be taught in schools, better then all Pakistani Educational board history books
And army will hang him 😢
School or madrasa?
Excellent....how many Pakistanis are listening. We as Indians are listening and learning too. I appreciate your clarity and courage ❤️
There are so many and we'll come to a conclusion someday, we'll have him and other enlightened ones and we'll strike back at our oppressors and make Pakistan better for the world, hope we Indian Pakistani and Bengalis meet with love in our hearts ❤️
@@niceguy2568 we hope so and wish Pakistan well. Progressive governments in the region will be good for the region.
@@niceguy2568 Oppressors ko sirf bhaga do, unhe strike karne ki koi zarorat nahi hai. Kha m Kha waqt barbaad hoga tumhara aur aage jo progress karna hai uspar dhyaan nahi de paoge.
Don't worry Pakistan, you will get company soon. We, Indians are in the process of making the same mistake you did many years ago.
@@chitharanjans4913 what a baseless comment
As an Indian I want to tell all the Pakistani that this guy really loves his country and wants only and only best for this country. Only true patriot will show mirror to his own country.
no he is supid punjabi..
Army will crush him like gewing gum😂
@@muhammadsulemansharif1389 😂 jaha pe sharia hai waha ho gayi development 😂😂 .. as far as I know ..only Afghanistan has sharia ...very developed country 😂😂 .go there
@@muhammadsulemansharif1389 bro don't get me wrong . I don't know about Islam that much ..but one thing that i do know is that ..Qur'an dictates women to stay at home in every single situation except for pooping .i think it was revealed in verses of hijab , since these verses are not abrogated it will imply that any education for women allowed by Qur'an is homeschooling ,if allowed at all . Unless you reject verses of hijab in which cases BELIEVE ME you don't want sharia near you . Also when women do have to go outside .. it's compulsory that she is escorted by male member of family .
@@muhammadsulemansharif1389Pakistan needs to be secular to function your stupid cult of sharia law has destroyed Pakistan it’s a dump now.
He is one of few sane voices left in this country. His wisdom, courage and rationality is phenomenal. Bravo Muzammil 👍
पाकिस्तान ने इस्लाम से पहले जो दुनिया को दिया गया 1दुनिया की सबसे पहले नगर कल्चर हड्डप्पा 2दूसरा दुनिया का पहली यूनिवर्सिटी तक्षशिला में थी 3दुनिया का सबसे पुराना धर्म हिंदू धर्म पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया 4दुनिया की सबसे पहले भाषा ग्रामर की किताब अष्टाध्याई Achaya पाणिनी ने पाकिस्तान में लिखी
5 दुनिया का सबसे बड़ा महाकाव्य महाभारत पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया र इसके अलावा
6 जिस सिकंदर को दुनिया में कोई नहीं हरा पाया पाकिस्तान में ही हारा यही झेलम पर सिकंदर को अपने idea मानतेऔर अपने बाप daade पोरस को हिकारत से देखते है
7 पाकिस्तान को लूट के हजारों औरतों के लेकर काबू में बेचने वाले गजनबी गौरी को आज भी पाकिस्तान बड़ी इज्जत की निगाह से देखता है हंसी आती
8जिसमें लाहौर को19 बार लूटने वाले अहमद शाह अब्दालीउसके नाम पर अपने तोपों के नाम रखते हैं और उस को हराने वाले लाहौर का पहला राजा महाराजा रणजीत सिंह को हिकारत की निगाह से देखते हैं
पाकिस्तान कि केवल दो बार अपनी राज्य हुई है एक राजा रणजीत सिंह की और एक sindमें राजा दाहिर मजे की बात दोनों के नाम पाकिस्तानीइतिहास से गायब है
@@asheeshmishra5392 bhai vo pakistan nhi Bharat hi tha.
Pakistan 1947 mai bna tha, plz correct yourself.
Ha 1947 k baad kuch diya h tho plz batana.
Very good person (may not be Pakistani):::::
Can you give power to Women's.
In(islamic) Pakistan Bangladesh India: ladies are suffering..
1) Ladies are machines for child production 20/30/40.
2) Talak for womens Then HALALA by Mulla Moulavee>> again Nikah TALAK HALALA.
3) Ladies not allowed in masjit,
4) 72 Hoors for mens ,, for womens WHAT..
Great intellectual at such a young age, fantastic understanding and very logical mind.
A Pakistani with correct knowledge .... A very rare thing 😅
I'm also a big fan of Syed muzammil. But with your statement it's evident that you don't like him because of his wisdom or ideology, you like him because he bashes Pakistan.
Clarity of ideas...translates into clarity in communication...noticed that the audience was stunned listening. Identity is at the core of all search...and is universal. Very well articulated...Young Man...kudos and more energy to you
Good lecture and analysis by mr mujamim.
Man this was such a great speech... Hope more people in pakistan listen to him and change their mindset.. Love from India🇮🇳
Hope more peole listen to kunal kamra
@@hke.4475 wah tu yaha bhi hag raha hai..
@@hke.4475 bhikhari people ki spelling to thik karle
Aise bahut aaye aur gaye. May be you don’t know much about Pakistan,
@@sahilsingh6048 bro when you here to 'Kukur Kamra', this is the least degradation you can expect😂
Your country need more intellectual people like you. Hearing a Pakistani speaking so well for the very first time. You are an inspiration for the Youth in Pakistan
Love from 🇮🇳
टुन्नी खुश हुआ 😀😀😀😀
BJP doing same. with. muslims so dont feel much pride
Protect this guy at all cost
Such voices cannot be suppressed. One Bhagat Singh will create 1000s.
History and truth cannot be wiped out, it can be suppressed but one or the other day it will re-dominate
Well he is a Kafir according to 95% of Pakistanis 😂
Yes, a sane voice
Speech in one sentence “Islam makes oppressors Messiah after one generation and converts loose identity forever”
This should be shown in every university and college of Pakistan ❤
Fatwa zari krwage ky bhai iske nam ka
ua-cam.com/video/z7UcOgHK7MI/v-deo.html
Ha marwa do isko bhi
Right 👍,Pakistanis are Mansik Gulams of Islamic Invaders ,and Dynast politicians 😆😆🤣🤣..
Pakis originally Belongs to ancient Indian(Indus(Hindus)) civilisation but were forcibly converted by Islamic Invaders 😵💫😵💫
Ri0ts ho jayenge.....they are beyond redemption now...
Inspiration for Pakistani youth..this depicts that only educated youth and their criticism force the institution to change their policies. More power to you sir and we want more such debates in educational institutions from your side. All the best
THE BIGGEST PROBLEM OF PAKISTAN IS A FAILED/DEFEATED MILITARY WHICH WANT TO KEEP ITS HEADS UP BY INTERFERING IN DAY TO DAY AFFAIRS OF THE NATION. THE MOMENT PAKISTAN IS IN PEACE WITH INDIA THERE IS NO MORE ROLE FOR THE ARMY AND WILL REMAIN AS A POLICE FORCES, ARMY DON'T WANT TO HAPPEN THIS.
ANOTHER FACTOR IS A SIXTH CENTURY CULT RELIGION AND IT'S MULLAS WILL LOOSE THE HOLD AND IMPORTANCE IF THERE NO MANUPULATION OF RELIGIOUS HATE AGAINST OTHER GROUPS AND INDIAN PEOPLE. THEY WILL LOOSE THEIR LIVELIHOOD.
From where you are??
🤣🤣
Burkhe wali aayat kab najil hui pta hai? Sach bol rha hu niche Sahih hadith ka reference bhi hai. Cross check karna 👍
- Ak din hazrat Umar ne khulle maidan me sandas ko ja rhi Hazrate Sauda ko awaje lagake ched diya. Tab Allah 🔒 ne Umar ko saza deneke bazaye sari momin aurtoko hi burkha pehna diya. Sach bol rha hu. (ref- SahihBukhari-146)
One major difference between Indian and Pakistani education system is that Pakistan doesn't promote critical thinking, as a result of this you can see the current Pakistan. I really appreciate this man and clapped after watching this Video. Stay safe bro
Why will the people whose whole power rely on oblivious public take any step to educate people?it's all thanks to free access to information that people are more aware of the scenirio.I see many Indians commenting in this comment section but there analysis of the whole situation seems slightly off the mark.Right now even if we know the reality and think critically,the situation might still take quite long to improve or we might have to go through a bloody revolution.Well,we still are optimistic though as nations learn from there mistakes to improve and set a better future course of action and moral values.let's see how the future unfolds because the power dynamics of Pakistan are already really very distorted at this point.
If critical thinking is promoted they will start questioning islam
As an Indian, let me say this to any Pakistani who may come across this comment :
It is discussions and discourses like this that make stable societies and in turn succesful and prosperous nations.
Open, historically honest, sharply analytical .
Protect these people, nurture these discourses, defend their right to articulate their lines of thought even though you may not agree with what he's saying. Otherwise it's a sureshot way to implosion as a nation.
Yahan Vigo aa jaati hai. Rehne do ap
Hahaha i think you forget the name Prof.Dr.Pervaiz Hoodbhoy ...
The great geography of Pakistan, its contribution to world and some pre historic evidences.....
1- INDUS VALLEY CIVILIZATION - worlds' oldest civilization (7000 years old).
2-TAXILA UNIVERSITY - worlds' oldest university (1000 BCE) , can u imagine, 3000 years before their was a university famous across the globe.
3- RIG VEDAS - worlds' oldest known literature was written in the holy land of pakistan more specifically punjab province...
4- Refrence of gandhar in world's largest epic Mahabharat ; punjab and its neighbourhood districts were established by Sons of Rama.
5- Hinglag temple- one of the most eminent site of durga and its refrence in shivpuran, which is again prehistoric.
6- Gurunanak dev ji and sikhism was the most indigenous religion developed in this land.
And now people of pakistan are searching for their identity!!
Who deserves to claim their indegenous identity, if u people are not?
A land that gave oldest literature, university, civilization to the mankind are facing identity crisis😢.
Lets accept some more truth...
BLOODIEST INVASION IN THE HISTORY OF MANKIND- Islamic conquest of india ( According to "will Durant") and the land facing highest atrocities was the west part of undivided india i.e. PAKISTAN.
Atrocities faced by rest of india is much lesser than west because from there only invaders enters in india.
As a result , west part of undevided india i.e pakistan was looted economically, literature destroyed, persecuted mentally and forced to change their ethnicity and cultre under the threat of sword.
But Now time changes after centuries when U people become powerful militairaily so that no external power will do atrocities on the people of this geography..
Time comes to introspect from the genesis based on evidences, based on the primary historical evidences and their scientific evaluation not to adopt any ideology or culture...this geography have guided the world in the past.
Don't become deaf and dumb your boundries start from Hindukush mountains in west.
You people are ready to accept every identity except those which have prehistoric roots.
Introspect! Introspect! Introspect!...
@@shivampandey6256well said but there will some Muslim will reply to your informative post saying it's false
@@elgonm289no they won’t!! Can’t read 😂😂😂
Literally appreciating every word this guy is spitting out . So awesome to finally have someone in Pakistan who understands what unravelled during the 1971 war. Not many Pakistanis today understand the deep rooted animosity and apathy Pakistanis , especially Punjabis felt toward the East Pakistani Bengalis - their culture , language , food , clothing , literature , music and heritage was loathed . This racism is what bred the war of 1971, nothing else . I’m ecstatic to finally come across a Pakistani who appreciates these nuances . Kudos to you from a Bangladeshi.
His every word is based on logic and reading between the line.... True true true
actually it was started in 21st february in 50's bhasha andalon..bengladeshi people not bowed down that time even jinnah asked bangladeshi people to adopt urdu instead of bengali .. started decent from that time ..
@@jcb20072007 Ji oboshhoi. Ei bhabe dui ta alada shongskritir jati ekta desh ek rashtrer moddhe porichalona kora hasshokhor. Er fate eitai howar kotha . Tobe ja injustice and torture hoyeche amader upor ta bibhotsho chilo
ua-cam.com/video/z7UcOgHK7MI/v-deo.html
But now many in Bangladesh prefer pakistan to India.They have forgotten 1971.
23:57 Our Late ExForeign Minister Sushma Swaraj said the same thing at United Nations General Assembly. " We set up IITs, IIMs, AIIMS and ISRO. What did Pakistan make? They set up Lashkar-e-Taiba, Jaish-e-Mohammed, Haqqani Network, Hizbul Mujahiddeen,"
In the other hand Ind created RAW BJP RSS bajrang dal and other terro organizations
The hatred between communities and regions in Ind is far more than in Pakistan
It’s just how you portray it .. we too have intellectuals academicians and our own little success stories .. which may be not as big as Ind but it doesn’t mean Pakistan is all about those things you mentioned .. no one here cares about those .. but since you are only focussed on Kashmir perspective you hear about them or Dawood Ibrahim etc all the time on yr media !!
PS Pakistan was the first country is South Asia to have a satellite in orbit back in the 60s
It's their pride, don't question.
I am an indan and when was I working in dubai 4 years back one Pakistani girl used to call me kafir instead of hindu... That time she was a 24 yeara old told me that she has never seen a single hindu in Pakistan ever..... Shame....
You really need to change basics in your country
Actually mughe Samjh ni aati k kafir kehne pr aap bura q maan jate hu? Kafir is basically ju aik Muslim & dosra Non-Muslim.. ab Non-Muslim ku kafir bhi kehte hn,usny koi bhi ho skta ha! Agr mughe koi Muslim kahe ga tu mughe bura nai lage ga
Bhai naam hai, insaan hai
@@clipclap9820 its a word said whith emotion of disgust and sepretism
@@clipclap9820and according to your Holy Book Quran how a Kafir should be treated?..
@@clipclap9820hindu tumlog ki bidharmi bola kabhi jabki jo gaay mansh khata h wo vidharmi h
If Pakistani youth become like this young intelligent gentleman then we got nothing to worry about . 👏🏼
Yes definitely u are correct..
But masla ye hai ki yeh hone nahi wala hai...😁😁😁😁😁😁
@@samirmaharana20 obviously Ek misogynist Atheist kow kew Pakistan value degi.
@@munimulhaque271
Blah blah blah n blah blah blah..
BooooooooM💥💥💥💥
😁😁😁
lol pak is fundamentally made against india , pakistan s balkanisation is inevitable for indians growth.
@@munimulhaque271 padta hai bhai....
We spend money , preparing to kill jihaadis. ....
Pakistan needs more secularists and intellectuals like you.... Love from India 🇮🇳
Look at the map of Pakistan he presents every time in his talks (background)
@@rvharikrishna ha to vo uske state ko he support karega na, indian left patriot bhi To state ke sath rehte the jab country ke bat ati he.
and india needs dharam sansad ?
@@pankaja7974 Yup, don't compare all religions and paint them with a safe brush.
Please Don't use Secular Word . Use Something else
This is the real intellectual mind, whom Indians respect always, no matter who is this person, Pakistan needs such intellectual personal and reread its own history. A great thanks to muzźamil bhai, God bless u 🙏
Uff, intellectual, muzzamil bhai … yaar tu toh fida ho gaya!
Calm down, grow up, itna nahi chatna chahiye.
Hamari history islam sy ha.. yh dally ko india bulaa loo ager itni hi peyar ha is sy to our is jesy baqee liberal ko b ap ki bohot mehrbani ho gi
Huuu He talking for welfare in pak..why r u getting mad of it.
@@ayushpatna ek Pis’stani ki itni Chat kyon raha hai!
Bhad meh jaye Pis’stan!
INiDam ReapCet lmao Apne liberals ko toh Pakistani funded bolte ho or Pakistani liberals k pages pe a k ye sab likhte ho wah
Oh my god....such an indepth research you have done.....i recognize all Indians should go through this lecture....because it's not about only Hindu and Muslim, its all about the cultural heritage that we all should. ❤️ from 🇮🇳
Bhai tumhe hi nahi malum tha kyo k tum cbse ka syllabus pade ho jo communist ne banaya tha 😅😅😅😅
Arnab Goswami will feel very bad😂😂😂
@@AnirimaGhosh arnab goswami kya muslim to apne aap ko bolte hi hai ki ham bharat se nahi arab se aaye hai 😊
Never thought I will hear a man of that much knowledge from Pakistan, especially who actually knows history of our great civilization. As an Indian and a history lover I respect your knowledge.
Not knowledge ,basic reality bta rha hai
@@RKT405 that clarity comes from knowledge.
Pakistan has a long, long way to go; deconstructing the colonial and medieval, anti-Modernist, mindset can be overcome with real knowledge.
@@vijayachandrabagaraoalleni2282 that knowledge comes from reality
There are 1000s of people in Pakistan who already discuss and talk on this subject matter.
Muzammil is the pride of Pakistan! Learnt so much through his unbiased analysis -
पाकिस्तान ने इस्लाम से पहले जो दुनिया को दिया गया 1दुनिया की सबसे पहले नगर कल्चर हड्डप्पा 2दूसरा दुनिया का पहली यूनिवर्सिटी तक्षशिला में थी 3दुनिया का सबसे पुराना धर्म हिंदू धर्म पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया 4दुनिया की सबसे पहले भाषा ग्रामर की किताब अष्टाध्याई Achaya पाणिनी ने पाकिस्तान में लिखी
5 दुनिया का सबसे बड़ा महाकाव्य महाभारत पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया र इसके अलावा
6 जिस सिकंदर को दुनिया में कोई नहीं हरा पाया पाकिस्तान में ही हारा यही झेलम पर सिकंदर को अपने idea मानतेऔर अपने बाप daade पोरस को हिकारत से देखते है
7 पाकिस्तान को लूट के हजारों औरतों के लेकर काबू में बेचने वाले गजनबी गौरी को आज भी पाकिस्तान बड़ी इज्जत की निगाह से देखता है हंसी आती
8जिसमें लाहौर को19 बार लूटने वाले अहमद शाह अब्दालीउसके नाम पर अपने तोपों के नाम रखते हैं और उस को हराने वाले लाहौर का पहला राजा महाराजा रणजीत सिंह को हिकारत की निगाह से देखते हैं
पाकिस्तान कि केवल दो बार अपनी राज्य हुई है एक राजा रणजीत सिंह की और एक sindमें राजा दाहिर मजे की बात दोनों के नाम पाकिस्तानीइतिहास से गायब है
@@asheeshmishra5392 bhai wo Pakistani khatoon h usko hindi ni padhni aati😅
Burkhe wali aayat kab najil hui pta hai? Sach bol rha hu niche Sahih hadith ka reference bhi hai. Cross check karna 👍
- Ak din hazrat Umar ne khulle maidan me sandas ko ja rhi Hazrate Sauda ko awaje lagake ched diya. Tab Allah 🔒 ne Umar ko saza deneke bazaye sari momin aurtoko hi burkha pehna diya. Sach bol rha hu. (ref- SahihBukhari-146)
I wish there were more people like this broad minded man in Pakistan .He is arguably the first person who has inspired me the most and knowing the presence of such people is such a relief .....
True brother agree with you
You will never hear about this kind of people in Pakistan. People in PK ignore logic and reason.
पाकिस्तान ने इस्लाम से पहले जो दुनिया को दिया गया 1दुनिया की सबसे पहले नगर कल्चर हड्डप्पा 2दूसरा दुनिया का पहली यूनिवर्सिटी तक्षशिला में थी 3दुनिया का सबसे पुराना धर्म हिंदू धर्म पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया 4दुनिया की सबसे पहले भाषा ग्रामर की किताब अष्टाध्याई Achaya पाणिनी ने पाकिस्तान में लिखी
5 दुनिया का सबसे बड़ा महाकाव्य महाभारत पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया र इसके अलावा
6 जिस सिकंदर को दुनिया में कोई नहीं हरा पाया पाकिस्तान में ही हारा यही झेलम पर सिकंदर को अपने idea मानतेऔर अपने बाप daade पोरस को हिकारत से देखते है
7 पाकिस्तान को लूट के हजारों औरतों के लेकर काबू में बेचने वाले गजनबी गौरी को आज भी पाकिस्तान बड़ी इज्जत की निगाह से देखता है हंसी आती
8जिसमें लाहौर को19 बार लूटने वाले अहमद शाह अब्दालीउसके नाम पर अपने तोपों के नाम रखते हैं और उस को हराने वाले लाहौर का पहला राजा महाराजा रणजीत सिंह को हिकारत की निगाह से देखते हैं
पाकिस्तान कि केवल दो बार अपनी राज्य हुई है एक राजा रणजीत सिंह की और एक sindमें राजा दाहिर मजे की बात दोनों के नाम पाकिस्तानीइतिहास से गायब है
This man should be the education minister of Pakistan.
90% of appreciation is from Indian this is what Pakistan youth is lacking they don't know whom to follow and learn from without any religious discrimination...I hope things will change for Pakistani youths atleast so that Pakistan can be considered as a normal state 10 - 15 yrs from now.
Accurate point I agree
Islam ka churan nhi h isiliye koi pakistani nhi dikh raha
This us what I was thinking. .pakistanis youth shhi baat sun na hi nhi chahti
im a Pakistan and i agree with you.
No one really cares if you're an Indian or not, you need to grow up a bit and should start to realize that no one's here going to praise you for being an indan.
That was a time , facebook recommed his video to me ,"france ka boycott tarikay se karain" from this i am fan of him .
Thank you brother. Love from India.
Good to hear this.
But be rest assured that someone like your previous self will kill him: sooner than later.
Try to protect him.
Regards.
Ex Muslim chennal (Sahil, Adam seeker, Zafer Heritec, Sachwala, Sameer, CIRA international, Hatun Tash, Apostate Prophet) pai jao or ISLAM ka reality jano 🙏🏼🙏🏼
@@satyajit2981 Bhai i am not an atheist please del this comment
@@fullinfo1 secularism khtm 🤣🤣
I am in the awe of this gentlemen. His knowledge, intelligence, discreet thinking and analysis and oratory is unparalleled.
Christopher Hitchens.... Rationalism
dont be awe....he was not talking about Hindus and Sikhs....
why don't you go to pakistan and enjoy with them.
Syeds are convert Brahmins
@@sauravdas2582 He was talking sense and he was talking about his country. He was also unequivocal regarding discrimination and pathetic conditions of minority communities in Pakistan.
what a speech. mashallah may allah keep you safe. i watched the entire thing in one sitting
What a man! It's because of people like you that we still have some hope left. Let's keep this work going.
Bro please tell me the history of this surname, why muslim using it still now. I never heard such surname in arab muslim. Shah, Malik, Nagoo, Sidhu, Nanda, Vohra, Rajput, Raja/Raza, Jakhar, Mallhi, Chamar, Butt, Randhawa, Chohan, Chowdhury, Dhillon, Chahil, Lakhani, Matto, Dar, Dua, Sehgal, Bajaj/Bazaz, Bakshi, Chowdhury, Rana, Umrani, Bhatia, Patel, Wani, Bhatti, Janjua, Jutt, Rajpoot, Dhillon, Chatha, Chadha, Gujjar, Indra, Kamboh, Parihar, Roy, Waraich(Varaich or Barayach in Hindus), Panwar, Gandapur , Sindh, Kakar, Suri, Panni, Gilani(Ghelani in Hindus), Sindhi
@@shubhamlate Whole Pakistan is India...and they are Indian 👍
True
Is that you sitting in right?
@@shubhamlate Similar surname proves conversion of Hindus into Islam .
I am from India. And I always watch Muzammils V Logue. He is true inspiration of every youth in South Asia . Love from India. May God keeps you in good health always.
Us bro us 💯🌻
Correct!
Pakistan is lost case. Sorry 😞😞😞💓💓💓
Not South Asia but indian subcontinent.
@@AMPA33 Neither he believes in your God.
First time I have seen such an intelligent person giving such beautiful thoughts in Pakistan. Bravo and God bless!
Big admirer of you sir. Such a great clarity of thoughts . Above all Long live Hindustan
This is called journalism, he is true human, i salute him from bottom of my heart ❤️
What a beautiful speech. Man seriously you are gem of our sub continent. Respect from India 🙏
I often it videos as they are based on reason n fact .
Gem of our subcontinent 😂😂. Esse yaee puchoo yaee kaun haee eskaee ancestors thaee kaun arabi turkey . Yaee saab kaee saab hindu Or Buddhist thaee yaee accept karregaa yaee. Gem of subcontinent😂😂
Indian subcontinent bol
ghanta .......issay jada gyan toh mera kutta jiska naam hai avinash d pelta hai.........
@@therock-mj4wh true 😅🤣
After 75 years of independence,
1) India 🇮🇳 is ranked 4th in terms of foreign-exchange reserves and Pakistan 🇵🇰 is ranked 4th in terms of debt default risk.
2) India is the world leader in IT (Information Technology) and Pakistan is the world leader in IT (International Terro,rism).
3) India has the world's highest number of software professionals at 4.5 million and Pakistan has the world's highest number of terro,rists at 78,500.
4) CEOs of most of the top multinational corporations are alumni of India's IITs and other universities and top leaders of most of the terro,rist organisations in the world are alumni of Pakistani madrassas.
5) India has its flag on Moon and Pakistan has Moon on its flag.
We Indians have a 600 billion dollars foreign reserves and Pakistan army have 650 gb videos of various politicians personnel life 😜😂
Kya milta he esi intellectual video pe ese bhadde comments kar k
Kya farak padta. Humara Competition toh china se hai.
🇮🇳
My ancestors were Hindu and were converted by Muslim invaders. Knowledge of the proper history of India is necessary to formulate an identity.
Jo pdaya jata hai wohi glat hai. Toh ap logo ki kya galti
@@sgofficial9220Thank you for your comment. I was lucky to develop my mind through education and research. Think critically and question everything. I am not a consumer of the Lahori chooran. That's why I love Muzammil's channel.
@@nitin9857 correct. I'm trying to find my original Hindu ancestry. I'm having difficulty beyond Muslim great Grand fathers from the mid 1800s.
My ancestors were hindu rajput rana family, now we are Muslims and we are proud of Islam .... Jao kr lo jo krna hai
@@Eric_Uthman kar to aap rahe ha. Apna khana kharab or bera garq..
Islam aik bimari ha jo aapko thokkkkkkk da ga 😆😆😆
Stay safe. AVOID ISLAM!!!!! IT'S A P.O.💩
I am actually awestruck at this man's flow of speech. Each point flowed so flawlessly.
Ek baar ko paper ya placards tak nahi rakha. Kitne research ke baad ek Banda aise bol sakta hai. Hats off.
It's also sad that Pakistanis think they have somewhat had a new birth out of nowhere after 1947. Like baptised and born new out of nowhere. Where in reality they were just us, eating, speaking, mentality just like us. Somehow they feel like relate to Turks who won't even accept them as permanent maids in their houses. (As pointed out by muzammil somewhere in the speech)
In the larger context, the Indian subcontinent incl Bangladesh, srilanka, Nepal, Pakistan, Bhutan all have similar thinking, way of life etc.
And more easy Asian countries like Vietnam Myanmar, Cambodia, Malaysia, Indonesia have larger Chinese influence. And they don't shy away from accepting that.
I mean it's a reality that you cannot run away from. It's good muzammil drilled on that point several times.
what you indians need to understand is that subcontinent is not a homogeneous regions it is a multi ethnic region made up of different racial backgrounds of people. The Pakistani ethnic groups Punjabi,Sindhi,Pashtun , Baloch, Gilgitis have nothing to do with indian ethnic groups of gangetic up bihari bengali and dravidian south indian tamil people. Pakistani ethnic groups are completely linguistically, ethnically, racially and culturally different from indian people. Try to understand this and stop obsessing over Pakistanis we don’t even look like you kala people
Hind. Hindi . Hind mahasagar.
Syed Muzammils words is mightier than the sword 👏. Glad the youth are paying attention.
I completely agree with you sir
And this person should be rewarded
U r looking like parvez mushraff-
Been constantly ignoring this video in my recommendation but I am blown away by this man. He has in depth knowledge on this topic. I am from hindi belt and I am lucky enough to stay in different states so can speak broken Bengali, nepali, telugu, Punjabi and multiple local dialect methali/awadhi(my mom N dad speak in it), haryanvi, rajasthani on top of it Hindi and English as well. Each of this language has their own history/culture and so does our South languages and our North East languages. So imposing one language on all is forcing them to give up their culture, history their story. Imposing it will not make them love it people will tend to hate it more and will feel alienated. I can be a proud Assamese, nagamese, Bengali, bihari, marathi, odia, nepali, telugu, Tamil, kannad, malayali, gujarati, Punjabi, Pahadi but I can still be proud indian.
As someone from outside the Hindi belt, I am relieved to here you understand why Hindi imposition is wrong. If I were ever to go to UP I would never expect them to learn my mother tongue. Imposing Hindi on non-Hindi speaking people is asking them to give up their own language, their own history.
@@yomamasohot6411 true... We in Assam had been protesting it. Coz Hindi had reduced the real Hindi belt languages like Garhwali, Awadhi, Maithili etc. We don't want that to happen in our place
@@yomamasohot6411 many Hindi belt people hate Hindi imposition.
@@yomamasohot6411 A garden has many plants and flowers. All are important. One may be more prevalent than others, but all are important. That is biodiversity and that is natures way of telling us that Hindi should not be imposed on non hindi belt people. I hail from the Hindi belt too. I dont think many people will support Hindi imposition even in Hindi belt.
Dear Muzzamil , I admire your courage of speaking on such issues in your country which have poorest record of saving and respecting minorities faith and belief . Hope many people hear and correct some though process which have been radicalised and trying to be in forefront of all worst religious practices ! Keep safe and keep on doing your good work !
My God! Who is this man who can speak extempore and non stop and so young. Each sentence is filled with deep insights. And where was this man hiding all these days from me.
Watch his other videos, you will learn so much
Goddamn he's a gem of your country if you're from Pakistan, save his voice to raise Pakistan, Shelter him if he faces any threat, There are similar voices out there in your nation , all it needs is demand for truth and reality check.
Blackrock he is mine. Get lost
Listening to him is such a intellectual treat. Love from India 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
As a very keen observer of Pakistan...for the very first time .. someone in Pakistan talking facts and rational ...keep it up sir..... regards all the way from BHARAT 🇮🇳
Ah from the motherland eh
Most of us know, it's the gorra western rule want this place to be islamic religious so they can sell weapons.
@@niceguy2568 perfect observer
Needs to read the translation of the holy Quran and Sunnah
Every individual owes identity to a single couple Adam and Eve.mrs ghazanfar thanks
Accha. Bharat me 11 saal se gandgi hai. Sach. Kaise jhuth se failaye gayi. Modi hai to ..Sab...Mumkin hai.
@@ghazanfarhussain5032aap upnishad padhen . Geeta ji padhen. Jai shri krishna.
POLITICAL SECULAR AND LIFESTYLE SECULAR.....wow..... this man is brilliant. Hats off from India.
Wali Khan quotable quote is " that for the last five thousands years I am pukhtun, am a Muslim for the last 1500 years and am a Pakistani only since 1947". In this order we should define our identity. No more no less.
In that case, what was the need for partition of inda, especially punbai-bengali sindh divisions from india, same people till 1947... !!.. (it was muslim league with jinnah at its head which startes direct action day that started religious riots in preparation india)..
you cannot be sure of being muslim since 1500 yrs.
Then you sure be Hindu since 8000 yrs
You guys are Hindus first then anything else. Your forefathers are converted to Islam as recently as 1947 partition.
@@sm1256 We are no longer Hindu. We are muslim now and thankful to our fore father's for leaving Hindu/ Buddhist/jain religion and accepting Islam.
Is this guy for real in Pakistan? Knowing that there is someone in Pakistan who talks sense is one thing but having balls to say it in Pakistan is the height of bravery. Sir Salute to u. I am a Punjabi Sikh settled in Canada. I hope common sense can prevail in Pakistani Punjab. I know for a fact that Pashtuns, Balochis and Sindhis have no doubt abt their ethnic back grounds. Baki Phajee please be safe in Pakistan. Truth is bitter to swallow for those who benefit from lies.
Khod to Khalistan ke nare lga rhe or Pakistanio ko nasihat de rhe ho 😂😂
Sami read my last name. And then Google KPS Gill (ex Punjab Police Chief). Just last name is sufficient. Jai Hind.
@@samip3124 Pehle Jaano, phir muh fado! Get a life boy.
@@NonieGill oh dfa ho jao tom khod sikho ke nsl ho hee nai lekan hm Pakistani real sikh bhaye ha unha Inshallah zarror support karta ha we want Khalistan 🚩❤️ 🇵🇰🇵🇰 💪
@@prashantdadhwal5885 oh dfa ho jao phle toilet bna lo tom loug phr hme nsihat deina
Gem of a thinker. World needs more and more people like him.
Not world.... Pakistan😂😂
india already have so many intellectuals
@@art_and_culture_ gobar or moot peene Wale intellectual 😀😀😀
@@khalidhasan7279 Abbe Madarsachhap 🤣. Abhi tu Bachcha hai Muhammad Paigambar ka Potty 💩 aur peshab 🤢🤮 khaane waalo aur Uunt 🐫💦 ka peshab piine waale intellectual
@@khalidhasan7279talking about hadiths of camel urine drinking 😂
Literally this man opened eyes of thousands of Muslims to pakistanis.... As an Indian I want to tell Pakistan that religion is person individual concept not countries concern people will have to understand this
Lekin pakistan to Arabi hai na turks hai 😊
It is good to see that,the new generation of Pakistan knows the history of the creation of Bangladesh to some extent. I hope this generation will change Pakistan.. To move forward you need to know your past as well as admit your mischief,Hope you will do that... Best of luck from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
We not buying establishment bullshite 😅
I hope all Pakistanis realise what a hero they have in Muzammil. So much to learn and unpack even for an Indian in America. Absolutely gold standard analysis
are you opposed to dharam sansad ? cause an indian "muzammil" would oppose that
@@pankaja7974 I would oppose that dharm sansad
@@pankaja7974 tunni Americans would never
l
@@r.k3261 Friend your assumption is wrong but I dont think its respectful to spam Muzammil's comment section with our internal Indian discourse. This is his moment , let us simply appreciate his scholarship.
One of the great talks i've heard to this date!! Keep up the good work 👏👏👏
Such a relief to see an actual Man in Pakistan.
A man who knows who he is, what his country is and does, and is so passionate about making others better that his voice chokes at some points during his lecture.. his knowledge and frustration upon duplicity of the System is too real to ignore. Pakistanis need a PM like this.
We Indians too want people like you, mr. Muzammil, to build upon our relations with your people. I hope this originality survives long enough to bring about a change, a real change there.
As an Indian-American, I have learned that no matter what corner of the world I’m in, my roots will always be in in India and its rich culture. The stronger I connect with the motherland the more clarity I have for my future. And the more I can contribute to the world. This was a great talk. Thank you 🙏🏽
I do find it strange why Pakistan is so hell bent on effacing it small ethnic heterogeneity. As an Indian, I have very strong sense of ethnic kinship but it doesn't mean that I am any less Indian or think of other Indian ethnic groups as not Indian. We are united by our common 'indianess'.
Very reason that Hindus are in majority kept things in sensible terms here . Hindu by nature are not fanatics or extremists
@@sagargart really do you even know the history of if not then maybe read h.m seervai and rss was the first organization to represent religion extremism and was ful of fanatics and terror 😐
@@levicodm1961 Okay. Give me 10 incidences of RSS terrorism across the world. And why it is not into any UN or international agencies list of terrorist organisation.
@@sagargart and expected gandhi was killed by it and many more political people but you wont know i dont know all the names as gandhi was a famous person i know it you can research for yourself terrorism inside country also count man
@@levicodm1961 Come in reality mate. It's not about me being right or you being right. Let's come to talk and seek truth. First of all I am neither a member, follower or supporter or RSS. Inspite of of someone who doesn't agree with everything that Gandhi says , I would choose and support Gandhi over RSS or savarkar. However I understand why people are getting intolerant and extremists. Why BJP and RSS are on rise. Hidutva is not an ideology or religion in itself. It comes as reaction to exploitation and annihilation done to the people of the indigenous culture and land . People are no more willing to stay quiet and be an audience to hundreds of years of torcher done to them by propagators of ideologies which are radical and exploitative in nature. What they are doing in china or to rohingiya or to palestinians or in France is something to think about. Why people are turning against you , you must think.
This man's every word hits home.. what an intellect
It's a rare privilege to have listened to such an erudite scholar, with such clarity of thought & flawless eloquence. I bow to to the scholarship of Mr Muzammil Shah. How I wish he visited India & presented his discourse in an Indian university & interacted with the Indian students too as did Dr Pervez Woodbhoy.
Respect for the impartial,sincere , rational and enlightened journalist ❤❤❤❤Syed Muzammil Keep on speaking truth
Dear Pakistanis save this man this is gem of Pakistan lots of love muzamil bhai ❤️ Love from India 🙏
Thank god that you exist bro, after tarak fateh second person from pakistan who is full of knowledge
A great session indeed. When you force anything on anyone the results would be hatred against the idea that you forced upon a person. Strict parents think they are rightfully raising their kids while in reality, they raising their enemies by doing this
Very true 👍
Hypocrite Muslim 😅😉🤣🤣☝
पाकिस्तान ने इस्लाम से पहले जो दुनिया को दिया गया 1दुनिया की सबसे पहले नगर कल्चर हड्डप्पा 2दूसरा दुनिया का पहली यूनिवर्सिटी तक्षशिला में थी 3दुनिया का सबसे पुराना धर्म हिंदू धर्म पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया 4दुनिया की सबसे पहले भाषा ग्रामर की किताब अष्टाध्याई Achaya पाणिनी ने पाकिस्तान में लिखी
5 दुनिया का सबसे बड़ा महाकाव्य महाभारत पाकिस्तान में लिखा गया र इसके अलावा
6 जिस सिकंदर को दुनिया में कोई नहीं हरा पाया पाकिस्तान में ही हारा यही झेलम पर सिकंदर को अपने idea मानतेऔर अपने बाप daade पोरस को हिकारत से देखते है
7 पाकिस्तान को लूट के हजारों औरतों के लेकर काबू में बेचने वाले गजनबी गौरी को आज भी पाकिस्तान बड़ी इज्जत की निगाह से देखता है हंसी आती
8जिसमें लाहौर को19 बार लूटने वाले अहमद शाह अब्दालीउसके नाम पर अपने तोपों के नाम रखते हैं और उस को हराने वाले लाहौर का पहला राजा महाराजा रणजीत सिंह को हिकारत की निगाह से देखते हैं
पाकिस्तान कि केवल दो बार अपनी राज्य हुई है एक राजा रणजीत सिंह की और एक sindमें राजा दाहिर मजे की बात दोनों के नाम पाकिस्तानीइतिहास से गायब है
THE BIGGEST PROBLEM OF PAKISTAN IS A FAILED/DEFEATED MILITARY WHICH WANT TO KEEP ITS HEADS UP BY INTERFERING IN DAY TO DAY AFFAIRS OF THE NATION. THE MOMENT PAKISTAN IS IN PEACE WITH INDIA THERE IS NO MORE ROLE FOR THE ARMY AND WILL REMAIN AS A POLICE FORCES, ARMY DON'T WANT TO HAPPEN THIS.
ANOTHER FACTOR IS A SIXTH CENTURY CULT RELIGION AND IT'S MULLAS WILL LOOSE THE HOLD AND IMPORTANCE IF THERE NO MANUPULATION OF RELIGIOUS HATE AGAINST OTHER GROUPS AND INDIAN PEOPLE. THEY WILL LOOSE THEIR LIVELIHOOD.
Burkhe wali aayat kab najil hui pta hai? Sach bol rha hu niche Sahih hadith ka reference bhi hai. Cross check karna 👍
- Ak din hazrat Umar ne khulle maidan me sandas ko ja rhi Hazrate Sauda ko awaje lagake ched diya. Tab Allah 🔒 ne Umar ko saza deneke bazaye sari momin aurtoko hi burkha pehna diya. Sach bol rha hu. (ref- SahihBukhari-146)
You have rare gift - I am fascinated on multiple fronts listening to you Muzzamil Your flow of well connected ideas in a non stop barrage with clear diction and great choice of words ; in the backdrop a vast historical reference and bluntly honest razor sharp critique - truly amazing scholarship and gift of the gab. Pakistan is lucky to have you 🌷
Very very informative and very well spoken.Being an Indian and a Bengali I find it very very useful not only for Indian but for whole human being for a state to survive for the betterment of their inhabitants.
This guy is a gem 💎in Pakistan
Save this. And Pakistan needs 100 people like this
Alhmdulillah! I was there. It was such an amazing and informative session. Thank You Muzamil...
Ye allahmudillah ne to tumhe barbad kiya
Alhamdulillah bolna jaruri hai🤣🤣 ye hai mind set .
jo bachpan se banaya ja rha hai,puri kaum khrab hai.
Hope Pakistani will concentrate on their problems and work with Rationality.
@@human-su4kj are yar muslim hain unka culture he aise bolna. Ab har bat ka majak banana jaruri he kya ?
🎶Yeh *sama* sama hai ye pyar ka
Kisi ke intzaar ka
Dil na chura le kahin mera
Mausam bahaar ka🎵
😁
This guy is great. He is intelligent, well-read, analytical and eloquent.
I'm amazed that this youth has such clarity on history, identity, and human rights. Even if 50% of Pakistani youths understand this and 25% of politicians think like this, Pakistan can become a powerful nation.
Powerful nation accha 😂😂
The existence of Pakistan is detrimental to the existence of India. Remember that.
You are amazed at his clarity, but I am more amazed at the lack of clarity of Indians like you.
Excellent speach. Pl translate into english.
@@vaibhavyadav9912 explain how Pakistan state can be detrimental to the existence of India? They have tried traditional wars 4 times, their strategy of thousand cuts has not only failed but turned back on to them and if you think their nuclear weapons is the danger then you probably haven't understood India's no-first-use policy. What are you scared of?
India needs Pakistan to be stable, prosperous and friendly. Without this the crisis will eventually spill into india as well.
I listen to this lecture almost daily .Such is the power of your thoughts ❤❤❤
May you live long brother, it's very dangerous to criticize army then even dangerous to criticize the religion.
He has no reason to criticise religion he is just criticising some pakistani pseudo muslims
Religion ko kanhi criticize nai Kiya properly define Kiya ki religion Kya hai country Kya hai aur politics Kya hai ethnicity Kya HOTA hai culture, language ka Kya importance HOTA hai .
Baki main ek BAAT to samaj gaya hun Pakistan is communist county where religion is main instrument of army.
1947 main radicals Muslims ne pure India ko bewakuf banaya hai.
Aapko itna nahi girna chahiye tha.....He is not criticizing religion....lekin shayad aap ko Boht accha Lage ga agar koi kare.
Please apna naam badal kar , koi Hindu ya Christian naam rakhlo..gaddaro ko pechanne meh asaani hogi aise.
@@MR.FlyingMonkey gaddar to wo the jinhone talwaaron ke darr se salwaarein khol di aur islam kabool kiya, jo itna sehne ke baad bhi apne dharm aur imaan par tike rahe vo hai asli insaan(yaani hindus)
@@DarkKnight-db1dy 🤣
Areh baba ji 🙏
Agar talwar seh kiya hai toh tuh bhi karke dekh leh...Puri family ke saat samshan ghat meh milega🙄.
Pathar pujne seh accha aadmi koi religion apna leh isiliye hamne chora.
Aur kuch log sati , Niyog, Jauhar, female foeticide, aur caste operation ke wajah seh chore. Boht Brahmins aur rajputo neh bhi chor diya...woh toh tumse bhi zyaada extreme bahadur hote hai. Aur tuh khud ko insaan bol raha hai , baaki 6.7 billion log insaan nahi🤦😂
I'm an Indian. Excellent speech worth listening. I don't know how many of the Audience understood & appreciated the speech being much Radicalized. But every Pakistani should listen to this.
Pakistan might have 0.1% people thinking like u
I am an Indian but love his speech..clarity abt history and future as well.
Never seen such a brave young man before in Pakistan.
More power to you brother.
Keep speeking truth and exposing the religious goons ♥️
Bravo Muzammil Bhai !!!!! What a shining light you are for the entire continent of Asia 👏👏👏
I am sure this man will bring change in Pakistan...more power to you 👏
Your lectures are creating an impact on young Pakistani students. How you think out of the box and shock us every time with blatant and real facts is really powerful. Your words enhance our horizon to see things with critical eye. More power to you!
Right 👍,Pakistanis are Mansik Gulams of Islamic Invaders ,and Dynast politicians 😆😆🤣🤣..
Pakis originally Belongs to ancient Indian(Indus(Hindus)) civilisation but were forcibly converted by Islamic Invaders 😵💫😵💫
I think the amount of this type of discussions should be increased bcoz this will help alot in de-radicalise youth mindset for better future.
Seek the 🔊 identity from the
Translation of the holy Quran and the sunnah
As descendents.of the first couple
Adam and Eve creatures species
Human to return to eternal Abode
Men women have sought identity in
Land language ancestry
Recognise self in the Divine guidance
❤❤❤
@@ghazanfarhussain5032 Adam was first mentioned in Jewism, when Quran and Islam was not even born...and Moreover the Adam story is a myth, imaginary story..
Man.. I am an Indian and I am proud of folks like you who has the audacity to speak truth.. I wish you and the next gen Pakistani youth to bring upon a change in your own country and set a path of introspection first before looking outwards for solution.. the moment the youth in pakistan think more on an economic perspective and keep religion personal choice.. Pakistan can shine..
I am student of puniab university i missed this particular seminar because hall was full and we didn’t find any place literally i was waiting for this video to shared and now the wait is over ❤😊 thank Yu Sir
This Young lad is far far better than any of Pakistani Thinkers and politicians.. We need more people like him not only for Pakistan but across the world including India . Amazing knowledge and perfectly narrated.. 🙏🙏
Am a proud Indian.
Am equally proud of the fact, that people like you exist in my neighborhood. It takes a good amount of nerves to speak nothing but stark truth. Salute, Sir!!
The biggest takeaway from this for us Indians is that we must maintain and celebrate the diversity we have in terms of everything. So that apne hi log humko chhor k na chala jaye. The biggest identity we must have is we are Indians.
Even culture is important and sanaatan dharma and many more. And remember when economy is strong then only things work in such situation orelse it's tough.
Yes we are bhartiya
Yeh Indian identity akaash se nahi tapaki. Yeh pehchaan Sanatan Dharm ke granthon se aayi hai
Biggest takeaway from this guy for India is that we must stop thinking India was formed in 1947. The Bharathiya civilization East of the Sindu river existed for over 10000 years.
No wonder Nehru tinkered with our history too.
This is perhaps the best commentary and analysis I have heard coming from a Pakistani. Such depth and clarity of speech delivered so eloquently! Hats off to Mr Muzammil. Pakistan needs thousands of people like you to bring about a change. God bless you. On a side note, I am surprised by two things. Most of the views/ comments are from Indians. I wish the Pakistanis listen to you more than the crazy politicians. The other thing that baffles me is how few people have subscribed to your channel. Makes me believe you are still a hidden gem in your own country.
There is hardly any Pakistani video on which you don’t find more Indian comments than Pakistani
I don’t know what’s the reason .. music news sports .. even if it’s Pakistani content you ll find more Indian comments ..
The internet proliferation and the population is far greater than Ind but must be something to do with Indian Gen Z culture the way they are commenting on literally everything.. there are other countries in the World US China etc which are both advanced and have high number of internet users but somehow Indians outnumber them when it comes to spamming and commenting lol
@Ummair That is India's problem...being an Indian myself..we should have forgotten about Pak a long time ago..and vice versa .Pak should forget about India and esp Kashmir and work on their internal politics to save their own country.We as Indians should compete with Developed countries like USA , China etc etc...
@@krislo4788 honestly if you look at the news channel yr extremist media is obsessed over Pakistan
On the other hand our media gives yr country far less air time
Yr whole shows are dedicated for discussion on Pakistan
So called internet experts like Major Arya earns his bread and butter by talking on Pakistan ..
As for Kashmir, our support for their just struggle will always be there because it’s an international dispute .. however, our focus is on bigger internal things .. economy businesses inflation security unemployment etc
@@UmairSajid Remove your army from POK first as per UNO..then we will talk about the plebcite..as per the rules of UNO....You have occupied our land illegally anyway..POK and Gilgit..so first remove your army from POK and both our countries can talk...if your God forsaken country remains a country..wishing you luck✌️
@@UmairSajid what kind of focus?? Your country has been knocking doors of every possible country,begging for money....Keeping insults aside( bcoz Pakistan itself seems like a insult now😂) u really should b ashamed of ur condition and work on it ryt nw rather than looking for an ego massage and procrastinating ur superiority....in 1990s wen India had to go to IMF for money ,the entire country was embarassed and decided to change our fate from there..and today we are in one of the top 5 countries of the world...deep inside we want your country to b destroyed( woh tum khud kar rahe ho without any external influence😂) bt logically agar neighbor kharab ho toh apne ghar ka climate bhi khrb hota he..so sudhro gadho..ISLAM ISLAM karna chod do..even the Arabs find u worse than pigs..All the best👍
Wow, you are one of the few Pakistanis I appreciate for their thoughts & understanding the real issues of Pakistan.
So informative and educative !!!
Salutations ...Muzammil Bhaai....pak/islamists in Indian subcontinent need educators like you.
Just wonderful to hear a young pakistani muslims speak so rationally and logically. There may yet be hope for that nation if there are more minds who think like this and have the guts to speak out without fear. Stay safe
As a Pakistani Our first job after this video is to ponder very hard over our identity...
We want you'll to be more orthodox, Fanatic and Staunch Muslim like Pathana. You'll should follow strictly Koran Hadis and MOHAMMAD.
@@madanprakash7445 why u want to discourage someone when they want to self respect.. ?.
You sarcastic comments and hatred will not take u anywhere..
@@siddhantk4985 siddhant ji ua-cam.com/video/RZar96Wd-6A/v-deo.html one more revolutionary channel concerning muslims in subcontinent
There is ntng called pakistan as an identity
@@siddhantk4985 it's not hate......do u think this will have any change in them?‼️ He just explained what they are.....they are too late to start this discussion.....there is no 10 years fr this fake nation called Pakistan.....the only way fr then is to become worse perish and then india will show a new way fr them
I'm Rajput from india, asked questions to pakistan named Aseem Rajput that your ancestors are hindus ? he said My ancestors are Arab's, i was like ok but it hurts when your family members forgets #Home
Muslim Rajputs aren't your family members. Dalit Hindus from Tamil Nadu are the sooner you get it, the better for all of us.
He is misguided. Cut from roots. N hence facing identity crisis.
The speaker speaks realistically which matches the Indian mentality and culture. My India is Great ❤🇮🇳
He is true Diamond of Pakistan .
Listen him & adopt his Ideas,
Single Person in Pakistan who talks about Truth.
Keep it up Brother. Love from India
Awesome speech, with such a clarity of thought and our common history. Being an Indian we feel partly connected to this and really want our neighbours to realise even now and have a course correction for a better, safer future of their country and South Asia as a whole.
Really respect you for this line of thought.
Never knew this kind of intellectuals exists in 🇵🇰
We Hindus were always Secular, But because Muslim Community became Radical First, We Hindus had to turn up Radical in Defence. Eg - Uttar Pradesh
What a logic...😂😂😂😂
India(which was mostly hindu) was always secular. But people like you were NEVER secular. Good and just people never changes their morals and ideology no matter what happens.
Look into your vedas and scriptures, if you had read those you'd know what I mean.
Oh bhai padha hai veda or upanishad samjha bhi hai usko ham to garv karte hai hamare ancestors ne likha hai use tumhe nahi samjh aati to usme hamara koi dosh nahi hai bhai ok 😊@@globalcitizen270
@@globalcitizen270India is secular because of us hindus we see a muslim majority country become Islamic eg is labnon
@@globalcitizen270 tu to bol hi mat bhai
Very true.
Save this guy on any cost. MashaAllah he is so brilliant 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻💗.
Where r u from
Absolutely amazed by this erudite scholar. If he is able to rally the educated and modern youth of Pakistan behind him, the country will surely see great days ahead. Lots of appreciation from India.
Syed is a critical thinker,he appreciated the Baloch nation,Baloch jatna bi religious ho jahe rahta wo politically secular hi hai.
That y i like baloch👍
Pashtun too, we both are Iranian 🚩🚩