Tug of War Duet by Charis Dwire
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 жов 2024
- Sheet Music: www.charismusi...
If you know my family, you know we come up with some interesting “what ifs.” The idea for this song came from my brother, Nathan Dwire. It is meant to picture a game of tug-of-war between two trombones. I am so thankful to Joseph and Sam for being willing to try this out and make it come to life.
Trombone: Joseph Greene and Sam Robertson
I’m surprised I saw this this early. This feels like a video that would have been up for like, 10 years by now.
Fr
Same
Frfr
Yeah
for real!
For a second I thought they would link their slides at the beginning xD
same lol
That’s why I clicked lol
how would they do that
@@tyronium2 the slide is detachable. as you can see in the last seconds of the video, the side can be completely removed.
@@pomelo9518it’s still impossible. The slide isn’t open at the top.
Ah, my favorite musical genre: Trombone Nonsense™.
LOL🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
As they played multiple notes in the beginning without moving, I realized I have no idea how a trombone works
I didn't either until I tried to start writing this😅
You can change notes within the harmonic series with your embouchure on all brass instruments, and the slide does the same thing as valves, changing what harmonic series you are playing in
You can play a few different notes by changing the way you vibrate your lips.
Ever seen a bugle?
@@jerbear7952 - Let's be nice; no need to be mean, but yes, a bugle is the perfect example of a brass instrument that can play multiple notes despite having no valves.
I’m pretty sure it’s against the Geneva Convention to play trombone directly at another person’s face like that.
why would that be against the Geneva convention
@@OffBrandPluto it's a joke pal
@@olibolton4633 yeah, but even a joke has to make sense.
@@aramisortsbottcher8201 the joke is that playing trombone right at someone's face is very very loud, maybe even unpleasant. The joke is that some people might find it so unpleasant it's painful, comparable to torture. Something which yeh Geneva convention would ban. The joke makes sense.
@@olibolton4633 blud explained it
I love when I discover people still making Old UA-cam Content in 2024 and not every thing is hyper scripted, and edited within an inch of It's life.
Same, it's like a breath of fresh air ngl
@@RAESP1TE i keep listening to this its just so good
Usually the scripted stuff is fine, as long as in the end it’s entertaining and isn’t harmful. Heavy editing can get exhausting after a while tho
UA-cam Poop will never ocmpletely die!
Now hold on, I need those 3 hour video essays on how Kataras hair loopies secretly reveal the ending of the whole show in episode 1.
And yet when I yank a trombonist's slide it's "destructively rude" and "extremely inappropriate behavior"
And yet when I yank my...
You are persecuted
They clearly consented to the pulling of each other’s slides smh my head😒😒😒😒
You can only yank if you too have a trombone
"Destructively rude" is so specific, there has to be a story
Ah, the trombone, an instrument with the perfect balance of beauty and comedy.
For some reason I can only read this with the drunk Orson Welles voice in my head. "Ahhh the French!"
@@Fimbleshanks I never heard of that video until now, thanks for the laugh!
About a year ago I told my sister, "Hey I've got an interesting arranging challenge for you. But you'll need to learn how trombones work."
Twelve months later, she's expertly turned that idea into a viral video! Congrats sis! 😄
I'm not musically intelligent. What makes it possible for the slides to move in unison and opposite and still be... not discordant (is that what I'm trying to say)?
Each position of the trombone has multiple pitches available. They can change their mouth shape to get different pitches within each position. This is written in Ab major, which I found was the best key to be able to make the pitches from opposite positions harmonize well together. It was definitely a learning curve for me as I am definitely not a brass player!😅
“I am not a brass player “
proceeds to make Trombone history.
@@yonatan62 I had some great friends and teachers who took the time to explain a lot of things to me. I've still never actually personally played a trombone...I probably should just to say I have 😅
@@musical_chairs15 It's a pretty easy instrument to start on. The embouchure isn't difficult. Heck, I once picked one up (well, a sackbut really, but same as a trombone, only smaller) and played accompaniment to my band for ten minutes. When the trombonist said, "I didn't know you played the trombone!" I had to answer, "I don't!" (To be fair, I did play Eb horn for a month or so when I was in the fourth grade. That might have helped.)
Fun composition, amusing performance. Thanks. :)
This the kind of video that would pop up on your feed in 10 years
Exactly
it popped up on my list me already were expecting it to be 8 to 10 years old
this feels like something a Disney movie would have used in a scene where the characters are hiding from each other or doing tug of war
Or Jackie Chan 😅
Idea for new sport: Trombone fencing!
🤣love this!
If you sat in front of me in band class you would know all boners already do this lol
You both have to get a hit, and blast a note before they have the chance to counterattack
I’d love to see it!
parry this you filthy casual
My orange cat's two braincells fighting for third place:
This is such an interesting concept, and a catchy song, too. So, now I'm trying to think of any other instruments whose natural movement could let you "duel" like this.
The best I've thought of so far are a pair of string players, sitting closely enough that their bows are just barely staying out of one another's way (which would look kind of like a saw); or two people playing mallet percussion instruments, and either "crossing swords," or trying to avoid doing exactly that.
But yes, the trombone is special. It's much cooler than a lot of people give it credit.
Smart and clever performance. Simple, memorable fun tune that’s stuck in my head. I love it.
Force a whole orchestra to provide back up.
Have 2 halfs of the orchestra behind each trombone lmao
I'll be happy to see this pop back up in my recommended in ten years, can't believe this wasn't made in like, 2012. Feels straight like old youtube content
It's kinda funny how many of the good candid videos of music are 2012 band kids doing something entertaining.
There have been hordes of comments like this on around half the videos I've watched in the last week. That's the point where you should ask if maybe it's not an "old UA-cam" thing. This is just a normal ass video; you don't need to assign something so arbitrary to it. Just let it be what it is.
The first four notes are like the start of Mario Kart or other racing games. Love that!
It goes back to horse racing and bugles that don't have any valves. If you just change your embrasure, you can blow a set series of notes. Bugle calls just use those notes.
@@johndodd7870(embouchure 😊)
This is an idea that can only work specifically on a trombone due to its build and thats wonderful.
This would make a good, military cartoon march.
Great composition, now I just need a trombone and a friend.
Sad trombone
This gives off the same aura as those videos that came from the past and suddenly become so famous in a distant future
this is why trombone is best instrument
Awesome! Reminds me of Der Spiegel, a violin duet attributed to Mozart where the score is one page, one violinist playing right-side up and the other playing upside-down!!
Thank you for reminding me of mirror duets. I once played one - great fun! (The one I tried can be done with flute and violin, if the violinist takes the orientation that ranges below middle C).
With a little internet searching, I found that there are 4 mirror duets that were attributed to Mozart (though modern scholarship thinks they pre-date Mozart). Bach wrote similar pieces, called crab canons (because crabs walk backwards as well as forwards) or table canons (because the musicians stand on either side of the table).
This feels like a video posted in 2014 in all the best ways
The slide at the end was amazing
Just played this duet with a friend at a concert yesterday. Super fun would recommend for other trombonists
Love this! So glad other people can enjoy it!
Aaah, love me some good instrument silliness. And extra good when it involves trombones. They hold a special place in my heart as I used to play when I was a kid, and my dad (as well as a few other extended family members) still play to this day.
Such an iconic instrument that looks crazy the moment I step back and look at it objectively.
This has such a classic UA-cam vibe to it.
This video really reads like 2012 UA-cam, and man am I here for it! Honestly the tomfoolery in this video is off the charts and I love that.
the fact that this isn’t a 10 year old video and was actually just released 9 days ago makes me so happy
The fact that people are still creating these short videos and that they will inevitably end up in someone’s recommended in 10 years or so (if we make it that far) is strangely comforting
This feels like a 2008 youtube video & I mean that in the best way possible.
I remembered each slide position of the trombone was used to play multiple notes... but this was a visual example of when trombonist must and can get by with not moving the slide to change the pitch of the trombone! Wow!
Hello person viewing this in 9 years when it randomly blows up
I think it must have already been 9 years then, it feels like it's already getting a lot of attention :)
I was about to comment that as well I have the feeling it will get viral in a few years ^_^
Ok, for a song based on keeping the trumpets ends overlapping each other without moving as the performer, that synced and sounded REALLY GOOD!!
This gonna blow up in 15 years
This has inspired me to joust with my trombone. Thank you.
This is such a clever idea and the arranging knowledge that must have gone into this is insane. I should try to convince two of my trombone friends to play this
Truly a 10 years later moment
This is what UA-cam should be like. Forget MrBeast, PewDiePie, etc. We need more QUALITY content like this.
The coordination between the two is amazing!
Best trombone battle I have seen 😂
Remember when youtube was just full of this stuff? I love that people are still making lovable content. algorithm can't kill creativity! :D
This is utterly amazing, deserves to go viral so everyone can witness this masterpiece
So fun! Fabulously done.
This song feels like a shitpost from the 2010’s and yet it’s not a shitpost and it’s actually very good holy shit
oh my gosh this is so cool !! its not only a composition but also a performance. and also the performance (as in the constraints of the game) informs the composition and vice versa waaohhh
also i thought this was a reupload or something but it turns out its uploaded by the actual composer heck yeah instant sub !!
I go to school with the composer. She’s crazy talented and I’m excited that her work is getting popular. Interestingly enough, she’s a violinist and pianist, not a brass person at all. I find it funny that her most popular composition is for trombone. 😂
You see, this is what I want to see on youtube
Can't wait for this to recommend to everyone several years from now.
the way his slide came off at the end😂
see you guys in 10 years
This piece feels so whimsical, like something out of an old disney cartoon or something like that
Love how they get into a "fighting stance" just before starting
This is a masterpiece that will transcend and outlast the popularity of UA-cam in the future.
The trombones in the back of the middle school band
Pleasantly surprised with an early arrival, and a well-made performance! Very nice.
i miss read the post date as 8 years ago and totally believed it but nope 8 days! also this is really cool
Q) What is the practical range of a bass trombone?
A) About 20 yards if you have a good arm.
I'm a trombone player and I thought they were gonna link the little spit valve hooks and actualy tug of war.
This feels like something from an old cartoon like Tom & Jerry. Not just the music but the concept itself. Lots of talent on display here!
This is going up there with the A-train sax battle video for me. I'll be coming back to this for years to come for sure
This feels like it should’ve been made 12 yrs ago or smth.
Can we appreciate the fact that this was arranged so the filmer knew exactly where to sit?
This is both genius and hilarious! Clever writing and great performance!!
The Mario-cart sounding "one two three go" at the beginning already got me
This is awesome... Also, this video absolutely BLASTED on this channel. Like THOUSANDS of times of average views. That's crazy
See you all in 5 years when the algorithm invites us to return
Youtbe algorythms bringing me this awesome creation in the middle of the night thank you!
This is a trust exercise among trombonists
Whenever I have to think of contrary motion I'll think of 2 dudes trombones never letting a gap of air settle between them. So thanks for the visual!
Even if the instruments aren't linked together, this is pretty fucking cool
Looks like something that would be in an episode of the three stooges. Sounds like it too.
You could turn this into a pretty funny slapstick routine, I think.
This is so fun! Works visually, fresh idea, great tune!
Woow! Thank you for the birthday present. Was posted on my birthday. Also it's adorable and fun to watch the video, especially the ending. that was fun!
This is so cool, what a clever idea! To make it actually have an interesting harmony and melody too seems impressive, although I can’t say I know much about playing brass instruments so maybe the math and physics would predict that you should be able to harmonize notes played by moving one direction with notes played by moving an equal amount the opposite direction.
The insane talent that goes into something like this is amazing to me.
this is what performance art means dude
Someone mentioned that this feels like a video filmed 10 years ago and I definitely agree with them. Leaving my comment here and hoping I'll revisit this video in 10 years.
this is so funny cute and cool ppl dont know how easy hard it is to play trombone (I witched to Sax) so to be able to change tunes without sliding too little or too hard let alone not hit each other with the handle face to face like that, is quite a lovely start to my day actually. those are heavy and also need to be constantly on top of lubricating the slider and unfort the emptying of the spit valve lol. So if anyone heres a Tromber Keep it up :D
Its seriously the easiest instrument ive ever learned. You learn seven positions and about 4 basic mouth shapes. Accuracy can be wildly off in most cases and still sound fine. It took me two hours to learn and at the end I was operating the slide with my right foot. Now getting good at it is different but still one of the easiest imo.
cool
@@jerbear7952 i never said it wasn't easy either but its a challenge because of the weight and size. what makes it hard is positioning the slid to the right notes because theres no way to tell, only by ear is what I'm saying also the condition of the instrument matters too. I switched because I kept pinching my fingers, thats the major part of it that sucks mainly tbh but again i started back in elementary school i preferred the sax to me the sax was easier and better
This video is giving me 2012 vibes. I feel like this would have been posted years ago.
Thank you for this beautiful piece and performance! 🎉
That was so creative! And catchy! And like another commenter said, this video reminds me of "old UA-cam" before ads, monetization, heavy editing, etc took over! Kudos
As a trombonist, I fully approve of this video. And, it is true that EVERY trombonist has lost a slide at least once, though that tends to stop happening as one matures with the instrument.
0:12 um.. oh! My headphones aren't on my head
This really feels like a 10 years ol video lol
Now I'll probably see this comment in 10 years and remember this masterpiece lol
Charis!! This is so cool! Congrats on writing such an awesome piece!
I am so proud to be a trombonist
When you are face to face with your buddy in a car:
really creative idea for a song and i think its great
How is this only 10 days old and not 10 years lol
this is amazing playing, genuinely glad i got to see this early
Not only is this delightful, But it's also a really interesting lesson in embouchure.
How they didnt laugh is beyond me. But they were amazing! In my experience, its pretty hard to maintain such a good tone like that. Like all jokes aside, they sounded amazing!
360k views isnt enough for this masterpiece
That is so fantastic. I can't believe this seems like a first. Very clever. I agree binding them together would add to the experience.
The vin diagram would look cool animated, the lighting doesn't do it justice. Awesome job.
I love fun silly things like this, the world needs more simple happiness
This was very clever and I love it.
here before we get reccomended this in 4 years