The Trouble With Trilobites
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 чер 2017
- PBS Member Stations rely on viewers like you. To support your local station, go to to.pbs.org/DonateEons
↓ More info below ↓
Trilobites are famous not just because they were so beautifully functional, or because they happened to preserve so well. They are known the world over because they were everywhere!
This episode was written by Blake de Pastino.
Thanks to Franz Anthony, Julio Lacerda, Lucas Lima and Studio 252mya for their illustrations. You can find more of their work here: 252mya.com/licensing
Produced for PBS Digital Studios.
References:
scienceline.ucsb.edu/getkey.ph...
www.uky.edu/KGS/fossils/trilo...
www.scientificamerican.com/ar...
www.trilobites.info/geotime.htm
www.trilobites.info/origins.htm
io9.gizmodo.com/5145786/trilob...
trilobite94.wordpress.com/tri...
www.cornellcollege.edu/geology...
science.nasa.gov/science-news...
www.els.net/WileyCDA/ElsArticl...
www.amnh.org/our-research/pale...
www.trilobites.info/lasttrilos...
evolution.berkeley.edu/evolibr...
Want to follow Eons elsewhere on the internet?
Facebook - / eonsshow
Twitter - / eonsshow
Instagram - / eonsshow - Наука та технологія
Death: It's time to go
Trilobite: Was I a good crab?
Death: No, I'm told you were the best
the trilo's were really the best crabby bois there were. F
Yeah
crying
What is the original meme?
Rip
"The trilobite's troubles may one day be our own."
Watch out for jawed fish.
Watch out for self and other-destructive narcissists, especially ones with artificially orange skin.
Just when you thought it was safe to go back into the primordial soup . . .
there’s always a bigger fish
Better watch out for great dyings as well.
Me eating a salmon:
*Sweats nervously*
Or they became sentient, built trilobite spaceships and left our galaxy...
Grew fur, ate everything, bothered our starships....
That seems more likely
Mr. Y. -“I beamed them all over to the Klingon ship”
Zoidberg, no
Probably.
I just know that one day a submarine will be trawling the depths of the sea when the lights will flash across something crawling along the sea floor, the pilot will aim the lights back over the spot to see a little trilobite just scuttling along and we will know that they are truly the greatest survivors.
That would be great :D
Yes, please.
Hope you're right dude!
Unlikely, but I still wouldn't bet against it.
I hope so
You know you're talking about early history when a period of 1 million years is considered "quickly"
Indeed
Wait, thats just quickly? Man, that sounds so brief, not even enough time to bounce back from a mass extinction. Barely enough time for humans to evolve.
"less then" 😁
@@MrBlack0950 not nearly enough time if you count all of the near human hominids it took to get to where we are.
From our last common ancestor with apes to humans took roughly 10 million years if I recall correctly.
you mean 20 million right?
Damn wasn't expecting to catch feels for an extinct species
Drinking alcohol when you Do care does help, I should know...
it might have been the sad piano music but me neither
Tell me about it. I feel more than a little sad that they're gone. :(
They survived for 270 million years. That's a good run.
@@ladysilverwynde me too now I'll never know what they taste like
I'm holding up my trilobite fossils so they can "watch" it.
句丹句句と 尺ヨ尸卞丹尺 £12 or $15
Neo Anderson I got mine from fossil era :D
My dad found a couple in the middle of nowhere, and now it hangs up in my house.
Me too lol
More pet obsessed than cat lovers. 😂
"I'm a surviver" said the human
"Tell me again in a few hundred million years" answered the trilobite
EXACTLY
Shook
Soooo they went through half of all mass extinctions... holy crap.
Sponges and Jellies: *Hold my survival skills!*
And that's just the known extinction events, there might have been more we don't know about lol
Holy crab*
It's like those people surviving the sinking of the Titanic only to go on and survive three other ship sinkings.
@@lonestarr1490 Funny you should say that, since there is a woman who survived not only the sinking of Titanic but also 2 other ships she was working on. Check out Violet Jessop, her story is amazing.
Damn you, Hank. That sad piano music at the end is making me emotional about Trilobites.
Very sad
Ikr
You should be happy for them, as a species they lived longer than any other
Me too wtf
me too, to think how much they strugled to survive, and being extinct broke my heart
"the trilobites' troubles may someday be our own" *jaws theme plays*
🤦♂️
*but giorno theme plays too*
Sentient sharks might be a problem
lol humans are jawed vertebrates
Honestly, I have more respect for trilobites than the dinosaurs or even fellow mammals as survivors. They didn't need to become towering giants or legendary predators, they were just little toughies who were only wiped out by the closest event to the actual apocalypse that the natural world has ever known (with the ancestors of the dinosaurs and mammals only _barely_ surviving it, and they weren't even already on the ropes like the trilobites were).
Rest In Peace, bold bugs. Hopefully, when reviving extinct species has been mastered, they'll be among those brought back again for round two at what they do best; adaptation and survival.
Don't forget Sharks as well.
I wonder how Horseshoe crabs made it through the Permian end extinction event
Unfortunately we have no way of getting direct DNA from a Trilobite, but we could possibly recreate one from Horseshoe crab DNA
Why do you have to compare different animals to each other? Such a human thing to do 😆
Nah
This combined with PBS Space Time just brings back good memories of old Discovery Channel. Before it got filled with ice road truckers and deadliest catch. Back when new sciences were being shown. When all the fun channels like History, National Geographic, Animal Planet, all had fun to watch and educational shows.
Good Job!
A Diabetic Jedi, I agree the Discovery Channel and History channel were great in the 1990's and early 2000's but then to save money they started putting all those boring reality TV shows. The only saving grace was The Universe series but when History started showing Ancient Aliens I jumped ship.
Yes, I agree with you guys. I used to watch Discovery, TLC, and History Channel as a kid in the 1990's. History Channel should now be called "The Pseudoscience and Conspiracy Theory Network".
Anodyne Melody it's become an entertainment channel rather than an education channel, which is understandable seeing that the demand is very high in entertainment. I don't blame them, and I like to entertain conspiracies, but my heart will always belong to the hard sciences and psychology education shows
Anodyne Melody *fox news
Not only educational channels unfortunately. Many cable channels are trying to be mainstream and feel less and less niche.
when big tv channels like discovery, history, nat geo sold themselves out for shows like storage wars or "blue collar" reality shows, I missed the educational stuff i partly grew up on. they were right next to my cartoons. I'm so glad to see PBS still has a soul!! thank you so much for this, crash course too!
When you consider how eagerly humans are attempting to destroy themselves, the trilobite's reign is amazing.
Mother Nature had to work hard to kill these fellows for good. She doesn't have to do anything to wipe us out. Maybe sip her coffie while watching us trying to find new ways to blow each other up
something something about dude in sky told them to subdue the planet so his son can have a battle with a fire dude.
I've always hoped that one day a deep sea dwelling species of trilobites would be found and we could see them for real.
I always thought they were still alive! I just realized when I watched this video. I am 32 year old lol but I think I thought that horseshoe crabs where them !
@@marcogasperoni2391 well horseshoe crabs are arthropods, so related? I loved horseshoe crabs as a kid. They're so damn cool.
This is quite an old thread, but just hopping in to say that horseshoe crabs (or possible sea spiders but they're weird and contentious) are most likely the closest living relatives of trilobites, and nearly as ancient (they've been around ~450 million years).
Horseshoe crabs and deep sea giant isopodscome close pretty close. I think a Trilobite wouldnt be much different
Might I introduce you to giant isopods, also known as giant woods lice?
You: Pill Bugs
Me, an intellectual: Rolley Polleys
sl1cky_n1cky I said that in my mind and was hoping someone in the comments did too, and was it just me or would you collect Rolley Polleys
Agreed. They never say rolly Polly
@@redlion9943 I like rolly Pollies there my favorite. Bug there so cute by insect standards
They are called rolly Polly
@@asmodeusasteroth7137 ok
I suddenly feel very sad for trilobites
Not much really...there are still Surviving Relatives of Trilobite...they were Horshoe Crabs and they had common Similarities to Trilobites..... Horshoe Crabs are Living Fossiles from Cambrian Era..
And the Blue Blood they had which is immune to all kind of Bacterias might explain how they Evolve further after the Almost Extinction
@@messier8379 did anybody ask?
My deepest sympathy and condolences go out to the family and friends of the trilobite.
I am not a trilobite myself but have known a great many trilobites and know of their struggles.
@@CruelestChris I wonder if you mean, "troglodyte"...
The horseshoe crabs great accept your belated sympathy.
I'll always love trilobites, my uncle taught me about them when I was a wee lass.
The emotional piano music in the background makes the extinction of the trilobites all the more sad; RIP Trilobites
Don't watch dovahatty
Very sad. Hope they are in heaven
There is nothing that makes me happier than the phrase "non-avian dinosaurs." Bless you, Hank Green.
because avian dinosaurs still exist
Heck yeah they do!
Foonian Relativity And they taste delicious!
Foonian Relativity To explain if your don't know, it is know accepted taxonomical understanding that birds did not evolve from dinosaurs, but, in fact, ARE dinosaurs. That is Aves is just a clade within Dinosauria.
...You make an excellent point, DON'T MEAN TO DISRESPECT BLAKE, bro does super important work on all these shows. But I also feel confident that Hank wholeheartedly endorses the pro-avian dino message.
they tried so hard~
and got so far~
Lmao
But in the end it doesn't even matter
But in the end Linkin Park's success was always an anomaly.
But in the end it doesn't even matter
IWillTakeAGuranteeOfBetterOverAPromiseOfPerfect is that a primeval reference?
"Nature had to kill them like four different times." When Mother Nature gets angry with you.... She's serious!
As a geology postgraduate, thank you. This is exactly the kind of video that will inspire people to learn about geology!
Yay!
Joe McNeil You are awesome, keep up the good work!
I'm about to do a geology degree (undergrad) and this series will really help, it's so interesting
Joe McNeil This is awesome! I'm in high school and have been planning to get a degree in geology for quite some time. I look forward to it!
Agreed! Except a representation of a geological timeline would be inverted. With older periods below more recent times.
Just found this channel. RIP sleep.
123 likes..
I would like too but I got ocd I kind of like it to stay 123 .-.
*"I'll love you like trilobite"* is my new life quote
After Hank's marvelous performance, I was touched and now feel attached to the little trilos
No one is going to comment about the awesome Star Trek reference in the title? Really? It's awesome! And then again at the end "The trilobite's troubles may some day be our own".
I came here for the Tribbles.
I was looking for this comment.
I was looking for this comment, even though the referent is old (nowhere near as old a trilobites).
Brilliant! May the horse be with you 🖖
Great job!
It always amazes me how Hank Green never seems to slow down, and I love that the results are as amazing as this fascinating vid!
I really don't give a damn about the recent drama. I am voting for Hank as King of UA-cam!
The drama is outside of his work as an educator. I can disagree with a man's politics or hypocrisy without disregarding his talent to educate.
Its the magic of Editing.
Hahaha. Make a video in this pleeeease
Editing...
"A small time of a million years"
I didn’t think it was possible, but you made me genuinely sad about a bunch of underwater bugs being extinct. Poor buggies. They wanted nothing more than to live.
The trilos aren't ever truly gone. They're just in liquid form.....In your car's fuel tank.
Thank you li'l trilos for your zoom-zoom juices.
Yep, the dinosaurs aren’t truly gone either, in fact, I’m eating one right now, I like them with barbecue sauce.
I’d prefer ketchup
feeshschticks lol zoom-zoom juice
And those plastic dinosaurs your kids are playing with come from oil and we all know where that comes from. OoOOOOoo ironic isn't it
That's in fact wrong. Fossil fuel comes from the trees in the Carboniferous era, not from the dinosaurs.
who else cried at trilobite death
At least they got to survive as long as they did!
Yea
I don't feel so good-Triobite
Messa
Gluttony no because I’m not a snowflake
I just opened this video for a rewatch only to realize it was released 6 years ago. Thank you pbs eons for continuing to provide educational content informed by actual science
RIP trilobites even though I never saw you and we aren't talking about these crabs that you buy in a box that die after a month
I'd just like to say how thankful I am for this series in the making. It has been so long since us natural history geeks have had the chance to sink our metaphorical teeth into a new series about life origins that is not just a poorly made and barely funded money grab. Not all of the more recent series where this way and the good ones that have been around didn't have enough money or attention to get them to be truly great. I would love for this to spark a new uproar in series and documentaries like this. I miss the days of Walking with Dinosaurs and Prehistoric Park. Needless to say I am great full for this new series. I am a long time sci show and crash course fan and I am super hyped.
I am super hyped about this comment. Thank you. Let us know what you think of the episodes.
PBS Digital Studios Will do. I have extremely high hope for all things to do with this series!
logan crawford Yo everything is the exact same with me! Prehistoric Park was the bomb!
Abhiram Srivastava I remember watching prehistoric park over and over again, wishing that a new episode would magically appear some day. Sucks that all the documentaries today recycle the same animations and special effects used for the past 10 years. No heart, just a bunch cash grabs with no insides or anything. Can not wait for this new series!
*new insights, sorry about that :/
This is awesome! Thanks PBS Digital Studios and everyone who is making it happen!
thank YOU for watching
And thank you for taking the time to read viewer comments!
+1
Thanks again, PBS Digital Studios. I hope you are archiving all your videos, because they will stand the test of time if given the chance. I especially love PBS Space Time. IMHO it is probably the best science-related program currently in production, rivaling Cosmos in impact on the viewers. IMO, Matt O'Dowd is the next Carl Sagan (but funnier); we need more people like him in the world. Cheers!
This is like a huge explosion of educational content! I could ask what took you guys so long to discover internet video but it's good you did :)
This is excellent, thank you guys!
Thank you. Very interesting. I have a fossilised enrolled trilobite, it blows my mind to think of its age every time I hold it.
I cant believe Horseshoe crabs arent descended from Trilobites, they look exactly the same
Beautiful & informative video. Side note: I'm guessing the first big success story was not the trilobites but their food? Worms & jellyfish have undoubtedly changed a lot since then, but they're still around.
This is absolutely brilliant. This channel is everything I wanted to hear about as a kid, I feel like an excited child on Encarta.
I'm so excited it's here! I've loved PBS digital studios from since I first saw a show from it, and with Hank Green being a part of it I know it'll be perfect. Keep it up!
Aw shucks
Vikings488 if
PBS Digital Studios crcrccrrrcrr
Trilobites: "We're going to live forever!"
Earth: "Challenge accepted!"
Fun fact 101
The Pokémon Kabuto is based on the trilobite (with several elements of the horseshoe crab). The entries for all the core games said they live somewhere around 300 million years ago...
We will always remember you, Trilobites
;_;7
PRAISE THE ALMIGHTY HELIX FOSSIL
what you mean still alive, their evolutionary cousins are alive but hte trilobite geno is dead
Isopods is a species classification, Trilobites were the ancestor of today isopods
that’s pretty funny fr&
My grandpa had a pet trilobite when he was younger- he says it got out the aquarium one day and got eaten by a dang anomalocaridid
JC Mik I feel ur pain. My sister dropped a bunch of pencil lead into my trilobites' tank. The graphite covered the floor and then... sniff sniff... I just can't talk about it
He kept a diary, once, but then fungi evolved the metabolic pathways necessary to digest lignin and ate it while he wasn't watching.
+JC Mik LOL, you know your biochemistry. ;)
JC Mik
Is Larry King your grandpa?
Damn how old is your grandpa because he sounds pretty immortal
I'll always find trilobites as cute and unique! :D
Do not worry lil Trilobites. We still have Horseshoe crabs and Triops.
Yeah the Blue Blood of Horshoe Crab are immune to all kind of Bacterias and Virus..this might explain how they survived From Great Dying....problem is Humans is Harvesting their blood for Medicines and Vaccine...Humans could be the another Footnote for them
If it's something other than space itself that interests me, it's prehistoric life. i'm hyped !
me too!
Ah, a scientific video ending with a philosophical statement. Love it.
I'm shaking and crying right now. I can't believe they're gone. I miss them so much.
Just started playing arc survival (dinosaur game) and I loved how cool the trilobites were, and I'm also a huge fan of the pokemon kabuto, which is based off the trilobite. The trilobite legacy lives on in our hearts.
The sad background music made the extinction of the trilobites more tragic.
Super stoked for this video series!
Long time Crashcourse/PBS digital studios watcher, first time commenter.
Go Education!
THANK YOU!
same
ditto. except the first time commenter part. : ]
Same I should comment more go youtube, love and subscribe
Brilliant writing
The delivery was good as always but the writing this time was close to flawless
I love this channel! Along with all the other pbs channels including it’s ok to be smart and all variations of Schishow! Thanks guys!
Back in does days, the internet speed was measured in trilobites! :D
but later on, as internet providers tried to make their services appear faster than they actually are, it became trilobits.
Hi... la... ri... ous!
GROAN
I'm a 20 year old guy and I clicked on this video because I thought my computer's RAM was running out of Trilobites.
So yeah... If anyone needs me, I'll be going back to Middle School.
Ha. So punny.
So what you’re saying is that you’re scientifically illiterate and proud of it?
I wouldn’t brag about being Exhibit A of what’s wrong with America’s sad aversion to science education.
Molly M. Moss Also I think it was blatantly obvious that he was joking, so maybe you should get yourself a sense of humor before you look at the youtube comment section.
@@MollyNMoss-gi6je r/iamverysmart
@@MollyNMoss-gi6je r/woooooooooosh
I want a plush of a trilobite to hug now. I got too invested ;-; love those funky lil arthropods
One of my favorite Star Trek episodes! Remember when Kirk opened that grain bin and all those Trilobites fell on him? 😁
I love More Tribbles, More Troubles when they tie back into that episode. The whole Klingon thing is hilarious.
so hype I'm gonna WATCH every episode Love you HANK!!
same.
+
+
reddeath4life +
I'm confused about the capitalisation of 'watch'.
I'm so happy this channel is getting more people into paleontology
love the Star Trek reference in the title!! I am surprised that the trilobites are still not with us. you would think that they could survive anything. R.I.P. trilobites.
0:19 "They're known the world over because they were everywhere!" Sounds like the original version of Cockroaches.
Seems like they were just as hard to kill too.
@@sunnyalphax3539 Four hits from Life itself?!? Yeah, definitely qualifies.
One of the few UA-cam ads that caught my attention more than the video I was going to watch. This is just what we need
my mind is now heavy with the sad history of the trilobites
1 like 1 chance to the trilobites be cloned
By 2026 humans will join them according to Guy McPherson. No need to thank me for that info. Sleep well. old geologist
Trilobites must be cloned!
...cloned how? Cloning requires DNA. They died off many millions of years before the dinosaurs. Furthermore, what remains we have of them are all fossilized. We can clone mammoths because we've found mammoth bones and I think a frozen mammoth or two (Google says yep, that's a thing.) Jurassic Park came up with the hypothetical process of cloning dinosaurs from dino blood in a fly in amber (which I think is impossible given the lifespan of DNA but I digress). But...there's nothing from that far back that left any biological material behind that I know of. It'd be like trying to clone a human from a photograph.
So, we'll whip them up from scratch someday once we finally commit the greatest blasphemy of all and start cooking up brand new forms of life for our own amusement.
EDIT: And after I wrote this silly comment I went 'a googlin' on the subject because I was curious. Apparently some team managed to analyze a 500 million+ year old fossil and figure out that it had cholesterol and was thus an animal. So apparently science is even more crazy awesome than I thought and maybe we will have cloned trilobites someday. Who knew?
only the future knows...
I’ll have sex with a trilobite
04:33 That is one seriously goth trilobite
Its always nice to learn about your ancestors. Thanks PBS!
He did say that they didnt leave any descendants. sorry but they are gone for good.
Let's see here... Star Trek reference. Trilobites. Factual information pertaining to said Trilobites. Correctly utilizing the word "Eons". Hank Green. Subscribed!
AstoundingChaotix what was the Star Trek reference
The title is a reference to a Star Trek (The Original Series) episode "The Trouble with Tribbles". Cute creatures, multiply like crazy and, in the end, get wiped in an instant.
Damn, didn't catch that
Not so much "An instant", the Klingons had to assemble an armada to destroy the Tribble homeworlds after all, and then round up all survivors... =p
We never did get to know if they have any songs about the great Tribble hunt...
Also diet of worms
I cried when watching this. I love trilobites so much 😭❤️
Love to see this guy, he taught me anatomy while I was in Massage Therapy school.
Trilobites Never Forgotten 😢
I knew nothing about trilobites before this video. Thanks :D
Ashley Clark are you like 10 years old?
no I'm not, but if I was there would be nothing about that that would invite your comment. 10 year olds use the internet too you know.
There is nothing wrong with being ignorant in a subject... It's what a person does with that ignorance that matters... And clearly Ashley Clark has a curious enough mind, that it brought her(him) to this video and was enlightened... One can now hope that from this new enlightenment that she(he) will seek other new things like this...
For learning more things like this, I would highly recommend anything from SIr David Attenborough.. He has a great 2 part series called "First Life" which goes in good depth on early life on this planet... Just do a search using "David Attenborough's First Life" He has so many docs out on life and animals... Great ones.. He's been doing it for over 50 years...
The title of this video made me remember a
Star Trek episode called “The trouble with the tribbles” in the original series...
Damn, it took me two years to realize that the title of this was a star trek reference.
Tribble will never go extinct.
I found a small one of these on a hike when I was really young.
I'd be curious to hear a hypothesis on why the horseshoe crabs survived and went on to live to this very day when the trilobites did not. They were similar animals presumably in the same niche. Maybe their reproduction cycle was vastly different? Did laying eggs on the shore help?
Or their mysterious blue blood
they evolved from a creature that had more than just armor, iirc the sea scorpion mainly prayed on trilobites
@Desmond. If that is the case, you could say that horseshoe crabs (rather their ancestors) contributed to the trilobites' demise.
It's rather interesting in that in their debut as a species, Trilobites were one of, if not the top predator for a period of time. By the time they died out, they had become one of the most bountiful prey in the ocean.
I was thinking the same thing,
I truly thought Horseshoe Crabs were their descendants
I feel for my trilobite brothers #prayfortrilobites
Trilobites! I was rooting for you!
My favorite animal group of prehistory. Love the little guys!
i wish trilobites still existed
Horse shoe crabs are pretty close
They do still exist just as fossils!
Sheogorath2077 me too I wonder if they taste like shrimp?
This is really awesome. It's crazy that Hank has the time to do all the amazing stuff he does
So sad im crying, farewell trilobites 😢
Regarding the ability to enroll: this may not have originally evolved as a defense against predation, but rather to improve their ability to moult. There are fossils of trilobites that died in the middle of moulting, apparently getting stuck on the way out of the old exoskeleton. Being able to significantly flex their body up and down probably allowed them to dislodge from the old exoskeleton much more easily. This flexibility could later be coopted to fully enroll as defense
This channel is fantastic. Each host is great and the content is so informative and interesting. Thanks to the studio
What a grotesquely fantastic format!!
I can't wait to see how the world will be in 10 million years from now
So glad this is happening.
Richard Kaskiewicz you're so glad what's happening?
Jess Vermont and what did you mean by you're having trouble with their trilobites and hoped nobody noticed what? Lol sorry I'm just a little confused on what u mean.
Richard Kaskiewicz, What, another massive extinction?
Hank Green, PBS, and Prehistoric life!?! This is the perfect UA-cam channel!!!
I remember reading somewhere that horseshoe crabs might be the closest living relatives of trilobites
I love how at the end he talks about human extinction with a checky smirk
All this talk of extinction and survival due to climate change really puts things into perspective!
The problem is we'll make ourselves extinct. Life on earth will move on.
@@HyperSpify Unless we blow up the earth. Then there will be no more life.
Climate change is s naturally occurring process? I'll second that.
I'm already Digging this
Camden Hill I'm already hating you for that joke
Naw jk bruh 😂
ba dum chiii
I dig it like Diglett
Hope you find some good fossils. ;)
Really like a more detailed examination of cambrian oddities other than Anomilocaris and trilobites. Love PBS Eons!
It's so awesome these videos that tell us the story of other animals that lived like us now
I am so deeply fascinated by this. And so far all I did to satisfy this fascination was ocassionally browsing Wikipedia. Now I have it in video form and this is my start of watching every single video of this channel in chronological order!
Awesome serie!!! Thanks to bring quality show on UA-cam!
Extremely well explained! Gracias!
They're so CUUUUUUUUUTE!!!
Great video! I enjoyed learning about the trilobites. I had no idea that there had been so many types or that they had existed for so long. Thanks for the info! 😊