How many species of Human were there?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 сер 2024
- #paleoanthropology #human #ancienthuman
Thanks for watching,
Make sure to like, share, comment and subscribe!
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Check out my stuff!
Instagram: / north02video
Subreddit: / north02reddit
Email: North02bank@gmail.com
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
All media displayed in this video is displayed with either permission from copyright owner, fair use, or is creative commons.
If I failed to give proper credit or you do no want your images displayed here, please contact me and I will give credit or immediatly remove at your request.
Much of the media displayed in this video is protected under FAIR USE for reasons of Commentary, Education, Criticism, Parody, and Social Satire.
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Sources:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Dee...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo_ru...
www.nature.com/articles/s4158...
australian.museum/learn/scien...
www.nhm.ac.uk/discover/who-we...
australian.museum/learn/scien...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denisovan
www.discovermagazine.com/plan...
www.sci-news.com/archaeology/h...
www.theguardian.com/science/2...
www.newscientist.com/article/...
www.sci-news.com/othersciences...
Naledi burial
www.newscientist.com/article/...
www.nationalgeographic.com/ad...
26 species concepts
scienceblogs.com/evolvingthou...
Good video about species
• What is a species?
Homo erectus brain size diversity
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
Human diversity, penguin, mongrels
www.pbs.org/race/000_About/00...
Sapiens article
www.sapiens.org/column/field-...
Flow of human genetics
www.scientificamerican.com/ar...
Human species
www.livescience.com/how-many-...
Litigon
www.natureasia.com/en/nindia/...
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
What topic would you like to see covered next?
I'd love to see you do a video about your other interests, I've seen you "in the wild" here on YT a few times and I'm always happily surprised when it seems we share similar interests
@@shinobi-no-bueno maybe I’ll use the second channel for that.
I think the oldest European genomes recently sequenced from several ancient Bacho Kiro Cave fossils would make a marvelous story, especially since their genetics showed long stretches of Neanderthal ancestry just 5-7 generations back in the lineages. A strong case could be made that 45,000 years ago interbreeding was a norm as opposed to the exception.
How our species, which managed to colonize the entire planet - including a vast array of habitats, and remaining reproductively isolated for many millennia in many cases - avoided subspeciating (as any other species would) in accord to evolutionary theory. Is this a miraculous fact, or pseudoscientific nonsense? If the former, what unique properties of Homo sapiens prevented subspeciation? If the latter, what is the motive behind pushing the pseudoscience?
Have you ever looked into sasquatch? Those things are real flesh and blood creatures. Act like a detective. Look into the topic like it might actually be true. Then make your decision. Modern people didnt know the mountain gorilla existed until the 1920s. Same sort of story was true about narwhals, Grizzlies in north America and giant squid. These where myth or at least a joke to the people at the time. The Europeans didn't believe the native Americans when they said there were giant brown bears up north that couldnt be stopped by guns. Youd think if there were any hominids left on earth they'd stay the hell away from us. Besides most people live in the city and that's the end of it. And if you go camping it's at like the edge of the mountains. Most people who see these things are way back in thick woods or high mountains. Far away from the droves of day hikers. If you want to take the topic seriously look up sasquatch chronicles. This guy does live interviews with eyewitnesses and these people will tell you they could see the wrinkles on its forehead. This guy has to have done 1000 interviews with people who saw that level of detail. You can also look up thefactsbyhowtohunt this guy takes emails from folks who have had an encounters and reads them word for word. No bullshit man you can listen to these people and decide for yourself whether or not thousands of people are misidentifying, hoaxing, lying, or crazy. I promise you this is worthwhile for you to look into. We need smart people like you to chip in your thoughts and theories on what these sasquatch, bigfoot, yeti, yowie creatures are. I've backpacked into the high sierras in California. Let me tell you it's like shangrula. I could live the rest of my life out there and no one would ever find me. Its rugged, tuff, beautiful land and full of food if you know how to catch it. Hell bears love it out there. I think a large hairy man like thing would like it too. The public deserves to know. There are people with terrifying encounters who are mocked and laughed at by their everyone they know including their family. People have nothing to gain but ridicule for telling their stories and that's why this isnt public knowledge. Also I think the government does keep these things underwrapps. But for the most part we do it to ourselves by not listening to our fellow man.
Imagine racisim if there were actually different species around lol
Racists did try to convince people we were different species after Darwin discovered evolution, it was all crockshit of course.
The thing is anthropologists would agree that different races were different species only stopping like 120 years ago
@@whipasnaper yeah and they were retards
@@whipasnaperno they wouldn‘t
@@MrUndertown If humans were animals human races would probably be separated as subspecies. It doesn't mean one race is superior to another it just means physically we have some significant differences like bone density,muscle fiber type,skin color and facial features bone structure and many many other things. Most Europeans have a small amount of Neanderthal DNA and most Asians have some Denisovan hominins in their DNA. If a Kodiak bear is a subspecies of Grizzly bear than different races would definitely be. It's pretty obvious.
As a child growing up in the 50s we were taught about the missing link between apes and man, can you imagine my delight of witnessing over the last 50 odd years the discoveries of humans and different species. I've been fascinated with this subject since I was about ten and it just keeps on getting more interesting. Thank you North for yet another wonderfully presented video.
As a child of the 60's, I totally agree with you! The evolving (no pun intended) science of paleontology is fascinating indeed, and I wait patiently for the next discovery!
There never was a single missing link. All animals make their slow changes and split off branches...the animals alive today are all the result of subtle, small changes over eons....no leap from an ape (which is a distant branch) to a human...the notion was always false.
Well *technically* there's no possible way for there to be any link, missing or not, between apes and humans because we *are* apes
I was born in 1960 and am fascinated by this subject. It’s been a rollercoaster ride in the last few decades.
As child of the 70s same here :b
I took my first college class in human evolution in 1971. I went on to a different discipline for my profession , law, but have always had an interest in the subject of human evolution. Please keep these videos coming ? This series has been the very best the public domain has to offer. Thank you.
You went from learning about a lie to becoming a liar 😂
Me too, 71. But I went on to brag about becoming a Shepherd.
@@YankeeDoodle2 😂😂😂
Those skulls are just of Apes ~ all a HOAX😂🎉
I was LIED TO and not given access to this information, since I was raised fundamentalist evangelical christian and homeschooled. Education and information is knowledge and knowledge is power. Thank you for making this information public. I’m crying why wasn’t I told this?! 😢
Fundamentalist lie about real Christianity. What do you expect.
I just wanted to say I am Christian and I KNOW for a fact this video is true. You can believe in both. I know god created an environment where we were able to evolve and flourish.
My catholic priest to my church says you cannot prove science wrong.
@@QuintessentialUltimatumso does this mean god looked more like a caveman or neanderthal or what we look like today? And how did Noah get 2 penguins to walk to a middle eastern desert to hop on a boat? Or was that story fabricated also? Did Noah get mad at his tribe and build a big enough boat to carry a few sustainable farm animals like cows pigs chickens goats and float down river for 4 days and start his own incestrial tribe?
When the internet does something positive
I'm from Indonesia. I've accidentally found this video from youtube's algorithm somehow. I deeply appreciate how peaceful, calming, & relaxing this video actually is, probably because of the background music & the voice of the narrator. It's very rare to find such informative & educative videos with unique style like this. Thank you for this.
This is misinformation read the bible to find true facts about our existence.
Yes, I agree. This is a gem, and I'm grateful I somehow found this video.
Indonesia probably has more species than just the hobbit. Imagine what might exist in more remote islands.
@@Dodgey_Damo america did a lot of colonial imperialist genocide in indonesia though.
All of his content is great, his soothing voice, thorough research, and effort are all top notch. His ancient human series dives into each of these much deeper, each about a half hour to a hour in length. That's my personal favorite series he does.
"Most people are familiar with the biological species concept."
You give most people too much credit.
This. 😂
yes, go for a drive on a Sunday, and see all the morons that come out the woodwork and congregate in flocks of stupidity...
What is a species?
Yeah, I'm afraid I'd have to go with the "most people are idiots" school of thought.🥴
@@guarddog318 on AVERAGE people are dumb AF. I wish it weren’t true.
300,000 years of existence and we still can't cope with the fact females have nipples...
Nipples😍
Why isn't this talked about in the mainstream, I find it so fascinating
It’s fear.
@@MySpaceDxC_Suffo_AtTheGates fear of what ?
I find it fascinating that the old concept of humans developed from one single line is turned out to be incorrect that we are more like branches of trees interwoven
I think so too. This is a marvelous development!
It's kinda weird how many parallels between biological evolution and linguistics there are, they come about and function nearly identically.
Out Of Africa was totally ridiculous we had the oldest human versions living at the end of the line it simply doesn't make sense
Anthropologist here. Early humans (H. sapiens) were considerably more robust than contemporary humans, nearly as robust as Neanderthals. Additionally, they had similar caloric requirements, with Neanderthals needing roughly 4400 and humans around 3600-4000. Our species didn't loose its great robusticity until around 40kya to 13kya, and it dropped of slowly. Also, excellent video, thank you.
I’ve heard this before, but I’m confused how the less robust traits were spread to all the human lineages when we were already out of Africa 40kya. Do some extant human lineages retain the older robust features? Or was it a convergent evolution?
@@robertbradley9825 Gene flow. The hallmark of human evolution over the past 200k years is gene flow and migration. It's easy for us to misunderstand how connected ancient populations were because we see vast distances and small populations and mistakenly imagine they were isolated. Along the lines of migration, various foraging populations lived and exchanged genes (married, had babies, etc) with populations next to them. Over generational time, novel genes, especially successful ones, travel up and down the migration pathways. This is called the "trellis model." There are a few examples of populations that became truly isolated - in these, you start seeing genetic drift take over, sometimes with unpredictable results, and usually a loss of technological progress. But no human population stays isolated long enough to evolve into a subspecies, that'd require tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of years. Populations can evolve novel genes that best fit their environment, though. These genes aren't very successful outside of specific geography and so don't travel well.
@@totalherenow what a thorough response, thank you! So by that logic, even “isolated” populations like the indigenous Australians and Andamanese made contact with other “continental” human lineages at some point over the last few tens of kya?
@@robertbradley9825 Yes, that's correct. The indigenous Australians had contact with those living on nearby islands in the PNG chain (the lowlanders. The highlanders were very isolationist, but even they usually exchanged wives from outside their group). And, if you read up on the Andaman Islanders, you'll see that they've had contact with outsiders over the past hundred years (and definitely more contact prior). Probably the indigenous Tasmanians reached a very high level of isolation before being contacted by the Europeans, but even that wouldn't have been total, nor that long over generational time.
If you think of groups of people as populations of genes instead, it's probably easier to visualize the gene flow across geographic and cultural barriers (and the cultural ones don't usually last long enough).
@@robertbradley9825 they just pull "facts outta there asses, we've found like maybe a few thousand good bones and skeletons, there were billions of them over millions of years, just like like everyone is built different now I'm sure it was the same then to.
It’s amazing how far humankind has come that we went from carving stone tools for hunting to now watching a video about our origins on a cool electronic device that somehow contains all the information ever recorded. I don’t know how any educated person can ever deny evolution when it’s written all over our existence
truly is amazing how have we all come as a species.
The problem is you're so excited about the future that you don't realise that these electronic toys that are keeping you occupied and keep you from noticing what's going on are so insidious. In the last 20 years since Google came out human intelligence has dropped dramatically now humans feel they can't make a statement if they're hate group hasn't already approved it ,we allow Google to get us arguing so they can sell that content and of course if Google is now running the world we're only going to get the political narrative of the Americans not the rest of the world which is extremely dangerous considering how that country operates . Most modern humans have no idea what's going on and I believe we're actually the stupidest people ever to walk the face of the earth . Most of them are completely useless without electronic assistance which is exactly what Google wanted every part of our life to be making money for them. Everything Google has come up with, we used to be able to do but we weren't paying the Americans to do it .
its amazing how so many people deny all of this simply because it contradicts their spiritual beliefs. great video.
It doesn’t contradict religion.
@@MySpaceDxC_Suffo_AtTheGates then why do the abrahamic religions have false narratives of history written in their books? If it doesn’t contradict religion, then why do so many Jews, Christians, and Muslims get angry and deny evolution is what created humans?
Or situation's like Australia where the Aboriginal people won't allow any research to be done because they're so scared to death of finding that people were here before them which means they lose their claimed all the compensation despite there being cave painting evidence
@@MySpaceDxC_Suffo_AtTheGates Even Judeo-Christian? How?
There is something so fascinating about species that were so similar to us, who now are gone.
History, science, spirituality
All part of the same stew
Savor it.
@@ChubbyTeletubby thanks now I'm hungry.
A lot of them interbred with humans, so at least to some extent they still live on in modern human populations.
We still have denisovan and Neanderthal
DNA but it’s in very tiny amounts
@@angh18 what evidence do you have that they were exterminated, as opposed to not being able to adapt quickly enough to a changing climate, or being out competed for resources by other species?
I grew up being taught that the achievements of any other hominins to be irrelevant or at most primitive forgeries of things real humans achieved. It is very humbling to know that isn't the case, to know that very often modern humans took ideas from other groups. We truly stand on the shoulders of those who came before us in a way that is hard to understand in the modern world.
i am studying english online
be my friend..
Thats not really true. For the most part sapiens were the inventers
@@Imaworldstar-jw3yj I don't speak Japanese
Name me one idea we got from another group of humans ?
@@Salacious-Crumb Based on archeology, tool use apparently.
I'm enjoying the content immensely and I truly appreciate your calm, soothing tone of voice. It makes listening to your videos a very pleasant experience. Thank you so much!!
I applaud this entire presentation! Accurate when it's possible with discussion about why when accuracy is not possible. Great narration, super visuals and lovely background music.
It's HORRIBLY inaccurate. And hilarious.
How so?
Top quality video. With the voice of a kind father who tells histories of anthropology to his children before they fall asleep at night. Before this video, I was kinda confused about all the species of hominids, where they lived, when they lived, who our ancestors were, etc. Now I understand why I was confused, and I understand that the science keeps evolving with each find. Thank you for this summary, North 02.
😃
@@unapologeticella4540. GOD MADE REAL HUMANS. NOT THE NEPHLIUM GIANTS. ANIKAM GIANTS. A LIST IN. Deuteronomy 20:17.
Why do you lie to your kids?! They will grow up to become drug addicts and/or radical homosexuals because they think we evolved from rocks rather than being made in gods image. Trust the bible not atheist lunatics grasping at straws to come up with alternative theories.
@ace_5677hes joking or maybe hes not, but if he ain't joking well thats just sad LOL
Everybody's mentioning his voice I haven't watched the video yet but I'm assuming he's a robot
It is rare to find uploads wherein content, audio, and video are all done well. Thank you for great content in a very accessible presentation. It makes for an interesting, informative, and very enjoyable experience.
Well, this is a platform that caters to, & was built on amateur video, so why would you expect any different?
Why haven't I ever found this channel? Love the relaxing voice, and very soft background music. Also, the very clear information.
Videos like this just make me feel so grateful and blessed to not only live in the time period I do. But i also feel proud to be a part of such a resilient species. How amazing is it that out of all the things that have happened, you just so happened to be born NOW and not in some other time period? I feel as though humans have complicated things with the ways we deal with one another, and I’m sure some of these issues existed even back in the days of Homo Erectus. But part of me feels like it was so much more simple. For us to have evolved to the point where we have the responsibility of maintaining the planet marvels me. Idk maybe I’m trippin
Nah ur spitting dawg
You could have also existed during those times in a past life but you currently just don’t know it
I don't know about looking after the planet when we have billions of people acting like 10-year-olds playing with Chinese plastic toys totally disregarding the fact that it's killing the environment or the fact that all our widescreen TVs and electronic toys are doing the same
I believe we’re too smart for our own good then again life then was purely about protecting territory finding food and reproducing now we come by everything so easily all we have time for is overthinking
I love the information. Sounds reliable and factual and any ideas put forth are smart, thought out, and plausible (or explained if dissmissable). - My favorite is the video lay-out. MAPPING the species as they've been found and grouped together. And comparing bones and skulls with their applied name. Much appreciation!
There’s definitely a lot more than most people would think and likely more to come.
Good point our "timeline" perception, or just our perception of time, isn't very... wide view, you know?
Even global warming. Earth will be fine. Life will thrive, die off, thrive again. Imagine what fascinating species there will be in a couple million years! A drop in the bucket, really. A thousand years is like a millisecond in this universe
Ah Hell... what am I saying? We don't even know what time is. OR space! Lol
It's all a big black bottomless hole!!!!!😁
Let's talk about Nostradamus and his quantrill's from 1555 how he says the Chinese plague is released upon the planet Earth and in twenty years 98% of all the species on the planet perish they stopped publishing the number of covid deaths because it was outrageous
@@ChubbyTeletubby everyone's perception is different and the only black hole that I've really had to deal with on this planet with is my ex-wife with a $500,000 .a year. Income from my company , she wasn't satisfied she stole from me every time my back was turned a bottomless black hole that was never satisfy greed Knows No Boundaries pretty much like the universe
There is no more to come since extinction is coming for us. Get ready for the age of rats and cockroaches.
@@_robustus_ I meant archaic human species. But it is possible for modern Homo sapiens to diversify into different types of humans
Many thanks, you've managed to make this both entertaining and informative, which is surely the best way to learn. I greedily absorbed the whole thing - but a special mention must go to the comedy covering up of the naughty bits.
Fantastic channel! Thank you for putting all these videos together so brilliantly and capturing just how interesting and complex our evolutionary past is, not to mention how challenging it must be to study. Great work!
it would be interesting to interact with all the different human species that existed in the past, especially homo floresienis.
homo erectus', I hear, were pretty big hornballs, hence their name. lol
@Vicente Gambini
Lmao 😆😂🤣
The Human species never changed.
Open your eyes people-- do your own extensive research to find and test presented evidence.
Science is slowly but surely catching up to the Truth the Bible tells.
Evolution is a false theory.
@@Neoprototype I can tell your family tree is a stick
just watch lord of the rings
@@JusNoBS420
Nah, it’s probably a wreath.
Such a great job on this one North 02. My absolute favorite channel on history.
Dollar signs over all the naughty bits.
Thank you so much for this video. Your voice is soothing and your characterization of human evolution as fluid and always subject to reinterpretation is great!
If he's that good he's probably a robot
it reminds me of a Joe Pera video
I'm really digging your style and narration. I've been subscribed for a while and I am ALWAYS excited to see what you do next. Keep on keeping on!
Excellent video on a topic that can be complicated and confusing. It was particularly impressive that much technical jargon was avoided whilst still including sufficient detail, making this topic accessible to any interested person.
Nothing worse with a know it all who uses great big long words and excessively complicated language to make themselves out to be intelligent ,its nice when people just speak in plain English
I just stumbled across this
absolutely excellent ! love your way of presentingmaterial.
Excellent video. Yours are the best in this category - the writing is very clear and straightforward - pure information, no annoying tangents, comedy and histrionics like other creators. And your voice is so calm and even, it's a pleasure to listen to. Surprised to see the blocking of "private parts" - did YT sensorship give you trouble? It seems prudish and unnecessary for a science focused video - these drawings aren't even of modern humans. The one tangent - the big foot comment - was a surprise and broke the narrative, I don't think pre-emptive dismissals of of pseudo science are necessary, maybe you could leave that to another video, if you feel strongly about it (you clearly do!). Thanks for your high quality work, I'm looking forward to watching many more...
I had read about various hominid species before, but I wasn't following how the early hominids spread and evolved. This presentation puts it all together in a way that make sense. Bravo !!
Bery informative and yet simple video. I'm currently studying to refresh all I learned in college and this video helped me evem more than some classes lol. Just truly appreciated, amazing video.
Cool video, well done
Homo Naledi really intrigues me because by the time Sapiens, Neandethals, Denisovins, and Florensis were around, Naledi was still hanging around being more primitive
Florensis was also primitive
Many human-like species branched out and went in all kinds of different directions, changing only when survival demanded it. The brain uses up a huge amount of food energy, so a species isn't going to evolve a larger and more complex brain unless it's worth the price. The ones that remained primitive probably lived in an environment that gave them plenty of resources so didn't demand much of them, beyond agility and physical strength, as long as the climate remained the same. Naturally changing climate was probably what led to the dying out of all these offshoots, along with competition for resources from more intelligent and adaptable branches of our species.
Amazing! I have learned more from watching this presentation about our ancestors than any other time. Thank you.
Great video. And yea, you got me with the Bigfoot stuff. However, no Bigfoot remains isn’t a surprise and whether or not Gigantopithecus was bipedal or not, doesn’t mean that it’s descendant couldn’t be. Either way, you did spark an outcry from me. Great video. Everything you covered is so important to our history and is one of the most under appreciated area of research.
Thanks good work
I would love for you to do a channel about how indigenous Australians arrived in Australia. Australia never seems to come up in your colour charts, just saying. Thank you for your efforts. Douglas from Australia
Do an entire _channel?_ Or did you mean a *video?*
which ones? the indigenous or the tamil islanders who now call themselves aboriginals that genocided them?
@@arroeducarlion4990 wtf?
Indigenous ausies are human not a sub spices, may be that's why
@@abhisheksharma-sb3er ? archeological evidence and DNA profiling has proven the " aboriginals" are tamil island decendants who have been in australia only the last 20 thousand years where as the indiginous " tasmanian " aboriginal have archeological traces upon the mainland dating back 60 thousand years and more.
i wonder why the " tasmanian " aboriginals ceased to exist on the mainland while the tamil islanders flourished....
Excellent presentation. Clearly, chronologically and coheasively presented. Thank you NORTH 02
Typical thing a communist like yourself would say... LETS GO BRANDON
@@noahjohnson2004 I can tell your family tree doesn’t fork. Yeah who’s your favorite NASCAR driver?? 😮
Very well-done . Thank You
Great doc. What's the lovely music in the background?
Brilliant, as always! Thank you!!
This was a high quality video. I will be watching some of your other videos.
I really enjoy the video it was very educational. I wasn’t aware of the different types of people millions, thousands of years ago.
Good Job !!
This is so fascinating. I’m learning more on with your content than I did in school. I’m much more interested now. I think you learn more when you’re interested.
Thank you for such excellent content.
It is so beautiful yet so sad to have little pieces dating back millions of years and thinking what was really going on at that time.. and such a long evolution involving all the species while some disappeared for ever. we only live a short life and will never get to know much...it feels so strange to have to use the little time we get on this planet to work for money that is needed to buy the food and pay for amusement parks, cellphones,internet ... that have been invented only a second ago...
3m years is an eyeblink in the history of the planet (and that only takes in the homonid evolution) and all life taken together. Wanna really get your mind blown? Think about the life forms that were largely wiped out in the FIVE great extinctions. All of life starting over in a sense. And the planet is still only middle aged.
@@speedomars six, counting the microorganism extinction event that took place when algae first evolved. This extinction came closer to eliminating all life than any other.
I didn't see any of that, I guess it was too far before my time
Modern working is slavery for mankind
@@Strawhalo What are you talking about? Having a job? Deadbeat?
excellent upload 👍
So that is how many species of humans their was back then and great video man :]
Your videos are very enjoyable and well worth viewing more than once. Thank you for the dedication, hard work and wonderful presentation. 👍💛👍💛👍
Very good discussion about what's a species!!! When I first started watching you last year, I was totally stumped on the issue. I stuck with you though and I've had a great education from you. Thanks!!!
Africans, the Hommo Sapiens, left the continent, headed north to civilize the Neanderthal Europeans.
Weird since Homo sapiens didn’t have civilization yet.
I love to think of that line of personal ancestors each of us has stretching back into the mists of time, and thank each one of them that we are here.
The tree dwelling Naledi with brains less than half the size of ours deposited their dead in caves? It almost suggests primitive ritual or religious beliefs? Interesting and amazing stuff! Great video! Keep them coming!
They weren’t tree dwelling . We find dozens of them in Dinoledi chambers , cave dwellers if anything
Assuming that the evidence supports the religion hypothesis it would show that respect for the dead was present on the genus homo farther back than previously known. There may have also been a religious impulse along with respect for the dead but so far we don't know.
@@forestdweller5581 I know how .uch so many in the evolutionist community would love to eliminate a religious impulse from any hominid except h. sapiens. Fact is, we don't know what these ancient hominids were thinking or feeling. I'll grant that a religious impulse is not immediately discernable and may never be. Some sort of a glimmering of respect for the dead is, however, discernable. And my ok I ion is that taking care of their diad may have given rise to thought on things they didn't understand and thinking a higher being might exist.
The papers I've read on Naledi do suggest ritualistic behaviour at least some sort of funerary practise, otherwise you have to ask yourself why they took the time and effort to drag their dead loved one's into a deep dark cave through narrow twisting passages, without (as far as we know) any means of illuminating the way. None of the remains were disarticulated to suggest being washed in there by flooding or dragged in by predators. So when considering the lengths gone to achieve protection of the remains it could be interpreted in several ways; some type of ancestor worship or preserving the dead in some manner and if you extrapolate that further you could suggest belief in an afterlife. Not saying I believe any of that is the case, just pointing out how you could get there to the "religious" path. The truth is we will never know - ritualistic behaviour / religion the only fact we have is that doing this was clearly important to them, hence the effort they put into doing it.
@@Lionesssa12 Interestingly, though found in caves, "Homo Naledi's curved fingers suggest the species retained an ape-like ability to climb trees while its long thumb points to [...] tool use. Its foot looks v similar to a modern human's, suggesting that it was also efficient at walking upright" - NatGeo. All in all, H. Naledi was a weird one that defies categorization. Would be fascinating to learn more about how life looked for a tree-climbing cave-dwelling far-walking human-brain-shaped chimp/Lucy-brain-sized tool-user competing w/more intellectually advanced and physically imposing relatives. It was like a living portmanteau of the physical characteristics of all our hominin ancestors/cousins rolled into one. Crazy. www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/151006-homo-naledi-human-hands-feet-science-anthropology
Thanks for such wonderfully made production ..SO fascinating ! Love how you move slowly thru each species and subspecies, North. You give my mind space to soak it in....all life here is on a fluid, ever changing course. Our time is Rich in discoveries and sharing ! Thank you tremendously!
Your a left wing Communist... I bet you keep a picture of Joseph Stalin In your wallet
Thanks to you for your calm voice and explanations regarding all the species.. I feel like there's a lot more missing pieces concerning Denisovans✨😌❤️until then take care
So a REAAALLLYYY long story short, there’s been a whole lot 👍
As ever, excellent, valuable work Sir. Thoroughly researched and presented. Thank You so much.
I'm guessing you American
Helps put into perspective how advanced our species was even as far back as the bronze age. Maybe there was a civilization or even multiple, 10,000 years before the bronze age who were just as advanced as bronze age civilizations whose traces remain undiscovered and buried. It is not outside the realm of possibility but we will never know..for now. Awesome content. I wish those little mini humans still existed. I would have liked to have be friends with them. I learned from Tolkien that hobbits are good friends to have lol
Me too! Their SO CUTE!!
@@daffodil815they’ll just get bullied by most humans. You see how we treat each other? 😂😢
I find it hard to believe there were not recently different human species....e,g, the South American humans were isolated for tens of thousands of years....there is a chance that world powers won't all human sub species to be acknowledged
They do still exist
@@1362pctens of thousands of years is not enough time to create a new species, you need at lest half a million years at minimum to create a sub-species, and 1 million years minimum for a new species
Nice job
i wish i had your videos when my adhd brain struggling through first semester of college. your explanations are so much better than my professor who preferred to be lazy and bad mouth his "rival" professor who got a book deal over doing his job.
Great vid. I hadn't heard about Sapiens Idaltu for a while, good to know what's going on with the classification of those remains.
"IN A MODERN DAY ONLY ONE SPECIES OF HUMAN REMAINS" that was hilarious hahaha
That's because there was, and evolution is a Only a theroy. The first person that tells me to my face that we are evolved from Monkeys ain't gonna like my reply. And he is saying about the size of the brain matters well tell that to an ant. Missing link please it's 2022 stop believing these people.
Amazing 👍
1 species? We are just so blended now. That is it.
I remember seeing a 1 hour TV show around 1960 on Nat Geo about some of the archaic human finds of Louis Leake in East Africa. I thought it was great. archeology has come a long way in the last 60 years. I enjoyed this program just as much if not more than that Louis Leake show. It's hard to believe that you do this channel as a sideline. It sounds like you have a PHD in archeology. This is the best show yet. Thanks
how is it that this video doesn't get ten times more views than it currently gets?! your channel is a gem, man, can't believe I get to see this free of charge
It is simple, humans prefer conspiracy theories and other stupid things, those do not need allot of thinking.
Bc it’s not based on facts. It’s based on a theory, THERE STILL IS NO MISSING LINK!
We don’t evolve, we die out.
Adaptation is the truth of truths, we haven’t been on earth for 100s of thousands of years, its ludicrous. It’s a hell of a religion I’ll tell. We see adaptation take place in nature all over!
Right! This was great, well presented and super informative. Imagine what this creator could do with cable channel budget.
I learned more in this 30 minute video than I have watching seasons of cable TV. Well done
I've never heard of these species wow it looks like I learned something new today
Absolutely facinating work and detailed presentation. Enlightening. Thank you.
I’ve often thought prehistoric times was a bit like Middle Earth with all the different human types running around. So I found it particularly amusing that there’s a period called the Muddle in the Middle [Earth]. 😊
So interesting and well put together. Thank you
Fascinating!
Ancestors: are ya winning sons?
Thank you
I find it hard to keep track of which hominid was when and where
It's great to have a video like this as a resource.
Of course a couple of finds and you may have to do, "How Many Species of Humans Were There v.2" lol
But by gum it's an exciting field of research
love the topics you cover. Additionally, love your organization and presentation of the topic. You have a great voice as well, makes it easy to listen and watch. Please keep it up the good work!
by the way I'm new. I just subscribed
This was fascinating.. i love nature but never really thought about us!
Hell yeah, call the bigfoot freak's out! Call out the alien freak's too!
As always, an awesome and very informative video. Someone get this man a medal!
Very informative and a great watch! I wanted to thank you for spending time on "Homo Ergaster" in it's own light instead of just lumping them in with "Homo Erectus!" as a whole sale "species" as many others do! Side by side skull comparisons of these extremely close in time parallel divergent groups shows undeniable differences between them in "Ergaster" having longer more angular faces and an antenuated bun at the back of the skull, which "Homo Erectus" lacks, while the "Erectus" has a more pronounced cheek bone structure as well as a very round head with no antenuated bun or more of a flat skull in the rear. I personally believe "Homo Ergaster" to be the forbearers of "Homo Heidelbergensis" which in turn led to the rise of "Homo Neanderthalensis". The skull affinities between these 3 groups seem pretty apparent, to me that is, in their morphology over time. Using the term "species" for each group could be misconstrued imo. It takes about 1.5 million years for "alopatric speciation" to occur between 2 distinct groups, yet having a common ancestor, where viable offspring that can not reproduce themselves starts to happen. Most, if not all, of these groups of early humans were probably not that long seperated by this length of time imo and the intermingling of genes that occured pushes the "alopatric speciation" clock back to zero hour with each occurence. The term "genus" for us is "Homo" and the names "Neanderthal" or "Sapiens" or "Sapiens Sapiens" considered "species" is all well and good, as long as the muddied term "species" does not infer the inability of intermingling with in the the genus "Homo" .. in my humble opinion! :)
Hi, thank you for creating these kind of videos. I was thinking about your depiction of the homo family tree line. Most of my sources tell me it was h. antecessor as a shared ancestor of h. neanderthalis, h. denisova & h. sapiens. And h. ergaster starting the line of h. antecessor & h. erectus. You seem to attribute less importance to h. antecessor.
I know findings in this field are made all the time, but I was just wondering how you did your research in this messy field of information, and how you decided how to draw the lines, for this video at least.
One problem is that "species" is not an equivalence class, but a distance relation. The relation "is the same species as" is not transitive. It is similar relation to the phrase "is within 5 miles of". You are the same species as a parent, who is the same species as either of his/her parents, and so on all the way back, even to the common ancestor we share with cockroaches. We are slightly different from our children, our parent, our cousins, etc, but we are not different enough to any two humans currently alive to be considered as different species.
This reminds me of my anthropology class. I had to chart out all the known hominids in order from date to region to cranial capacity and various facts about each.
Ya well you voted for Joe Biden so you shouldn't even be commenting
@@noahjohnson2004 you’re corny
@@noahjohnson2004 guess what
@@noahjohnson2004 this is embarrassing, you should be embarrassed.
Unfortunately genetics doesn't really support evolution.
Thanks a million
Great content as usual 👏
Waiting for the sources..
Thanks for the sources in the description 🙏🏾👍🏽
Very good video.
Your documentary is not only educative but also very calming ❤❤
Wonderful work you do. The visuals speak to so many questions that are on that spectrum of evolution - and debate. Keep it coming. So much good teaching skill here!
I’d always been told erectus was our direct ancestor so it’s very interesting to learn otherwise. Good video, I learned a lot from it
Erectus means "standing up". The proper word is sapiens from the Latin verb sapio (:to think) and loquens (from verb loquor : to speak) in 35.000 b.C
"Our direct ancestor"? Speak for yourself, please.
@@100perdido lmao
Maybe your direct ancestor yes 😂
@@vanyakouveli3113 There is nothing wrong with what greensiren said. He had always been told that Homo Erectus was our direct ancestor. There is nothing to correct. Sapiens is NOT our direct ancestor because we ARE Homo Sapiens.
This vídeo was very informative and relaxing, thank you!
Excellent.
As someone who wants to be an archeologist in the future, this was a fun video to watch!
oops that's paleontologist
Yay !
I live in a trailer park, I'm still counting
the $ Pasties $ are cracking me up
A speculation: the co-existence of multiple hominids at the same time with overlapping territories, might have provided the selection pressure that created Homo sapiens as a distinct species. In other words, competition between hominids created the modern human brain.
can you make videos about the first civilisations please, i think the way you make your videos is perfect for a format like that
your quality is amazing
Stefano milo does some good stuff on e.g. the transition from hunter gathering to farming and early civilizations. And there are lots of other history channels. Best not to get people to stretch themselves too thin.
First civilization was in north iraq (Mesopotamia) !
How would he know that? would that not be filled with opinions and inaccurate images?
@@lexusnissian there is scientific evidence for so many things
Im talking about civilisation
Whole empires with big cities like the sumerians for example
Really excellent video: current, measured, reasonable, and avoiding the axe grinding of some paleoanthropologist nerds. Also, very pleasant and calm voice-so much better than all of the irritating robo-voices out there. I felt like I was hearing a great story from an accomplished storyteller. Keep up the good work. It’s always pleasant to experience a pro doing good things.
storytelling is right he can't explain a group of people that resemble the first human beings in Australia
U prolly voted for trump.. what a deplorable
ua-cam.com/video/9NjGO_fku_w/v-deo.html
I concur with your opinion of the narrator. There are many with beautiful speaking voices, who could narrate these videos. Why do they resort to the robo-voices? Are they too cheap to hire a live speaker?
Great Video, except could UA-cam explain to us why, when we click on the Replay Button the Video doesn't play from the beginning and starts from some predetermined Point in the Show?
Tack!