Hey Balkan, I’ve been following your tutorials for a while now, And some have been great but with this one for example I would just like to see a little bit more of attention and polishing to the joints, finishes and details for the construction of the roof.
Why did you not use reference planes for the rafters? I use it al the time and i makes getting the right angle very easy. Also the beam at 10:00 can just be done with a normal beam with a cut at both ends, so you can have an accurate schedule
This video is just about "how u can make that" and "not the right way to make that", right ?Because, have several details in a roof like this, is not just so simple like u show...
Hey Balkan, your videos are very nice easy to learn and understanding. Could you please share the videos of how to draw wooden rafters in ridges of sloping roof
does anyone else have an issue with the wood structure not showing up in the section cuts? im drawing a house and the roof structure is very important, however, I can not get the damn timber to show up in the section cuts Help plz
Agin model in place? That is the worst thing you can do in BIM!! Nex video make about how you can schedule this? lenghts for elements and element marks? If you do it like this you lose all purpose of BIM, if you can't schedule what you have drawn. It is only good for visual purpose, nothing more. For collar ties you can just create a beam and reference plane for the sloped end, and then just cut the end.
Model-in place is in Revit for a reason, you use it for one off project design's, I'm sure if he was planning on scheduling what he has drawn then he would have done it differently so instead of criticising, how about you make your own video?
I agree with Davis, Revit most important feature is "information" not just "nice looking". for nice looking we have other software. The chritisism is for growing up Balkan Architect should take it like this and try to be better from all the ideas we share. Thank you Davis and Thank your Balkan architect, I expect from you your next video.
Hi BA my model wont let me set an extrusion at the south elevation for some reason it keeps saying ''Can't draw because Work Plane is at a very sharp angle in this view. Go to another view or redefine the Work Plane.''
Balkan. Thank you so very much for you time out in helping me and many others to learn this program. I'm having some problem on screen on the propertyies box where in yours it is showing the timber and its size, i'm not seeing it on nor am i seeing my elevation grids when i go in to 3D view. What do i do to have it like yours?
Love your videos! What do you think about making a video about one specific roof construction which I'll send you in dwg? I have some problems with it :( Greetings !
I think faster to do wood profile family on a base of steel profile to use new steel button. With standart wood profile new steel connections doesnt work. Model In-Place it is worst idea to do roof constructions. Unless you make a picture and the number of bars you do not need.
Wow!!! I understand that this is for you some way to make some money on the side, but lately you're adding way too many ads to your videos. And get interrupted constantly so people will lost track of your explanations, so will be hard for them to learn....just a word of advise
Hello Balkan, my name is Jorge and I am on my last year of architecture's master in Turin. I was wondering if you could give me some pieces of advice with my final thesis or rather suggest me some examples for my thesis (always using BIM Revit). I will be very pleased if you could answer me. Thank you in advance.
Hello! Why you dont use axes when you copy elements/groups? (You trying to find center of elements) This is just the main purpose of axes! Anyway, please, keep going on. I'm now not afraid revit whaching your videos. And made some projects in revit. Before I worked in Archicad only.
hello there is a part of roof we use in south of france that is called "genoises". it s placed outside at the top of the wall under the roof. could you do a tuto on that please i would also know how to make "tuiles" on the roof.? if you can do so ill take a 15 per month suscribe ;)
@@AussieBIMGuru that's why I was having my doubts... My field is more about topography, and from the couple of tutorials I have seen from him (like localisation, using of shared coordinates and such) the approach is very loose, a bit "how are you doing" with a lot of "moving by hand" stuff which is absolutely not the right thing to do if you want to keep your project referenced...
@@trollenz I always aim to gear my tutorials this way - there are best practices vs. half measure workflows. Balkan has just finished his studies, so whilst he has done an amazing job at introducing many people to Revit at a fundamental level, professionally he will learn a lot more (and hopefully bring it back to his channel). I began my channel as I noticed the lack of content being shared for free by professionals to help students and other professionals learn best practices - many such as Balkan have tried to fill this gap, but as you noticed it isn't always reflecting best practices (moreso an experimental take on the workflow). I have a few videos on my channel which cover DWG survey alignment and shared coordinate workflows, hope they help: ua-cam.com/video/cKvIIJd9hSI/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/1_F6YRgY6aI/v-deo.html
@@AussieBIMGuru true, being one of the few subjects I'm actually good at... Just the fact of the default "center to center" import in Revit says it all... I've worked with a lot of architects and I can say that most of them truly don't have a clue about how to use these tools... They're all about BIM and stuff, but as soon as they open a point cloud or any kind of survey they always end up moving everything by hand or rotating it all over the place... Maybe they secretly expect earth to move around their project ;-) Pretty nice high end content you have there, you just got yourself a new subscriber. Thanks.
Hey Balkan, I’ve been following your tutorials for a while now, And some have been great but with this one for example I would just like to see a little bit more of attention and polishing to the joints, finishes and details for the construction of the roof.
Hey Balkan you are good man. I love your level of work put in.
Thank you. Very practical.
Why did you not use reference planes for the rafters? I use it al the time and i makes getting the right angle very easy. Also the beam at 10:00 can just be done with a normal beam with a cut at both ends, so you can have an accurate schedule
This video is just about "how u can make that" and "not the right way to make that", right ?Because, have several details in a roof like this, is not just so simple like u show...
Hey Balkan, your videos are very nice easy to learn and understanding. Could you please share the videos of how to draw wooden rafters in ridges of sloping roof
Thanks mr BA, this really helps! Can you make a tutorial about how to make a parts list after drawing a construction like this?
Excellent. Keep up the good work man. God bless
Is there any video about beams connection?
But these Monel in place elements, it won't come in schedule right!!!
does anyone else have an issue with the wood structure not showing up in the section cuts? im drawing a house and the roof structure is very important, however, I can not get the damn timber to show up in the section cuts
Help plz
Could you please tell us how to get those family files?
iI'm trying to do it but the view does not let me to draw the component. It says the view is too sharp...wtf?
Balkan can u do a tutorial of a Farm House with half logs as walls and a simple roof, with a chimney and with a wood burning stove.
hey, where can I get that family file?. my software don't have it
In Brazil we call "tesoura". That means scisors in portuguese :)
sr can you make a video on, how to place beam bracing on conical roof ?
Agin model in place? That is the worst thing you can do in BIM!! Nex video make about how you can schedule this? lenghts for elements and element marks? If you do it like this you lose all purpose of BIM, if you can't schedule what you have drawn. It is only good for visual purpose, nothing more.
For collar ties you can just create a beam and reference plane for the sloped end, and then just cut the end.
I appreciate if you could create a video and upload it in YT and give us a a link on how to do ?
Model-in place is in Revit for a reason, you use it for one off project design's, I'm sure if he was planning on scheduling what he has drawn then he would have done it differently so instead of criticising, how about you make your own video?
I agree with Davis, Revit most important feature is "information" not just "nice looking". for nice looking we have other software. The chritisism is for growing up Balkan Architect should take it like this and try to be better from all the ideas we share. Thank you Davis and Thank your Balkan architect, I expect from you your next video.
Hello, thanks for the video, just wanted to ask how do you join the beams, if they are not perfectly joined? thanks
Hi BA my model wont let me set an extrusion at the south elevation for some reason it keeps saying ''Can't draw because Work Plane is at a very sharp angle in this view. Go to another view or redefine the Work Plane.''
can you edit the profile of dimensional lumber like you did with your generic model?
perfect work
very good
please ı dont have the metrek library and i couldnt download it ı have dounloaded every library from every where but the origenal is not exist
Balkan. Thank you so very much for you time out in helping me and many others to learn this program. I'm having some problem on screen on the propertyies box where in yours it is showing the timber and its size, i'm not seeing it on nor am i seeing my elevation grids when i go in to 3D view. What do i do to have it like yours?
Love your videos! What do you think about making a video about one specific roof construction which I'll send you in dwg? I have some problems with it :( Greetings !
thanks Sir
Gracias
Can you teach how to do roof construction and not roof constrction please?
sir please make a vid tutorial OF HOW to make roof materials ( ex. Metal twin Rib-type )
I think faster to do wood profile family on a base of steel profile to use new steel button.
With standart wood profile new steel connections doesnt work.
Model In-Place it is worst idea to do roof constructions. Unless you make a picture and the number of bars you do not need.
Wow!!! I understand that this is for you some way to make some money on the side, but lately you're adding way too many ads to your videos. And get interrupted constantly so people will lost track of your explanations, so will be hard for them to learn....just a word of advise
Common! This guy is giving so much quality content for free. The least you can do is to put up with the adverts and skip them asap
merci ! :D
Hello Balkan, my name is Jorge and I am on my last year of architecture's master in Turin. I was wondering if you could give me some pieces of advice with my final thesis or rather suggest me some examples for my thesis (always using BIM Revit). I will be very pleased if you could answer me. Thank you in advance.
thank you
Thank u
really gud sir
Hello! Why you dont use axes when you copy elements/groups? (You trying to find center of elements) This is just the main purpose of axes!
Anyway, please, keep going on. I'm now not afraid revit whaching your videos. And made some projects in revit. Before I worked in Archicad only.
hello there is a part of roof we use in south of france that is called "genoises". it s placed outside at the top of the wall under the roof. could you do a tuto on that please i would also know how to make "tuiles" on the roof.? if you can do so ill take a 15 per month suscribe ;)
No cleaner way than modelling a generic model ?
Best way is to use actual structural families and trusses/connections
@@AussieBIMGuru that's the kind of tutorials I'm really looking for... How to make things the proper way.
@@AussieBIMGuru that's why I was having my doubts... My field is more about topography, and from the couple of tutorials I have seen from him (like localisation, using of shared coordinates and such) the approach is very loose, a bit "how are you doing" with a lot of "moving by hand" stuff which is absolutely not the right thing to do if you want to keep your project referenced...
@@trollenz I always aim to gear my tutorials this way - there are best practices vs. half measure workflows. Balkan has just finished his studies, so whilst he has done an amazing job at introducing many people to Revit at a fundamental level, professionally he will learn a lot more (and hopefully bring it back to his channel).
I began my channel as I noticed the lack of content being shared for free by professionals to help students and other professionals learn best practices - many such as Balkan have tried to fill this gap, but as you noticed it isn't always reflecting best practices (moreso an experimental take on the workflow).
I have a few videos on my channel which cover DWG survey alignment and shared coordinate workflows, hope they help:
ua-cam.com/video/cKvIIJd9hSI/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/1_F6YRgY6aI/v-deo.html
@@AussieBIMGuru true, being one of the few subjects I'm actually good at... Just the fact of the default "center to center" import in Revit says it all... I've worked with a lot of architects and I can say that most of them truly don't have a clue about how to use these tools... They're all about BIM and stuff, but as soon as they open a point cloud or any kind of survey they always end up moving everything by hand or rotating it all over the place... Maybe they secretly expect earth to move around their project ;-)
Pretty nice high end content you have there, you just got yourself a new subscriber. Thanks.
you are mixing model in place and beams - this will RUIN analitycal model
could you please do a tutorial for logwood architecture where the walls
are really made up of logwood and not just applying wooden material
Explain how to draw nalukettu roof in revit..
The way you model is very generic. You should model smartly like using 3D snaps and beam system
FRANCO HERNANDO you can create a tutorial please
That picture look like a cartoon
The final product doesn't have the level of detail of the first images shown in the video. That's really annoying.
could you please do a tutorial for logwood architecture where the walls
are really made up of logwood and not just applying wooden material
could you please do a tutorial for logwood architecture where the walls
are really made up of logwood and not just applying wooden material