My family and I started going to a low church again regularly about a year ago...I, my wife, my mother in law, my daughter, her husband, and 3 grandkids all live under one roof. Everyone is so excited to be going to church again, and my daughter and her husband are really forming some bonds in small group. I somehow stumbled on Pints with Aquinas and started becoming interested in Catholicism. I would convert tomorrow if it weren't for my family, who are all really happy being nondenominational and against being Catholic. I am going to be as Catholic as I can without converting for now, and pray that God sorts it all out to his will. I am ordering my first rosary today. lol
I just tonight came across your channel and I really like it!! This is the second video I've watched!! I'm Catholic and I'm very happy for you and your family!! Happy All Saints Day and All Soul's Day! We have to pray for the dead people!! P.S. your baby and the sounds she makes is beautiful!!!!!!! Mike
Hmmm, I stumbled upon your videos, and I feel led to make a few comments: First of all, congratulations! As someone whose journey mirrors your own to a great extent, I know how you must be feeling- as a Protestant, it is so exciting to discover the truth and beauty of Christ's original church and embrace Catholicism. With that being said, I simply wish to say this- just move forward with what God is instructing you to do- seriously- just go on and do it! You mention that you are now thoroughly "convinced" and that God has put it both "in your mind" and "on your heart." Well then? What are you waiting for? I listened to what you said about your wife not being convinced and your own desire for you and her to "walk together" on the journey, BUT- God doesn't work that way! God often places convictions on us as individuals- HE has a divine plan for our lives that is according to HIS holy will. We should not allow others' opinions or lack of enthusiasm about our own God-given convictions to become reservations on our part and to cause us to delay our action in carrying out HIS will. (Of course, you know what happened to Jonah when he resisted...) And believe me- I do know what you are going through- I won't tell my whole story in this comment*, but I will say enough so that you understand that I can definitely relate to you: After research and prayer, I voiced my interest in Catholicism at the beginning of this year (I was raised Baptist and all my close family members are either Baptist also or other evangelical Protestants). My mother (who was Pentecostal as a girl and became a hard-core Baptist) was quite critical of my decision. More relevantly, my wife, like yours, also was not initially excited about it- like your wife, I guess she was "supportive enough," but she thought I was being a bit weird and going in a questionable direction regarding my faith. Of course, we had very deep conversations about it and I was open about teaching her everything that I was learning for myself, and doing so made her more supportive but she still wasn't truly positive about it. Then you know what? I bluntly (but politely) told her (and everyone else) that I had made my decision and that I didn't care what she or anyone else thought about it- stating plainly that it was not because I was being contrary or wanted to rebel or any other trivial reason, but because God had brought me to the decision and that I knew it was for my benefit according to HIS plan for me- because it was bringing me into a closer relationship with HIM and was strengthening my faith. Then, I met with a deacon in my parish to begin a fast-track RCIA course and I started going to mass every Sunday. I also started doing the liturgy of the hours and praying a daily rosary. In addition, I became involved in my parish church's activities- I joined a Catholic men's Bible study and attend monthly Catholic events and conferences. In other words, I essentially "became Catholic" at least in mindset and practice (and I will have my confirmation this Easter). After only a few weeks, my wife saw the very evident positive difference it had made in me, and she started expressly asking me what I was learning and went to a conference with me. Then the following week, she joined me at mass and has been going with me ever since. Fast forward a couple weeks later, and now she will be starting a RCIA course soon and will be on the same journey. We men should remember that we are called to be the spiritual leaders of our household- the best type of leadership is by example (not only in our homes and in religious matters, but in any environment and on any subject), so if God speaks to us with a clear calling, we should act on it. Again, I only write all this because you yourself clearly state in the video that you are convinced and that it is on your heart (I wouldn't write any of this if you hadn't said that, because then you might just still be exploring). And I hope my words here don't seem harsh or scolding- indeed, I hope they are comforting and encouraging (again, I used to be in your same situation, so I know what it's like). I realize I am just a random guy on UA-cam commenting on your video, but I am also your brother in Christ who just felt guided by our Lord to advise you. That's all. Peace and blessings! *I am very open about myself and love to connect with others whom I can relate to- if you do want to know my full story, feel free to ask and/or send me a private message.
I was here for your name change video!! My first video was your Rosary video. I was was excited your were catholic curious then you changed your channel name. I was sad for selfish reasons since I no longer had someone to walk with from the beginning but i never stopped praying for you!! Still praying for you! Since Easter had passed i was curious today so I looked up “Protestant prays the rosary”! So I’m here to let you knew I’m praying for you and your family!!
So exciting! Our journeys have been side by side for awhile, though I’m not married. Lately I’ve been having Padre Pío “reach out” to me. That’s been a little terrifying as a Protestant, but it’s also so cool! God bless you!
Literally just yesterday I found out that the person who gave me the book Rome Sweet Home works in the Padre Pio building at his job. It's so crazy! @@BecomingCatholic
I'm taking rcia/ocia classes right now, I'm not sure if I'm ready to convert, but I'm leaning in that direction. My spiritual journey has been long Latter-Day Saint, to Pentecostal, to Wiccan, to Methodist, and simply felt like there was something missing, but I do believe that its the real Presence that's missing. Thanks for sharing your journey.
Wow, great to hear! I’m a recent convert myself (confirmed in 2022) and come from a Protestant background with Pentecostal roots, Bible school and ministry experience, preaching etc. I went through an extremely similar experience to you. Even held off on becoming Catholic to also walk with my wife to make sure we could hopefully be received into the Church as a family. Would be happy to connect with you if you ever want to chat with someone who went through the same journey (specifically with waiting to be confirmed)!
I’m so pleased to watch this video! My husband and I converted in 2020, my youngest son converted last year, and my eldest son just entered RCIA. I have been following you since one of your first videos and I will be praying for you and your family! Please, please pray for my eldest son (who is also named Nate ☺️) and for his marriage, which needs prayer, and his daughters. I look forward to seeing more content from you and following your journey. St. John Henry Newman, pray for us!
It's so good to see you back! Thanks for the update! In regards to what you said about your channel becoming a ministry, I do recommend that when you do decide to become Catholic, you watch Keith Nester's video on something like 'First year of being Catholic'. I forget the exact name of the video. The point, though, is not to jump right in and be doing everything. Take it slow and find where your faith fits into your life.
Thank you! While I am very much interested and open to the idea, I have no plans to make the channel anything other than what it is now. Im just enjoying learning and growing
Im so happy to see you back and that you have restarted your journey. My husband and i were married 31 years ago, and he is a cradle Catholic. I was raised Latter Day Saint but left years ago. Last year my husband had a health scare and long story short..i ended up in daily mass. The more i learned about Catholicism the more i loved. We raised all 4 of our children Catholic and i came and went to Mass here and there but i didnt feel it calling me as i do now. (My husband is all good health wise btw). I started RCIA a few weeks ago and am so happy. I just love the Catholic faith. I feel confident that you and your wife will make your way home eventually. Hopefully it doesnt take you 31 years like me. 😂 God Bless you and your sweet family. I will be watching your journey and praying for you. Take care Laura
Thank you for sharing Laura! That is an awesome story! Haha yeah I don’t expect it to take too long, although right now any amount of time feels like too kick time.
Nate, thank you for sharing the journey that you and your wife are on right now. As I’ve mentioned before I’m a cradle Catholic (poorly catechized) and I left for a Pentecostal Church. As I slowly saunter back to Catholicism I’ve taken up with my devotions again. The Hallow app has been a help for me. I’m not sure if you’ve looked at it. I will be praying for you and your family. I can’t wait to watch your journey!! God bless.
So glad you're back. Was concerned, I have thought of you regularly. Have you or your wife read Jesus Shock by Peter Kreeft? It isn't theological but it is apologetic. It is a FANTASTIC book which really expresses the whole picture of what we are to aim at. I highly recommend it. I will continue to pray for your family!
Thank you! Much appreciated! We are not currently going to mass regularly because I still work full time at a Protestant church. We do have some plans to go in the future, but I’m currently working 2 jobs so it’s hard to find time
Hey Dawn! Thanks for commenting! Somewhat! lol I'm don't have a strong posting schedule YET, but I will be actively working on new content to keep you all updated on my journey!
I am intrigued by the fact that your approach to Catholic Faith seems to happen in your readings or watching Catholic things. Is there any contact with the life of the Church, like attending Mass, Eucharistic Adoration, prayer groups...? Do you have any personal encounters with Catholic people, Priests, nuns, cathechists...? By the way, where do you live now, still in New York State? I am a Spanish friar and priest living now in Orange, New Jersey, Do you have a Facebook account?
If you are feeling that you want to become Catholic, that is because God himself is calling you. The same thing with your wife, if she is warming up to it, God is calling her as well. I am certain that you will reach the fullness of the faith, because once you open the door to Christ he is going to be there, calling you in your heart and in your mind, till you reach the goal. Bless you in your journey.
My family and I started going to a low church again regularly about a year ago...I, my wife, my mother in law, my daughter, her husband, and 3 grandkids all live under one roof. Everyone is so excited to be going to church again, and my daughter and her husband are really forming some bonds in small group. I somehow stumbled on Pints with Aquinas and started becoming interested in Catholicism. I would convert tomorrow if it weren't for my family, who are all really happy being nondenominational and against being Catholic. I am going to be as Catholic as I can without converting for now, and pray that God sorts it all out to his will. I am ordering my first rosary today. lol
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I just tonight came across your channel and I really like it!! This is the second video I've watched!! I'm Catholic and I'm very happy for you and your family!! Happy All Saints Day and All Soul's Day! We have to pray for the dead people!! P.S. your baby and the sounds she makes is beautiful!!!!!!! Mike
Thank you so much for the encouragement! God bless!
Hmmm, I stumbled upon your videos, and I feel led to make a few comments:
First of all, congratulations! As someone whose journey mirrors your own to a great extent, I know how you must be feeling- as a Protestant, it is so exciting to discover the truth and beauty of Christ's original church and embrace Catholicism. With that being said, I simply wish to say this- just move forward with what God is instructing you to do- seriously- just go on and do it! You mention that you are now thoroughly "convinced" and that God has put it both "in your mind" and "on your heart." Well then? What are you waiting for? I listened to what you said about your wife not being convinced and your own desire for you and her to "walk together" on the journey, BUT- God doesn't work that way! God often places convictions on us as individuals- HE has a divine plan for our lives that is according to HIS holy will. We should not allow others' opinions or lack of enthusiasm about our own God-given convictions to become reservations on our part and to cause us to delay our action in carrying out HIS will. (Of course, you know what happened to Jonah when he resisted...) And believe me- I do know what you are going through- I won't tell my whole story in this comment*, but I will say enough so that you understand that I can definitely relate to you: After research and prayer, I voiced my interest in Catholicism at the beginning of this year (I was raised Baptist and all my close family members are either Baptist also or other evangelical Protestants). My mother (who was Pentecostal as a girl and became a hard-core Baptist) was quite critical of my decision. More relevantly, my wife, like yours, also was not initially excited about it- like your wife, I guess she was "supportive enough," but she thought I was being a bit weird and going in a questionable direction regarding my faith. Of course, we had very deep conversations about it and I was open about teaching her everything that I was learning for myself, and doing so made her more supportive but she still wasn't truly positive about it. Then you know what? I bluntly (but politely) told her (and everyone else) that I had made my decision and that I didn't care what she or anyone else thought about it- stating plainly that it was not because I was being contrary or wanted to rebel or any other trivial reason, but because God had brought me to the decision and that I knew it was for my benefit according to HIS plan for me- because it was bringing me into a closer relationship with HIM and was strengthening my faith. Then, I met with a deacon in my parish to begin a fast-track RCIA course and I started going to mass every Sunday. I also started doing the liturgy of the hours and praying a daily rosary. In addition, I became involved in my parish church's activities- I joined a Catholic men's Bible study and attend monthly Catholic events and conferences. In other words, I essentially "became Catholic" at least in mindset and practice (and I will have my confirmation this Easter). After only a few weeks, my wife saw the very evident positive difference it had made in me, and she started expressly asking me what I was learning and went to a conference with me. Then the following week, she joined me at mass and has been going with me ever since. Fast forward a couple weeks later, and now she will be starting a RCIA course soon and will be on the same journey. We men should remember that we are called to be the spiritual leaders of our household- the best type of leadership is by example (not only in our homes and in religious matters, but in any environment and on any subject), so if God speaks to us with a clear calling, we should act on it. Again, I only write all this because you yourself clearly state in the video that you are convinced and that it is on your heart (I wouldn't write any of this if you hadn't said that, because then you might just still be exploring). And I hope my words here don't seem harsh or scolding- indeed, I hope they are comforting and encouraging (again, I used to be in your same situation, so I know what it's like). I realize I am just a random guy on UA-cam commenting on your video, but I am also your brother in Christ who just felt guided by our Lord to advise you. That's all. Peace and blessings!
*I am very open about myself and love to connect with others whom I can relate to- if you do want to know my full story, feel free to ask and/or send me a private message.
I will be praying the Rosary for you and your wife!!!
I was here for your name change video!! My first video was your Rosary video. I was was excited your were catholic curious then you changed your channel name. I was sad for selfish reasons since I no longer had someone to walk with from the beginning but i never stopped praying for you!! Still praying for you! Since Easter had passed i was curious today so I looked up “Protestant prays the rosary”! So I’m here to let you knew I’m praying for you and your family!!
That is great!
So exciting!
Our journeys have been side by side for awhile, though I’m not married. Lately I’ve been having Padre Pío “reach out” to me. That’s been a little terrifying as a Protestant, but it’s also so cool!
God bless you!
That is awesome! That’s how I have felt about St. Thomas Aquinas. He seems to be popping up everywhere.
Literally just yesterday I found out that the person who gave me the book Rome Sweet Home works in the Padre Pio building at his job. It's so crazy!
@@BecomingCatholic
For some reason, he keeps bringing books into my life and having someone leave a holy card or bring him up when talking to me. @@BecomingCatholic
I'm taking rcia/ocia classes right now, I'm not sure if I'm ready to convert, but I'm leaning in that direction. My spiritual journey has been long Latter-Day Saint, to Pentecostal, to Wiccan, to Methodist, and simply felt like there was something missing, but I do believe that its the real Presence that's missing. Thanks for sharing your journey.
Wow, great to hear! I’m a recent convert myself (confirmed in 2022) and come from a Protestant background with Pentecostal roots, Bible school and ministry experience, preaching etc. I went through an extremely similar experience to you. Even held off on becoming Catholic to also walk with my wife to make sure we could hopefully be received into the Church as a family. Would be happy to connect with you if you ever want to chat with someone who went through the same journey (specifically with waiting to be confirmed)!
I would definitely love to connect and hear more about your story. Email me at becomingcatholic@proton.me
I’m so pleased to watch this video! My husband and I converted in 2020, my youngest son converted last year, and my eldest son just entered RCIA. I have been following you since one of your first videos and I will be praying for you and your family!
Please, please pray for my eldest son (who is also named Nate ☺️) and for his marriage, which needs prayer, and his daughters. I look forward to seeing more content from you and following your journey. St. John Henry Newman, pray for us!
Amen! Thank you for sharing! I will say a Hail Mary for your son and his family.
Wonderful story! Greetings from the Netherlands.
Thank you!
It's so good to see you back! Thanks for the update! In regards to what you said about your channel becoming a ministry, I do recommend that when you do decide to become Catholic, you watch Keith Nester's video on something like 'First year of being Catholic'. I forget the exact name of the video. The point, though, is not to jump right in and be doing everything. Take it slow and find where your faith fits into your life.
Thank you! While I am very much interested and open to the idea, I have no plans to make the channel anything other than what it is now. Im just enjoying learning and growing
@@BecomingCatholic I wish you all the best and will continue to pray for you 🙏
Im so happy to see you back and that you have restarted your journey.
My husband and i were married 31 years ago, and he is a cradle Catholic. I was raised Latter Day Saint but left years ago.
Last year my husband had a health scare and long story short..i ended up in daily mass. The more i learned about Catholicism the more i loved. We raised all 4 of our children Catholic and i came and went to Mass here and there but i didnt feel it calling me as i do now. (My husband is all good health wise btw).
I started RCIA a few weeks ago and am so happy. I just love the Catholic faith.
I feel confident that you and your wife will make your way home eventually. Hopefully it doesnt take you 31 years like me. 😂
God Bless you and your sweet family. I will be watching your journey and praying for you.
Take care
Laura
Thank you for sharing Laura! That is an awesome story! Haha yeah I don’t expect it to take too long, although right now any amount of time feels like too kick time.
Welcome back! 😊
Thank you! 😁
Nate, thank you for sharing the journey that you and your wife are on right now. As I’ve mentioned before I’m a cradle Catholic (poorly catechized) and I left for a Pentecostal Church. As I slowly saunter back to Catholicism I’ve taken up with my devotions again. The Hallow app has been a help for me. I’m not sure if you’ve looked at it. I will be praying for you and your family. I can’t wait to watch your journey!! God bless.
Thank you for sharing! Yes o do have a subscription to the hallow app! I use it occasionally, however, I often say my prayers without it.
So glad you're back. Was concerned, I have thought of you regularly. Have you or your wife read Jesus Shock by Peter Kreeft? It isn't theological but it is apologetic. It is a FANTASTIC book which really expresses the whole picture of what we are to aim at. I highly recommend it. I will continue to pray for your family!
Thank you for the thoughts and recommendation. I haven’t read that book but I’m sure I will! I’m a big fan of Kreeft.
Good to hear from you and your wife. Prayers for you both 🙏 are you going to mass regularly?
Thank you! Much appreciated! We are not currently going to mass regularly because I still work full time at a Protestant church. We do have some plans to go in the future, but I’m currently working 2 jobs so it’s hard to find time
Hi Nate, is your channel going to post videos regularly? I’m not pushing lol I’m just so excited to see how it’s going! 😁
Hey Dawn! Thanks for commenting!
Somewhat! lol I'm don't have a strong posting schedule YET, but I will be actively working on new content to keep you all updated on my journey!
Thank you for answering😊
I am intrigued by the fact that your approach to Catholic Faith seems to happen in your readings or watching Catholic things. Is there any contact with the life of the Church, like attending Mass, Eucharistic Adoration, prayer groups...? Do you have any personal encounters with Catholic people, Priests, nuns, cathechists...? By the way, where do you live now, still in New York State? I am a Spanish friar and priest living now in Orange, New Jersey, Do you have a Facebook account?
If you are feeling that you want to become Catholic, that is because God himself is calling you. The same thing with your wife, if she is warming up to it, God is calling her as well. I am certain that you will reach the fullness of the faith, because once you open the door to Christ he is going to be there, calling you in your heart and in your mind, till you reach the goal. Bless you in your journey.