I could not agree more. I'm not a massive city boy, but also not super rural... I am the definitive subdivision kid, but I can very much relate to so much of this. Thanks for watching dC
Wow! I am so happy to stumble on this reaction to one of my favorite Rush songs. There are so many things I want to praise about your video, but to keep this short enough I will start by thanking you for sharing your personal "relationship" with this song. You put into words many of the feelings I have about the lyrics and the music. This was very enjoyable to watch and "share" with you. I can't wait to watch some of your other videos. I hope you have a successful trip and return better off for having made the sacrifice / journey. Peace and best wishes to you.
Why keep your comments short when I so obviously can't keep ANYTHING I do short!? :) :) Thank you for your kind words, and thank you to the almighty Algo for allowing you this stumble... I don't do ANY of the things I am supposed to do, so the algo is not often my friend! :) The trip has been interesting so far, played some Poker good and bad, done some writing (good and bad) and am currently doing urgent repairs to my show after 'mistakes were made' and a key sub-plot was kinda ruined! But, we carry on. I hope you will dip in and look at some other stuff, maybe even stuff you don't know - for me that is where the gold is often found... Thanks for coming, thanks for staying, thanks for playing Keep the faith dC
I read somewhere a while ago in guitar magazine I think during the counter parts album, Alex was interviewed about bringing back the guitar prominence and cut back on keyboard sounds that he said the analog kids solo was the fastest guitar picking solo he has done to that date of the interview
It has always stood out to me as one of the most shredding things he ever did. Often he is more soaring (Like Steve Rothery) but with this he just ripped it to pieces. One of my favourites, for sure And when combined with this great lyric... Perfection. Thanks for watching dC
Well said. Always that timeless reflection on the adolescent pull between childhood 'safety' and comfort of home, our family and the new life on the edge of his knowing but drawing him naturally away from 'home' to the wider world w/ peers and independence.
I have said no matter how the years have takin a tole on Geddy’s vocals I don’t think there is anyone else that can sing Neil’s lyrics like Geddy! I’ve said they were brought together. We are forever grateful for the incredible legacy these 3 amazing talented musicians are passing on.
Very, very true. Once you have heard a Geddy version of a lyric, it's hard to get that template out your head. That said, I do like it when people take a Rush song and own it. See, for instance, Jacob Moon's Subdivisions. He does not TRY to be Geddy, he makes it his own... and that is for sure the key. Only one Geddy (two if you count my since departed ginger cat, he was an OG Geddy too!) Thanks again for playing in the sandpit with me dC
Can't agree with you more. A stunning son, an amazing lyric. Part of the sound track of my life. Trip is going well, including winning a Poker tournament! Hoping to post again soon, as soon as I work out how to make it all work. A Rush series is in the offing. Thanks for watching dC
You are the lyrical master ! 😉 I get the charlie brown explanation , I love how you translate lyrics that have hidden meanings or show how such a lyric can mean something else or multiple things depending on the listening... The song you play before your journeys is your liminal.transition tune/album...👌 I hope south Safrica will go well for you again and it will be a safe 😊
I am beginning to realise that, as much as anything, this is not about reaction, it's about unpacking my own response to words and music and the world even knowing that it is ONLY my own. I guess my hope is that the specifics of my world view resonate with the people that watch. So far South Africa has been a wild ride, and I'm about to ride into a massive script battle to try and save the show I wrote from the people making it. So, wish me luck. As ever, thank you for taking this ride with me. BTW: Lyric master probably translate to 'blow-hard who talks too much'. I accept that! :) ktf dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 Ha ha ha no far from the talk too much blow hard ha ha ...YOu have an excellent way with words, and whether you are going through your own personal view and take on lyrics or other...you give us lyrical food for thought...For me personally , you also make me re think over my own life situations and re evalue a lot of things...You just have a way with words and its always great to hear your own personal stories or takes on life and lyrics...life and lyrics.....👌Thats it....you live a life through lyrics and i love it... We all use at some time or other...some more than others...songs to council us through our life situations..whether its , love, loss, happy moments...imagine a world without songs with lyrics.... our channel wouldnt even be here for starters! ha ha All the best in South Africa and look forward to your return 🤗😊👍
@@RetroReminiscing A life lived through and with, informed and infused with lyrics. This could not be more true. A few years back i made myself a ring... a treble clef and semi clef entwined. My nanny always said "rings on his fingers and bells his toes, he shall have music wherever he goes..." I now have music on my fingers because of that... But... It really should be "he shall have lyrics where ever he goes, whatever he talks about and pretty much all the time!" As ever, thank you so much for the kind words... I am very glad you are along for the ride. dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 Thats a brilliant little story ! I LOVE that! And yes, should be 'lyrics' wherever he goes for you ha ha ha ! This gave me a big smile reading about your nanny saying that to you about your ring you made...Gave me a warm feeling and a smile..lovely! 🖖💍🎶
@@RetroReminiscing Here's the thing I almost 9wish i had) forgot. I had the ring made, then it fell off my finger in the first week so I had to have it made AGAIN. Properly expensive mess up! :( I'm nothing if not a moron. :) dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 .....also amazing lyrics , themes, and atmosphere in Middletown Dreams ( glad you mentioned that tune). Mission and Mystic rhythms too 😀🎵😀 !!
I've finally could listened and watched this video, and, as usual, discovered au little bit more of this band, thanks to you. And yet, as usual, stirred by thoughts that come along with your words and thoughts
I'm glad you made the time. This is one of my lifetime favourite songs. I think I may do a deep dive into some Rush next, so, I hope you come along for the ride. As ever, thanks for joining me. ktf dC
Great analysis. This has always been one of my favourite songs by them. Neil paints such incredible pictures and that solo by Alex is blistering! I read somewhere that the girl Neil mentions is one that he liked when he was younger but was too shy to talk to. Hope you are enjoying South Africa. Cheers
I was pretty sure it had to be some specific reference. But i think we all have our own 'fawn eyed girl / boy' don't we? isn't that part of growing up? South Africa has been kinda intense so far, but we abide. Thanks for watching. dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 Yes, I think we all do as well. Well, it is still very cold and snowy here on the Canadian praries. It has been a long harsh winter.
@@debbieplato5107 meanwhile... here in the deep Sarf... 30 degrees, humid and hellish! (I'm TRYINg not to sound like I'm bragging!) Stay warm and well dC
As I've stated in past reactions, I absolutely love and appreciate your lyrical breakdowns. I was waiting, however, for you to mention the musical aspect as it too adds to the storytelling, doesn't it? It's what makes Rush as a whole one of the greatest bands ever. It seems they intentionally composed the music to be full of energy and excitement during the lyrics, dropping down to a dreamy sort of synth backed rhythm during the chorus. Masterful composing by virtuoso musicians. I love this band so much! 😃🤘
I also love this band, since I was 11! (43 years and counting! I do talk music, passim. But I also know I'm not super 'qualified' to talk music. I figure usually you can SEE me loving the music! But yes, I think as a prog rock boy, that compositional brilliance combined with them actually PLAYING it live to such a high standard was very much part of the appeal of Rush. I will try to remember to occasionally do more than nod along. I have promised myself that if I ever (long shot) crack 1000 subs I will do a lyric reaction to La Villa Strangiato! My single favourite Instrumental and maybe favourite track, period. :) :) Thanks for watching, and engaging. dC
let's not forget... and how can we... losing it... THAT breaks my heart and my soul and is sheer perfection too! One of my top pick albums, for sure. Thanks for watching dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 Agree. When I was young and foolish, Losing It was a song I fast forwarded through most times. Now I appreciate it MUCH more.
@@jasonwilliams6005 I've been freelance my whole life so the idea of losing the ability to earn a living has always been in my mind. (I could not talk for at least an hour after watching Guilty by Suspicion!) And even before then, as a teenager, something about 'for you the blind who once could see...' spoke to me. I remember arguing with my dad about the idea that losing what you had is sadder still. I was maybe 14! It was 40 years ago to day, sgt dodgy fought his dad to say... ;) dC
Did I? What a goober! I mean, I spent the last two summers in the north, i am aware! Maybe it was the dark santa suit You have not lived until you have had a southern summer - Christmas poolside! Such a goober :) dC
@@don-o-seven1437 Like I say, total goober. BUT At least I was quite POETIC in my brain fart. Also, fun fact, the winter sky in the highveldt is crystal cerulean blue - so, amma go with that as a totally made up excuse! :) dC
That was an excellent analysis best I've heard yet of this song I have to say. I would love to get your thoughts on so many other Rush songs so keep them coming!!!
Please feel free to let me know what ones you would like to see. I promised myself when i started this I would NOT do the really big ones that all the 'confirmation bias' reactors do - but I'm happy to see your list and see if there are any that I feel I have particular affinity for. Thanks for watching dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 off the top of my head, I would say the pass, nobody's hero, driven, one little victory, half the world, and anything from clockwork Angels, let's face it that was a work of art.
My absolute top Rush song lyrically. I love dozens of songs but always have this one in the rotation. Which Hunt and Red Sector A in my top 10. But I thing better than this…I always see myself as the kid with a blade of grass stuck between his teeth, laying on a hill staring at clouds thinking about life. Then pulling his baseball cap over his eyes to hold that moment in time.
Yeah, I think a lot of men 'of a certain age' relate to that image. I love Red Sector A, maybe should look at that one, esp now with what is happening in the world. Thanks for watching. dC
A while back someone described what Alex does as COMPOSITIONAL, as opposed to free flowing... So I once he has composed the solo, that is mostly the solo with, maybe a few flourishes and embellishments. I tend to feel this suits their work, usually, what is on the album feels like the most perfect form for a solo, so I like it when he nails it... La Villa is a perfect example of that. When he messes with the second solo 9is it monsters) I never feel like it's quite as good as the album... but that is also probably patter recognition, nostalgia and familiarity. One thing is for sure, in a band with arguably the best drummer and bass player of their genre and generation, Alex does NOT ever let the side down. he should be mentioned more alongside the other 'greats'. Thanks for watching dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 His solos always sound so appropriate for the songs that I've sometimes had a hard time enjoying some other groups because they just didn't match up so well. I'm sure I've missed out on a lot of other good music. Hope you are doing well and enjoying your gig in the south. :)
First! (again!) 🤣
I know, I know, I'm an ass...
I was that prairie boy from Western Canada, lived away for 28yrs now. This is the perfect song, lyrics, music, perfection.
I could not agree more. I'm not a massive city boy, but also not super rural... I am the definitive subdivision kid, but I can very much relate to so much of this.
Thanks for watching
dC
Wow! I am so happy to stumble on this reaction to one of my favorite Rush songs. There are so many things I want to praise about your video, but to keep this short enough I will start by thanking you for sharing your personal "relationship" with this song.
You put into words many of the feelings I have about the lyrics and the music. This was very enjoyable to watch and "share" with you.
I can't wait to watch some of your other videos. I hope you have a successful trip and return better off for having made the sacrifice / journey.
Peace and best wishes to you.
Why keep your comments short when I so obviously can't keep ANYTHING I do short!?
:) :)
Thank you for your kind words, and thank you to the almighty Algo for allowing you this stumble... I don't do ANY of the things I am supposed to do, so the algo is not often my friend! :)
The trip has been interesting so far, played some Poker good and bad, done some writing (good and bad) and am currently doing urgent repairs to my show after 'mistakes were made' and a key sub-plot was kinda ruined!
But, we carry on.
I hope you will dip in and look at some other stuff, maybe even stuff you don't know - for me that is where the gold is often found...
Thanks for coming, thanks for staying, thanks for playing
Keep the faith
dC
I read somewhere a while ago in guitar magazine I think during the counter parts album, Alex was interviewed about bringing back the guitar prominence and cut back on keyboard sounds that he said the analog kids solo was the fastest guitar picking solo he has done to that date of the interview
It has always stood out to me as one of the most shredding things he ever did. Often he is more soaring (Like Steve Rothery) but with this he just ripped it to pieces.
One of my favourites, for sure
And when combined with this great lyric... Perfection.
Thanks for watching
dC
Well said. Always that timeless reflection on the adolescent pull between childhood 'safety' and comfort of home, our family and the new life on the edge of his knowing but drawing him naturally away from 'home' to the wider world w/ peers and independence.
You say well said, but honestly, you just said it WAY better than i did... and WQAY shorter too!
Thanks for watching
dC
I have said no matter how the years have takin a tole on Geddy’s vocals I don’t think there is anyone else that can sing Neil’s lyrics like Geddy! I’ve said they were brought together. We are forever grateful for the incredible legacy these 3 amazing talented musicians are passing on.
Very, very true.
Once you have heard a Geddy version of a lyric, it's hard to get that template out your head.
That said, I do like it when people take a Rush song and own it.
See, for instance, Jacob Moon's Subdivisions.
He does not TRY to be Geddy, he makes it his own... and that is for sure the key.
Only one Geddy (two if you count my since departed ginger cat, he was an OG Geddy too!)
Thanks again for playing in the sandpit with me
dC
One of the greatest songs ever written, period! A lyrical gem as well as a sonic thrill ride! Thanks much for this one, and oh yes, happy travels! ☮😊
Can't agree with you more. A stunning son, an amazing lyric. Part of the sound track of my life. Trip is going well, including winning a Poker tournament! Hoping to post again soon, as soon as I work out how to make it all work. A Rush series is in the offing.
Thanks for watching
dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 WOW! A RUSH FAN AND A POKER OFFICIANADO, LIFE IS GOOD !😊☮
@@thegman8968 More like a Rush fan and Poker de-gen! :)
You are the lyrical master ! 😉 I get the charlie brown explanation , I love how you translate lyrics that have hidden meanings or show how such a lyric can mean something else or multiple things depending on the listening...
The song you play before your journeys is your liminal.transition tune/album...👌
I hope south Safrica will go well for you again and it will be a safe 😊
I am beginning to realise that, as much as anything, this is not about reaction, it's about unpacking my own response to words and music and the world even knowing that it is ONLY my own. I guess my hope is that the specifics of my world view resonate with the people that watch.
So far South Africa has been a wild ride, and I'm about to ride into a massive script battle to try and save the show I wrote from the people making it.
So, wish me luck.
As ever, thank you for taking this ride with me.
BTW: Lyric master probably translate to 'blow-hard who talks too much'. I accept that!
:)
ktf
dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 Ha ha ha no far from the talk too much blow hard ha ha ...YOu have an excellent way with words, and whether you are going through your own personal view and take on lyrics or other...you give us lyrical food for thought...For me personally , you also make me re think over my own life situations and re evalue a lot of things...You just have a way with words and its always great to hear your own personal stories or takes on life and lyrics...life and lyrics.....👌Thats it....you live a life through lyrics and i love it... We all use at some time or other...some more than others...songs to council us through our life situations..whether its , love, loss, happy moments...imagine a world without songs with lyrics.... our channel wouldnt even be here for starters! ha ha All the best in South Africa and look forward to your return 🤗😊👍
@@RetroReminiscing A life lived through and with, informed and infused with lyrics. This could not be more true.
A few years back i made myself a ring... a treble clef and semi clef entwined.
My nanny always said "rings on his fingers and bells his toes, he shall have music wherever he goes..."
I now have music on my fingers because of that...
But... It really should be "he shall have lyrics where ever he goes, whatever he talks about and pretty much all the time!"
As ever, thank you so much for the kind words... I am very glad you are along for the ride.
dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 Thats a brilliant little story ! I LOVE that! And yes, should be 'lyrics' wherever he goes for you ha ha ha ! This gave me a big smile reading about your nanny saying that to you about your ring you made...Gave me a warm feeling and a smile..lovely! 🖖💍🎶
@@RetroReminiscing Here's the thing I almost 9wish i had) forgot. I had the ring made, then it fell off my finger in the first week so I had to have it made AGAIN. Properly expensive mess up!
:(
I'm nothing if not a moron.
:)
dC
Great reaction to one of my favourite Rush songs. You have a new sub 🇨🇦
Thank you, sir.
One sub closer to my La Villa lyric review!
'Preciate the support.
dC
Brilliant reaction of a Brilliant song !! And album,,,,,everything works on this album. Music, synths too, and great lyrics !!
You're very kind to say so,
thank you
And yes, one of my top albums of all time.
dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 .....also amazing lyrics , themes, and atmosphere in Middletown Dreams ( glad you mentioned that tune). Mission and Mystic rhythms too 😀🎵😀 !!
@@johntabakos1295 I DID Middletown dreams. Quit early in the channel. I'm adding Mystic - maybe to do it while I am here in South Africa.
I've finally could listened and watched this video, and, as usual, discovered au little bit more of this band, thanks to you. And yet, as usual, stirred by thoughts that come along with your words and thoughts
I'm glad you made the time.
This is one of my lifetime favourite songs.
I think I may do a deep dive into some Rush next, so, I hope you come along for the ride.
As ever, thanks for joining me.
ktf
dC
❤️-ed this. Always travelling from moment to moment!
Very kind of you to say so, thank you for watching.
Keep the faith
dC
Great analysis. This has always been one of my favourite songs by them. Neil paints such incredible pictures and that solo by Alex is blistering! I read somewhere that the girl Neil mentions is one that he liked when he was younger but was too shy to talk to. Hope you are enjoying South Africa. Cheers
I was pretty sure it had to be some specific reference. But i think we all have our own 'fawn eyed girl / boy' don't we? isn't that part of growing up?
South Africa has been kinda intense so far, but we abide.
Thanks for watching.
dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 Yes, I think we all do as well. Well,
it is still very cold and snowy here on the Canadian praries. It has been a long harsh winter.
@@debbieplato5107 meanwhile... here in the deep Sarf... 30 degrees, humid and hellish!
(I'm TRYINg not to sound like I'm bragging!)
Stay warm and well
dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 Enjoy the heat, It is supposed to warm up a bit next week and get above freezing. 🤞
@@debbieplato5107 meanwhile... we pray for rain! Always
Ktf
dC
As I've stated in past reactions, I absolutely love and appreciate your lyrical breakdowns. I was waiting, however, for you to mention the musical aspect as it too adds to the storytelling, doesn't it? It's what makes Rush as a whole one of the greatest bands ever. It seems they intentionally composed the music to be full of energy and excitement during the lyrics, dropping down to a dreamy sort of synth backed rhythm during the chorus. Masterful composing by virtuoso musicians. I love this band so much! 😃🤘
I also love this band, since I was 11! (43 years and counting!
I do talk music, passim.
But I also know I'm not super 'qualified' to talk music.
I figure usually you can SEE me loving the music!
But yes, I think as a prog rock boy, that compositional brilliance combined with them actually PLAYING it live to such a high standard was very much part of the appeal of Rush.
I will try to remember to occasionally do more than nod along.
I have promised myself that if I ever (long shot) crack 1000 subs I will do a lyric reaction to La Villa Strangiato!
My single favourite Instrumental and maybe favourite track, period.
:) :)
Thanks for watching, and engaging.
dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 Haha! That is fantastic 👏
I will look forward to THAT 😃
@@jonathanspahn7308 1000 subs could be a LONG way away, but we live in hope!
Subdivisions and New World Man got most of the attention, but this has always been my favorite song from the album. Hope you have a great trip.
let's not forget... and how can we... losing it... THAT breaks my heart and my soul and is sheer perfection too!
One of my top pick albums, for sure.
Thanks for watching
dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 Agree. When I was young and foolish, Losing It was a song I fast forwarded through most times. Now I appreciate it MUCH more.
@@jasonwilliams6005 I've been freelance my whole life so the idea of losing the ability to earn a living has always been in my mind. (I could not talk for at least an hour after watching Guilty by Suspicion!)
And even before then, as a teenager, something about 'for you the blind who once could see...' spoke to me.
I remember arguing with my dad about the idea that losing what you had is sadder still. I was maybe 14!
It was 40 years ago to day, sgt dodgy fought his dad to say... ;)
dC
Had to laugh, the august leaves are not winter here in the northern hemisphere. It is deep summer prior to autumn, bright sunshine and heat.
Did I?
What a goober!
I mean, I spent the last two summers in the north, i am aware!
Maybe it was the dark santa suit
You have not lived until you have had a southern summer - Christmas poolside!
Such a goober
:)
dC
8:29 “under the winter skies of the rural idle” :)
@@don-o-seven1437 Like I say, total goober.
BUT
At least I was quite POETIC in my brain fart.
Also, fun fact, the winter sky in the highveldt is crystal cerulean blue - so, amma go with that as a totally made up excuse!
:)
dC
That was an excellent analysis best I've heard yet of this song I have to say. I would love to get your thoughts on so many other Rush songs so keep them coming!!!
Please feel free to let me know what ones you would like to see.
I promised myself when i started this I would NOT do the really big ones that all the 'confirmation bias' reactors do - but I'm happy to see your list and see if there are any that I feel I have particular affinity for.
Thanks for watching
dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 off the top of my head, I would say the pass, nobody's hero, driven, one little victory, half the world, and anything from clockwork Angels, let's face it that was a work of art.
@@ginamarandino6451 I'm making a list, I'm counting it twice.
Watch the skies.
:)
dC
@@ginamarandino6451 And yes, I think Ca might be in the top 5 albums they EVER made. Sheer brilliance.
I love you his song and this album!
It is one of my all time greats, for sure.
Thank you for watching
dC
x
My absolute top Rush song lyrically. I love dozens of songs but always have this one in the rotation. Which Hunt and Red Sector A in my top 10. But I thing better than this…I always see myself as the kid with a blade of grass stuck between his teeth, laying on a hill staring at clouds thinking about life. Then pulling his baseball cap over his eyes to hold that moment in time.
Yeah, I think a lot of men 'of a certain age' relate to that image.
I love Red Sector A, maybe should look at that one, esp now with what is happening in the world.
Thanks for watching.
dC
Alex stuck pretty close to the studio version of the solo. Sometimes he goes a lot further. All good. :) Rockin', yep. :)
A while back someone described what Alex does as COMPOSITIONAL, as opposed to free flowing... So I once he has composed the solo, that is mostly the solo with, maybe a few flourishes and embellishments. I tend to feel this suits their work, usually, what is on the album feels like the most perfect form for a solo, so I like it when he nails it... La Villa is a perfect example of that. When he messes with the second solo 9is it monsters) I never feel like it's quite as good as the album... but that is also probably patter recognition, nostalgia and familiarity. One thing is for sure, in a band with arguably the best drummer and bass player of their genre and generation, Alex does NOT ever let the side down. he should be mentioned more alongside the other 'greats'.
Thanks for watching
dC
@@dodgycamreacts-lyricsinabo5170 His solos always sound so appropriate for the songs that I've sometimes had a hard time enjoying some other groups because they just didn't match up so well. I'm sure I've missed out on a lot of other good music. Hope you are doing well and enjoying your gig in the south. :)
I hope all is well with you? :)