Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
Doctor Who: 10 Worst Things The Eleventh Doctor Has Ever Done
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 сер 2024
- The Eleventh Doctor has certainly left his mark on Doctor Who history.
For more awesome content, check out: whatculture.co...
Follow us on Instagram: / whoculture
Catch us on Twitter: / whoculture
#DoctorWho #EleventhDoctor #MattSmith
Thanks for having me back ✨
Keep it up -- you're great!
Ozzy ozzy ozzy, oi oi oi!
Ayo crispy, so glad your doing more stuff. 🎉
Great work. Glad you back indeed. Did know you work for them before?
Yes now crispy are u a new host?
Matt Smith was brilliant at being young at heart and a extremely old soul at the same time. Saying that, he definitely did some things that made my jaw drop.
Agreed. That Colonel Runaway speech… chilling stuff.
If I ever grow up, I want to be just like the 11th Doctor.
Yeeep, Exactly, @Hardcore!
Aaaaand that's why Matt Smith is definitely my ONLY ONE DOCTOR!
♡♡♡♡♡
My 11th have seen things we wouldn't believe. 11th have lost things we will never understand.
Matt Smith definitely knows things. Secrets that must never be told.♡
His not even acting in those moments
ok, in all fairness, most of those things are NOT his fault, and come on, Solomon killed off all the Silurians by ejecting them into space.
Yes, it was heartbreaking to make Rory choose which Amy, but he was the one who had to spend the rest of his life with the Amy he chose--that was not the Doctor's choice to make
For a final defeat by the doctor, it wasn't bad. Just ask the Family of Blood.\
Yeah but the Doctor is always the forgiving one that doesn’t dispense with cool and harsh punishments and certainly not murder. I understand the Doctor has his dark moments and I do love them but I don’t like it when he straight up murders someone or tortures people like he did to the Family of Blood.
Although I love Dinosaurs On A Spaceship, feel like the ending subverting everything Doctor Who is about. The Doctor is always about outsmarting his enemies and never resorting to the violence that would be such an easy solution and the solution in all action films. The ending felt like a classic conundrum: captured companion, missiles are locked on, and the villain is escaping. This is usually the point where The Doctor comes up with a really good plan that solves all of those problems with no bloodshed, but instead he does solve all the problems but results to murder to do them.
They're running out of content a little bit lmao
I don't think any of these are really as bad as they're portrayed in the video as being. I was going to say that maybe I can agree with "The Girl Who Waited," but then I remembered Rory didn't tell Amy which button to press and Amy didn't ask which one she should press and walked into a very clearly empty room after pressing the wrong one. Sure, that doesn't completely excuse the Doctor for lying about him being able to save both Amys but I'm not going to blame him for being put in a situation that could have been easily avoided in the first place.
To their defense, Amy and Rory couldn't have known what the consequences would be if they stepped into the wrong room.
And better for Rory to make the choice than the Doctor. Whoever the Doctor saved Rory would have resented him for not saving the other one or both of them. Rory had to be the one to make the choice as he was the one who would have to live with the consequences.
@@adelucas4824 And I've also been thinking what would have happened if the Doctor hadn't lied in the moment about being able to take both Amys?
If he had told the truth about that not being possible, then nothing good would have come of that. Both Amys needed to be cooperating with each other at the time so they could make it back to the TARDIS.
Still a questionable thing the Doctor did? People can call it that if they want to. But, if he hadn't, then neither Amy was likely making it out of there. And, as you said, better for Rory to make that choice. Maybe this would actually be a "worst thing Eleven has done" if Eleven had decided to make the choice for Rory instead.
I always thought the same thing. Ya have eyes! Rorys clearly not in that room
Technically Ami and Rory was still safe. Just in the past. They lived a long life with each other. That must have been somewhat free and happy as Ami did write the book. And the Doctor couldn't visit with the Tardis. But River still could with the armband. So they did at least get to see someone they loved from this time period.
*Amy
Some people theorise that the epilogue was all a lie.
Remember, River stated earlier on in the episode, “Never let The Doctor see the damage, and never ever let him see you age”, so some people think that they never got to live a happy life, but followed Rule #1, and told a lie, as The Doctor does.
As my favorite Doctor, as River would say: MY DOCTOR, I will NOT be accepting any 11 Slander on this beautiful Sunday thank you✌🏽
I've always said Davros had a point in The Stolen Earth when he showed The Doctor himself and makes weapons out of his companions and asked how many died in his name.
Not to that school nurse in The Family of Blood who asked if all those people would have died of he hadn't chosen to hide on Earth.
The Doctor has a lot blood on his hands
He knows. In the episode where Missy is to be executed, Twelve has the executioner look up 'cause of death = The Doctor'
although I love The Family of Blood, the Doctor caused all of the events there. He coudl've just dealt with them and not hid. Even if he did need to hide, he could've gone anywhere in time and space and he chooses a school in a racist time period and leaves his black companion to fend for herself.
*chosen to hide on Earth.
@@mousermind 👍🏾 Cheers for the correction.
theres a deleted scene from the end of the Angels take Manhattan thats been animated where its Brian meeting his grandson, who is actually older than he is and its just heartbreaking
The Doctor is neither good or bad. They are not simple like that. They are neither. A neutral party. They do bad and good things. They are complex. They are the Doctor
There is also the balance of Justice and Mercy which the Doctor must keep. Basically, he is a de facto godling in this Universe. (Which I think is a mistake, btw. The Doctor should be fallible, should make mistakes and pay for them himself.)
Since the Time Lord Victorious, (which I think is the Doctor's lowest and darkest moment), it seems to me that the Doctor makes the mistakes and the people around him pay for it.
not a good man, not a bad man, just an idiot with a box and a screwdriver.
a bunch of these are "the doctor didnt know/have any control" like until the baby melted and the reveal of where melody is did we know that the doctor lost melody, and he was right she was safe after all he did marry her the next season, and the tardis is notorius for not taking the doctor when he wants to be
Eleven could sometimes be a bit reckless but this falls into the same false narrative that says The Doctor is the most dangerous creature in the universe because he keeps fighting all these different folk and, sometimes, killing them. Daleks, Cybermen, Slitheen, Sontarans, Zygons, The Silence, etc, etc, etc...poor, poor victims who did nothing to deserve their fate. Oh wait, yes they did. Gotta say, it is one of the few things that really annoyed me about that whole narrative, that the Doctor is somehow a bad guy because he prevents all these other bad guys from killing a lot of people, destroying planets, the universe, or time and space itself.
True. The Doctor has a code against killing because he has killed so many. He's come to a deep understanding of the fragility of life and will try to preserve it at all costs. It doesn't mean he won't allow nature to take it's course or lend a helping hand occasionally though. Most times he lets them die by giving them a choice and if they make the wrong choice then that's on them. It's rare he outright goes out of his way to kill someone and it's only if they are utterly irredeemable (like Soloman) will he make that choice. Even then, Soloman would have been let go if it wasn't a choice between him and the innocents on the ship.
"Good men don't need rules. Today is not the day to find out why I have so many."
Promised to keep the Ponds safe then didn't: "He says that some of them met very sad ends but promises that the same fate will not befall his son & daughter-in-law. But then the angels took Manhattan... the Doctor loses Amy & Rory when a bunch of Weeping Angels trap them in 1930s New York."
Uhhh, they got to be together. They lived into their 80s... TOGETHER. Yes, not in their own time, but they were still together DAMMIT! Why is he saying this like they died tragically!? Amy & Rory didn't meet a "sad end" They were together!
I agree. Technically they went on to live long and productive lives, just not in the time period they were expecting. I imagine they made a killing on the stock market too, just knowing the names Apple, Microsoft, Samsung, Sony etc would have been enough to get in on the ground floor and become quite wealthy. The trick would be not to be too obvious about it.
@@adelucas4824 Like it's weird to me how it's said that some of his companions "met very sad ends" and I'm sitting here going over all the companions (since the reboot) and literally all of them are pretty happy I'd say lol.
Rose: in another dimension where her dad's alive, got to be with a "human" Doctor.
Martha: met Mickey, got married, had a kid.
Donna: got married & won the lottery (thanks to the Doctor lol)
Clara: stole her own dang Tardis & is traveling with Ashildr.
Bill: was saved by Heather, reverted to human form & grew old together.
Ryan & Graham: living their best lives being grandad & grandson.
Dan: most likely living a happy life with Diane.
And Yaz is too recent to tell yet.
i think their ending was a bit fairytale like. realistically, they would've been homeless, deported, Rory would've been drafted into war and most likely killed. Their ending is far to jolly to every make any sense in the situation.
Some say Amy’s letter to The Doctor was a lie, as River tells her earlier on in the episode “to never let The Doctor see the damage”.
What’s if they didn’t have a happy ending, but she knew The Doctor couldn’t save them, other wise it would have disastrous consequences, so told him that they lived happily ever after to give him some peace.
I mean it’s in 11’s run where he states multiple times that Rule #1: The Doctor lies.
Maybe Amy’s last message to The Doctor is a lie, to hide the damage from him?
I’ve never done anything wrong, look how adorable I am!
YOU ARE ONE SEXY TIME LORD!
Matt IS adorable!!!
Clara's nan "voted yes" to playing twister. True Who fans know what I'm talking about.
So... when making this list, did it occur to you just how many of your bullet points were events completely out of the Doctor's control?
This is so true… Like wth
For a dude with a machine that can go anywhere in space and time absolutely nothing is out of his control. He is a literal god.
@@angbald Do you not watch the show?
Uhhh for an example… you think killing Solomon is “out of his control”?
Right? Most of these points are absolute bull.
2) Both Amy and Rory WERE safe. Both had died of OLD AGE, not being killed in the Tardis or due to them being in the tardis. When the dad asked what happened to them, the doctor told him and the dad agreed that the doctor had kept his word.
Rule #1: The Doctor Lies.
Also, River is the one who tells Amy to always hide the damage from The Doctor.
Maybe her final letter to The Doctor was all lies, as she knew he wouldn’t be able to save them, so gave him fake peace by saying they lived happily ever after?
For the christmas carol, He didn't MAKE them fall in love, how would he know?
And the weeping angels, the bit you called out, they didn't realize then! how would he also know that they were in danger?
He wasn't given any choice, the mission would have happened and everyone would have died regardless. Even River, usually the most intelligent and observant person in the room after the Doctor was tricked and felt stupid at how none of them realised the statues were Angels. Even the audience, despite being told repeatedly that the natives had two heads, looked at the single head statues and didn't make the connection. I had to rewatch it to see how clever it was, they were in front of us all along and we were told they were in front of us all along and we still missed it.
@@adelucas4824 Adding to my point.
Love Matt Smith and his portrayal of 11. 11 can be ruthless and conflicted, + a little dark towards the end, but mostly he just is so kind and loving. That’s why the character is so special. Further, this list of things- most of them were entirely out of his control.
This is kind of a silly list. None of these are awful things. Other incarnations have done way worse than what's listed here.
I agree it’s just picking holes in things they personally didn’t like
They said in the comments they're going to try to go through every Doctor, so don't think they're just picking on 11.
@@ladycplum Ok cool. That's chill then. I thought they were just pooping on 11.
@@mosescosme8629 I think 10 has done far worse things myself.
Finally, more Crispy WhoCulture content!
Next video: 1000 worst things the seventh doctor has done
Besides rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrolling his "r"'s, you mean? 😆
How many of them are McCoy just showing off his performer skills.
Only 1000?
@@WhoCulture well 10 mill counting big finish
So you’re just gonna upload pretty much his entire run, across all the media?
One thing thats always bothered me is in "Last of the Time Lords" after the Doctor rewinds time and reverses his own year of hell, why doesn't he use the Arch Angel Network to erase everyones memory of what happened and who The Master was. Everyone on the Valiant is horribly traumatized and it would've also ended The Master's little cult who later resurrected him.
I never liked the way he went from being a cross between Gollum and Dobby to a normal-sized Tinkerbell!
It was only the people on the Valiant who remembers, everyone else forgets. Also, if they'd been made to forget, Martha's parents wouldn't have reunited and that muddies the water IMO.
@@qienna6677 But its still cruel of The Doctor to not make them forget and force everyone on the ship to live with the trauma.
And one couple is not worth a ship full of mentally scared people.
@@StephenLeGresley I can imagine a lot of people not wanting to forget, despite the trauma. He could have offered them the choice. Although, I don't think Martha's family would choose to forget
He literally couldn’t make them forget though, he said as they were in the epicentre, the eye of the storm, they would unfortunately remember it all.
I’m pretty sure 10 would’ve chosen to make everyone forget, if he could’ve.
The Doctor in Doctor Who isn't perfect. Like all of us, The Doctor has a dark side, and sometimes it gets the better or the worst of him and he made mistakes. In "The Girl Who Waited", he shouldn't have lied to Rory about having 2 Amy Ponds in the TARDIS and that the TARDIS couldn't withstand the paradox of there being 2 versions of the same person. In "The Waters of Mars", The Doctor did go too far and realizes he went too far when he saved the Bowie Base One crew which was their destiny and is a fixed point in human history, which an ungrateful Adalaide Brooke berates him for changing her fate and her destiny. The Doctor could be manipulative and cunning. Some of these bad things he did were for the greater good and to help others and his own sense of morality. It makes you question if The Doctor is a hero, an anti-hero, a vigilante or an anti-villain?
Adelaide wasn't ungrateful so much as appalled and horrified by the Doctor's cavalier and arrogant attitude, and she was right to berate him. He went too far, and he only realized that after Adelaide killed herself to preserve a semblance of the original timeline. "Lived too long" indeed.
Adelaide had absolutely every right to berate him, and ungrateful, more like disgusted that The TimeLord Victorious gets to decide who lives and who dies, who’s considered a “little” person or a “big” person in the grand scheme of things, but more importantly, he told her how important her death was.
She would be responsible for inspiring humanity to travel into the stars, and she decided, that the greater good of humanity was worth more than her living longer past her established timeline.
This is the closest The Doctor had gotten to becoming The Valeyard.
Well, your interpretations of certain events were certainly... novel. I'm not sure we watched the same show.
1:56-1:59. Like Rory punching him in the face. Your girlfriend is no more important than the whole universe. SHE IS TO ME!!!! HAHAHAHA!!!!Welcome back Rory Williams!!
Eleven’s more childlike personality cutting to an anger more like Ten’s has always been one of the reason why I love him so much.
Right out the gate - The Doctor was naked because he was going to church. They both ended up naked when they WENT TO CHURCH. Have you watched the show?
I just realised the fake doctor shouldn't have pretended to regenerate. I know this is cause they hadn't decided he was actually the 13th, but still.
Exactly! At least the Atraxi and Cybermen not displaying the War Doctor on their lists of incarnations is explainable. It's because they missed the Time War.
It makes sense when you look at Classic Who and The Crispy Master.
11 still regenerates because his body is programmed to do that, but just doesn’t have enough energy to follow through with the process, and if he really wanted to bypass the limit before TTOD/TTC, he would’ve ended up as a Crispy 11.
I want an Unbound series with a Cripsy Doctor, that would be cool.
Technically he didn't even just let the Cleric Soldiers die, he also let them be erased from existence, with the exception of the Bishop that we don't know for certain none of the others were even born!
Good point!
And they were there to stop the doctor anyway cause the papal mainframe said a group did break off from the church to go back to stop the doct from getting where he wound up in time of the doctor cause it’s a safe bet they are the same group she was telling the doctor about or at least part of that group
@@kevin10001 I think that was just the group with Madam Kavarian, I think that lot were actually alright!
Loved this list especially seen as 11 is my favourite docter.
Geronimo
GERONIMOOOOO
Crispy I hope you convince Ellie to do your guess The Doctor Who episodes by the bad reviews
Most of the things on this list are things outside of The Doctors control I. E. Abigail being terminally I’ll was something he had no knowledge of until almost the end of the special
To be fair, 12 years is a short amount of time for someone who has lived for centuries and seen all of time
Hindsight morality is an easy game to play.
It's not valuable though; there is no reading, nor depth.
Few of these aren't the Doctor's fault. Well technically they are, but with good intentions.
He didn't know about Abigail's conditions, sure a woman frozen in a box, but Kazran's dad started a business with frozen people, forcing their families to pay their debts.
Punishing Solomon, who murdered all Silurians in cold blood and killed an innocent dino, just because the Doctor said NO to him. A cold blooded mass murderer doesn't deserve to be spared, especially when a missile is heading towards the Arch. The Doctor solved 2 problems here, saved Earth and got the universe rid of a mass murderer.
I could continue with most points on this list, but I think it's best for me to say, this list isn't the best, you've ever done. Most of those entries are either misconceptions, or reaching hard. Some aren't the Doctor's fault, and some are simply irreversible. Even after finding out the truth about Abigail, he still couldn't do anything about it, or about young Kazran falling in love with her. It's not the worst things the Doctor ever did. Not even remotely.
I am pretty sure, that the Doctor did far worse things, than ignoring the health condition of a frozen woman, sending a missile after a mass murderer, getting away with a mad space vampire sacrificing herself to her male younglings, disappointing a parent of one of his companions and other stuff from this list. I'm also pretty sure, that he did all stuff in Classic Who, that would make this list going green with envy.
to be fair Killing the Sillence Was a MORE well Dificult situation The Silence make you forget WHo they are When you look away How the F can YOu fight that By Using mental manipulation to Basically drive them From earth For all externity If they had peaceful intentions Then The Idea of It Would be quite different but its pretty hard to Fight something you forget the moment you look away
I’m sorry but your just picking holes in things you personally didn’t like you turning choices that the characters made themselves and putting in the doctor completely wrong and fault
3:00 he didn’t lead soldiers to their deaths they asked him to come being a expert if anything river was more responsible the doctor didn’t know what he was going into that’s just too harsh on the doctor
4:33 there are reasons why the tardis didn’t return to the exact moment she left both times we need to remember the silence and the alliance we’re manipulating events which was the bit thing in season 5 and 6
4:39 that was his own fault he was going to take a innocent woman as his own property he also killed a dinosaur and technically the missles killed him launched from the military
5:22 Amy chose the waterfall and Rory didn’t say which button to press that’s their own fault
6:20 no absolutely not that was no way his fault he raised a army to rescue amy and melody no one knew melody was swopped not even her own mother so that’s bull
7:13 again he tried everything to save them even nearly leveling New York trying ti break through thanks to the angels constant time warping also if Rory hadn’t deserved to randomly look at a grave stone with his name on it he wouldn’t of been zapped again amy wouldn’t of sacrificed herself to be with Rory tho that was sweet nothing was the doctors fault
8:50 that was his choice he decided that the doctor didn’t want they at all 8:56 that was Amy’s choice (roll credits) she literally volunteered and the doctor said no but Amy insisted not his fault 9:01 that was her choice not the doctors you literally see him running saying no your taking other characters choices which lead to their deaths and putting them on the doctor do more research before making videos because nothing you said was right
So what you're saying is that they should fire Jacob Simmons?
@@GabePuratekuta where the hell did you get that from
@@nathanbell8415 Everything that you said. And since he wrote the script...
@@GabePuratekuta you don’t need to be so extreme plus I said what they need to do just do the research he was blaming everything in the doctor when it wasn’t they all made their own choices and he was blaming in the doctor for a video so that’s the tip do the research simple as that no need for firing
Respectfully disagree with all because if you want to get technical The Doctor has killed and/or doomed everyone in every regeneration
British people are so weird about justice and punishment. The good guy is always supposed to let the bad guy go to be a hero or turn them into a good guy? Weirdos
Harriet Jones was right.
@@williamhollenbach1249 from which episode? Christmas invasion?
@@smalltowncop4907 Yes.
Yo congratulations Crispy Pro 👌🏼
Matt Smith is great as the doctor my favourite doctor he's great and matt Smith is still going strong with house of the dragon as daemon
I often disagreed with some of the eleventh doctors actions towards clara oswald in the second part of series 7. In the episode Cold War he allowed clara to put herself in danger with ice warrior knowing that she was trying to prove herself to him. And in the episode The Time of the Doctor he sends clara home by tricking her into the tardis, something which had previously backfired and failed back in the series 1 episode The Parting of the Ways with the ninth doctor and rose tyler. So it was a bit pointless really! 🙈 Still love the eleventh doctor though! Geronimo! ❤️❤️😊
Did any True Who fans know what I was talking about? Well I guess I'll tell you. It wasn't that Clara's nan wanted to play twister with naked 11. The actress who played Clara's nan, Sheila Reid, was in the Sixth Doctor serial "Vengeance on Varos" (1985) where torture and executions were televised and citizens voted whether the one being tortured lived or died. But along comes good ol' Six and Peri to put and end to it all.
For me, Matt Smith was my all time favourite Doctor, his era had so much wonder and mystery to it, but you can't make an omelette without breaking a few eggs
#2 - keeping the Ponds safe. It's a promise the Doctor always makes and breaks one way or another with each companion that turns out detrimental if not fatal. Rose ended up in a different dimension, Martha nearly lost her family, Donna had her memory wiped, the angels got the Ponds, Clara died, Bill turned into a cyberman and Yaz had her heart broken. So, pretty poor record on the safety thing. Cheers....
The worst thing he ever did was regenerate! Oh God why did he have to leave us?
Yess
Well, in his defense, Solomon did commit genocide of an entire spaceship or people who helped him
A number of these are his choices he's left with and not actions he simply did.
But then, how would they explain how Amy inexplicably aged a few decades?
9. The Doctor didn't know that she was dying, nor did he make them fall in love. The Doctor didn't know that Kazeran would fall in love with her, nor did he know that she was terminally ill.
8. Inviting his friends to watch him die was a fixed point in time. That point in time, in order to avoid paradoxes, the documentation of his death was absolutely necessary. However, because that was a fake body, he didn't actually die.
6.The first time was a mistake. There is an excuse for the second time, but that I'll save for the end because it's an excuse that applies to everything on this Top 10 list (except for 7, which is exclusively unique to the 11th Doctor being forgetful).
5. The Doctor isn't as forgiving as people give him credit for. And this is not exclusive to the 11th Doctor. The Family of Blood is a perfect example of how unforgiving the Doctor is. Or how about that kid that he dropped off in the present who came back from the future with a hole in his head.
4. This is complicated because there was no right answer. But technically, by choosing to save Young Amy, Old Amy ceased to exist, so there was no need for her to be saved. This isn't a case of the Doctor being in the wrong, this was simply a case of fate being cruel.
3. Although I've argued against why previous things shouldn't be on the list, I at least understand why they would be. This is a case where you have to have misinterpreted or misremembered the episode to have any justification for this to be on the list. The fact is that the title of this list, by definition, excludes this as being on the list. The Doctor was not at fault in any way whatsoever.
2. The problem with making promises, and this applies to anyone, is that you can't predict what will happen in the future. So in reality, the only real promise you can do is to try. And Amy and Rory didn't mean a sad end. It's just sad from the point of view of the Doctor. As the Doctor has said before, the Weeping Angels are the only assassins that will kill you kindly. They send you into the past and make you live to death. Amy and Rory still got to have a happy ending. And keep in mind that River was sent into the past as well. This itself is a paradox if she's incapable of escaping that time. Because she will (or technically already have (and technically will again with the 12th Doctor)) meet the Doctor again.
1. This is a weird one, because it's either commit genocide, or allow a race to take part in slavery.
As stated earlier, and what applies to most of this list, The Doctor doesn't think like a human. The actions he takes likely are the result of being able to see all fixed points in time (this has been demonstrated in a 10th Doctor episode). There are many times when the Doctor just knows that there are only a few ways things can go without creating a time paradox. But imagine having that kind of knowledge and not being omniscient. The points in time that are no fixed points are unknown to him. For example, with the episode with the vampires, it is an absolute fact that those aliens don't exist in the future. He may have committed genocide, not because he likes it, because that too may have been a fixed point. The reason those aliens don't exist in the future may be because it has always been the case that the Doctor committed genocide. And if you think of it, if fixed points in time exist, then free will cannot exist. Humans have the luxury of at least experiencing the illusion of free will. But to someone like the Doctor, his nature would allow him to see through that illusion and realize that free will doesn't exist. That would change how you view reality.
Ahhhh so proud of you Crispy!!!
Thank you!!!
@@CrispyPro no prob! Been watching ur stuff since u were a small Who creator!
Ok to defend the 11th for the dino’s on Space, Solomon jettisoned the original Passengers off the ship killing millions, and treating one of his friends like an object and not a human. At some point the doctors hands are always tied and at this one he had to either let 1 die or let hundreds of living Dinosaurs die. Sometimes the best choice is a bad one
While I don't agree with most of the things on the list since there were genuine reasons for it and they weren't his fault.
One specific one that ISN'T on the list is: The Creation of the New Dalek Paradigm in Victory of the Daleks. His reckless emotional outbursts against the Daleks who were in World War 2 allowed those remnants to record his voice to gain access to the progenitor device that they needed to literally jump back the Daleks back to near full strength. Granted the Daleks always know how to provoke the Doctor. Even worse is that once the New Daleks were created the Doctor tries to fix his mistake and managed to fight back and had them cornered, however the Daleks threatened to detonate their android bomb back on Earth if he didn't spare them. The Doctor just being too compassionate or being gullible agreed to let them escape but as the Daleks are pure evil monsters, they activate the bomb anyway which made the whole act of compassion pointless anyway. Had the Doctor just committed to killing off this one last Dalek saucer at the time expecting that the Daleks will never keep their word the whole New Dalek Paradigm wouldn't even exist and continue to EXTERMINATE all life. Granted in later episodes there were still surviving Daleks around anyway, but at least this would have given the Doctor and the time of the universe a much long and much needed break instead of another huge skyrocket in Dalek population again.
Edit: I would like to make a correction of my misunderstanding. The Doctor already knew the whole time that the Daleks would activate the bomb anyway so it's more likely the Daleks would have made the bomb detonate immediately if he didn't spare them instead of the extra time to disarm it in the end of the episode. That being said the Doctor's emotional outbursts cost him his episode.
While it certainly wasn't the worst thing he did, I think The Doctor's 'Colonel Runaway' speech ought to have been on this list.
I wouldn't necessarily say promising to keep the Ponds safe in and of itself was a bad thing (although he should know from past experience it's not a promise he should EVER make), but I would count trying to drag Amy away from making her own choice to follow Rory back into the past after he's zapped by the Weeping Angel as a pretty bad thing. I always thought the Doctor had a rather unhealthy fixation on Amy, the whole "first face this face ever saw" thing, and his trying to talk her out of being with her soulmate because of that fixation was both bad and creepy. Oh, and I'd also add almost giving Kahler-Jex to the Gunslinger (while holding him at gunpoint) and his even worse obsession with Clara than with Amy, especially when he scared her to death by getting right up in her face an demanding to know who or what she was in Journey To the Centre Of the TARDIS, as pretty bad things too. (Let's face it, the 11th was a bit stalker-ish)
With Amy, I think another reason he was trying to keep her from following Rory was simply that he didn't want to lose another friend. But, it's still selfish on his part. Understandable, but selfish
Crispy Pro! Look at you! I've been watching you for a couple years now and how far you've come! Good on you. A true whovian. Excellent video.
You could say 11 leaves Amy 3 times if you count the alternative Amy, even though she vanished from existence
Ok We need a 10 worst things the 7th doctor has done
The hope is to get to every Doctor eventually!
@@WhoCulture Oh I can't wait to see the 10th!
@@ladycplum they have already done 10
Did also the doctor killed several “last of their kind” creatures?
You guys need to do a six degrees of Doctor Who. If you did you would find that you could connect am surprising amount of people to the doctor. Everyone from President s, Rock Bands and even the Rat pack of you look carefully.
Frank Sinatra was in Around the World in 80 Days with Patrick Cargill, who was in Inspector Clouseau with Clive Francis, who was in Official Secrets with Matt Smith.
@@ladycplum you can also connect him through the Bond Films. He appeared in the original Oceans 11 with Dean Martin and Sammy Davis, Jr. Years later both Sammy and Dean Martin did guest spots on Charlie's Angels. A year aftér Dean's guest spot Timothy Dalton appeared on the show as a high society jewel their. Thirty years later he appeared in the End of Time parts one and two with David Tennant.
I think this list proves that you're being unfair. A vast majority of the things on this list were not his fault. And it's not like he was unaffected by the decisions. The only thing that was really his fault was that second genocide you mentioned about the science and even that was not really a genocide because he knew that there were some of the science that would survive it but it's not like he had an alternative.
The Doctor speculated that there was a perception filter that's why they didn't notice the angels
Man, now that you bring it up, 11 was a bit of a dick
Love the 11th dr he’s my favourite and you can never love a good Whoculture video.
"you can never love a good Whoculture video" so you only love the bad Whoculture videos?
The Doctor shouldn't have promised to keep Amy and Rory safe. Nobody's safe. Anywhere. Any time. Safe is an illusion.
Gotta point out. Solomon did kill a thousand Silurians.
"Had some fun in the Tardis and now Melody has time lord DNA" haha.
the christmas sceens were clearly filmed in the summer, 11 would have got very cold at christmas
This list feels at times like a bit biased against the 11th
Most of the things here aren't actually his fault and the ones that are... Well
F.e., i wouldnt say that saying the ponds are aafe and then they aren't is awful. Not coming back to face Brian and tell him the truth making him always wonder... Well, that is
The entire arc with clara is awful, as he travels with her out of wanting to unravel the mistery and actually is using her in a way
The two amys, that is one i can totally agree. That was dark
And the leaving the Young Amy behind in the first episode(s) - okay, he's occasionally a shitty driver. He didn't mean for it to come back 12 years later.
The two Amys one was the doctor more they likely not wanting to create a paradox cause two versions of the same person aren’t supposed to be in the same point in time at the same time like a future version of yourself going back to an earlier point in their life that would create a paradox especially if u interact with yourself from that point in time
@@kevin10001 true, true
@@kevin10001 no, i know why it was. But he was manipulative there. Not only that, he used rory and then left him to be the one choosing. That was awful af.
That said, not the first time different versions of the same person have been in the tardis at once
11 was a badass. Basically, Run.
I feel like he was horrible to river when he found out her mum was going to die and instead of telling her he shouted at river then made her break her wrist 🥲
He also lied (rule one The Doctor lies) about his regenerations to Clara. But that's just down to Moffat's poor sense of continuity.
Actually in my opinion he didn’t lie the scene was ment to tell the audience through Clara thst john hurt is “the war doctor” but an actual numbered regeneration being the new 9th regeneration making the regeneration number higher then their actors number with Christopher moving up to being the 10th regeneration David becoming the 11 & 12th regenerations and then Matt becoming the 13th regeneration the last one in the cycle so basically they were given the revised regeneration order
@@kevin10001 Completely different to what I'm referring to.
Are we playing twister now? Hehe
I'm not sure there was a better move for the Doctor to make in The Girl Who Waited.
He apparently can't take both. He couldn't have saved anyone if older Amy knew he couldn't take both.
The Angel 2 head issue, was down to basic perception Filter
River emerged from Lake Silencio in a spaceSHIP ???
He also gave the Great Intelligence the idea of infiltrating the London underground causing the events of the Patrick Troughton story Web of Fear.
This is (so far) the only video in the legion of WhoCulture videos that I had to stop watching after 40 seconds.
1:03 how exactly "made" he fall karzan in love? Last time I checked, you can't force love (and to be fair: would Kazran be better off as and old and bitter man?)
I know there's a lot of love for 11. But honestly, he's definitely one of my least favorite doctors. Between the issues listed in this video, his compulsive lying, and a laundry list of character defects that are too often written off as "quirks" I honestly don't understand why so many hold him as the best doctor. Am I alone in this? If so, that's totally fine. Everyone can have their own opinion. I'm only stating mine.
To me, the Doctor killing Solomon stands out a mile because it's so against his usual "Thou Shalt Not Kill" philosophy. In this case, without the Doctor's actions, missiles wouldn't have hit Solomon's ship so Solomon survived. Worse, the Doctor, who could easily have taken Solomon off the ship, instead imprisoned him there despite Solomon's pleas for mercy.
My reaction was a huge: "What the @#$@?:" This was outright cold-blooded murder.
WHat about when 10 genocided the racnoss?
SpaceSUIT not spaceSHIP.
In bells of Saint John didn’t he use the sonic screwdriver to break into Clara’s house
I thought the way Matt spoke his lines about how he loved being asked "Doctor who?" was SERIOUSLY creepy, he almost sounded turned on. No wonder Clara shut the door in his face!
Yeah @CrispyPro you definitely forgot about that
I'd be very upset if the Doctor ruined my Amy twinsie ideas. 🤔
Losing Melody is Number one in my book
Crispy Pro??? What the heck are you doing here? 😯 Also, this list is a mess
DO NOT pause at 7:47
I have a way to save Amy and Rory, and even explain their aging, but sadly the story won’t see the light of day.
90% of these things weren’t so bad lmao, what did y’all expect? Did you expect him to be super careful and pay attention to everything? It wouldn’t be The Doctor then, it would be more like a perfect boring hero. The Doctor isn’t a hero, and he didn’t know what was going to happen in most of these. It was u expected for him.
Crispy!!!!
I hate videos like this. Very judgemental. Mostly unavoidable. Almost always with no alternatives. Often blaming the Doctor for the actions of others.
Most of the things on this list weren’t even is fault
love how y'all just cut context and actual canon evidence to make these choppy "worst things" lists. pretty much everything mentioned here is either out of the Doctor's control OR done as a last resort after giving multiple chances for the antagonist of the week to make a different choice.
do y'all even LIKE the Doctor?
The Doctor never pulls the trigger. He merely hands you a loaded weapon and tells you not to shoot yourself after ensuring that the weapon is pointed directly at your head.
1. Existing because he’s by far my least favourite out of all of them.
I mean the character, the Eleventh Doctor. How they were conceptualised and written. Not got a bad word against Matt Smith the actor. I don’t blame him.
11 is my second least favorite, but I do put some of that down to Matt's acting. Sometimes it seems like he was trying too hard to be quirky and weird. One of the episode guide books I have mentioned sometimes he acted like a children's TV show host, and he definitely does.
@@ladycplum I remember his first interview in a dark ensemble, anyone would’ve assumed he would be a cool or darker Doctor but it was the complete opposite.
I don’t think Matt is anything remotely like 11 from what I’ve seen but I might be wrong. Maybe he auditioned quirky and wasn’t written like that initially.
11 definitely has “Blue Peter” or CBBC Tuesday morning programme energy. Cartoonish but not in a funny way like Jim Carrey, just annoying.
I call him “Mr. Magoo” because that’s the perfect word for it.
@@GT3NB HAH! Mr. Magoo, I love it!
You’re really reaching in condemning the 11th Doctor. Your argument is invalid!☝️😌
Naah. Rubbish list. Most of them are not his fault. It's just like you try real hard.
Most of these were accidents and hard to make choices ... strange but ok.
Love having Crispy Pro on the channel