Pakistan's Education Crisis: A Futureless System? | EconFest Debate

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 133

  • @ahmedrazamughal
    @ahmedrazamughal 6 днів тому +3

    The host is a living example of what is wrong with education system of Pakistan

  • @aakm1525
    @aakm1525 24 дні тому +11

    The professor was actually giving very crucial suggestions. But unfortunately the boss didn't hear that. Your higher ranks does not mean that your opinion will be right always.

  • @AsiyaNaqi-t7h
    @AsiyaNaqi-t7h 19 днів тому +5

    Well said Ma'am Aqsa, you explained the issues very effectively totally agreed with your profound thoughts

  • @RaguRaghupathi
    @RaguRaghupathi Місяць тому +28

    With such an arrogant moderator - he knows it all - the participants were continuously humiliated! If the moderator is so knowledgeable, why have this session in the first place?

    • @aminajaved8199
      @aminajaved8199 23 дні тому +1

      @@RaguRaghupathi I completely agree with you. I was going to say the same thing.

    • @SaraKhan-t6z
      @SaraKhan-t6z 22 дні тому +1

      @@RaguRaghupathi exactly that's what I was thinking that how he is the conducting this program he is so proud of being A GC teacher and he saying that we did This we did that we r doing that Kamal hy

    • @dr.shaun.g
      @dr.shaun.g 12 днів тому

      @@RaguRaghupathi you nailed it. This guy is so arrogantly dumb

  • @Pohantoon
    @Pohantoon Місяць тому +22

    Disappointing. The title of the session is catchy but unfortunately the entire discussion is irrelevant and futile. Besides, why invite panelists if the host already knows everything about the subject matter.

  • @Diebe-ks8ws
    @Diebe-ks8ws 28 днів тому +3

    This arrogant behavior of the moderator is a good picture of what is wrong with the system. These old souls, being insecure themselves, in big offices, thinks that they know everything and they don’t want to let other people solve anything. This is typical Pakistani Sarkari Afsar behavior, they can destroy whole departments or sometimes generations instead of listening to others.

  • @rj6404
    @rj6404 Місяць тому +6

    A weak foundation cannot support a tall structure , foundations are key to the future .

  • @adaborfun
    @adaborfun Місяць тому +9

    I am very disappointed to say that the moderator is very biased towards his university. Moreover, the behaviour of the moderator is very arrogant.

  • @abdulmalik5852
    @abdulmalik5852 Місяць тому +23

    You guys talked in English. I am writing in English. Our 95 percent population doesn't understand English. This summarizes our educational system.
    Education should be in the mother tongue.

  • @asianazar8022
    @asianazar8022 Місяць тому +11

    This program was held and recorded almost an year ago at Alhmra art council, I attended it and founded the VC very rude and humiliating and gender biased during entire program he continued humiliating Miss Aqsa repeatedly and the students who dared to ask the questions.

    • @yasmeeniqbal7002
      @yasmeeniqbal7002 Місяць тому

      Yeah such a jahil host

    • @Knowledge_Hunt
      @Knowledge_Hunt Місяць тому +2

      No, are you talking about VC? He is a very learned person, and even if he did criticize someone, he rightly did so.

    • @zubairmuhammad8972
      @zubairmuhammad8972 Місяць тому

      @@asianazar8022 don't agree with u, plz

  • @suppltv5345
    @suppltv5345 29 днів тому +11

    السلام عليكم۔ میں نے مکالمہ مکمل سنا ہے ۔27 منٹ 27 سیکنڈ کا مکالمہ تھا جس کو 54 منٹ 55 سیکنڈ پیش کیا۔ اسی طرح وقت ضائع ہوتا ہے۔ جب بات بنیاد ی تعلیمی نقائص کی بات ہے تو اردو یا انگریزی بات ایک زبان میں کرنی چاہیے۔ ایسا نہیں پاکستانیوں کو انگریزی نہیں آتی سن بول اور لکھ سکتے ہیں۔یہ مسئلہ قومی ہے اردو میں ہی ہونا چاہئے ناکہ عالمی۔ میں انگریزی سے اختلاف نہیں کرتا وہ ایک زبان ہے بس۔

  • @saqibhaidersyed4428
    @saqibhaidersyed4428 18 днів тому +1

    Absolutely Right,I do agree that our education system and degrees are dead rubber,no skill set development,not relevent to the job market needs.Many degrees are irrelevant to the job market.Faculty and curriculum is old schooled.That is why the world don't recognize our degrees and universities.

  • @pinkikhan3883
    @pinkikhan3883 14 днів тому +1

    She raised very basic points which are absolutely exist,,,

  • @billzkhan100
    @billzkhan100 Місяць тому +4

    As soon as the VC started talking about Dr Allama Iqbal in the traditional way.. Mujahy samjh aa gayee kaybyeh riwayaati discussion hai..

  • @mahnoorsajjad9921
    @mahnoorsajjad9921 Місяць тому +3

    The problem is not with the curriculum and something else . Only one thing is that monopoly of one institution on whole system. Last 70 years, we only taught students to glorify national anthem in universities. Students only got in universities as they supposed to get. Secondly, authoritarian approach at teaching level is one of the soul factors that led the nations at this level. Critical thinking is discouraged.

  • @mahmoodsahotra3824
    @mahmoodsahotra3824 26 днів тому +2

    I strongly disagree that curriculum does not matter. Both the curriculum and the way it is taught are equally important.

  • @muhammadjunaid4589
    @muhammadjunaid4589 Місяць тому +6

    The host of the seminar, vc, is very arrogant.

  • @asadabbasmirza9519
    @asadabbasmirza9519 Місяць тому +4

    School.going age in Finland is 7 years whereas ours r pushed at 2.5 years
    Only 22 to 25 % age go to higher education.......

  • @Health-Blitz
    @Health-Blitz Місяць тому +27

    the old guy conducting this panel is very arrogant
    also he thinks that speaking in fake accent will make him sound smarter
    unless you get rid of such arrogant people, your country cannot progress

    • @TeslaHugestFan
      @TeslaHugestFan Місяць тому +3

      I was about to write the same and I don’t have to write the same. His fake accent is very irritating. I work in. America and this accent totally puts me off

    • @Health-Blitz
      @Health-Blitz Місяць тому +1

      @@TeslaHugestFan 👍

    • @faisalshahzad9314
      @faisalshahzad9314 Місяць тому +2

      Agreed

    • @Health-Blitz
      @Health-Blitz Місяць тому +2

      @@faisalshahzad9314 Yeah, he was disrespecting the woman sitting on the stage again and again
      it is unacceptable

  • @DrAahad-xo6ev
    @DrAahad-xo6ev Місяць тому +6

    Bravo! Education with nu future!
    Shikayat hey mujeh ya rab khudawandanay Maktub se. Sabaq derahey hen soft concepts tifilay makab men.
    Nu Demand driven skills.
    Scalability.

  • @kashifkaifee
    @kashifkaifee 29 днів тому

    What a discussion, hats off sir ❤️

  • @shujaatali-zb8uv
    @shujaatali-zb8uv 14 днів тому +1

    Such an arrogant host! His attitude towards the audience and the panelists is unbearable. This type of arrogant people is the main hindrance in the ways of success in education. All the people present in the session should have bycott the host during the session.

  • @khalidaahmad7835
    @khalidaahmad7835 21 день тому

    Quality education is a basic right of all learners from various backgrounds from age 5 to higher education and responsibilities of techers to provide quality education to all learners.

  • @toobabatool4678
    @toobabatool4678 Місяць тому +2

    Addressing to the second question posed by the moderator Mr. Qasim Kasuri used some of the fancy words which are used in routine by people of same sectir as his, but the irony is even though creativity and critical thinking is practiced in the classrooms of private sector, these are most of the time oral activities. Students are given a lot of writing work afterwards as homework!!!

  • @shamaaleem975
    @shamaaleem975 16 днів тому +1

    The moderator was not aware of his role and played as Judge or a decision maker which destroyed the very purpose of an "OPEN" discussion. He used the penalists only to present his fixed views rudely and crudely.

  • @FahimKhan-ty7kp
    @FahimKhan-ty7kp 26 днів тому +2

    طبقاتی نظام تعلیم
    بھی ایک بہت بڑا مسئلہ ہے ۔
    آپ کو اس پر بات کرنی چاہیے ۔

  • @adeelahmedawan1079
    @adeelahmedawan1079 Місяць тому +5

    No doubt this is an intellectual session and we need more but agr mn audience mn baitha hta tu kbhi question na krta q k VC sahib ka attitude kafi zada arrogant ha ksi hadh tk humiliating behavior ha, as a teacher i don’t think so such a behavior is acceptable. Contradiction between words and vision.

  • @tabrezkhan24
    @tabrezkhan24 Місяць тому

    Agreed 💯 with ur opinions

  • @sairamehmood7024
    @sairamehmood7024 Місяць тому +2

    I believe the only one reason for teaching for sorry Infront of students is that they see their students bare handed even investing 4years for Future career,if the students get opportunity I believe they can perform well even with limited knowledge or skills. the game is Only of opportunities for implementation of our knowledge..

  • @BilalButt-q4x
    @BilalButt-q4x 22 дні тому

    32:41 respectable movement 😊

  • @sehrishnida
    @sehrishnida Місяць тому +1

    Excellent

  • @alandoe6622
    @alandoe6622 Місяць тому +3

    With this ignorantly arrogant and arrogantly ignorant VC of GC, expect descend from mediocrity to incompetence.

  • @tayratayra8578
    @tayratayra8578 12 днів тому

    Sir, you are right about AI's dominance but even after billions of years, the AI can not replace doctors because they can't understand the emotions well . They may do best in others but not in mental health sector.

  • @badarzaman5561
    @badarzaman5561 Місяць тому +1

    Punjab School Privatization Py Bhi bat honi chiye

  • @mtayyab6852
    @mtayyab6852 21 день тому +1

    Rude moderator, such a pity that he is the VC of a premier university.

  • @ashaharyani7733
    @ashaharyani7733 Місяць тому

    Informative channel 😊

  • @Philosophersvibes
    @Philosophersvibes Місяць тому +1

    Issue yeh hy k yeh former VC khud student ko categorise krta th dressing ki bases py, inhn criticise krny walon ka future khrab krta th by expelling them…

  • @KhanAhmad-d1c
    @KhanAhmad-d1c Місяць тому

    Great ❤❤❤

  • @Slayer123-g6v
    @Slayer123-g6v Місяць тому +5

    GLOBAL INNOVATION INDEX 2024 RAnking (INDIAN Subcontinent)
    INDIA -39 th (world )
    SRILANKA-89 th
    PAKISTAN -92 th
    NEPAL -104th
    BANGLADESH -114th
    India jumped 42 steps ranks from 82 in 2015 to 39 in 2024

  • @atifafzal6311
    @atifafzal6311 23 дні тому

    The educational system which is nowhere in the world.. such a shame that even sfter 70 plus years there is no high budget allocation.planning, vision,for the youth..

  • @adnanmagsi9496
    @adnanmagsi9496 12 днів тому

    I think when they say that curriculum is not important or less important, it is their narrow view of curriculum. And even if we have problems with curriculum implementer (teachers) then i believe we need to make sound teacher training curriculum for pre-service and in-service teachers. In addition, when the Kasuri sahb gave example of Finnish Curriculum, the one of the most important parts of the Finnish Curriculum is bridging gap between the theory and practice which we lack in Pakistan. Simply, curriculum should not be underrated.

  • @ashrafalam6075
    @ashrafalam6075 Місяць тому +2

    Respected Penalist, First 40- 50 years education system produces ( roughly) 80 % for local needs and 20% for international market. Now only top 10 - 20 institutions are producing 100% for international market. Rest institutions are producing for routine clerical jobs. Those who are going to international market have become Slaves ( More Mental,some financially). Is anyone interested to Educate masses in Pakistan. Conciously total infrastructure has been destroyed ( Peelay Schools/ Colleges).

  • @OmkarOmkar-j9n
    @OmkarOmkar-j9n Місяць тому +2

    1 hote Bina aaknh ke andhe or
    1 hote hi Pakistan 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @qasimaslam2622
    @qasimaslam2622 Місяць тому +1

    Here is my question ❓
    Apny basis ko development counties ky educational basis Sy kese compete karengy
    Ager app Yahan ky educational system ko direct jaky higher level merge ker dengy tu oski basis kese hasli hogi
    Ye Jo Gap ha oski fulfilment kese hogi'
    Asan lafzon me samjha dun Yaha ka bacha radio nhi bana Sakta osky oper research ki zarorat ha tu direct app osko iphone kese banana sikhaengy ye Jo bech me gap ha wo kese fill Hoga kia hum dunya Sy hamesha 50 Saal pichy hi rahengy

  • @andleebarshad-hi8kc
    @andleebarshad-hi8kc Місяць тому +1

    Mujhe ye bataein educated hazrat k jolog English MN nahi parhe hoe wo apki discussion kese samjhein

  • @asterrani7706
    @asterrani7706 26 днів тому

    Teacher hun or teaching 8 years ki lakin jis curriculum ko dekha or system to regulate sab mein aik link hote he nehi

  • @Philosophersvibes
    @Philosophersvibes Місяць тому +1

    He is not vc of GCU anymore dont write VC with his name

  • @muhammadbilalmirajdin3764
    @muhammadbilalmirajdin3764 Місяць тому +2

    what an outdated and useless way of discussion. that HOST is living in an alternate reality.

  • @zakaullahabbasi5975
    @zakaullahabbasi5975 Місяць тому

    Nice Answered by VC GC to lady professor.

  • @Abdulwahab-110-s5d
    @Abdulwahab-110-s5d Місяць тому +1

    31:15 In this moment o got to know that in Pakistan there will be no reforms will come in future because we don't have exactly assets that we invest in it even our time 😆😆😆

  • @amberzareen3055
    @amberzareen3055 24 дні тому

    Lady professor was competent and had valid arguments. The so called moderator was very rude and arrogant. Also disrespectful towards audience and female professor

  • @asifkar
    @asifkar Місяць тому +1

    For sure, GC VC doesn't know the meaning of curriculum and that's why he mentioned skills separate from Content Teaching. Keep it up.

  • @himayatullah7437
    @himayatullah7437 Місяць тому +1

    If the behaviour of VCs is kept this way. We will never be able to progress .

  • @obaidullahmirwani2923
    @obaidullahmirwani2923 Місяць тому +3

    Baloch not balochi sir plz say correctly

    • @PIDEOfficial
      @PIDEOfficial  Місяць тому +2

      Right Dear noted. Will correct it

  • @asterrani7706
    @asterrani7706 26 днів тому

    Student ki demand society ki jo requirements donu he curriculum mein nehi

  • @abdulhameedkhatti9231
    @abdulhameedkhatti9231 Місяць тому +1

    Insy behtr mein bol skta hun issue py

  • @kotresh31jan
    @kotresh31jan Місяць тому +2

    Why debate on Quality Education when you have plenty of Madrassa that are imparting knowledge & skills to PakPunjabi youth…??? Now you have a state guest Dr Zahil Nalayak and u missed calling him for this moot to take his words of wisdom for upliftment education…!!!

  • @bemotivatedwithmurad5805
    @bemotivatedwithmurad5805 Місяць тому

    nice couplet of iqbal

  • @adventuresofelishapaul4418
    @adventuresofelishapaul4418 26 днів тому

    pakistani education is a real problem. since in fsc we are reading mr chips novel for the last 50 years. It was introduced in 1970s, it is in english syllabus since then. i read it, my father, my old uncle, my college professor, my college dean, old people that were in 70s , stuck with us since then.

  • @FahimKhan-ty7kp
    @FahimKhan-ty7kp 26 днів тому

    Sir
    I think you are going to miss language problems,we didn't decide yet that either our national language is Urdu or English.

  • @PracticalWisdom360
    @PracticalWisdom360 19 днів тому

    ۔جب نشان حیدرٹیچرکو نہیں مل سکتا تو اگلے 76 سال بھی تعلیمی نظام بہترنہیں ہوسکتا۔

  • @abbasshahi8608
    @abbasshahi8608 Місяць тому +1

    Please leave Iqbal Sb for the future of Pakistan.His ideology doesn't have room for free thinking rather a party against a secular way of life.Dr Ali is branding his institute in the name of Iqbal Sb.

  • @facts7366
    @facts7366 Місяць тому +1

    Just to address the issue that Curriculum doesn't matter the thing that matters is Teacher Ability to deliver the lecture
    Things needed to be in mind
    Teacher didn't have complete independence what he/she think it's right for their students as they are bound with the curriculum. 2nd thing Teachers that's going to teach the student is definitely going to be from the Pakistan institute so how dare he that he will deliver anything extra if the approach they gain fron their teachers is the same of following the Curriculum.
    The Moderator is taking more time than penalist sound like a puppet who is defending Higher Authority in every possible manner

  • @TeslaHugestFan
    @TeslaHugestFan Місяць тому +3

    The dude or the host is hijacking

  • @ashaharyani7733
    @ashaharyani7733 Місяць тому

    ❤❤❤❤❤😊

  • @aminajaved8199
    @aminajaved8199 23 дні тому

    I think the moderator is pretty biased when it comes to gender. He repeatedly disagreed with whatever Miss Aqsa said. I know differences of opinion shape our discourse but his particular disagreement is what put this whole conversation off.
    While reading comments, I'm glad other listeners noticed this too.

  • @pinkikhan3883
    @pinkikhan3883 14 днів тому

    In any level of education anovation, experiments, hidden tellent, are not allowed to show

  • @asghargopang4217
    @asghargopang4217 28 днів тому +1

    What a rubbish session where host is so rude and arrogant and guests are not well aware about the relevant topic.
    The actually problem in education system is the rude and arrogant behavior of teachers like this host who humiliate the students for asking questions . Secondly,we are artificial in speaking, lecturing and dealing like here everybody is trying to talk in English!!

  • @AamirAliSeelro-g5j
    @AamirAliSeelro-g5j 12 днів тому

    The moderator seems pretty much knowledgeable. He single handedly could have done all. Lol!
    Let's learn to respect others' opinions Mr VC.

  • @asterrani7706
    @asterrani7706 26 днів тому

    Numbers game or first or second positions or buht kuch

  • @professoraftab7488
    @professoraftab7488 Місяць тому +1

    اب ماضی کو ہی یاد کر کے زندہ رہو۔موجودہ پاکستان میں تعلیم کا ماحول نہیں ہے۔نام کی یونیورسٹیاں ہیں اور برائے نام پروفیسرز۔

  • @truthseeker000
    @truthseeker000 28 днів тому

    I met this guy but was highly disappointed due to his bad manners and arrogant behaviour. When such people will lead this discussion so we can well imagine that our future is safe or not????

  • @first6969
    @first6969 Місяць тому +1

    The Day You Decided To Invite Dr Zakir Naik.
    You Set Your Priorities Clear.
    Where Your Country Has To Align / Head.

  • @theultimatenoor
    @theultimatenoor 19 днів тому

    No substantial arguments in discussion and vague solutions that even a high school student can suggest - time wasted indeed.

  • @AmjadAli-cm6oq
    @AmjadAli-cm6oq 11 днів тому

    The host's behavior was incredibly unprofessional and disappointing. If time was limited, there was no need to allow the audience to ask questions only to respond with frustration and hostility. It was disrespectful to see the host resort to abusive language when audience members simply wanted to engage in the discussion. Such conduct creates a negative atmosphere

  • @mariyumakhtar1699
    @mariyumakhtar1699 Місяць тому

    Sanam Saeed after barzakh is here

  • @ashaharyani7733
    @ashaharyani7733 Місяць тому

    Pakistan zindabad thx❤❤❤😊😊

  • @grankhan5648
    @grankhan5648 Місяць тому +4

    Many friends in comment section are talking about the host's behavior but i think there is no rude behavior no arrogance from moderator, he was just disagreeing with logic and argument, and that is very good to see because in Pakistan we don't have this culture.
    More important, why are we observing behaviors, just focuse on ideas and arguments🙂

  • @quddusquddus136
    @quddusquddus136 Місяць тому

    Who gave these panelists the right to talk about a very important subject? She in her yellow outfit could have been delivering missiles from the Hezbollah outpost in Lebanon-half English and half Urdu. Nobody offered her a glass of water. Just to calm her down.

  • @OmkarOmkar-j9n
    @OmkarOmkar-j9n Місяць тому +1

    Kon sa muslman is Dunia ko kuch
    Dia mantal cash 🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @khalidaahmad7835
    @khalidaahmad7835 21 день тому

    Teachers must plan to support learning for 6 to 8 hours for active learning. And students must spend 6 to 8 hours in active learning.

  • @atifafzal6311
    @atifafzal6311 23 дні тому

    Hmm.so future does not need education system of pakistan..🤔

  • @Philosophersvibes
    @Philosophersvibes Місяць тому +1

    I hate this man, GCUL ka bera garq kia is ny

  • @sharifuddindar6534
    @sharifuddindar6534 22 дні тому

    السلام علیکم ورحمة الله
    Pride and prejudice of the anchor will never allow you to reach a viable solution.

  • @adventurequotes5888
    @adventurequotes5888 26 днів тому

    As you GC university chancellor you should ashamed because you are responsible for this disaster

  • @YoutubwatcherLearner
    @YoutubwatcherLearner Місяць тому

    Such a pathetic way to discuss about educating plan and strategies nothing is here which become a source of gaining something.moreover host and that lady guest arrogant and impolite

  • @niyajee
    @niyajee Місяць тому

    Quran hadiths sabse best books hein. Sara knowledge isme hai. Allah ki books ke aagey insano ki books ki koi aukaat nahi. Ye earth ki life ek test hai aur test paas karke jannat jana hai. So ye education sab bakwas hai. Education ka Matlab Sirf aur Sirf Allah ki books padhna hai.

  • @noorfatima8688
    @noorfatima8688 24 дні тому

    How rude is this moderator!

  • @alikhanlhr
    @alikhanlhr 28 днів тому

    The old guy conducting this session is unreasonable and arrogant. He is using Philosophy of Iqbal who was a tout of British colonist. Also he was talking very rudely to the people who were asking genuine question.
    Eventually when we have this kind of old generation i am sure WE WILL NEVER HAVE EDUCATION with ANY FUTURE. ...

  • @UsmanKhan-yp3jt
    @UsmanKhan-yp3jt 12 годин тому

    آپ ایک جامعہ کے وائس چانسلر ہے اور آپ کے باتوں سے ہی پتا چل رہا ہے کہ ایجوکیشن سسٹم میں کہاں مسلئہ ہے مسلئہ اخلاقیات میں ہیں پہلے دوسروں سے بات کرنے کا طریقہ سیکھے پھر پروگرام کو ہوسٹ کریں 🙏🏻

  • @OmkarOmkar-j9n
    @OmkarOmkar-j9n Місяць тому

    Islam lackhuar Dena janta bus🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @murtazaali-637
    @murtazaali-637 12 днів тому

    ap jasy moderator education system pa booj hy
    qasm isy sun k jahil rehna hi bhtr lag rha h

  • @muhammadnaeem7812
    @muhammadnaeem7812 Місяць тому

    Kasuri tu ny education system bera gharak kya

  • @storyverse705
    @storyverse705 Місяць тому

    Funny people

  • @GuzzarAwan
    @GuzzarAwan 25 днів тому

    Total BAKWAS

  • @anveshpadhy6469
    @anveshpadhy6469 Місяць тому +3

    Zakir Naik's public gatherings will lead to Pakistan being a highly educated nation. Please keep him for some more time.

    • @supersayaaain
      @supersayaaain Місяць тому

      😂😂

    • @tlp8669
      @tlp8669 25 днів тому

      @@anveshpadhy6469 I think so😁😁😁