I hate it when people call Starfield mid tier. Personal opinions can vary, but I think it is definitely below mid. Every aspect of the game is below what I would expect from an average game.
Yeah so many people said it's 7/10 or 6/10 but that's ultra generous. Taking everything into account it's more of a 4.5 /10 at best. If Starfield came out in 2013 maybe I could give it a 6/10.
The progression (regression really) from Fallout 3, to 4 to 76 makes me think the last good ES game was Skyrim, and that's being generous I know. They'll try to make the game "xxx's times bigger than Starfield!!!!11!" but bigger doesn't equal better, and that creaking engine can't handle it. I don't care if they come out with Creation Engine 3.0, it will have the same jank, the same and new bugs, and way too many loading screens or some other "watch our animation, we are very proud of it" moments that happen in their games. Think the real talent has left the building at Bethesda.
@@amandahuginkiss6868And Skyrim was already kind of a regression compared to Morrowind and Oblivion even if it improved on certain other things and it's a good game overall. But IMO many people view Skyrim through very thick nostalgia glasses. Bethesda was already lagging behind other big developers back then but at this point their game design is hilariously outdated.
Wait, I'm confused by this comment so because he sounds like someone you grew up with, that's the reason why you know his review is honest and legit? What? It's just a very confusing read, maybe the context is lost or something.
I think he sounds like the UA-camr by the name of shacamma, I might be spelling it wrong, but it's a really bizarre name anyway, maybe there's a K in there somewhere.
@@5226-p1e I only meant that a lot of game reviewers try to sound professional on video. A lot of professional game reviewers also gave Starfield praising reviews upon release while not giving Bethesda any constructive feedback the game needs. Sometimes these professional reviewers make sure their reviews are positive so that Bethesda keeps letting them get early access to their games. In contrast, this dude sounds like someone who lives down the street who just did not like the game. He don't care about getting early access, this is just a straight opinion. Plus, he just sounds hood and that is kinda funny.
@@vincemcgaj628 yeah i know what you mean and your right, there were plenty who were really hyping the game and boasting about how great it was when it was really a very held back space game in comparison to other games. to many of them were payed to give it a good reputation, this is why i don't ever fall for the game at launch, i always wait a few months after it's been out, by then is when the signs eventually show if the game is worth all the hype or not, some people also seem to have beer goggles on and they think something is soo great and then later change their review and take off their beer goggles and see the truth. maybe i should use the matrix reference instead, at first they took the blue pill because they wanted so badly to live in la la land, but eventually that feeling wore off and they saw through the code and took the red pill and learned the truth lol.
The state of gaming has gotten sad. Bethesda is washed up, Activision is washed up, and Microsoft is washed up. All the money in the world, enough to "spend sony out of business", and they can't even beat ps4 titles. I can't understand why people support what they are doing, and refuse to demand better
CDPR gives me hope tbh...they're still independent and they're massive, they redeemed themselves with Cyberpunk and now they have 2 successful IP's to work with...plus they're focused on single player experiences - Kojima is doing interesting stuff too....I hope they help other studios realize that single player games are still huge drivers of the industry
Bethesda showed me how much "care" they put into this thing when they released it WITHOUT an FOV SLIDER. Theeennn Emil the "writer" comes out talking to the CUSTOMERS like they're idiots. Well in my case he's absolutely RIGHT. I've been buying their games allll these years thinking they'll improve, innovate, apply lessons learned. Yeeaahh right. Didn't buy this thing, ( thank you youtubers for showing, SAVING me a bunch of money), and won't be making the mistake of buying ANYTHING of their again...EVER. My deal with now is , fine you keep your LIES, Liethesda and I'lllll keep my money. Have a nice day.
I was so naive that I thought Microsoft was able to make a difference but the game is a bug infested pile of crap that gets more and more unplayable the longer one plays. New issues pops up constantly. I'm done with this sh!t company for good. Alone the lousy control implementation on pc is enough to make me stay away from any game also developed for game boxes.
Everything you said I said to my friends about the game at various times. I played for about 37 hours and finally gave up. It was SUCH a random and disjointed playing experience. Loading screen to loading screen, and not even remembering wtf happened between it all because it was so fuhginng boring and mundane.
The second they announced 1000 planets I knew the game was going to be heavily procedurally generated unlike a regular open world RPG, so I played it with that in mind and I LOVED IT, the fact that with a 40min presentation people didn't realice the kind of game it was and still dare to call it "LIES" is baffling to me, a lot of people like the game, if you don't is fine you don't have to like or play every game made by a big developer.
Fan of their past efforts, but this game was boring and just became a chore to even think about playing. Under MS, I can't even think of a time where they helped make any other IP better instead of eventually just running them into the ground. R.I.P. BGS (2001-2011)
It just works, it just works, Little lies, stunning shows, People buy, money flows, It just works. It just works. New Bethesda games come out. But this song... This songs never changes.
In 12 months we will be talking about how fantastic Starfield is in terms of graphics and gameplay...once the DLC packs are purchased and installed...in theory. If we're really lucky Bethesda will have learned to create a map.
I didn't really enjoy Skyrim, being a Morrowind fan. Oblivion and Fallout 3 were fine, but already showing some cracks in the formula, but okay. Fallout 76, didn't bother trying it out.. Fallout 4 was a 150 hour long wait for something that never materialized.. a waste of time. When Starfield was announced with only the logo, I was a little bit hyped. When the first trailer dropped, I was out and have never looked back. Not gonna lose my time with this bullshit. Reading alot of classic SciFi recently (Dick, LeGuin, Cixin..) would have made it even worse. Let's hope they rethink their whole approach to making games with TESVI. Good thing we have FromSoftware and Larian around these days.
no vehicles because all the maps you are, are actually very small. For met the most annoying thing was the loading screens and that there was not a map where u could see where shops were.
Good video first off. I gotta say i think this game was specifically designed to reach as many people as possible kids, especially included. Bruh they spent how much fuckin money on marketing??? There was commercial and branding every fucking where before the game came out. My biggest gripe about the game is that there is literally ZERO gore. Cmon wheres my bloody gore perk. The fact that basic game features are locked behind perk points is digusting. This game was designed to eat your time with menus, travel and transportation. This game fuckin sucked i coukd barely make it to 60 hours. Its boring plain and simple
I'm confused why this game uses people as minors and not robots, I mean it's the future right? And I know this game has robots, it has plenty of fucking robots, yet for whatever reason they're making the humans do the mining, it makes zero sense to me.
Well, i think the first reviewers were still influenced, by the hope and promised this game was supposed to be. Plus there isn't that many sci-fi space rpg game out there! RPG not action adventure or space simulation! Mass effect was the last great sci-fi rpg game i had played (the first trilogy)! A month after that...
The Simple Fact that also Obsidan made the best FallOutGames with Fall Out 1 , 2 and NewVegas in the Series should clear BugTester is Overatet Buggy and Glitchi unfinishedCasual IngameShopExtraPayGarbgae since FallOut3 and OblivionHorseSkin😂😂😂Stop that BullCrap FallOut3 or Skyrim where MasterPeaces couse it selled well like CoD and Fifa Games 😂😂😂
Fallout 1 and 2 are the best. Fallout I never liked and could not finishes it. the have a very in-depth character creation engine but al the character faces in the game looked the same.
Bethesda do not make good games. they just make spaces for their players to make into games with mods. it's ridiculous to me that the company still exists after reselling Skyrim 8 times to the public. why did people buy that shit? these are not good games. you could emulate croc and croc2 and those games have more mechanical depth than any Bethesda game in the hd era.
Ive watched dozen of videos bashing on Starfield to a point that im pretty sure i'll somewhat enjoy it cause i know exactly what it is and what it isnt. But then i remember its 30 fps on xbox and i lose any interest i might have gathered again. What a dumpster this game ended up being.
Lame lazily put together story; exploration feels like a last minute thing they barely put thought into; the shipbuilding (the coolest part of the game) barely matters because space combat is clunky and boring; the cities are unimaginitve and boring; every location type is literally copied..see that mining post? It's EXACTLY like the last one you just explored with the same layout and enemy/treasure locations...no matter how much people try to be charitable and say its a decent game...its not, they made very weird gameplay design choices that make the game a struggle more than a joy to play
Obviously you’re not enjoying the game. From one gamer to another. Quit and move on to something else instead of continuing to see everything you don’t like with the game.
I don't know, I've had a blast but, then again, I like to build outposts & ships & I like to explore on the planets .. Get you some mods , stop complaining, OR don't play it & move along.. We won't miss you .. Skyrim needs over 1000 mods to be "fun" O wait your on Xbox ...
Came to hear all the things missed out that should have been in etc “The ship is small” at the start im done that’s just a person going off ranting Since when does any game start you with a huge end game ship did you expect that? And a bigger ship is better!? like it’s supposed to be that way!? mouth has overtook brain there i think Stopped watching at 7:46
I agree with you man. The game is a complete joke and a massive let down. In terms of your video though, I got bored after 12 minutes. Maybe shorten your videos, or think of a structure before your make them. Not being bad, I'm just giving you some constructive feedback.
Game was just amazing for 10 Year old and Low IQ Peopel 😂EldenRing was Amazing..Lies of P did a amazing Job as Non FromSoftware Studio...BugTester just made an over Amazing Marketing to brainwash your 3 Fanboyish BugTester or GamePass BrainCells 😂😂😂
What was Constelations Job ? I mean in every Planet you explore allready some Human Bases, Pitates or Caves where Humans let Treasure😂 ?You find that Material in the Beginnin of the Game nobody should know what it is..but at the Moment you tuched it and get your Vision you are the Chosen LowJobMiner and Pirates land instant in the Szene for that Material😂Lol
But you have to play NG+ the 4th time then Starfield will show you the masterpiece it is. 😁😆😅😂🤣 But you can build ships and bases and Starborn will spawn randomly and attack you. Don't you want to do that a 100,000 times? That's the later content I was always looking forward to. Not a new quest line or anything. Not a totally new type of game. Great video. Well said.
I hate it when people call Starfield mid tier. Personal opinions can vary, but I think it is definitely below mid. Every aspect of the game is below what I would expect from an average game.
Agreed, that's being very generous. A mid game would have been fun, unlike what happened when I played Starfield.
that's how I know you only played 75 hours. the game doesn't get mid until after 200 hours
@@revanisalive I heard if you pass 5000 hours it gets objectively good.
Yeah so many people said it's 7/10 or 6/10 but that's ultra generous. Taking everything into account it's more of a 4.5 /10 at best.
If Starfield came out in 2013 maybe I could give it a 6/10.
Sixteen times the load screen
That was what Todd meant.
Knowing they will use the same engine, and have less time, i have no hope for the next elder scrolls.
The progression (regression really) from Fallout 3, to 4 to 76 makes me think the last good ES game was Skyrim, and that's being generous I know. They'll try to make the game "xxx's times bigger than Starfield!!!!11!" but bigger doesn't equal better, and that creaking engine can't handle it. I don't care if they come out with Creation Engine 3.0, it will have the same jank, the same and new bugs, and way too many loading screens or some other "watch our animation, we are very proud of it" moments that happen in their games. Think the real talent has left the building at Bethesda.
@@amandahuginkiss6868And Skyrim was already kind of a regression compared to Morrowind and Oblivion even if it improved on certain other things and it's a good game overall. But IMO many people view Skyrim through very thick nostalgia glasses. Bethesda was already lagging behind other big developers back then but at this point their game design is hilariously outdated.
I like how this dude just sounds like a real person, someone I grew up with. That's how you know this review is honest and legit.
Wait, I'm confused by this comment so because he sounds like someone you grew up with, that's the reason why you know his review is honest and legit? What?
It's just a very confusing read, maybe the context is lost or something.
I think he sounds like the UA-camr by the name of shacamma, I might be spelling it wrong, but it's a really bizarre name anyway, maybe there's a K in there somewhere.
@@5226-p1e I only meant that a lot of game reviewers try to sound professional on video. A lot of professional game reviewers also gave Starfield praising reviews upon release while not giving Bethesda any constructive feedback the game needs. Sometimes these professional reviewers make sure their reviews are positive so that Bethesda keeps letting them get early access to their games. In contrast, this dude sounds like someone who lives down the street who just did not like the game. He don't care about getting early access, this is just a straight opinion. Plus, he just sounds hood and that is kinda funny.
@@vincemcgaj628
yeah i know what you mean and your right, there were plenty who were really hyping the game and boasting about how great it was when it was really a very held back space game in comparison to other games.
to many of them were payed to give it a good reputation, this is why i don't ever fall for the game at launch, i always wait a few months after it's been out, by then is when the signs eventually show if the game is worth all the hype or not, some people also seem to have beer goggles on and they think something is soo great and then later change their review and take off their beer goggles and see the truth.
maybe i should use the matrix reference instead, at first they took the blue pill because they wanted so badly to live in la la land, but eventually that feeling wore off and they saw through the code and took the red pill and learned the truth lol.
I’d sum up Starfield’s procedural generation as “Radiant Quests: The Game”
The state of gaming has gotten sad. Bethesda is washed up, Activision is washed up, and Microsoft is washed up. All the money in the world, enough to "spend sony out of business", and they can't even beat ps4 titles. I can't understand why people support what they are doing, and refuse to demand better
Forgot blizzard
@@breezyolive abk as a whole, although I don't know much about king
CDPR gives me hope tbh...they're still independent and they're massive, they redeemed themselves with Cyberpunk and now they have 2 successful IP's to work with...plus they're focused on single player experiences - Kojima is doing interesting stuff too....I hope they help other studios realize that single player games are still huge drivers of the industry
@@Big_Dip1 Very true. We need more devs like cdpr
Real
Bethesda showed me how much "care" they put into this thing when they released it WITHOUT an FOV SLIDER. Theeennn Emil the "writer" comes out talking to the CUSTOMERS like they're idiots. Well in my case he's absolutely RIGHT. I've been buying their games allll these years thinking they'll improve, innovate, apply lessons learned. Yeeaahh right. Didn't buy this thing, ( thank you youtubers for showing, SAVING me a bunch of money), and won't be making the mistake of buying ANYTHING of their again...EVER. My deal with now is , fine you keep your LIES, Liethesda and I'lllll keep my money. Have a nice day.
I was so naive that I thought Microsoft was able to make a difference but the game is a bug infested pile of crap that gets more and more unplayable the longer one plays. New issues pops up constantly. I'm done with this sh!t company for good. Alone the lousy control implementation on pc is enough to make me stay away from any game also developed for game boxes.
You forgot the steam comments on negative reviews from Bethesda ChatGPT "You are playing our game wrong if you are bored, you need to play some more"
Everything you said I said to my friends about the game at various times. I played for about 37 hours and finally gave up. It was SUCH a random and disjointed playing experience. Loading screen to loading screen, and not even remembering wtf happened between it all because it was so fuhginng boring and mundane.
At least in the opening moments, you get to experience dialogue without the person talking staring into your soul at every second of every moment
The second they announced 1000 planets I knew the game was going to be heavily procedurally generated unlike a regular open world RPG, so I played it with that in mind and I LOVED IT, the fact that with a 40min presentation people didn't realice the kind of game it was and still dare to call it "LIES" is baffling to me, a lot of people like the game, if you don't is fine you don't have to like or play every game made by a big developer.
Great video and I agree 100%. The collective was called Constellation, Min’s name was Lin.
😂 This dude had no clue what he was talking about 😂
Glad people are catching onto Fraud Howard's lies.
Did you cry?
The last point about obsidian is dead on. Bethesda would be rendered obsolete if obsidian had access to their IPs
Fan of their past efforts, but this game was boring and just became a chore to even think about playing. Under MS, I can't even think of a time where they helped make any other IP better instead of eventually just running them into the ground. R.I.P. BGS (2001-2011)
It just works, it just works,
Little lies, stunning shows,
People buy, money flows,
It just works. It just works.
New Bethesda games come out. But this song... This songs never changes.
In 12 months we will be talking about how fantastic Starfield is in terms of graphics and gameplay...once the DLC packs are purchased and installed...in theory. If we're really lucky Bethesda will have learned to create a map.
Love videos of Todd being called out for his contact lies
I didn't really enjoy Skyrim, being a Morrowind fan. Oblivion and Fallout 3 were fine, but already showing some cracks in the formula, but okay. Fallout 76, didn't bother trying it out.. Fallout 4 was a 150 hour long wait for something that never materialized.. a waste of time. When Starfield was announced with only the logo, I was a little bit hyped. When the first trailer dropped, I was out and have never looked back. Not gonna lose my time with this bullshit. Reading alot of classic SciFi recently (Dick, LeGuin, Cixin..) would have made it even worse. Let's hope they rethink their whole approach to making games with TESVI. Good thing we have FromSoftware and Larian around these days.
The first vision made me immediately think of ME1. SF is what ME1 would've been had Bioware cut out the best parts of their game.
no vehicles because all the maps you are, are actually very small. For met the most annoying thing was the loading screens and that there was not a map where u could see where shops were.
I tried playing as a pirate but that took away more than half the enimies away
It's time to call Starfield what it is, a cashgrab ..
Good video first off. I gotta say i think this game was specifically designed to reach as many people as possible kids, especially included. Bruh they spent how much fuckin money on marketing??? There was commercial and branding every fucking where before the game came out. My biggest gripe about the game is that there is literally ZERO gore. Cmon wheres my bloody gore perk. The fact that basic game features are locked behind perk points is digusting. This game was designed to eat your time with menus, travel and transportation. This game fuckin sucked i coukd barely make it to 60 hours. Its boring plain and simple
Ship combat is mostly a joke on hard mode if you buy plasma turrets.
On Point! bravo
I logged 125 hours waiting for it to "get good". I got so bored I switched to Farming Simulator and watched the grass grow.
Bethesda doesn't deserve the "AAA".
But "A Shame , A Shame, A Shame..is Exactly what BugTester is Releasing since Decades yet...😅
Blizzard is also kind of lame since Activission buyed them ...
"AAA" = "Awful-Ass-Anus"
I'd never fallen asleep while playing a game and then I played Starfield.
watching this while playing skyrim
I'm confused why this game uses people as minors and not robots, I mean it's the future right? And I know this game has robots, it has plenty of fucking robots, yet for whatever reason they're making the humans do the mining, it makes zero sense to me.
Well, i think the first reviewers were still influenced, by the hope and promised this game was supposed to be. Plus there isn't that many sci-fi space rpg game out there! RPG not action adventure or space simulation! Mass effect was the last great sci-fi rpg game i had played (the first trilogy)! A month after that...
I put a deposit down! Wheres my gawd damn gattling laser bruce!?!
I tried playing it last night. It didn’t work out.
The Simple Fact that also Obsidan made the best FallOutGames with Fall Out 1 , 2 and NewVegas in the Series should clear BugTester is Overatet Buggy and Glitchi unfinishedCasual IngameShopExtraPayGarbgae since FallOut3 and OblivionHorseSkin😂😂😂Stop that BullCrap FallOut3 or Skyrim where MasterPeaces couse it selled well like CoD and Fifa Games 😂😂😂
Fallout 1 and 2 are the best. Fallout I never liked and could not finishes it. the have a very in-depth character creation engine but al the character faces in the game looked the same.
Bethesda do not make good games. they just make spaces for their players to make into games with mods.
it's ridiculous to me that the company still exists after reselling Skyrim 8 times to the public. why did people buy that shit? these are not good games.
you could emulate croc and croc2 and those games have more mechanical depth than any Bethesda game in the hd era.
I played this game for 100hrs and i really tried to like it but i couldnt even play the game for more than 30 mins because my ship kept glitching out
"Wide as AN ocean". Not wide as "a" ocean...
Sometimes you just have to let it go, or you'll be policing up the internet all day.
Americans are too stupid to understand real grammar.
What rhymes with lies?
Todd.
I found starfield about as much fun as jumping on a trampoline covered in dog 💩 tbh
I expected to find a plethora of copium in comments but it seems that it is not the case this time. I guess honey moon is over.
Bro all I know is elder scrolls 6 needs to be the second coming if Bethesda hopes to redeem
The elder scrolls 6 will be garbage.
Dude, great video, but your audio is a little off.
Ive watched dozen of videos bashing on Starfield to a point that im pretty sure i'll somewhat enjoy it cause i know exactly what it is and what it isnt.
But then i remember its 30 fps on xbox and i lose any interest i might have gathered again.
What a dumpster this game ended up being.
The fact that you didn't even get the names of Lin and Constellation right speaks volumes to how weak the game is.
I pray the algorithm bless me like it blessed u
All 100% correct
Starfield was so bad, so lame and so boring that I canceled my gamepass lol
Lame lazily put together story; exploration feels like a last minute thing they barely put thought into; the shipbuilding (the coolest part of the game) barely matters because space combat is clunky and boring; the cities are unimaginitve and boring; every location type is literally copied..see that mining post? It's EXACTLY like the last one you just explored with the same layout and enemy/treasure locations...no matter how much people try to be charitable and say its a decent game...its not, they made very weird gameplay design choices that make the game a struggle more than a joy to play
Obviously you’re not enjoying the game. From one gamer to another. Quit and move on to something else instead of continuing to see everything you don’t like with the game.
A game made for a person that will not be playing anything else. What a boring game it is right now.
Starfield is brilliant... cant wait to play your space game... keep quiet nobody
I don't know, I've had a blast but, then again, I like to build outposts & ships & I like to explore on the planets ..
Get you some mods , stop complaining, OR don't play it & move along.. We won't miss you .. Skyrim needs over 1000 mods to be "fun" O wait your on Xbox ...
Why are you here? Go enjoy the game. The rest of us are sick of paying for crap meant for 12 year olds.
Came to hear all the things missed out that should have been in etc
“The ship is small” at the start im done that’s just a person going off ranting
Since when does any game start you with a huge end game ship did you expect that?
And a bigger ship is better!? like it’s supposed to be that way!? mouth has overtook brain there i think
Stopped watching at 7:46
I agree with you man. The game is a complete joke and a massive let down. In terms of your video though, I got bored after 12 minutes. Maybe shorten your videos, or think of a structure before your make them. Not being bad, I'm just giving you some constructive feedback.
+
TRASH GAME!
🤣🤣🤣Honest review
Starfield isn't Fallout...there I saved you 32 minutes.
The game was amazing so quit crying
Game was just amazing for 10 Year old and Low IQ Peopel 😂EldenRing was Amazing..Lies of P did a amazing Job as Non FromSoftware Studio...BugTester just made an over Amazing Marketing to brainwash your 3 Fanboyish BugTester or GamePass BrainCells 😂😂😂
What was Constelations Job ? I mean in every Planet you explore allready some Human Bases, Pitates or Caves where Humans let Treasure😂 ?You find that Material in the Beginnin of the Game nobody should know what it is..but at the Moment you tuched it and get your Vision you are the Chosen LowJobMiner and Pirates land instant in the Szene for that Material😂Lol
you probably have the Starfield watch on while posting this...game is junk
Are you disagreeing or you just have a different opinion of the game? I don't have an Xbox so I've never played it
@@slicksilver9441 wait for a sale
But you have to play NG+ the 4th time then Starfield will show you the masterpiece it is. 😁😆😅😂🤣
But you can build ships and bases and Starborn will spawn randomly and attack you.
Don't you want to do that a 100,000 times?
That's the later content I was always looking forward to.
Not a new quest line or anything. Not a totally new type of game.
Great video. Well said.