Very useful video! I own this exact SKMEI, and use it regularly for a year now as my swimming watch. Even tempting disaster by using the push buttons while it's wet (not underwater: that wouldn't be fair to the watch), and it works perfectly, no condensations whatsoever.
You are a legend Gary. This is a great service to watch buyers. As you may remember I've actually dived with Heimdallr and Steeldive watches with no issues. However I think your testing will give people a sense of security if they buy something that you have tested and it passes or even if a watch they like fails, they cwn understand that they should be careful with it.
Not necessairly true. The batches of watches should be tested continously. Look what happened to Escapent Time fliegers. They used to be the best of the best 3-4 years ago, but today's units are at least mediocre. The quality dropped according to many reviews.
If you want to increase your testing rigour, place watches on the radiator BEFORE the pressure tests as well, followed by ice block, for checking the atmosphere of the watch's starting condition. Then if after the pressure test, there is more condensation than before, well, bingo! fail
Hey Gary! Curious why you don’t do the condensation test first to see if any water is already in the watch when you bought it then do the pressure tests with Herman. This would allow you to do a before and after Herman ingress comparison. Great video as usual.
@@ILikeWatches2 HI Gary, I studied materials engineering in my young days and don't worry an ice cube will not shrink or distort mineral glass or sapphire. It may however effect resin or hexalite crystals. Given that, there is no need to do an ice cube test first, they will all show some condensation it doesn't matter if it's a Rmalti or a Rolex, there is always water content in the air inside a watch and condensation will appear. It's a fruitless exercise. Keep with your original method.
@@brianmsahin Yes, most if not all watches will have some condensation prior to the water pressure test. The idea of doing the condensation test prior to the water pressure test and after the water pressure test is to use the initial test to evaluate relative amounts of condensation pre and post test. if you have a small amount of condensation prior to the water pressure tests and much more after, that would indicate moisture ingress.
That's a really good question, Marc @ LIW sometimes tests sapphire crystals by placing them on the forehead; a sapphire crystal will be noticeably cooler.
great content who knew watching bubbles would keep me entertained not being a west ham fan on a more serious note I really would like Benyar just to tell the truth there still great value we all know they're not steel cases I only care because they say it is.
Lol, no idea where he’s from but have you seen the clip I included in a video where I put a balloon in him and increase the pressure…it showed visually what happens and what the pressure looks like..it’s quite impressive
Ok, so I understand why you no longer review Benyar watches, which makes sense. They are really dishonest on their listings. Why are Pagani no longer reviewed? I would have liked to have seen their Sub homages in the test.
They don’t own the name, the car company does, the Italian car company owns the trademark for class 14 which is jewellery and watches which makes pagani watches fakes…technically they are illegal and Anyone who reviews them risks losing their channel in the future if their content is reported to UA-cam.
I never wear my watches if I think they will even get slightly wet. I do not even care what the WR is rated. I will take a watch off just to wash my hands. I have had several inexpensive and several very expensive watches fail just swimming at a beach that claimed they were good for deep diving. When one of those high end watches fail they try to blame you. I fought with an AD because a new (R brand) watch failed two weeks after I bought it luckily I knew the owner of the Watch Store and he sent it back to the manufacturer they admitted the seal on the case had failed somehow and rebuilt the watch and I got back 6 or 7 months later. After that I just decided no to wear watches in the water after that.
Had to report another scum bag trying to impersonate ILW2 I have been reporting these replies as harassment until You tube does something to stop them!
So my original 50 dollar Tandorio, Invicta, and Pagani real steel and real steal tool-watches beat 50-thousand dollar Swiss imitation tool-watches with their water resistance? Case closed, Chinese watches and Japanese calibres are superior to over-priced Swiss watches made with underpaid Swiss workers, in a country where 40K (I checked watch assembly wages) barely pays rent! These profiteering Swiss con-artists should be ashamed!
Very useful video!
I own this exact SKMEI, and use it regularly for a year now as my swimming watch. Even tempting disaster by using the push buttons while it's wet (not underwater: that wouldn't be fair to the watch), and it works perfectly, no condensations whatsoever.
That’s reassuring
You are a legend Gary. This is a great service to watch buyers. As you may remember I've actually dived with Heimdallr and Steeldive watches with no issues. However I think your testing will give people a sense of security if they buy something that you have tested and it passes or even if a watch they like fails, they cwn understand that they should be careful with it.
Thank Brian…
Not necessairly true. The batches of watches should be tested continously. Look what happened to Escapent Time fliegers. They used to be the best of the best 3-4 years ago, but today's units are at least mediocre. The quality dropped according to many reviews.
love these tests
I’ve swam with multiple addiesdive,steeldive and pagani watches and never had any trouble .
Mumbles: I really wanted that Benyar to fail.. Lmao. Great video as usual, Gary.
Impressed to see how the 1963 fared, I thought the pushers could be a weak point.The only chronograph I've ever thought of buying.
Although there were some big bubbles coming from the pushers by the looks of things.
@@murph8411 I wouldn't dream of deliberately taking one into the water so being able to withstand accidentally wetting it should be ok, I hope.
If you want to increase your testing rigour, place watches on the radiator BEFORE the pressure tests as well, followed by ice block, for checking the atmosphere of the watch's starting condition. Then if after the pressure test, there is more condensation than before, well, bingo! fail
When you put the 1963 inside of Herman, I heard myself say "nooooo!" 😄
Cheers Gary, definitely made me chuckle!!
I really like these. You’re the only one testing WR
Quite surprised by the 1963. Until I saw this I wouldn't have let mine anywhere near water.
Great stuff, loving Herman as your glamorous assistant. He made me feel a little anxious wearing my Tandorio in the shower this morning though.
He’ll do that!
Hey Gary! Curious why you don’t do the condensation test first to see if any water is already in the watch when you bought it then do the pressure tests with Herman. This would allow you to do a before and after Herman ingress comparison. Great video as usual.
Time but also I’m not sure how it impacts the fit of the crystal…does it shrink it and how long would I need to wait for it to return to normal size?
@@ILikeWatches2 HI Gary, I studied materials engineering in my young days and don't worry an ice cube will not shrink or distort mineral glass or sapphire. It may however effect resin or hexalite crystals. Given that, there is no need to do an ice cube test first, they will all show some condensation it doesn't matter if it's a Rmalti or a Rolex, there is always water content in the air inside a watch and condensation will appear. It's a fruitless exercise. Keep with your original method.
@@brianmsahin Yes, most if not all watches will have some condensation prior to the water pressure test. The idea of doing the condensation test prior to the water pressure test and after the water pressure test is to use the initial test to evaluate relative amounts of condensation pre and post test. if you have a small amount of condensation prior to the water pressure tests and much more after, that would indicate moisture ingress.
Thanks for that quite telling test for water resistance Gary, at least we know one aspect of those watches to expect?
Thank for watching!
Maybe Gary you needed to “Benyar” arm a bit more?…💪🏼😈🤣
🤦🏻♂️
So interesting. Is there a way to test Herman to know if it's actually putting that full 60m worth of pressure?
I’m curious. Is there a difference in the thermal conductivity between a mineral crystal, and sapphire. This might affect the condensation.????
Not sure, someone else would need to answer that one
That's a really good question, Marc @ LIW sometimes tests sapphire crystals by placing them on the forehead; a sapphire crystal will be noticeably cooler.
Would doing the ice block test before and after allow for a comparison?
So except for the Tandorio, the rest seem to be okay so far.
H2O Horology with Herman.
great content who knew watching bubbles would keep me entertained not being a west ham fan on a more serious note I really would like Benyar just to tell the truth there still great value we all know they're not steel cases I only care because they say it is.
Agreed…
Would it not be better, Gary, to see how much condensation you have in the watch before you start the pressure tests.
Question. Considering the questionable/dubious depth ratings on Ali watches, isn't herman also a Chinese fellow? And how reliable is He?
Are you questioning Herman's integrity? Yes, he is of humble Chinese origins, but is now a proud British citizen and performs his job without bias.
@@trogpo I've been exposed...
Lol, no idea where he’s from but have you seen the clip I included in a video where I put a balloon in him and increase the pressure…it showed visually what happens and what the pressure looks like..it’s quite impressive
@@ILikeWatches2 I did Gary! I often dive down to +/- 40m and have felt it first hand. 60m is plenty.
@@ILikeWatches2 Sure! This video proves Herman's physical as well as moral integrity.
For sure I would have expected the Benyar to fail, oh well, never mind.
Maybe next time!
Just wear a G-shock near/in water and no worries.
Or a Duro. 😁👍
@@SomeGuyNamedTex 👍👍
These tests would just give me confidence of how accidental soaking would affect them.
I for one would love Herman to meet a Hamilton khaki field mechanical and have his way with it…. Cheers!!
I'm not disappointed! I cringe when they fail.
I thought the 1963 is only 30m
According the the specs it’s 50m….it passed so that’s amazing if it is only 30m
@@ILikeWatches2 just checked the specs. Some sites say 3 and some say 5 🤔🤷
@@goldfools5445 They should do it like they do for bike tires. Fill it til it blows off the rim, and set the limit at half the blow off pressure. :D
Ok, so I understand why you no longer review Benyar watches, which makes sense. They are really dishonest on their listings. Why are Pagani no longer reviewed? I would have liked to have seen their Sub homages in the test.
They don’t own the name, the car company does, the Italian car company owns the trademark for class 14 which is jewellery and watches which makes pagani watches fakes…technically they are illegal and Anyone who reviews them risks losing their channel in the future if their content is reported to UA-cam.
I never wear my watches if I think they will even get slightly wet. I do not even care what the WR is rated. I will take a watch off just to wash my hands. I have had several inexpensive and several very expensive watches fail just swimming at a beach that claimed they were good for deep diving. When one of those high end watches fail they try to blame you. I fought with an AD because a new (R brand) watch failed two weeks after I bought it luckily I knew the owner of the Watch Store and he sent it back to the manufacturer they admitted the seal on the case had failed somehow and rebuilt the watch and I got back 6 or 7 months later. After that I just decided no to wear watches in the water after that.
Had to report another scum bag trying to impersonate ILW2 I have been reporting these replies as harassment until You tube does something to stop them!
I would like to see Berny in Herman
I put a Berny in Herman recently in a review video…it passed
🤬 Beeeeennn-yaaarrrrrr
So my original 50 dollar Tandorio, Invicta, and Pagani real steel and real steal tool-watches beat 50-thousand dollar Swiss imitation tool-watches with their water resistance? Case closed, Chinese watches and Japanese calibres are superior to over-priced Swiss watches made with underpaid Swiss workers, in a country where 40K (I checked watch assembly wages) barely pays rent! These profiteering Swiss con-artists should be ashamed!
Swim in the pools of blood from murdered Uighurs of Xinjiang's genocide