If Goku Black Was GOTEN? - Dragon Ball Super
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 січ 2025
- A Lone Warrior of Hope. An eradicated future. A menace wearing the face of a friend. The story of the Future Trunks Saga will never be the same- as Trunks is pursued into the past by GOTEN BLACK.
With beautiful, picture-perfect artwork by the one and only Ash, a lineup of talented voice actors, the folks at WarpStar bring you the definitive story of Goten Black.
First off, I know uploads from me are a long time coming. Which I apologize for. Ash and I conceptualized the story of Goten Black back in January of 2021, and this is the culmination of a year of work. Hopefully, this new endeavor was worth the wait to those who actually watch this channel.
(Cassandra Cain in DB is not canceled btw merely on hold for a spell.)
Discord: / discord
Special Thanks!
Voices (In order of appearance)
Future Trunks - Anon
Vegeta - Trevor Wilson / omegamallet
Goku - Devilkicksanji / devilkicksanji2
Goten Black - Anon
Beerus - Acethewindrider / acethewindrider
Whis - Chris Burns / chrisburnsva
Bulma - ErinGrey / eringreyvo
Gohan - Joshua Waters / tunnelva
Kid Trunks - Luna - / @starryskipper
Kid Goten - ErinGrey / eringreyvo
Music Credits
Dragonball Z - Theme of Tapion (HQ Epic Cover) - PokeMixr92
Original Video - • Dragonball Z - Theme o...
Creator Channel - / slhtubit92
I like how Goten was feeling so edgy that he developed a deep British accent
That's just because of the tea
If this was Goku black's og voice he would be flooded by fan girls
So are you saying that British people are evil
@@Saiyzar already is pal. Already is.
Black would have way more
Goku to Goten: son are you on drugs? Did you join some British street gang?
Goten: i am the apprentice of zamasu I am creating a utopia
Zamasu: In summary yes, a Brittish street gang...
But on a...
wider... scale.
Future Trunks: Well *EXCUSE ME* for not having access to training with the Gods and gravity chambers!
Bulma coulda made a gravity tho. And the HTC was still around
@@Black_Knight_-BK- no yajirobi stated that the androids destroyed it after finding him and korin
Well EXCUUUSE ME Prince!
@@Slimmthekidd bulma was still alive though so i dont see ur point
@@ithoughtso.7016 Still no Hyperbolic Time Chamber lmao
I always thought Goten Black was weird but a very interesting and unique twist for DBS. This is amazing!
The black part is not necessary since they call zamasu goku black because he is goku with black gi on.
@@tgjurassic9229this man is not black
@@Nombrenooriginal indeed
Hey have you ever heard of generational defenders?
I don’t understand how this idea is “silly”. The idea that a version of Goten growing up and becoming evil is kinda interesting.
This thumbnail art is so freaking cool!!!! I'm so hyped to see this story!!
HI PROFESSOR!!!!
Professor hiiii
Bott
@@gregkareem9824 u r a bot
Can you please make part two please
If Goku Black was Goten, then that would make DBS more dark
Back then when the Theory of Goten being Goku Black was a thing, *I used to believe* that Goten was indeed born in that timeline but it was hidden from all that Android mess because Chi-Chi didn´t want to lose another son the hands of evil robots. And since technically Future Gohan did die because of Trunks in Goten´s perspective, Goten would grow into a Saiyan blinded by rage and darkness wanting to destroy everything in his path.
I rly wanted the title to be
"What if goten was black"
Honestly, Goten Black would have been so much better than Goku Black because of the friendship Goten and Trunks had. So much interpersonal drama, Trunks feeling betrayed by his former friend and later trying to find a way to save his former friend, ultimately being forced to kill him, because except for his body nothing is left of his former friend
Unfortunately is impossible, if Goten existed in future timeline, Androids and Cell incident would be very different, I doubt Gohan, Goten and Trunks would struggle too much
@@voidx6782 It is not impossible. The Zamasu and and Goku that was Goku black was from the future of the present timeline post Android Saga so if it was just slightly further in the future it COULD have been Future Goten.
@@weathermangohanssj4 That timeline is the normal timeline but the only difference is Goku dead and everything else is the same, Gohan and Vegeta are there, and most likely Goten and Trunks aren't going to fight.
Goku black doesn't come from the future timeline he comes from the main timeline after like a year then he takes over Goku's body killes goten and chichi then with the time ring goes to the future time line hope that helps@@voidx6782
No what if something like what happened of the origin of history trunks happened. Where the heroes unexpectedly fell to a greater threat and Goku wasn't there ? I don't know how Gohan would possibly be defeated but he doesn't have to. What if Gohan sacrificed himself years later even further in the future than future trunks timeline but in a branch of the main timeline. Trunks and Goten weren't prepared and trunks sacrifice his life to save Goten being the bro he is to Goten mirroring future Gohan sacrificed himself for future trunks in the other timeline. Then Goten goes insane or zamasu recruits Goten as a perfect vessel in their quest across the timelines. If anyone or everyone actually tried to make some fiction on the level of a studio flesh it out it could be fire. What if Goten didn't listen to piccolo during the fight with Buu and went ssj2 against buu but got everyone killed and then Goten went insane or zamasu took Goten or his body as a vessel. Lots of possiblity
I love that friendly shot at MasakoX I bet he would get a chuckle out of it
Much love to him, the R and R crew, and the folks at DB Multiverse!
@@warpstar9421 when is part two
@@BlitzøBucko-e9jikr damn it's been a year 😂
It's always great to see another dragon ball what ifer with talent! The way you've written Goten Black and how he knows next to nothing about the events of super is all very intriguing, makes me wonder what kind of timeline he comes from and what his issues with Future Trunks are, especially with how he prefers to focus on Trunks rather than Fight Goku. It's very interesting to see how you've turned this originally silly idea into a well thought out and serious story. I also like you've expanded this scenario from just Goku Black being Goten to a whole rewrite of the sags based around the concept! I like how Vegeta took Future Trunks into the time chamber, which is something they should of done in canon, and not only that Gohan's been training in this timeline but you've also brought him into the future, giving him time to shine while keeping out Goku and Vegeta, avoiding what MasakoX calls "The Goku and Vegeta Show"(Which I fully agree with him on, those two have gotten so much of the spotlight I'm surprised their not sunburnt). I'm excited to see more, but no rush or pressure of course!
I Also just finished your "Cassandra Cain in Dragon Ball" Series, I enjoyed it as well and I hope you plan on continuing that series, but I understand if that's a long while if you do, especially if you want to focus on this series first. Either way, I'll definitely comment more of my thoughts on that series later, just wanted to comment on this first.
I look forward to this guys growth, his skill is really good.
Ik bro
Couldn't have said it better myself.
Technically he should still be named Goku black but fair enough
"Dragonball fans only want 2 things: Raditz to be good and Goku to be evil"
LMAO you didn't lie
Okay I'm sold. I want more of this! Will be waiting for part 2.
When is part two
☠️
in our dream
goten black went back in time to stop warpstar from making part 2
Very solid! Happy to keep helping out as Goku! ^^
I love the changes you did to the characters, like Trunks keeping the lavender and having an open jacket/better SSJ2 look and Gohan with his long childhood hair.
Vegeta using the HTC with Trunks, thank you. Why they didn't do this originally is beyond me, but I'm glad you guys did it. I'm hyped for God Trunks.
Goten Black is interesting, and I can't wait to hear how he came to be.
Gohan and Trunks in the future, almost like old times. Can't wait to see more, Warp.
Agreed!
That's how goten black hair should've looked like.
I mean.. what's interesting of goten black?
This is amazing!!! I love the change you did to the story and characters, it gives Gohan some more build to his character. If you are making a part 2 I can't wait, keep up the good work. I also love that Gohan comes to the future instead of Goku and Vegeta
Gohan Looks Different Haircut Wise I Don't Think Present Gohan Would Even Consider Adopting That Hairstyle
That was amazing, sorry I couldn't catch the full premiere but this was so good and everyone involved did so good.
There's not that many what if you tubers that have good narration aside from dragon ball content, you are one of those good narrators.
I love the redesigns lmao Gohan with long hair as an adult seems amazing imo
Edit: finished the video, the production quality was amazing, and the story has so many plot twists that made this 20x better to enjoy, I hope there’s a Part 2, and if there is I can’t wait for it!!
One of the most well done “What If?”s I’ve seen, I loved this first part. I love the reconnection between Trunks and Gohan, and the reveal that Gohan came with Trunks back to the future was stellar. Vegeta and Trunks training together was also really well done. VAs and art were all stellar. (Goten Black’s voice was personally my favorite, but every VA did an incredible job.).
Overall, amazing job, I can’t wait to see where this story goes!! ❤️❤️
This would have been such a great way of showing Gohan's growth before the ToP and people would have been less pissed about his Beast form.
At first you had my interest but now, you have my attention, can't wait to see where you're going with this, especially with having gohan come to the future as well
Amazing video, absolutely LOVED it. Great story, great artwork. Thank you!!
I forgot to say in my previous comment the things I loved here. I apologize for this long comment.
Goku Black was so inconsistent with his power, but Future Goten isn't quite on that Goku/ Vegeta tier, but that's not a problem because they have been written out of the fight. It leaves Gohan and Future Trunks some spotlight. 2 longterm fanfavorites, reunited.
I liked how Goku immediately called out Future Goten's accent, before the genocidal tendencies.
You nailed Kid Trunks and Goten. THANK YOU! You kept the Mario Kart reference from the Manga to! and kept the Pilaf gang's gags to a minimum.
Bulma's maternal instincts and sneakiness paid off. You kept the arc from feeling bloated with too many characters by having the Gods act how they should, like i totally can see Beerus dragging Goku to U10 because he doesn't trust him to stay put unsupervised.
Simply having Futre Trunks mentioning how Future Gohan would mention longing to be a scholar makes the transition feel so much better. Like now it makes me happy knowing Gohan is truly happy and this really is what he always wanted. It retroactively makes Future Gohan even more tragic though leading to a bittersweet, but overall wholesome moment. (also Gohan simply forgetting to cut his hair when he throws himself back into training along with the other stuff just feels right and not pandering.)
I loved how you kept 18's moment in. And had Vegeta and Future Trunks in the HTC. It's parallel to his last visit, but now Future Trunks can truly soak in the change in his Father.
I honestly hope you do something with explaining Super Mai within the context of the arc, at least her meeting Future Trunks.
It also might be cool if they unsealed Buu's cocoon and gained another ally. What if Future Yajirobe becomes Majin Buu's Bestie as a Hercule stand in. They share enough traits, heck Saiyan Saga Yajirobe felt like a proto Hercule. during the fillers where he was taking credit for Goku's accomplishments.
Gohan is in the Great Saiyaman suit, which means he is going full super hero. It's so appropriate! but for some reason, he is wearing his Saiyan Saga headband. Interesting call back.
Also Gotenks might foreshadow that Gohan and Trunks will fuse. If neither of them can transform into Super Saiyan God/SS Blue, perhaps their fusion would.
Thank you for the nice comments! We enjoy the interaction and speculation. We have lots of plans for Future Mai! Also Gohan’s headband is just meant to be his Saiyaman Bandana tied in a different way. Thank you for watching!
@@warpstar9421 Well I think you are doing a good job on this so far. I am really looking forward to more with this series since I have put a lot of thought into reworking this arc from several angles including this theory. Thank you for replying to me (it means a lot) and I apologize for my wordy comments.
I love this, this is so cool I had a huge smile on my face almost the whole time.
I really like the Changes you did to the Story and some of the Character Designs! This story really is starting out amazing!
After watching this I immediately checked out the rest of your videos and I gotta say I'm a fan of your work, I look forward to watching more from you in the future!
This was really well done, can't wait to see the story continue
This absolutely brilliant! I freaking love what you’ve done with this concept and I can’t wait to see more of it
The art and story are so good, I wonder if goten will be spared since gohan came with trunks and if he will help goten back to the path of good.
This was pretty good I like how you kept if interesting and fixed most people issues with characters (despite me not minding Trunks Blue hair, and Gohan keeping his hair short.) I also like how you took the Manga Gohan concept of him training with Piccolo after the black arc bur instead moved it to after resurrection F and instead of him copying hid father and never taking off the gi it's just him forgetting to cut his hair it makes it kinda funny.
Also I'm assuming that Trunks is gonna remember what Vegeta told him true power comes from when Mai and Gohan are like almost gonna get well ya know and is gonna finally turn SSG Trunks and then later on Goku and Vegeta will show up with Shin and Gowasu or with Beerus and Whis in order to take the time ring and potara away from Goten "Black"
Side note: in the intro when you kept putting the smiling Goten pic I was ☠ lol I can't wait for more if this what if.
This is the best what if channel the whole editing and dialogue is perfect it’s so well edited and tells the story perfectly
10/10 highly entertaining even knowing nothing about dragon ball. love the swooshy cape effect at the end!!!!!!!!
THIS STORY IS ... GREAT I LOVE IT
Goku: you've done some pretty messed up things son! You're grounded!
Zamazu ( in gotens body ): ...what?
I hope that when all is said and done that the Time Patrol takes both Future Trunks AND Future Goten (maybe he has a redemption story arc or gets another chance) forcing them into a buddy cop adventure as there divine probation for messing with the timelines.
I love that Gohan is going into the Future with Trunks because of how poetic it is and how Gohan missed out on U6 so it's like he was saved for this. I can't wait to see how far Gohan's training has come and his interactions with Future Goten are going to be like.
It would be cool if you touched upon the Future Z-Warriors currently in Otherworld for backup because there are ways they could arrive and assist from Baba to Namekian Dragon Balls, etc. Besides, I bet they all have had a ton of adventures and gotten super strong. If you think about it, BoG Beerus' first stop was King Kai's planet so it's possible they already have met the GoD before the Supreme Kai died.
I wonder if Future Trunks learned Instant Transmission from Supreme Kai in this? Now that would come in handy for him because he would regain access to Namek, could recruit Future Dende, and get some Earth Dragon Balls to help restore the devastation. I could totally see Gohan suggest this to Trunks.
Do you have discord because I thought long and hard about the missed opportunities this arc more than once and would love to have a discussion with you guys?
That's definitely an interesting thought on what happens with F. Trunks and F. Goten.
I'm glad Gohan's got a lot more love here, like having him logically train right after Frieza messed him up and being involved here (which fits poetically well).
Wouldn't it be the Kai Kai that Trunks could learn, instead of the Instant Transmission? Kai Kai is a better version of Instant Transmission, not requiring focus to lock on to someone.
I would like for Gohan to make those suggestions, because it would finally give back the Dragon Balls after so long. Plus, the ending in the original should definitely be overwritten with a much better one.
It's been a soft little rewrite of the arc, and I'm looking forward to what they do next.
@@leisurelyindex Glad you like it. I just think in the Gods' perspectives, they are equally at fault for messing with time and dished out the same punishment. Plus the irony is so within Dragon Ball's wheel house.
Oh man, if F Trunks knew Kai Kai (Godly Transportation), he could go almost anywhere, even Otherworld like Kami and Baba have done. That would open so many doors, but that would be a rabbit hole.
If they get the Dragon Balls back on Earth, Future Trunks could wish his mom back to life. Future Bulma's ressurection would be the first wish in decades. That would make a better ending.
I feel the same way.
@@JakeSmith-mq5dc
Tell you what. You ever heard of Manga Adventures?
He does have a Discord server, if the offer interests you. I've joined it and it's been quite enioyable.
@@leisurelyindex What is Manga Adventures? do you have a link because I can't find it?
This is amazing, just found ur content from Salads cord, I make what ifs too and seeing a new whatifer with this quality is amazing, glad ur here to help make the community better.
I see potential, subbing.
I look forward to your growth my guy 👍
And that DBZ: attack of the Saiyans dialogue edit is just "Muach"
Super saiyan rose
Very excited to see
Hi geeks
Goten with a Scottish accent is something I wasn't prepared for
Holy the art was and edit was godly you got yourself a subscriber
I was hoping Goku black was Goten. Would had been so much better.
What life events would twist Goten. Even reckoning his birth and developing this orphan child.
I still love Gohan's hair. They give me nostalgia to Classic badass kid gohan. Pls update about this series.
This is what happens when fathers are absent from there sons lives
the worst part is youre not wrong
This was really good I hope to see more of you in the future!
Very interresting ending. The battle of the Hybrid-Saiyans.
Wow Awesome "What If" story with Goten Black. My boy Gohan growing his hair out is epic. The voice actors are on point!!! Hopefully you keep the story going!!!
An absolute masterpiece! I really love this
This is astonishing what if story
I subscribe you
I can’t wait for part 2
Congratulations man
You have a 1k subscribers
this is the best version of this what if I've seen
Hey this was really good, you should make more like this. I love the way you made it how old fashioned games used to do alternate storylines
WOW THE END SOOO GOOD PLS DO MORE PARTS
I love this video SO SO much... I've been thinkin' about what how things wouldve ended up if GOTEN was Goku Black instead for so long and thought of how much cooler and interesting it wouldve been, but could never quite think of anything different and unique happening if it happened, until you made this video! This is awesome. I also love the voice acting you all did and the script was well-made! GREAT job! As a matter of fact, i liked this so much, i actually even prefer it to the original way the arc was handled to be honest! I also LOVE the fact the you made Future Trunks' hair purple again!! Also also.... LOVE the fact that you made Gohan's hair long and cool-looking this time! It's a HUGE improvement!! And i really like how you fleshed out Adult Gohan's character where ended up balancing out training and work! PROPS. And then ontop of that, you had it so that Gohan went WITH Trunks to the future?? 👀
I'm subscribing.
I almost imagine that Bulma asked Chichi to go to the future with Trunks so she could ground the evil Goten.
ash brought me here and tbh I don’t regret it, it’s amazing how you guys managed to make an amusing theory into an amazing storyline, great job!
Alright! It's here!
It came out so great!
Damn I really wanted another part to this!
Absolutely FAN-FLIPPING-TASTIC-
"Dragon ball fans only want two things, Raditz to be good and Goku to be evil"
Guilty as charged >:)
GeeksforFun brought me, and I love the respect goten is getting. Also, sigma male gohan design and purpose 🐐
Goku, Gohan, Trunks and Vegeta's voice is perfect!!!💯❤🎉
I didn't even think about the dynamic between Trunks and Goten this thumbnail fully sells how cool this idea would.
Goten being a hero turned villains having to face his childhood best friend, family friends and his own dad
Ayooooo! I want part 2 lol holy hell!
Okay, this is damn good. I need past 2 asap 😂
to save goku?
@@bobherobrine3415 goku dies
Let’s go! Make part 2 happen I promise it won’t be a waste of time, everybody will like it
Yo this NEEDS a second part.
The image of this version of gohan and future trunks... I love it it works so damn well
Bro this is a amazing idea I’m glad you did it
THE GREAT SAIYAMAN!??!??
OK WE NEED PART 2 ASAP
Well done on the amazing video part 2 soon? 10/10
Omg and Gohans Hair!!! I love the small design changes so much
This makes sense, goten could be vengeful because goku never paid much attention to him and he gotmmade and wanted revenge
i read the title as "if goten was black"
PLEASE MAKE A PART 2
This is pretty good! Why the writers didn't take this route with the Future Trunks stuff I'll never know
Because goten never existed
@@the_real_idoit8166 that doesn't really make sense Goku black came from a different timeline so wouldn't Goten black be from a different timeline
@@dongold1964 Yeah. Goku/Goten Black would be from a completely different timeline, and one where Goten was still able to be born.
the thumbnail goes so hard
I never realized how cool of a dynamic that would be actually
You’re so underrated
You know it’s bad when goku says, I heard ur pretty strong
Please finish this one! It’s so good.
Bro, I love this thumbnail. It automatically made me say "Oh shit" without even watching the video.
I can't wait for more. You got a new subscriber
I hope to see a part two too this alternative black saga.
This is what it shouldve been. The emotional pull of Goku seeing Goten and Vegeta not pulling punches and putting Goku down for not fighting all out. Then unveiling the history of how Goten turned like that having his body stolen from Zamasu, then Vegeta wanting to be more separate from Goku showing more of their rivalry. Trunks losing and getting beat by an evil Goten would make Vegeta mad his son is weak and train like crazy. The emotional distress in Dbz is whats missing in super
Damn i liked your gohan design and him coming along at the end with his great saiyaman custom was awesoms. Mind you. I aint even a gohan fan. But his long hair made a difference for me. I was honestly expecting goten and trunks though
I actually like Goten being Goku Black so much more
We need a part 2, I don't care how long it takes, I just want a part 2 the same quality as this one.
Keep up the grate work dude I can't wait for part 2
MY GOD I WOULD HAVE LOVED GOHANS HAIR TO STAY LIKE THAT
This is so good I want to see a continuation to this
I wish more people knew about you
Can’t wait for the next one and see how things pan out
U half to continue this soon plsssssssssssss this was so good and i need morrrrrrrrrre
Goten Black: IT'S NOT A PHASE DAD!!
awsome thumbnail!
Nice artwork man keep it up
Shame this never got a part 2 would've enjoyed the fight
Voice acting is fucking on point
Bro, please bless us with a part 2. This was 🔥🔥🔥.