REALITY OF HOSPITALS & HEALTH INSURANCE IN INDIA
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 лис 2023
- With Ditto, you get the best advice on insurance. Understand your policy, get answers to your burning questions, and buy insurance, all at the same place
Register Today: bit.ly/49MUr09
#ditto #insurance #terminsurance #dittoinsurance #insurance
We have uncovered the harsh truths of healthcare system in the country.Lack of infrastructure in government hospitals, the costly and often unethical practices in private healthcare, and the challenges surrounding the availability of generic medicines.
watch the complete video for more analyses by Harsh Dhaka.
My Social Handles:
INSTAGRAM- / harsh_dhaka
TWITTER- / tooharshdhaka
VLOG CHANNEL- / lakshaychaudharyvlogs
Disclaimer : This video is for educational purpose only. copy right disclaimer under section 107 of the copyright act 1976 allowance is for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news, reporting, teaching, scholarship, research.
bit.ly/49MUr09 - Schedule a free call with Ditto
Like = Comment
promotion xd
I can say more about private hospital
Harsh bhai ma hu aadipanwarx😂
Sarkar khud nhi likhne deti, aur log bhi aalsi h , pvt m paise leke aaram diya jata h , bt i do not support looting
Finally someone is saying truth... Even BHU is also a worst hospital bcz doctor doesn't come.. only the student of 4th year MBBS treatment people
Doctors idhar bhi to pit jate hai, yes only 4th year MBBS students come here.
BHU hospital is one of most important in purvanchal region and many poor people depend on it that's really sad
@@TheOneWhoKnocks969 bro i belong to Varanasi... Due to the carelessness of BHU... I lost my grandmother
@@somamishra977 I'm a student there, and the conditions when dengue was at its peak are not worth mentioning. My friend had to go to Delhi AIIMS for it.
All doctor are available here , bhu is best , aap janti ho kya bol rahe ho aap
@@somamishra977I am also ❤
I'm a med student and I highly approve of this video.💯🙌🏻👏🏻
I think this is the only video on the internet which has provided all the insights and POVs on Indian Healthcare System rather than being biased and indulging in blame game.
The interview of Dr. Rohan was simply "cherry on the top".🤗🍒
I think the problem is their are too many mouths to feed.
@@Crybitch. Overpopulation is indeed a major reason. But insufficient allocation of funds, corruption at lower levels and improper utilisation of resources are also equally responsible.
One more side of this -
Govt. Spend so much money in health care but that doesn't reach to patients because of corrupt people in jobs...like hospital pharmacist sell lot of government medicine to medical stores .... You can notice some time the medicine you buy may have written behind it govt. Supply only.not for sale...
Hospitals gets lot of medical stuff but the staff present there also makes money from that
As a NEET aspirant I really appreciate the efforts of bringing this side of health care system. Thanks bro!
Sis bhai aise lag rhe hai mbbs kr li lekin ab bhi gareeb hi hai
how much O2 is delivered by 100 ml of oxygenated blood?
@@niteshpal801020 ml ez
@@niteshpal8010 5ml under normal conditions
Tax payers money is used in double or triple pensions for ministers but in the name of treatment in government hospital nothing is given not even hope of survival to patients .
there should be a law where all ministers and politicians cannot enter a private hospital: they can only do their treatment in government hospital.
Yes they should
Why do we pay so much tax when hospital and medical facility not there
Citizens of India want government colleges for study but don’t want treatment from government hospitals,As a medical student I highly appreciate harsh’s efforts and this video ❤
Medical student here….
12th ke baad apni bachi jawani ko kitabo and competition me fook kr 10-12 saal ki pdhai ke baad ek complete specialist doctor bante hai…jab government ki taraf se fundamentals infrastructure and basic life support bhi shi se nhi mil pata to patients ko kuchh hone pr saari responsibility doctor pr ajati hai….and jisne 12 saal pdhai krke skills sikhe kisiki life ko banaye rkhne ke liye vo basic resources ki kami ki vjh se ek patient ko bacha nhi paya to uspe kya gujarti hogi socho zara. Isliye doctors government hospitals me duty prefer nhi krte because vha unki value bhi nhi hoti and insecurity bhi hoti hai.
As a medical student I can confirm that the doctor said a 100% truth
Everyone should understand the doctor's perspective also
Relatable ke name pe doctor ko milke gaali Dene ke culture bann gaya han iss desh me
but he missed one important point (and I think it was deliberate) that there is fix commission of doctors if they give x company medicines and why there is scarcity of doctors in remote villages that's why there is increasing number of so called jhola chap doctors
@@namitsati5091 Bro the village people are too irritating, they do not listen to doctors
There is no supply of healthcare by the government in villages and villagers think it's the fault of doctors and they disrespect the doctor and there is not enough pay for doctors and what about the doctor's family settlements and future possibilities
And about the commission we doctors are not angels some of us are also evil persons and that does not mean every doctor gets a commission and generic medicines are not effective in many cases just they are cheap and government boast about it they are famous otherwise branded medicines are best
They cost you more but in infection or some serious disease you should take branded medicine over generic one
lol I have faced it,doctors are new demons Period
@@namitsati5091 as a medical student I agree with you that there’s a commission but that totally depends on person to person like there are good and bad people in every profession and as long as that commission is not harming anyone it should not be a problem because they are getting medicine with better efficacy and hence better treatment if they can afford it. And about working in a remote village I don’t think if you were in their place you would choose to go there. Just see what kind of facilities are there and why would someone who has worked so hard for so many years go there where even basic human facilities like washrooms are not available. If government works on improving facilities then people will definitely go there. After all doctors are human too. They will do what profits them and get what they deserve. I don’t know why people want doctors to act like god but they treat them like thugs.
I think this Debat is far better than Debats on religion 🙂
Debates on everything is imp
Govt hospital lack facilities and everyone know who's fault it is . Doctors can't do everything alone . It's not that doctors are bad or can't do anything . Every doctor try best to treat patients .
Bhai m bikaner rhta hun
Vha k govt hospitals mein saare facilities h bs doctors hi problems create krte h😢
Bhai hamare yanha bhi govt hospital mast he
mere yaha to govt hospitals acche hai
@@tihor7953facility me kya h wha?
come to chennai health capital of india
The problem with generic medicines are most of them are duplicate in market.
LEVEL SABKE NIKLENGE 😅
Edit-removed
😂😂😂
Laval
😂😂
Apun diamond BN gya re
@@rj_rahul258 🥲mera to level 2 hai jii
Ekdm shi facts hai ! Lekin 1 bda fact yeh bhi hai - ki patients ko sudden result chiye ( like a magic) toh is condition me hospitals bhi whi medicines denge jinka result top notch ho !!! Generic ssti hai , lekin effectivity bhi toh km hai !!!!
Agree
Claim settlement ratios of various insurers (avg of last 3 years):
Claim settlement ratio = Claims settled / (Claims booked + Claims outstanding at the beginning - Claims outstanding at the end)
1. IFFCO Tokio: 99.94%
2. New India Assurance: 99.92%
3. Oriental Insurance: 99.89%
4. HDFC Ergo: 97.55%
5. United India: 94.94%
6. Edelweiss: 94.57%
7. Digit: 94.56%
8. Bajaj Allianz: 94.18%
9. National Insurance: 94.14%
10. SBI: 92.62%
11. Royal Sundaram: 92.56%
12. Care: 91.8%
13. Niva Bupa: 90.74%
14. Manipal Cigna: 88.9%
15. Tata AIG: 88.53%
16. Aditya Birla: 87.54%
17. ICICI Lombard: 86.67%
18. Universal Sompo: 85.9%
19. Bharti AXA: 85%
20. Star Health: 83.07%
21. Navi: 82.83%
Source: Ditto
Your source?
Education system aur healthcare system aisa hona chahiye desh me ki kisi bhi logo ko jyada tension naa lena pade iss chizz k liye.
In odisha the government have provided e card to poor people... which provide them free healthcare....I really appreciate this 🙏 no one should die becoz they cannot afford the bills😶
I agree with this problem but as a Gujarat citizen in Gujarat government hospital is way better than private hospital and good service government doing good job at this and ahmedabad civil hospital is asia biggest civil hospital
Being a final year mbbs student, i would like to inform u all that government hospitals lack infrastructure and machines...doctors (most of), especially at CHC and above level try to give their best at work but many a times patients suffer bcoz of lack of facilities here... people need to understand that only the government decides what to provide at different levels of health system and doctors have no role in buying medicines , machines etc.
Exactly! I'm currently doing internship in a private hospital for billing department. And honestly the amount of frustrated patients we see is so astounding, my god. Some are even frustrated with doctors because they have high surgery charges and the room rent is also skyrocketing
Why one doesn't prefer govt hosp., here are more reasons
1. I would atleast expect a toilet for 18 hour shift
2. You can rarely treat a patient(drugs not available), if you do you're a headline with lawsuit
3. You have to entertain higher ranking govt. officials
4. Peons/nurses(permanent jobs) don't listen well to instructions which are given precisely leading to loe fear/care for patient's health and its responsibility
5. In case of death, you have to cycle to courts/committees while all work is pending
6. Nobody values us in govt. hospitals. People treat like they own us because they gave 10rs
7. Doctor's Opinion doesn't matter many times. Believe it or not when you pay good money you're going to listen to same advice seriously.
8. Higher chances of confrontation as people have to wait long in misery, standing in hot/cold weather with their conditions(infrastructure problem)
9. Media is against doctor. You also try to build that narrative to attract viewers. Cheap@$.
4:58 personally I don't have problem with overbilling, but I'm afraid that just because I'm from non-medical background, they'll hospitalize me (or do unnecessary surgery) to get extra income even when it is not required, at the risk of my life.
Yeah same brother..
Even in many cases hospitals do c section even when delivery can be done normally...to increase the patients bill and also c section is faster so many deliverys can be done per day per doctor..😢😮
Government hospitals are not having perfect resources and by seeing private hospital's bill middle class toh vaise hi tata bye bye hojaega. Hum kare toh kare kya bole toh bole kya??😢
Govt medicine hi available nahi karti govt hospital mee kyuki sara paisa to freebies me waste karna han 🤡 sabhi govt ko
My personal experience. FYI: I have speed-watched the video and might have missed some detail
Had an accident about 2 years ago, had muscle damage on my whole left side and had 2 minor fractures in my skull I was admitted to government hospital also in the General ward. The only few things that bothered me were 1. Sanitation and hygiene (Yes, Toilets were shit in most literal sense) 2. Getting reports, like yes there are lots of queues and it takes time and it's a mess. But I think the doctors and all medical students there who treated me over the week were super nice, quite overworked but nice. As far as infrastructure is concerned, I think at least the Hospital I was in i.e. Ahmedabad civil hospital had all the infrastructure needed. But I also understand infra would be a major issue in other city's govt hospital
Exactly sir.
What a Matured person he is......Not getting biased for anyone and all and telling just reality. Highly Appreciate this
My mom had a heart attack, the government hospital did not even examine her properly but I thank Ayushman Yojana. My mom's operation was done in the best hospital of Indore.
Being a healthcare professional I fully agree with this conversation
Our healthcare system is really very very poor
I am a radiographer who has given his 12+2+3 studies for this career and any other random wardboy who knows only how to shoot x rays wether it is anatomically incorrect that guy will be chosen instead of me jst because he will demand less salary. This is wat our healthcare system is.
In west bengal SSKM , RG Kar , MCK, NRS are well equipped and we'll developed ❤
I thought this video would be the same old same old to garner view time & only to sell the product.... proved wrong. The ONE & ONLY video on UA-cam that's ONE IN A MILLION. My alma mater is NRS, Kolkata (one of the most subsidised healthcare in the country & govt. college providing reasonable service) - where 2 of my seniors (interns back then) were stoned & a nation wide longest protest of doctors followed, back in 2019. Even Tertiary care hospitals may not have the required medicines in the wards. Thank you so much for considering the root cause & presenting everything so clearly. Kolkata ki Garmi me OT, OPD dekhna, Emergency dekhna, PPE pehenna..... ekbar phir se sab sarthak lga bas ye ek video sunke jaha you gave a voice to the medical community, especially to young govt. doctors. Dr. Rohan voiced all of our thoughts.
We never had "as-per-protocol antibiotics" during COVID in Head injury ward back in 2020-2021. Literally the nurse would be like "this this" is available in stock & we'd have to write as per that. Age old needle holders & artery forceps jisse kaise bhi karke, alag tarah k surgical techniques use karke stitches bhi diye hai. Even state Tertiary care govt. medical colleges/hospitals can lack. Kabhi kabhi student hoke bed nahi mila toh hostel k room ko bhi dengue k samay ward me convert kiya hai. #nostalgia
So one would not even want to imagine what are the facilities available in a PHC or CHC.
Doctors bathroom k darwaze bandh nhi hote waha, someplaces doctors bathroom is half used as storage room. Jis samay us bathroom ko banaya gya tha, uska cement ka bora bhi mil jata hai kabhi kabhi bathrooms me. Public needs to understand that Govt. hospitals aren't run by Doctors. Neither is Pvt. corporates (Doctors are literally given targets by business persons). For a few bad apples, it's bizarre how they come with pitchforks against every doctor.
Security point is 101% true. It's the primary reason why many many Doctors across the country are closing down their own small clinics, nursing homes or small hospitals that's run only by Doctors. Many of them charged very reasonably & worked for the public. It won't be long until no neighbourhood clinics will remain due to fear of Mob violence. Corporates are already taking over.
Gaao me jaha proper roads nhi milegi, waha USG with a jhola chaap who knows how to differentiate sexes on a USG, wo mil jayega. Aisa haal hai desh ka. Have never commented on a non-academic video & that too sucha long one. But this touched my heart. Lots of genuine problems highlighted.
Also documentation issues - everything is files n pen n paper in State Govt. colleges. Adds to the burden. AIIMS & the centrals have digitised things which has helped make administration & accessing patient data & communication very smooth. I know this' a dream but one can wish.
Plus faulty posting. Politicians interfere. Many doctors are from Tier 2 n 3 cities or towns. Even when they want posting in the district hospital of their hometown (which is in dire need), unka transfer & posting in far off places. Instead of the hometowns or even rurals that need the doctor & where the doctors comes from.
My town government hospital are really good. Better than local private but not as good as big city private hospitals
Brother maximum government facilities ka bura haal hai India me 😢😢 Sad reality
When I saw the title I thought it is going to be just like other videos blaming doctors. I’m a final year medical student and it feels bad to see those kind of videos. It is demotivating to see how public treats doctors as thugs and violence against doctors is becoming so common these days. That’s why a lot of medical students are preparing to leave the country and I think every medical student feels like this when we hear about violence against doctors. Thank you for sharing doctors perspective too. I hope this video reaches a lot of people and brings a slight change in perspective of general population. And thank you dr. Rohan for so clearly describing condition of our healthcare system
Soon the government will force such students to treat patients for free after graduating from government colleges . No one wins these types of wars
Our country need better doctor.
Then maybe you should become that better doctor yourself.
@@nikhilxdevil No we need better, educated people. Not idiots who believe in totka & dhongi babas/fake doctors
Being a d.pharma 2nd year student I worked in CHC for 2 months and everything is true that doctor says and people use abusive language a lot for both pharmacist and doctor I know it's our healthcare industry fault like to much costly medicine and all but patients should also understand not everything in our hands you would not believe but 1 rupye ki parchi ke liye bhi log apke upar gussa dikhne lgte h bhai wo fee h at the end of the day we have to give hisab to our seniors
Finally someone speak my mind in mainstream
In my village our government hospital doctor's are humble and responsible ❤️
Harsh big i have some tips
1st outro needed
2nd formal look will be better + hairstyle
3rd editing is good and music can be a littrle slower it sometimes disturbs"
and good work it was an informative video i have been ur whole squad viewer from 1 year so i hope you look at the suggestions i gave
Once my friend told me that their was this senior who came to give speech in their medical College and he told them that after practicing medicine for government you should open your private clinic or join private institution and earn a lot and literally told them if someone asks why are you charging so high them told the struggle you faced becoming a doctor and the money you spend I was baffled how can someone who should save lives can say such things
Govt. Give us load on load.. as a doctor i know that doctors do their duties even 18 hrs also.. residents can't take leave even for sleep 😩nd patients also misbehave with us.. harras us nd govt. Neither do anything for our work load nor for our safety 😩😓
Your salary per month
Your salary per month
Your salary per month
I live in panchkula a district of haryana... Thankfully the govt hospitals here are so good that i never required to go to private hospital...and there are such good govt hospital in chandigarh as well. They have dr. For anything i ever required dr. Too take rounds on time and are very concerned for patient's health
A well deserved vedio my brother please also do this type of segment with a foreign graduate doctor [FMG'S]. There are lots of hardships these doctors have to face when they come in India apart from the exam the government is never with these doctors so as a result we see more private clinics and doctors migrating to different countries!
I totally support the things said by Doctor...
Reality of India..
Govt. Hospitals in Chandigarh are way better, getting treatment might be a bit slow process but sure shot and precise
Main streem media who r busy in debates should learn from such channels 🙏thank you for providing such relevant information ❤️appreciate ur hard work
Finally someone covered this topic 🤍, hats off 🙏🏻
Proud to be Rajasthani 😎😎😎😎😎😎beat health care infrastructure 😈😈😈 thanku so much CM Ashok gehlot 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏😊😊😊
Plot Twist : Sarkari Schools Ka Bhi Yhi Haal Hai ! 😂
Bhai baki government sector mai yahi haal hai
No in haryana in my area tge government hospital is like private top doctors ❤
@@PUCHU-rh9ynrohtak pgi to ha hi top notch
Godi government me yahi hoga😊
come to de;lhi
1 month old news from my city Nagpur, doctor abandoned the ongoing operation due to not getting tea on time.🙂
I did BSc in Biotech, now doing internship in a corporate hospital. I was in the insurance department for quite some time too & saw all this happening
Jo kaam media ko karna chahiye vo ab youtubers ko karna padh rah hai
Same media 😢
Love your content harsh ❤❤
Shame
As a pharmacy student I can clearly said that in generic medicines the proportion of drugs used for its preparation can vary either in large or in small quantity from the actual quantity required resulting in saving cost of manufacturing and selling it for cheaper rates
Thanks to rajasthan govt for chiranjiv yojna free of cost treatment in private hospitals
This won't be covered by mainstream media
Brother....in my area Govt. Hospital are changing
There rules are also strict now
thanks bro as a neet aspirants i am just overwhemled that u made this types of videos
Rajasthan is way ahead in health care govt not only improving condition of hospitals but also providing free treatment in private hospital.
Like this new interview format. Continue this only wherever possible.
Frustrations of the people in rural areas are real because they dont feel security around doctors. Everyone respects a doctor, even a jhola chap doctor but doctors dont respect people. They have a bad opinion about people. And you can't ask anything from a doctor "Its a rule in so many small hospitals". They are rude, abusive, and manipulative while looting from the same people. Ofcourse people have also a bad opinion, but reason is on that side too. And if you want proof, come with me, there are doctors ki "Litteraly gale padwa dunga tumhare"
Aaj govt hospital ki halat ki jimmedaar doctor nhi blki govt khud h jo na toh kbhi proper infrastructure provide kr pata na proper medicine.
Itne boring topics ki videos bhi itni interesting Harsh bhai hii bana sakte hai ,thanka for this video.
In my city , You have to pay the nurses to take care of your patient. If you don't pay , they don't even come close to atleast adjust the saline levels. It is that pathetic. And let alone good treatment. I feel in todays market , if you have enough money, then only you can save your patient in good private hospital else they will probably get no treatment and may lose life in government hospital.
Mere ghar k paas LHMC hospital h central Govt ka, it's really good, even the gates open automatically, new building banai hai. Baki govt hospitals ki haalat kharab he dekhi hai, even in LHMC mein bhi time lagta hai but ilaaj bhot sahi hojata hai bhai
Thank God I'm living in gujrat ❤
This make me be healthy so that i don't have to go to so bad hospitals
Someone told the truth 💯
Harsh I subscribed for choosing this topic. This case is very sensitive I ask every creator to push on this Hospital Mafia.
insighful information👏.... no one talks about this side of health care systems...thank you harsh nd his team for providing us these information🤍
Thanks a lot HARSH for speaking on this topic! Appreciate it brother
no lies detected but i would say delhi's govt hospitals are far better then others.
As I know Gov. Hospital's doctors are more experienced n their treatment is also good although facilities are not upto the level but treatment they provide private Hospital's docs can never provide...one more thing this doc didn't give any insight about what surgeons do mistake while operating Patients in OT ...they leave surgical instruments into the Patients...n this is not acceptable at any cost...ohterwise he said many things which we as a common people didn't know...so thanks Dr Rohan 👍
Sare Private Hospitals me koi na koi Politicians share holder hai to wo kabhi bhi Govt Hospitals ko acha banne hi nahi denge
Rajasthan ne last kuch years me Health Sector me kafi achha kaam kiya hai...
Great work 👏👏
Well said Dr. Rohan @HeyDocGaming,
This is a very serious problem, that everyone should together speak upon.
I think finding a solution to this problem is not a question of "What", it's a question of "When."
Very insightful video harsh bhai. I am a NEET aspirant and this video was very helpful and informative.
Great work❤
Finally someone is putting the truth of other side here❤❤....thankyou
Respect 🙏 that doctor for telling truth.
When A Government runs private hospitals 😊😊
Very good information harsh
Keep it up 💪🔥🔥🔥
Maturity is when you realise SRK's Jawan made sense!
Harsh Is Too Harsh❤🔥
If I become a dictator of this country (hypothetical scenario), then, I will try to improve total healthcare system in less than 2 years. And appreciate your efforts sir, thank u ❤🎉
Harsh bhai has the gold insurance for any problem 😁
thanks for such an informative video Mr. Goli
Thanks harsh bhai aapne muje sahi way me guide kiya hai... Mera goal abhi yahi hai ki kuch bhi krke government facility improve kr saku aur i'll research and study hard and agar kisi ko pata hoto please muje guide kr sakte hai k kaise ye sab theek kr sakte hai aur is sare issues ko highlight krke improve kr skte hai 💙
11:15 artificial tears to bhot basic hai yeh to almost sabke ghar me hoti he hai.. I think the party which takes healtcare into 2024 elections manifesto can surely get higher stakes
We should respect Doctors
I will ask everyone to vote very careful so that next government can do something for us man like in laws ...
Very informative video bro keep posting like this you save a lot of life’s.
Finally किसी ने इस मुद्दे पर बात किया thanku ❤❤
Thank you guddu dhaka bhai for teaching us many new things everyday 🙏🏻
Goli h be uska name😂
Bhai video recommendations me nhi arhi
Thanks you for opening our eyes
Ohooo kal Lakshay ka video aj vlog and sath me Harsh ka video wha wha!!
As a student I am with doctor ❤
❤
Aap doctor ke sath ho toh apna ilaaz krwao yeh comment mai kya kr rahe ho? 😢
@@smartrk2599 bro I am a medical student and I am in support of this doctor on this what he said
@@smartrk2599 NXT level 😂
@@smartrk2599😂😂
Some day doctors would also be at the place engineers are
India may be bad in public healthcare but us,Canada, UK are worse where even if it's life threatening emergency, the doctors make them wait for 5-6 hrs
true.atleast we dont have to wait even for normal consultation.
Well yeah, but their infrastructure is still better.
No point of whataboutism in this
Goli dhaka ne Govt. ko uski aukaat dikha di 😂
Sir, govt. Hospital me approach lagana padhta hai bed lene ke liye, aur agar approach laga rahe ho to kisi v.vip se lagana padega, approach laga bhi diye to time PE bed mil jayega ye bhi confirm nhi hai, agar bed Khali bhi hai to ye log nhi batate wo bed be pre booked rehta hai jinhone approach lagayi hai
in my opinion the only way to tackle the healthcare problem is the development of better government hospitals and forcing the doctors to work for government hospitals for some years enforced by law .