Decorating Our Bookshelves TWO WAYS *Minimalist vs Maximalist* | GUIDE TO DECORATING BOOKSHELVES

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,4 тис.

  • @bthompson95
    @bthompson95 Рік тому +1190

    You should make a library ladder. Add a railing for both sides and a ladder that you can hook on and move. It could stay stationary on the right side for aesthetic purposes but be practical for when you want to switch up your shelves.

    • @annehelenegroven
      @annehelenegroven Рік тому +19

      Yesss that's such a great idea 😁😁. I think that would look amazing. MaCenna is just such an amazing person ❤️🥰❤️

    • @Edu_Kate
      @Edu_Kate Рік тому +26

      DIY Wife made one a couple months ago. Check out her kids' playroom makeover video.

    • @jemma50
      @jemma50 Рік тому +34

      I love the idea of a library ladder; however, I don't think there is enough space for one here. You really need a whole solid wall of bookshelves for a ladder not to intrude on the shelf decor. Or if the shelves were filled with just books, it could work.

    • @blahblah123436
      @blahblah123436 Рік тому +21

      I wonder if there would be a way to make one that would function in the kitchen for the higher cabinets too. One ladder for both rooms

    • @sherylbentley3724
      @sherylbentley3724 Рік тому +2

      Wonderful Ideal 💜

  • @ceer9141
    @ceer9141 Рік тому +44

    "Every room like a library" feel is definately 100% me. I'm a maximalist, moody vibes, these shelves are beautiful!!! 😍

  • @5272caribou
    @5272caribou Рік тому +185

    I love how even on the “more” side, it’s not crammed full, there’s still room for the clusters to breathe and have their own moment. So visually appealing

  • @_SarahHolly
    @_SarahHolly Рік тому +84

    One option for your coffee table dilemma is to purchase brass feet to add to a wooden table you love! Etsy shops have lots of options for the size and shape of the brass feet.

    • @gypsyrhodescovers
      @gypsyrhodescovers Рік тому +3

      I love this idea! And if anyone could actually make a coffee table and add brass feet...it's MaCenna!

  • @annkaufmann2549
    @annkaufmann2549 Рік тому +14

    MaCenna - your bust is a copy of David - a masterpiece of Renaissance sculpture, created in marble between 1501 and 1504 by the Italian artist Michelangelo. 🤩🤩🤩

    • @JButler661
      @JButler661 Рік тому +3

      I was just reading through the comments to see if anyone mentioned that. I love that statue.

    • @lemmingmeringuepie
      @lemmingmeringuepie Рік тому +1

      My mum has a smaller version in the same style with the black base. She brought it back from a trip to Rome in the early 70s when she was 17. I would think that the one MaCenna has probably dates from the same time period and was also a holiday souvenir ☺

    • @ashraj2146
      @ashraj2146 Рік тому +1

      Finally, the comment I've been looking for 😉 The original statue still exists in Galleria dell"Accademia in Florence, out of one piece of marble! Masterpiece, worth a look, I love Michaelangelos sculptures! 😍

  • @denises9426
    @denises9426 Рік тому +25

    I’m usually a minimalist but I LOVE how you did the “max” shelves, they’re both gorgeous!!

  • @lenorezp
    @lenorezp Рік тому +78

    The birds are quail. The flowers are peonies. Love your style!

    • @annajorgensen2043
      @annajorgensen2043 Рік тому +5

      I think they might be partridges, since quail have that floopy thing on their heads. But maybe I just didn’t see it.

    • @Ruezy428
      @Ruezy428 Рік тому +3

      @@annajorgensen2043 Not all quail have the plumage on their heads. I feel like they could be either partridge or quail. They're some sort of upland bird 😆

    • @makaylaanderson7327
      @makaylaanderson7327 Рік тому +2

      I’m pretty sure they’re quail as well just by by looking at the texture of all the feathers. Out of the countless pictures of partridges I looked at they lack that visual texture, or at least that’s what I think.

  • @AysKuz
    @AysKuz Рік тому +1

    I am definitely more the minimalist.
    That sculpture of the man´s head is David by Michelangelo.

  • @FaithyandOtis..Massachusetts
    @FaithyandOtis..Massachusetts Рік тому +217

    I love both homes, but this home is my favorite❤❤❤love the maxi side😊

  • @LindaKayHolevas
    @LindaKayHolevas Рік тому +137

    This episode MaCenna- “I can’t find the perfect coffee table. I want it wood & brass, etc”
    Next Episode MaCenna- “since I couldn’t find the perfect coffee table, I am going to build one” 😊 Edit- I am definitely more of a maximalist, so that is the bookshelf I like the most, but both are beautiful.

    • @RaeC5280
      @RaeC5280 Рік тому +6

      That's exactly what I was thinking! "... She's just going to build it herself" if anyone could, it's MaCenna!

    • @walkwithMilo
      @walkwithMilo Рік тому +1

      I swear she got some sort of brass inlay type stuff at an estate sale or flea market some time ago, I reckon she'll find it and it will all come to her in a flash, and we'll be watching a Sunday how to make a coffee table in no time!

    • @aliplay5
      @aliplay5 Рік тому +1

      that is exactly what I thought too haha

  • @robynsnest22
    @robynsnest22 Рік тому +100

    I love your new fairytale house in LA but I have to say I LOVE your being back at the cottage and working on that! Beautiful styling as always. Hope you and Romeo feel better soon. 💜

  • @sashahera5679
    @sashahera5679 Рік тому

    Little dog always makes the scene complete ❤

  • @daky9434
    @daky9434 Рік тому +74

    I love the maximalist bookshelf!! The more books the better🤩

    • @EricaMEspino
      @EricaMEspino Рік тому +1

      I agree ! I used to style with less but now that my house is full of beautiful things I love it and it feels so homier.

    • @nenayrigoyen8624
      @nenayrigoyen8624 Рік тому +1

      Love both sides

    • @OICUR12
      @OICUR12 Рік тому

      Quail, not pheasants.

  • @kimberlylabelle8986
    @kimberlylabelle8986 Рік тому +1

    You did it again McCenna!!! Love both of the book shelves…I always go for more…I just love the stuffed/more look…my mom and sister always say it’s like an antique shop in our home…but I LOVE IT!!! Now my other half not so much…😬 Thank you again for another amazing video ❤

  • @mikkileon6380
    @mikkileon6380 Рік тому +43

    I know you and Romeo have a really tight schedule and so much on your plate. So I am so happy to see you both set an excellent example by taking time to rest when you possibly could. You’ve been pushing yourself so hard both of you. I hope you feel like 100% very soon🌷🌷

  • @marilynwoodard7961
    @marilynwoodard7961 Рік тому +1

    I'm a fan of the "More" side. It is still not cluttered, just nicely populated! I think, with your knowledge of art, you must know that your bust is a copy of the head of Michaelangelo's David. But, I thought I'd mention it in case anyone was wondering. Yours is a nice one.

  • @cathymorrison22
    @cathymorrison22 Рік тому +92

    I am definitely a minimalist. When I see a bunch of stuff all I see is "dust". So much stuff to have to dust off. But I'm an old woman and I've mellowed out so much that I don't want any extra work.You're young enough and have the energy to take care of it all- boy do you have energy!

    • @lindaga820
      @lindaga820 Рік тому +13

      I CAN TOTALLY RELATE CATHY, I'M ALMOST 73 and I think of the dust factor too ! I'M TRYING TO SIMPLIFY MY HOME A LOT!

    • @RebeccaTreeseed
      @RebeccaTreeseed Рік тому +10

      I'm 69 and have cut down on the dust factor too. I gave my son and his wife an "estate sale" day and they took a moving truck full of stuff to their empty house! I sized down much easier without having to move so much.

    • @debstrout1844
      @debstrout1844 Рік тому

      I thought the same thing, I can't imagine getting a ladder out each week or two to dust but I'm getting older all the time! I love the "more" side and have missed the cottage. Hope you and Romeo get better soon, there is so much stuff going around.

    • @2FullMoons
      @2FullMoons Рік тому +4

      I’m only 26 and all I can think about is dust too LMAO but I also appreciate a more clean, less cluttered space for comfort reasons. I feel more relaxed in spaces that don’t visually distract me a lot.

    • @susinok
      @susinok Рік тому +1

      Same! Dusting all that is not fun at all, and it accumulates every week.

  • @nancyhart5027
    @nancyhart5027 Рік тому +1

    Also I love the max side of the bookshelves!

  • @boniwales
    @boniwales Рік тому +55

    I loved how calm this video was , the fact that there was no music and it was just you decorating, it felt like a dream, and you look as cute as a button. Thank you so much for sharing. ❤

  • @todayplay8532
    @todayplay8532 Рік тому +3

    So I already knew coming into this video I was a maximalist! This proves it! I love the shelf on the right, not saying the left doesn't look good, but we both know the extra space will be filled before long! If you were decorating for a client that would be a good start to help them form ideas and have room to grow. And the brass birds are a pair of Quails.

  • @pw4075
    @pw4075 Рік тому +17

    I like the way both shelves have been styled ... hard to choose but the maximalist style won out. As for the coffee table dilemma --- have you thought about looking at vintage chests or something that is vintage that maybe you could add brass elements to yourself? I love your new LA home but the TX cottage is my fav. It has your heart stamped throughout.

  • @delicatedots
    @delicatedots Рік тому +1

    I'm still watching, but had to comment how much I love the top shelf of books!! Wow! Ok...back to the video!

  • @lipstickstories2409
    @lipstickstories2409 Рік тому +59

    Can’t wait much longer for the kitchen cabinets! Aaaaah! Excited for that day!

  • @YellowSparksJoy
    @YellowSparksJoy Рік тому +1

    I love the more side. It doesn't look too much at all. I think it's just right for your house 💛

  • @tondapatterson5297
    @tondapatterson5297 Рік тому +31

    So glad you are back at the cottage. It's my favorite!

  • @schlendergirl1113
    @schlendergirl1113 Рік тому +21

    Macenna, I usually don’t comment on videos, but I just wanted to tell you that you are a huge inspiration! You have exquisite taste and you are so crazy-talented! I wish you Aaaall the best for you and your family ♥️

  • @MariaGonzalez-nw8hr
    @MariaGonzalez-nw8hr Рік тому +16

    I love both houses, but definitely the Texas house is my favorite one. I really love everything in this house!❤

  • @sallyhook102
    @sallyhook102 Рік тому +7

    I really like the way you explained and filmed this episode! 😊

  • @alamahala
    @alamahala Рік тому +18

    Both are beautiful but if I had to pick then I love the more home-y library vibes of the maximalist side ❤

  • @elisabethreinbach9034
    @elisabethreinbach9034 Рік тому +1

    It is just stunning

  • @JL11775
    @JL11775 Рік тому +12

    Sweet Kinsley on the chair makes the room perfect! Hope you and Romeo feel,better soon!

  • @normaochavez6484
    @normaochavez6484 Рік тому +5

    My favorite was the maximalist. I love the syling.

  • @LeslieNikulka
    @LeslieNikulka Рік тому +1

    Hi MaCenna! If I'm not mistaken, I think your pair of brass birds are "Quail" and the 3-D carving of a man's head I think is a replica bust of Michelangelo's "David". If I'm wrong, please correct me to anyone out there who knows better; thank you. Thanks, MaCenna for another fun and inspirational video. OX

  • @ksl2634
    @ksl2634 Рік тому +29

    Welp, I guess I'm a maximalist! 😄 Either that or I just really enjoy the use of books more heavily on that side of the fireplace. Always loved the idea of a moody academia feel 📚 🕯

  • @darlenesansing8758
    @darlenesansing8758 Рік тому +3

    I love both. But my favorite is the maximum shelf. But that’s a great idea to to do minimal in summer for fresh and maximum in winter to create a cozy vibe. Great job!

  • @natashahamilton1965
    @natashahamilton1965 Рік тому +48

    2 videos of book shelf decor in one night! Lone Fox did one too.. Fab! 💜

  • @Vees2219
    @Vees2219 Рік тому +1

    Totally unrelated to bookshelves, but hearing your fireplace in the background while watching was everything😍

  • @Auguste.
    @Auguste. Рік тому +59

    I was literally thinking: “ I hope she does some layered art work…” I love the look of layered art work just adds nice “effortless” look while still feeling curated 😍 20:14

  • @birdsong62
    @birdsong62 Рік тому

    24:23 Kingsley is so cute sitting on the chair. Love the bookshelves I could look at it for ages.
    Ps I think I am drawn to the minimal side.

  • @Breana6111
    @Breana6111 Рік тому +4

    The books across the top are just perfect 😍

  • @SynEveness
    @SynEveness Рік тому +3

    I'm usually a more minimalist style but for some reason I really loved the maximalist one more. And dang... I do love that color on the bookshelves! Can't get over that 😍

  • @yvettegoodlow6081
    @yvettegoodlow6081 Рік тому +1

    Both are beautiful, only a subtle difference.

  • @cassandragoss3041
    @cassandragoss3041 Рік тому +55

    im just loving all your content macenna! i love both the houses so much in there own ways! ❤ your amazing at this and make it look so easy

  • @vickylongcrier2376
    @vickylongcrier2376 Рік тому +1

    Love the maxi side and the little brass birds are quail. My mom also had these same birds on the coffee table when I was growing up in the 60’s and 70’s. You have helped me with color and design. Decorating my bookcases is now going to be easier with your help. Thanks for sharing!

  • @havvashenol6777
    @havvashenol6777 Рік тому +5

    I have to be honest this house is my favourite I could quite happily live there!!!! I love watching all your content love from London

  • @barbarajennings1057
    @barbarajennings1057 Рік тому +1

    I like the fuller look. I can hardly wait for the completion of the kitchen.

  • @anitawoollard7087
    @anitawoollard7087 Рік тому +18

    Glad that you added all your books in the upper shelves, they look so good along with the decor. Hope you are feeling better now.

    • @clairemcblair
      @clairemcblair Рік тому

      It'll be easier to dust up there too! Just run the duster over everything. 😹

  • @debgibson5570
    @debgibson5570 Рік тому +1

    Now I understand your fascination for buying some of the books you were always buying! As usual, beautiful results...I like both sides.

  • @meganconklin8168
    @meganconklin8168 Рік тому +86

    Coffee table struggles are real. I've been hunting for the perfect one for my space and nothing seems right so far. Hopefully we'll both land on the perfect one soon. 🤞

    • @XOMaCenna
      @XOMaCenna  Рік тому +19

      who would have thought it wouls be soooo hard right???

    • @heathererickson282
      @heathererickson282 Рік тому +6

      I ended up buying coffee table that someone took a dining table and shortened it. Absolutely love it.

    • @_Sarby1
      @_Sarby1 Рік тому +3

      @@XOMaCenna Your statue head looks like it's is Michelangelo's David xx

    • @tristannatalie7
      @tristannatalie7 Рік тому +1

      For sure RH has brass and wood coffee tables

    • @lovly2cu725
      @lovly2cu725 Рік тому

      maybe she will cobble something together

  • @maevaallio2581
    @maevaallio2581 Рік тому

    I definitely love the maximalist side 😍 The sounds of this video with the fireplace is so ASMR.

  • @elizabethsincere
    @elizabethsincere Рік тому +51

    I honestly LOVE YOUR CHANNEL! I look forward to watching every Sunday !! Your decor style is so unique and has inspired me in so many ways! I can’t wait to buy my own home 😂

    • @XOMaCenna
      @XOMaCenna  Рік тому +6

      awwww thank you so much!!!

  • @crystalkirkland781
    @crystalkirkland781 Рік тому +1

    I am more minimal stying by nature but I liked your max best. I felt like it still had great breathing room.

  • @jaymieeason990
    @jaymieeason990 Рік тому +3

    MaCenna you are so creative. Everything you do in your decorating is what I call simply perfect. Never too much but perfectly done. Congrats on the new house. That one too is simply perfect.

  • @ilonakatalindako-tolman5545
    @ilonakatalindako-tolman5545 Рік тому +1

    I loved your book shelves....I love books and pictures and flowers ...❤

  • @nopitseneklidou8982
    @nopitseneklidou8982 Рік тому +4

    I am so glad you are back to our favourite cottage!!! The shelves are so perfect! I love both sides but i will you pick the minimalist! So beautiful!!!😍

  • @michelleboydston8036
    @michelleboydston8036 Рік тому

    I loved both sides! I love the books all the way across the top. Kinsley is so cute on the chair. Love the sound of the fireplace in the background

  • @jackienorris2093
    @jackienorris2093 Рік тому +6

    I hope you both feel better soon. I actually like both sides of your shelf styling. I love using books to decorate. I have lots that my grandma gave my mom every year for Christmas. My mom is soon to be 98, so the books are very old!

  • @RebeccaTreeseed
    @RebeccaTreeseed Рік тому +1

    I love layered art work. But my shelves have bbbbooooookkkkksss!
    I do have a 6 foot cabinet with edge where I filled the top with brown gravel, added a few rocks, a round vase in moody colors filled with water and live pothos and a horsehair ceramic sitting female. I still love it a year later. A friend calls it a meditation.

  • @laurab7379
    @laurab7379 Рік тому +8

    Both sides look great but I am leaning towards to right side with more, I feel those shelfs can handle more items, some book shelfs look better with less. You did a fantastic job! Gives me so many ideas for my home. This house keeps getting better and better. Your California home is amazing as well, you knocked it out of the park with using your own things for the living room. Beautiful homes!

  • @norawotton5440
    @norawotton5440 Рік тому

    Both are gorgeous. I like that even the ‘more’ side has breathing room on each shelf.

  • @dianamangas9398
    @dianamangas9398 Рік тому +6

    I'm so ready to see your kitchen done.sorry your sick hugs and love sent your way

  • @jhale6699
    @jhale6699 Рік тому

    The "more" side is my favorite...it's all so beautiful

  • @paulamiller3878
    @paulamiller3878 Рік тому +4

    Styling videos are my favorite.. especially maximalist with vintage finds. This episode is giving me all the feels. Time to restyle my bookshelves. ❤

  • @cd2659
    @cd2659 Рік тому +1

    I like the maximal side because of all the books you added. I like the dark academia look right now. Hope you feel better soon.

  • @dulcegrace1188
    @dulcegrace1188 Рік тому +10

    Okay, mom is making the popcorn! Thanks for this Sunday ritual!

  • @rachel.lee1979
    @rachel.lee1979 Рік тому +1

    Macenna - Have you considered a vintage baggage trolley coffee table. I'd just paint the metal wheels an aged brass. It could look fab.

  • @SeaTurtle515
    @SeaTurtle515 Рік тому +4

    I like the more curated side, it’s not over done by any means and what’s really nice is that you get to display the items you love and have been collecting for a long time. Those built ins are gorgeous, even if they were empty.

  • @momofmanyjewels7
    @momofmanyjewels7 Рік тому +1

    More is More! love the more side

  • @traceynaples7572
    @traceynaples7572 Рік тому +8

    I love the maximalist side. Looks great! Hope you're both feeling better. Can't wait to see more projects.

  • @maryp186
    @maryp186 Рік тому +2

    The fact that you got a video live even when you didn't feel your best just goes to show your dedication and hard work! i hope you feel better

  • @stefanieand7501
    @stefanieand7501 Рік тому +5

    I love your natural decorating style. It might be “more” but it never feels like clutter to me and it feels curated while also feeling lived in ❤

  • @lynnjohnson1413
    @lynnjohnson1413 Рік тому +1

    Beautiful so much personality! Like the shelves loaded more full.

  • @allykennedy9211
    @allykennedy9211 Рік тому +8

    So glad you’re back in Texas! Also really glad you said “I need more books” for the right side because I was saying that for the left side. Clearly I lean on the maximal side for my shelves 😂

  • @christineadams796
    @christineadams796 Рік тому +2

    They both look beautiful you can't go wrong with either choice the book shelves are such a beautiful color

  • @Styledandorganized
    @Styledandorganized Рік тому +4

    Well let me tell you, you do magic when you decorate 😍 I am a minimalist for sure, HOWEVER… I’m obsessedddd with the “more is more” side! Because it’s still nice and clean looking, it looks purposeful and not cluttered just because. I love it soooo much!

  • @heidil.4651
    @heidil.4651 Рік тому

    I think the birds are quails and the shelves are PERFECTION!

  • @childressherd1558
    @childressherd1558 Рік тому +4

    Love your new house but this one is so much nicer!!!!

  • @sophiepanagiotopoulos6788
    @sophiepanagiotopoulos6788 Рік тому +2

    The bust is actually David from David and Goliath. The actual statue can be seen in Florence Italy. The statue of David was created by Michaelangelo.

  • @symphoniecameron
    @symphoniecameron Рік тому +7

    i genuinely can't pick a side, they both look amazing!! i've been dying to see all your beautiful books and i'm so so happy you did the top shelves JUST books! it seriously turned out stunning

  • @Lwicdwt1
    @Lwicdwt1 Рік тому

    I love how you share your thoughts while you go. Feel better sweetie 💕

  • @donnad.7986
    @donnad.7986 Рік тому +10

    This is the best video on shelf styling I’ve ever watched. Thank you MaCenna
    More is More ❤❤❤

  • @susanandrews2340
    @susanandrews2340 Рік тому

    The more side looks cosy and lived in not show home .Love it Xx

  • @ba3140
    @ba3140 Рік тому +13

    I'm definitely a maximalist! Love it

  • @MayaACJoye
    @MayaACJoye Рік тому +2

    I'd love to see a video on how to style a bookshelf that holds books you read (contemporary novels, paperbacks etc). The vintage books look phenomenal, but I have so many books I have read that I want to style in an aesthetic way despite not having that beautiful antique look. Maybe in your new LA home?

  • @kungaie
    @kungaie Рік тому +3

    I love this, it's so relaxing. But also after a long draining day it's so nice to wind down and relax watching. I also loooooove the little fireplace background sound, it's making my ears happy :)

  • @janetdavis5619
    @janetdavis5619 Рік тому

    I love more things on the shelves, the right side is beautiful!

  • @frankhetzel5363
    @frankhetzel5363 Рік тому +13

    Hope you feel better! Great to see you at cottage! Love new house, but cottage is our favorite!

  • @jeannegrumbles7595
    @jeannegrumbles7595 Рік тому +4

    Absolutely loved watching you do the bookshelves and can’t wait for you to do more renovations, both your homes are absolutely beautiful, your so talented and I love watching your videos.!!!❤️

  • @asd-vv6ug
    @asd-vv6ug Рік тому +1

    I’m definitely a maximalist! Love the top shelves full of books on both sides - it really pulls both sides together

  • @ansbach74
    @ansbach74 Рік тому +4

    I have the same brass birds. They are quails.

  • @nothingness7580
    @nothingness7580 Рік тому

    That’s why i love shelves! ur artsy perspective will comeout easily and whatever u do… it would look beautiful!!!!

  • @shelleyscarborough9171
    @shelleyscarborough9171 Рік тому +4

    Both are so gorgeous. Thank you for no "farmhouse". Your channel is so refreshing!! You are so talented.

  • @ruthedwards-shirley9042
    @ruthedwards-shirley9042 Рік тому

    Definitely a maximalist fan! The flowers are peonies. Love Kathy’s new art piece! Hope you feel better soon. I had that flu and it took ages to go away!

  • @lwahethabdo7071
    @lwahethabdo7071 Рік тому +11

    Oh the cottage content is back❤
    FINALLY 🎉

  • @evawohl2572
    @evawohl2572 Рік тому

    Moody Maximal Kind of Gal!!! Just Georgeous!!! Thank yo you so much for sharing!!!❤

  • @adriennestapleton
    @adriennestapleton Рік тому +12

    As a librarian, I have been waiting for this video. 😍 And I completely agree that decorating a home to feel like a library is a very worthy goal.
    P.S. Get better soon.

  • @patbaisden1731
    @patbaisden1731 Рік тому

    Love how you decorated the bookshelves! Your two birds are quail by the way. They look great on the shelves.

  • @BrittniNicole
    @BrittniNicole Рік тому +4

    I’m definitely a maximal person 😂. Do you plan on staining the French doors or leaving them?

  • @pam6830
    @pam6830 Рік тому

    MOrE is MorE!! I hope you got a cup of scoffs and just sat there and looked at how beautifully you did those.

  • @MsJet1
    @MsJet1 Рік тому +5

    Find a glass/brass coffee table and make your own wood table top!