Britannic movie: The final verdict
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
- Discord: / discord
Music: Norway (Battlefield 5)
Spitfires (Battlefield 5)
Pride and Honor (Battlefield 5)
Far from home (Battlefield 5)
Exploring autumn mountain (Paper Mario, the origami king)
See you tomorrow (How to train your dragon)
Battlefield 5 legacy theme (Battlefield 5)
Devastation (Battlefield 5)
Who thinks James Cameron would have done a better job with a Britannic movie?
I do
In terms of historical accuracy and CGI, then yes, he could have done it better
Absolutely 100%
Yes
Yes
They made the 1997 titanic
And britannic was made in 2000
The titanic wins
So its a 100%
I think tons of people could have done a better job. it didn’t even need to be cameron. this movie was just a poorly-executed phoned-in mess.
Imagine if james cameron made the britannic movie, it would be so fire 🔥
i want that
i want that
i want that
i want that
i want that
The movie could have worked, if it left out the German sabotage plot, as if this were a spy thriller like 007, instead the movie could have been about Violet Jessop, a real person who survived the sinking of the Titanic and Britannic, that way there is history, and it works with the film's shoe-string budget.
Mmhmm, but real, tragic history is just tOO bOOORING for Hollywood, no, no, no, they needed stupid action and a flop romance plot
@@YellowSuitEdits It is just an attempted carbon copy of Titanic
That was what the script originally was however, the Studio basically gaslit the director into rewriting the film as an action film late into pre-production
@@raymondleggs5508 *_bruh_*
the movie's cgi looks like a history channel documentary
From the people who brought you hunting hitler and ancient aliens comes crappy cgi britannic
@@MainMezzer, oh god my dad used to watched that.
That's an insult to the History Channel
@@jerrystauffer2351 TRUE. **AIR HORN INTENSIFES**
and its also like a history channel documentary, it messes everything up.
Not gonna lie there is a Roblox game with better animation than the Britannic movie
You Play it? I do
#flex
Omg yes it’s so much better and 100x more accurate
Literally yes
Wait, ROBLOX Britannic or Britannic S.O.S? I say the first one 1000%. ROBLOX Titanic and Titanic S.O.S however are more neck-and-neck
I like how you added HTTYD music in this video, and the last one. It made the videos feel suitable.
Finally someone notices lol
@@theshipenthusiast ha
@@theshipenthusiast you are doing well keep up the good work
4:05 That’s exactly what I would do when I was younger. I actually thought that Britannic had fully capsized when her plunge began like what the movie depicts. I would be so passionate about that to the point where if I saw the ship sink properly, I would get super pissed lol
Same thing with James Cameron’s Titanic lol
I can agree there, I had the same problem up till about a year ago.
Same, until i watched the Honor and Glory version of Britannic that it made me realize that the final plunge on the movie is unrealistic and decided to go for the H&G sinking which is more realistic, like the Britannic completely on its starboard side and hits the seafloor leaving the stern to dip down
@@koltp1909 only thing very unrealistic of THGs Britannic sinking real time is that it hit the sea floor right when the stern was gonna submerge Britannic isn’t 500 feet long she it’s 884 feet long and the ocean floor was 400 feet long so she would of hit it right after the 3rd funnel fell
@@mexicanofr7762 very well then, i’ll make my own Britannic sinking animation
hes still right about the movie
Yup
It’s hard to make the case to excuse a movies inaccuracies just because the movies old when you have movies like A Night To Remember that really put in the effort to be as accurate as possible.
So true!
I get why people are mad. I really do but, there are just some things in the film that didn’t need to happen and the year the movie was made in isn’t an excuse. Also,I don’t think some of you should shame anyone for having a different opinion to you. Idk about you but I personally loved the video and I agreed with the points that it made. And if you do enjoy the film well that’s fine and I respect ur opinion but, don’t put anyone down over an opinion.
Like titanic is way better in all ways and it's older
Huh?
I agree I think James Cameron should make a sequel to Titanic maybe that covers the Britannic like maybe we could see Rose working as a nurse onboard the Britannic
Yeah plus
BRITANNIC IS A "GENERIC SHIP" TO YALL?? O-HO-HO, SO I GUESS THE VICTIMS ARE "GENERIC" TOO! GO TO HELL, THE MAN GOT IT RIGHT IN THE PREV. VIDEO!!!
@@drewadventurehistory oook so like, Rose takes over for that other unlucky nurse i guess lol
Why would she get on Britannic after Titanic, brah
Shoutout to that Melvin that said “if you don’t like a movie don’t watch it” on a video he’s choosing to watch that he doesn’t like🔥
Well pissed off commenters, how about you look up what a criticism and review is? It’s obviously just the same people who don’t like it when a review doesn’t swing in their liking or favor.
REALLLL
15:30 she actually smiled when he died lol
She just cried
I do have problems, but I admire them for the nostalgia
I mean some characters are good but otherwise it sucks
A inaccuracy: when that guy drops that bottle and makes a hole in the ship like 1 minute later HOW DOES THE ENGINE JUST EXPLODE
Molotov*
The reciprocating engines never exploded
@@Test-j7x8f e
This is what you get when you buy the titanic movie off of wish.
😂😂😂 agreed
🤣
If James Cameron made Brittanic it would have been so amazing
I agree
Re B BBIAB C 1997
Banco 19997
Plus if someone wants to learn something, it’s important to point out what’s correct vs false. Your research is great and it’s clear you put a lot of time and effort into your videos that pertain to the Britannic movie
They could've at least made Campbell playing the role of a nurse while secretly being a spy watching the German guy's actions. But no, they not only gave her a role of a simple "passenger" on a hospital ship's voyage which only had the mdeical staff and crew onboard but also bring children there. Additionally, I believe they could do so much more and so much better with the plot if they stayed faithful to the historical facts. Like, even establishing that the mine detonation still took place but she would mistakenly blame the German guy for detonating the ship during the sinking sequence, trying to get him only to figure out just before the final plunge that he didn't do that. She didn't see him coming for breakfast for the first time during the whole voyage on the 21 November morning so she could easily get the assumption from that. A revelation could be made that he was thinking of doing that but decided not to do just by the time the mine detonation takes place, and with him being somewhere below decks during that time the film could also be able to show the early sinking havoc. Then during the final plunge they could show the German guy helping her to escape and jump overboard while he could be crushed by a collapsing funnel or something, thus solidifying his redemption. Just, so much better could be done with the film if they just weren't so lazy.
Honestly that would've been way more interesting!!
Can this be made into a Fixed Britannic Movie
To be honest The best part of the movie is the music
Me: “ORDER IN THE COURT! Final verdict of why the Britannic Movie *sucks.*”
TheShipEnthusiast: *says everything in the video*
Me: “Alright, Britannic Movie sucks.”
Britannic Movie fans: *crying*
P.S. the HTTYD music fits and me and my friend (she a girl) are huge fans are HTTYD
ME, THE TITANIC ENTHUSIAST: **OFFICER OF THE COURT** ALRIGHT, PIPE UP, YALL, GIT OUT! - Escorts crybabies out of courtroom -
As with your first video, I am inclined to agree with you on most of the points. To me a film regarding the history of the ship should have been historically accurate. Including the model and the set.
I get that they had a limited budget but you should at the very least get certain things correct. Such as the date she was in Napels, why she sank, the way she sank, the events leading up to it and the disastrous mistake made by some of the crew who launched their boats too early and thus got hit by the propellers.
In that scene when it happened, all boats were in the water but in reality it happened before the other boats were even lowered.
I do however understand where some of the people pro movie are coming from. In a way its an OK movie to put your feat up with in a Sunday. That's its all it is mind.
It's good to have a plot which is meant to grab you and the plot was not overly bad, however it still should be historically correct. That's the biggest issue I have with the film.
At least with Titanic 1997, it was largely historically correct. Was a few points wrong but not extreme. I do have to disagree with the person who said the characters in Britannic were better than Titanic, I respect the opinion but I disagree. It felt thrown together and what happened in the plot was "because" or "for reasons".
Yes. In Jame's Cameron's movie, everyone talks about how the dramatic even-keel sinking was inaccurate. But other then that, his movie was incredibly accurate. Watching behind-the-scenes doccumentaries and being a big Titanic Enthusiast-geek myself, I had to appreciate Jame's effort and the money that went into the movie. It was so well done that the fictional characters made for the highlight of the romance plot blended in so well, instead of sticking out like sore thumbs, even when interacting with the real characters, like Mr. Andrews, Bruce Ismay, etc. James did his research alright, trying to cram an insane amount of big and TINY facts about the sinking into the movie, making it really long on purpose to match the sinking duration of the real vessel, yet you still got many deleted scenes that were really cool, like the Marconi operator telling the Californian to shove it (cause he was struggling to hear the faint distant beeping from Cape Race and whatnot, so the nearby Californian literally came BLARING INTO HIS EARS, totally oblivious) the scene of Bruce getting on the Carpathia and being stared down in shame by the surviving children, and the comical scene of Molly "The Unsinkable" Brown asking for ice as the berg passed behind her lol. The movie was VERY expensive, all the sets basically made up what must've been about almost 50% of the real ship, and James went for every detail he could find, down to the smallest ones a lot have no clue about. He even included the light of the Californian on the horizon during the sinking (although, you need to up the brightness and use an Observatory-grade magnifying glass to remotely see it) and within my peak of Titanic interest, my deep studies into the many details of the Titanic, big and small, lead me to also find that the research put into the Titanic movie, and the quality of how the movie was built was incredible, and I wish more knew of all the tiny and big details James included, rather then focusing on the sinking style and marking it up as another Hollywood filmcrew juicing up the story.
Another interesting movie fact: I learned from Historic Travels (which you should totally check out, that dude is amazing) that while the Britannic's Grand StaIrcase rotted away, the metal frame remained, but Titanic's Grand Staircase was non-existant, no trace of its wreckage within the gapping hole through the ship. That is because the way the Olympic Class Grand Staircases were designed, Titanic's Grand Staircase pretty much floated out when Titanic went deep underwater, and disintigrated on its desent, unlike Britannic, which sunk onto her side in shallow waters, not allowing for that to happen to her. Over-Achieving James Cameron used real blueprints of the Olympic Class's Grand Staircase, and designed the movie set in accordance. When they flooded it, the thing started to float up off the base, pinning some actors, and they had to quickly avert disaster. I dunno what they did to capture the flooding Grand Staircase scenes in the end, but props to them for finding a way, and those extras will forever know a taste of what may have happened on the real ship as it floundered...
Overall, I rate that movie %100, and it is no suprise it blew up at the box office, and the song, "My Heart Will Go On" got popular for some time. Absolutely a masterpiece, especially for when it was made! Some modern movies are total blunders, but not Titanic! The Britannic film crew and cast should feel ashamed for their lousy and disrespectful movie...
I think the britannic was sunk by a mine
That's correct.
I just want an Olympic movie, and the soundtrack of this movie to be released.
In a few years, I am going to create an Olympic and an accurate britannic movie
I want to create an actually accurate Britannic movie featuring some scenes with The Britannic and Olympic at Southampton
@@TheRedPanda. I going to do a Olympic and Britannic movie too. Also a better Lusitania movie.
@@tina519 👍
Pretty sure Olympic could only work in a doccumentary, after all, she never sank.
If I were to create a proper Britannic movie, it would be about Violet and the ship, it would focus on Violet through Acts 1 and 2 and half of Act 3, the other half of Act 3 would be Britannic taking her final plunge
I love The Movie...But I still Do agree With him
Same
11:10 literally laughing so hard rn ngl
The film’s historical consultant, Simon Mills, who owns the Britannic wreck, had them remove his name from the credits. They rejected his advice at every turn and made a huge mess.
Here is my opinion: This has historical inaccuracies which some people like myself don't really like but it has good action scenes which is why even though it is inaccurate i loved it
Agreed
i agree to all of your opinions on the britannic movie
I'm just happy Britannic got a movie
The thing people have to take into consideration is this, you either make a super accurate movie like the 1997 Titanic, or you don't make a movie at all.
I can't belive people would hate on this video like that, they just can't accept that the movie is just God Awful.
People have different opinions you have to accept that people like and hate the film
I'm with you - the film sucks although a valid point brought up was tha fact that the 1998 Titanic movie was basically a Dills and Hoon (Mills and Boon) sickly romance on a giant budget.
the background music is 🔥
YES THANK YOU, i really hated the Britannic movie and i was hoping for someone to agree with me. im a big Britannic fan myself! I've written my own Britannic storys. one is the REAL story of Britannic and one is a fic story of what if Britannic didnt sink keep up the great work! (p.s. you really did a great job and do not deserve the hate)
I think you're right
I'd love to hear your thoughts on the 1996 and 2012 Titanic miniseries. They're so bad!
@Documentary Detective III Yep. The 2012 series was written by the guy that wrote Downton Abbey. It's awful.
Or maybe about that Titanic II movie from 2010
For me the britannic movie is amazing
We need to remake the britannic movie
Those comments in the beginning are not real Britannic fans, they're so fake
Also, @Alexius said that a 2000s animation usually sucks, excuse me? go take a look at some scenes of 1997 Titanic, some were animated and they look as if it was in 2021
First the movie makes no sense first off all the port propeller killed the passengers not the starboard second off all just stick with one side off the ship that got damaged third of all the reciprocating engines never explode fourth of all why are there kids on the Britannic it's a Hospital Ship basically going into a war zone in WW1 fifth of all the grand staircase is not the real grand stair case like on the Britannic or the Olympic or Titanic
Suggestion for content: The Lusitania movie is another Titanic knock-off, but at least the creators read some books first and respected the material. It’s not bad.
I haven’t see the movie but it’s probably a good movie
On the effects/looks of this movie, the Titanic mini TV series from 1996, with Catherine Zeta-Jones looks much MUCH better.
Look what I copied from google!: 90% liked this movie. I think you are in the 10%, that is, those who do not like the movie!😡😡😡😡
Just because something is off Google doesn't mean it's true
And also stay mad
@@stanisawstanczyk5526 oh
Explain how he’s being picky and ‘In the 10%’ by pointing out a bad movie abt a tragedy u clearly don’t know anything abt man get a grip I bet the only thing u watched was that sleeping sun video mate get a grip ur 10 and trying to be diff this was a tragedy and killed 30 people and this film basically disrespects all of that and gets all of it wrong get a grip
@@Beau.871 I Will admit It, but I write that with 5 years old, now my opinion is diferent, now I think like the creator of this video
To have an, errm, a "mingle scene" **CENSORED**
Adults: saw it coming, they all have a "mingle scene"
Kids: huh? You mean they play games or somethin...?
@@YellowSuitEdits yep
0:54 Titanic (1997) was 3 years older than Britannic (2000), like, Titanic had realistic animations and i didn't feel like it was fake
The music is literally the only thing this movie is good for. . . sometimes.
I highly recommend you "The Mystery of the Britannic"
It’s basically a world war 1 movie but instead of them using their own boat they use the name Britannic in order to get more views
I think it's okay. Yeah there are lots of inaccuracies (some of which are just down right stupid) and the story is simple, but I just remember there was hardly anything on Britannic at the time. And given this is the only movie to highlight another ship of the Olympic-class, that's probably why it gets brownie points.
Yeah, but Britannic and the victims are dissrespected by them cashgrabbers snatching up that honor. James Cameron would be rolling in his grave over the Britannic movie, he didnt just make the movie for moolah. He did incredibly deep research, and his movie is a masterpiece. I cant express how much I respect the man and his movie, I know a bunch of small details and stuff he tried to crammed into the movie, and he was perfect for making the Titanic movie, as he must've cared a lot for the real ship for making the movie so accurate minus the non-existant listing and high angle.
I like the movie. But I know its a cash-grab version of Titanic also. Still love the opening music, and silly CGI/plot lol
I also liked the fact that main girl survived Titanic. Reminds me of the nurse that boarded all 3 sisters.
Agreed
The movie name he doesn’t mention is Titanic 2.
hmm well if any viewers who know britannics history, i would still recomend this movie because of the action, sure some scenes might be wrong all in all its a good movie
Did you make that drawing of the britannic at 6:20, or was it an image you found on Google?
I made it
@@theshipenthusiast it's actually really good
@TheShipEnthusiast Omg that’s so cool. I wondered if you had made it
@@theshipenthusiast also i just found out that when britannic went down, one of her port side aft gantry davits broke down, and was (and still is) in the retracted position.
But in the movie, the davit is in the extended position, did you notice that?
@@TheRedPanda. I did not
My problem with the movie is the model of the ship since it looks like this happened
Movie: hey make this ship
Expert modeler: ok
*Brings out modeling resources he uses*
Movie: no use this
*Brings out play Doo*
Expert Modeler: are you serious I can't use this stuff if I make it detailed It would not support it's weight
Movie: I don't give a shit
Expert modeler: dude I made the model for the titanic movie to make ships I need clay not play Doo
Movie: just make it
I want to see this guy make a review on that Lusitania movie
0:34 Congratulations
You've managed to piss off the RMS Lusitania!
Honestly the only thing I like about the Britannic movie was the title sequence with the old black and white footage with the music. Other than that though, that was really the only part I found good.
The only think I liked about the Britannic movie was Amanda Ryan LOL.
List of actually
Captain - One of the mains (yay we don’t have to suffer physical pain)
Townsend (the first officer) - switches from side to one of the mains so often it’s confusing (only bad part)
The medic guy who speaks to Campbell every now and then - Side character and also dies
Crew boi - Side character
Small boi - One of the mains
Oh don’t worry the horrible affects and the other characters hold them down.
in an other timeline titanic dosent sinks and the britannic becomes the big ship sinking thing that we all buzz about, and in 1997 a person the name of James Cameron made the movie: BRITANNIC and features 2 lovers that sneak into the hospital for some reason and the male dies bec of soem reason leaving the female depressed or whatever and later in the year 2000 a crappy movie the title which states: Lusintainia was made and it got many hates among the plubic and resulting in a ship guy talking in a youtube video about how bad the movie is
At the end of the day, yes Britannic is a bad film and telling of how she sank. However, what we cannot deny is that without the movie the Britannic wouldn’t be as relevant as it is in the Titanic Fandom today.
The second class stairway on the Olympic class didnt look like the one in the movie, a stairwell
The britannic movie did suck the movie was based on one of the theories people had thrown out there so thats why the u boat was there
I know how badly inaccurate it is, but I like how they got creative and changed the way Britannic sunk for the plot. They surely were creative, but the most important parts were the stuff they got wrong. The acting too was bad, but I think its okay. I know Britannic's history and I can say they got ALOT wrong but I watched the movie but despite its bad acting and inaccuracy I like it! It is a bad movie but I can watch it, but hey! Just my opinion
The director was famous for doing low budget sets, movie and stuff
I can’t help but notice how nasty and mean people have gotten with their comments. Like you said, everyone is entitled to their opinion, but the movie Britannic really is factually incorrect. I seen the movie, and while some aspects are true, others are false. People that will belittle and criticize you, don’t deserve any attention. They’re generally the people who have no clue what’s nonfiction vs fiction.
Very good choice of music for this video
I know it's bad but not as bad as Titanic 2 which sucks
Hey hey not worry if James Cameron did directions of Britannic this movie could end up like titanic 1997
We need to get him to direct a historically accurate Blockbuster movie about Britannic
Well atleast the 2016 documentary got the sinking right instead of just capsizing the whole ship.
Britannic 21 November❤💚🌹
The movie isnt that bad,it's just very old and had a low budget.
even I like Ships you have a point
now that our technology has improved this movie should be way better
Amazingly Done my friend i loved evry bit of this movie i agree on all points.
And let the haters hate man there are WAAYYYYY better docomanterys talking about the britanic then this poor thing as a movie again i higly enjoy it well Done
When is your justica video
@@braydensrandomvideos1628 good one soon
At the end of the day it is just a movie but you still gotta tell people what really happened that’s my opinion
A Roblox game put more effort in to the sinking then this movie did
Like does no one ever think that that video is an opinion geez
I guess there pretty young that’s why
I love this movie and it’s my opinion hell I was just laughing my ass off when I saw it the first time and the second time I was just yelling justice for the director because how Matter it’s inaccurate it still has a special place in my heart
.......
Well its your opinion
@@rafiqstarline yep
Hmmmm..... ur opinion, indeed....
I know it’s been over a year since you made this but you forgot about the movie completely left out that gantry diver getting jammed
as a titanic enthusiast myself ,id like to say that staying true to the real events in a movie is crucial for the movie in my opinion. you are retelling. a story about a real event, you can have fictional characters like rose and jack do as as you wish with those characters, but you still need to make sure the real event plays out as close to how it really went down as possible. Would you believe me if i told you there was a titanic movie where theres a literal RAPPING big black terrier?
I saw both the Titanic and Britannic movies when they were released. One at the cinema and the other on TV of course. I wasn't a computer geek and Britannic's cgi still looked crappy to me ( Zena the warrior Princess had better cgi). Plus i didn't know anything about the ship's story... Still felt really cheezy and faked🎉
Those comments are plain toxic
The Britannic movie deserves no slack for its blatant disrespect and laziness, just tryna cash out on James Cameron's Titanic movie, which, BTW, was AMAZINGLY MADE FOR A 1997 FILM!!! SUCK ON IT, AT 2000 THEY SHOULDA DONE BETTER!
I’m just gonna say Bruh fro the intro ok
I respect your opinion ok
He showed the RMS Olympic
like bruh i agree 100% i am a titanic nerd and i still know a lot of Britannic and these people who know nothing about Olimpic and her sisters just triggers me a lot
I really enjoyed the acting thats all
If James Cameron makes a newer Britannic movie in say 2023 or 2024, with a higher budget, the movies surrounding the Britannic could possibly be saved. But honestly I think its too late now.
I was floored by people saying in the comments of the last video that the acting was “objectively good” … like… what? objectively good on what planet?
I agree with you the Britannic movie is horrible and bad
its kinda written in the stars that you cant make a good movie on Britannic and its not because i don’t like britannic i love it but the popularity of titanic guarantees that if you put money into a movie and make it good you will make profit and it will be a success but with britannic its not known so its not guaranteed that if you were to put alot of money into it and its a genuinely good movie but its not a popular subject it can very easily flop and jst be a waste even tho it might be a very good film
Honestly the only things i like about the movie was the scene where the ship tries to avoid the torpedoes and U-boat fires them at her, and the music. That’s it
In my opinion the only three ships you need to know in your lifetime are the
Titanic
Carpathia for being the ship that recued the survivors of Titanic
Californian for being the ship that ignored the Titanic's distress signals
Do u know how disrespectful that is to survivors / victims of other ships? Ur basically saying that ‘in ur opinion’ The Lusitania’s, britanic’s and the weilhelm gustof’s (forgive my spelling for the last one) victims all deserved to be ignored because of the titanic that’s what ur saying ‘in ur opinion’ well go on spread ur opinions saying all other ship tragedies should be ignored mate see where that gets u ‘in my opinion’
California didn't ignore the titanic. They just didn't understand
@@Beau.871 No that’s not what I mean
We should still honour the lives of those lost on other sunken ships but Titanic is kinda like the base knowledge.
@@abhiyanrana602 that’s is exactly what u were saying u js realise ur wrong
I don’t like both movies. The 1997 titanic movie was pretty good without the romance. But with that detail it makes the movie (at least for me) unwatchable. Same with the brittanic movie just without all the extras. Everything in that movie sucks.
I like the coment "if you don't like the movie, don't watch it. bla bla bla". Interesting, what about those, who actually paid for it? Seen the movie in cinema or bought VHS/DVD/BD. Customer rights doesn't work with movies. You cannot get refund, if you're not satisfied with the product. And how can one know if movie is good or bad? Two options: see it themselves or seek for reviews. And this is why you did a good job with your review, explaining the topic in organized and detailed manner.
"movie wasn't meant to be accurate" - yes. It meant to be a cashgrab on the Cameron's Titanic. And personally i seen it for only this exact reason.
Gezz , If this movie is ANYBODY'S favorite - they must be from England. Bored the ______out of me. "The future belongs to England?"
Oh no! Somebody has an opinion on the internet! How dare they!? I must immediately begin bullying them and cancelling them on twitter!!
That's not his point. It's HIS opinion to say it's bad, but it's bad if he disagrees with your opinion?
“women didn’t question there roles until the 1920s” the womens right to vote movement started in the early 1900s, got the vote in 1919 so. No the 1920s wasnt when women started to question there roles first.
I completely agree with this video. I am an animator and modeler myself, and I don't care if it's 2000, the CGI is horrible. I'm 14 and I could make something better then that. At first when I watched the movie, I didn't know the whole story of the movie. Then I started to research since when I watched the movie, I knew something didn't feel right. When I found out the whole story, I was disappointed in this movie. Heck, they could have made a better movie by using shots from Titanic.
Britannic was a straight copy of James Cameron’s titanic, they just left the good parts at home I guess