Is Better Call Saul Better than Breaking Bad??

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 232

  • @autwolfleo6764
    @autwolfleo6764 2 роки тому +322

    I guess Garnt’s Breaking Bad complaint is “Can something be so good that it is bad”

    • @TheAnizenYT
      @TheAnizenYT 2 роки тому +75

      He's really the first person I know who's said "It's so good it's bad"

    • @hieple4164
      @hieple4164 2 роки тому +3

      @@TheAnizenYT He didn't tho? The heck are you guys on?

    • @rifway22
      @rifway22 2 роки тому +21

      It's like The Grapes of Wrath or The Great Gatsby, they are flawless books and lauded by literary critics as the pinnacle of their medium, but I find them boring and rather read LOTR for the 5th time.

    • @openmind4060
      @openmind4060 2 роки тому +2

      @@rifway22 oh no, Garnt is not alone

    • @billybucks9963
      @billybucks9963 2 роки тому

      @@rifway22 this how I feel about rappers like ice cube like their rhyme schemes and lyrics are praised highly but that shit just wack to me I can’t vibe to it

  • @comixproviderftw_02
    @comixproviderftw_02 2 роки тому +182

    I never thought Better Call Saul would get that praise, hype or dare I say, the meme status it’s gained this past year. I only saw the first season, and I never got around to watching the second season when it premiered. It’s mostly because I forgot all about it, it also didn’t help with the two or three year breaks it kept getting but it’s good that the entire Breaking Bad saga is flawless in every way.

    • @lordbauer5983
      @lordbauer5983 2 роки тому +19

      It only started taking an extra year hiatus with seasons 5 & 6, but I hear you. I think BCS was always destined to get more respect AFTER the finale aired.
      It’s not as bombastic as BB was, so there weren’t half as many “holy shit” moments in this one that would encourage viewers to rush back week after week to see what happens next.
      It’s a very laconic experience, but it’s never lethargic. There’s always something exciting happening, but it’s never excessive. I recently binged watched all 6 seasons over the last two months and I firmly believe that the show was made to be viewed in quick succession like this, where you can see how intricately patterned the story is from front to back with less risk of missing/forgetting details.
      Just like Mad Men before it, BCS feels more like reading a novel than watching a tv show.

    • @royalfun1031
      @royalfun1031 2 роки тому

      Same
      I watched the first ep of S2

    • @FredMaverik
      @FredMaverik 2 роки тому

      the first two entire seasons are slow bros. The show only really starts ar 3 or after it.

    • @JaydevRaol
      @JaydevRaol 2 роки тому

      Yeah but it's so good.

  • @hundvd_7
    @hundvd_7 2 роки тому +110

    8:10 Joey's pun got robbed of the attention it deserves
    I love Methaverse

  • @chikasnotmadjustdisappoint6266
    @chikasnotmadjustdisappoint6266 2 роки тому +143

    I simultaneously understand and don't understand Garnt's reasoning to why he doesn't like Breaking Bad.

    • @josemariareyes3448
      @josemariareyes3448 2 роки тому +9

      username fits so well

    • @LORDdrPepper
      @LORDdrPepper 2 роки тому +32

      He didn't say he doesn't like it, I think he's just doing a shit job at explaining what he actually means. From what I gathered, he thinks it's a good show but isn't as attached to it as someone usually would be when they like a show

    • @johnthai6188
      @johnthai6188 2 роки тому +19

      @@LORDdrPepper it's kinda like, how you know everything in a story is firing on all cylinders, on how well it's written, acted, directed etc., but for some reason you aren't emotionally attached to the story. something like the movie called moonlight has this for me. where i can see the story is firing on all cylinders, but i'm not emotionally attached to the story.

    • @wasabi.2839
      @wasabi.2839 2 роки тому +41

      @@johnthai6188 You can appreciated something that it's done so well, without being attached emotionally. You can appreciate The Godfather Part l and ll but your favorite movies are Deadpool or Avengers: Endgame, lol. It's a matter of subjectivity imo of what resonates with your o not.

    • @fat1fared
      @fat1fared 2 роки тому +2

      I actually think Moonlight is a much better example of what Grant is getting at because it was peak Oscar bait.
      What he really means is that US TV is put together in an almost clinical and cynical way that ensures it is objectively good and has mass worldwide appeal.
      The problem is that Breaking Bad is probably not a great example of this because the show really shouldn’t have worked, right down to its premise.

  • @pokekiller787x
    @pokekiller787x 2 роки тому +84

    I prefer Breaking Bad, but Better Call Saul is not far behind, this franchise is masterful in so many ways and it deserves all the praise it receives.

  • @brandonmyers4050
    @brandonmyers4050 2 роки тому +49

    As meticulous and detailed the writing was in Breaking Bad, it’s incredible how many different routes it could’ve went. Like the most well known fact is how Jesse was supposed to be killed off in S1. BB and BCS couldve each went very different ways but we got them in their most perfect ways.

  • @zirotsero6951
    @zirotsero6951 2 роки тому +37

    what garnt is saying is so out of this world, conner is not even offended

  • @0p41
    @0p41 Рік тому +12

    Garnt is basically saying "it's so good it's bad". Literally Early 2010's Hipster energy right there.

  • @magdytalaat1680
    @magdytalaat1680 Рік тому +12

    garnt actually just argues for the sake of arguing, i swear he doesnt even believe what he says half the time

  • @amongoose1087
    @amongoose1087 2 роки тому +55

    I prefer Baking Bread over Bitter Coleslaw, tbh

  • @Wireseason3-4myfavficton
    @Wireseason3-4myfavficton Рік тому +20

    sopranos, Vinland saga till farmland arc, 20th-century boys, Berserk up to conviction arc, cowboy bebop, monster, and Breaking Bad are easily the best media I have consumed.

    • @AveChristusRex789
      @AveChristusRex789 Рік тому +2

      I like conviction more than GA tbh

    • @John34bruh
      @John34bruh Рік тому +5

      All arcs of Berserk are amazing, but Golden Age slightly outshines the others

    • @titan-framboise3126
      @titan-framboise3126 Рік тому +5

      I would add AoT and Better Call Saul to your list. But yeah, the rest is perfect.

    • @raymondsims7042
      @raymondsims7042 Рік тому +3

      @@titan-framboise3126what’s your top ten shows? I’d go
      1. The wire (hands down)
      2. Game of thrones
      3. Six feet under
      4. Mr robot
      5. Dark
      6. The boys
      7. Breaking bad
      8. Succession
      9. The Americans
      10. Yellowstone
      Honorable mentions
      Stranger things
      Sopranos
      Mad men
      Bcs
      Ozark
      Dexter
      The shield (only on season five but it can easily make my top ten)

    • @SaulofIceandFire
      @SaulofIceandFire 7 місяців тому +1

      ​​@@raymondsims7042
      you again? man you literally pop up wherever these "prestige shows" are mentioned and start spamming your top 10. Like chill

  • @iSouleyx
    @iSouleyx 2 роки тому +35

    It's so hilarious that Garnt and Joey mention "Cigarettes" and "Coke-a-cola" as the two examples of powerful marketing because the series Mad Men literally book opens and book ends with those two products (Lucky Strikes and Coke)

  • @nelisezpasce
    @nelisezpasce 2 роки тому +17

    Joey loves Monogatari, doesn't he? He would enjoy the dialogue of Mad Men, great writing all around

    • @8kuji
      @8kuji Рік тому

      Wait, is mad men really like that

    • @8kuji
      @8kuji Рік тому

      If it is

    • @8kuji
      @8kuji Рік тому

      LET'S GOOOI

  • @leiruz6949
    @leiruz6949 2 роки тому +22

    I will never forget the day my friend said Euphoria was than Better Call Saul. He wasn't even being sarcastic, the man straight up called the show trash.

    • @ryukokanami7645
      @ryukokanami7645 2 роки тому +7

      What in the name of fu-

    • @vn9574
      @vn9574 Рік тому +8

      @@Carlo775 You aren't a real human being

    • @brigs247__8
      @brigs247__8 Рік тому +3

      Preferring a show over better call Saul is alright. But calling better call Saul trash is just factually incorrect. And if they did that without even giving the show a chance, that's a crime.

  • @baririzqullah5782
    @baririzqullah5782 2 роки тому +15

    Better Call Saul is so good, it is so good that for someone that rarely watch a TV Series like me, watch BCS and Breaking Bad, it's just that good. But because of the fucking memes, each time I watched BCS, every episode I'd say 'What does Vince Gilligan means by this?' or 'Bravo Vince! Truly one of the episodes in BCS!'

  • @Waryfuls
    @Waryfuls 2 роки тому +6

    *_These be the discussions that truly matter hahaha_*

  • @Vasco1001
    @Vasco1001 2 роки тому +22

    Short answer: Yes.

  • @jloe01
    @jloe01 2 роки тому +13

    I will say, I didn't mind Gus's spanish, but when I heard him speak it for the first time I just thought, "why's his accent like that?"

    • @rsotuyo15
      @rsotuyo15 Рік тому

      The only character that has a good accent and pronunciation is Lalo

    • @H432-v6w
      @H432-v6w Рік тому

      @@rsotuyo15 Don't forget Don Eladio and Nacho's dad

  • @Laura_Darkspear
    @Laura_Darkspear 2 роки тому +6

    Makes me so happy to hear such praise of Futurama. I love that show so much! ❤️

  • @snowlocke1
    @snowlocke1 2 роки тому +13

    Looking back at the series, the first season of better call Saul was the weakest and from there it got so much better
    What I liked is how the show did the same trick with the main character being bad from the start and I fell for it again because I like Saul
    But after the finale it’s kinda sad to know that this universe is finally over and after all that…a happy ending

  • @fat1fared
    @fat1fared 2 роки тому +29

    Grant desperately trying not to sound like a contrarian with his hot take on Breaking Bad!

    • @nimazsheik5152
      @nimazsheik5152 Рік тому +4

      This podcast is literally Garnt and Joey being contrarians just to sound more interesting. Common quote you will keep hearing "I guess I angered so many fans with [insert forced contrarian take here]"

    • @soblessed973
      @soblessed973 Рік тому +3

      @@nimazsheik5152 it does feel a little bit scripted to be honest, like if they just agreed with each other this episode wouldnt be interesting, sometimes i do feel the takes were a bit too forced

    • @Stanzbey69
      @Stanzbey69 Рік тому +1

      @@nimazsheik5152 sometimes they sound like contrarians and other times they have the most normie takes ever like ‘bleach fell off after soul society’ which is bs

  • @beat-man5167
    @beat-man5167 2 роки тому +2

    11:46 basically he'd prefer fire punch over chainsaw man

  • @atakkuuuuu
    @atakkuuuuu Рік тому +1

    I enjoyed bcs more than bb because I got to see mike again. Having mike in that show was like the crème de la crème.

  • @meatymateo705
    @meatymateo705 2 роки тому +11

    Breaking Bad’s one flaw is the spanish in the show, any spanish speakers know that the spanish in the show is ATROCIOUS, totally takes you out of the show if you understand the language

    • @nicjuancarlospe1866
      @nicjuancarlospe1866 4 місяці тому +1

      i thought spanish and mexican spanish have slight differences

    • @lennonmahoney7302
      @lennonmahoney7302 3 місяці тому

      Because of different linguistics. Mexican Spanish is going to sound muuuuuch different to actual Spanish

  • @sen3291
    @sen3291 2 роки тому +15

    Garnt's take is so bizarre because its like saying someone is way too good looking to be able to build any connection with
    However Breaking Bad universe is not like that at all, it has many flaws as well just not as noticeable
    Also the writers (etc.)put their whole soul, passion, blood, sweat and tears into this show that it's honestly insane, so you can feel the message, emotional connection and such through the perfectly nuanced characters and story

  • @spector1892
    @spector1892 2 роки тому +22

    Yeah, it absolutely is. Better call saul might be the best show ever made, it's fucking incredible.

    • @raymondsims7042
      @raymondsims7042 Рік тому +1

      The best show ever made is the wire. Better call Saul is certainly a borderline top ten show though. I do think breaking bad is slightly better

    • @sumirunihon
      @sumirunihon 5 місяців тому +2

      tl;dr at bottom
      i am inclined to agree with you. breaking bad is more focused on story beats and themes rather than characters and environment. better call saul is more character focused and building a captivating world. in other words, breaking bad is about what happens and better call saul is about who it happens to and how they feel about it. i felt so much more connection to the characters of better call saul because they all felt real and they all effected the world in their own way whereas in breaking bad everything is more or less just a result of walt's actions and the characters exist solely to tell his story. not that plot and theme focused stories are inherently worse than character or setting focused stories but i personally absolutely love complex characters and interesting environments. the characters in breaking bad were perfect in terms of the purpose they served but i don't think any character in breaking bad including walt is nearly as complex as the main characters in better call saul and i just personally love feeling attached to characters like they're real. characters in better call saul felt real to me and closer to me in a way they just didn't in breaking bad. that's just my opinion tho.
      tl;dr breaking bad is about plot, better call saul is about characters. i personally like complex characters more than complex plotlines but both are perfect for purpose they serve and how they were executed.

    • @lennonmahoney7302
      @lennonmahoney7302 3 місяці тому +1

      See i can't help but laugh at a comment like this. BCS had slow points, BB never did

    • @sumirunihon
      @sumirunihon 3 місяці тому +1

      @@lennonmahoney7302 just because a show is slow does not mean it's bad. a short attention span is not the fault of the writers...

    • @lennonmahoney7302
      @lennonmahoney7302 3 місяці тому

      @@sumirunihon no but poor pacing is lmao

  • @Angel-Otk
    @Angel-Otk 2 роки тому +8

    Theres an argument there that it could be breaking bad just doesn’t feel as personal to Gornt than anime, usually anime is based on a manga whose story is usually the vision of 1-2 creators where as better call Saul has a team of writers all bringing their own ideas and directors and actors. A live tv show can’t feel as personal because of how much people are involved

    • @vn9574
      @vn9574 Рік тому +2

      Eh, I disagree heavily. But whatever.

    • @H432-v6w
      @H432-v6w Рік тому +1

      @Angel Ortega personally I prefer the way live action tv does things. Sometimes it's better to have a team of writers with different talents and abilities who all understand the characters and the story than just having one creator and maybe a couple of editors who may or may not have the story's best interests at heart

    • @Angel-Otk
      @Angel-Otk Рік тому

      @@H432-v6w nah Gornt is tripping fr but I’m saying that I think that’s the way he’s processing things. I hardly watch anime, BCS is my favorite show. And I think input from a lot of different people adds more character rather than take it away especially if they are all passionate

  • @teamofwinter8128
    @teamofwinter8128 2 роки тому +4

    bro i also thought better call saul was shit. but trust me, give it another shot and you will be amazed. same thing happened with breaking bad for me btw had to give it another shot to realize how amazing it actually is

  • @99sonder
    @99sonder 2 роки тому +11

    I get Garnt's take on Breaking Bad. When a show's approaching a point where there's no flaws that's holding it back and it's just almost universally agreed upon as good. You going into it as a critic can't even find much to flame it about. It's a lot more difficult for you to let it make a unique impression on you.
    One of my favourite games is Sonic Unleashed. But by many objective standards, it's a bad game (flaws and qualities listed at the bottom of the comment). Although, I still love the game because the good qualities it has are specifically aspects I love and look for in games, but also because all of the flaws don't really bother me in particular. When I sit down to play that game, I feel like I'm making a deal with it. Taking in the bad stuff so that I can enjoy the good parts. I feel more personally attached to it because many other people would just play many other games instead.
    Of course breaking bad shouldn't be more like Sonic Unleashed. But it's made me realize that flaws make it easier for some people to latch onto flawed works. And it's a bit deeper than "these people just don't like it because it's popular"
    Sonic Unleashed Flaws: A majority of the game is spent with a very non-sonic playstyle that's kinda shamelessly ripped off from other games. And in that other style, the soundtrack is constantly interrupted by the same battle theme for 90% of the levels. The controls and camerawork is shaky at times leading to unpredictable damage or deaths. The framerate at some points take a massive dump into powerpoint presentation territory. The tone of the story is super inconsistent with the tone of many cutscenes where one second the world's being shattered into pieces then the next you're chatting with locals about flowers and such. You have an obnoxious little imp flying and crying over your shoulder for most of the game.
    Qualities: The soundtrack fucking slaps. The daytime levels are very fun on repeat playthroughs. The level variety is amazing, taking good inspiration from real world locations. The texture and model quality is some of the best stuff in the entire sonic franchise, being comparable to frontiers (and it came out in 2008). Aside from the inconsistent tone, the story presentation is amazing when it comes to the final boss and everything leading up to that.

    • @pugman9672
      @pugman9672 2 роки тому +4

      Imagine if BB was more like sonic unleashed tho lol. “Jessie!!! we have to restore the chaos meth before Gus destroys my family!!”

  • @theanimeboy9953
    @theanimeboy9953 Рік тому +3

    Better Call Saul is one of the best series ever dude. Enough said.

    • @raymondsims7042
      @raymondsims7042 Рік тому +1

      No question about that it’s borderline top ten

  • @jumpvelocity3953
    @jumpvelocity3953 9 місяців тому

    Thank you Connor, for doing BB and BCS justices

  • @TheCreepypro
    @TheCreepypro Рік тому

    love hearing anybody talk about futurama

  • @Arpin_Lusene
    @Arpin_Lusene 5 місяців тому +1

    I'll take BB's ultra polishness any day of the week over GOT's flawed end.

  • @jumpvelocity3953
    @jumpvelocity3953 9 місяців тому

    10:08 perfectly put.

  • @אלוןקינן-ת7י
    @אלוןקינן-ת7י 2 роки тому +55

    To be honest I don't know what's worse , garnt take on breaking bad or joey refusing to watch arcane

    • @hieple4164
      @hieple4164 2 роки тому +11

      Is Garnt take really that bad? He didn't say that it's a bad show, he just didn't have any emotional attachment to it. You can admit something is peak and at the same time feel indifferent toward it.

    • @אלוןקינן-ת7י
      @אלוןקינן-ת7י 2 роки тому +14

      @@hieple4164 he said he prefers the latest seasons of game of thrones...

    • @hieple4164
      @hieple4164 2 роки тому +7

      ​@@אלוןקינן-ת7י That's beside the point? They were talking about Breaking Bad and how Garnt was emotionally detached from it. Wack take tho.

  • @alphamotivationclips0
    @alphamotivationclips0 Рік тому +1

    I completely get Garnt, I love breaking bad but couldn't rewatch it

  • @jumpvelocity3953
    @jumpvelocity3953 9 місяців тому +1

    It’s like this. Better Call Saul would not work that well without Breaking Bad, but BB is still a masterpiece in the world without BCS. However, in our timeline where both exist, BCS improves BB by at least two times, meaning it has just as much value as BB if not more, but only if you watch both.

  • @Ash_Wen-li
    @Ash_Wen-li 2 роки тому +3

    I'm just here watching The Wire

    • @Big_show_guy
      @Big_show_guy 2 роки тому +1

      The wire is gas and mad underrated. I’m only on season 2 but cleaning up is one of the best episodes I’ve seen of a show

    • @raymondsims7042
      @raymondsims7042 Рік тому

      @@Big_show_guythe wire is the best show ever made by far for me mate

  • @sickanimeart428
    @sickanimeart428 9 місяців тому

    Man Joey's T look soo good fr 🥶

  • @charlesw7397
    @charlesw7397 Рік тому

    As a huge Breaking Bad fan, it's insane to go back to that show after finishing Better Call Saul. You catch glimpses of Saul's hijinks early on but it takes the entire series to see how he became the Saul we knew from Breaking Bad who did horrible things and protected horrible people. In Breaking Bad, Walt literally cooks meth and kills someone in episode one. With Better Call Saul's pacing and story telling, we would have watched Walt's home and work life for a season before he really even started considering cooking meth. To me, that's not a bad thing. The character development in Better Call Saul is insane and definitely surpasses Breaking Bad in that regard.
    Breaking Bad has been my absolute favorite show ever since I first watched it which is why Better Call Saul making me question my ranking is so surprising. The show is just so amazing. It's almost hard to separate them in my mind. The Breaking Bad/Better Call Saul universe is just the ultimate television experience lol

  • @imjustme5934
    @imjustme5934 2 роки тому +1

    idk, better call saul about it

  • @wPZew
    @wPZew 2 роки тому +1

    I like the coffee episode too

  • @halloweenferret
    @halloweenferret 2 роки тому

    Since you guys like Futurama - I'm just putting it out there that you should watch venture bros

  • @Rihcterwilker
    @Rihcterwilker 2 роки тому +6

    I think one show can't be classified as "better", as it is essentialy an interdependant, cumulative experience. If you don't watch BB before, i'm sure the experience will be ok, but not as great as it is. The original works together to an overall enhanced experience.

    • @lordbauer5983
      @lordbauer5983 2 роки тому +9

      Watching BCS without having first seen BB is just WRONG.
      Even if we took the ending out of the equation, the viewer would miss out on so much of the world-class plotting and layering that goes on between BCS and BB that it would be a fundamentally flawed experience.

    • @royalfun1031
      @royalfun1031 2 роки тому

      @@lordbauer5983 yea

  • @ivanesquivel9840
    @ivanesquivel9840 2 роки тому

    lowkey need to distinguish between BB and BCS... BB seems way more interesting than BCS to me. something about BCS never interested me but BB I could watch over and over again

  • @karamjitdedyal752
    @karamjitdedyal752 6 місяців тому

    I think Connor forgot to mention Mad Men starts in 1960. Also it was not the top agency but a boutique one where they do not exist anymore. There is a few other nuances missed but hey ho.

  • @Ostrava6572
    @Ostrava6572 2 роки тому +4

    I believe breaking bad is clearly better but better call Saul is not to far behind and still one of the best shows to ever be made.

  • @vn9574
    @vn9574 Рік тому +2

    Yeah, I heavily disagree with Garnt. I related and connected more to Breaking Bad and it's characters than 99% of anime, and I am a huge anime fan. Walter, Jesse, Saul, Mike, Hank etc are goated on a personal level. It's not just called perfect on a surface level. Also, Breaking Bad is nothing similar to the typical American TV shows at all. It's different and unique, so I don't really understand Garnt.

  • @vishanthfishy
    @vishanthfishy Рік тому

    Ok simply put Garnts take on Breaking bad can be chocked up to him preferring anime as a medium overall. In general he needs the animeisms the tropes and short form simple consumability of anime

  • @Dreamer98-l9t
    @Dreamer98-l9t 2 роки тому +2

    There are both amazing, but i preffer BCS.

    • @sumirunihon
      @sumirunihon 5 місяців тому +2

      bcs has deeper and more complex characters i think

  • @sneakysquid9917
    @sneakysquid9917 3 місяці тому

    I think what garnt is trying to say is that he didn’t really vibe with Breaking Bad but still recognizes it’s good

  • @RocSandy
    @RocSandy 2 роки тому +1

    Donuts

  • @titania396
    @titania396 3 місяці тому

    Yes

  • @DeceptiJOHN.
    @DeceptiJOHN. 2 роки тому +3

    This is one of the most bizarre takes I have ever heard. To be honest I don't think he's actually watched the show or at least not much of it.

  • @dinzzz0000
    @dinzzz0000 11 днів тому

    7:45 this is why you came 😊

  • @dajokahbaby1506
    @dajokahbaby1506 2 роки тому +10

    You know, I don’t wanna sound pretentious, but I can pretty much fucking guess what Garnt mostly consumes or what his tastes in film/television are if he thinks Breaking Bad is “too perfect” to the point that an AI must’ve made it. Once again, affirming why this podcast is called Trash Taste

  • @OCRay1
    @OCRay1 2 роки тому +2

    “Is Better Call Saul better then BB?”
    Lol!!!

  • @lordeisschrank
    @lordeisschrank 2 роки тому +3

    I guess I can relate more to garnt... I saw breaking bad twice, I think its good, but thats about it... I really don't like the characters that much. Saul on the other hand... I can't think of a single bad charakter or episode. It may be slow, and yet it kept me coming back (unlike BB...).
    So, is Saul better than BB? Yes, yes it is. In every aspect.

    • @vn9574
      @vn9574 Рік тому

      In my opinion I relate more to BB than BCS, though both are nearly perfect. It's portrayed beautiful and connects personally on the same level as BCS.

  • @pheunithpsychic-watertype9881
    @pheunithpsychic-watertype9881 3 місяці тому

    Definitely because it has no skyler

  • @Myuutantobasuta
    @Myuutantobasuta 2 роки тому

    It is because it’s more accessible

  • @titanjakob1056
    @titanjakob1056 2 роки тому +52

    I love both personally but it depends what you want
    For a drama about a man who wants to provide for his family before he dies but evolves into a Drug kingpin breaking bad the way to go
    But if you want a law drama about an ex con trying to stay on the straight and narrow but evolves into a “criminal” lawyer with little to no morals because every time he tries to do good he gets screwed every time then Better Call Saul

    • @adawongz
      @adawongz 2 роки тому +1

      He’s not really doing it for his family though that’s just a front. It’s his ego, greed, pride and fragile masculinity that made him become a drug lord.

    • @iamjaboba
      @iamjaboba Рік тому

      IMO, Better Call Saul is a bit better than Breaking Bad to me. Never would I have thought that the funny lawyer guy in Breaking Bad would have such a tragic past, and how it simultaneously concludes both shows in its finale. I never would've imagined that I'd be more invested into Jimmy becoming Saul over Walter becoming Heisenberg and yet Better Call Saul did it.

    • @hematite9914
      @hematite9914 4 місяці тому

      ​@@adawongz Exactly from episode 1 one Walter finds out he has cancer and said I turn evil now, truly one of the best written characters ever.
      THE SHOW IS CALLED BREAKING BAD, IT'S ABOUT A PERSON BREAKING BAD.

  • @upside-down6211
    @upside-down6211 Рік тому

    It's is the 9 seasons TV series.Why do you need a comparison?

  • @abc123tiktok
    @abc123tiktok 4 місяці тому

    For me personally Breaking Bad has better story and pay off but it was a show very much carried by Bryan Cranston. He made the show go from good to great by his performance and corruption of a character. Everyone else is good but I don't think they kept up with him. While Better Call Saul story gets fuddle by the end and fizzles out. I think its the more entertaining show to watch and rewatch because they went out of way to add more depth. But more than that the show is carried by its 4 to 5 main characters that step up to plate to make them so enjoyable to watch their lives unfold. From Jimmy, Kim, Nacho, Mike, Gus just do wonderful job breathing life into them to be so much more and even the side characters were phenomenal. So while I think BB is better show I prefer BCS.

  • @kaleeyed
    @kaleeyed 2 роки тому +3

    Giancarlo Esposito was fantastic in BB as Gus, but yeah, he has an Italian dad and an African American mum. Even as a non-Spanish speaker, I can tell he's slowly phonetically pronouncing the Spanish, once you concentrate on it, it sounds bad. But I still thought he was great. I also probably prefer Better Call Saul, up until Lalo and the Germans turned up. I found Lalo a really annoying supervillan. Howard's death was a lazy end to a brilliant character that they should really have done more with. Season 5 was a bit of a bust, and the first half of season 6, but it finished strong. Would have liked more of the black and white flash forward Jimmy/Gene story overall, and more callbacks to Jimmy with Chuck. The relationship between Jimmy and Chuck was so rich and emotional, the bit where they sing The Winner Takes It All gives me goosebumps. Once Chuck was out of it, I think it lost a lot of what made it great.

  • @jacobchappell2197
    @jacobchappell2197 2 роки тому

    didnt john hamm kill someone?

  • @robroskey6515
    @robroskey6515 Рік тому

    I'm still waiting for bcs s6 to hit Netflix but unless its gets beyond amazing in s6 I can't possibly imagine it being better than BB based on the 5 seasons I've watched, the first few of which were actaully boring by BB standards. Still good just not on the same level

  • @xavmanisdabestest
    @xavmanisdabestest 2 роки тому

    Think garnt is saying its great but has no character which I remember thinking when I first watched it as a teenager. Watching better call saul as an adult I feel a lot of character. I wonder if I would feel the same now

  • @edwinjusto5739
    @edwinjusto5739 Рік тому

    Yes it is but thats comparison between a 9.8 to a 9.9 better call saul is not perfect but its made by the same people as breaking bad with added years of experience so of course it was gonna be better kind of like how the sandman comics are fantastic and the tv show is somehow better cuz it was made by the same writer of the comics with decades of experience added

  • @equilibrium_69
    @equilibrium_69 5 місяців тому

    I don't hate arcane. I refuse to watch it on principle because its roots started with Pendragon.

  • @neptunejoo
    @neptunejoo Рік тому

    Same. I feel no emotional attachment to Breaking Bad. Unlike with True Detective or the Wire

  • @kopiko91021
    @kopiko91021 2 роки тому

    well it is breaking bad

  • @shounakbanerjee7874
    @shounakbanerjee7874 2 роки тому

    Its better yes

  • @thabokgwele5268
    @thabokgwele5268 2 роки тому +6

    I'm not yet done with BCS, but it doesn't seem better than BB.

    • @bighugelargebig7248
      @bighugelargebig7248 2 роки тому +5

      Are you on season 6 yet?

    •  2 роки тому +2

      @@bighugelargebig7248 people are blinded by hype. Rewatch breaking bad again and it's still better

    • @bighugelargebig7248
      @bighugelargebig7248 2 роки тому +2

      @ Sure, never said Breaking Bad was worse. I don’t know what you mean by hype tho, what about BCS has been hyped up? I don’t think either show is really above the other both are masterpieces but I find it to be a disservice to say BCS is not at least on the same level of talk as BB.

    • @noobmasterruben5167
      @noobmasterruben5167 2 роки тому

      I’m on the same situation. I’m still mixed if I want to prefer BCS or not. I’m on season 3 the acting is so GOOD

    •  2 роки тому

      @@bighugelargebig7248 People have recency bias from the last season and since it was good they thing that is the best they have seen

  • @ErioArubino
    @ErioArubino 2 роки тому +21

    Skylar isnt in better caul saul so it wins by default

    • @snooze1927
      @snooze1927 2 роки тому +23

      Least misogynist breaking bad fan

    • @ErioArubino
      @ErioArubino 2 роки тому +10

      @@snooze1927 Im a kim wexler feet fan btw

    • @Rihcterwilker
      @Rihcterwilker 2 роки тому +12

      @@snooze1927 i know it is a joke, but there are people out there that legit don't get that finding a character annoying has nothing to do with gender. The majority of both men/women hated her, it was a consensus.

    • @dunno7819
      @dunno7819 2 роки тому

      Personally I don't like skyler and I still think that breaking bad is superior, I think that her being like that contributes to the show even though she is annoying

  • @kenkaneki2509
    @kenkaneki2509 20 днів тому

    no one has any idea what this grant guy is on about in this video

  • @AlanGonzalez-ev6ur
    @AlanGonzalez-ev6ur 2 місяці тому

    Garnts take is horrible, the main thing i disagree with is the AI remark. If you tell AI to make the perfect show it is not going to make a story about a chemistry teacher who gets cancer and decides to produce and sell meth with a young junkie. Although it is a show that is deeply grounded, it is also pretty damn unique

  • @Nolzhan
    @Nolzhan 2 роки тому +6

    short answer: no

  • @roka3960
    @roka3960 10 місяців тому +1

    Yes.

  • @royalfun1031
    @royalfun1031 2 роки тому +2

    Gotta continue BCS
    Is it really better?

  • @MrShadowThief
    @MrShadowThief 2 роки тому

    Yes.
    Thanks for coming to my TED Talk.

  • @Subird
    @Subird 4 місяці тому

    Call Saul is Better, Breaking is just Bad

  • @newpgaston6891
    @newpgaston6891 2 роки тому +2

    I'd say they were comparable (Breaking bad wins for the action, Better Call Saul wins for the character drama), until the final few episodes.
    BrBa's finale was a hundred times better than BCS's finale.
    Also, I do not think Lalo is nearly as great an antagonist as some make him out to be. Gus was so much better.

  • @nimazsheik5152
    @nimazsheik5152 Рік тому +1

    Breaking Bad was good....until I discovered The Wire, Deadwood, Mad Men (AMC), Rome and Sopranos. Early HBO shows were IMO untouchable, just on a totally different level.

    • @Wireseason3-4myfavficton
      @Wireseason3-4myfavficton Рік тому

      Classic anime and tv shows have more hidden gems then you will find in mordern entertainment

  • @chrisvalentine4365
    @chrisvalentine4365 2 роки тому +4

    breaking bad is the ONLY good america tv show so weird that garnt would actually mistakenly think it's in any way similar to american tv generally, it really isnt

    • @jloe01
      @jloe01 2 роки тому +3

      Now I don't watch a lot of TV anymore, but that is definitely a bad take if I've seen one.

    • @sumirunihon
      @sumirunihon 5 місяців тому +1

      seems you just have a bias against american tv in general but there are plenty of legendary american tv shows. there is no fair way you can actually claim this unless you genuinely are an american tv connoisseur and go out of your way to look for shows that get alot of praise and find that all of them suck except for breaking bad. but seeing as you're a youtube commenter who barely put any thought into your dogshit take, you probably just have bias against american stuff...

  • @noobmasterruben5167
    @noobmasterruben5167 2 роки тому +5

    I can tell why Garnt has zero attachment to Breaking Bad because he is an Isekai fan.
    In my opinion, Breaking Bad isn’t the type of show that I’d get into unless I see the context.
    Even the pitch meeting says that an event when said out loud doesnt sound cool like: Walt gets a guy to say his name or Gus gets killed by a guy in a wheelchair

    • @wasabi.2839
      @wasabi.2839 2 роки тому +2

      Hi! What have to do the isekai genre with not liking a heavy emotional weight story? This it's a genuine question, i'm not familiar with the Isekai genre at all (so far).

    • @royalfun1031
      @royalfun1031 2 роки тому

      @@wasabi.2839 don't
      It's garbage and shouldn't exist

    • @royalfun1031
      @royalfun1031 2 роки тому

      Tfym

    • @kenshiro1719
      @kenshiro1719 2 роки тому +2

      Name checks out

    • @noobmasterruben5167
      @noobmasterruben5167 2 роки тому

      @@wasabi.2839 hear me out. Breaking Bad is a grounded to reality show. It is not a special fx heavy and fast paced adrenaline and escapist kinda show. Meanwhile, Overlord and several other isekais are pure escapist fantasies

  • @juice6521
    @juice6521 2 роки тому +2

    I think Better Call Saul is an excellent show but I can't help but think how iconic and memorable every single episode of Breaking Bad was. You can show me a single scene from Breaking Bad and I could tell you exactly what happened in that episode, but a lot BCS has faded from my recent memory. Also many of the best characters from BCS are just holdovers from Breaking Bad.

    • @gismark
      @gismark 2 роки тому +3

      Nacho is definitely a standout tho, what a beautiful character arc he had

    • @elnopalero4691
      @elnopalero4691 2 роки тому +3

      Breaking Bad is the best rollercoaster… but better call Saul is a novel. If you appreciated depth… your take is completely flipped

    • @juice6521
      @juice6521 2 роки тому

      @@elnopalero4691 I like that analogy, very apt.

    • @raymondsims7042
      @raymondsims7042 Рік тому

      @@elnopalero4691i “appreciate depth” and I love both shows but I’d give breaking bad the edge. It has lots of symbolism, depth, nuances to it. But where it’s just beater than better call Saul is in it’s extremely high peak (season 4 and 5 of breaking bad are two of the best seasons of tv ever) and it’s more consistent and neatly written. Breaking bad for me is a top ten show ever, while better call Saul does have a case for being top ten. It would just miss my top ten. But like I said but incredible shows.

    • @sumirunihon
      @sumirunihon 5 місяців тому +1

      lalo was only in the last half of the show and was really only important in the last 2 seasons but still made an incredible impact on the show

  • @brownbricks6017
    @brownbricks6017 2 роки тому +7

    Breaking Bad is definitely a cut above the rest, but it and BCS also have a lot of slow moments where I was on my phone.

    • @raymondsims7042
      @raymondsims7042 Рік тому

      Yeah I’d say breaking bad is easily a top ten show ever, better call Saul while great would be too 13-15 for me. Both absolutely amazing shows

  • @IT.93
    @IT.93 2 роки тому +11

    Not even close. Even tho BCS is very good, BB is a Masterpiece.

    • @Rihcterwilker
      @Rihcterwilker 2 роки тому +8

      BB has some fat with the Skyler sections that could be reduced for a more concise watching. Every episode is meaningfull, sure, but it has small filler sections in some of them. BCS doesn't have any of that, because every character on screen is a delight to see (while Skyler sections we were used to "endure" until the good part came).

    • @addison_1661
      @addison_1661 2 роки тому +2

      @@Rihcterwilker this doesn’t change the fact that BB is overall better still lol

    • @willlowry2288
      @willlowry2288 2 роки тому +10

      @@Rihcterwilker literally nothing about any of Skyler is filler. Character writing = filler apparently.

    • @Rihcterwilker
      @Rihcterwilker 2 роки тому +5

      @@willlowry2288 her character is definitely needed, i never said to cut her out. Don't know where you took it from.
      Well, i'm sure you know what B plot is, and that it is usually the least interesting part of a show. Skyler just happens to be in most of the worst and most boring B plots, the "what's happening in Walter house right now while he's doing the interesting crime stuff". Similar to her case is Chuck Mcgill, but he has very interesting quirks with his condition, and is played by a really good actor.
      Compare the two and you can see how good the writing got. Or maybe you liked the cut from the action to check to see what walter Jr and Skyler were up to once in a while, i don't know. To each their own.

    • @ARM3LO
      @ARM3LO 2 роки тому

      eh. they're about equal. definitely both masterpieces. i can see an argument for both.

  • @ColonCommander
    @ColonCommander 5 місяців тому

    Arcane has no business being there

  • @frenchcoupon3391
    @frenchcoupon3391 Рік тому

    Short answer- No.
    Also, for the me, the show ended with the best episode- the season 5 Finale (Lalo’s Mansion). It was on paar with Breaking Bad best episodes.
    Season 6 is subpar and the final is all anti-Saul Goodman and all pro Kim.
    Kim got out way too easy after all the schemes and indirectly causing Howard’s death.

  • @TommySkywalker11
    @TommySkywalker11 2 роки тому

    I get what Garnt means, it's too sanitized and so hard into realism that it lacks emotion, when something gets too "real" it's boring

    • @sumirunihon
      @sumirunihon 5 місяців тому +1

      breaking bad hardly lacks emotion. i appreciate what garnt said because he insisted that it was his own opinion and i can sort of put myself in his shoes to an isekai fan i get how breaking bad wouldn't be to is taste but that by no means is an objective take. something being too sanitized and realistic by no means makes lack emotion it just means that you personally lack an emotional attachment to the style, which again is fine, but that by no means applies to everyone which is very apparent judging by how many people love breaking bad.

    • @katharsis101-
      @katharsis101- 4 місяці тому

      I wouldn't say it's too real and too sanitized, it has a very whacky humor and part of the charm is how absurd the situations can be at times; walter without his pants pulling out a gun or heck SPOILER's death itself (season 4 main death) is so exaggerated and unrealistic and still delivers. I think it has a lot of soul and character.

  • @Great_Sandwich
    @Great_Sandwich 2 роки тому +3

    You think people understanding the importance of advertising began in the '50..?
    (I love it when Gen X-ers discuss social history. 😅)

    • @sumirunihon
      @sumirunihon 5 місяців тому +1

      they're millennials dude

    • @Great_Sandwich
      @Great_Sandwich 5 місяців тому

      @@sumirunihon True. Too young to be X-ers. Either way, not too bright, either.

    • @sumirunihon
      @sumirunihon 5 місяців тому +1

      @@Great_Sandwich are you a baby boomer?

    • @Great_Sandwich
      @Great_Sandwich 5 місяців тому

      @@sumirunihon Are you a Zoomer?

  • @0Asterite0
    @0Asterite0 2 роки тому +10

    arcane fans are so annoying. at this point i'll just never watch it

    • @pugman9672
      @pugman9672 2 роки тому

      Just tune em out I still haven’t seen it. I plan too but I’m gonna do it went ever I am finally able to

  • @DementedAnimalz
    @DementedAnimalz 2 роки тому +1

    I haven't watched much of either but I remember waking up to my friend watching better call saul and after like 2-3 episodes literally nothing happened, seemed really boring.

    • @Haddonfield63
      @Haddonfield63 Рік тому

      It’s so hard to explain for those not really into the universe. You gotta give it a chance. Unless your just not into slow burn shows which is understandable. Vince relies on us the fans which is why he can use a slow pace. We appreciate it. I believe if you ever finish the show you’ll understand

    • @vn9574
      @vn9574 Рік тому

      Yeah, it's not really for you then. You probably like fast paced action stories with little plot and development. BCS mostly surrounds around the characters on a personal level and the plot itself has a slow but beautiful pace. You would have to watch more than 2 seasons to appreciate it to the fullest.

  • @willlowry2288
    @willlowry2288 2 роки тому +4

    It’s wild that this is even a discussion. I personally never thought BCS was anywhere close to BB. Wait till the hype dies down for people to get a perspective on it, because as of now people are definitely being a prisoner of the moment.

    • @mondude89
      @mondude89 2 роки тому +8

      bcs is better, bb is for plebs that want explosions every episode.

    • @willlowry2288
      @willlowry2288 2 роки тому +1

      @@mondude89 you have a very tainted memory of Breaking Bad if you think explosions happen every two seconds lmao. BCS is for “intellectuals” like you I guess hey? Snob.

    • @royalfun1031
      @royalfun1031 2 роки тому

      @@mondude89 tf

    • @elnopalero4691
      @elnopalero4691 2 роки тому

      @@mondude89 Those saying BB is way better that BCS are plebs

    • @vn9574
      @vn9574 Рік тому

      @@mondude89 BB is definitely not for plebs. The last season for BB was more than the last three seasons of BCS. Action isn't even the important factor why Breaking Bad is so highly acclaimed. Maybe get your head checked before you give out such shitty opinions next time because you have lost your mind.

  • @TremereTT
    @TremereTT 2 роки тому

    I dont get both Shows. why would you start selling drugs just because your mum has cancer? There is just no connection.
    same with Saul. how would you have to care about money when you are an Independant lawyer?
    Its a totally unbelievable scenario.

    • @pimentx3253
      @pimentx3253 2 роки тому +2

      Because they had no idea who they really were, and the show is about self-discovery.

    • @jloe01
      @jloe01 2 роки тому

      I mean I can understand Walt's reason. He's a dying man whose family is barely keeping their head above water, and with a daughter on the way, he knows that they'll have an even harder time dealing with financial issues, especially since Walter was his family's main source of income. Not to mention how flawed Walt is due to his pride and ego and refusal to allow other people to help.
      Haven't watched BCS tho, so I can't comment on him.

    • @dog-eared6991
      @dog-eared6991 Рік тому

      ... you think all lawyers are rich? Jesus.

    • @blackhole5803
      @blackhole5803 Рік тому

      It's not about money, it's about empire

  • @dat_dudedustin1823
    @dat_dudedustin1823 2 роки тому

    No. It is not. Better call saul isnt a bad show, but its not comparable to breaking bad

  • @MacCoy
    @MacCoy 2 роки тому +2

    havent seen better call saul. not interested in a scuffed lawyer slice of life story.

    • @bighugelargebig7248
      @bighugelargebig7248 2 роки тому +10

      Not really about that it’s actually kind of similar to Breaking Bad. It’s a character evolution type of story but a lot more sad than BB. Not for everyone, but I would give it a shot.

    • @YoastnToastn
      @YoastnToastn 2 роки тому +2

      Slice of Life?

    • @asliaffan
      @asliaffan 2 роки тому +2

      @@bighugelargebig7248 a lot more sad that BB? bro BB was depressing as fuck, especially season 5.

    • @vn9574
      @vn9574 Рік тому

      It's not even a slice of life. It's literally just the prequel to all characters from BB before Heisenberg appeared.

  • @joeyc5879
    @joeyc5879 2 роки тому

    I'm there with Garnts breaking bad complain. I'd argue that he doesn't want shows to feel super polished, but for there to be roughness. It's like seeing the Yankees win the championship. You don't hate it, but you'd prefer to see something else

  • @RavagHer
    @RavagHer 2 роки тому +2

    i think better call saul is good. i dont think its better than breaking bad. the best parts of better call saul has to do with returning characters and seeing storyline that adds to the original stories or characters as well as see what happens to saul after breaking bad