what you said on your number 2 is exactly the answer for all of those who can't understand why drag race are bringing allstars 1 girls for their 3d shot
My only issue with AS2 was that it felt like they sometimes really favored Alaska. AS5 was a great cast with a shitty format. I hated the lipsync assassin and the "everyone who's not in the top is in the bottom" twists because it ruined the track records of queens like Alexis.
as5 would've been great if they didn't have the lip sync assassins, it flattened the season and we barely were exposed to the mid-level girls who did well but didn't lipsync.
For me the "design a hotel" really put a damper on the season and the TMZ challenge didn't pick things up either. The comedy challenge was also a bust. Yvie was the only assassin that really lived up to her title. I mean when Alyssa Edwards does just OK in a LSFYL you know somethings wrong.
I think the lip sync assassin format was good I think they picked some of the worst songs to do. I think that was just the main problem with with that.
My only issue about AS3 will forever be that Shangela was robbed. Don't get me wrong, I live for Trixie but the growth of Shangela from seasons 2 & 3 to AS3 was amazing and she absolutely slayed the whole season.
@@scottsummers4234 No, that is actually shitty, most of them voted Trixie because Trixie was a flatline during the season and never won a single challenge, so she never send anyone home, the did not voted Shangie literally for being a good contestant and for have to send some people home
@@tyagohiee many of them said they didnt vote for Shangela because she was "over-produced". Like the "diva attitude" she had in the divas live and the forced note fight. I think trixie (and Kennedy too probably) got the votes because the queens didnt want to vote for the other two, not because trixie didnt send anyone home
AS5 is worse than AS3 just for the fact that AS5 was sooo boring , eventhough as3 had a lot of unfair twists , but at least it was entertaining. But the rest I agree 100%
@Todor Boychev I would say as1,as5,as3,as4,as2 4 was way more entertaining then 3 and 5 with every decision and the winners to me Monet was the deserving winner and Manila was rightfully sent home that were 3 other people with better chances at winner then her
This is my ranking from best to worst! 1. *AS2* - I mean, obviously 2. *AS4* - The best runways of any season ever, but the season had awful timing. 3. *AS3* - Iconic moments but one of the weirdest casts with the weirdest chemistry, and THAT jury shenanigan. 4. *AS5* - Some iconic queens, the vibe felt more chill but again awful timing sandwiched between S12 and CDR. 5. *AS1* - The best cast behind AS2, but completely shat on and under-utilised
@Todor Boychev Yep I'd agree! In terms of actual cast it would probably be AS1, AS4, AS2 for me! But yeh in terms of each cast's use, rudemption and iconicness post-All Stars, AS2 still wins
AS2 AS4 AS3 AS5 but seems like AS winners were never based on the track record but favouritism of production since AS2, i knew it might sound bitter but im still going to say it, Shangela should've won AS3, Monique should've be one of the double winners on AS4, Ms Cracker had the best track record on AS5, lets be honest, Shea was just okay
@@onekissallittakes8536 how come that was fair to set her in the bottom two every single time not based on the performance she gave? like the girl group “u were stuck in the jacket so we gonna put u in the btm two", i mean seriously?
For me it’s clearly 1 < 5 < 3 < 4 < 2 I might even have 4 above 2. I just think as4 had such a good cast, the challenges were amazing and it wasn’t predictable at all. We got amazing redemption stories for Monique and Monet and the runways were incredible
Its funny how you feel about AS4 and i feel completely different. I loved the snatch game and think it was a really good one. Of course the judging was a little off but i loove love love the cast of it. It wouldve been my 2nd place with as2 being 1st ofc. The promo, the girl group challenge, the jersey justice challenge, the club challenge, snatch game, the lalaparuza and the talent show were all so amazing and i just loved it.
2 All Stars - 1 Classic season Also - 3 seasons aren’t “a moment”. If you wanna say something interesting - it helps to have a vocabulary #MakeItMakeSense
@@carmineggrrr she had MANY MomentS -- I listed those MomentS above. Also the word He could have used would be: Momentous “Jujubee being in 3 seasons was Momentous!”
Love the repeat of the JuJu homage Mera looks great with that young Bonnie Raitt hair. S1 was totally harsh but yeah RuJubee was the best part of it aside the Untucked pile on Mimi Imfurst. Two was great for Katya and Rolaskatox, I got bored halfway through 3 and stopped watching. The roughness of 4 for me was minimal because I’m a huge Monet fan so...it worked out to me. Five was great to but 2 was seriously the best to me.
Mera and Scarlet every week I see your numbers jumping up and it is so well-deserved. I love your videos and ye vibe so well off each other. Wishing ye every success and thanks for posting 🙏
5. All Stars 1: Crazy 4. All Stars 5: Kinda boring 3. All Stars 3: Great but sometimes confusing 2. All Stars 2: Legendary but the judging was frustrating 1. All Stars 4: Perfect cast and all had their moments to shine.
AS2: best season of drag race ever. Though Alaska got favouritism and coco should have been allowed to do Janet for the talent show.truly the best queens from seasons 2-7 outside of the AS1 cast. AS4: best runways, surprisingly great dynamic between the cast, the highs were worth the lows, judging was weird, double crown was meh. Most unpredictable season of AS. Naomi will forever be iconic for truly playing the all stars game. Great lipsyncs. AS3: terrible dynamic between the cast. No one wants to see one queen win 6 challenges. Trixie didn’t come to play. Aja slayed but was mistreated by judges. Bebe ruined the season because they had to force a winner to finale. There were some “some stars in there” lipsyncs were trash. Robbed of Kennedy vs Chi Chi. AS5: any season of any tv show were there is absolutely nothing at stake is bad tv. Where are the stakes? It was Shea coulee’s drag race, even though she didn’t have the best stats (love her tho). The lipsyncs were meh because half the assassins didn’t care. The cast and the top all star always picked the same queen? Boring. To be honest, apart from the great premiere, I probably preferred AS 1 AS1: the cast was stellar. The challenges were awful mostly. The format was bad. First time we seen upgraded queens! Their level of drag was so much higher it was so fun to see!
AS2: Best season, great challenges and iconic chast (it did missuse Coco and Ginger). The returning episode was super fun (though a bit over edited on Alyssa's jokes). Incredible scenes and so much. AS4: good season (except is you love Manila), outside of it feeling over produced mid season and the tie, it was great. AS3: was good until the returning girls episode, which it did go bad. The squirrel friend acting challenge was terrible and the jury was a huge mistake and the snatch game was meh. But kitty girl was incredible. AS5: it was bad, the season was fully carried by the Queens mainly Jujubee, Alexis and Mariah (but Mariah didn't make it that far sadly). It felt predictable, even more than when Alaska won cause atleast we got the episode where she lost and they joked about letting her go. If it wasn't for those three the season would have been plain boring as almost no one enjoyed most of the challenges (except for the performances of Jujubee). And twist of either being on top or bottom was bad. AS1: great cast, great first episode for untucked. Bad format, challenges and why did Channel not win the crown too. Why have raven be the runner up when her and jujubee were basically the roxxxy Andrew's from AS before Roxxxy had even returned, they where in the bottom half the season.
I'd love to hear your thoughts on ranking the depth of casting for each season. Certain seasons have a fully iconic cast, while others have stars, but some that have not left as big of an impact on the franchise.
the sad part about AS3 is that trixie can't even celebrate because she feels like it was just handed to her. should've been her and shangela in the top 2. even trixie believes it. and i say this as a huge kennedy, trixie, and shangela fan
AS5 would have been EPIC with the lipsync for you Legacy format. The top Queens of each challenge were really close and the top 2 lip syncing would have been a lovely deciding factor.
Loving your videos! Subscribed! Here’s my requests for Drag Race topics: 1 - History of Untucked! Seasons 1-5 reflecting Drag Race seasons 2-6. I MISS the silver lounge and gold bar, pink box and peak-a-Ru. Drag Race season 7 sucked even harder because Untucked! read as budget cuts and camera time for the crew. WTF... 2 - Remember how Drag Race season 4 intro prize listing had each eliminated queen holding giant $100,000 check and wearing Sharron’s crown?!?! Only Lashauwn Beyond didn’t participate in the shameful holding of checking and wearing of crown on S4E3. 3 - Shift from Drag Race seasons 1-8 of Ru crowning next drag superstar versus Drag Race seasons 9 - 12 of the BS wheel of fortune. I guess the history of reunion/reunited finale episodes. 4 - History of main judges from Merle/Santino, reason for Merle departing, Michelle/Santino/Billy B, reason for Santino departing, Michelle/Carson/Ross/Todrick 5 - Unique episodes per Drag Race seasons such as S3E1 casting extravaganza. Hope these topics bring inspiration 😘
I literally woke up this morning and thought, I hope Mera does a video ranking All Stars seasons after that video the other day ranking main seasons. Call me Cleo.
I would say I agree with most of this list, but I would switch 4 and 5. I will say that I like 4 a little bit better because it has the one winner that I would say the show actually got somewhat right(yes I don’t think Shea or Alaska should’ve won) I think when we look at final performance in the last episode and through out the season, Monet does win.
Exactly Monet beat Trinity in that last lip sync it was a double win becaudlse trinity had more wins snd they knew the white stans would attack monet if trinity didn't win
You need to do the updated version of this video. It would be interesting to see how things have changes after AS6, AS7 All Winner, UK Vs the World and Canada VS the World
All Stars 6 cast is amazing. I have really High expectations. Look at this 4 Big Girls: Jiggly, Silky, Eureka and Ginger 4 Black Queens (Btw These are sheer excellence): TKB, Silky, Ra’Jah and A’keria 2 Trans Qweens: Jiggly and Sonique Fan faves: Jan and Scarlet Early outs: Jiggly and Serena There are queens from literally almost EVERY SEASON S2: Sonique and Pandora S3: Yara Sofia S4: Jiggly Caliente S5: Serena ChaCha S6: TKB S7: Ginger Minj S9: Eureka S10: Eureka S11: Silky, Ra’Jah, Scarlet and A’keria S12: Jan
AS4 should have been top 2 just for the runway looks alone !! None of the queens really were "fashion" queens in the sense of raja, aquaria and violet (except maybe naomi) but some of the girls (those being Manila, Trinity and Naomi) never having a bad runway with some other girls (Latrice, Monet, Monique and Valentina) always having above average runways with some stellar ones sneaking in on some runways. AS4 is the second best all stars season for me right after all stars 2
the sound mixing on Clap Back was definitely why the song was so bad, you couldn't tell what they were saying, and on top of that Rupaul's lyrics were bleh to begin with. Thank god they slayed the lip sync for the crown later in the episode tho
Agree that AS3 is the 2nd best. That season was great except for the finale twist. The challenges were great that season (Divas Live, Girl Group, Bitchelor), wonderful runways and the finale song Kitty Girl was outstanding. And I dont know if they can ever top AS2. That was perfection.
Aww Mera I was right there with you until you started on with the Trixie/Shangela conspiracy stuff. Can’t we support a person that didn’t win and who was equally deserving by not tearing down the person who did win? You’re better than that.
Completely agree with All Stars 4! Such questionable choices!! Like How on earth did Monet win the makeover challenge ?! It almost feels like they had every challenge winner picked out and just forced it to ‘make sense’
OF COURSE ALL STARS 2, I wouldn't mind if they have 14 or 13 queens that season. Add Shangela, Jessica and Any season 6 queen, this would be even more Perfect.
i loved the super queen song. i play that song like every day. BUT my coworker and i both agreed that there shouldn’t have been a double win. it was just time that a queen of color win all stars.
The Jury Twist at the end of AS3 is so confusing. Its similar to the queens-eliminating-queens twist in AS2. It makes sense if you introduce it in the beginning because it gives queens an expectation for the rest of the season, it puts them in that mindset and stirs up drama. But the jury twist in AS3 in theory could've been great if it was set from the beginning with the queens knowing about it, having to play nice with other queens just in case, creating drama with alliances and such. But they didn't do that and it totally screwed up the finale. The jury twist is unlike the queen-wheel finale thing in the main seasons because its not that important, mama its a goddamn wheel
this is the most acccurate ranking ever! I would rank them the exact same and I totally agree with everything you said about AS2. It is just ICONIC and the best season of all time
All Stars 2 had at least one iconic moment per episode that we still reference today. 1: The Same Parts 2: The entire Snatch Game 3: Alyssa's Annie Oakley 4: Alaska as Bette Davis 5: The lip sync!!! 6: Katya's commercial 7: Alaska's meltdown 8: I'm Roxxxy Andrews and I'm here to make it clear! I know you love me baby, that's why you brought me here!
i felt like trixie being in the bottom for kitty girls didn't make a whole lot of sense. if she wasn't she'd have had one of the best track records of all time! so i don't mind her win too much. shangela not being top2 was a big let down though.
Mera, Subscribed after watching my second video... that was about two months ago. Haven’t missed one since. I think you and Scarlett are the best! Your content is great and very well produced. Very professional. Keep up the good work. Yours sincerely, Tara Newhole
1. All Stars 2 Loved Alaska and Katya 2. All Stars 5. The season where the double crowning between Shae and Jujubee should have been. 3. All Stars 3...until Dela left 4. All Stars 4. The double crowning shouldnt have happen. 5. All Stars 5. Meh
1. AS2 2. AS4 3. AS3 4. AS1 5. AS5 AS2 is undoubtly the best season in the entire franchise, everything was right, the girls, the challenges, the runways, the format, flawless. AS4 and AS3 kinda tie for me, I'm a huge fan of Monet and Monique and loved getting a whole season with both of the girls, the drama was there, and it was a well rounded cast. AS3 is interesting, I love a lot of those girls too, and I'm a huge Trixie fan but there's no way she could've won without the jury. There were so many gags that season. AS1 is in fourth solely bc of RuJubee. AS5, oof we knew who was gonna win before the cast was announced, the LSA twist killed the show for me, AS2 was also fairly predictable, but by week 2 in AS5, the front runners were VERY obvious, and it didn't make it as enjoyable to watch, and there truly were so many girls that deserved to be in that cast over some that got casted.
5. AS1 - very unfair and the challenges were..... something. 4. AS5 - as you guys said it was predictable and we all knew shea was winning before the cast was announced. The LSA twist was dumb and started off great and then slowly deteriorated. 3. AS4 - i really like this season and the cast, its just that the judging was garbage. Trinity winning the talent show, Manila winning snatch game, it was just not cute. 2. AS3 - shangela's lipstick speech. thats it. 1. AS2 - i dont think i need to explain either.
My problem with As5 was the fact that Miz Cracker was blatantly favored. It should’ve been: Ep1) India Farrah Ep2) Shea Ep3) Juju Ep4) Shea and Alexis, if only one; Shea Ep5) Shea Ep6) Juju Ep7) Shea
My ranking was this: AS2 A25 AS3 AS4 AS1 Only reason 5 is above two is because it was the only season besides two that I was desperate to watch each week
AS1 was in the words of Latrice “a shoddy situation” AS2 had some bullshit but was very entertaining and amazing AS3 was amazing until Ben quit AS4 was good until Manila left AS5 had a slow start but no bullshit and Shea won I like All Stars but not as much as the regular seasons, my ranking is: 1) AS2 2) AS5 (Jujubee made it) 3) AS3 4) AS4 5) AS1
My ranking would be: 1. AS2. This season is as close to a perfect season there’s ever been. It really was ALL stars and not SOME stars. There were some frustrating moments when Rolaskatox came into play but it did add to the drama. Overall, I agree that it’s the best season of any drag race season. 2. AS4. I loved this season. Great cast. The double-crowning was a bit anticlimactic but I’m glad that Trinity finally got a crown considering season 9 was basically her and Shea in the lead throughout until the finale lip-sync twist. 3. AS5. Another great cast and a really solid season. Unpopular opinion, but I actually love the lip-sync assassin format. It feels like what “all stars” is all about. Like I said previously regarding Trinity, I’m glad Shea finally got a crown. It was also a treat seeing how elevated Jujubee is now. There was also a lot of entertaining drama! 4. AS3. It’s a shame because there’s so many great moments from this season and it did have an amazing cast but it was unfortunately spoiled by plot twists. I believe this was an attempt by the producers to one-up AS2 but they ultimately failed in doing so. We had puzzling decisions by the judges (why was Milk not in the bottom for the divas challenge?!), we had BenDelaCreme eliminate herself and then the nail in the coffin was, of course, Shangela not winning because of an ill-advised plot twist at last minute. The whole thing just feels unsatisfactory. Finally, I can’t actually comment on AS1 because it’s not on Netflix anymore. 🙃
I really was not feeling at least half of the episodes of AS5. Two girls ended up giving up, too many poorly executed improv/acting challenges, the “drama” was so petty and boring, and I had a general feeling that the girls just weren’t really connecting to each other and we didn’t get a lot of meme-worthy moments.
The AS5 lip sync assassin twist had promise, but crashed and burned after episode one. It was a great way to introduce the season's lip sync format, but the concept went downhill fast as the bar was set so high with India and Yvie slaying Livin' La Vida Loca.
IMO 4, All Stars 1 (No. Everything is No. Except that one untucked😂) 3. All Stars 4 (Boring) 2. All Stars 3/5 (AS3: Ok Cast Ok Season overall. AS5 IMPECCABLE CAST Wonderful 1st episode) 1. All Stars 2 (Best Season of Drag Race)
I really dislike All Stars season bc every season always has a big flaw: As1: Teams, obviously As2: favouring of rolaskatox As3: the Jury twist (even though i'm happy that trixie won) As4: Queens just doing shitty in all the challenges As5: SO much forced drama that I didn't even understand anything bc there were 15 diffrent dramas per ep.
I was thinking in All Stars 5 th winner must put the bottom queens to lipsyncs the lip sync assassins, it was the opposite, bc I was hopping that rule should change bc alot the queens have something to show
100% agree s2 best season of any drag Race! But my fave season is s5 so all my faves got to come back and slay! I only wonder how diff it would been if adore ddnt quit. Love her too!
So, in a nutshell: AS2: best cast, best challenges, best final act. AS3: good challenges, good lipsyncs, the greatest gag (Bendela leaving), but the worst twist (that jury). AS5: predictable outcome, although some good challenges. AS4: overly produced. AS1: bad format.
I placed AS5 on my 4th spot cause I find it kinda bland cause of the show’s turns were yea, too obvious with the frontrunners and all and with the show obviously leading to Shea. Lip Sync Assassin twist could have been a bigger gag but it seemed manipulated by production and ended up being underwhelming.
two things are clear:
1. as2 is best
2. as1 is worst (but they rlly wasted a bunch of those girls’ potential :((
💯
I would even argue AS1 had the strongest cast to date! LEGENDS!
what you said on your number 2 is exactly the answer for all of those who can't understand why drag race are bringing allstars 1 girls for their 3d shot
@@scrubscrubscrubs This is not even argueable, this is a FACT
Tyago right?! Literally only tops 3s/4s or miss congenialities! I remember even being slight disappointed with AS2’s cast at the time in comparison
My only issue with AS2 was that it felt like they sometimes really favored Alaska.
AS5 was a great cast with a shitty format. I hated the lipsync assassin and the "everyone who's not in the top is in the bottom" twists because it ruined the track records of queens like Alexis.
So the moment I saw the tittle I knew who was at the top. How will any season beat all stars 2.
maybe an all winners season?
@@johnsjogerstenturner9204 It ain't happening
@@benjamintic3653 i know lol but that's the only way i can ever see as2 get topped
all stars was the best only because of the season 4 girls. season 5 is the ultimate in drag race herstory.
@@benjamintic3653 maybe it will
as5 would've been great if they didn't have the lip sync assassins, it flattened the season and we barely were exposed to the mid-level girls who did well but didn't lipsync.
exactly, the lip sync assasin twist had so much producer input
Yeah, the lip sync assassin thing plust the "everyone who's not in the top is in the bottom" close to the end honestly ruined it for me.
For me the "design a hotel" really put a damper on the season and the TMZ challenge didn't pick things up either. The comedy challenge was also a bust. Yvie was the only assassin that really lived up to her title. I mean when Alyssa Edwards does just OK in a LSFYL you know somethings wrong.
no the all stars 5 cast is realy bad, the only queens that I think deserved to be there were the top 3 and Alexis.
I think the lip sync assassin format was good I think they picked some of the worst songs to do. I think that was just the main problem with with that.
so what im getting is we just need jujubee in every season
YES! YES! YES!
like how they kept bring stacy lane matthews back in as4 for challenges they should bring jujubee back in as6 for challenges
This aged well
My only issue about AS3 will forever be that Shangela was robbed. Don't get me wrong, I live for Trixie but the growth of Shangela from seasons 2 & 3 to AS3 was amazing and she absolutely slayed the whole season.
💯💯💯
@Todor Boychev ikr? It wasn't Trixie's fault that the eliminated queens voted her. I like Shangela but she should have been nicer to them. 😂
@@scottsummers4234 Exactly we don't know what happend behind the scenes 🤷🏾♂️ maybe Shangela was a bitch bts
@@scottsummers4234 No, that is actually shitty, most of them voted Trixie because Trixie was a flatline during the season and never won a single challenge, so she never send anyone home, the did not voted Shangie literally for being a good contestant and for have to send some people home
@@tyagohiee many of them said they didnt vote for Shangela because she was "over-produced". Like the "diva attitude" she had in the divas live and the forced note fight. I think trixie (and Kennedy too probably) got the votes because the queens didnt want to vote for the other two, not because trixie didnt send anyone home
I don’t think many people deviate from this ranking
1: AS2
2:AS4
3/4:AS5
3/4:AS3
5:AS1
AS5 is worse than AS3 just for the fact that AS5 was sooo boring , eventhough as3 had a lot of unfair twists , but at least it was entertaining. But the rest I agree 100%
truuuuuuuu
Switch as3 and as5 and it’s exactly my ranking
i agree but as3 is better as5 for me
@Todor Boychev I would say as1,as5,as3,as4,as2 4 was way more entertaining then 3 and 5 with every decision and the winners to me Monet was the deserving winner and Manila was rightfully sent home that were 3 other people with better chances at winner then her
This is my ranking from best to worst!
1. *AS2* - I mean, obviously
2. *AS4* - The best runways of any season ever, but the season had awful timing.
3. *AS3* - Iconic moments but one of the weirdest casts with the weirdest chemistry, and THAT jury shenanigan.
4. *AS5* - Some iconic queens, the vibe felt more chill but again awful timing sandwiched between S12 and CDR.
5. *AS1* - The best cast behind AS2, but completely shat on and under-utilised
Exactly!!
I agree fully
On point
@Todor Boychev Yep I'd agree! In terms of actual cast it would probably be AS1, AS4, AS2 for me! But yeh in terms of each cast's use, rudemption and iconicness post-All Stars, AS2 still wins
agreed completely
AS2
AS4
AS3
AS5
but seems like AS winners were never based on the track record but favouritism of production since AS2, i knew it might sound bitter but im still going to say it, Shangela should've won AS3, Monique should've be one of the double winners on AS4, Ms Cracker had the best track record on AS5, lets be honest, Shea was just okay
monique ? choices
ranvit bahirwani she literally never had a bad week
@@ranvit1305 monet? was a choice
@@onekissallittakes8536 how come that was fair to set her in the bottom two every single time not based on the performance she gave? like the girl group “u were stuck in the jacket so we gonna put u in the btm two", i mean seriously?
Hsu Will RIGHT, even had one of the best singing voices
For me it’s clearly 1 < 5 < 3 < 4 < 2
I might even have 4 above 2. I just think as4 had such a good cast, the challenges were amazing and it wasn’t predictable at all. We got amazing redemption stories for Monique and Monet and the runways were incredible
Alyssa, Katya, and Alaska give me life in all of their seasons. The acting challenge was iconic
Its funny how you feel about AS4 and i feel completely different. I loved the snatch game and think it was a really good one. Of course the judging was a little off but i loove love love the cast of it. It wouldve been my 2nd place with as2 being 1st ofc. The promo, the girl group challenge, the jersey justice challenge, the club challenge, snatch game, the lalaparuza and the talent show were all so amazing and i just loved it.
"nothing can make this season better"... "my name is roxxy andrews and i'm here to make it clear!"
jujubee being in 3 seasons of all stars..... what a moment
2 All Stars -
1 Classic season
Also - 3 seasons aren’t
“a moment”.
If you wanna say something interesting - it helps to have a vocabulary
#MakeItMakeSense
@@nextleveljourney6612 someone’s angry
@@carmineggrrr the word you’re Looking for,
Kimorah Blaq,
is
Disappointed.
@@carmineggrrr she had MANY MomentS -- I listed those
MomentS above.
Also the word He could have used would be:
Momentous
“Jujubee being in 3 seasons was Momentous!”
We need an all stars season with just season 6, 9, and 12 girls lol so much talent
Love the repeat of the JuJu homage Mera looks great with that young Bonnie Raitt hair. S1 was totally harsh but yeah RuJubee was the best part of it aside the Untucked pile on Mimi Imfurst. Two was great for Katya and Rolaskatox, I got bored halfway through 3 and stopped watching. The roughness of 4 for me was minimal because I’m a huge Monet fan so...it worked out to me. Five was great to but 2 was seriously the best to me.
you look soooo good in that outfit! 🍓
Thank you! ❤️
Mera and Scarlet every week I see your numbers jumping up and it is so well-deserved. I love your videos and ye vibe so well off each other. Wishing ye every success and thanks for posting 🙏
Phi Phi in show squirrels saying “hOw dAre yOu!” Is something that I will never forget 😂
5. All Stars 1: Crazy
4. All Stars 5: Kinda boring
3. All Stars 3: Great but sometimes confusing
2. All Stars 2: Legendary but the judging was frustrating
1. All Stars 4: Perfect cast and all had their moments to shine.
AS2: best season of drag race ever. Though Alaska got favouritism and coco should have been allowed to do Janet for the talent show.truly the best queens from seasons 2-7 outside of the AS1 cast.
AS4: best runways, surprisingly great dynamic between the cast, the highs were worth the lows, judging was weird, double crown was meh. Most unpredictable season of AS. Naomi will forever be iconic for truly playing the all stars game. Great lipsyncs.
AS3: terrible dynamic between the cast. No one wants to see one queen win 6 challenges. Trixie didn’t come to play. Aja slayed but was mistreated by judges. Bebe ruined the season because they had to force a winner to finale. There were some “some stars in there” lipsyncs were trash. Robbed of Kennedy vs Chi Chi.
AS5: any season of any tv show were there is absolutely nothing at stake is bad tv. Where are the stakes? It was Shea coulee’s drag race, even though she didn’t have the best stats (love her tho). The lipsyncs were meh because half the assassins didn’t care. The cast and the top all star always picked the same queen? Boring. To be honest, apart from the great premiere, I probably preferred AS 1
AS1: the cast was stellar. The challenges were awful mostly. The format was bad. First time we seen upgraded queens! Their level of drag was so much higher it was so fun to see!
AS2: Best season, great challenges and iconic chast (it did missuse Coco and Ginger). The returning episode was super fun (though a bit over edited on Alyssa's jokes). Incredible scenes and so much.
AS4: good season (except is you love Manila), outside of it feeling over produced mid season and the tie, it was great.
AS3: was good until the returning girls episode, which it did go bad. The squirrel friend acting challenge was terrible and the jury was a huge mistake and the snatch game was meh. But kitty girl was incredible.
AS5: it was bad, the season was fully carried by the Queens mainly Jujubee, Alexis and Mariah (but Mariah didn't make it that far sadly). It felt predictable, even more than when Alaska won cause atleast we got the episode where she lost and they joked about letting her go. If it wasn't for those three the season would have been plain boring as almost no one enjoyed most of the challenges (except for the performances of Jujubee). And twist of either being on top or bottom was bad.
AS1: great cast, great first episode for untucked. Bad format, challenges and why did Channel not win the crown too. Why have raven be the runner up when her and jujubee were basically the roxxxy Andrew's from AS before Roxxxy had even returned, they where in the bottom half the season.
All stars 4 below All stars 3 and 5 was a CHOICE
A CHOICE
AS3 was very entertaining. AS4 was a mess.
Scott Summers your kidding ? As3 was A MESS
as4 went downhill as soon as valentina was eliminated
Strxberry Jxm ok your just as delusional as she is 😂😂
I'd love to hear your thoughts on ranking the depth of casting for each season. Certain seasons have a fully iconic cast, while others have stars, but some that have not left as big of an impact on the franchise.
the sad part about AS3 is that trixie can't even celebrate because she feels like it was just handed to her. should've been her and shangela in the top 2. even trixie believes it. and i say this as a huge kennedy, trixie, and shangela fan
Omggg you should do a list of the best drag race Duos: Rujubee, bob and Monet, trixie and Katy’s etc....
AS5 would have been EPIC with the lipsync for you Legacy format. The top Queens of each challenge were really close and the top 2 lip syncing would have been a lovely deciding factor.
Loving your videos! Subscribed!
Here’s my requests for Drag Race topics:
1 - History of Untucked! Seasons 1-5 reflecting Drag Race seasons 2-6. I MISS the silver lounge and gold bar, pink box and peak-a-Ru. Drag Race season 7 sucked even harder because Untucked! read as budget cuts and camera time for the crew. WTF...
2 - Remember how Drag Race season 4 intro prize listing had each eliminated queen holding giant $100,000 check and wearing Sharron’s crown?!?! Only Lashauwn Beyond didn’t participate in the shameful holding of checking and wearing of crown on S4E3.
3 - Shift from Drag Race seasons 1-8 of Ru crowning next drag superstar versus Drag Race seasons 9 - 12 of the BS wheel of fortune. I guess the history of reunion/reunited finale episodes.
4 - History of main judges from Merle/Santino, reason for Merle departing, Michelle/Santino/Billy B, reason for Santino departing, Michelle/Carson/Ross/Todrick
5 - Unique episodes per Drag Race seasons such as S3E1 casting extravaganza.
Hope these topics bring inspiration 😘
I literally woke up this morning and thought, I hope Mera does a video ranking All Stars seasons after that video the other day ranking main seasons. Call me Cleo.
I would say I agree with most of this list, but I would switch 4 and 5. I will say that I like 4 a little bit better because it has the one winner that I would say the show actually got somewhat right(yes I don’t think Shea or Alaska should’ve won) I think when we look at final performance in the last episode and through out the season, Monet does win.
Exactly Monet beat Trinity in that last lip sync it was a double win becaudlse trinity had more wins snd they knew the white stans would attack monet if trinity didn't win
You need to do the updated version of this video. It would be interesting to see how things have changes after AS6, AS7 All Winner, UK Vs the World and Canada VS the World
Omgggg I looooove Mera's outfit
9th..! Hey Mera and Scarlet! Im addicted to your RANKINGS ! MWAaa....xo
Thank you rextrek!!! You been there since the beginning!!!❤️❤️❤️
Love your LEWK Mera...reminds me of a 1950's-60's Movie star / in a movie about a Top Act Entertainer
I'm so glad I got to see you guys as well 🙂
Definitely!!! All Stars 2 was my first introduction to the show. Flash forward four years and I have binge watched every season multiple times. LOL
Love this episode! But no mention of Tatianna’s best talent show of all time? 😔
Yes All Stars 2 was SO good. All those girls were SO TALENTED.
All Stars 6 cast is amazing. I have really High expectations. Look at this
4 Big Girls: Jiggly, Silky, Eureka and Ginger
4 Black Queens (Btw These are sheer excellence): TKB, Silky, Ra’Jah and A’keria
2 Trans Qweens: Jiggly and Sonique
Fan faves: Jan and Scarlet
Early outs: Jiggly and Serena
There are queens from literally almost EVERY SEASON
S2: Sonique and Pandora
S3: Yara Sofia
S4: Jiggly Caliente
S5: Serena ChaCha
S6: TKB
S7: Ginger Minj
S9: Eureka
S10: Eureka
S11: Silky, Ra’Jah, Scarlet and A’keria
S12: Jan
I wished there wasnt too much S11 queens. 4 is a lot.
But it’s the first time that S11 onward girls can be on all stars.
Plus there’s nobody really left from 5 so that frees up a lot of spots.
thatonewelshgamer s11 could have been on AS5 but they all declined lol
You nailed the order for both this and the video for the regular seasons.
My list would have been:
1. AllStars 2
2. AllStars 4
3. AllStars 5
4. AllStars 1
5. AllStars 3
AS4 should have been top 2 just for the runway looks alone !! None of the queens really were "fashion" queens in the sense of raja, aquaria and violet (except maybe naomi) but some of the girls (those being Manila, Trinity and Naomi) never having a bad runway with some other girls (Latrice, Monet, Monique and Valentina) always having above average runways with some stellar ones sneaking in on some runways. AS4 is the second best all stars season for me right after all stars 2
the sound mixing on Clap Back was definitely why the song was so bad, you couldn't tell what they were saying, and on top of that Rupaul's lyrics were bleh to begin with. Thank god they slayed the lip sync for the crown later in the episode tho
Agreed!!!
Living for your opinion about Trinity's in the final of AS4 🔥
Mera and Scarlet are so adorable together!
Literally my exact same order! I've thought about this before LOL!
You two are adorable as always ❤️
I love how they only have 5 seasons to rank, but this is quite a longer video than we’re used to
All stars 2 and 3 are my faves except the jury vote's twist on AS 3
@MeraMangle love how your channelling juju top 3 Allstars 5 finale
As4 below as5 :0. Gurlllll
Agree that AS3 is the 2nd best. That season was great except for the finale twist. The challenges were great that season (Divas Live, Girl Group, Bitchelor), wonderful runways and the finale song Kitty Girl was outstanding.
And I dont know if they can ever top AS2. That was perfection.
Really was Amazing!!!!
@@MeraMangle and their gold promo is the best promo yet of any Drag Race season.
If all stars 1 had the same rules as the other seasons, it would’ve been great, plus we all love the earlier or older cast of the queens
I can't help but wonder how different, probably even more awesome, as2 would be if Adore was in it to win it.
My god Mera, you slayyyed that outfit. Great ranking :)
Aww Mera I was right there with you until you started on with the Trixie/Shangela conspiracy stuff. Can’t we support a person that didn’t win and who was equally deserving by not tearing down the person who did win? You’re better than that.
Completely agree with All Stars 4! Such questionable choices!! Like How on earth did Monet win the makeover challenge ?! It almost feels like they had every challenge winner picked out and just forced it to ‘make sense’
"An episode packed with lip-syncs is great!"
So great they did an entire season premiere on it and, well...
Completely against your views on the Trixie win. That twist did not happen to stop Shangela from winning or for Trixie to win.
I was just watching AS2 again and each episode is like a movie. I would pay $$$ to watch it on the big screen!
OF COURSE ALL STARS 2, I wouldn't mind if they have 14 or 13 queens that season. Add Shangela, Jessica and Any season 6 queen, this would be even more Perfect.
i loved the super queen song. i play that song like every day. BUT my coworker and i both agreed that there shouldn’t have been a double win. it was just time that a queen of color win all stars.
The Jury Twist at the end of AS3 is so confusing. Its similar to the queens-eliminating-queens twist in AS2. It makes sense if you introduce it in the beginning because it gives queens an expectation for the rest of the season, it puts them in that mindset and stirs up drama. But the jury twist in AS3 in theory could've been great if it was set from the beginning with the queens knowing about it, having to play nice with other queens just in case, creating drama with alliances and such. But they didn't do that and it totally screwed up the finale. The jury twist is unlike the queen-wheel finale thing in the main seasons because its not that important, mama its a goddamn wheel
I would live for an All-Stars season with crownless Winners like Bendela, Katya, Jujubee, Manila, Shangela, Detox, Tatianna, Alyssa, Alexis...
this is the most acccurate ranking ever! I would rank them the exact same and I totally agree with everything you said about AS2. It is just ICONIC and the best season of all time
❤️❤️❤️
All Stars 2 had at least one iconic moment per episode that we still reference today.
1: The Same Parts
2: The entire Snatch Game
3: Alyssa's Annie Oakley
4: Alaska as Bette Davis
5: The lip sync!!!
6: Katya's commercial
7: Alaska's meltdown
8: I'm Roxxxy Andrews and I'm here to make it clear! I know you love me baby, that's why you brought me here!
i felt like trixie being in the bottom for kitty girls didn't make a whole lot of sense. if she wasn't she'd have had one of the best track records of all time! so i don't mind her win too much. shangela not being top2 was a big let down though.
Oh, first ranking that I fully agree 100% and wouldn't change anything
Mera,
Subscribed after watching my second video... that was about two months ago. Haven’t missed one since. I think you and Scarlett are the best! Your content is great and very well produced. Very professional. Keep up the good work.
Yours sincerely,
Tara Newhole
❤️❤️❤️Thank you Tara!❤️❤️❤️
1. All Stars 2 Loved Alaska and Katya
2. All Stars 5. The season where the double crowning between Shae and Jujubee should have been.
3. All Stars 3...until Dela left
4. All Stars 4. The double crowning shouldnt have happen.
5. All Stars 5. Meh
Monique and Trinity shouldve been the top 2 of AS4 don’t even @ me.
1. AS2
2. AS4
3. AS3
4. AS1
5. AS5
AS2 is undoubtly the best season in the entire franchise, everything was right, the girls, the challenges, the runways, the format, flawless. AS4 and AS3 kinda tie for me, I'm a huge fan of Monet and Monique and loved getting a whole season with both of the girls, the drama was there, and it was a well rounded cast. AS3 is interesting, I love a lot of those girls too, and I'm a huge Trixie fan but there's no way she could've won without the jury. There were so many gags that season. AS1 is in fourth solely bc of RuJubee. AS5, oof we knew who was gonna win before the cast was announced, the LSA twist killed the show for me, AS2 was also fairly predictable, but by week 2 in AS5, the front runners were VERY obvious, and it didn't make it as enjoyable to watch, and there truly were so many girls that deserved to be in that cast over some that got casted.
Only complaint with AS2 is that Ginger was criminally underused. Hoping her AS6 run gives her the attention she deserves.
5. AS1 - very unfair and the challenges were..... something.
4. AS5 - as you guys said it was predictable and we all knew shea was winning before the cast was announced. The LSA twist was dumb and started off great and then slowly deteriorated.
3. AS4 - i really like this season and the cast, its just that the judging was garbage. Trinity winning the talent show, Manila winning snatch game, it was just not cute.
2. AS3 - shangela's lipstick speech. thats it.
1. AS2 - i dont think i need to explain either.
My problem with As5 was the fact that Miz Cracker was blatantly favored. It should’ve been:
Ep1) India Farrah
Ep2) Shea
Ep3) Juju
Ep4) Shea and Alexis, if only one; Shea
Ep5) Shea
Ep6) Juju
Ep7) Shea
Some of Miz Cracker's wins were questionable tbh.
#1: AS2
#2: AS4
#3: AS5
#4: AS3
#5: AS1
My ranking was this:
AS2
A25
AS3
AS4
AS1
Only reason 5 is above two is because it was the only season besides two that I was desperate to watch each week
AS1 was in the words of Latrice “a shoddy situation”
AS2 had some bullshit but was very entertaining and amazing
AS3 was amazing until Ben quit
AS4 was good until Manila left
AS5 had a slow start but no bullshit and Shea won
I like All Stars but not as much as the regular seasons, my ranking is:
1) AS2
2) AS5 (Jujubee made it)
3) AS3
4) AS4
5) AS1
Same! Juju made as5 so good.
As2 the best minus the riggary
As4 a very good cast and season
As3 a good season overall
As5 Terrible
As1 terrible but had a nice cast
My ranking would be:
1. AS2. This season is as close to a perfect season there’s ever been. It really was ALL stars and not SOME stars. There were some frustrating moments when Rolaskatox came into play but it did add to the drama. Overall, I agree that it’s the best season of any drag race season.
2. AS4. I loved this season. Great cast. The double-crowning was a bit anticlimactic but I’m glad that Trinity finally got a crown considering season 9 was basically her and Shea in the lead throughout until the finale lip-sync twist.
3. AS5. Another great cast and a really solid season. Unpopular opinion, but I actually love the lip-sync assassin format. It feels like what “all stars” is all about. Like I said previously regarding Trinity, I’m glad Shea finally got a crown. It was also a treat seeing how elevated Jujubee is now. There was also a lot of entertaining drama!
4. AS3. It’s a shame because there’s so many great moments from this season and it did have an amazing cast but it was unfortunately spoiled by plot twists. I believe this was an attempt by the producers to one-up AS2 but they ultimately failed in doing so. We had puzzling decisions by the judges (why was Milk not in the bottom for the divas challenge?!), we had BenDelaCreme eliminate herself and then the nail in the coffin was, of course, Shangela not winning because of an ill-advised plot twist at last minute. The whole thing just feels unsatisfactory.
Finally, I can’t actually comment on AS1 because it’s not on Netflix anymore. 🙃
It was generous of Rupaul to pick 2 winners in AS4 paying out double the money because she felt they both deserved it
I really was not feeling at least half of the episodes of AS5. Two girls ended up giving up, too many poorly executed improv/acting challenges, the “drama” was so petty and boring, and I had a general feeling that the girls just weren’t really connecting to each other and we didn’t get a lot of meme-worthy moments.
You always agree on EVERYTHING??? Lol!!
Great List and Mera looks STUNNING
The AS5 lip sync assassin twist had promise, but crashed and burned after episode one. It was a great way to introduce the season's lip sync format, but the concept went downhill fast as the bar was set so high with India and Yvie slaying Livin' La Vida Loca.
I love you all. Glad to see you are getting near 10000 hope that means you can get money out of UA-cam too!
AS3 is my personal fave but AS2 is the best. I love AS4... up till the club ep... then it kind of trails to the finish line
The issue with the AS4 finale was that they didn’t film a proper double crowning- like why not have it just in case?
Mera is wearing almost Jujubee's same lipsync for the crown costume
I would have switched 3 and 5 just because of that twist at the end at 3. but the rest I agree with. hope Allstars 6 is up there with 2 :)
IMO
4, All Stars 1 (No. Everything is No. Except that one untucked😂)
3. All Stars 4 (Boring)
2. All Stars 3/5 (AS3: Ok Cast Ok Season overall. AS5 IMPECCABLE CAST Wonderful 1st episode)
1. All Stars 2 (Best Season of Drag Race)
I really dislike All Stars season bc every season always has a big flaw:
As1: Teams, obviously
As2: favouring of rolaskatox
As3: the Jury twist (even though i'm happy that trixie won)
As4: Queens just doing shitty in all the challenges
As5: SO much forced drama that I didn't even understand anything bc there were 15 diffrent dramas per ep.
The jujubee outfit is back ❤️❤️
I was thinking in All Stars 5 th winner must put the bottom queens to lipsyncs the lip sync assassins, it was the opposite, bc I was hopping that rule should change bc alot the queens have something to show
im still sad for Adore not being able to finish the season
100% agree s2 best season of any drag Race! But my fave season is s5 so all my faves got to come back and slay! I only wonder how diff it would been if adore ddnt quit. Love her too!
wait u didn’t like the girl group challenge on as4?!
you both look Gorgeous
My Ranking worst to best
1
5
2
3
4 HANDS DOWN THE BEST SEASON
I’d say you nailed this
So, in a nutshell:
AS2: best cast, best challenges, best final act.
AS3: good challenges, good lipsyncs, the greatest gag (Bendela leaving), but the worst twist (that jury).
AS5: predictable outcome, although some good challenges.
AS4: overly produced.
AS1: bad format.
Roxxxy's verse in Read U Wrote U is iconic fo how horrible it is and I am here for it
I’m glad I’m not the only one who thinks AS3 is the second best. Loved Aja
Me too. It was a very entertaining season.
I placed AS5 on my 4th spot cause I find it kinda bland cause of the show’s turns were yea, too obvious with the frontrunners and all and with the show obviously leading to Shea.
Lip Sync Assassin twist could have been a bigger gag but it seemed manipulated by production and ended up being underwhelming.