It's ok, she has two more. I know this because she died in the attack at Last Light's Inn and I looted them all from her body after I realized you couldn't revivify her.
Update: So I've been trying to roleplay an evil character, and it's near impossible. The NPCs having an actual human reaction makes it very difficult. However when I just decided to always take the most evil choice, instead of thoughtfully roleplaying it, then it gets much easier. That way I'm only making the decision to be evil in general, and not making any on the individual issues that come up.
Astarion: I might approve of that Gale: I can't believe you, I'm going to go cry and eat Ramen now Wyll: I'm permanently leaving, good is thrown out the window
Far better than any generic chaotic evil murderhobo, is going full neutral or good, except for when the opportunity arises to let the intrusive thoughts win and do really petty acts of evil like this.
The only time this is a proper behaviour is when doing a Dark Urge playthrough where you fully give in to the urge and roleplay the incarnation of destruction and rage And even then, when the purpoae of the playthrough is to wreak as much destruction as possible, I felt so fucking bad I almost quit lol. I hate playing evil characters 😭
Look after 2 whole goodie two shoe playthroughs with all the available origin companions, completing alfira's song, saving the nightsong, saving *all* the tiefling refugees, tried for the good(est) endings for every character and knowing all their stories etc. its nice to kick back and be the menace, my current durge run has been absolutely fucked lol
what's even worse? my friend was playinbg dark urge, i was a bard, when i saw her join the camp i got SO excited.... played a song with her and gale, was thinking of all the adventures we were gonna go on. then that scene happened, we had share private scenes on and i fucking screamed xD meanwhile my crazy friend who loves killing shit was laughing the whole time. but you know what?....that's fine......cause i know something. he saw the companions for this game and he says he likes karlach...that's all i need to know
I never even knew she played a song until after I was done with my second Playthru because of UA-cam. I never met her on my first Playthru and on my second I was evil so I smashed it and tried to push her off the cliff but she wouldn’t fall. Now that I know she plays that song I feel bad about it.
what's even worse? my friend was playinbg dark urge, i was a bard, when i saw her join the camp i got SO excited.... played a song with her and gale, was thinking of all the adventures we were gonna go on. then that scene happened, we had share private scenes on and i fucking screamed xD meanwhile my crazy friend who loves killing shit was laughing the whole time. but you know what?....that's fine......cause i know something. he saw the companions for this game and he says he likes karlach...that's all i need to know
@@VoFALT What rule? Why are you applying RL to fantasy worlds where the music is literally magical and imbues allies with power?? Why make such an insipid useless comment?
I like how Shadowheart casting guidance kinda makes her complicit in all the terrible things you do.
“…she’s DEAD!”
“Appeal to emotion”
"...you BASTARD!"
"Ad hominem"
This game is allowing us to be bastards on a whole new level and it's fucking awesome.
Quite contrary. The game makes you feel awful for being evil. It does not glamorize it.
Her sobbing is so sad, I love her
It's ok, she has two more. I know this because she died in the attack at Last Light's Inn and I looted them all from her body after I realized you couldn't revivify her.
Did u get her outfit when she was killed?
First order of business when the fighting begins: cast sanctuary on Alfira
I think it's less about how many lutes has and more the fact that the one you decided to break was her teacher's.
damn, that voice-acting is too good.. I'd probably reload after that ☹
Update:
So I've been trying to roleplay an evil character, and it's near impossible. The NPCs having an actual human reaction makes it very difficult. However when I just decided to always take the most evil choice, instead of thoughtfully roleplaying it, then it gets much easier. That way I'm only making the decision to be evil in general, and not making any on the individual issues that come up.
@@Marqanthis is so real 💀
Astarion: I might approve of that
Gale: I can't believe you, I'm going to go cry and eat Ramen now
Wyll: I'm permanently leaving, good is thrown out the window
Far better than any generic chaotic evil murderhobo, is going full neutral or good, except for when the opportunity arises to let the intrusive thoughts win and do really petty acts of evil like this.
No matter how good your playthrough is.
Always slap gales hand
Redeem Shadowheart just to sell her back to Viconia.
Holy shit, this is beyond cruel.
"Sorry."
Any character that does this deserves a fate worse than gnashing gnolls
I thought it was pretty funny
@@Gleemzo to the gnolls with you, and far worse.
The only time this is a proper behaviour is when doing a Dark Urge playthrough where you fully give in to the urge and roleplay the incarnation of destruction and rage
And even then, when the purpoae of the playthrough is to wreak as much destruction as possible, I felt so fucking bad I almost quit lol.
I hate playing evil characters 😭
I did this
@@lucasshea3382 to the gnolls with you too, and far worse as well.
As a Drow I did the same, then I stole it off her. I had to do the opposite of my initial neutral goodish run.
Look after 2 whole goodie two shoe playthroughs with all the available origin companions, completing alfira's song, saving the nightsong, saving *all* the tiefling refugees, tried for the good(est) endings for every character and knowing all their stories etc. its nice to kick back and be the menace, my current durge run has been absolutely fucked lol
Step 1: Smash lute.
Step 2: Fancy Hat
…all part of THE PLAN.
what's even worse? my friend was playinbg dark urge, i was a bard, when i saw her join the camp i got SO excited.... played a song with her and gale, was thinking of all the adventures we were gonna go on. then that scene happened, we had share private scenes on and i fucking screamed xD
meanwhile my crazy friend who loves killing shit was laughing the whole time.
but you know what?....that's fine......cause i know something. he saw the companions for this game and he says he likes karlach...that's all i need to know
On the intrusive thoughts run i see
I gave my love a cherry
Imagine you ar a bard you practice for cheer up people and some shity halfing come and break your lute for no reason her reaction his normal
Thot=Patrolled
I need to know why this is even an option. I love that it is.... but WHY?
Cause she deserved it
@@cafeterialocaHell yeahhh, those poor little chipmunks were hurting their ears
Doing gods work
I am doing full evil-rude-game and its heartbreaking
I never even knew she played a song until after I was done with my second Playthru because of UA-cam. I never met her on my first Playthru and on my second I was evil so I smashed it and tried to push her off the cliff but she wouldn’t fall. Now that I know she plays that song I feel bad about it.
Did this on my murder hobo playthrough. Was very satisfied with the result.
If you are Dark Urge, it can get even more satisfying :)))
what's even worse? my friend was playinbg dark urge, i was a bard, when i saw her join the camp i got SO excited.... played a song with her and gale, was thinking of all the adventures we were gonna go on. then that scene happened, we had share private scenes on and i fucking screamed xD
meanwhile my crazy friend who loves killing shit was laughing the whole time.
but you know what?....that's fine......cause i know something. he saw the companions for this game and he says he likes karlach...that's all i need to know
That was a pretty sculpture, NGL 😂
PLEASE tell me this ended how I think it did...
My shadowheart did broke this lute. Very fun)))
D:
Doesnt even make sense since bards are ultra useful in battles by using their lutes
Which is also a stupid rule because your music isn't gonna do shit other than create white noise at the worst possible time.
@@VoFALT What rule? Why are you applying RL to fantasy worlds where the music is literally magical and imbues allies with power?? Why make such an insipid useless comment?
@@tenjenk Because I have an irrational hatred for bards as a class.
I hope your save file gets corrupted
quit save scumming and own it
Single player game, let people do what they want.
nerd
@@Bruced82 no
Based
No I think it's a lute guitar actually
More like LUTED! EYYYYYYYYYY
Drop the based