I just got a Pivot Shuttle LT with the EP801 last weekend and made sure they had the updated firmware in it when i bought it. i haven't changed anything in the app yet, but you definitely notice the overrun. I haven't tried a Bosch bike to compare, but i really like the 801 so far.
That's true, but the point was compare the race version from Bosch and the update from Shimano to catch up on races. Very few people with Shimano motors are able to access to factory stuff. If Shimano can keep up with Bosch with the update you could choose way more different bikes and not just be forced to buy a Bosch motored one.
@@SamsBikesactually Bosch Race turbo mode is exactly the same as standard Bosch Turbo… it’s just the “Race” mode that unlocks the extra power and over run.
You can do the firmware update from your phone, you don’t have to go into a bike shop to get it done. What you can’t do without the PC software is enable the overrun and aggressive cutoff as those settings aren’t visible in the phone app till October In New Zealand they’ve also enabled you to up the speed cutoff from 32km/h to 45km/h, though that requires a shimano rep to do it
Nice test, but i think it's more for a show than for a real result. I think it would be better to show which motor is stronger if You would test this way: Use a power meter pedal (to be more accurate than what the motor shows) and test the bikes with the same cadence (same gear ratio) and same leg power (100 watts, 150 watts , 250 watts), same tires, same tire pressure, and which bike goes the fastest. You only need a 10-15% tarmac uphill like one km long. (sorry for my poor english)
Thanks rider for the comment, we actually did a hill climb test 6 months ago on 7 of the best Motors on the market, maybe you can check that video out.
@@SamsBikes Thanks. I have a Canyon Spectral with EP8 today, and looking at the new Canyon ON (But I do not like a lot of design choices) or the Canyon Strive ON With Bosch motor (not the race edition). Strive is just more bike than i will ever need in Denmark (no mountains) :) This helps a bit on my descision.
Bosch is now a moped. It tears and is difficult to control. Shimano still remains faithful to the concept of a bike. And then, since Shimano introduced EP801, it has been dominating the E-EWS world championship. There are many variables to consider in a motor. I prefer Shimano EP801 absolutely.
Bought a bike with an EPA motor it was so underpowered compared to the competitors. I would never buy another Shimano engine powered sbike. Shimano deserted its customer base with no upgrades whatsoever and now they want you to buy an EP801. My next upgrade was going to be to a Bosch powered bike.. however both Bosch and Shimano are in catch-up mode. I will only consider now at DJI power bike or opinion mgu powered Bike . Shimano and Bosch have been caught with their pants down.. have shown that they’re not innovators in the industry and don’t provide real investment for Bike owners
Sam the man can you do a video on the bafang m820 lightweight motor? People are saying that it's crazy, powerful and even snapping chains but it claims 75 Newton meters
Both are pretty similar, but maybe the Shimano has an smoother transition when you reach the limit, if we talk on boost-turbo mode, in lower assistance modes both are almost seamless.
They really failed the update. I can't fathom who programs these bikes or makes these decisions. Do they have any mtb experience? Bosch has had the winning formula for 3 years now. You can do a full crankback rotation on Bosch gen4 and the motor stays on. You can do about quarter crankback on the new Shimano EP801 update because they decided it's a great idea to cancel the overrun when you backpedal... It just boggles the mind how these decisions are made. Let's add overrun but then make it stop when you need it... My brain just dies thinking about this.
The Shimano ep800 sucked. Didn’t realize until I started riding and keeping up pace with Brose and Bosch groups lol. Not interested in their motors anymore. Happy with my Bosch race motor.
I think Shimano are Back! what are we thinking?
I just got a Pivot Shuttle LT with the EP801 last weekend and made sure they had the updated firmware in it when i bought it. i haven't changed anything in the app yet, but you definitely notice the overrun. I haven't tried a Bosch bike to compare, but i really like the 801 so far.
Unfortunately, BOSCH is still clearly better for racing purposes. And I write this as an owner of a Spectral CF on the Shimano EP801 platform.
Would have been better to compare it to the Bosch CX non Race motor. Most people running Bosch don't have the Race version.
That's true, but the point was compare the race version from Bosch and the update from Shimano to catch up on races. Very few people with Shimano motors are able to access to factory stuff. If Shimano can keep up with Bosch with the update you could choose way more different bikes and not just be forced to buy a Bosch motored one.
Totally agree but unfortunately or fortunately I only have the Bosch race so we need to use what we have.
@@SamsBikesactually Bosch Race turbo mode is exactly the same as standard Bosch Turbo… it’s just the “Race” mode that unlocks the extra power and over run.
Does it overheat ?
Came here to say this. Would be really nice to see the difference between regular Bosch CX and the new Shimano.
Thank you!
Got my S-Works, two Days ago!
Oh yea!!! Enjoy it mate and if you have any questions just ask
@@SamsBikes 🤗 Thank you!
You can do the firmware update from your phone, you don’t have to go into a bike shop to get it done.
What you can’t do without the PC software is enable the overrun and aggressive cutoff as those settings aren’t visible in the phone app till October
In New Zealand they’ve also enabled you to up the speed cutoff from 32km/h to 45km/h, though that requires a shimano rep to do it
Nice test, but i think it's more for a show than for a real result. I think it would be better to show which motor is stronger if You would test this way: Use a power meter pedal (to be more accurate than what the motor shows) and test the bikes with the same cadence (same gear ratio) and same leg power (100 watts, 150 watts , 250 watts), same tires, same tire pressure, and which bike goes the fastest. You only need a 10-15% tarmac uphill like one km long. (sorry for my poor english)
Great idea mate I’ll definitely think of next time! Thanks for watching!
Great comparison!!!
Thanks legend
What are the chances that we will see a similar update in ep8? And if you don't see it between the lines, there is a pleading look here
Good question, I personally don’t feel that will happen
Very Interesting video Sam!!
Thanks my love great editing
Very good Sam and Pablo, thank you. Please consider comparing the brose and whatever other motors others would like to see.
Thanks rider for the comment, we actually did a hill climb test 6 months ago on 7 of the best Motors on the market, maybe you can check that video out.
Great video! 👍 A tough choice for sure
Thanks mate I feel Shimano are definitely back
Any thoughts on how the new Shimano firmware compares to the non race version of the bosch motor ?
Good point! I feel the Bosch still has the edge but Shimano is coming back
@@SamsBikes Thanks. I have a Canyon Spectral with EP8 today, and looking at the new Canyon ON (But I do not like a lot of design choices) or the Canyon Strive ON With Bosch motor (not the race edition).
Strive is just more bike than i will ever need in Denmark (no mountains) :)
This helps a bit on my descision.
Bosch is now a moped. It tears and is difficult to control. Shimano still remains faithful to the concept of a bike. And then, since Shimano introduced EP801, it has been dominating the E-EWS world championship. There are many variables to consider in a motor.
I prefer Shimano EP801 absolutely.
Congrats shimano on almost catching up with 4 year old Bosch tech,
Haha you might be right
Bought a bike with an EPA motor it was so underpowered compared to the competitors. I would never buy another Shimano engine powered sbike. Shimano deserted its customer base with no upgrades whatsoever and now they want you to buy an EP801. My next upgrade was going to be to a Bosch powered bike.. however both Bosch and Shimano are in catch-up mode. I will only consider now at DJI power bike or opinion mgu powered Bike . Shimano and Bosch have been caught with their pants down.. have shown that they’re not innovators in the industry and don’t provide real investment for Bike owners
Although the Bosch is more powerful, I was so impressed with the Shimano how it was performing uphill during the day. For sure Shimano is closer now.
Do we listen to loooser ? hahah great job mountain goat I agree the Shimano is so close now
@@SamsBikes hahaha 🔥🔥
Pablo máquina!!
Sam the man can you do a video on the bafang m820 lightweight motor? People are saying that it's crazy, powerful and even snapping chains but it claims 75 Newton meters
How do the motors feel when you hit the speed limit on fire roads?
Both are pretty similar, but maybe the Shimano has an smoother transition when you reach the limit, if we talk on boost-turbo mode, in lower assistance modes both are almost seamless.
Yep as Pablo said in the higher modes I feel the Shimano is smoother
I wish the limit was 32kph. Do you think in the future this might happen as the current limit is a the only thing I dislike.
How many motor energy did you used??????
Do most people unlock their restricted e bikes?
Some of the bikes shown in your UA-cam video have been launched in India ?
Thought indians only rides cows?
Shimano are not back because thousands of EP8 users will never choose it again. This being the reason, as well.
It should be compared with the Bosch Performance Line CX which is installed as standard!
Agree but I only have the Bosch race so better than nothing
Hasn't it been proven that the performance cx is faster than race?
They really failed the update. I can't fathom who programs these bikes or makes these decisions. Do they have any mtb experience? Bosch has had the winning formula for 3 years now. You can do a full crankback rotation on Bosch gen4 and the motor stays on. You can do about quarter crankback on the new Shimano EP801 update because they decided it's a great idea to cancel the overrun when you backpedal... It just boggles the mind how these decisions are made. Let's add overrun but then make it stop when you need it... My brain just dies thinking about this.
I like the cancel of the overrun but I can see why you might not your right maybe they should have to turn off if you want to
@@SamsBikes Why would you ever want to cancel the overrun? You can just use brakes to stop the motor.
The Shimano ep800 sucked. Didn’t realize until I started riding and keeping up pace with Brose and Bosch groups lol. Not interested in their motors anymore. Happy with my Bosch race motor.
shot aw johnny
This weak motor will only overheat faster now
Shimano and their unrepairable motors are dead to me.
How are they unrepairable?