@@JacktheRah Might just need to Remove The "Soviet Union" &. "Socialist World Republic" off the Lyrics and replace them what you vision as appropriate for a Anarchist Song, and probably replace "Red Banner of Labour" into a "Black and Red banner"
It's interesting how you went with "Eure" instead of "Alle". I'm not sure if that's authentic, but it makes more sense. This is easily the best rendition of this song publicly available
I like this one for it's home-quality. But have you heard the one by Ernst Busch? Not trying to compare the singer to Ernst Busch, that would be unfair and I like this singer, he does a good job and I love his bella ciao and Abraham Lincoln Brigade!
It can could only make more sense, if the songwriter had messed it up - which is not the case. It's "alle" (all) , because it is not just the hearts of those in the movement that should be ablaze, but those of every worker in the world. Where as "eure" is simply "your" in plural - which wouldn't have the same weight. Lyrics in question from the original: ..."Zerschlagt die faschistischen Räuberheere, setzt alle Herzen in Brand. Pflanzt eure roten Banner der Arbeit Auf jede Rampe, auf jede Fabrik!"...
It's very weird that your voice can sound so different depending on what language you are speaking. If I had heard just the audio from this video and one of your english vocals, I would probably think they were two completely different people. Edit: Good work btw!
This song is the video with the most views. I'm a little happy with that since this is my second favorite German song with Einheitsfrontlied being my favorite. And he's done both!
Well done once more, there is talent, there is hard work and then there is both. I am not musically talented, so I couldn't properly ascertain about someone else's talents but Monsieur Jack seems to possess both talent and hard work.
That has to be one of your best arrangments so far, I've had goosebumps for every second of the song. I'd even go as far as saying I like it better than the original version.
Well done! The lyrics to the song were written in 1927 and set to music by Hanns Eisler in 1931 in the version presented. The Stalinist counter-revolution had not yet reached its peak. Grotesquely enough, the German Reichswehr had been testing its weapons in the Soviet Union under the strictest secrecy since 1924, financed by the "Ruhr Fund", i.e. the industrialists of the German armaments companies gagged by the Treaty of Versailles (Thyssen, Krupp etc.). This went on until 1933 and cost two million Reichsmarks a year. Most of the German soldiers and officers trained in the Soviet Union during this period were then involved in the invasion of the Soviet Union in 1941. By this time, the Soviet Union was no longer the "heart of the revolution"; the Stalinists had already torn it out themselves and liquidated the old guard of the Bolsheviks en masse. So much for the background - I still like listening to the song. But instead of the verse "Denn der Angriff gegen die Sowjetunion ist der Stoß ins Herz der Revolution" ("Because the attack against the Soviet Union is the thrust into the heart of the revolution"), I sing "Jeder Krieg zwischen Nation und Nation ist Krieg gen die Arbeiterrevolution!" ("Every war between nation and nation is a war against the workers' revolution!".) The verse "Es flüstert von allen Kontinenten Mobilmachung gegen die Sowjetunion" ("Whispers from all continents Mobilisation against the Soviet Union") I replace the last part by "Mobilmachung gegen eine böse Nation", "Mobilisation against an evil nation". This fits in better with today's world, in which the warmongers once again have the upper hand.
I'm always excited as soon as I see a new upload from you :) Pretty good German for a non-native speaker as well, as a suggestion: The German Version of Warszawianka?
Listen to our marches, comrades, when you are attacked by the fascists. gives us strength and power. for our socialist fight. for fellow workers. for our deceased comrades.
I'm from Brazil, and situation over there with Bolsonaro is simply shitty. Food prices are skyrocketing, because the agrobusiness send all soy to other countries while they destroy our rainforests, Bolsonaro has already sent a phrase of Mussolini in his facebook, he had a Minister of Culture that repeated a speech from Goebbels... Since I became a communist, I've been watching your videos, and I love it! Could you please do the anthem of MST (Movimento dos Sem Terra, the Landless' movement)? Or "Marcha dos Pescadores". I would love it!
Sai daí Comuna, vai para o paredão, isso vem de muitos anos, essa crise é por causa do coronavirus e nada podia ser feito, Bolsonaro tem fortes alianças com Israel, definitivamente não é fascista.
kkkkkk Sério que você está comparando o imbecil do Bolsonaro ao Fascismo ou ao Nacional-Socialismo por conta do ministro que ele demitiu (parecia ser um bom ministro) e porque ele usou uma frase que todo mundo usa e que é do Mussolini? Parece que se tornar comunista deixa as pessoas burras mesmo.
@@igormsh14bidevisualizacoes45 Ah, você acha isso por acaso? E todo mundo quem? Aliás, o mero fato e você pressupor que eu sou comunista já te torna burro, pois até tem monarquista que odeia o Bolsonaro.
@@igormsh14bidevisualizacoes45 Eu adoro como seu argumento é criar um constraste entre a imbecilidade e o nazismo quando ambas são coisas que caminham lado a lado. Nem todo imbecil é nazista, mas todo nazista é um imbecil.
@@igormsh14bidevisualizacoes45 Afinal, como que chama um grupo de pessoas que diz uma coisa e que quando é confrontada com evidência científica se limita a chamar faculdades premiadas de "judias" ou "marxistas"?
Beautiful! I from russia, and i want to play on cam this song (i have planned in future upload video) on guitar and accordion. Although my knowledge of German or English languages is poor. Fur die Arbeiterklasse, Genosse!
Have you ever considered doing The Sacred War (Священная война (Svjaščénnaja vojná))? I love that song and since you're pretty great at singing in foreign languages (foreign for you), I feel like it could be really cool. Just an idea. ^-^
Monsier Jack is a true comrade, singing even in the middle of a esrthquake.
Yosaf when you still need to make a video for the great Soviet Union
it is the march of the working class, do you feel it?
I wanna like but it's at 69
Edit: ok I'll like it now
It's the power of his notes that create an earthquake
Lol
id personally like to hear a version of this song rewritten for the modern day
Possibly English?
There is a more "modern" version but that's from 1957 as well.
I'd like to see a more modern, more anarchist version of it.
Mhmm. You should get on that
@@JacktheRah but anarchy and socialism are two different things
@@JacktheRah Might just need to Remove The "Soviet Union" &. "Socialist World Republic" off the Lyrics and replace them what you vision as appropriate for a Anarchist Song, and probably replace "Red Banner of Labour" into a "Black and Red banner"
Fantastic! Japanese comrades are healed by your piano.
貴方のピアノ演奏は素晴らしい！日本から敬意を表明します！
nato minister's cry is so loud that it shoke the camera
Aha yine buldum seni
@@safabi7577 naber
@@ArnWuhridenn iyi senden naber
@@safabi7577 ben de iyi
bu offene değil heimliche
As a native speaker I can say the pronounciation is sometimes really on point👍
äöü
Üöğşç
Manchmal...
Meine Aussprache ist besser
It's interesting how you went with "Eure" instead of "Alle". I'm not sure if that's authentic, but it makes more sense.
This is easily the best rendition of this song publicly available
I like this one for it's home-quality. But have you heard the one by Ernst Busch?
Not trying to compare the singer to Ernst Busch, that would be unfair and I like this singer, he does a good job and I love his bella ciao and Abraham Lincoln Brigade!
It can could only make more sense, if the songwriter had messed it up - which is not the case. It's "alle" (all) , because it is not just the hearts of those in the movement that should be ablaze, but those of every worker in the world.
Where as "eure" is simply "your" in plural - which wouldn't have the same weight.
Lyrics in question from the original:
..."Zerschlagt die faschistischen Räuberheere,
setzt alle Herzen in Brand.
Pflanzt eure roten Banner der Arbeit
Auf jede Rampe, auf jede Fabrik!"...
As a German speaker I can say that it's amazing even if there are some mispronounced words
I am not a native German speaker, and I can tell that there are a lot of mispronounced words. Not “some.”
@@TheWalrus163 it was overall very clean. A few words were off but I understood everything perfectly
@@TheWalrus163I am a native germand and it was perfectly clean.
It's very weird that your voice can sound so different depending on what language you are speaking. If I had heard just the audio from this video and one of your english vocals, I would probably think they were two completely different people.
Edit: Good work btw!
It will be great if you play Anthem of Comintern for the next time. Good job!
My favorite German Song done in a really amazing way. This was alot easier to sing along to than trying to follow along with Ernst Busch's voice
as always, this was fantastic. You should consider doing "when johnny comes marching home again
Большое спасибо! Браво! Слушаю стоя!
@Топпатский маппер
Враньё!
This song is the video with the most views. I'm a little happy with that since this is my second favorite German song with Einheitsfrontlied being my favorite. And he's done both!
Well done once more, there is talent, there is hard work and then there is both. I am not musically talented, so I couldn't properly ascertain about someone else's talents but Monsieur Jack seems to possess both talent and hard work.
This is one of my favorite songs ever.
That has to be one of your best arrangments so far, I've had goosebumps for every second of the song. I'd even go as far as saying I like it better than the original version.
Glad to see you back!
really love your music i look forward to it
I can't spell today, but you are good at what you do and keep it up.
Well done!
The lyrics to the song were written in 1927 and set to music by Hanns Eisler in 1931 in the version presented. The Stalinist counter-revolution had not yet reached its peak. Grotesquely enough, the German Reichswehr had been testing its weapons in the Soviet Union under the strictest secrecy since 1924, financed by the "Ruhr Fund", i.e. the industrialists of the German armaments companies gagged by the Treaty of Versailles (Thyssen, Krupp etc.). This went on until 1933 and cost two million Reichsmarks a year. Most of the German soldiers and officers trained in the Soviet Union during this period were then involved in the invasion of the Soviet Union in 1941. By this time, the Soviet Union was no longer the "heart of the revolution"; the Stalinists had already torn it out themselves and liquidated the old guard of the Bolsheviks en masse.
So much for the background - I still like listening to the song. But instead of the verse "Denn der Angriff gegen die Sowjetunion ist der Stoß ins Herz der Revolution" ("Because the attack against the Soviet Union is the thrust into the heart of the revolution"), I sing "Jeder Krieg zwischen Nation und Nation ist Krieg gen die Arbeiterrevolution!" ("Every war between nation and nation is a war against the workers' revolution!".) The verse "Es flüstert von allen Kontinenten Mobilmachung gegen die Sowjetunion" ("Whispers from all continents Mobilisation against the Soviet Union") I replace the last part by "Mobilmachung gegen eine böse Nation", "Mobilisation against an evil nation". This fits in better with today's world, in which the warmongers once again have the upper hand.
I'm always excited as soon as I see a new upload from you :)
Pretty good German for a non-native speaker as well,
as a suggestion: The German Version of Warszawianka?
Это прекрасно !!!
when jack uploads it brings me so much joy when things lighten up here in eastern TN ill drink a toast to you abeit it may be a bud light
Я русский Коммунист
I'm Russian communist!
Forward to victory
Forward to communism!
Kurdish communists are with you
@@albtraumderhochfinanz7573 with **US**
@@Gabelel ahh, correct, i'm sorry, comrade. I meant , we're with all communists on the world
Chinese ccp doing well
Ты за нод?????? Они враги народа., ты предатель, с не коммунист. Сталин таких расстреливал нахер
I'm not a communist supporter but this is a beautiful work of art that should get more views
you have nothing to lose but your chains comrade
What would you describe your ideology as being? But yes this guy's got some good talent
if you are part of the working class, you should be
Agreed, Socialist music is something else and i love it.
@@comradecapybara Depends on if losing my chains means I have to bow to a "dictatorship of the proletariat"
Federal law requires an instrumental version be uploaded next.
Beautiful!
And pretty good german pronounciation :-)
I have a strange request, but its an interesting one and I love your stuff: Swallowing Dust. Its a rather sad song about the Soviet Afghan war.
Ur voice is revolutionary, comrade!!
Wonderful version, played so well you can overcome mispronounciations. Great work
My favorite song tanks
your voice is insane
ИМММММММБА!
I love that song :D
I have been listening to the song for a year)
Its wonderful, just remember the ü ö and ä pronunciations and its perfect!
One of my favorite songs
Can you keep up the theme of German communist songs with wenn as aben wird or Krupp und Krause
Why as a centrist we never get such fire music but only the radicals do?
Becausw centrist is fucked up as well
What the hell are you gonna sing to? “We love the status quo”
Listen to our marches, comrades, when you are attacked by the fascists. gives us strength and power. for our socialist fight. for fellow workers. for our deceased comrades.
The song feels so powerful you can feel it in your soul
FINIALLY! THANKS SO SO MUCH!
ulan bu adamı bir ikimiz izliyoruz trden galiba
Incredible work as usual comrade!
Awesome video!
Bro keep it up!Very good piano player!
Great job. The version i first heard is much more talked than sung but thats good too
Pięknie
Greatest version of the song
I cant help but sing with you. Amazing
Can you do ta-ra-ra-boom-de-ay/ the wooden shoe next? I love that song so much
wow, you're killing it with the german pronunciation. and the vocals are beautiful. thank you for sharing, comrade
this is better!
Awesome :)
I love it 😳💕💕💕
Beautiful
I really like your voice
Очень классно! Спасибо! Коммунизм победит во всем мире!
name one ideologie that makes better songs? i wait
DUUUUDE THAT WAS FIRE! YOUR VOICE IS FIRE BROO. KEEP IT UP AND MAYBE DO UNTERWEGS
I'm from Brazil, and situation over there with Bolsonaro is simply shitty. Food prices are skyrocketing, because the agrobusiness send all soy to other countries while they destroy our rainforests, Bolsonaro has already sent a phrase of Mussolini in his facebook, he had a Minister of Culture that repeated a speech from Goebbels...
Since I became a communist, I've been watching your videos, and I love it! Could you please do the anthem of MST (Movimento dos Sem Terra, the Landless' movement)? Or "Marcha dos Pescadores". I would love it!
Sai daí Comuna, vai para o paredão, isso vem de muitos anos, essa crise é por causa do coronavirus e nada podia ser feito, Bolsonaro tem fortes alianças com Israel, definitivamente não é fascista.
kkkkkk Sério que você está comparando o imbecil do Bolsonaro ao Fascismo ou ao Nacional-Socialismo por conta do ministro que ele demitiu (parecia ser um bom ministro) e porque ele usou uma frase que todo mundo usa e que é do Mussolini?
Parece que se tornar comunista deixa as pessoas burras mesmo.
@@igormsh14bidevisualizacoes45 Ah, você acha isso por acaso? E todo mundo quem?
Aliás, o mero fato e você pressupor que eu sou comunista já te torna burro, pois até tem monarquista que odeia o Bolsonaro.
@@igormsh14bidevisualizacoes45 Eu adoro como seu argumento é criar um constraste entre a imbecilidade e o nazismo quando ambas são coisas que caminham lado a lado. Nem todo imbecil é nazista, mas todo nazista é um imbecil.
@@igormsh14bidevisualizacoes45 Afinal, como que chama um grupo de pessoas que diz uma coisa e que quando é confrontada com evidência científica se limita a chamar faculdades premiadas de "judias" ou "marxistas"?
Beautiful! I from russia, and i want to play on cam this song (i have planned in future upload video) on guitar and accordion. Although my knowledge of German or English languages is poor.
Fur die Arbeiterklasse, Genosse!
my day is joyful today with this music
You have mein respekt.
Мне очень нравится 👏🏼
That's soooo gooood. Love from Germany
Saudações do Brasil
Have you ever considered doing The Sacred War (Священная война (Svjaščénnaja vojná))? I love that song and since you're pretty great at singing in foreign languages (foreign for you), I feel like it could be really cool. Just an idea. ^-^
This dude has some talent!
BRAVOOOOOO VERY NICE
FROM ARGENTINA
2021
Very nice From USSR.
I'm from Russia . In the future of the USSR
Слава Коммунизму! ☭
That was insane
Love it
you german pronunciation is perfect my good sir
Based, Gute Arbeit Kamerad.
It would be awesome if you did the song of the united front comrade
Daaaymnnn cover so good the camera starts shaking
awesomeeeee
Joder es espectacular
You only missed the sound of the Umlaut letters, but your pronunciation is on point.
not as mighty as the original. But it's still good to listen to, keep up the good work.
Could you do Lied der unruhevollen Jugend (Song of the restless youth) next please?
Реинкорнация Эрнеста Буша?
I love your songs! I love your praxis, how many languages do you speak? Greetings, salud y anarquía!
May you play Wos wollen wir trinken for a next video?
our piano
nice kameraden
gute Arbeit kamerad!
Time for the workers revolution!!!
EAST GERMAN - BEST GERMAN
Привет с России
Based
Just a tip, ö is pronounced like "uh" ;)
is writted "auf jede acker auf jede fabrik"" but is "auf jede rampe , und jede fabrik"
"Acker" is correct. Somebody on the Ernst Busch video f-ed up the subtitles.
@@JoetheDilo1917 oh ok, i didnt know that, thx for correction
Wow that's wonderful!
I'm wondering if I can take this music for my Animatic, for the end credits in my video?
Thanks Google translate.
Love from india 🇮🇳🇷🇺🇩🇪 upload more
this accent
Can u do "Die Arbeiter von Wien"/"Wir sind das Bauvolk" (The Workers of Vienna"'/"We are the builders") too?
Do some DDR songs.
I want to hear black metal version of this song.
Everyone Gangsta till the German Kid called out “die sozialistische Weltrepublik”
Make an english version
Ernst busch 🥰👍🏿
✊
FOR SOVIET UNION
I'm pretty sure the only reason Communism is still popular is because of BANGER music like this
communism will be popular as long as capitalism or some other form of oppression by the minority of the majority exists
Would love to hear your take on Der offene Aufmarsch.