I wish Cesar would hear those two ! Excellent coloring of sounds and the grey hairs inspire maturity. After this how many of you would prefer with the original violin ? !
C’est merveilleux. Deux immenses interprètes pour une œuvre admirable. César Franck est, pour moi, le plus grand des compositeurs français. Le finale contient ce que je considère comme la fameuse petite phrase de la sonate de Vinteuil. Un moment rare à savourer sans fin.
@@guillermocorvalan3725 D’accord. Pardon pour la confusion. Comme dirait Woody Allen, quand j’entends du César Franck, j’ai envie d’envahir la Belgique.
Cher Guillermo, Il faut dire à ma décharge que, bien que né à Liège, César Franck est arrivé à Paris à l’âge de treize ans, y a fait l’essentiel de sa carrière, y a composé ses œuvres maîtresses, y a enseigné, y a connu la célébrité et les honneurs, y a été naturalisé français et a été inhumé au cimetière de Montparnasse. Sa belgitude me semble donc être un accident de naissance et une parenthèse dans sa vie. Mais, quelle que soit son appartenance, c’est un immense compositeur, et son œuvre est majeure et essentielle.
@@guillermocorvalan3725 d'origine Belge oui mais naturalisé Français et ayant fait la totalité sa carrière en France on le considère mondialement comme un compositeur Français 🇫🇷. Exit la Belgique. 😂
I think that he is the greatest of them all. In my opinion the cello is not a natural solo instrument but he manages to extract an almost beautiful sound from the instrument. Good luck to him!
Grazie! Questo è proprio un bel regalo, e inaspettato. Quella sera rimasi fuori dal Del Verme perché era tutto esaurito. Come mai questa chicca viene pubblicata solo ora?
Extraordinary playing... BUT what an epic editting fail in the 4th movement (around the 24 min mark where the a segment of video doesn't match the music).
I would have liked to have heard it performed by Tortelier, though I'm not aware that he ever recorded it. I am certain however that had Harvey Shapiro made it a mainstay of his repertoire as he did the Rachmaninoff sonata, his would have been a marvelous interpretation. My opinion only but at my twilight age I will indulge myself in my own preferences. :)) @@samuelgaskin3600
One thing that makes this composition so beautiful is chromatic modulation. And these two artists are next level. Nevertheless, it's written for violin, not cello. This arrangement, transposition, can never equal the original scoring.
I wish Cesar would hear those two ! Excellent coloring of sounds and the grey hairs inspire maturity. After this how many of you would prefer with the original violin ? !
At this level of phrasing and sound, it's beyond musicianship it's artistry
C’est merveilleux. Deux immenses interprètes pour une œuvre admirable. César Franck est, pour moi, le plus grand des compositeurs français. Le finale contient ce que je considère comme la fameuse petite phrase de la sonate de Vinteuil. Un moment rare à savourer sans fin.
Franck etait belge,pas français!
@@guillermocorvalan3725 D’accord. Pardon pour la confusion. Comme dirait Woody Allen, quand j’entends du César Franck, j’ai envie d’envahir la Belgique.
@@VladimirSartin Pas de souci,bonne soirée
Cher Guillermo,
Il faut dire à ma décharge que, bien que né à Liège, César Franck est arrivé à Paris à l’âge de treize ans, y a fait l’essentiel de sa carrière, y a composé ses œuvres maîtresses, y a enseigné, y a connu la célébrité et les honneurs, y a été naturalisé français et a été inhumé au cimetière de Montparnasse. Sa belgitude me semble donc être un accident de naissance et une parenthèse dans sa vie. Mais, quelle que soit son appartenance, c’est un immense compositeur, et son œuvre est majeure et essentielle.
@@guillermocorvalan3725 d'origine Belge oui mais naturalisé Français et ayant fait la totalité sa carrière en France on le considère mondialement comme un compositeur Français 🇫🇷. Exit la Belgique. 😂
I think that he is the greatest of them all. In my opinion the cello is not a natural solo instrument but he manages to extract an almost beautiful sound from the instrument. Good luck to him!
These two are seriously the greatest musicians alive
Absolutely not true lol
No, there are many others.
@@TheJonagold Yes, there are so many others, lucky for us. However, they are among the very best.
@@TheJonagold This is their level at ~70 years old, younger musicians will have massive shoes to fill
ΘΑΥΜΑΣΙΟΙ ΕΡΜΗΝΕΥΤΕΣ.ΑΠΟ ΤΟΥΣ ΚΑΛΥΤΕΡΟΥΣ ΠΟΥ ΕΧΩ ΑΚΟΥΣΕΙ. ΜΕΓΑΛΗ ΑΠΟΛΑΥΣΗ!!!
Pienso lo mismo, They are amazing
Maravillosos ambos, Geniales !!!! Muchas gracias
Звук виолончели Миши Майского просто волшебный!!!!!!!
Eccellente sonata e ottima interpretazione.Bravi!!!!!
Sono due mostri di bravura. Brano musicale non facile affatto!
Meraviglioso , grazie !!!
Thanks Mischa 👏
Wonderful ❤
Allegretto ben moderato 00:26
Allegro 6:48
Recitativo-Fantasia (ben moderato) 15:05
Allegretto poco mosso 22:52
Grazie !
What a PERFORMANCE
23:49 music missing with video 😂😂
Siamo molto lontani dalla poesia di Franck
E' un vero incanto. Bravissimi
❤😊🎉😂
At 24´03 the cello plays alone, without action of the cellist
It's a miracle!. Ah no, I made a mistake, sorry.
Esseri Superiori.
que cosy!
Lovely
When was this recorded
March 2016
@@EdoardoLambertenghi thanks!!
Grazie! Questo è proprio un bel regalo, e inaspettato. Quella sera rimasi fuori dal Del Verme perché era tutto esaurito. Come mai questa chicca viene pubblicata solo ora?
difficoltà sui diritti
Il gusto il gusto das Geschmach..la Linea la Linea...il climax il climax...Ich bitte ihnen...die Warheit la Verità per favore non la posa...
Extraordinary playing... BUT what an epic editting fail in the 4th movement (around the 24 min mark where the a segment of video doesn't match the music).
La publicidad en medio de una obra debería prohibirse, lo arruina todo.
Absolument d'accord !
is this score pdf?
This is the right link (César Franck) under arrangements and transcriptions:
imslp.org/wiki/Violin_Sonata_(Franck%2C_C%C3%A9sar)
@@EdoardoLambertenghi first one is of E. Franck, not C. Franck ;)
Bravíssimos!!!!
28:08
二人とも音楽の猛獣だから、もうなんか、すこ。（語彙力）
そして、あらゆる演奏は原曲、作曲家の頭の中にある音楽、の編曲にすぎないのかもしれないとも思った。
途中、音楽と映像が一致しないと航路があったけど、編集ミスか？
yes, my mistake, sorry.
@@EdoardoLambertenghi no problem ; )
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! B R A V O !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Very mannered and self indulgent performance by two otherwise marvelous artists. I don't get it.
Agreed ! Surprised your comment is the only one that mentions it
I would have liked to have heard it performed by Tortelier, though I'm not aware that he ever recorded it. I am certain however that had Harvey Shapiro made it a mainstay of his repertoire as he did the Rachmaninoff sonata, his would have been a marvelous interpretation. My opinion only but at my twilight age I will indulge myself in my own preferences. :)) @@samuelgaskin3600
Нет. Не единственный…..!
@@IrinaVinogradova-f3b спасибо
One thing that makes this composition so beautiful is chromatic modulation. And these two artists are next level. Nevertheless, it's written for violin, not cello. This arrangement, transposition, can never equal the original scoring.
Argerich la tocó con Gidon Kremer en |989.
Parece deberse a la transcripción para cello que Marta Argerich esté tocando con partitura; no es corriente en ella.