On Calls to Condemn Hamas | Norman Finkelstein Teach-in on Gaza, Israel, and Hamas

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 20

  • @barnabyvonrudal1
    @barnabyvonrudal1 Рік тому +3

    I like trying to read the titles in Norman's bookshelf - so far I've recognized three. 2 on Gaza (of course, lol)

    • @thoughtteaanna6052
      @thoughtteaanna6052 11 місяців тому

      the shelves are curved from the weight of all the knowledge.

  • @nosoblaze5765
    @nosoblaze5765 Рік тому +33

    freedom fighters of gaza can make mistakes and freedom fighters of gaza can be condemned for their mistakes but that cannnot be used to justify the brutalities of the occupation.

    • @IndepenisDay
      @IndepenisDay Рік тому

      Freedom fighters is a wiiiiild term here, laughable

    • @bisratezra8247
      @bisratezra8247 Рік тому

      You call what happened on 7/10 a mistake?!?

    • @nosoblaze5765
      @nosoblaze5765 Рік тому +1

      @@bisratezra8247 no, just some of the civilian casualties that perhaps may have been avoided

    • @nosoblaze5765
      @nosoblaze5765 Рік тому +1

      @@IndepenisDay the term may be wild but it's still accurate though

    • @sebastianporras2440
      @sebastianporras2440 9 місяців тому

      ​@nosoblaze5765 solo tratas de justificar el genocidio que cometio hamas pero muy bien quieres llamar genocidio a lo que hace Israel contra hamas siendo que hamas usa a su propio pueblo como escudos humanos asi de payaso eres ?

  • @TBD3.0
    @TBD3.0 Рік тому

    Sad times we're living in.

  • @empireoflightz
    @empireoflightz Рік тому +5

    This is insane, how the hell can an atrocity not be condemned. How can the murdering of children and babies not be condemned. Whether it's Israelis or Palestinians that do it or anyone else it has to be condemned, otherwise we've lost our humanity!

    • @Goreuncle
      @Goreuncle 5 місяців тому

      It's not that simple.
      Imagine that a group of Jewish prisoners managed to escape the gas chambers and started killing all Germans in the area, regardless of whether they were civilians or military, regardless of whether they supported the nazis or not.
      Would you condemn them? On what grounds?
      Do you also belong to a group targeted for extermination or do you belong to a group that's allowing it to happen?
      There are no innocents in Israel, Israelis either support the occupation/genocide or fail to stop it, I imagine that this is the way Hamas fighters see it.
      In order to accuse others of committing atrocities, you first have to make sure that you haven't committed any or haven't allowed others to commit them, by staying silent.

  • @russturner2490
    @russturner2490 Рік тому +4

    They will not let there be a peaceful resolution. You are not absolute bearer of truth.

  • @jasonrose6288
    @jasonrose6288 Рік тому +3

    Would have been very skilful at self rationalizing being a kapo!

    • @francescogulli576
      @francescogulli576 7 місяців тому

      You should educate yourself on the history of the region, before making idiotic remarks alluding to the holocaust

    • @jasonrose6288
      @jasonrose6288 7 місяців тому

      @@francescogulli576 Highly educated, thanks.