Am not getting difference between "free will" as criminal do crime with his choice then how it is different from state of mind ...as free will is also his choice to do crime his intention in implied in that can u plz explain me...am not getting it
Those are some very important ideas behind criminal law. I knew the ideas but not Beccaria's name. Thank goodness we live in a time where those ideas are mundane and unremarkable and uncontroversial (except perhaps the death penalty in some parts of the world).
Thank you, very helpful. However, the quote given at the end of the video is not in the link you have given in the description. Is the quote from a different version of the essay? Thank you
Correct, the original document that I referred to is unfortunately no longer available, and translations differ a little. However, contentwise it's the same.
Am not getting difference between "free will" as criminal do crime with his choice then how it is different from state of mind ...as free will is also his choice to do crime his intention in implied in that can anyone plz explain me...am not getting it
Excellent prensentation. Thank you. Can the poster or anyone else explain how proportionality to the harm caused and fidelity to laws passed by legislators can co-exist? If two people each fire a gun at another person and one hits the spine and the other nicks the ear, surely the legislatures can't account for each and every scenario, so it would still be up to the magistrate/judge to determine the punishment, no? The legislature most likely would pass a law against attempted murder with a sentence for the crime being ten years. But each shooter getting the same sentence would not be proportional where one victim is paralyzed for life and the other was treated and released the day of the shooting barely worse for wear. Again, thanks for the primer-very interesting.
Those societies that adopted these enlightened ideas certainly had to consider scenarios like yours. In the United States our founders concluded that in your scenario what was important was the mens reah, or the state of mind of the perpetrator. In your example the state of mind of either of your two shooters could have been to kill in in order to eliminate or on the other hand either shooter could have meant to merely protect one's self from death or great bodily injury. The motive, as it should, makes a big difference although not the only factor hence our different penalties for "attempted murder" vs "murder in the 1st degree", etc.
Am not getting difference between "free will" as criminal do crime with his choice then how it is different from state of mind ...as free will is also his choice to do crime his intention in implied in that can u plz explain me...am not getting it
Am not getting difference between "free will" as criminal do crime with his choice then how it is different from state of mind ...as free will is also his choice to do crime his intention in implied in that can u plz explain me...am not getting it
So 17 to 25 years of life imprisonment is better than death penalty ? In my view, people fear death more than being locked in a room for limited amount of time. I am so confused. 😭
@@CriminologyWeb What? Nono, the video is really accurate! It has even more details than I could ever ask for packed in six minutes! Sorry for yesterday, studying sometimes is able to blackout my reasoning...
This video was made years ago but has managed to help me understand this theory with ease until this day. Thank you!
Glad to hear Bethany
Am not getting difference between "free will" as criminal do crime with his choice then how it is different from state of mind ...as free will is also his choice to do crime his intention in implied in that can u plz explain me...am not getting it
@@CriminologyWeb
Just ordered "On Crimes and Punishments, and Other Writings" by Cambridge.
How does Beccaria compare to Bentham and Hobbes?
This was right on time with my essay
Awesome! Glad I could help :)
This really helped me for my current Artefact for my Uni.
Great, Darya!
Most effective and helpful video on Beccaria!
Thanks! I really appreciate your comment :)
Thank you for the explanation it actually made more sense than what my teacher was sharing.
Thanks so much, Brett! Really happy it was helpful.
Thank you for the video. This was truly informative and helpful
Thanks for your comment, Christine, I'm happy to hear that.
Thank you so much! I finally understand with your simple explanation.
Great, glad I could help!
Good video, very informative and well explained.
Greetings from Milan!
Greetings to Milan! Glad it was helpful
Thank you for explanation!
You are welcome!
Ma'am I am from India and I am law student . Your videos are very helpful to us so please can you make some other topics of criminology videos
Hi Chandan, glad they're helpful. But not sure what you mean?
@@CriminologyWeb He's asking for more videos on different aspects of criminology
Yeah, it was edited. More videos coming up!
Good relevant information to modern theoretical analysis
Glad it was helpful
Muchas gracias, tu canal es muy interesante...
De nada. Happy to hear that, Michael.
Thanks on this. Very informative topic on this field
Glad it's helpful
Those are some very important ideas behind criminal law. I knew the ideas but not Beccaria's name. Thank goodness we live in a time where those ideas are mundane and unremarkable and uncontroversial (except perhaps the death penalty in some parts of the world).
很棒的內容
Thank you very much Mam
helped me with my history class :)
Glad to hear, Giauy
very well done.
Thanks....
Thank you, very helpful. However, the quote given at the end of the video is not in the link you have given in the description. Is the quote from a different version of the essay? Thank you
Correct, the original document that I referred to is unfortunately no longer available, and translations differ a little. However, contentwise it's the same.
Thanks ma'am , found you on Udemy ..searched and found you here too
Glad to hear kidz zone!
Hi, CriminologyWeb! The PDF might not exist anymore, may I ask for a copy? Thanks!
Am not getting difference between "free will" as criminal do crime with his choice then how it is different from state of mind ...as free will is also his choice to do crime his intention in implied in that can anyone plz explain me...am not getting it
You do have "free will" that should be good and without hurting others and damaging things. Otherwise you get consequences.
Good explaination
Thank you
thanks
You're very welcome, desert rose. Merry Christmas.
Excellent prensentation. Thank you. Can the poster or anyone else explain how proportionality to the harm caused and fidelity to laws passed by legislators can co-exist? If two people each fire a gun at another person and one hits the spine and the other nicks the ear, surely the legislatures can't account for each and every scenario, so it would still be up to the magistrate/judge to determine the punishment, no? The legislature most likely would pass a law against attempted murder with a sentence for the crime being ten years. But each shooter getting the same sentence would not be proportional where one victim is paralyzed for life and the other was treated and released the day of the shooting barely worse for wear. Again, thanks for the primer-very interesting.
Those societies that adopted these enlightened ideas certainly had to consider scenarios like yours. In the United States our founders concluded that in your scenario what was important was the mens reah, or the state of mind of the perpetrator. In your example the state of mind of either of your two shooters could have been to kill in in order to eliminate or on the other hand either shooter could have meant to merely protect one's self from death or great bodily injury. The motive, as it should, makes a big difference although not the only factor hence our different penalties for "attempted murder" vs "murder in the 1st degree", etc.
Hello. I'd like to cite this, but there is no name of author of this video :(
Hi Renate, it's fine if you just say CriminologyWeb as the author
Good
Great :)
thanks for this video :) 🔔
No problem, John.
You have not talked about the causes of crimes he gave i.e rational causes , that is very important for classical theories of criminology
Although explanation was to the point and very effective.
nice
Glad to hear
I am wandering if anyone here can go into a little more detail for what beccaria meant with the 'educstion is the best deterrent' thing
Im not really sure but i think its something related with people who came from lower class or basically just poor and uneducated people
Hey can you perhaps list your source / full essay it seems like the page listed doesnt exist. thank you so much in advance
Thanks for letting me know! Here's an alternative: www.criminologytoday.com/beccaria.pdf
Where are you getting your information from?
Am not getting difference between "free will" as criminal do crime with his choice then how it is different from state of mind ...as free will is also his choice to do crime his intention in implied in that can u plz explain me...am not getting it
Punishment is not really equal today is it?
Am not getting difference between "free will" as criminal do crime with his choice then how it is different from state of mind ...as free will is also his choice to do crime his intention in implied in that can u plz explain me...am not getting it
Uitstekend!
Graag gedaan!
👌👌👌👌👌👌👏👏👏
So 17 to 25 years of life imprisonment is better than death penalty ? In my view, people fear death more than being locked in a room for limited amount of time. I am so confused. 😭
in 1700 no chance of living 20 years in prison, maybe 10.
I think you missed the point. Basically what Beccaria said was the certainty of punisment is more important than the severity of the punishment
AAAAAAAAAAAAAA SONO STANCO. Nice video though!
Ha, not tired of the video I hope.
@@CriminologyWeb What? Nono, the video is really accurate! It has even more details than I could ever ask for packed in six minutes! Sorry for yesterday, studying sometimes is able to blackout my reasoning...
LOL; studying can do that :) Hope things are okay in Italy at the moment.
@@CriminologyWeb Hahah, yeah, losing my head just sitting in my home 24/7, it ain't that difficult, just pretty unusual... Thanks for asking though!
@@fedevice No kidding, unusual to say the least!
so what comes first crime or law?🤣
I vote for crime
Depends on the definition lmao. If its the legal definition of crime then law comes first. In other definitions mostly crime comes first
Law comes first. Law is the only one that defines the crimes.
hi Blonde